SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 38
Photopolymerization of LC networks as
Ph t     l     i ti    f      t   k
  tool for micro- and nanostructuring
           micro
  Towards Soft Actuators &
                Nanoporous Membranes




    Dirk J. Broer, C.W.M. Bastiaansen, C.L. van Oosten,
          K. D. Harris, J. Lub, C.
          K D Harris J Lub C Luengo Gonzalez

           Eindhoven University of Technology
              Philips Research Laboratories
Functional polymers towards medical and
  cleantech
   l   t h
                                            • biosensors            • regenerative medicine
                                            • μ-fluidics
                                                fluidics            • triggered scaffolds
                                            • MEMS                  • fiber technology



       membranes
          b                                                                                        responsive
                                                                                                    materials
                                                           Nano-
                                                           Nano-medicine



                            Water treatment                                   Energy /
                                                                           light management
• purification
      ifi ti                                                                                  • light capturing & guiding
• targeted filtering                                                                          • sun tracking
• electro dialysis                                                                            • reverse electrodialysis
                                                                                              • (blue energy)
                                                        Clean Technologies



                                              self-
                                              self-organized micro- and nano features
                                                             micro-

  Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Soft Actuators
Courtesy: http://plantsinmotion.bio.indiana.edu




      phototropism in sunflower                                phototropism in plastic
Courtesy: Nikon Microscopy
          /Digital Video Gallery




   cilia motion in paramecium                                  cilia motion in plastic


  Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Soft Actuators
  •     Actuating elements, e.g. in microfluidic devices, μ-pumps,
        mixers, valves
  •     (Bio) sensors & controlled drugs release
  •     Artificial muscles / robotics
  •     Regenerative medicine
  •     Energy harvesting and sun tracking




                                                             What is needed ?
                                                             •   Responsive molecules
                                                             •   Miniaturize structures down to μm level
                                                             •   Integrate into devices
                                                             •   Improve on motion figures,
                                                                 e g as inspired by micro organisms
                                                                 e.g.                micro-organisms

Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Electrostatic actuation of integrated artificial cilia
                                g




Jaap den Toonder, Hans Wilderbeek, Titie Mol, Murray Gillies, Judith de Goede, Wim Talen
  Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Fabrication of electrostatic elements
                 800 μm            100 μm




      glass (embedded electrodes not shown)                           develop acrylate in alkaline solution
      + patterned Al (100 nm)




      add 10 nm chromium layer                                        etch Cr in cerium ammonium nitrate




 add 10 μm acrylate mix                                               etch Al in phosphoric acid
 photopolymerized through mask                                 CH3
                  O CH3                              CH2       C
                                                                  n
             O C       C CH2                                   C O
             CH2               O CH3                           O
CH3   CH2    C    CH2     O C C          CH2                   CH2
             CH2                                                       induced stresses make the elements curl
             O C       C CH2
  Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
                  O CH3                                                  Christiane de Witz, Thijs Bel
Photopolymerization of self-organizing reactive
liquid crystals
                                                             liquid crystal with reactive end groups
                  O
                                                               O
           O
                                                                         O      O
                                            O                   O
                                                                         O                     O
                                                                                           O




                                                                    hν

                                 bottom-up / top-down
                                 nano/micro structuring
                           aligned LC monomer



Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
± 25 yrs experience: LC networks are presently used to
improve LCDs on viewing angle, contrast and brightness
                         angle




                                                                hν



                                                    based on solid coatings and thin films with
                                                    anisotropic optical properties

                                                             e.g. Δn = n// - n⊥= 0.05 to 0.25
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Liquid Crystal Actuators
                                O
                                                                 O
                         O
                                                                          O    O
                                                             O   O
                                                                           O           O
                                                                                   O
                                                                     hν


                                               LC networks
                                                • Can be patterned, e.g.
                                                  by lithographic means
                                               • Can be made responsive
                                                 by orientation gradients

                                               • High modulus - 1GPa
                                               • Large work potential!
                                                 despite small deformations
                                                 ~ 2%
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Thermal actuation splayed LC network
                                                                                                  poly(C3M) / 60 μm


                                                              αe
                                       contraction


                                       expansion
                                                              αo
              500

              400

              300                                                          αo
              200
α (ppm.K-1)




              100

                0

               100
              -100

              -200
                                                                           αe
              -300
                     200   250        300            350             400        450
                                                             T (K)

Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)                            Titie Mol
UV light driven
        parallel to uniaxial orientation




                        UV        VIS
    perpendicular to uniaxial orientation                        E           Z


                                                                         E


                                             contraction




                                                                     Z
                                              expansion
                                 Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Liquid crystal network UV-actuator
     q      y
   Specific internal work comparison

                                                                          Modulus   Work density*
    Actuator comparison                                          Strain    (MPa)      (kJ/m3)
    LC network UV actuator                                       1,5%      1000          56
                                                             1
    LC elastomer UV actuator                                     13%         1           4
                                                   2
    Thermal LC elastomer                                         50%         1           50
                                     2
    Skeletal Muscle                                              20%        40           80

                                                                                    *W = ¼ ε2E
   1.       M. Camacho-Lopez et al., Nat. Mater., vol. 3, 2004, 307-310
   2.
   2        J.Madden al., J.
            J Madden et al J Of Oceanic Eng 29 (3) July 2004 706-728
                                          Eng.,    (3),      2004, 706 728

                                 Casper van Oosten
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Optimized X-link density for fast response

                                                                                                          UV
0s                          8s                           16 s                24 s             32 s

                                                                                                          VIS
0s                          4s                                8s             12 s             20 s
                                                                                        poly(5.5wt-%A6MA/C6M)

                 O
      H2C
                     O      (CH2)6 O                      O
                     + 48%                                             O   (CH2)5 CH3
                                                          O




