6. Symbols Give Some Form of
Implicit Meaning
•Can mean….
•Formal and Informal Learning Pathways
•Represent hard and soft skills
•Stackable LIFELONG learning
8. The Learning Experience throughout a
Learning Career
• Enter into an institution
• Make selections during their
education, pay for them, and
when they are all done they
get……
11. The Validity of a Badge
•Technical Standards
•Meta Data Standard
•Identifies all the
associated material of
the badge
•Can be displayed
12. Badges are based on Demonstrating
Mastery
• Assessments
• Portfolio of work
• Certifications
• Field work in real time
documented with images,
movies….
Demonstrating Mastery
can be….
27. Institutions & Companies Using Badges
• Purdue University
• Penn State
• University of Indiana
• Colorado State University – Ft. Collins
• University of Denver
• Deloitte
• City of NewYork
• City of Chicago
• ACE and the US Military
• Samsung
• LearnDash
• Extreme Networks
• LinkedIn
• Khan Academy
30. Issuing Badges
• Access the
badge
Badge
• Review the
meta data
Meta data
• Compile
the meta
data
Competencies
• Transcript
PLA
• Identify
grandular
Competencies
Competencies
• Identify how
to measure
Mastery
Assessments
• Compile the
meta data
Meta data
• Issue digital
credential
Badges
Accepting Badges
31. Enter the
CCCS-
CHAMP
badge
initiative
Goal is to recognize and document learning outside the traditional college credit system.
Goal is to recognize and document learning outside the traditional college course.
A learner will be able to show competency in a specific skill or base of knowledge not necessarily reflected in a college course title or description
Badge info
content ow ner technical ow ner visual ow ner badge nam e type / category purpose description criteria evidence assessm ent type m inim um reqs
Who is responsible for
overseeing and
Who is responsible for
the technical
Who is responsible for
the visual design of
Do you have a system
for naming? How are
What are the badge
categories that you'll
What is your badge
seeking to
How can the badge be
explained in a simple,
What does someone
need to do in order to
Are your badges
artifact driven? If so,
How will the work be
assessed? Some
Are there minimum
requirements for the
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team ????? Essential Geometry achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Earn the Angles,
and Triangles,
Circles and
Polygons, and the
Geometric Solids
Badges
Earn the Angles,
and Triangles,
Circles and
Polygons, and the
Geometric Solids
Badges
Earn the Angles,
and Triangles,
Circles and
Polygons, and the
Geometric Solids
Badges
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team Angles and
Triangles
achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Summative Math
Test
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team Circles and
Polygons
achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Summative Math
Test
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team Geometric Solids achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Summative Math
Test
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team Essential Algebra achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Earn the Algebraic
Operations,
Equations and
Formulas, and the
Systems of
Equations Badges
Earn the Algebraic
Operations,
Equations and
Formulas, and the
Systems of
Equations Badges
Earn the Algebraic
Operations,
Equations and
Formulas, and the
Systems of
Equations Badges
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team Algebraic
Operations
achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Summative Math
Test
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team Equations and
Formulas
achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Summative Math
Test
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team Systems of
Equations
achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Pass at an 80%
assessment
Summative Math
Test
CHAMP/Brenda
Perea
CHAMP Team Essential Math achievement Competency in
specific math skill
or concept
Earn the Ratio,
Proportion and
Percents, Units of
Measure,
Fundamentals of
Numbers, Powers
of 10 and Scientific
Notation Badges
Earn the Ratio,
Proportion and
Percents, Units of
Measure,
Fundamentals of
Numbers, Powers
of 10 and Scientific
Notation Badges
Earn the Ratio,
Proportion and
Percents, Units of
Measure,
Fundamentals of
Numbers, Powers
of 10 and Scientific
Notation Badges
Goal #1
Goal #2
Goal #3
Badge System Goals
What are the primary goals of your badge system? What would you like this system to
accomplish? What values would you like to see expressed? How will a badge earner grow and
evolve by earning badges in this system? Consider answering these questions individually and
then gather as a team to discuss responses.
Badge team
33. Anatomy of a Proposed Digital Badge
• Ratio, Proportion and Percent
• Demonstrate knowledge and use of ratios,
proportions and percents.
