SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
Services are now at the heart of everything that is marketed and customer and employee
loyalty are at the heart of all service breakthroughs (Heskett, 1990). We live in the post-
industrialization era, which rely more on the services and less on the industries. It contributes
higher than agriculture and manufacturing industry as a percentage of GDP in the world
(WorldBank, 2015). In middle and high-income countries share of the services industry
dominates even when agriculture and industrial outputs are combined. This paradigm shift in
economy in the past few decades explains consumer demand for services in various fields
that includes hotel and tourism, health care, food, retail, information technology,
telecommunications, entertainment, legal, consulting and many other areas. Services
marketing, the need for concepts evolved in the academic literature since 1977 (Shostack,
1977). This has led to the development of many dimensions and perspectives that focused on
intangible resources, relationships and value co-creation (Vargo & Lusch, 2004) ranging
from integrative view of products and services to pure service dominant view of marketing.
Broadly, Services can be classified into four categories as per Lovelock (1983). They are
either directed at people’s bodies or minds or tangible possessions or intangible assets. Unlike
products, nature of services is that production and consumption are simultaneous processes
for the organization and the consumer. Service dominant logic can offer the solutions through
intangible offering and can gain the competitive advantage through clear differentiation and
positioning strategies which might be less easy with the physical products alone. In fact, more
the dominance of services then more the complexity in terms of consistency,
communications, quality, ownership, supply-demand synchronization, pricing and
reproducibility (i.e., intangibility, heterogeneity, inseparability and perishability). This
complexity deems some additional variables (in addition to 4P’s: Product, Place, Promotion
and Price) to be incorporated in the marketing philosophy namely people, physical evidence
and process for services. All these elements along with traditional marketing mix elements
will be explored in detail for a telecommunication company “AirTel” which is serving
millions of customers everyday.
1
Bharti AirTel Limited, an Indian MNC that has its presence felt in 20 countries is ranked 5th
telecommunication service operator in the world (AirTel, 2014). Founded in 1995, the vision
of the brand “AirTel” is to become the most loved brand by 2015. The company is known for
pioneering its unique business model minutes factory to build its 1.85bn customer base
worldwide profitably laying the road for many of its competitors to follow its core
competency model. Although the company is an international one and offers multi-platform
services in telecom, enterprise and digital TV, the focus here will be on telecommunication
services in India. Telecommunication services can be regarded as merely service dominant
along the Services continuum scale (Shostack, 1977). We examine how AirTel conveys its
brand positioning and personality using Service branding model proposed by Berry (2000)
and analyse how the brand differentiates its services to its target audience throgh its
communications and operations activities. Various models like service blueprint,
SERVQUAL attributes and gaps model have been used appropriately in evaluating the
services and whereever necessary, recommendations for improving the brand positioning are
also suggested alongside the discussion with relevance to the academic literature.
Brand Positioning and Personality – AirTel:
Brand personality assigns consumers meaning in which they can relate and effectively
increase brand awareness and popularity. As described by Aaker (1996), brand personality
builds the emotional relationship between the consumer and the brand and is very important
in differentiating services (Zeithaml, 1981). The brand lends its appeal to the target audience
through recognition (Malhotra, 1988; Sirgy, 1982) and helps to build trust and loyalty
amongst them. As proposed by Berry (2000), the components and relationships of the service
brand are the presented brand, brand awareness, external brand communications, brand
meaning and customer experience as illustrated in the figure 1. Dotted lines show the
secondary impact and the solid lines shows the main impact on the dimensions shown in the
figure.
2
Figure 1. Berry’s (2000) Service branding model
The logo of the brand has been redesigned in 2010 (EconomicTimes, 2010) to appeal to the
target global younger consumers. The changed dark red background color is designed to
refresh the brand to assign younger, energetic associations and to signify the heritage on a
global level. It also indicate the core values of the brand like leadership, performance,
dynamism and enthusiasm as this color has got resemblance with global recognizable brands
like Coca-Cola and McDonald’s for example. The white color is the recognition for humility.
The curved letter “a” is called the wave and highlights warm dynamic and friendly appeal of
the brand repositioned to become the most lovable brand by 2015. The current tagline that the
brand employs is “The Smartphone Network” to transit from a traditional model to a
company dedicated for smartphone (Mankotia, 2014). AirTel’s brand name, logo, uniforms
that employees wear and Servicescape contribute to visual identity in brand differentiation
which has been acknowledged by several scholars (Aaker, 1996; Boyle, 1996; Kotler, 1973;
Onkvisit & Shaw, 1989).
Figure 2. AirTel brand current logo (Source: www.airtel.com )
3
Service companies have only cues such as service’s price and the physical appearance of the
facilities (Zeithmal, 1981) and it is similar to the package of the physical product. Price
comparison is easier than the physical evidence cues, which are quiet hard to be compared by
the customers. AirTel’s physical evidence is linked to the organisation’s vision and goals.
This so called Servicescape takes the role in the form of package, facilitator, socializer and
differentiator as mentioned by Bitner (1992). There are three kinds of servicescape namely
self-service, interpersonal and remote servicescape. Self-service affects only consumers who
use the service. Interpersonal servicescape affects both the consumers and employees
whereas a remote servicescape in which only the environment affects only the employees.
In the interpersonal servicescape aspect, AirTel’s physical complexity is more elaborate,
which facilitates the interaction between the employees and consumers to deliver its pre-paid,
post-paid, data and digital TV services under one roof. The warm and cool interior facility
design and lighting in the relationship center differentiates from the competitor’s physical
appearance. This is the only tangible aspect among the five dimensions of service quality
(i.e., SERVQUAL attributes – reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy and tangibles)
as mentioned by Parasuraman (1993) to have a significant impact on the consumers’
