2. 1] INTRODUCTION
2] FUN WITH NUMBERS
3] RISK AND RETURN
4] LOOKING FORWARD, LOOKING BACK
5] EFFICIENT MARKET HYPOTHESIS
6] MODERN PORTFOLIO THEORY
Break
7] GAMES THE PROS PLAY
8] INVESTOR PSYCHOLOGY
9] MUTUAL FUND MADNESS
10] A SENSIBLE APPROACH
8. What is this seminar NOT about?
⢠The next hot stock
⢠Trading stocks
⢠Predicting the future
⢠Tax advice
⢠Personal finance
⢠Telling you what to do
9. My Basic Philosophy
⢠The best investorsâŚ
⢠You have betterâŚ
⢠Keep itâŚ
⢠Make a fewâŚ
⢠StartâŚ
⢠Be a longâŚ
⢠Max our yourâŚ
10. Three pillars of investing
⢠People want to make as much money as
possible
⢠With as little risk as possible
⢠And with as little effort as possible
11. Some basic terminology
Financial asset: cash, stocks, bonds, mutual funds
Securities: tradable financial assets (stocks, bonds, etc)
Stocks: security that represents ownership, Equity
Bonds: security that represents debt, Fixed Income
Principle: the initial amount you invest
Return: interest, yield, rate, dividend
Liquidity: the ease of selling an asset
12. A little Latin
Ex post: looking backward
Ex ante: looking forward
Ceteris paribus: all else being equal
17. Numbers are how we keep score
We use percentagesâŚ
âŚand percentages
have problems
18. Percentages are not symmetrical
And down hurts worse than up helps
$15.00
Up 50% Down 50%
$10.00 $7.50
19. Percentages donât add or subtract
Be careful over multi-year time frames
$22.50 $20.00
Up 50%
In 1 year
Up 100%
$15.00 In 2 years
Up 50%
In 1 year
$10.00 $10.00
20. There is more than one percentage
Arithmetic average vs geometric average
$22.50 $20.00
Up 50%
In 1 year
Up 100%
$15.00 In 2 years
Up 50%
In 1 year
$10.00 $10.00
21. Arithmetic vs geometric average
Arithmetic average = 50% per year
$20.00 $20.00
Up 100% Up 100%
In 2 years In 2 years
$10.00 $10.00
Geometric average = 41.4% per year
22. Arithmetic vs geometric average
Arithmetic average: âaverageâ, is always
bigger, gives typical performance over any
one year
Geometric average: compound annual
(growth) rate, is always smaller, change in
wealth over time, the only one to use over
multi-year periods. âAnnualized returnsâ
32. What is risk?
Risk: the probability that you will get
something different than you expect
Risk of a financial asset: a measure of
its volatility around the expectation
33. Volatility
Asset A
Price
Time
Price
Asset B
Time
43. Payback schedule
Bet Type Payout (for $1) Odds Payback
Even, odds $2 18/38 94.7% (36/38)