            0s                    0.08 s                      0.16 s       0.24 s        0.32 s



                                  Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten
 Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Bending also possible in uniaxial LC networks
 with gradient i UV i t
  ith    di t in    intensity
                          it
                                                                                            gradient in
                                                                                            deformation
                                                             gradient in
                                                             UV intensity




                                                                      Light tracking

                                                                                  Tabiryan
    Under study:                                                                  Beam Engineering
    efficient light harvesting                                                    Bunning group, Air Force
    for solar energy?                                                             Lab Dayton, USA

                                                                                   O ti Express, 2005 13 7442
                                                                                   Optics E      2005, 13,

Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Back bending of uniaxial films in UV
   gradient films
 • time delayed azo response
 • photobleaching




 • bending depends on X-link                                                 Acknowledge Mark Warner
   density
 • X-link gradient by
   X link
   polymerization-induced diffusion
                                           UV light

                                                            Side
                                                            Sid A

  Fast reacting molecules                                        Intensity
                                                                 gradient
Slower reacting molecules
                Substrate                                   Side B



   Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Device integrated photoresponsive elements:
       • structured by inkjet technology
       • multi-color responsive elements
         multi-




                                                        160
                                                        140
                                                                                                       contraction
                                                        120
                                                        100
                                                  Angle
                                                         80
                                                 (degr)
                                                         60
                                                             40
                                                             20
                                                                                                       expansion
                                                                                                         p
                                                              0
                                                                  0   500     1000       1500   2000
                                                                            I (mW/cm2)
                                 Casper van Oosten
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Next steps at TU/e group

  Reverse function and
  employ microstructures f energy harvesting:
     l     i    t t      for      h     ti

  E.g.
  • polymer flaps with oriented dipoles
    (ferroelectrics)
  • electrodes top and bottom

   Energy from:
   • breeze
   • motion (vibration e.g. in building)
   • sound


    First estimates: 0.1 to 10 W.m-2                         large area technologies


Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Reduction of order parameter + gradients in director
profile  driving force for geometry changes




 Mechanisms for Order Reduction / triggers
         –     Temperature variation
         –     Breaking order by isomerization under radiation
         –     Breaking chemical bonds, chemical reactions (pH)
         –     Solvent swelling/deswelling



                                 Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Anisotropic hydrogels: H-bridged LC networks

                                                             O    HO                O
             O
                                          O                            O
                                                                                O
         O                                                   OH   O

         L. Strezelecki, L. Liebert, Bull. Soc. Chim. France, 597 (1973) & 605 (1973)




                                                                           hν




                            Cr 92 SmA 110 I




                                 Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Anisotropic hydrogels: H-bridged LC networks

                           OBA n = 3,5,6 (1:1:1)




                                               C6M
                 140

                 120
                                                                           hν
                 100
Temperatu ( C)
o




                 80    70 -105 oC processing window
        ure




                 60               Nematic
                                  N    ti                                       12 wt% C6M
                                                                           //
                 40
                       Smectic
                 20
                                                             Cryst
                  0
                           Cryst                                            ⊥
                 -20
                       0        20        40         60      80      100

                                     Composition (wt% C6M)
                                        Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Anisotropic swelling in alkaline buffer solution
                                   O         HO                     OH-                O         O-

                                   OH           O                    H+                O-         O




         L⊥

                                L//




                                                                                 %)
                                                                         ansion (%
                                                                                            ΔL ⊥ ΔL //
                                                                                                >
                                                                                             L⊥   L //


L⊥+ΔL                                                                 Expa

⊥                                                                                           Time (min)
                                                                                            Ti   ( i )

                                 L//+ΔL//


                                                       Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten
    Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Chemical Actuation – pH

                                                                 • Twisted configuration
                                                                                g
                                                                 • poly(nOBA/12%C6M)
                                                                 • 18μm thick

                                                                 • pH controlled with NaOH
                                                                   and acetic acid


                                                                            slow
                                                                          expansion

                                                                            fast
                                                                         expansion


        •      Motion occurs over limited pH range at pH~11
        •      Deformation i reversible
               D f     ti is        ibl
                                 Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Activate by KOH dip – deactivate in acetic acid

                                                                             polymer chains




                                                                                    L
                                                                  activate deactivateo
                                                                   base      acid
Challenges:
• water driven motor (with Peter Palffy-Muhoray)
• (bio) molecular recognition:
     -NH2, CO2, O2 together with Sijbesma -TU/e
                                                                           uptake of agent
                                                                           molecules




                                                                                         Lt


                                  Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten
 Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Application of a hydrogel soft actuator: Wrapping of
eukaryotic cells

                                                                      Objectives:
                                                                      • To develop cell delivery technique
                                                                      • Potential to combine different cell
                                                                        population

                                                                      Status:
                                                                      • Experiments withA 431, human
                                                                                    withA-431,
                                                                        carcinoma epidermoid cells




                                                                                               37    25 oC



                                                                                                25    37 oC

                                             Sara Pedrón-Haba, Emiel Peeters,
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Smectic hydrogen-bridged networks towards
nano-channels
      h     l
                                                                 OBA n = 3 5 6 (1:1:1)
                                                                         3,5,6




                                                                                    C6M
                 140

                 120

                 100
Temperatu (oC)




                 80
        ure




                 60                    Nematic
                                       N   ti
                 40
                       Smectic
                 20
                                                                     Cryst
                   0
                           Cryst
                 -20
                       0       20         40             60           80      100

                                    Composition (wt% C6M)
                                                                           Carmen Luengo
    Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
X-linked smectic hydrogen-bridged LC networks
                 hydrogen-
                O
                                                             O       HO                ~19 Å             O
                                             O                                     O
                                                                                                     O
           O                                                 OH       O
                                                             O                                                O
             O
                                          O                       ~42 Å
                                                                   42     O            O
                                                                                                          O
         O                                                   O
                                                                          O



   monomer / 104oC                                               polymer / 104oC                         polymer / RT

