SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
Download to read offline
APRIL 2015 RESEARCH REPORT
The Latino Experience in
Museums: An Exploratory
Audience Research Study
Contemporanea contemporanea.usT 415.404.6982San Francisco CA 941035 Third Street Suite 925
Salvador Acevedo
Principal
Monique Madara
Senior Insights Strategist
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
1
INTRODUCTION
The fast growth of the Latino population in the Unit-
ed States is a well-known fact, but most museums ac-
knowledge that this growth is not reflected among
their audiences. According to the National Endowment
for the Arts’s Survey of Public Participation in the Arts
(SPPA, the nation’s largest population survey of arts par-
ticipation trends), cultural participation among Latinos
is slowly growing. For example, the 2013 SPPA report
shows that 14.5% of adults who visited an art museum
identify as Latinos—an increase of just 0.2% from the
2008 report. Even though there are many general de-
mographic studies about the participation of Latinos
and other minority groups in museums and the arts
(SPPA/NEA, 2013; Farrell, B. & Medvedeva, M., 2010; In-
stitute of Museum and Library Services, 2008), there are
few studies that focus specifically on the perceptions,
motivations, and values of this population associated
with museums and other cultural institutions (Betan-
court, 2012; MPAC, 2008). Contemporanea’s primary
motivation in conducting this study is to contribute to
the field of museums and cultural institutions by deep-
ening the discussion of audience diversification.
An in-depth understanding of the Latino experience in
museums can help provide institutions with the foun-
dation for strategic planning that supports long-term
sustainability. This exploratory research study attempts
to understand the drivers of engagement and the un-
derlying factors that permeate the experience of Lati-
nos at museums—any type of museum—with the goal
of helping organizations to design experiences that are
engaging and relevant for this important growing pop-
ulation1
. While there are important distinctions among
the different types of museums that need to be consid-
ered, our analysis focuses on commonalities and shared
insights. Additional research and analysis may be useful
in building on this research and highlighting those dif-
ferences. Furthermore, while this study focuses on mu-
seums, its implications are broader in reach and likely
relevant for the cultural participation field in general.
1 For the purposes of this study, we do not include Latino or other
culturally specific museums in the scope of this research.
METHODOLOGY
1. Six focus groups among self-identified Latino respon-
dents were conducted in California. A total of 50 partici-
pants were divided into two main categories:
• Spanish dominant – limited or no English
fluency (sessions conducted in Spanish with
28 participants)
• Bilingual – different levels of Spanish fluency,
from conversational to fully bilingual
(sessions conducted in English with 22
participants)
All respondents represent head of household, the ma-
jority with children and/or grandchildren under 18
years old living at home. The respondent pool includes
a mix of education and income levels; urban, suburban,
and rural residencies; and countries of origin represen-
tative of the total Latino population. Most respondents
(75%) were foreign born, while the rest were born in the
United States. All participants had visited at least one
museum (of any type) at least once in the 12 months
prior to the interview date.
2. An online survey was conducted with self-identified
Latino residents of California (224 respondents). Respon-
dents selected their preferred questionnaire language,
with 58.9% responding in English and 41.1% in Spanish.
A mix of income and education levels participated, and
all had visited a museum of some type in the previous
year. A convenience sampling approach was used in ac-
cordance with the exploratory objectives of the study.
For the purposes of this report, respondents are divid-
ed in two main segments: low acculturation and high
acculturation2
. The level of acculturation was based on
language preference (Spanish dominant and bilingual);
place of birth (U.S. born and foreign born); education and
socioeconomic levels; and (for the foreign born) number
of years living in the United States. This segmentation
approach is commonly used in corporate-sector market
research studies, and provides a base for an analysis of
the evolution of attitudes over time.
2 Acculturation refers to the process of acquiring a second culture,
while maintaining the original one.
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
2
MAIN FINDINGS AND IMPLICATIONS
The results herein are presented in three sections. The
first looks into the signals of inclusion provided by a
museum that make Latinos feel welcome. The second
explores the motivations and drivers of participation
among Latinos, including desired experiences and the
dynamic impact of acculturation. The third section
outlines perceptions and real-world experiences that
inhibit engagement, and identifies immediate areas
of opportunity for museums seeking to engage Lati-
no audiences.
1. Signals of Inclusion and Acknowledgement
This study explores aspects of museum participation
among Latinos and offers numerous insights on their
participation drivers and barriers. A pervasive theme
woven throughout respondent feedback, including
that related to driver and barrier insights, was the de-
livery (or lack thereof) of overt signals of inclusion that
speak directly to Latinos. The presence or absence of
these signals in many ways amplifies or inhibits their
experience and directly shapes their perceptions of val-
ue.Therefore, due to their importance, these signals are
provided first to give context to themes presented in
the remainder of this report.
In this research, respondents articulated ways in which
museums can welcome and include potential Latino
visitors. Without exception, the two most important
factors that convey inclusion are:
• A diverse staff that“looks like us”in language,
appearance, cultural identity, values, etc.
• The use of Spanish language
communications
Of these two, the first is considered by far the most
important. Participants reported wanting to see other
Latinos working at museums, “…but not only as jan-
itors.” Personnel who interact directly with visitors are
critical for newcomers because they can help decode
the experience, convey behavioral expectations, high-
light available resources, and otherwise create a com-
fortable experience. In addition to seeing Latino staff
included in visitor services, respondents would like to
see them included in the planning of exhibits and pro-
grams, actively contributing a Latino perspective as cu-
rators and advisors.This research implies that museums
integrating Latino staff throughout more levels and
functions of the organization can make large strides in
delivering programming and experiences that are val-
ued by Latino visitors.
The presence of Spanish-language communications is
considered critical, not only to support comprehension
of the exhibits or programs (a functional need), but
also to create an emotional connection. Low-accultur-
ation respondents frequently mentioned feeling more
comfortable reading labels and panels in Spanish and
cited largely functional benefits. High-acculturation
and bilingual respondents mentioned more emotion-
al reasons, including the concern that Spanish-dom-
inant family members also enjoy the visit. In essence,
museums can immediately leverage the use of Span-
ish- language communications in marketing and inter-
pretation to signal inclusion and cultural relevance to
Latinos of all acculturation levels.
2. Drivers of Museum Participation among Latinos
2.1 An Educational Experience
The role of museums as educational institutions
is well established among this sample of Latinos.
Respondents refer to them as places:
• Worth visiting
• To discover new things to learn
• To learn in a fun or entertaining way
• To explore the cultural and scientific heritage
of different people
• To appreciate art and artifacts from people
and cultures around the world
• To learn about the past and its connections
to the present
• To teach children about their own or other
people’s heritage and traditions
• Where individuals can come together, leave
behind societal labels, and simply
appreciate the beauty and inspiration of art
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
3
The benefit of a museum visit is strongly connected to
education, though this perception is nuanced by the
presence of children in the home. Respondents with no
children at home are more focused on their own individ-
ual experiences, specifically that of having a meaning-
ful and enjoyable visit and sharing it with their friends
or family. Conversely, respondents with children living
at home tend to prioritize benefits for the children over
their own. For these parents, the role and impact of the
museum or specific exhibit on child growth and educa-
tion is the most important consideration.
Latinos in this study specify that, in addition to being
educational, the experience must be enjoyable for the
entire party and not solely for the children because vis-
itor groups are often multi-generational and include
extended family and friends. While the entertainment
value of the experience is clearly not the primary rea-
son for attendance, it is regarded as an important com-
ponent, an engagement driver, and an underlying pre-
requisite for attendance.
2.2 An Experience of Connection
In this study, we identified a certain connecting func-
tion that museums fulfill for Latinos, which may be
better explained using the concepts of bonding and
bridging. As Robert Putman defined in his book Bowl-
ing Alone (2000),“bonding”refers to the value assigned
to social networks between homogeneous groups of
people. “Bridging” refers to that of social networks be-
tween socially heterogeneous groups.
Bonding. One of the most powerful experiences at
museums for our respondents is related to the con-
nection they feel to their native cultures through cul-
turally specific programs and exhibits. Many indicate
that their interest in attending a museum was initially
sparked by a particular exhibit related to their own cul-
ture (cherished Día de los Muertos celebrations were
mentioned most often). The interest in and attraction
for these types of exhibits and programs lies primarily
in the connection that respondents feel to their own
traditions and heritage (and the associated nostalgia),
but also in the desire to pass these cultural values to
LOW ACCULTURATION /
SPANISH DOMINANT
LOW
MEDIUM
BICULTURAL /
BILINGUAL
HIGH ACCULTURATION /
ENGLISH DOMINANT
HIGH
Emotional Benefits of Spanish Language Services enhance
the cultural connection during the experience.
Functional Need for Spanish Language Services facilitate
comprehension and a complete experience during the museum visit.