Third of board $3 12/38 94.7%
Six numbers $6 6/38 94.7%
Four numbers $9 4/38 94.7%
Three numbers $12 3/38 94.7%
Two numbers $18 2/38 94.7%
One number $36 1/38 94.7%
44. Adjusting for risk
⢠You must adjust investments for risk beforeâŚ
⢠And you must get compensated forâŚ
45. Risk & expected return
Asset A
Price
Ď
Expected Return
Time
Price
Asset B Expected Return
Ď
Time
47. Why do we look back?
⢠Itâs all we have
⢠We can learn a lot ifâŚ
⢠It helps set ourâŚ
48. The numbers looking back
⢠Average annual returns
1926-2003 Geometric Mean Arithmetic Mean
Large Company Stocks 10.4% 12.4%
Small Company Stocks 12.7% 17.5%
Long Term Corporate Bonds 5.9% 6.2%
Long Term Government Bonds 5.4% 5.8%
T-Bills 3.7% 3.8%
Assumptions: All dividends and coupons reinvested, no taxes
49. The numbers looking back
⢠Best year, worst year
1926-2003 Best Year Worst Year
Large Company Stocks 53.99% -43.34%
Small Company Stocks 142.87% -58.01%
Long Term Corporate Bonds 42.56% -8.09%
Long Term Government Bonds 40.36% -9.18%
T-Bills 14.71% -0.02%
50. The numbers looking back
⢠Risk, Ď
1926-2003 Risk
Large Company Stocks 20.4%
Small Company Stocks 33.3%
Long Term Corporate Bonds 8.6%
Long Term Government Bonds 9.4%
T-Bills 3.1%
51. The numbers looking back
⢠Up years
1926-2003 Up Years
Large Company Stocks 70.5%
Small Company Stocks 69.2%
Long Term Corporate Bonds 79.5%
Long Term Government Bonds 73.1%
T-Bills 98.7%
52. The numbers looking back
⢠Rolling period returns (1926-2003)
8.68%
1926 1930
-5.10%
1927 1931
-12.47%
1928 1932
-0.57%
1999 2003
1926 2003
53. The numbers looking back
⢠Rolling period returns
1926-2003 5 year 10 year 20 year
Rolling Period Returns Best Worst Best Worst Best Worst
Large Company Stocks 28.55% -12.47% 20.06% -0.89% 17.87% 3.11%
Small Company Stocks 45.90% -27.54% 30.38% -5.70% 21.13% 5.74%
Long Term Corporate Bonds 22.51% -2.22% 16.32% 0.98% 12.13% 1.34%
Long Term Government Bonds 21.62% -2.14% 15.56% -0.07% 12.09% 0.69%
T-Bills 11.12% 0.07% 9.17% 0.15% 7.72% 0.42%
54. The numbers looking back
⢠Rolling period returns
1926-2003 30 year 40 year
Rolling Period Returns Best Worst Best Worst
Large Company Stocks 13.70% 8.47% 12.47% 8.85%
Small Company Stocks 18.83% 8.83% 17.90% 11.09%
Long Term Corporate Bonds 9.42% 2.83% 7.76% 3.42%
Long Term Government Bonds 9.39% 1.53% 7.53% 2.26%
T-Bills 6.77% 0.94% 6.11% 1.52%
55. The moral of the story
⢠No one can predictâŚ
⢠But you can estimateâŚ
⢠When assets are heldâŚ
56. Time impact
Possibility of losing money diminished
Price
Buy price
Time
57. What about market timing?
⢠The story of
⢠A hypothetical 20 year, $2000 investment
⢠Best day vs worst day through 1999
Best day = $387,120
Worst day = $321,569
58. What about international investing?
⢠Through 2003, international stocks
outperformed domestic stocks in 16 out of
25 ten year rolling periods
⢠The U.S. represents only 52% of the
worldâs stock market capitalization
59. What about IPOs?
⢠A study by Kidder Peabody
⢠Of 1000 IPOs, 67% underperformed the
Dow.
60. What about value vs growth?
⢠Depends on accounting numbers
⢠Depends on how you define them
⢠And the winner isâŚ
61. The best investors in history
⢠Benjamin Graham
⢠Peter Lynch
⢠Warren Buffett
62. Predictions for the future
From IbbotsonâŚ
1999-2025 CAGR
Large Company Stocks 11.6%
Small Company Stocks 12.5%
Dow Jones at 100,000 in early 2024
70. Three forms of market efficiency
1. Historical info does no good
â Technical analysis
2. Publicly available info does no good
â Fundamental analysis
72. Three forms of market efficiency
1. Historical info does no good
â Technical analysis
2. Publicly available info does no good
â Fundamental analysis
3. Inside info does do good
â Martha Stewart
74. The bottom line
⢠Historical info does no good
⢠Publicly available info does no good
⢠Inside info definitely does do good
⢠The debate continues
⢠The paradox
75. Issues affecting the EMH
⢠Only managers of large portfoliosâŚ
⢠Only investors thatâŚ
⢠Even if you were smart enoughâŚ
⢠Investment advice paradoxâŚ
⢠Winning managers are the ones thatâŚ
76. Where the EMH breaks down
⢠The small firm in January effect
⢠Low P/E effect
⢠Dogs of the Dow
⢠Pros vs the dart board
⢠Adding a new member to the S&P
77. Consequences of the EMH
⢠Articles, magazines, newspapers
⢠Web sites, research
⢠TV shows, radio shows
85. Three kinds of risk
Unique risk: extra risk of a single security
Market risk: of a diversified âmarketâ portfolio
Total risk: Ď, total risk of a single security
86. Impact of diversification
Since all rational investors hold portfolios of
stocks and therefore only experience market
risk, a stockâs price (which is a function of
risk) is based on market risk. Investors are
not compensated for stocks held in isolation.
Ergo, it is irrational to only own one or a few
stocks.