                                                 hν
                                                 h                                          cool
                                      polymerization                                       down




                                                      26Å                                      27Å
                                                                                                 Å
                                    43Å                                            30Å                                  31Å


                                 Carmen Luengo
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
X-linked smectic hydrogen-bridged LC networks
                 hydrogen-
                                                                     O      HO                                    O
                O
                                                O                                           O
                                                                                                              O
           O                                                         OH       O
                                                                   O                                                  O
             O
                                           O                                         O          O
                                                                                                                  O
         O                                                         O
                                                                                     O
                                                       0.50
                                                                                         ν H-bridges
                                                                                           (C=O)
                                                                                     only H bridges / RT
                                            sorbance
                                                       0.40                              H-bonded
                                                                          ν (C=O)                         δ (C=C)
                                                       0.30               acrylate
                                          Abs

                                                       0.20

                                                       0.10

                                                       0.00
                                                       0 00

                                                              1900 1850 1800 1750 1700 1650 1600 1550 1500 1450 1400 1350 1300
                                                                                         Wavenumber
                                                                                                                      O
                                                                                                       free       C
                                                  hν                                                                  OH
                                                                                                       would have ν(C=O)
                                                                                                                   (   )
                                                                                                       at ~ 1730 cm-1
                                 Carmen Luengo
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Covalent X-link bridges conserve order
         X-
during heat cycling
                                                             O    HO               Δ
                                                                                   Δ                    O    HO

                                                             OH   O                                     OH   O
                                              linear / RT                     linear / >200oC                 linear / RT



                                                                       heat                         cool

    linear

                                       X-linked (10w%) / RT                     X-linked / >200oC                 X-linked / RT

  X-linked
  X linked
                                                                       heat                         cool



                                                                               O                                      O
                                                     O
                                                                       O                  O         O
                                                                                                                  O
                                                 O                             O
                                                                                          O
                    Conclusion: Alignment is recovered by presence of covalent X-links
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Covalent X-link bridges conserve order
         X-
during heat cycling
                                                             O       HO                        Δ
                                                                                               Δ                  O         HO

                                                             OH          O                                        OH        O




                                                                         600

                                                                         500

                                                                         400
                                                                                     Birefringence:
                     Δ
                                                                  dΔ n
                                                                         300         planar oriented samples
                                                                                     between rubbed polyimide
                                                                         200
                                                                                     glass plates
                                                                         100

                                                                             0
                                                                                 0        50       100   150          200        250
                                                                                                            o
                                                                                               Temperature ( C)




                                 Carmen Luengo
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Breaking the H-bridges at high pH
             H-
                                                                                                                                                                                        NH4+
                                                            O                HO                                NH44OH
                                                                                                               NH OH                                                        O               O-

                                                            OH                  O                                     H++
                                                                                                                      H                                                     O- NH            +       O
                                                                                                                                                                                         4



             0.14    184-10% om
                            079h eotropicfilm on w ou solu
                                             -am ia, ith t tion                                                                             0.45    184-10% om
                                                                                                                                                           079h eotropicfilm on after addin solu
                                                                                                                                                                            -am ia,        g tion                                       symmetric CO2
                                                                                                                                                                                                Antisymmetric CO2




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        1382.1
                                                                                                                                            0.40
                                                          1675.6


             0.12
                                                                                                                                            0.35
             0.10
                                                                                                                                            0.30




                                                                                                                                                                                                              1531.8
Absorbance




                                                                                                                               Absorbance
             0.08                                                                                                                           0.25

                                                                                                                                            0.20
             0.06
                                                                                                                                            0.15
             0.04
                                                                                                                                            0.10
             0.02
                                                                                                                                            0.05
                                                                                                                                            005



                    1900   1850    1800    1750    1700            1650   1600   1550   1500   1450   1400   1350   1300   1                       1900   1850    1800    1750   1700    1650       1600   1550        1500   1450   1400        1350   1300   1
                                                                          W enum
                                                                            av ber                                                                                                                  W enum
                                                                                                                                                                                                      av ber




                                                                                                                                                          • Hi h order of th l
                                                                                                                                                            High d      f the layers
                                                                                                                                                          • Reduced order within the layer
                                                                          Carmen Luengo
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Breaking the H-bridges at high pH
             H-
                                                                                 NH4+
                           O        HO                       NH44OH
                                                             NH OH           O       O-

                           OH         O                       H++
                                                              H              O- NH    +   O
                                                                                  4




          27Å                                                   NH4OH
                                                    31Å                                         34Å




                                                                        • Hi h order of th l
                                                                          High d      f the layers
                                                                        • Reduced order within the layer
                                 Carmen Luengo
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Opening of the network at high pH
                                                                                    NH4+
                            O        HO                       NH44OH
                                                              NH OH             O       O-

                            OH         O                       H++
                                                               H                O- NH    +   O
                                                                                     4




             27Å                                                 NH4OH
                                                     31Å                                               34Å



       800
                                                                            • Well-spaced p
                                                                                     p      porous p y
                                                                                                     polymer layer
                                                                                                               y
       600
                                                                              structure with ionic interior
                                                                            • Estimated pore size ~ 1 nm when
dΔ n




       400
                                                                              molecular rods adapt random order
                                                                            • Anisotropic ‘in-plane’ pore dimensions
       200          measured pKa                                            • Upon electrolyte/water uptake:
                    at monomer                                                                         in-plane swelling
         0
             0                   4                     8               12
                                           pH
 Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
                                                                                                 Carmen Luengo
Opening of the network at high pH
                                                                                                                           ClO4-