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
4
their children. They are endeavoring to teach their chil-
dren not only the particulars of the content, but also
the value of pride in their own heritage and traditions.
Museums that make these programs available provide
an additional type of validation and reinforcement of
the importance of that heritage. While central for all
respondents, the desire for bonding experiences was
most pronounced among less-acculturated Latinos.
Bridging. Many respondents in the study expressed
interest in programs and exhibits that extend beyond
Latino subjects, and felt resentment when museums
limited outreach efforts to Latino-specific programs or
exhibits. Clearly there is an underlying desire for a more
expansive (bridging) experience in those cases.“Monet
is also part of my experience, because we are also Euro-
pean,” one respondent explained. More acculturated
respondents feel that a dichotomy exists between be-
ing American and being Latino, but they embrace both
with equal enthusiasm. While connecting with “other
cultures” most often implies American White (non-Lati-
no) culture and traditions, respondents indicate an ap-
preciation of the many cultures they encounter in their
daily lives and an interest in learning more about them.
Study results suggest that the preference for bonding
versus bridging experiences may be linked to the accul-
turation level of the Latino visitor, in that less-accultur-
ated Latinos tend to prefer culturally specific programs
and exhibits that are targeted directly to them. Howev-
er, acculturation is not the only variable at play. Respon-
dent comments suggest that the desire for bonding or
bridging experiences may be dynamic in nature and
further influenced by life stage, socioeconomic and
education level, personality traits, and personal values.
What is perhaps most interesting is that people tend
to find affinity with likeminded individuals, creating
social networks based on these factors and developing
a shared approach to cultural participation. As these
networks grow larger, they become real communities.
As one respondent explained: “We went [to a museum]
because my friend who’s been here longer than I said it
was a good thing for us.” Museums should be aware of
these networks, understand how they form and oper-
ate, and learn how to connect with them. This could be
one of the most important and effective engagement
strategies for diversity that a museum could pursue, as
it leverages and reinforces valued social connections.
Understanding cultural participation as a function of
a particular community’s interest in either bonding or
bridging experiences should ultimately prove useful in
the planning and execution of programs, exhibits, and
Acculturation is one of the important
influences on the preferred type of experience.
LOW ACCULTURATION /
SPANISH DOMINANT
HIGH ACCULTURATION /
ENGLISH DOMINANT
BRIDGING ACTIVITIES
BONDING ACTIVITIES
INFLUENCES ON THE
PREFERRED TYPE
OF EXPERIENCE
Values
Socioeconomics
Stage of Life
Acculturation Level
Personality
Education
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
5
communications. A single exhibit might generate sig-
nificantly different levels of interest, participation, and
impact depending on visitor objectives, which could
encompass fostering intimacy with their own culture
as well as seeking understanding and connection with
other people and cultures.
2.3 An Experience of Inclusion
Our findings indicate that the perceived value of bond-
ing and bridging experiences is amplified by an organi-
zation’s ability to create an inclusive experience. There
is a strong desire for institutional acknowledgment and
welcome of the Latino visitor.
The preliminary release of findings for this study present-
ed two psychographic clusters based on the needs that
respondents associated with their cultural identity and
the role of museums in their lives. These two clusters
were based on:
• Cluster A – the need to be identified as
Latino by the museum with which they are
engaging:“As a Latina, there is no recognition
of my culture at the main museums.”
• Cluster B – the need to be acknowledged
as a regular museum-goer without any
classification:“The good thing about being
in a museum is that you can leave behind the
labels that we assign to each other and enjoy
art together as human beings.”
During preliminary analysis, these seemingly different
attitudes surfaced as a potential basis for a segmenta-
tion model for engaging Latinos. Cluster A Latinos ap-
pear to prioritize bonding experiences and culturally
relevant programs and exhibits. Cluster B respondents
appreciate these culturally relevant experiences, but
gravitate towards bridging experiences as a key value
of museums.
As data was further collected and analyzed, initial as-
sumptions were questioned. It became increasingly
apparent that these two needs might not be mutually
exclusive. In fact, the report asserts that these needs
may exist as part of the same spectrum—a phenom-
enon identified here as the Latino Paradox. Findings in-
dicate that Latinos want to be acknowledged as such
by museums, but not singled out as different from any
I AM LATINO
AND DIFFERENT FROM
OTHER AMERICANS.
I AM AMERICAN
AND THE SAME AS
EVERYBODY ELSE.
Prefer to not be singled
out or treated differently
than other visitors.
Stronger desire for
acknowledgement as
a Latino visitor and
recognition of culture.
Seeks and appreciates
signals of inclusion.
The Latino
PARADOX
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
6
other visitor. Initially, this may seem contradictory and
mutually exclusive, but for bicultural Latinos this per-
spective is natural and mirrors their day-to-day experi-
ence. Many respondents reported being regular Amer-
icans, just like everybody else. At the same time, they
feel they are different from the rest of the population.
To paraphrase respondents: “I am Latino and different
from the rest of Americans, and I am American and the
same as everybody else.”What seems paradoxical is ac-
tually a normal way of life.
In practical terms, what this means for an engagement
strategy is that the Latino visitor expects and desires an
experience that feels inclusive in the broadest sense of
the word, and he or she simultaneously expects and
demands to be treated just like any other visitor. Stated
in another way, this means offering Latinos the cultural-
ly specific services and acknowledgement that will pro-
vide them with the same or comparable visitor experi-
ence that other groups enjoy. Delivering this nuanced
experience in an organic, authentic way may depend
on the extent to which the organization’s staff mirrors
the demographic reality of its community.
Most respondents mentioned that when they are mak-
ing the decision to visit a museum, there is virtually
nothing that makes them feel invited or speaks directly
to them as Latinos. There is no advertising or publicity
directed to them that reflects their experience. Most re-
spondents agree that, with the exception of culturally
specific exhibits or programs that are by nature tempo-
rary, there is very little at a museum that inspires them
to connect with their ethnic and cultural identity. Lati-
nos are looking for indications that a museum is open
and willing to engage with all facets of their identity.
This helps illustrate why Spanish-language communi-
cations and Latino staff are such critical, yet missing,
signals of inclusion.
3. Inhibitors of Engagement
This study reveals a large number of factors that cur-
rently inhibit Latino participation and engagement
with museums, many of which intersect and com-
pound each other. While some of the most persistent
and challenging obstacles are perceptual (beliefs and
assumptions), others are tangible and directly expe-
rienced, and represent immediate opportunities to
strengthen engagement.
3.1 Perceptions of exclusion
While museums are broadly acknowledged as educa-
tional institutions, the personal relevance and impor-
tance of these institutions has not been established for
many Latinos in this study. Evidence of personal detach-
ment is apparent in their descriptions of museums as:
• For white [non-Latino] people
• For Americans (as opposed to“minorities”
or people of color)
• For people“with money”
• Places in which they feel discriminated
against based on their appearance, and their
socioeconomic status
• Places that are not for them
• Places that are behind in making them feel
welcomed and included, even respected
• Places that do not provide services that fulfill
their needs
• Places that look at them only when they
have a“Latino exhibit”and forget them the
rest of the time
• Places where everything is expensive
• Places that are boring
It is important to clarify that these perceptions and the
overall participation in museums varies by level of ac-
culturation. Low acculturation respondents tend to see
museums as places where they do not belong. High
acculturation respondents tend to perceive themselves
as active participants (even though actual participation
might be low). Some of these differences are linked to
perceptions of status, in that some respondents believe
museums are places for “rich people,”“White [non-Lati-
no] people,” or “other people.” Some acculturated
Latinos tend to see these descriptions as evidence of
self-exclusion, lack of familiarity, or ignorance of the be-
havioral code expected at these types of venues. They
also tend to see themselves as more adapted to U.S.
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
7
culture and willing to take advantage of the opportuni-
ties available to them.
Regardless of their participation level with museums, re-
spondents are universally and keenly aware of the lack
of diversity at both the staff and board levels. As a key
driver of engagement, the absence of Latino and multi-
cultural staff not only impacts respondents’on-site expe-
rience, but also reinforces their perceptions of museums
as being for White (non-Latino) or wealthy people.
Among the more acculturated sample in our study—
regardless of the content of exhibits and programs—
there exists a perception that museums have a strong
point of view that is Euro-centric. This is particularly
problematic when the exhibit is focused on a Latin
American culture and is curated by a non-Latino per-
son, since the implication is that there are no Latinos
capable of curating such an exhibit. This perception,
although most pronounced in art exhibits, is prevalent
across museum types: art, history, science, technology
or a combination of these.
3.2 Lack of familiarity
Potentially more influential than level of acculturation
is the respondents’ background familiarity with mu-
seums, specifically childhood experiences with their
families. One of the most important factors associated
with active participation in museums as an adult ap-
pears to be a person’s own experiences and familiarity
with museums as a child, regardless of his or her edu-