perceptions of service quality (Bitner, 1992). It is also a proof of service delivery in relation
to the price which determines the level of customer satisfaction. The AirTel iconic ringtone
that was composed by music director A.R. Rahman is still being used by AirTel today in all
its customer relationship centers, advertisements and also during the call waiting time for any
query in the remote servicescape. This music is clearly a consistent socializing and
differentiating element for the brand to convey its eternal youth identity through
communicating the personality status.
Positioning services effectively involve more than marketing efforts such as the designing the
service blueprint and the process itself is the product (Heskett, 1990,p. 53). In the remote and
self-service servicescape, AirTel is supported by IBM support processes and has good
relationship with the company for integrating the customer facing process alongside all
platforms. Examples can include customer SIM card activation time reduction from days to
hours, customer self-service through USSD/SMS facility, web and interactive voice response
system, generation of unbilled information to the postpaid customers via SMS. Although
these support systems are invisible to the customer as seen in the service blueprint figure 3,
the company integrates information from the websites, social media, retail outlet, advertising
and promotion, billing to communicate the Service Quality Proposition (SQP) to the
4
customers in a seamless and flawless way (Srikapardhi, 2014). Websites today are very
useful for consumers to find the information they needed and also is a very powerful
judgmental tool for the Indian consumers to perceive the service quality in terms of
competitive edge, efficiency, fulfillment and reliability (Santos, 2003; Zeithaml, et al., 1996).
An examination of AirTel’s Servicescape (including e-servicescape like website) can be very
useful in understanding consumers’ perception formation that can be used to position itself
from the competition. This will be discussed with recommendations to improve the
positioning of the brand.
Figure 3. Service Blueprint – AirTel
AirTel uses various platforms like advertising in radio, television, social media, news stories
and signage consistently to provide tangible cues, capitalize on WOM, advertise to
employees and create advertising continuity to make the service understood (Mortimer,
2002). The brand creates pervasiveness by making impossible for customers to get the
advertisements unnoticed. AirTel’s ads scores reasonably well on the grounds of imagery and
music. The communications that have been grasped by the consumers about the company like
WOM and publicity are the most common forms of external brand communications (Berry,
2000; Hill & Gandhi, 1992). Advertising literature indicates that cognitive, emotion and
experience are key intermediate advertising effects. AirTel recognizes this fact and
incorporates intangibility and emotions in its external communications for the consumers to
discern its brand identity. Also, the high quality service promise which is its functional core
5
protects itself from against the unlikely consumer experiences as suggested by Aaker (2004).
External brand communications are moderately effective for AirTel because of the firm’s
limited efforts to manage the internal marketing communications to the employees to deliver
the promise as shown in the figure 4. An example is, facilitating internal channels of
coordination between front end executives in relationship centers, retailers who sell the
company products and back end support staff pays-off to reduce the gap between service
delivery and customer expectations.
Figure 4. Services Marketing triangle (Kotler, 1997)
Consumer Service Experience:
Service always comes with an experience (Carbone & Haeckel, 1994). Dr. Jai Menon (2007),
Director of IT and Innovation, AirTel, said “Our new strategy is all about delivering a truly
differentiated experience and having the flexibility to continually improve the customer
experience”. AirTel’s advanced capabilities of integration enables to transform core aspects
of customer experience. One of the examples is the ability to cut down the time required to
activate the accounts by 90% through maximum efficiency. AirTel’s consumer experience
encompasses every aspect of company’s offering such as customer care quality, advertising,
servicescape, service features (not limited to Value-added features and 4G), connectivity,
ease of use and reliability. The company also understands that secret to a good experience lies
in embedding the core or fundamental value proposition in its offerings and not in the
multiplicity of features as described by Meyer & Schwager (2007). As we have seen about
advertising and servicescape above, the following will be addressed in context to operations
or quality of services being offered by AirTel.
The five key dimensions that is used to assess the service company are reliability,
responsiveness, assurance, empathy and tangibles. It is a revised model by Parasuraman et al.,
6
(1993), which was based on a study on five service companies including a telecommunication
firm. The five dimensions will be explained as follows with respect to AirTel, India.
Tangibles: The Company uses modern equipment in the relationship centers including mobile
handsets and kiosks that gives consumers a good perception about the brand. This element is
very important in the emerging countries like India, where the consumers evaluate strongly
based on the amount of sophisticated technology elements that is employed. Especially, the
younger consumer segments has a positive affinity to the brand. Employee uniforms which
are modestly formal and neat looking (not many service providers other than Vodafone and
AirTel stresses so much importance on this), bill desks at touch points and overall visually
appealing interior servicescape actually associates the brand meaning in the minds of the
consumers. The company uses its campaign information on its floor walls in most of the
relationship centers.
Reliability: As noted through observation, Value added services (VAS) are the highest
contributor of revenues for telecommunication companies in India including AirTel. The
consumers’ service perception of VAS is more for Vodafone, and AirTel is trailing behind
which is due to fact of lack of personalization, reliability and comfort in use attributes (Gupta
& Nagpal, 2014). AirTel brand has been modestly reliable for more than a decade for its
network clarity and customer care services as promised. This dimension has been the most
important for the brand to communicate its consistency through keeping its promises,
services delivered appropriately with provision and resolving the consumer problems.
Consumers are also highly dependable on the company to resolve their problems. The
reliability and trust factor is also amplified by the brand ambassadors with names of few like
A.R. Rahman, cricket legend Sachin Tendulkar, Shah Rukh Khan from the company’s
advertising strategies.
Responsiveness: In telecommunication, responsiveness is communicated by the length of