                                                                                                            N


                                                                                             H2N            O   N    CH3

                                                                                                                    CH3


                                                                              reddish/colorless                     blue
                                                         2                                           0.04
t = 0 / pH>11                                                                                               pH < 10.1-11.1
NH4OH solution
                                                        1.5                                          0.03
                                                  nce
                                           Absorban




                                                         1                                           0.02

      t = 24 hrs
                                                        0.5                                          0.01




                                                         0                                            0
                                                          300   400   500     600     700   800    900
         pH ~7
                                                                        Wavelength (nm)     Carmen Luengo
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Filling the ion channels with Ba2+




Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
                                                             Carmen Luengo
Insertion of dipyridines in monomeric state
influences the pore sizes
 Forms a stable smectic complex:
                                                                      ~47 Å          O                               O
      O                                               O                                             O   (CH2)6   O
              O    (CH2)6       O                                                 N HO
                                                      OH      N
      O                                                                             ( SmX 110 I)
                                                                  O
             O                                                                                                   O
                                           O                                  O          O
                                                                                                           O
                                                                  O

                                                                              O

                                                                      ~42 Å


43Å                                              43Å                                          43Å
                                    polymerization                                  NH4OH
                                      at 110 oC
                                      cool to RT


                                                                                             Estimated (XRD) pore sizes:
                                                                                                      5 to 9 nm
                                    Carmen Luengo
 Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Applications being studied

                                                                          easy integration in
    nanolithography, e.g.                                                  μ-fluidic devices
    for nanoelectronics

                                                                                       separation, e.g
                                                                                   for water desalination



                                                                                     clad inner surfaces,
                                                                                       e.g.
                                                                                       e g for catalysis

    templated polymerization,
    e.g.
    e g for anisotropic
    conduction

                                                      ion conduction
                                                     e.g. for batteries   ion l ti
                                                                          i selection, e.g.
                                                                            for blue energy
Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
Summary
•      Engineering toolbox for top down/bottom up polymer network structuring

•      Top down: lithography/holography/printing mostly in the μm range;
       occasionally down to 50 nm

•      Bottom-up: control over molecular order               structured down to nm level

•      Applications:
       Optics, mechanics, electronics, fluidics, separation, biosensors,
       …………………medical, clean technologies.




Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
With thanks to:
 The PICT group at TU/e                                                                The Biomolecular Engineering
 • Cees Bastiaansen                               - Associate Prof.                    group at Philips Research
 • Dick de Boer                                   - Industrial Fellow (10%)            •   Johan Lub
 • Michael Debije                                 - Postdoc                            •   Emiel Peeters
 • Ko Hermans                                     - PhD student                        •   Roel Penterman
 • Carmen Luengo-Gonzalez                         - PhD student                        •   Ralph Kurt
 • Xiaoran Li                                     - PhD student (1/9-08)
                                                                  (1/9 08)             •   David Halter
 • Casper van Oosten                              - PhD student                        •   Christiane de Witz
 • Katherine Pacheco Morillo                      - Postdoc                            •   Titie Mol
 • Helena Plasschaert                             - PhD student                        •   Hans Wilderbeek
 • An Prenen                                      - PhD student                        •   Thijs Bel
                                                                                           Thij B l
 • Shufen Tjoi                                    - PhD student                        •   Jaap den Toonder
 • Joost Valeton                                  - PhD student                        •   Auke van Dijken
 • Shabnam Zakerhamidi                            - Staff                              •   Harry Wondergem
 Just left                                                                             •   Chamindie Punyadeera
 • Chris van Heesch                               - finished PhD                       •   Ron van Lieshout
                                                    (now Philips Research Eindhoven)
                                                                                       •   Judith de Goede
 • Charlotte Kjellander                           - finished PhD
                                                                                       •   Murray Gillies
                                                     (now TNO Holst Eindhoven)
 • Blanca Serrano-Ramon                           - finished PhD
 • Ken Harris                                     - former postdoc
                                                     (now NINT - Edmonton)




Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)

More Related Content

What's hot

Fcv bio cv_simoncelli
Fcv bio cv_simoncelliFcv bio cv_simoncelli
Fcv bio cv_simoncellizukun
 
12.45 o15 m bartle
12.45 o15 m bartle12.45 o15 m bartle
12.45 o15 m bartleNZIP
 
Chap 6 lecture Part 1 with Audio
Chap 6 lecture Part 1 with AudioChap 6 lecture Part 1 with Audio
Chap 6 lecture Part 1 with Audiogneal0907
 
The optical constants of highly absorbing films using the spectral reflectanc...
The optical constants of highly absorbing films using the spectral reflectanc...The optical constants of highly absorbing films using the spectral reflectanc...
The optical constants of highly absorbing films using the spectral reflectanc...Alexander Decker
 
Spatio-temporal control of light in complex media
Spatio-temporal control of  light in complex mediaSpatio-temporal control of  light in complex media
Spatio-temporal control of light in complex mediaSébastien Popoff
 
Poster3
Poster3Poster3
Poster3ozkira
 
DIPA 2000 Particle Size & Shape Analyzer
DIPA 2000 Particle Size & Shape AnalyzerDIPA 2000 Particle Size & Shape Analyzer
DIPA 2000 Particle Size & Shape Analyzerbdon71
 
Mems seismology
Mems seismologyMems seismology
Mems seismologyajsatienza
 
Using GEOBIA to assess crown diameter classes of Acacia tortilis in Bou-Hedma...
Using GEOBIA to assess crown diameter classes of Acacia tortilis in Bou-Hedma...Using GEOBIA to assess crown diameter classes of Acacia tortilis in Bou-Hedma...
Using GEOBIA to assess crown diameter classes of Acacia tortilis in Bou-Hedma...kdlaplac
 