cation, income level, or birth place. Respondents with
experience visiting museums in their own countries of
origin felt more at ease with visiting museums in the
U. S., while those with no experience far more often
attributed their lack of participation to both real and
perceived obstacles.
3.3 Museums as“One Time Occasion”
A nearly universal inhibitor of engagement among Lati-
nos is an entrenched perception of museum visits as a
one-time occasion. For most, attendance is infrequent
and not part of their regular activities, even among
those familiar with museums. Accordingly, a visit is
largely considered a special occasion, something new
and different from their routines, and is often prompt-
ed by a particular exhibit or by a special family occa-
sion (often associated with Latino-specific exhibits or
programs). After visiting, most believe they have expe-
rienced all the venue has to offer, and see no reason to
establish an ongoing relationship with the organiza-
tion. It is not considered necessary or important to visit
again unless a special exhibit of interest occurs in the
future, in which case the visit will again be strictly for
that purpose.
3.4 Visitor group size
Another factor that appears to inhibit participation
is the price of admission, which was commonly men-
tioned as an obstacle by both segments in this study
(low and high acculturation). Upon further probing of
this particular issue, the study found that the main ob-
stacle associated with admission price is the size of the
visiting party. Latinos not only have larger (and young-
er) families compared to the general population (2012
U.S. Census), but because of the high value placed on
social experiences, they tend to visit in large groups.
These groups often include not only nuclear and ex-
tended family members, but also friends and even ac-
quaintances. It is common that the responsibility for
paying belongs to one or two of the organizers (“he/she
whoinvites,pays”).Thus the price of admission that may
be affordable for a family of four becomes a challenge
for a group of ten.
Also impacting the cost of the experience for these
larger visitor groups is the price of food and souvenirs
that are part of the museum outing. Food is not only a
complement to the visit, but in many cases an essential
aspect of the social experience. Sharing food is high-
ly valued and has a strong cultural connotation that is
alluring. For some respondents with young children,
food is also a necessity to keep their child engaged and
nurtured. For respondents with older or no children, a
visit to the restaurant and museum shop contributes to
the special nature of the occasion. However, most criti-
cize the high prices of food at the museum’s restaurant
or cafeteria, which they consider prohibitive for larger
families. Many opted instead to visit a preferred off-site
restaurant after their visit.
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
8
Although the total cost of a museum visit for larger
groups is a significant obstacle for respondents, deep-
er discussions quickly revealed that the true barrier is a
gap between cost and perceived value. Most respon-
dents stated that price (along with location, transporta-
tion, and other barriers) would not be an impediment if
they found sufficient value and meaning in participat-
ing in a museum experience.
3.5 Spanish-language communications
Most respondents believe that museums are not inter-
ested in engaging them because they encounter little
or no publicity directed towards the Latino population,
as explained before. Even in cases where Latinos are in-
terested in a particular museum, they feel unwelcome
because they don’t see any targeted communications
that speak directly to them. With no advertising in
Spanish-language TV or radio, most potential Latino
visitors rely on personal recommendations to assess
the value offered by a museum, which may have the
residual effect of perpetuating existing beliefs and be-
haviors. Added to the absence of Spanish-language
media is the lack of on-site Spanish-language services,
including signage, printed and audio materials, and bi-
lingual personnel. This often solidifies the perception
that museums are “not for them,” especially for low
acculturation, Spanish-dominant Latinos. Even many
bilingual Latinos vividly recalled language difficulties
during a visit. As a result, they felt disconnected from
the experience.
The conspicuous lack of Spanish-language communi-
cations at museums stands out to respondents because
most other organizations, businesses, and brands they
encounter now provide these services. While many Lati-
nos acknowledge this is a function of living in California
(where Latinos reached a plurality in 2013, according
to a 2014 Pew Research Center report), they find it per-
plexing that museums with public-service missions
Barriers are interrelated and compound each other.
Visitor
Services
One Time
Occasion
Spanish
Language
Communications
Lack of
Familiarity
Visitor
Group Size
PERCEPTUAL BARRIERS
Internal attitudes and
beliefs that inhibit
museum participation.
EXPERIENTIAL BARRIERS
Tangible, real-world
factors that inhibit
participation.
Perceptions
of Exclusion
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
9
seem uninterested in reaching and serving Latinos, the
largest ethnic group in the state.
3.6 Visitor Services
Many respondents described the prominent role of
guards and docents in their experience, but unfor-
tunately most interactions were not positive. Of all
museum staff, guards may have the longest and clos-
est interactions with visitors. They appear to play a
crucial role in shaping the experience, especially for
first-time visitors. Through stereotyping and discrim-
inatory practices, guards are likely the main variable
that can transform the Latino visitor experience from
unfamiliar or difficult to unequivocally negative. As a
direct result of how a guard treated his family on their
first visit, one respondent said, “I’m not going back to
that museum, or any other museum for that matter!”It is
critical that museums take decisive steps to minimize
these types of experiences because of the strong role
of word of mouth in the Latino population. As Latinos
rely heavily on personal recommendations, one fami-
ly’s negative experience will circulate widely in a dra-
matic ripple effect.
Another key factor is docent interactions. Docents have
a large impact on the museum visit, making respon-
dents feel included and helping them to navigate the
experience. However, respondents reported that bilin-
gual docents were exceedingly rare, despite the oppor-
tunity they have to create a meaningful experience for
visitors. Furthermore, most respondents were unaware
at the time of their visit that a docent is a volunteer po-
sition who is trained on the content of the exhibit, but
not necessarily on basic information of museum oper-
ations. As a result, it was disconcerting to respondents
that docents did not know museum hours or prices of
admission.The perception is that these“employees”are
not familiar with their own institution.
CONCLUSIONS / CONSIDERATIONS
Museums are the depositaries of a country’s idiosyncra-
sies, history and identity, and they usually represent the
point of view of the dominant culture. We suspect this
influences the decision Latinos make to visit museums.
Our data indicates Latinos know there is much more to
visiting a museum than simply being entertained. Re-
spondents pointed most often to the high educational
value of museums, and in deeper discussions, praised
the connective and inclusive experiences these orga-
nizations could potentially provide. Accordingly, we
reject the notion that a decision to visit a museum is
exclusively a leisure one. Rather it is, in many ways, a
conscious or unconscious decision to learn about, and
therefore participate, in the narrative that conforms to
the identity of a society.
That being said, noting respondents’ infrequent visita-
tion patterns and numerous barriers given, it becomes
immediately clear that the perceived value is a distant
and transactional one at best. Many simply do not have
an internalized sense of personal relevance and im-
portance attached to the museum experience. In fact,
many overtly acknowledge that obstacles like price,
transportation, location, etc. would not be deterrents
if they recognize the evident value in a museum visit.
Therefore, the opportunity for museums lies in estab-
lishing a connection, fundamentally demonstrating
personal value, and building a tangible, reciprocal rela-
tionship. To be sustainable, this relationship cannot be
static, but must evolve over time and become a reflec-
tion of what is important for both sides. This research
delivers compelling evidence that to achieve these
objectives, an organization must reflect the cultural di-
versity of its community and prioritize inclusive experi-
ences for its Latino visitors.
© Contemporanea 2015
Latino Experience in Museums
10
SOURCES REFERENCED
Betancourt, Verónica Elena (2012). Brillan Por su Ausencia: Latinos
as the Missing Outsiders of Mainstream Art Museums. Thesis to ful-
fill Master of Arts degree requirements, Ohio State University. Re-
trieved from https://etd.ohiolink.edu/!etd.send_file?accession=o-
su1339516509disposition=inline
Farrell, B., and Medvedeva, M. (2010). Demographic Transformation
and the Future of Museums. Washington, D.C.: The AAM Press. Re-
trieved from http://www.aam-us.org/docs/center-for-the-future-of-
museums/demotransaam2010.pdf
Institute of Museums and Library Services (2008). InterConnections:
The IMLS National Study on the Use of Libraries, Museums and the Inter-
net. Retrieved from http://www.interconnectionsreport.org/
Maricopa Partnership for Arts and Culture (2008). Arts, Culture and the
Latino Audience. Retrieved from http://www.azmc.org/wp-content/
uploads/2012/12/arts_culture_and_the_latino_audience.pdf
National Endowment for the Arts (2013). Survey of Public Participation
in the Arts. Retrieved from http://arts.gov/news/2013/national-en-
dowment-arts-presents-highlights-2012-survey-public-participa-
tion-arts
Pew Research Center (2014). In 2014, Latinos will surpass whites as
largest racial/ethnic group in California. Retrieved from http://www.
pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/01/24/in-2014-latinos-will-surpass-
whites-as-largest-racialethnic-group-in-california/
Putnam, Robert D. (2001). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of
American Community. Simon  Schuster, New York, NY.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Contemporanea would like to acknowledge the contributions of the
Bay Area Discovery Museum, the Museum ofVentura County, and the
Palo Alto Art Center to this study. We would also like to thank Jimena
Salas for her invaluable help with the analysis for this report.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Знакомство с порталом ЯУМ
Знакомство  с порталом ЯУМЗнакомство  с порталом ЯУМ
Знакомство с порталом ЯУМPavlo Krasikov
 
