27. MAD
RSFE
MAD
RSFE
CASE
· 3.
Hammerstein University—Enrollment
Hammerstein University president Blake Sherman was worried
about the survival of his university. The state of Illinois had
been having financial troubles for years. For the past two years
it was at an impasse in passing a budget. One consequence was
that students were not getting the state tuition funds they had
received in past years. This issue had multiple results.
· (1)
Less students were enrolling because of the lack of state funds.
· (2)
Those students who did enroll were tentative about remaining in
school and this generated a high dropout rate.
· (3)
To support the students, Hammerstein University increased its
own tuition assistance program.
All three results were affecting Hammerstein University’s
financial well-being.
28. The key to survival was simple. Enrollment has to be
maintained at a level to support the current level of degree
programs, staff, and faculty. In addition, there still are the basic
expenses of running Hammerstein University such as building
repairs, grounds upkeep, and travel costs for sporting events. If
the enrollment could not be maintained at the required level,
Blake knew he would have to make some significant cuts.
Degree programs that were not paying for themselves may need
to be cut. This obviously would affect faculty. Cosmetic repairs
for building or the grounds may need to be deferred to later.
The potential financial crisis may make it necessary to
temporarily shut down some sports. Blake feared that while
these types of actions would ease the financial crisis in the
short term, the same actions could further reduce enrollment
and result in a slow downward spiral.
Blake had his admissions staff provide the enrollment for the
past six semesters. The following table provides the data.
SEMESTER
ENROLLMENT
2017 fall
2017 spring
3,120
2016 fall
3,249
29. 2016 spring
3,716
2015 fall
3,520
2015 spring
3,170
2014 fall
3,094
Blake has the vice president of finance, Leroy Hardy, to
calculate how many students represented a breakeven point
under the current financial situation. He then asked Leroy to
calculate what the enrollment breakeven point would be if the
state began to provide tuition assistance again to their students.
Leroy said for the enrollment breakeven point for no-state
tuition was 3,265. The enrollment breakeven point for state
tuition being paid was 3,000.
Blake had not yet been told the forecast for fall 2017. However,
as he looked over the past enrollments, he was not optimistic.
Both spring 2017 and fall 2016 enrollments were below the
breakeven point for no-state tuition. Although he would have to
wait for the figures from admissions staffs, he believed he needs
to begin looking at options if the state didn’t pass a budget that
included tuition assistance.
Discussion Questions
1. Calculate the potential enrollment for fall 2017 using a three-
30. semester weighted moving average, with weights 0.1, 0.3, and
0.6, with 0.06 for the most recent semester. Start your forecast
for the spring 2016 semester and continue to fall 2017.
2. Calculate the potential enrollment for fall 2017 using
exponential smoothing with a forecast for fall 2014 of 3,094 and
a smoothing constant of 0.2. Which forecast do you think is the
best? Why?
3. Which forecast or forecasts match or exceed the enrollment
breakeven point if the state continues to not pay tuition
assistance? Which match or exceed the enrollment breakeven
point if the state pays tuition assistance? What is the next task
Blake should have his staff do, based on these forecasts?
Case
· 1.
Quincy Snodgrass Enterprises—Forecasting
Quincy Snodgrass is an entrepreneur and a lover of the
outdoors. He has worked for various companies since he
graduated college with his business administration degree in
management. Over the years, he has saved every extra penny
and now has the starting capital he needs; consequently, he
plans to open his own business. Quincy plans to open a
landscaping business. The primary services he’ll offer are grass
cutting, edging, and bush trimming. Obviously, this will only
31. provide income in the spring, summer, and early fall. Therefore,
he plans to offer snow removal in the winter. His goal is to
continue to provide those baseline services and expand into
actual landscaping work.
Quincy’s initial challenge is to develop a forecast of how many
customers he’ll have each month. This is essential to determine
if he needs to hire any additional labor throughout the season.
Unfortunately, none of the jobs Quincy has had involved
forecasting. Quincy is digging deep into his memory to recall
his supply chain management course and the chapter on
forecasting. He knows he has two methods to choose from,
qualitative and quantitative.
Quincy is a numbers guy and is partial to using a quantitative
method if possible, but he doesn’t rule out the option of using
one of the qualitative methods. He had worked many summers
for other yardwork companies. Knowing he wanted to own his
own business someday, Quincy took notes on how things went.
Since his customer base would be in a series of small towns,
Quincy knows he cannot charge as much as the companies that
served larger communities. Consequently, volume is necessary
to earn the revenue he will need.
Quincy focused on three small towns, Smithburg with a
population of 700, Emeryville with 1,800, and Golf Creek with
2,500. He believes he can get 10 percent of the homes in each
town to hire him. Quincy used information from the county files
32. to estimate that on average, the number of homes is equal to
about 25 percent of the population, meaning in Smithburg (700)
the potential number of homes is about 175. Quincy believes his
calculations are reasonable and could be the foundation for
using a qualitative method to kick off his forecasting.
Discussion Questions
1. Since Quincy doesn’t have any historical data (only an
estimate of the number of customers he’ll serve each month),
which specific type of qualitative method is he using? What
would be the total number of customers based on his
assumptions? Is this a realistic number to allow the business to
survive? He estimates his average fee will be $25.
2. Because of the type of communities, overtime Smithburg will
provide 20 percent of the homes as customers, Emeryville still
10 percent, and Golf Creek only 7 percent. Assuming he was
charging $25 per home, what effect does this change in monthly
forecast have on his monthly revenue? Should he change his
price either up or down? Explain.
3. Quincy has been gathering data for over five years now. He
has a record of how many customers he had each month. He also
has information on the weather, for example, which month has
the most rain. Quincy wants to use these data to improve his
forecasting. He has a choice of cause-and-effect models. Based
on what data he has and what he wants to do, what would be the
best method from the choices he has? Explain the elements of