SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Just because a teacher is
teaching, does not mean
students are learning
STOP MARKING!
“The most powerful single modification that
enhances achievement is feedback.” (John Hattie)
“Much of the feedback that students get
has little or no effect on their learning.”
(Dylan Wiliam)
“Teachers who spend time crafting helpful
comments are wasting their time if they also
give a mark.”
(Dylan Wiliam)
13/20
Interest in learning is
diminished and thinking is
more superficial
Feedback should
cause thinking.
Students must be required to respond to
feedback
A B C D/F
Volume So loud I can’t hear
myself think
Loud enough that I
can’t hear myself
speak
Loud-ish in some parts of
the room but quiet in
others
So quiet I can hear the
toilets flush
Tempo Rapid: Hands are
hurriedly smacked
together
Fast: Hands are
quickly brought
together
Leisurely: Hands are hit
together at an unhurried
pace
Slow: Fingers are slowly
tapped together
Dynamics Erupts suddenly,
builds to a
deafening crescendo
that is sustained for
a second or more,
then fades slowly
and reluctantly
Builds up for a
second, peaks, then
fades
No change in dynamics:
Half-hearted throughout
Begins with a silent pause,
pitter-pats for a second,
then fizzles
Applause Rubric
Where am I?
Where am I going?
How do I get there?
Be kind
Be specific
Be helpful
“Experience success and failure not as a
reward and punishment, but as
information.” (Jerome Bruner)
20-Seconds
What is the most important
thing you have learned so far at
this Teach-Meet?
20-Seconds
What is one question that you
have?
Assessment is a
conversation, not a
number
Learning or
Performance?

More Related Content

More from Cameron Paterson

Education Leadership presentation.pptx
Education Leadership presentation.pptxEducation Leadership presentation.pptx
Education Leadership presentation.pptxCameron Paterson
 
Complex Leadership presentation.pptx
Complex Leadership presentation.pptxComplex Leadership presentation.pptx
Complex Leadership presentation.pptxCameron Paterson
 
Who is Going to Teach the Kids.pptx
Who is Going to Teach the Kids.pptxWho is Going to Teach the Kids.pptx
Who is Going to Teach the Kids.pptxCameron Paterson
 
Presentation for St Louis School of Milan2022.pptx
Presentation for St Louis School of Milan2022.pptxPresentation for St Louis School of Milan2022.pptx
Presentation for St Louis School of Milan2022.pptxCameron Paterson
 
Unsettled: Exploring Systems of Power
Unsettled: Exploring Systems of PowerUnsettled: Exploring Systems of Power
Unsettled: Exploring Systems of PowerCameron Paterson
 
Syd Uni - Assessment lecture 2021
Syd Uni - Assessment lecture 2021Syd Uni - Assessment lecture 2021
Syd Uni - Assessment lecture 2021Cameron Paterson
 
Redesigning Unjust Systems
Redesigning Unjust SystemsRedesigning Unjust Systems
Redesigning Unjust SystemsCameron Paterson
 
Redesigning Unjust Systems
Redesigning Unjust SystemsRedesigning Unjust Systems
Redesigning Unjust SystemsCameron Paterson
 
Syd Uni Assessment Lecture 2020
Syd Uni Assessment Lecture 2020Syd Uni Assessment Lecture 2020
Syd Uni Assessment Lecture 2020Cameron Paterson
 
Mentone Grammar January 2020
Mentone Grammar January 2020Mentone Grammar January 2020
Mentone Grammar January 2020Cameron Paterson
 
Coaching for a Culture of Thinking
Coaching for a Culture of ThinkingCoaching for a Culture of Thinking
Coaching for a Culture of ThinkingCameron Paterson
 

More from Cameron Paterson (20)

Education Leadership presentation.pptx
Education Leadership presentation.pptxEducation Leadership presentation.pptx
Education Leadership presentation.pptx
 
Complex Leadership presentation.pptx
Complex Leadership presentation.pptxComplex Leadership presentation.pptx
Complex Leadership presentation.pptx
 