Vapor phase cutting of carbon nanotubes using a nanomanipulator platform-ms&t...
Vapor phase cutting of carbon nanotubes using a nanomanipulator platform-ms&t...Vapor phase cutting of carbon nanotubes using a nanomanipulator platform-ms&t...
Vapor phase cutting of carbon nanotubes using a nanomanipulator platform-ms&t...Paul McClure
 

What's hot (19)

Fcv bio cv_simoncelli
Fcv bio cv_simoncelliFcv bio cv_simoncelli
Fcv bio cv_simoncelli
 
3
33
3
 
12.45 o15 m bartle
12.45 o15 m bartle12.45 o15 m bartle
12.45 o15 m bartle
 
Hoip10 presentacion cambios de color_univ_granada
Hoip10 presentacion cambios de color_univ_granadaHoip10 presentacion cambios de color_univ_granada
Hoip10 presentacion cambios de color_univ_granada
 
Chap 6 lecture Part 1 with Audio
Chap 6 lecture Part 1 with AudioChap 6 lecture Part 1 with Audio
Chap 6 lecture Part 1 with Audio
 
EFFECT OF DEPOSITION PERIOD AND pH
EFFECT OF DEPOSITION PERIOD AND pHEFFECT OF DEPOSITION PERIOD AND pH
EFFECT OF DEPOSITION PERIOD AND pH
 
The optical constants of highly absorbing films using the spectral reflectanc...
The optical constants of highly absorbing films using the spectral reflectanc...The optical constants of highly absorbing films using the spectral reflectanc...
The optical constants of highly absorbing films using the spectral reflectanc...
 
Spatio-temporal control of light in complex media
Spatio-temporal control of  light in complex mediaSpatio-temporal control of  light in complex media
Spatio-temporal control of light in complex media
 
History and Current Status of Strontium Iodide Scintillators
History and Current Status of Strontium Iodide ScintillatorsHistory and Current Status of Strontium Iodide Scintillators
History and Current Status of Strontium Iodide Scintillators
 
Poster3
Poster3Poster3
Poster3
 
DIPA 2000 Particle Size & Shape Analyzer
DIPA 2000 Particle Size & Shape AnalyzerDIPA 2000 Particle Size & Shape Analyzer
DIPA 2000 Particle Size & Shape Analyzer
 
Algae for biofuels production
Algae for biofuels production Algae for biofuels production
Algae for biofuels production
 
Radioisotopes jps
Radioisotopes jpsRadioisotopes jps
Radioisotopes jps
 
Testo 881 datasheet
Testo 881 datasheetTesto 881 datasheet
Testo 881 datasheet
 
Mems seismology
Mems seismologyMems seismology
Mems seismology
 
Using GEOBIA to assess crown diameter classes of Acacia tortilis in Bou-Hedma...
Using GEOBIA to assess crown diameter classes of Acacia tortilis in Bou-Hedma...Using GEOBIA to assess crown diameter classes of Acacia tortilis in Bou-Hedma...
Using GEOBIA to assess crown diameter classes of Acacia tortilis in Bou-Hedma...
 
BME 521 December 6
BME 521 December 6BME 521 December 6
BME 521 December 6
 
Vapor phase cutting of carbon nanotubes using a nanomanipulator platform-ms&t...
Vapor phase cutting of carbon nanotubes using a nanomanipulator platform-ms&t...Vapor phase cutting of carbon nanotubes using a nanomanipulator platform-ms&t...
Vapor phase cutting of carbon nanotubes using a nanomanipulator platform-ms&t...
 
671 679
671 679671 679
671 679
 

Similar to Icam 2009 Soft Actuators H Bridges Nanopores

sensors & actuators.
sensors & actuators.sensors & actuators.
sensors & actuators.Naseem abbas
 
Nanotechnology by manish myst ssgbcoet
Nanotechnology by manish myst ssgbcoetNanotechnology by manish myst ssgbcoet
Nanotechnology by manish myst ssgbcoetManish Myst
 
Nanosensors basics design and applications.pptx
Nanosensors basics design and applications.pptxNanosensors basics design and applications.pptx
Nanosensors basics design and applications.pptxssuser65cc68
 
Introduction to nanoparticles and bionanomaterials
Introduction to nanoparticles and bionanomaterialsIntroduction to nanoparticles and bionanomaterials
Introduction to nanoparticles and bionanomaterialsShreyaBhatt23
 
Albelissa nanoforum2012 perucca_2
Albelissa nanoforum2012 perucca_2Albelissa nanoforum2012 perucca_2
Albelissa nanoforum2012 perucca_2Massimo_Perucca
 
iMinds The Conference 2012: Bernard Gallez
iMinds The Conference 2012: Bernard GalleziMinds The Conference 2012: Bernard Gallez
iMinds The Conference 2012: Bernard Gallezimec
 
Practical Use Of Nanomaterials In Plastics
Practical Use Of Nanomaterials In PlasticsPractical Use Of Nanomaterials In Plastics
Practical Use Of Nanomaterials In Plasticslusik
 
Recent advancement in microscopic techniques cryoem and super
Recent advancement in microscopic techniques  cryoem and superRecent advancement in microscopic techniques  cryoem and super
Recent advancement in microscopic techniques cryoem and superDanishNigar
 
Lensfree Microscopy and Tomography
Lensfree Microscopy and TomographyLensfree Microscopy and Tomography
Lensfree Microscopy and TomographySERHAN ISIKMAN
 
Metal ano particles and rods for biosensors
Metal ano particles and rods for biosensorsMetal ano particles and rods for biosensors
Metal ano particles and rods for biosensorsvenkata016
 

Similar to Icam 2009 Soft Actuators H Bridges Nanopores (20)

Nanotechnology
NanotechnologyNanotechnology
Nanotechnology
 
De Long - Natural Materials, Systems and Extremophiles - Spring Review 2012
De Long - Natural Materials, Systems and Extremophiles - Spring Review 2012De Long - Natural Materials, Systems and Extremophiles - Spring Review 2012
De Long - Natural Materials, Systems and Extremophiles - Spring Review 2012
 
sensors & actuators.
sensors & actuators.sensors & actuators.
sensors & actuators.
 