time customers wait in the relationship centers or in the customer care call(s) for assistance,
promptness of answers to questions and the level of detailed attention to the problems and
understanding of the issue.
7
Assurance: AirTel has sustainable high performance culture that assures the best innovative
quality services available in the country at an affordable cost. Assurance is an important
factor in delivering services especially in telecommunication queries where customers expect
a level of technical expertise and courtesy from the customer care executives as well.
Assurance creates customers confidence and is likely to be affected when the issue is
repetitive in nature even after the query is thought to be solved by the customer care
executive. In the digital world today, where people want to stay connected by every second,
this makes customers perceive it as moderate risk if the communication fails and the feel of
uncertainty might erode the customers’ loyalty and trust of the brand.
Empathy: The brand deliver services with its individualised plans, for instance, “myPlan” in
which customers can choose their proposition of talk time hours, mobile data, text messaging
limit, STD calls with in the country and roaming plans. Understanding that India is a
collectivist culture, the brand offers “One family one plan” to signify that this brand
recognises the culture and family values and provides to fulfil the gap through offering
uniquely in its first place. The Company empathizes with people in its promotion through
emotional campaign like “Barriers break when people talk”. This makes the customers feel
themselves unique and special.
8
Assessmentof Organisation’s activities and recommendations to improve
AirTel’s brand positioning:
Service Quality:
AirTel is ranked 2nd amongst the most valuable Indian brands in 2014 and 1st in the
telecommunication sector. Although, this is a credible result for an organisation that is
operating for almost two decades, it is really essential for the brand to build its positioning for
a sustainable competitive advantage and attain the personality status of the most loved brand
by 2015. Based on observation and secondary data, recommendations will be made wherever
necessary to improve its service quality to satisfy customers or exceed expectations. As
illustrated by Parasuraman et al., (1985), SERVQUAL model is commonly used to assess the
service quality. Figure 5 illustrates the SERVQUAL gaps model of Service quality.
Figure 5. “SERVQUAL” Gaps model of Service quality (Parasuraman, et al., 1985)
9
Customer gap is the difference between perceptions and expectations of the customer
(Parasuraman, 1993). Based on the observation, expectations from customers are to have a
consistent pricing, clear communication messages and promises being delivered to them in a
consistent manner. Price is an easy way to compare alternative services (Aaker, 1996) and on
pricing, the company has changed its strategies from time to time which affect the service
reliability dimension. For example, AirTel’s VoIP- voice over internet protocol service plan
which was introduced by the company (Krishnamurthy & Abrar, 2014) to avoid the internet
services cannibalizing the voice services revenue made customers dissatisfied with this move
even though none of the competitors introduced a plan to provoke customers by charging
consumers differently for using Skype or similar ones. Although this has been rolled back
within few days, the perceived cause of events will influence the perceptions of customers’
satisfaction as well. Another example which may disrupt consumers’ perception is “AirTel’s
4G Plans are lower than 3G plans” (Mahajan, 2014) which might seem over delivering the
promises but infact aggragating desired service levels by the current 3G consumers. It is the
customers’ perceptions of service that determines the true brand values.
Apart from the customer gap, there are four other gaps that might exist within the service
organisation and hence referred to as provider gaps. They are knowledge gap, service design
and standards gap, service performance gap and communications gap.
Gap 1: Knowledge gap
Employees’ lack of first-hand information about the services offered was observed during the
conversation with the customer care executives on a query regarding automatic balance
deduction from the virtual account. This might be due to the improper knowledge of
employees who delivers the services or there is limited empowerment of the frontline
personnel. This is also true in queries related to Value Added Services (VAS) queries where
frontline executives facing customers directly can’t resolve the issue due to the insufficient
authority provided to them but know a great deal about customers. The gap widens due to
lack of upward communication to the management who can address it. Since Consumers
experiences are collected at “touch points” (Meyer & Schwager, 2007), each touch point
gives opportunities or challenges to the company to vary the expected and actual service
levels to delight the customer or anything less. This understanding of customer experience
requires capturing rich information across all customer interactions with the service provider
and even other service providers that support the overall customer activity (Teixeira, et al.,
10
2012) and also must know to act when customers expereince a service failure. Technology
must be used to build powerful relationship management and tailor the services uniquely to
the individuals (Bitner, et al., 2010)
Gap 2: Service design and standards gap
Service encounters are much more than the point of staff-customer interactions, sometimes
referred to as “moment of truth” or simply “customer contact” (Chase, 1981) and provide an
opportunity for emotional engagement (Berry & Carbone, 2007). It has been observed during
a tele conversation with the customer care executives that a customer who is waiting for a
query to be resolved, is then enquired and diverted to the concerned technical team for
resolution which is in total makes the wait time hectic for the customers. A key
recommendation to address this issue is the adequate training of frontline customer contact
staff with basic technical skills to use the technology as a customer-driven standard so that a
significant amount of calls can be dealt by a single executive contact point for the customers.
This facilitates measurement of service operations through customer defined service
standards rather than company driven service standards and incorporating as a measure of
hard standards in service blueprinting. This is expected to make changes in the overall
turnaround time by the renovation in the service process design for the average call wait time
and in turn reduce the service design and standards gap. In examining the company’s website,
having an online chat seems to be a viable option that can be incorporated in the service
blueprint to depict the possibility of serving the customer more effectively with the use of
technology (Bitner, et al., 2010). Customers must be communicated how the progress might
look like and the company must set goals and criteria to be examined at times.