88. Beta
⢠The risk of a stock held in a diversified portfolio
⢠Relative to the market (market = 1)
⢠Can also have a beta of a portfolio
ββββββββββ
89. How is beta used?
In a formula for expected returnâŚ
ER = RF + β x (market premium)
90. How is beta used?
If you want to get a higher expected returnâŚ
ER = RF + β x (market premium)
95. Asset allocation
⢠Two types of asset allocation
â Tactical: specific securities & market timing
â Strategic: major asset types (stocks, bonds) &
asset size (small, large)
style (value, growth)
96. The cold hard facts
⢠Between 90% - 100% of a portfolioâs performance
over time depends on strategic asset allocation
⢠Less than 10% of a portfolioâs performance over
time depends on tactical asset allocation
97. A quick reminder
1926-2003 Geometric Mean Arithmetic Mean
Large Company Stocks 10.4% 12.4%
Small Company Stocks 12.7% 17.5%
Long Term Corporate Bonds 5.9% 6.2%
Long Term Government Bonds 5.4% 5.8%
T-Bills 3.7% 3.8%
Assumptions: All dividends and coupons reinvested, no taxes
98. Another reminder
1926-2003 30 year 40 year
Rolling Period Returns Best Worst Best Worst
Large Company Stocks 13.70% 8.47% 16.96% 11.97%
Small Company Stocks 18.83% 8.83% 24.55% 15.06%
Long Term Corporate Bonds 9.42% 2.83% 10.48% 4.58%
Long Term Government Bonds 9.39% 1.53% 10.16% 3.02%
T-Bills 6.77% 0.94% 8.23% 2.03%
100. Review
⢠The sooner you start the better
⢠2% over 40 years is worth fighting for
⢠Risk is just a measure of volatility
⢠You must get compensated for the risk you take
⢠You can reduce the chance of losing money by holding
securities longer
⢠You can reduce risk through diversification
⢠Stocks are a winning game over the long run
⢠You should own international securities
101. Review
⢠IPOs are losers
⢠Most returns are due to just a few good days
⢠Even investing on the worst day pays well
⢠You can only get abnormal returns with inside info
⢠The only way to âbeatâ the market is to assume more risk
⢠There are two kinds of risk: Ď and β
⢠You donât get compensated for a stock held in isolation
⢠90%+ of return is due to strategic asset allocation
111. Conflicts of interest
⢠Pay without performance
⢠Financial advice
⢠Short term incentives
⢠Unnecessary risk taking
⢠Tweaking performance
⢠Justifying their existence
119. Basic human frailties
⢠Impatience
⢠Greed
⢠Cognitive dissonance
⢠The law of small numbers
⢠The disposition effect
⢠The diversification dilemma
⢠The heard mentality
⢠Regrets of commission
⢠Ego
120. Biases
⢠Overconfidence
⢠Over optimistic
⢠Hindsight
⢠Loss aversion
⢠Overreaction
HHHHHTTTTT HTHHTHTTHT
121. More biases
⢠Errors of preference
⢠We value changes not states
⢠Narrow framing
122. The madness of crowds
⢠Irrational exuberance
â Tulip bulbs
â Florida real estate
â The Internet
123. Conclusions
⢠Great investorsâŚ
â are dispassionate
â are patient
â are not greedy
â have courage to stick with their plan
â take the long view and focus on the end point
125. What are mutual funds?
⢠A portfolio of securities that (theoretically)
follows a stated objective
⢠Two kinds
â Open endedâbuy & sell from the company
â Closed endedâbuy & sell from other investors
126. The role of mutual funds
⢠Diversification
⢠Divisibility
⢠Record keeping
⢠Professional management
⢠Lower transaction costs
127. Breakdown of mutual funds
1. Asset type
2. Asset company size
3. Asset company location
4. Fund âstyleâ
5. Fund objective
6. Sales fees
7. Sales classes
8. Specialty funds
9. Management
128. Asset type
⢠Stocks
â âEquity fundâ
⢠Bonds
â âFixed income fundâ
⢠Mixture of stocks & bonds
â âBalanced fundâ
129. Asset company size
⢠Large cap
⢠Mid cap
⢠Small cap
⢠Micro cap
⢠Multi cap
130. Asset company location
⢠US: the US
⢠International: all the world except US
⢠World: all the world
132. Fund objective
⢠Capital appreciation
â Growth, aggressive growth
â Stocks only
⢠Income
â Stocks and/or bonds
⢠Both
â Growth and income, equity and income, value
â Stocks and bonds
133. Bond funds
⢠Maturity
â Short term (1-5 years)
â Intermediate term (5-10 years)
â Long term (10-20 years)
⢠Borrower
â Treasury/Agency
â Municipalities
â Corporations (graded for risk)
⢠Risk
â High grade, high yield
134. Active vs passive management
⢠Passive management is called an index fund
â Pre-determined portfolio of securities
â Usually tracks one of the major indexes
⢠Active management lets the manager choose
â Individual securities
â Market timing
143. Large Cap Mid Cap
Russell 1000 Russell Mid Cap (800)