Advanced medical micro devices
Advanced medical micro devicesAdvanced medical micro devices
Advanced medical micro devices
 
Nanomedicine 2005
Nanomedicine 2005Nanomedicine 2005
Nanomedicine 2005
 
Nanotechnology by manish myst ssgbcoet
Nanotechnology by manish myst ssgbcoetNanotechnology by manish myst ssgbcoet
Nanotechnology by manish myst ssgbcoet
 
Nanosensors basics design and applications.pptx
Nanosensors basics design and applications.pptxNanosensors basics design and applications.pptx
Nanosensors basics design and applications.pptx
 
Introduction to nanoparticles and bionanomaterials
Introduction to nanoparticles and bionanomaterialsIntroduction to nanoparticles and bionanomaterials
Introduction to nanoparticles and bionanomaterials
 
Albelissa nanoforum2012 perucca_2
Albelissa nanoforum2012 perucca_2Albelissa nanoforum2012 perucca_2
Albelissa nanoforum2012 perucca_2
 
Nanobots
NanobotsNanobots
Nanobots
 
Nanobots
NanobotsNanobots
Nanobots
 
Nano - Robotics - The future world
Nano - Robotics - The future worldNano - Robotics - The future world
Nano - Robotics - The future world
 
iMinds The Conference 2012: Bernard Gallez
iMinds The Conference 2012: Bernard GalleziMinds The Conference 2012: Bernard Gallez
iMinds The Conference 2012: Bernard Gallez
 
Chemist’s Approach to Nanofabrication: Towards a “Desktop Fab”
Chemist’s Approach to Nanofabrication: Towards a “Desktop Fab”Chemist’s Approach to Nanofabrication: Towards a “Desktop Fab”
Chemist’s Approach to Nanofabrication: Towards a “Desktop Fab”
 
Practical Use Of Nanomaterials In Plastics
Practical Use Of Nanomaterials In PlasticsPractical Use Of Nanomaterials In Plastics
Practical Use Of Nanomaterials In Plastics
 
Nanotechnology
NanotechnologyNanotechnology
Nanotechnology
 
Recent advancement in microscopic techniques cryoem and super
Recent advancement in microscopic techniques  cryoem and superRecent advancement in microscopic techniques  cryoem and super
Recent advancement in microscopic techniques cryoem and super
 
Nanotechnology
NanotechnologyNanotechnology
Nanotechnology
 
Lensfree Microscopy and Tomography
Lensfree Microscopy and TomographyLensfree Microscopy and Tomography
Lensfree Microscopy and Tomography
 
Metal ano particles and rods for biosensors
Metal ano particles and rods for biosensorsMetal ano particles and rods for biosensors
Metal ano particles and rods for biosensors
 