Gap 3: Service performance gap
A good example of service performance gap is an issue (example) of delivering a promised
service which is “100% bill guarantee”. It has been noted that a chunk of consumers
complaining to the company for exaggerating the bill statements inaccurately in the post-paid
usage and a few complaints related to the data services charges in the pre-paid service
delivery. This underperformance of not living up to the promises might backfire what have
been regularly promised to consumers through various channels of communications by the
brand. AirTel needs to manage the customer expectation (CEM – Customer Experience
Management) in delivering the services of this kind. It has been noted from many instances
(Mouthshut, 2015) that the area that impacts most on the customer satisfaction is spontaneity
11
and coping of employee to the consumers’ problems in relevance to the service performance
gap.
Gap 4: Communications gap
Communications gap exist in terms of poor process depiction to customers on process and
physical evidence of touch points, inconsistency in updating information across relationship
centers and in brand communications. Process depiction to the consumers via Service
blueprint is missing in the relationship centers (physical evidence). For example, photographs
or videos can be used to depict the process to the consumers who can understand how to get
the query solved in a relatively easier way at all relationship centers. Inconsistency in
regularly updating the information (i.e., tangibles) between the relationship centers was noted
demographically. Although this might be due to the fact that customers don’t expect much
from the relationship centers in the semi-urban areas, this might create a mixed perception of
the brand in the consumers’ minds. Servicescape although more functional in its role, AirTel
needs to have it incorporated in the facility design uniquely so that customers have the clear
line of recognition of the brand from the competition (for example: Vodafone’s logo – red
color background is also similar to AirTel, which is the second largest network operator in
India and can disrupt the consumer perceptions in the brand recall and recognition).
Renovating the evidence combines with clear presentation of the brand with an element of
youth fashion will send clear external communication messages to the consumers as a good
advertising strategy.
Simply to put, Services are the way forward for companies to clearly differentiate their
offerings in the marketplace because of its intangibility, heterogeneity, perishability and
inseparability. AirTel conveys its brand personality as mentioned by Berry (2000) through
the company’s presented brand, external brand communications, customer experience with
the company, brand awareness and brand meaning. On Brand expression, the company is
recommended to change its logo with a mixture of black and red instead of just red
bacground to reduce the imitation cue of rival brand Vodafone and as a measure to increase
its uniqueness. Brand’s advertising strategy of Airtel is a plausible one and it communicates
the messages promptly to the consumers in all possible medium mainly via WOM because of
its good service quality and loyal customer base. Logo, name and advertising are just the
visible tip of the brand iceberg to signify “what the brand stands for”. For any brand to
communicate “who we are” it must keep its promises by creating customer experiential
12
values such as service quality, customer relations, service recovery strategies, personnel and
other operations. It is the later that creates brand loyalty and confidence. As the evaluation of
consumer experience depends on the customer’s expectations and his/her interaction with the
company’s offering in correspondence to the different moments of touch-points
(Mouncey,2003), the brand should try to reduce the customer gap by focusing on its
servicescapes for instance, on virtual servicescape, creation of interactive websites that are to
the customers are very important in appealing to customers with rich content (eg: videos) as
suggested by Luís, et al., (2013) to communicate the market leadership in its service
offerings.
Customer gaps can be addressed through consistency across all brand touch points like
advertising, employee partners, social media, review sites, website, signage and WOM.
Provider gaps can be reduced by interpreting customers’ expecations and customer activity
through adequate market research, service operations by customer defined standards and
appropriate physcial evidence including virutal servicescape i.e., 24 hour online chat via
website, focus on customer relationship management through employee-technology job fit
and manage the service expectations, service recovery strategies and communication
strategies like upward communication and proper customer education through process
depiction via service blueprinting in the relationship centers.
A study suggests that Indian consumers are willing to spend more for good services
(BestmediaInfo, 2014). This adds an argument for the brand to employ the recommendations
to attain the desired brand personality status “to become the most loved brand by 2015”. As
the saying goes “There is no business without emotions” and customer experience must be
created in a way that will mutually benefit the company and the customer through an eternal
relationship.
13
References:
(2014), M., 2014. HDFC BankNamed India'sMostValuableBrand in BrandZ™ Ranking,asService
Sector BrandsDominate- See moreat: http://www.millwardbrown.com/global-
navigation/news/press-releases/full-release/2014/08/19/hdfc-bank-named-india's-most-valuable-
brand-in-bran. [Online]
Available at:http://www.millwardbrown.com/global-navigation/news/press-releases/full-
release/2014/08/19/hdfc-bank-named-india's-most-valuable-brand-in-brandz-ranking-as-service-
sector-brands-dominate
[Accessed07 March 2015].
(2015), M., 2015. Airtel Mobile OperatorReviews. [Online]
Available at:http://www.mouthshut.com/airtel
[Accessed09 March 2015].
Aaker,D.,1996. Measuringbrandequityacrossproductsand markets. California management
review, 38(3), pp.102-120.
Aaker,D. A.,2004. Leveragingthe corporate brand. California managementreview , 46(3), pp.6-18.
Airtel,2014. ManagementPresentationBhartiAirtel limited May 2014. [Online]
Available at:http://www.airtel.in/wps/wcm/connect/7cb62734-9f86-4265-9da8-
6dccd8f37be1/Bharti-Management-Presentation_vfc-
May+2014.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&CONVERT_TO=url&CACHEID=7cb62734-9f86-4265-9da8-
6dccd8f37be1
[Accessed22 February2015].
Alamro,Ahmed&Rowley,J.,2011. Antecedentsof brandpreference formobiletelecommunications
services. Journalof Product&Brand Management, 20(6),pp.475-486.
Berry,L. L., 2000. Cultivatingservice brandequity. Journalof theacademy of Marketing Science,
28(1), pp. 128-137.
Berry,L. L. & Carbone,L.P., 2007. Buildloyaltythroughexperience management. Quality progress,
40(9), pp. 26-32.
BestmediaInfo,2014. Indian customerwilling to pay premiumfor‘excellent service’: AmEx study.
[Online]
Available at:http://www.bestmediainfo.com/2014/10/indian-customer-willing-to-pay-premium-for-