• Pass an assessment at 80%
• CHAMP grant out of the ColoradoCommunity College
System
• Assessment in theTechnical Math MOOC
• 7/1/2015
• Essential Math
• CCCS, CHAMP, Ration, Proportion, Percent, MAT108,
Badges … Visual representations of achievements, learning, skills, competencies
Symbols have meaning. They are images that give us information through imagery.
For instance:
This symbol could be Electrical hazards or Zeus Warning
Push button to dry hands or push button to get bacon
Wear your seatbelt or (ask audience for possible response)
Engine needs oil or Engine needs gravy
In education, symbols are used to represent what people learn and master.
They can be certificates or degrees to show mastery of specific disciplines
They can be awards or exclusive memberships in organizations
The meaning is implied – the symbols themselves don’t necessarily mean anything
They have become a tool….where we apply them and have given them meaning that they represent an assessment of performance
The forms that are represented on the transcript is a capture in time,….the learning is evolving
What was once a course, represented by a credit, or a Carnegie Unit is evolving…Learning can happen in a lot of different places, MOOCs, Online learning, employer training, for-profit training, OSHA, apprenticeships ….
Digital badges have become a way to symbolize learning that happens outside of traditional institutions for learning such as CCCS.
They are visual representations and can mean whatever the issuer wants them to mean.
This can be a problem for the receiver of the badge who tries to use them as evidence of learning because and employer or other organization will not necessarily know if the badge means anything more than the image.
Problem of “carpet badging” vs truly documenting mastery of skills
Rather than have implicit meaning, digital badges have EXPLICIT meaning
If you are uncertain of the value of the badge you can find out the:
Criteria
Context
AND the evidence of learning that has occurred
So anyone who looks at that badge has the same information.
Standards are emerging to make badges more relevant for the receiver of the badge and the employer who wants to know what specific skills a prospective employee has
Demonstrating mastery can be shown through
Assessments
Portfolio of work
Certifications
Field work
Questions on the background of badges?
Dr. Nagitichi…nobel prize winner in organic chemistry
Recognized on a transcript like…..
So enters into the value of the badge….
It is important on who issues it….
The nuance of who issues it and the value around the issuer
Badge should be like an iceberg. The surface is what people see, but that surface should represent depth and substance underneath.
Badges give students a new path to create paths to learning….capturing sub-course level learning by pursuing outcomes through different paths
Badges can be versatile, allowing learners to create their own certificates/degrees
Can even be threatening to traditional institutions since engaged learners to pick and choose not only what they learn, but where they learn it.
Evidence
criteria, WHO issued it
Motivation?
Value is an extrinsic motivator
Badges are goals
Digital representation of some aspect in the course
Badges can be used to show mastery of competencies beyond completion of specific course competencies.
Badges can be used to show competencies in traditional co-curricular organizations
Not associated with a particular course
Don’t need to upend the educational process or institutions to apply badges, we can make badges work in existing learning environments by capturing assessments in different ways
Badges creates a series of credentials related to learning outcomes which are unique to the holder of the badge
Value is the ability to stand out in a crowd
Examples of badges based on master of skills
Certifications - New York City Department of Education
Validation – Educause validating completion of IT trainings
Commemorate – Smithsonian badges unique programs/activities
Institutions and companies using Badges
Purdue University
Penn State
University of Indiana
Colorado State University-Fort Collins
University of Denver
Deloitte
City of New York
City of Chicago
ACE and the US Military
Samsung
LearnDash
Extreme Networks
LinkedIn
Khan Academy
Challenges to badges.
No official institution to certify badges are legitimate
What does it mean to have an institutional badge? We know about transcripts, diplomas, certificates
Branded—do you include or not include the institution’s official badge
FERPA—how do you do badges and protect privacy? Only share the elements a student wants
Two processes for developing and using badges
Issuing badges
Who is the audience?
Accepting badges
What do they represent?
Badging initiative part of CHAMP TAACCCT Grant
Focus on issuing badge to represent learning outside of our typical course work
Math MOOC based on MAT108 competencies
Aligned badges to the competencies in CCNS.
Started with clusters based on industry needs – reviewed literature and studies showing what specific skill-sets industry looked for and how they were tied to what workers actually needed on the job
Rather than have implicit meaning, digital badges have EXPLICIT meaning
If you are uncertain of the value of the badge you can find out the:
Criteria
Context
AND the evidence of learning that has occurred
So anyone who looks at that badge has the same information.
Backed by Evidence and credentials
Criteria
Evidence
Assessment
Standards
Issuer