BV Multicultural Festival Powerpoint
BV Multicultural Festival PowerpointBV Multicultural Festival Powerpoint
BV Multicultural Festival PowerpointMallory K Carter
 
топология лвс
топология лвстопология лвс
топология лвсPavlo Krasikov
 
лекционное занятие №4
лекционное занятие №4лекционное занятие №4
лекционное занятие №4Pavlo Krasikov
 
Bv festival final powerpoint
Bv festival final powerpointBv festival final powerpoint
Bv festival final powerpointMallory K Carter
 
Yalta present2 photo_2
Yalta present2 photo_2Yalta present2 photo_2
Yalta present2 photo_2Pavlo Krasikov
 
Горные котята
Горные котятаГорные котята
Горные котятаPavlo Krasikov
 
Blue Valley Multicultural Festival
Blue Valley Multicultural FestivalBlue Valley Multicultural Festival
Blue Valley Multicultural FestivalMallory K Carter
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Mrn general resource guide
Mrn general resource guideMrn general resource guide
Mrn general resource guide
 
Знакомство с порталом ЯУМ
Знакомство  с порталом ЯУМЗнакомство  с порталом ЯУМ
Знакомство с порталом ЯУМ
 
BV Multicultural Festival Powerpoint
BV Multicultural Festival PowerpointBV Multicultural Festival Powerpoint
BV Multicultural Festival Powerpoint
 
топология лвс
топология лвстопология лвс
топология лвс
 
лекционное занятие №4
лекционное занятие №4лекционное занятие №4
лекционное занятие №4
 
Pathways
PathwaysPathways
Pathways
 
healthy heart and mind
healthy heart and mindhealthy heart and mind
healthy heart and mind
 
Bv festival final powerpoint
Bv festival final powerpointBv festival final powerpoint
Bv festival final powerpoint
 
8 22 11 newcomer program overview -mena
8 22 11 newcomer program overview -mena8 22 11 newcomer program overview -mena
8 22 11 newcomer program overview -mena
 
Jurnal ultra1.pdf
Jurnal ultra1.pdfJurnal ultra1.pdf
Jurnal ultra1.pdf
 
Yalta present2 photo_2
Yalta present2 photo_2Yalta present2 photo_2
Yalta present2 photo_2
 
Mln teachers guide to tutorials 4 28-12
Mln teachers guide to tutorials 4 28-12Mln teachers guide to tutorials 4 28-12
Mln teachers guide to tutorials 4 28-12
 
2013 nasdme conference
2013 nasdme conference2013 nasdme conference
2013 nasdme conference
 
2012 CoTESOL
2012 CoTESOL2012 CoTESOL
2012 CoTESOL
 
Board of directors
Board of directorsBoard of directors
Board of directors
 
Hhmpowerpoint
HhmpowerpointHhmpowerpoint
Hhmpowerpoint
 
Healthheartandmind
HealthheartandmindHealthheartandmind
Healthheartandmind
 
Learn consortium sept 2010 9 21-10
Learn consortium sept 2010 9 21-10Learn consortium sept 2010 9 21-10
Learn consortium sept 2010 9 21-10
 
Горные котята
Горные котятаГорные котята
Горные котята
 
Blue Valley Multicultural Festival
Blue Valley Multicultural FestivalBlue Valley Multicultural Festival
Blue Valley Multicultural Festival
 

Similar to Latino-Experience-in-Museums-Report-Contemporanea

Bienven Bienvenidos! Engaging Latino Audiences and Building Cross-Cultural Br...
Bienven Bienvenidos! Engaging Latino Audiences and Building Cross-Cultural Br...Bienven Bienvenidos! Engaging Latino Audiences and Building Cross-Cultural Br...
Bienven Bienvenidos! Engaging Latino Audiences and Building Cross-Cultural Br...West Muse
 
041E
041E041E
041EJen W
 
Intercultural Communication & ELT
Intercultural Communication & ELTIntercultural Communication & ELT
Intercultural Communication & ELTSeray Tanyer
 
Westaf - ZAPP keynote presentation September 19, 2011
Westaf - ZAPP keynote presentation September 19, 2011Westaf - ZAPP keynote presentation September 19, 2011
Westaf - ZAPP keynote presentation September 19, 2011Salvador Acevedo
 