excellent-service-amex-study/
[Accessed08 March 2015].
Bitner,M. J.,1992. Servicescapes:the impactof physical surroundingsoncustomersandemployees.
The Journalof Marketing, pp.57-71.
Bitner,M. J.,Zeithaml,V.A.& Gremler,D.D., 2010. Technology’simpactonthe gaps model of
service quality. Handbookof servicescience, pp. 197-218.
Boyle,E.,1996. "Anexperimentinchangingcorporate image inthe financialservicesindustryinthe
UK", Journal of. Journalof ServicesMarketing, 10(4), pp.56-69.
14
Carbone,L. P.& Haeckel,S.H.,1994. Engineeringcustomerexperiences. MarketingManagement,
3(3), pp.8-19.
Chase,R. B.,1981. The customercontact approach to services:theoretical basesandpractical
extensions. Operationsresearch, 29(4),pp.698-706.
Corporation,I.,2007. Bharti growsata stunning paceby keeping its, New York: IBMCorporation
2007.
EconomicTimes,T.,2010. Newlogo more global,youngerand aspirational:Sanjay Kapoor,CEO
Bharti Airtel. [Online]
Available at:http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-11-18/news/27612278_1_new-
logo-symbol-ceo-bharti-airtel
[Accessed22 February2015].
Gupta, G. & Nagpal,S.,2014. Value AddedTelecomServices:Examiningthe ImpactandLinkages. IM
QUEST, 10(1), pp. 1-10.
Haucap, J. & Ulrich, H., 2011. Consumerbehaviortowardson-net/off-netprice differentiation.
TelecommunicationsPolicy, 35(4), pp.325-332.
Heskett,J.L., 1990. Service breakthroughs. s.l.:SimonandSchuster.
Hill,D.J. & Gandhi,N.,1992. Service Advertising:A Framework toItsEffectiveness. Journalof
Services Marketing, 6(4),pp.63-76.
Kotler,P.,1973. Atmosphericsasa marketingtool. Journalof retailing, 49(4), pp. 48-64.
Kotler,P.,1997. Marketing Management:Analysis,Planning,Implementation,and Control. 9thed.
s.l.:PearsonEducation.
Krishnamurthy,K.&Abrar,P., 2014. Startupsworried aboutAirtel’sVoIPmove,despiterollback.
[Online]
Available at:http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/tech/tech-news/Startups-worried-about-Airtels-
VoIP-move-despite-rollback/articleshow/45687438.cms
[Accessed07 March 2015].
Lovelock,C.H.,1983. Classifyingservicestogainstrategicmarketinginsights. TheJournalof
Marketing, pp.9-20.
Luís, J. etal.,2013. Driversof in-groupandoutof-group. European Journalof Marketing, 47(7),pp.
1067-1088.
Mahajan, A.C., 2014. Airtel Slashes4G Rates.Gets Cheaperthan 3G!. [Online]
Available at:http://trak.in/tags/business/2014/11/26/airtel-4g-rates-slashed/
[Accessed08 March 2015].
Mahit, 2014. Airtel leadsthe leaguewhen it comesto Highest RuralSubscribersBase,forthe month
of July 2014. [Online]
Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-leads-highest-rural-subscribers-base-july2014/121813/
[Accessed27 February2015].
Malhotra,N. K.,1988. Self-conceptandproduct choice:anintegratedperspective. Journalof
EconomicPsychology, 9(1),pp.1-28.
15
Mankotia,A.S., 2014. Airtel turning itself into a company builton and fora smartphonenetwork.
[Online]
Available at:http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2014-09-
03/news/53522512_1_smartphone-network-srinivasan-gopalan-bharti-airtel
[Accessed25 February2015].
Menon,J.,2008. Bharti Airtel growsat a stunning paceby keeping its focuson the customer. [Online]
Available at:www.ibm.com/services/us/.../tc_bharti_ariel_grows_odc03064-usen.pdf
[Accessed23 February2015].
Meyer,C. & Schwager,A.,2007. Understandingcustomerexperience. Harvard businessreview,
85(2), p. 116.
Mortimer,K.,2002. Integratingadvertisingtheorieswithconceptualmodelsof servicesadvertising.
Journalof Services Marketing, 16(5),pp.460-468.
Mouncey,P.,2003. BuildingGreatCustomerExperiences. InteractiveMarketing, 5(1),pp.93-95.
Onkvisit,S.&Shaw,J. J.,1989. Service Marketing:Image,Branding,andCompetition. Business
Horizons, 32(1), pp.13-18.
Parasuraman,A.L. L. B. a. V.A. Z.,1993. More on improvingservice qualitymeasurement. Journalof
retailing, 69(1), pp.140-147.
Parasuraman,A.,Zeithaml,V.A.&Berry, L. L., 1985. A conceptual model of service qualityandits
implicationsforfuture research. TheJournalof Marketing, pp.41-50.
Reichheld,F.F.,2003. The One NumberYouNeedtoGrow. Harvard BusinessReview, 81(2), pp. 46-
55.
Santos,J.,2003. E-service quality:amodel of virtual service qualitydimensions. Managing Service
Quality:An InternationalJournal, 13(3),pp.233-246.
Shostack,G. L., 1977. Breakingfree fromproductmarketing. TheJournalof Marketing, pp. 73-80.
Shostack,G. L., 1984. DesigningServicesThatDeliver. Harvard BusinessReview, 133(February),p.9.
Sirgy,M. J., 1982. Self-conceptinconsumerbehavior:A critical review. Journalof consumerresearch
, 9(3), pp.287-300.
Srikapardhi,2014. Airtel,IBM 2014 Deal – Whatis it all about:Our indepth Analysis. [Online]
Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-ibm-2014-deal-what-is-it-all-about-our-indepth-
analysis/115632/
[Accessed27 February2015].
Teixeira,J.etal.,2012. Customerexperiencemodeling:fromcustomerexperience toservice design.
Journalof Service Management, 23(3),pp.362-376.
Telecominfo,2013. VodafoneIndia and Idea OffersBetterFriendly Self CareServices Than Airtel.
[Online]
Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/vodafone-india-and-idea-offers-better-friendly-self-care-
services-than-airtel-infographics/112313/
[Accessed08 March 2015].
16
TelecomInfo,2014. Airtel customersfeelcheated with misleading 3G rechargebenefiton its official
portal.[Online]
Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-cheating-customers/122963
[Accessed08 March 2015].
Telecominfo,2014. Airtel hikes it’s 2G Data packsfor Postpaid users,Now 2GBData CostRs.278
approx. [Online]
Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-2g-data-pack-postpaid/122808/
[Accessed08 March 2015].
Telecominfo,2014. TT Analysis: 76% of subscribersare notwilling to switch to Airtel myPlan orIdea
iPlan. [Online]
Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/76subscribers-are-not-willing-to-switch-to-airtel-myplan-or-
idea-iplan/127718/
[Accessed08 March 2015].
Telecominfo,2015. Airtel Web Based self care services forPrepaid CustomersNotreliable : Our
Experience. [Online]
Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-web-based-self-care-services-for-prepaid-customers-not-
reliable-our-experience/114186/
[Accessed08 March 2015].
Uniyal,P.,2014. Can yourwifebe yourbossand cookat the sametime? Airtel ad confusesTwitterati,
evokesmixed reaction. [Online]
Available at:http://indianexpress.com/article/lifestyle/feelings/can-your-wife-be-your-boss-and-
cook-at-the-same-time-airtel-ad-confuses-twitterati-evokes-mixed-reaction/
[Accessed08 March 2015].
Vargo,S. L. & Lusch, R. F.,2004. Evolvingtoa new dominantlogicformarketing. Journalof
marketing, 68(1),pp. 1-17.
WorldBank,2015. Growthof theService Sector. [Online]
Available at:http://www.worldbank.org/depweb/english/beyond/global/chapter9.html
[Accessed14 February2015].
Yadav, K,R. & Dabhade,N.,2013. Impactof service qualityoncustomersatisfactionof mobileusers:
a case studyof Airtel. InternationalJournalof InnovativeResearch and Studies, pp.139-163.
Zeithaml,V.A.,1981. Howconsumerevaluationprocessesdifferbetweengoodsandservices.
Marketing of services, 9(1), pp.25-32.
Zeithaml,V.A.,Berry,L.L. & Parasuraman,A.,1996. The behavioral consequencesof servicequality.
the Journalof Marketing, 60(2),pp.31-46.