Who is Going to Teach the Kids.pptx
Who is Going to Teach the Kids.pptxWho is Going to Teach the Kids.pptx
Who is Going to Teach the Kids.pptx
 
Presentation for St Louis School of Milan2022.pptx
Presentation for St Louis School of Milan2022.pptxPresentation for St Louis School of Milan2022.pptx
Presentation for St Louis School of Milan2022.pptx
 
LeadMeet 2021
LeadMeet 2021LeadMeet 2021
LeadMeet 2021
 
Unsettled: Exploring Systems of Power
Unsettled: Exploring Systems of PowerUnsettled: Exploring Systems of Power
Unsettled: Exploring Systems of Power
 
JxD workshop PZAus 2021
JxD workshop PZAus 2021 JxD workshop PZAus 2021
JxD workshop PZAus 2021
 
Syd Uni - Assessment lecture 2021
Syd Uni - Assessment lecture 2021Syd Uni - Assessment lecture 2021
Syd Uni - Assessment lecture 2021
 
Redesigning Unjust Systems
Redesigning Unjust SystemsRedesigning Unjust Systems
Redesigning Unjust Systems
 
Redesigning Unjust Systems
Redesigning Unjust SystemsRedesigning Unjust Systems
Redesigning Unjust Systems
 
QHTA
QHTAQHTA
QHTA
 
TeachMeet Road Ahead
TeachMeet Road AheadTeachMeet Road Ahead
TeachMeet Road Ahead
 
Democracy and Education
Democracy and EducationDemocracy and Education
Democracy and Education
 
ACSA TeachMeet 2020
ACSA TeachMeet 2020ACSA TeachMeet 2020
ACSA TeachMeet 2020
 
Syd Uni Assessment Lecture 2020
Syd Uni Assessment Lecture 2020Syd Uni Assessment Lecture 2020
Syd Uni Assessment Lecture 2020
 
Distance Learning Plan
Distance Learning PlanDistance Learning Plan
Distance Learning Plan
 
Mentone Grammar January 2020
Mentone Grammar January 2020Mentone Grammar January 2020
Mentone Grammar January 2020
 
PZ Sydney TeachMeet
PZ Sydney TeachMeetPZ Sydney TeachMeet
PZ Sydney TeachMeet
 
Coaching for a Culture of Thinking
Coaching for a Culture of ThinkingCoaching for a Culture of Thinking
Coaching for a Culture of Thinking
 
Coaching for CoT
Coaching for CoTCoaching for CoT
Coaching for CoT
 

Stop marking pk

  • 1. Just because a teacher is teaching, does not mean students are learning STOP MARKING!
  • 2. “The most powerful single modification that enhances achievement is feedback.” (John Hattie)
  • 3. “Much of the feedback that students get has little or no effect on their learning.” (Dylan Wiliam)
  • 4. “Teachers who spend time crafting helpful comments are wasting their time if they also give a mark.” (Dylan Wiliam) 13/20
  • 5. Interest in learning is diminished and thinking is more superficial
  • 7. Students must be required to respond to feedback
  • 8.
  • 9. A B C D/F Volume So loud I can’t hear myself think Loud enough that I can’t hear myself speak Loud-ish in some parts of the room but quiet in others So quiet I can hear the toilets flush Tempo Rapid: Hands are hurriedly smacked together Fast: Hands are quickly brought together Leisurely: Hands are hit together at an unhurried pace Slow: Fingers are slowly tapped together Dynamics Erupts suddenly, builds to a deafening crescendo that is sustained for a second or more, then fades slowly and reluctantly Builds up for a second, peaks, then fades No change in dynamics: Half-hearted throughout Begins with a silent pause, pitter-pats for a second, then fizzles Applause Rubric
  • 10.
  • 12. Where am I going?
  • 13. How do I get there?
  • 17. “Experience success and failure not as a reward and punishment, but as information.” (Jerome Bruner)
  • 18. 20-Seconds What is the most important thing you have learned so far at this Teach-Meet?
  • 19. 20-Seconds What is one question that you have?