The whitney museum family and kids program comm campaign
The whitney museum family and kids program comm campaignThe whitney museum family and kids program comm campaign
The whitney museum family and kids program comm campaignElizay Pierre
 
El voluntariado como estrategia informal para construir valores interculturales
El voluntariado como estrategia informal para construir valores interculturalesEl voluntariado como estrategia informal para construir valores interculturales
El voluntariado como estrategia informal para construir valores interculturalesAlexandro Escudero-Nahón
 
Verbal expressions in giving and receiving presents in English and Vietnamese...
Verbal expressions in giving and receiving presents in English and Vietnamese...Verbal expressions in giving and receiving presents in English and Vietnamese...
Verbal expressions in giving and receiving presents in English and Vietnamese...HanaTiti
 
Masters Project 2016 corrections and edits
Masters Project 2016 corrections and edits Masters Project 2016 corrections and edits
Masters Project 2016 corrections and edits Andrew Fileta
 
Intercultural learning
Intercultural learningIntercultural learning
Intercultural learningVielka Reece
 
chapter 9Culture and EducationBy this point in the vol
chapter 9Culture and EducationBy this point in the volchapter 9Culture and EducationBy this point in the vol
chapter 9Culture and EducationBy this point in the volJinElias52
 
Bertelsman & CD
Bertelsman & CDBertelsman & CD
Bertelsman & CDkrisbibler
 
GLOBALIZATION: Report in Ed 3 English.pptx
GLOBALIZATION: Report in Ed 3 English.pptxGLOBALIZATION: Report in Ed 3 English.pptx
GLOBALIZATION: Report in Ed 3 English.pptxRichnielOlamit1
 
What is Ethnographic Method
What is Ethnographic MethodWhat is Ethnographic Method
What is Ethnographic MethodJairo Gomez
 
Atravesando FronterasBorder Crossings A Critical Ethnog.docx
 Atravesando FronterasBorder Crossings A Critical Ethnog.docx Atravesando FronterasBorder Crossings A Critical Ethnog.docx
Atravesando FronterasBorder Crossings A Critical Ethnog.docxaryan532920
 
Toole_ResearchProposal_RES5000
Toole_ResearchProposal_RES5000Toole_ResearchProposal_RES5000
Toole_ResearchProposal_RES5000Susan Toole
 

Similar to Latino-Experience-in-Museums-Report-Contemporanea (20)

Bienven Bienvenidos! Engaging Latino Audiences and Building Cross-Cultural Br...
Bienven Bienvenidos! Engaging Latino Audiences and Building Cross-Cultural Br...Bienven Bienvenidos! Engaging Latino Audiences and Building Cross-Cultural Br...
Bienven Bienvenidos! Engaging Latino Audiences and Building Cross-Cultural Br...
 
041E
041E041E
041E
 
Intercultural Communication & ELT
Intercultural Communication & ELTIntercultural Communication & ELT
Intercultural Communication & ELT
 
Westaf - ZAPP keynote presentation September 19, 2011
Westaf - ZAPP keynote presentation September 19, 2011Westaf - ZAPP keynote presentation September 19, 2011
Westaf - ZAPP keynote presentation September 19, 2011
 
The whitney museum family and kids program comm campaign
The whitney museum family and kids program comm campaignThe whitney museum family and kids program comm campaign
The whitney museum family and kids program comm campaign
 
El voluntariado como estrategia informal para construir valores interculturales
El voluntariado como estrategia informal para construir valores interculturalesEl voluntariado como estrategia informal para construir valores interculturales
El voluntariado como estrategia informal para construir valores interculturales
 
Culture in teaching English
Culture in teaching EnglishCulture in teaching English
Culture in teaching English
 
Cultural awareness
Cultural awarenessCultural awareness
Cultural awareness
 
Verbal expressions in giving and receiving presents in English and Vietnamese...
Verbal expressions in giving and receiving presents in English and Vietnamese...Verbal expressions in giving and receiving presents in English and Vietnamese...
Verbal expressions in giving and receiving presents in English and Vietnamese...
 
Masters Project 2016 corrections and edits
Masters Project 2016 corrections and edits Masters Project 2016 corrections and edits
Masters Project 2016 corrections and edits
 
Intercultural learning
Intercultural learningIntercultural learning
Intercultural learning
 
chapter 9Culture and EducationBy this point in the vol
chapter 9Culture and EducationBy this point in the volchapter 9Culture and EducationBy this point in the vol
chapter 9Culture and EducationBy this point in the vol
 
Bertelsman & CD
Bertelsman & CDBertelsman & CD
Bertelsman & CD
 
GLOBALIZATION: Report in Ed 3 English.pptx
GLOBALIZATION: Report in Ed 3 English.pptxGLOBALIZATION: Report in Ed 3 English.pptx
GLOBALIZATION: Report in Ed 3 English.pptx
 
What is Ethnographic Method
What is Ethnographic MethodWhat is Ethnographic Method
What is Ethnographic Method
 
Semester Paper
Semester PaperSemester Paper
Semester Paper
 
Intercultural communication
Intercultural communicationIntercultural communication
Intercultural communication
 
Atravesando FronterasBorder Crossings A Critical Ethnog.docx
 Atravesando FronterasBorder Crossings A Critical Ethnog.docx Atravesando FronterasBorder Crossings A Critical Ethnog.docx
Atravesando FronterasBorder Crossings A Critical Ethnog.docx
 
Toole_ResearchProposal_RES5000
Toole_ResearchProposal_RES5000Toole_ResearchProposal_RES5000
Toole_ResearchProposal_RES5000
 