More Related Content

What's hot

Project -Marketing research project on consumer behaviour towards nike footwear
Project -Marketing research project on consumer behaviour towards nike footwearProject -Marketing research project on consumer behaviour towards nike footwear
Project -Marketing research project on consumer behaviour towards nike footwearNikita Sharma
 
STRATEGIC PLAN OF INDIAN TOBACCO COMPANY (ITC)
STRATEGIC PLAN OF INDIAN TOBACCO COMPANY (ITC)STRATEGIC PLAN OF INDIAN TOBACCO COMPANY (ITC)
STRATEGIC PLAN OF INDIAN TOBACCO COMPANY (ITC)Utkarsh Bisht
 
Branding challenges and opportunities
Branding challenges and opportunitiesBranding challenges and opportunities
Branding challenges and opportunitiesDharamraj Raj
 
Nestle Porter Five Force & SWOT Analysis
Nestle Porter Five Force & SWOT AnalysisNestle Porter Five Force & SWOT Analysis
Nestle Porter Five Force & SWOT AnalysisMuwas Mia
 
Hari Krishna Exports Pvt Ltd.
Hari Krishna Exports Pvt Ltd.Hari Krishna Exports Pvt Ltd.
Hari Krishna Exports Pvt Ltd.Sunny Agarwal
 
Presentation on adidas and it's company profile
Presentation on adidas and it's company profilePresentation on adidas and it's company profile
Presentation on adidas and it's company profileAkash Islam
 
Marketing : Repositioning Strategies of Cadbury Dairy Milk
Marketing : Repositioning Strategies of Cadbury Dairy MilkMarketing : Repositioning Strategies of Cadbury Dairy Milk
Marketing : Repositioning Strategies of Cadbury Dairy MilkRohan Bharaj
 
Airtel – Positioning and Repositioning
Airtel – Positioning and RepositioningAirtel – Positioning and Repositioning
Airtel – Positioning and RepositioningJugal Thakkar
 
Duracell marketing, promotion
Duracell marketing, promotionDuracell marketing, promotion
Duracell marketing, promotiongopesh maurya
 
Brand questionnaire
Brand questionnaireBrand questionnaire
Brand questionnaireyasiniub
 
Bharati airtel final project 1
Bharati airtel final project 1Bharati airtel final project 1
Bharati airtel final project 1Karan Singh
 
Project 1 Marketing Grade 12 CBSE 2016-2017
Project 1 Marketing Grade 12 CBSE 2016-2017Project 1 Marketing Grade 12 CBSE 2016-2017
Project 1 Marketing Grade 12 CBSE 2016-2017Harsimran Singh
 
MKT345 Assignment (Oreo presentation)
MKT345 Assignment (Oreo presentation)MKT345 Assignment (Oreo presentation)
MKT345 Assignment (Oreo presentation)Adlina Zainuri
 
Product life cycle cadbury
Product life cycle cadburyProduct life cycle cadbury
Product life cycle cadburySiddharth Shetye
 

What's hot (20)

Project -Marketing research project on consumer behaviour towards nike footwear
Project -Marketing research project on consumer behaviour towards nike footwearProject -Marketing research project on consumer behaviour towards nike footwear
Project -Marketing research project on consumer behaviour towards nike footwear
 
STRATEGIC PLAN OF INDIAN TOBACCO COMPANY (ITC)
STRATEGIC PLAN OF INDIAN TOBACCO COMPANY (ITC)STRATEGIC PLAN OF INDIAN TOBACCO COMPANY (ITC)
STRATEGIC PLAN OF INDIAN TOBACCO COMPANY (ITC)
 
Nestle - Brand Management
Nestle - Brand ManagementNestle - Brand Management
Nestle - Brand Management
 
Branding challenges and opportunities
Branding challenges and opportunitiesBranding challenges and opportunities
Branding challenges and opportunities
 
Nestle Porter Five Force & SWOT Analysis
Nestle Porter Five Force & SWOT AnalysisNestle Porter Five Force & SWOT Analysis
Nestle Porter Five Force & SWOT Analysis
 
Hari Krishna Exports Pvt Ltd.
Hari Krishna Exports Pvt Ltd.Hari Krishna Exports Pvt Ltd.
Hari Krishna Exports Pvt Ltd.
 