Russell 200 Russell 2500
S&P 500 S&P Mid Cap 400
DJIA DJ Mid Cap
DJ Large Cap Lipper Mid Cap
Wilshire Target Top 750 Wilshire Mid Cap 750
Lipper Large Cap
Indexes Small Cap Entire Market
Russell 2000 Russell 3000
as Russell Small Cap Completeness
S&P Small Cap 600
DJ Small Cap
Wilshire 5000
DJ US Total Market
S&P Supercomposite 1500
bench- Lipper Small Cap Lipper Multi Cap
Lipper Equity Income
Lipper Balanced Fund
marks
Sector International
NASDAQ Biotech MSCI EAFE Index
NASDAQ Computer MSCI Emerging Markets
NASDAQ Telecom Lipper International Fund
NYSE Financial
NYSE Healthcare
Lipper Science & Technology
S&P Utilities
144. How do you size up a mutual fund?
⢠Annual report
â Looking back
â Precise
â One moment in time
⢠Prospectus
â Looking forward
â Promises, promises
â About objectives
145. Whatâs in an Annual Report?
â˘Report from the chairman/advisor
â˘Profile of the fund
â˘Performance summary
â˘List of all the shares in the fund
â˘Accounting statements with notes
â˘About the people who manage the fund
149. Whatâs in a Prospectus?
â˘Objective, strategy, investment policies
â˘Risks
â˘Fees
â˘Performance and accounting snapshots
â˘About the people who manage the fund
â˘How to buy shares
150. Objective, strategy, investment policies
Objective: long term capital appreciation
Strategy: invests in US companies with
rapid earnings growth potential
Investment polices: what they can do and
what they canât
154. Direct fees
⢠Come directly out of your pocket
â Loads, commissions, sales charges
â Maintenance fees
â Larger than you think
5.75%
$2000 $1885 $115 $115/$1885 6.1%
155. Direct fee class warfare
⢠Class A: pay me now
⢠Class B: pay me later
⢠Class C: pay me during
156. Indirect fees
⢠These fees reduce the return you get
⢠âExpense ratioâ expressed as %
161. Mutual fund performance
⢠Must compare apples to apples
⢠Compare active funds to an index
⢠Hard for two reasons
1. Active funds may not âmatchâ index
2. You never know exactly what you have
162. Finding the
best index
⢠Standard indexes
â Use R2
Value fund
163. Finding the
best index
⢠Standard indexes
â Use R2
Healthcare fund
165. Problems with assessing active funds
Large turnover leads to uncertainty inâŚ
âŚsecurities
âŚbeta
âŚR-squared
âŚthe proper index to use
166. So what is known about active funds?
1. Bad funds tend to persist
2. Do good funds persist?
3. On average, because of market timing and security
selection, active funds add no value
4. Funds with higher fees do not increase gross returns
enough to justify the fees
5. Over the past 10 years, 25% of active funds have beaten
the benchmark
6. Over the past 20 years, 12% have beaten the benchmark
167. Other problems with mutual funds
⢠Survivorship bias
⢠Big funds become the market
⢠Size creep
⢠Style shift
⢠Window dressing
⢠Unnecessary risk
⢠Unpredictable management
⢠The successful fund issue
⢠The scandal
169. Review active vs passive
Active Passive
Â
Management fees High Low
Know whatâs in portfolio No Yes
Turnover Can be high Low
Trading costs Can be high Low
Risk Unknown Market
Diversification Unknown Perfect
Manager trying to get famous? Yes No
Trying to beat the market Yes No
Size creep Yes No
Style shift Maybe No
Tax efficient No Yes
Can beat the market Maybe No
Forced buys/sells No Yes
173. Mutual fund breakdown
Mutual fund family:______________________
Mutual fund name:_______________________
Â
Asset type: Stocks Bonds Both
Asset size: Small cap Mid cap Large cap Multiple cap
Asset location U.S. World International
Style: Growth Value Blend
Objective: Apprec Income Both
Bond Maturity: Short Interm Long
Borrower: Govât City Corporations
Bond Risk: High grade High yield
Management Active Passive
Specialty funds Sector Regional Other______________________
Sales load Yes No
12b-1 fees Yes No
Expense ratio:_____________________________
Turnover ratio:_____________________________
Beta:______________________________________
R-squared:_________________________________
174. Exchange traded funds
⢠Mutual funds traded like stocks
⢠Advantages: ultra low expenses, buy/sell
any time, better capital gains handling
⢠Disadvantages: brokerage fees, dollar cost
averaging is expensive
176. What weâve learned
1. The best time to start investing isâŚ
2. You are younger than you think
3. Under 45, you should have ______% equities
4. There are no good ________ investment strategies
5. There are plenty of goodâŚ.
6. The best person to make your investment decisionsâŚ
7. Diversify to get compensated forâŚ
8. You canât beat the market andâŚ
9. Stop watching your investments and get aâŚ
177. A simple plan
⢠Max out your tax deferred first
⢠Dollar cost average
⢠Diversify
⢠Keep it simple
⢠Core and explore if you must
⢠Portfolio rebalance once a year