Ucsp week 2
Ucsp week 2Ucsp week 2
Ucsp week 2
 

Latino-Experience-in-Museums-Report-Contemporanea

  • 1. APRIL 2015 RESEARCH REPORT The Latino Experience in Museums: An Exploratory Audience Research Study Contemporanea contemporanea.usT 415.404.6982San Francisco CA 941035 Third Street Suite 925 Salvador Acevedo Principal Monique Madara Senior Insights Strategist
  • 2. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 1 INTRODUCTION The fast growth of the Latino population in the Unit- ed States is a well-known fact, but most museums ac- knowledge that this growth is not reflected among their audiences. According to the National Endowment for the Arts’s Survey of Public Participation in the Arts (SPPA, the nation’s largest population survey of arts par- ticipation trends), cultural participation among Latinos is slowly growing. For example, the 2013 SPPA report shows that 14.5% of adults who visited an art museum identify as Latinos—an increase of just 0.2% from the 2008 report. Even though there are many general de- mographic studies about the participation of Latinos and other minority groups in museums and the arts (SPPA/NEA, 2013; Farrell, B. & Medvedeva, M., 2010; In- stitute of Museum and Library Services, 2008), there are few studies that focus specifically on the perceptions, motivations, and values of this population associated with museums and other cultural institutions (Betan- court, 2012; MPAC, 2008). Contemporanea’s primary motivation in conducting this study is to contribute to the field of museums and cultural institutions by deep- ening the discussion of audience diversification. An in-depth understanding of the Latino experience in museums can help provide institutions with the foun- dation for strategic planning that supports long-term sustainability. This exploratory research study attempts to understand the drivers of engagement and the un- derlying factors that permeate the experience of Lati- nos at museums—any type of museum—with the goal of helping organizations to design experiences that are engaging and relevant for this important growing pop- ulation1 . While there are important distinctions among the different types of museums that need to be consid- ered, our analysis focuses on commonalities and shared insights. Additional research and analysis may be useful in building on this research and highlighting those dif- ferences. Furthermore, while this study focuses on mu- seums, its implications are broader in reach and likely relevant for the cultural participation field in general. 1 For the purposes of this study, we do not include Latino or other culturally specific museums in the scope of this research. METHODOLOGY 1. Six focus groups among self-identified Latino respon- dents were conducted in California. A total of 50 partici- pants were divided into two main categories: • Spanish dominant – limited or no English fluency (sessions conducted in Spanish with 28 participants) • Bilingual – different levels of Spanish fluency, from conversational to fully bilingual (sessions conducted in English with 22 participants) All respondents represent head of household, the ma- jority with children and/or grandchildren under 18 years old living at home. The respondent pool includes a mix of education and income levels; urban, suburban, and rural residencies; and countries of origin represen- tative of the total Latino population. Most respondents (75%) were foreign born, while the rest were born in the United States. All participants had visited at least one museum (of any type) at least once in the 12 months prior to the interview date. 2. An online survey was conducted with self-identified Latino residents of California (224 respondents). Respon- dents selected their preferred questionnaire language, with 58.9% responding in English and 41.1% in Spanish. A mix of income and education levels participated, and all had visited a museum of some type in the previous year. A convenience sampling approach was used in ac- cordance with the exploratory objectives of the study. For the purposes of this report, respondents are divid- ed in two main segments: low acculturation and high acculturation2 . The level of acculturation was based on language preference (Spanish dominant and bilingual); place of birth (U.S. born and foreign born); education and socioeconomic levels; and (for the foreign born) number of years living in the United States. This segmentation approach is commonly used in corporate-sector market research studies, and provides a base for an analysis of the evolution of attitudes over time. 2 Acculturation refers to the process of acquiring a second culture, while maintaining the original one.
  • 3. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 2 MAIN FINDINGS AND IMPLICATIONS The results herein are presented in three sections. The first looks into the signals of inclusion provided by a museum that make Latinos feel welcome. The second explores the motivations and drivers of participation among Latinos, including desired experiences and the dynamic impact of acculturation. The third section outlines perceptions and real-world experiences that inhibit engagement, and identifies immediate areas of opportunity for museums seeking to engage Lati- no audiences. 1. Signals of Inclusion and Acknowledgement This study explores aspects of museum participation among Latinos and offers numerous insights on their participation drivers and barriers. A pervasive theme woven throughout respondent feedback, including that related to driver and barrier insights, was the de- livery (or lack thereof) of overt signals of inclusion that speak directly to Latinos. The presence or absence of these signals in many ways amplifies or inhibits their experience and directly shapes their perceptions of val- ue.Therefore, due to their importance, these signals are provided first to give context to themes presented in the remainder of this report. In this research, respondents articulated ways in which museums can welcome and include potential Latino visitors. Without exception, the two most important factors that convey inclusion are: • A diverse staff that“looks like us”in language, appearance, cultural identity, values, etc. • The use of Spanish language communications Of these two, the first is considered by far the most important. Participants reported wanting to see other Latinos working at museums, “…but not only as jan- itors.” Personnel who interact directly with visitors are critical for newcomers because they can help decode the experience, convey behavioral expectations, high- light available resources, and otherwise create a com- fortable experience. In addition to seeing Latino staff included in visitor services, respondents would like to see them included in the planning of exhibits and pro- grams, actively contributing a Latino perspective as cu- rators and advisors.This research implies that museums integrating Latino staff throughout more levels and functions of the organization can make large strides in delivering programming and experiences that are val- ued by Latino visitors. The presence of Spanish-language communications is considered critical, not only to support comprehension of the exhibits or programs (a functional need), but also to create an emotional connection. Low-accultur- ation respondents frequently mentioned feeling more comfortable reading labels and panels in Spanish and cited largely functional benefits. High-acculturation and bilingual respondents mentioned more emotion- al reasons, including the concern that Spanish-dom- inant family members also enjoy the visit. In essence, museums can immediately leverage the use of Span- ish- language communications in marketing and inter- pretation to signal inclusion and cultural relevance to Latinos of all acculturation levels. 2. Drivers of Museum Participation among Latinos 2.1 An Educational Experience The role of museums as educational institutions is well established among this sample of Latinos. Respondents refer to them as places: • Worth visiting • To discover new things to learn • To learn in a fun or entertaining way • To explore the cultural and scientific heritage of different people • To appreciate art and artifacts from people and cultures around the world • To learn about the past and its connections to the present • To teach children about their own or other people’s heritage and traditions • Where individuals can come together, leave behind societal labels, and simply appreciate the beauty and inspiration of art
  • 4. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 3 The benefit of a museum visit is strongly connected to education, though this perception is nuanced by the presence of children in the home. Respondents with no children at home are more focused on their own individ- ual experiences, specifically that of having a meaning- ful and enjoyable visit and sharing it with their friends or family. Conversely, respondents with children living at home tend to prioritize benefits for the children over their own. For these parents, the role and impact of the museum or specific exhibit on child growth and educa- tion is the most important consideration. Latinos in this study specify that, in addition to being educational, the experience must be enjoyable for the entire party and not solely for the children because vis- itor groups are often multi-generational and include extended family and friends. While the entertainment value of the experience is clearly not the primary rea- son for attendance, it is regarded as an important com- ponent, an engagement driver, and an underlying pre- requisite for attendance. 2.2 An Experience of Connection In this study, we identified a certain connecting func- tion that museums fulfill for Latinos, which may be better explained using the concepts of bonding and bridging. As Robert Putman defined in his book Bowl- ing Alone (2000),“bonding”refers to the value assigned to social networks between homogeneous groups of people. “Bridging” refers to that of social networks be- tween socially heterogeneous groups. Bonding. One of the most powerful experiences at museums for our respondents is related to the con- nection they feel to their native cultures through cul- turally specific programs and exhibits. Many indicate that their interest in attending a museum was initially sparked by a particular exhibit related to their own cul- ture (cherished Día de los Muertos celebrations were mentioned most often). The interest in and attraction for these types of exhibits and programs lies primarily in the connection that respondents feel to their own traditions and heritage (and the associated nostalgia), but also in the desire to pass these cultural values to LOW ACCULTURATION / SPANISH DOMINANT LOW MEDIUM BICULTURAL / BILINGUAL HIGH ACCULTURATION / ENGLISH DOMINANT HIGH Emotional Benefits of Spanish Language Services enhance the cultural connection during the experience. Functional Need for Spanish Language Services facilitate comprehension and a complete experience during the museum visit.