Presentation on adidas and it's company profile
Presentation on adidas and it's company profilePresentation on adidas and it's company profile
Presentation on adidas and it's company profile
 
Brand Equity of Coca Cola
Brand Equity of Coca ColaBrand Equity of Coca Cola
Brand Equity of Coca Cola
 
Marketing : Repositioning Strategies of Cadbury Dairy Milk
Marketing : Repositioning Strategies of Cadbury Dairy MilkMarketing : Repositioning Strategies of Cadbury Dairy Milk
Marketing : Repositioning Strategies of Cadbury Dairy Milk
 
Airtel – Positioning and Repositioning
Airtel – Positioning and RepositioningAirtel – Positioning and Repositioning
Airtel – Positioning and Repositioning
 
Oreo analysis
Oreo analysisOreo analysis
Oreo analysis
 
Duracell marketing, promotion
Duracell marketing, promotionDuracell marketing, promotion
Duracell marketing, promotion
 
Brand questionnaire
Brand questionnaireBrand questionnaire
Brand questionnaire
 
Bharati airtel final project 1
Bharati airtel final project 1Bharati airtel final project 1
Bharati airtel final project 1
 
Coca cola dharm project
Coca cola dharm projectCoca cola dharm project
Coca cola dharm project
 
Project 1 Marketing Grade 12 CBSE 2016-2017
Project 1 Marketing Grade 12 CBSE 2016-2017Project 1 Marketing Grade 12 CBSE 2016-2017
Project 1 Marketing Grade 12 CBSE 2016-2017
 
Strategic analysis on telecom industries
Strategic analysis on telecom industriesStrategic analysis on telecom industries
Strategic analysis on telecom industries
 
Coke ppt
Coke pptCoke ppt
Coke ppt
 
MKT345 Assignment (Oreo presentation)
MKT345 Assignment (Oreo presentation)MKT345 Assignment (Oreo presentation)
MKT345 Assignment (Oreo presentation)
 
Product life cycle cadbury
Product life cycle cadburyProduct life cycle cadbury
Product life cycle cadbury
 

Viewers also liked

Vodafone Brand Analysis
Vodafone Brand AnalysisVodafone Brand Analysis
Vodafone Brand AnalysisHitaishi Gupta
 
Brand Image Measurement - Cadbury Dairy Milk
Brand Image Measurement - Cadbury Dairy MilkBrand Image Measurement - Cadbury Dairy Milk
Brand Image Measurement - Cadbury Dairy MilkArunachalam Ramanathan
 
Audi Brand Awareness Study, Customer Experience Identification, and Analysis
Audi Brand Awareness Study, Customer Experience Identification, and AnalysisAudi Brand Awareness Study, Customer Experience Identification, and Analysis
Audi Brand Awareness Study, Customer Experience Identification, and AnalysisMyuran Kanga, MS, MBA
 
Consumer perception of big bazaar
Consumer perception of big bazaarConsumer perception of big bazaar
Consumer perception of big bazaarShweta Germanwala
 
Brand Management- vodafone project
Brand Management- vodafone projectBrand Management- vodafone project
Brand Management- vodafone projectLufthansa
 
Vodafone Brand Positioning
Vodafone Brand PositioningVodafone Brand Positioning
Vodafone Brand PositioningWadut Al Mamun
 
Airtel Presentation (BRAND IDENTITY)
Airtel Presentation (BRAND IDENTITY)Airtel Presentation (BRAND IDENTITY)
Airtel Presentation (BRAND IDENTITY)gauravjain1985
 
Vodafone Brand Analysis
Vodafone Brand AnalysisVodafone Brand Analysis
Vodafone Brand AnalysisHitaishi Gupta
 
Amul: the brand building challenge
Amul: the brand building challengeAmul: the brand building challenge
Amul: the brand building challengeParesh Ashara
 
Vodafone Brand Academy
Vodafone Brand AcademyVodafone Brand Academy
Vodafone Brand Academymattus
 
Final ppt of tata tea
Final ppt of tata teaFinal ppt of tata tea
Final ppt of tata teameghna
 
Branding strategies of amul
Branding strategies of amulBranding strategies of amul
Branding strategies of amulshrutivatrana
 
Brand Personality
Brand PersonalityBrand Personality
Brand PersonalitySj -
 
Brand Management Study of Amazon
Brand Management Study of Amazon Brand Management Study of Amazon
Brand Management Study of Amazon Nikhil Narayan
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Vodafone Brand Analysis
Vodafone Brand AnalysisVodafone Brand Analysis
Vodafone Brand Analysis
 
Brand Image Measurement - Cadbury Dairy Milk
Brand Image Measurement - Cadbury Dairy MilkBrand Image Measurement - Cadbury Dairy Milk
Brand Image Measurement - Cadbury Dairy Milk
 
Audi Brand Awareness Study, Customer Experience Identification, and Analysis
Audi Brand Awareness Study, Customer Experience Identification, and AnalysisAudi Brand Awareness Study, Customer Experience Identification, and Analysis
Audi Brand Awareness Study, Customer Experience Identification, and Analysis
 
Consumer perception of big bazaar
Consumer perception of big bazaarConsumer perception of big bazaar
Consumer perception of big bazaar
 
Brand Management- vodafone project
Brand Management- vodafone projectBrand Management- vodafone project
Brand Management- vodafone project
 
Allensolly
AllensollyAllensolly
Allensolly
 
Vodafone Brand Positioning
Vodafone Brand PositioningVodafone Brand Positioning
Vodafone Brand Positioning
 
Cadbury -Brand Audit
Cadbury -Brand AuditCadbury -Brand Audit
Cadbury -Brand Audit
 
32589249 big-bazaar
32589249 big-bazaar32589249 big-bazaar
32589249 big-bazaar
 
Amul final
Amul finalAmul final
Amul final
 
Airtel Presentation (BRAND IDENTITY)
Airtel Presentation (BRAND IDENTITY)Airtel Presentation (BRAND IDENTITY)
Airtel Presentation (BRAND IDENTITY)
 