Icam 2009 Soft Actuators H Bridges Nanopores

  • 1. Photopolymerization of LC networks as Ph t l i ti f t k tool for micro- and nanostructuring micro Towards Soft Actuators & Nanoporous Membranes Dirk J. Broer, C.W.M. Bastiaansen, C.L. van Oosten, K. D. Harris, J. Lub, C. K D Harris J Lub C Luengo Gonzalez Eindhoven University of Technology Philips Research Laboratories
  • 2. Functional polymers towards medical and cleantech l t h • biosensors • regenerative medicine • μ-fluidics fluidics • triggered scaffolds • MEMS • fiber technology membranes b responsive materials Nano- Nano-medicine Water treatment Energy / light management • purification ifi ti • light capturing & guiding • targeted filtering • sun tracking • electro dialysis • reverse electrodialysis • (blue energy) Clean Technologies self- self-organized micro- and nano features micro- Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 3. Soft Actuators Courtesy: http://plantsinmotion.bio.indiana.edu phototropism in sunflower phototropism in plastic Courtesy: Nikon Microscopy /Digital Video Gallery cilia motion in paramecium cilia motion in plastic Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 4. Soft Actuators • Actuating elements, e.g. in microfluidic devices, μ-pumps, mixers, valves • (Bio) sensors & controlled drugs release • Artificial muscles / robotics • Regenerative medicine • Energy harvesting and sun tracking What is needed ? • Responsive molecules • Miniaturize structures down to μm level • Integrate into devices • Improve on motion figures, e g as inspired by micro organisms e.g. micro-organisms Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 5. Electrostatic actuation of integrated artificial cilia g Jaap den Toonder, Hans Wilderbeek, Titie Mol, Murray Gillies, Judith de Goede, Wim Talen Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 6. Fabrication of electrostatic elements 800 μm 100 μm glass (embedded electrodes not shown) develop acrylate in alkaline solution + patterned Al (100 nm) add 10 nm chromium layer etch Cr in cerium ammonium nitrate add 10 μm acrylate mix etch Al in phosphoric acid photopolymerized through mask CH3 O CH3 CH2 C n O C C CH2 C O CH2 O CH3 O CH3 CH2 C CH2 O C C CH2 CH2 CH2 induced stresses make the elements curl O C C CH2 Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers) O CH3 Christiane de Witz, Thijs Bel
  • 7. Photopolymerization of self-organizing reactive liquid crystals liquid crystal with reactive end groups O O O O O O O O O O hν bottom-up / top-down nano/micro structuring aligned LC monomer Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 8. ± 25 yrs experience: LC networks are presently used to improve LCDs on viewing angle, contrast and brightness angle hν based on solid coatings and thin films with anisotropic optical properties e.g. Δn = n// - n⊥= 0.05 to 0.25 Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 9. Liquid Crystal Actuators O O O O O O O O O O hν LC networks • Can be patterned, e.g. by lithographic means • Can be made responsive by orientation gradients • High modulus - 1GPa • Large work potential! despite small deformations ~ 2% Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 10. Thermal actuation splayed LC network poly(C3M) / 60 μm αe contraction expansion αo 500 400 300 αo 200 α (ppm.K-1) 100 0 100 -100 -200 αe -300 200 250 300 350 400 450 T (K) Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers) Titie Mol
  • 11. UV light driven parallel to uniaxial orientation UV VIS perpendicular to uniaxial orientation E Z E contraction Z expansion Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 12. Liquid crystal network UV-actuator q y Specific internal work comparison Modulus Work density* Actuator comparison Strain (MPa) (kJ/m3) LC network UV actuator 1,5% 1000 56 1 LC elastomer UV actuator 13% 1 4 2 Thermal LC elastomer 50% 1 50 2 Skeletal Muscle 20% 40 80 *W = ¼ ε2E 1. M. Camacho-Lopez et al., Nat. Mater., vol. 3, 2004, 307-310 2. 2 J.Madden al., J. J Madden et al J Of Oceanic Eng 29 (3) July 2004 706-728 Eng., (3), 2004, 706 728 Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 13. Optimized X-link density for fast response UV 0s 8s 16 s 24 s 32 s VIS 0s 4s 8s 12 s 20 s poly(5.5wt-%A6MA/C6M) O H2C O (CH2)6 O O + 48% O (CH2)5 CH3 O 0s 0.08 s 0.16 s 0.24 s 0.32 s Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 14. Bending also possible in uniaxial LC networks with gradient i UV i t ith di t in intensity it gradient in deformation gradient in UV intensity Light tracking Tabiryan Under study: Beam Engineering efficient light harvesting Bunning group, Air Force for solar energy? Lab Dayton, USA O ti Express, 2005 13 7442 Optics E 2005, 13, Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 15. Back bending of uniaxial films in UV gradient films • time delayed azo response • photobleaching • bending depends on X-link Acknowledge Mark Warner density • X-link gradient by X link polymerization-induced diffusion UV light Side Sid A Fast reacting molecules Intensity gradient Slower reacting molecules Substrate Side B Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 16. Device integrated photoresponsive elements: • structured by inkjet technology • multi-color responsive elements multi- 160 140 contraction 120 100 Angle 80 (degr) 60 40 20 expansion p 0 0 500 1000 1500 2000 I (mW/cm2) Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 17. Next steps at TU/e group Reverse function and employ microstructures f energy harvesting: l i t t for h ti E.g. • polymer flaps with oriented dipoles (ferroelectrics) • electrodes top and bottom Energy from: • breeze • motion (vibration e.g. in building) • sound First estimates: 0.1 to 10 W.m-2 large area technologies Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 18. Reduction of order parameter + gradients in director profile driving force for geometry changes Mechanisms for Order Reduction / triggers – Temperature variation – Breaking order by isomerization under radiation – Breaking chemical bonds, chemical reactions (pH) – Solvent swelling/deswelling Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 19. Anisotropic hydrogels: H-bridged LC networks O HO O O O O O O OH O L. Strezelecki, L. Liebert, Bull. Soc. Chim. France, 597 (1973) & 605 (1973) hν Cr 92 SmA 110 I Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 20. Anisotropic hydrogels: H-bridged LC networks OBA n = 3,5,6 (1:1:1) C6M 140 120 hν 100 Temperatu ( C) o 80 70 -105 oC processing window ure 60 Nematic N ti 12 wt% C6M // 40 Smectic 20 Cryst 0 Cryst ⊥ -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 Composition (wt% C6M) Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 21. Anisotropic swelling in alkaline buffer solution O HO OH- O O- OH O H+ O- O L⊥ L// %) ansion (% ΔL ⊥ ΔL // > L⊥ L // L⊥+ΔL Expa ⊥ Time (min) Ti ( i ) L//+ΔL// Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 22. Chemical Actuation – pH • Twisted configuration g • poly(nOBA/12%C6M) • 18μm thick • pH controlled with NaOH and acetic acid slow expansion fast expansion • Motion occurs over limited pH range at pH~11 • Deformation i reversible D f ti is ibl Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 23. Activate by KOH dip – deactivate in acetic acid polymer chains L activate deactivateo base acid Challenges: • water driven motor (with Peter Palffy-Muhoray) • (bio) molecular recognition: -NH2, CO2, O2 together with Sijbesma -TU/e uptake of agent molecules Lt Ken Harris, Casper van Oosten Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 24. Application of a hydrogel soft actuator: Wrapping of eukaryotic cells Objectives: • To develop cell delivery technique • Potential to combine different cell population Status: • Experiments withA 431, human withA-431, carcinoma epidermoid cells 37 25 oC 25 37 oC Sara Pedrón-Haba, Emiel Peeters, Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 25. Smectic hydrogen-bridged networks towards nano-channels h l OBA n = 3 5 6 (1:1:1) 3,5,6 C6M 140 120 100 Temperatu (oC) 80 ure 60 Nematic N ti 40 Smectic 20 Cryst 0 Cryst -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 Composition (wt% C6M) Carmen Luengo Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 26. X-linked smectic hydrogen-bridged LC networks hydrogen- O O HO ~19 Å O O O O O OH O O O O O ~42 Å 42 O O O O O O monomer / 104oC polymer / 104oC polymer / RT hν h cool polymerization down 26Å 27Å Å 43Å 30Å 31Å Carmen Luengo Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 27. X-linked smectic hydrogen-bridged LC networks hydrogen- O HO O O O O O O OH O O O O O O O O O O O 0.50 ν H-bridges (C=O) only H bridges / RT sorbance 0.40 H-bonded ν (C=O) δ (C=C) 0.30 acrylate Abs 0.20 0.10 0.00 0 00 1900 1850 1800 1750 1700 1650 1600 1550 1500 1450 1400 1350 1300 Wavenumber O free C hν OH would have ν(C=O) ( ) at ~ 1730 cm-1 Carmen Luengo Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 28. Covalent X-link bridges conserve order X- during heat cycling O HO Δ Δ O HO OH O OH O linear / RT linear / >200oC linear / RT heat cool linear X-linked (10w%) / RT X-linked / >200oC X-linked / RT X-linked X linked heat cool O O O O O O O O O O Conclusion: Alignment is recovered by presence of covalent X-links Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 29. Covalent X-link bridges conserve order X- during heat cycling O HO Δ Δ O HO OH O OH O 600 500 400 Birefringence: Δ dΔ n 300 planar oriented samples between rubbed polyimide 200 glass plates 100 0 0 50 100 150 200 250 o Temperature ( C) Carmen Luengo Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 30. Breaking the H-bridges at high pH H- NH4+ O HO NH44OH NH OH O O- OH O H++ H O- NH + O 4 0.14 184-10% om 079h eotropicfilm on w ou solu -am ia, ith t tion 0.45 184-10% om 079h eotropicfilm on after addin solu -am ia, g tion symmetric CO2 Antisymmetric CO2 1382.1 0.40 1675.6 0.12 0.35 0.10 0.30 1531.8 Absorbance Absorbance 0.08 0.25 0.20 0.06 0.15 0.04 0.10 0.02 0.05 005 1900 1850 1800 1750 1700 1650 1600 1550 1500 1450 1400 1350 1300 1 1900 1850 1800 1750 1700 1650 1600 1550 1500 1450 1400 1350 1300 1 W enum av ber W enum av ber • Hi h order of th l High d f the layers • Reduced order within the layer Carmen Luengo Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 31. Breaking the H-bridges at high pH H- NH4+ O HO NH44OH NH OH O O- OH O H++ H O- NH + O 4 27Å NH4OH 31Å 34Å • Hi h order of th l High d f the layers • Reduced order within the layer Carmen Luengo Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 32. Opening of the network at high pH NH4+ O HO NH44OH NH OH O O- OH O H++ H O- NH + O 4 27Å NH4OH 31Å 34Å 800 • Well-spaced p p porous p y polymer layer y 600 structure with ionic interior • Estimated pore size ~ 1 nm when dΔ n 400 molecular rods adapt random order • Anisotropic ‘in-plane’ pore dimensions 200 measured pKa • Upon electrolyte/water uptake: at monomer in-plane swelling 0 0 4 8 12 pH Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers) Carmen Luengo
  • 33. Opening of the network at high pH ClO4- N H2N O N CH3 CH3 reddish/colorless blue 2 0.04 t = 0 / pH>11 pH < 10.1-11.1 NH4OH solution 1.5 0.03 nce Absorban 1 0.02 t = 24 hrs 0.5 0.01 0 0 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 pH ~7 Wavelength (nm) Carmen Luengo Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 34. Filling the ion channels with Ba2+ Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers) Carmen Luengo
  • 35. Insertion of dipyridines in monomeric state influences the pore sizes Forms a stable smectic complex: ~47 Å O O O O O (CH2)6 O O (CH2)6 O N HO OH N O ( SmX 110 I) O O O O O O O O O ~42 Å 43Å 43Å 43Å polymerization NH4OH at 110 oC cool to RT Estimated (XRD) pore sizes: 5 to 9 nm Carmen Luengo Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 36. Applications being studied easy integration in nanolithography, e.g. μ-fluidic devices for nanoelectronics separation, e.g for water desalination clad inner surfaces, e.g. e g for catalysis templated polymerization, e.g. e g for anisotropic conduction ion conduction e.g. for batteries ion l ti i selection, e.g. for blue energy Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 37. Summary • Engineering toolbox for top down/bottom up polymer network structuring • Top down: lithography/holography/printing mostly in the μm range; occasionally down to 50 nm • Bottom-up: control over molecular order structured down to nm level • Applications: Optics, mechanics, electronics, fluidics, separation, biosensors, …………………medical, clean technologies. Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)
  • 38. With thanks to: The PICT group at TU/e The Biomolecular Engineering • Cees Bastiaansen - Associate Prof. group at Philips Research • Dick de Boer - Industrial Fellow (10%) • Johan Lub • Michael Debije - Postdoc • Emiel Peeters • Ko Hermans - PhD student • Roel Penterman • Carmen Luengo-Gonzalez - PhD student • Ralph Kurt • Xiaoran Li - PhD student (1/9-08) (1/9 08) • David Halter • Casper van Oosten - PhD student • Christiane de Witz • Katherine Pacheco Morillo - Postdoc • Titie Mol • Helena Plasschaert - PhD student • Hans Wilderbeek • An Prenen - PhD student • Thijs Bel Thij B l • Shufen Tjoi - PhD student • Jaap den Toonder • Joost Valeton - PhD student • Auke van Dijken • Shabnam Zakerhamidi - Staff • Harry Wondergem Just left • Chamindie Punyadeera • Chris van Heesch - finished PhD • Ron van Lieshout (now Philips Research Eindhoven) • Judith de Goede • Charlotte Kjellander - finished PhD • Murray Gillies (now TNO Holst Eindhoven) • Blanca Serrano-Ramon - finished PhD • Ken Harris - former postdoc (now NINT - Edmonton) Philips Research Laboratories, D.J.Broer, Date(in numbers)