  • 5. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 4 their children. They are endeavoring to teach their chil- dren not only the particulars of the content, but also the value of pride in their own heritage and traditions. Museums that make these programs available provide an additional type of validation and reinforcement of the importance of that heritage. While central for all respondents, the desire for bonding experiences was most pronounced among less-acculturated Latinos. Bridging. Many respondents in the study expressed interest in programs and exhibits that extend beyond Latino subjects, and felt resentment when museums limited outreach efforts to Latino-specific programs or exhibits. Clearly there is an underlying desire for a more expansive (bridging) experience in those cases.“Monet is also part of my experience, because we are also Euro- pean,” one respondent explained. More acculturated respondents feel that a dichotomy exists between be- ing American and being Latino, but they embrace both with equal enthusiasm. While connecting with “other cultures” most often implies American White (non-Lati- no) culture and traditions, respondents indicate an ap- preciation of the many cultures they encounter in their daily lives and an interest in learning more about them. Study results suggest that the preference for bonding versus bridging experiences may be linked to the accul- turation level of the Latino visitor, in that less-accultur- ated Latinos tend to prefer culturally specific programs and exhibits that are targeted directly to them. Howev- er, acculturation is not the only variable at play. Respon- dent comments suggest that the desire for bonding or bridging experiences may be dynamic in nature and further influenced by life stage, socioeconomic and education level, personality traits, and personal values. What is perhaps most interesting is that people tend to find affinity with likeminded individuals, creating social networks based on these factors and developing a shared approach to cultural participation. As these networks grow larger, they become real communities. As one respondent explained: “We went [to a museum] because my friend who’s been here longer than I said it was a good thing for us.” Museums should be aware of these networks, understand how they form and oper- ate, and learn how to connect with them. This could be one of the most important and effective engagement strategies for diversity that a museum could pursue, as it leverages and reinforces valued social connections. Understanding cultural participation as a function of a particular community’s interest in either bonding or bridging experiences should ultimately prove useful in the planning and execution of programs, exhibits, and Acculturation is one of the important influences on the preferred type of experience. LOW ACCULTURATION / SPANISH DOMINANT HIGH ACCULTURATION / ENGLISH DOMINANT BRIDGING ACTIVITIES BONDING ACTIVITIES INFLUENCES ON THE PREFERRED TYPE OF EXPERIENCE Values Socioeconomics Stage of Life Acculturation Level Personality Education
  • 6. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 5 communications. A single exhibit might generate sig- nificantly different levels of interest, participation, and impact depending on visitor objectives, which could encompass fostering intimacy with their own culture as well as seeking understanding and connection with other people and cultures. 2.3 An Experience of Inclusion Our findings indicate that the perceived value of bond- ing and bridging experiences is amplified by an organi- zation’s ability to create an inclusive experience. There is a strong desire for institutional acknowledgment and welcome of the Latino visitor. The preliminary release of findings for this study present- ed two psychographic clusters based on the needs that respondents associated with their cultural identity and the role of museums in their lives. These two clusters were based on: • Cluster A – the need to be identified as Latino by the museum with which they are engaging:“As a Latina, there is no recognition of my culture at the main museums.” • Cluster B – the need to be acknowledged as a regular museum-goer without any classification:“The good thing about being in a museum is that you can leave behind the labels that we assign to each other and enjoy art together as human beings.” During preliminary analysis, these seemingly different attitudes surfaced as a potential basis for a segmenta- tion model for engaging Latinos. Cluster A Latinos ap- pear to prioritize bonding experiences and culturally relevant programs and exhibits. Cluster B respondents appreciate these culturally relevant experiences, but gravitate towards bridging experiences as a key value of museums. As data was further collected and analyzed, initial as- sumptions were questioned. It became increasingly apparent that these two needs might not be mutually exclusive. In fact, the report asserts that these needs may exist as part of the same spectrum—a phenom- enon identified here as the Latino Paradox. Findings in- dicate that Latinos want to be acknowledged as such by museums, but not singled out as different from any I AM LATINO AND DIFFERENT FROM OTHER AMERICANS. I AM AMERICAN AND THE SAME AS EVERYBODY ELSE. Prefer to not be singled out or treated differently than other visitors. Stronger desire for acknowledgement as a Latino visitor and recognition of culture. Seeks and appreciates signals of inclusion. The Latino PARADOX
  • 7. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 6 other visitor. Initially, this may seem contradictory and mutually exclusive, but for bicultural Latinos this per- spective is natural and mirrors their day-to-day experi- ence. Many respondents reported being regular Amer- icans, just like everybody else. At the same time, they feel they are different from the rest of the population. To paraphrase respondents: “I am Latino and different from the rest of Americans, and I am American and the same as everybody else.”What seems paradoxical is ac- tually a normal way of life. In practical terms, what this means for an engagement strategy is that the Latino visitor expects and desires an experience that feels inclusive in the broadest sense of the word, and he or she simultaneously expects and demands to be treated just like any other visitor. Stated in another way, this means offering Latinos the cultural- ly specific services and acknowledgement that will pro- vide them with the same or comparable visitor experi- ence that other groups enjoy. Delivering this nuanced experience in an organic, authentic way may depend on the extent to which the organization’s staff mirrors the demographic reality of its community. Most respondents mentioned that when they are mak- ing the decision to visit a museum, there is virtually nothing that makes them feel invited or speaks directly to them as Latinos. There is no advertising or publicity directed to them that reflects their experience. Most re- spondents agree that, with the exception of culturally specific exhibits or programs that are by nature tempo- rary, there is very little at a museum that inspires them to connect with their ethnic and cultural identity. Lati- nos are looking for indications that a museum is open and willing to engage with all facets of their identity. This helps illustrate why Spanish-language communi- cations and Latino staff are such critical, yet missing, signals of inclusion. 3. Inhibitors of Engagement This study reveals a large number of factors that cur- rently inhibit Latino participation and engagement with museums, many of which intersect and com- pound each other. While some of the most persistent and challenging obstacles are perceptual (beliefs and assumptions), others are tangible and directly expe- rienced, and represent immediate opportunities to strengthen engagement. 3.1 Perceptions of exclusion While museums are broadly acknowledged as educa- tional institutions, the personal relevance and impor- tance of these institutions has not been established for many Latinos in this study. Evidence of personal detach- ment is apparent in their descriptions of museums as: • For white [non-Latino] people • For Americans (as opposed to“minorities” or people of color) • For people“with money” • Places in which they feel discriminated against based on their appearance, and their socioeconomic status • Places that are not for them • Places that are behind in making them feel welcomed and included, even respected • Places that do not provide services that fulfill their needs • Places that look at them only when they have a“Latino exhibit”and forget them the rest of the time • Places where everything is expensive • Places that are boring It is important to clarify that these perceptions and the overall participation in museums varies by level of ac- culturation. Low acculturation respondents tend to see museums as places where they do not belong. High acculturation respondents tend to perceive themselves as active participants (even though actual participation might be low). Some of these differences are linked to perceptions of status, in that some respondents believe museums are places for “rich people,”“White [non-Lati- no] people,” or “other people.” Some acculturated Latinos tend to see these descriptions as evidence of self-exclusion, lack of familiarity, or ignorance of the be- havioral code expected at these types of venues. They also tend to see themselves as more adapted to U.S.
  • 8. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 7 culture and willing to take advantage of the opportuni- ties available to them. Regardless of their participation level with museums, re- spondents are universally and keenly aware of the lack of diversity at both the staff and board levels. As a key driver of engagement, the absence of Latino and multi- cultural staff not only impacts respondents’on-site expe- rience, but also reinforces their perceptions of museums as being for White (non-Latino) or wealthy people. Among the more acculturated sample in our study— regardless of the content of exhibits and programs— there exists a perception that museums have a strong point of view that is Euro-centric. This is particularly problematic when the exhibit is focused on a Latin American culture and is curated by a non-Latino per- son, since the implication is that there are no Latinos capable of curating such an exhibit. This perception, although most pronounced in art exhibits, is prevalent across museum types: art, history, science, technology or a combination of these. 3.2 Lack of familiarity Potentially more influential than level of acculturation is the respondents’ background familiarity with mu- seums, specifically childhood experiences with their families. One of the most important factors associated with active participation in museums as an adult ap- pears to be a person’s own experiences and familiarity with museums as a child, regardless of his or her edu- cation, income level, or birth place. Respondents with experience visiting museums in their own countries of origin felt more at ease with visiting museums in the U. S., while those with no experience far more often attributed their lack of participation to both real and perceived obstacles. 3.3 Museums as“One Time Occasion” A nearly universal inhibitor of engagement among Lati- nos is an entrenched perception of museum visits as a one-time occasion. For most, attendance is infrequent and not part of their regular activities, even among those familiar with museums. Accordingly, a visit is largely considered a special occasion, something new and different from their routines, and is often prompt- ed by a particular exhibit or by a special family occa- sion (often associated with Latino-specific exhibits or programs). After visiting, most believe they have expe- rienced all the venue has to offer, and see no reason to establish an ongoing relationship with the organiza- tion. It is not considered necessary or important to visit again unless a special exhibit of interest occurs in the future, in which case the visit will again be strictly for that purpose. 3.4 Visitor group size Another factor that appears to inhibit participation is the price of admission, which was commonly men- tioned as an obstacle by both segments in this study (low and high acculturation). Upon further probing of this particular issue, the study found that the main ob- stacle associated with admission price is the size of the visiting party. Latinos not only have larger (and young- er) families compared to the general population (2012 U.S. Census), but because of the high value placed on social experiences, they tend to visit in large groups. These groups often include not only nuclear and ex- tended family members, but also friends and even ac- quaintances. It is common that the responsibility for paying belongs to one or two of the organizers (“he/she whoinvites,pays”).Thus the price of admission that may be affordable for a family of four becomes a challenge for a group of ten. Also impacting the cost of the experience for these larger visitor groups is the price of food and souvenirs that are part of the museum outing. Food is not only a complement to the visit, but in many cases an essential aspect of the social experience. Sharing food is high- ly valued and has a strong cultural connotation that is alluring. For some respondents with young children, food is also a necessity to keep their child engaged and nurtured. For respondents with older or no children, a visit to the restaurant and museum shop contributes to the special nature of the occasion. However, most criti- cize the high prices of food at the museum’s restaurant or cafeteria, which they consider prohibitive for larger families. Many opted instead to visit a preferred off-site restaurant after their visit.
  • 9. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 8 Although the total cost of a museum visit for larger groups is a significant obstacle for respondents, deep- er discussions quickly revealed that the true barrier is a gap between cost and perceived value. Most respon- dents stated that price (along with location, transporta- tion, and other barriers) would not be an impediment if they found sufficient value and meaning in participat- ing in a museum experience. 3.5 Spanish-language communications Most respondents believe that museums are not inter- ested in engaging them because they encounter little or no publicity directed towards the Latino population, as explained before. Even in cases where Latinos are in- terested in a particular museum, they feel unwelcome because they don’t see any targeted communications that speak directly to them. With no advertising in Spanish-language TV or radio, most potential Latino visitors rely on personal recommendations to assess the value offered by a museum, which may have the residual effect of perpetuating existing beliefs and be- haviors. Added to the absence of Spanish-language media is the lack of on-site Spanish-language services, including signage, printed and audio materials, and bi- lingual personnel. This often solidifies the perception that museums are “not for them,” especially for low acculturation, Spanish-dominant Latinos. Even many bilingual Latinos vividly recalled language difficulties during a visit. As a result, they felt disconnected from the experience. The conspicuous lack of Spanish-language communi- cations at museums stands out to respondents because most other organizations, businesses, and brands they encounter now provide these services. While many Lati- nos acknowledge this is a function of living in California (where Latinos reached a plurality in 2013, according to a 2014 Pew Research Center report), they find it per- plexing that museums with public-service missions Barriers are interrelated and compound each other. Visitor Services One Time Occasion Spanish Language Communications Lack of Familiarity Visitor Group Size PERCEPTUAL BARRIERS Internal attitudes and beliefs that inhibit museum participation. EXPERIENTIAL BARRIERS Tangible, real-world factors that inhibit participation. Perceptions of Exclusion
  • 10. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 9 seem uninterested in reaching and serving Latinos, the largest ethnic group in the state. 3.6 Visitor Services Many respondents described the prominent role of guards and docents in their experience, but unfor- tunately most interactions were not positive. Of all museum staff, guards may have the longest and clos- est interactions with visitors. They appear to play a crucial role in shaping the experience, especially for first-time visitors. Through stereotyping and discrim- inatory practices, guards are likely the main variable that can transform the Latino visitor experience from unfamiliar or difficult to unequivocally negative. As a direct result of how a guard treated his family on their first visit, one respondent said, “I’m not going back to that museum, or any other museum for that matter!”It is critical that museums take decisive steps to minimize these types of experiences because of the strong role of word of mouth in the Latino population. As Latinos rely heavily on personal recommendations, one fami- ly’s negative experience will circulate widely in a dra- matic ripple effect. Another key factor is docent interactions. Docents have a large impact on the museum visit, making respon- dents feel included and helping them to navigate the experience. However, respondents reported that bilin- gual docents were exceedingly rare, despite the oppor- tunity they have to create a meaningful experience for visitors. Furthermore, most respondents were unaware at the time of their visit that a docent is a volunteer po- sition who is trained on the content of the exhibit, but not necessarily on basic information of museum oper- ations. As a result, it was disconcerting to respondents that docents did not know museum hours or prices of admission.The perception is that these“employees”are not familiar with their own institution. CONCLUSIONS / CONSIDERATIONS Museums are the depositaries of a country’s idiosyncra- sies, history and identity, and they usually represent the point of view of the dominant culture. We suspect this influences the decision Latinos make to visit museums. Our data indicates Latinos know there is much more to visiting a museum than simply being entertained. Re- spondents pointed most often to the high educational value of museums, and in deeper discussions, praised the connective and inclusive experiences these orga- nizations could potentially provide. Accordingly, we reject the notion that a decision to visit a museum is exclusively a leisure one. Rather it is, in many ways, a conscious or unconscious decision to learn about, and therefore participate, in the narrative that conforms to the identity of a society. That being said, noting respondents’ infrequent visita- tion patterns and numerous barriers given, it becomes immediately clear that the perceived value is a distant and transactional one at best. Many simply do not have an internalized sense of personal relevance and im- portance attached to the museum experience. In fact, many overtly acknowledge that obstacles like price, transportation, location, etc. would not be deterrents if they recognize the evident value in a museum visit. Therefore, the opportunity for museums lies in estab- lishing a connection, fundamentally demonstrating personal value, and building a tangible, reciprocal rela- tionship. To be sustainable, this relationship cannot be static, but must evolve over time and become a reflec- tion of what is important for both sides. This research delivers compelling evidence that to achieve these objectives, an organization must reflect the cultural di- versity of its community and prioritize inclusive experi- ences for its Latino visitors.
  • 11. © Contemporanea 2015 Latino Experience in Museums 10 SOURCES REFERENCED Betancourt, Verónica Elena (2012). Brillan Por su Ausencia: Latinos as the Missing Outsiders of Mainstream Art Museums. Thesis to ful- fill Master of Arts degree requirements, Ohio State University. Re- trieved from https://etd.ohiolink.edu/!etd.send_file?accession=o- su1339516509disposition=inline Farrell, B., and Medvedeva, M. (2010). Demographic Transformation and the Future of Museums. Washington, D.C.: The AAM Press. Re- trieved from http://www.aam-us.org/docs/center-for-the-future-of- museums/demotransaam2010.pdf Institute of Museums and Library Services (2008). InterConnections: The IMLS National Study on the Use of Libraries, Museums and the Inter- net. Retrieved from http://www.interconnectionsreport.org/ Maricopa Partnership for Arts and Culture (2008). Arts, Culture and the Latino Audience. Retrieved from http://www.azmc.org/wp-content/ uploads/2012/12/arts_culture_and_the_latino_audience.pdf National Endowment for the Arts (2013). Survey of Public Participation in the Arts. Retrieved from http://arts.gov/news/2013/national-en- dowment-arts-presents-highlights-2012-survey-public-participa- tion-arts Pew Research Center (2014). In 2014, Latinos will surpass whites as largest racial/ethnic group in California. Retrieved from http://www. pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/01/24/in-2014-latinos-will-surpass- whites-as-largest-racialethnic-group-in-california/ Putnam, Robert D. (2001). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. Simon Schuster, New York, NY. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Contemporanea would like to acknowledge the contributions of the Bay Area Discovery Museum, the Museum ofVentura County, and the Palo Alto Art Center to this study. We would also like to thank Jimena Salas for her invaluable help with the analysis for this report.