Imc vodafone
Imc vodafoneImc vodafone
Imc vodafone
 
Allen solly ppt
Allen solly pptAllen solly ppt
Allen solly ppt
 
Vodafone Brand Analysis
Vodafone Brand AnalysisVodafone Brand Analysis
Vodafone Brand Analysis
 
Amul: the brand building challenge
Amul: the brand building challengeAmul: the brand building challenge
Amul: the brand building challenge
 
Vodafone Brand Academy
Vodafone Brand AcademyVodafone Brand Academy
Vodafone Brand Academy
 
Final ppt of tata tea
Final ppt of tata teaFinal ppt of tata tea
Final ppt of tata tea
 
Branding strategies of amul
Branding strategies of amulBranding strategies of amul
Branding strategies of amul
 
Brand Personality
Brand PersonalityBrand Personality
Brand Personality
 
Brand Management Study of Amazon
Brand Management Study of Amazon Brand Management Study of Amazon
Brand Management Study of Amazon
 

Similar to International services marketing airtel - brand - personality 11.3.2015

Running head marketing mix for docu signmarketing mix for
Running head marketing mix for docu signmarketing mix for Running head marketing mix for docu signmarketing mix for
Running head marketing mix for docu signmarketing mix for SHIVA101531
 
THE IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY AND BRAND AWARENESS ON BRAND LOYALTY: (A STUDY ...
THE IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY AND BRAND AWARENESS ON BRAND LOYALTY: (A STUDY ...THE IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY AND BRAND AWARENESS ON BRAND LOYALTY: (A STUDY ...
THE IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY AND BRAND AWARENESS ON BRAND LOYALTY: (A STUDY ...paperpublications3
 
Running Head UBER TECHNOLOGY2Student NamePro.docx
Running Head UBER TECHNOLOGY2Student NamePro.docxRunning Head UBER TECHNOLOGY2Student NamePro.docx
Running Head UBER TECHNOLOGY2Student NamePro.docxtoltonkendal
 
Individual paper_Internet marketing_Hoffman
Individual paper_Internet marketing_HoffmanIndividual paper_Internet marketing_Hoffman
Individual paper_Internet marketing_HoffmanVeronika Tarnovskaya
 
Wp businessmodels in TIME Atos Consulting
Wp businessmodels in TIME Atos ConsultingWp businessmodels in TIME Atos Consulting
Wp businessmodels in TIME Atos ConsultingMarketingfacts
 
The Influence of Deceptive Advertising and Consumer Loyalty in Telecommunicat...
The Influence of Deceptive Advertising and Consumer Loyalty in Telecommunicat...The Influence of Deceptive Advertising and Consumer Loyalty in Telecommunicat...
The Influence of Deceptive Advertising and Consumer Loyalty in Telecommunicat...Muhammad Tehseen
 
Assignment digital (1)
Assignment digital (1)Assignment digital (1)
Assignment digital (1)Faith Shoko
 
Brand Equity and Customer Satisfaction as the Mediation of Advertisement infl...
Brand Equity and Customer Satisfaction as the Mediation of Advertisement infl...Brand Equity and Customer Satisfaction as the Mediation of Advertisement infl...
Brand Equity and Customer Satisfaction as the Mediation of Advertisement infl...IOSRJBM
 
DETERMINE THE INFLUENCE OF INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION ON CONSUMER DEC...
DETERMINE THE INFLUENCE OF INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION ON CONSUMER DEC...DETERMINE THE INFLUENCE OF INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION ON CONSUMER DEC...
DETERMINE THE INFLUENCE OF INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION ON CONSUMER DEC...IAEME Publication
 
Marketing for service quality in jordanian construction project organisation
Marketing for service quality in jordanian construction project organisationMarketing for service quality in jordanian construction project organisation
Marketing for service quality in jordanian construction project organisationAlexander Decker
 
New branding challenges and opportunities facing by asian service industry
New branding challenges and opportunities facing by asian service industryNew branding challenges and opportunities facing by asian service industry
New branding challenges and opportunities facing by asian service industryHanis Koh
 
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...prjpublications
 
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...prj_publication
 
Correlation Between an Airline’s Mission Statement, Customer Satisfaction, an...
Correlation Between an Airline’s Mission Statement, Customer Satisfaction, an...Correlation Between an Airline’s Mission Statement, Customer Satisfaction, an...
Correlation Between an Airline’s Mission Statement, Customer Satisfaction, an...inventionjournals
 
IRJET- A Study on the different Elements of Customer Loyalty and its Impact o...
IRJET- A Study on the different Elements of Customer Loyalty and its Impact o...IRJET- A Study on the different Elements of Customer Loyalty and its Impact o...
IRJET- A Study on the different Elements of Customer Loyalty and its Impact o...IRJET Journal
 
Running head Assignment 3 Part C Marketing PlanAssignment 3 .docx
Running head Assignment 3 Part C Marketing PlanAssignment 3 .docxRunning head Assignment 3 Part C Marketing PlanAssignment 3 .docx
Running head Assignment 3 Part C Marketing PlanAssignment 3 .docxjoellemurphey
 

Similar to International services marketing airtel - brand - personality 11.3.2015 (20)

Running head marketing mix for docu signmarketing mix for
Running head marketing mix for docu signmarketing mix for Running head marketing mix for docu signmarketing mix for
Running head marketing mix for docu signmarketing mix for
 
THE IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY AND BRAND AWARENESS ON BRAND LOYALTY: (A STUDY ...
THE IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY AND BRAND AWARENESS ON BRAND LOYALTY: (A STUDY ...THE IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY AND BRAND AWARENESS ON BRAND LOYALTY: (A STUDY ...
THE IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY AND BRAND AWARENESS ON BRAND LOYALTY: (A STUDY ...
 
Running Head UBER TECHNOLOGY2Student NamePro.docx
Running Head UBER TECHNOLOGY2Student NamePro.docxRunning Head UBER TECHNOLOGY2Student NamePro.docx
Running Head UBER TECHNOLOGY2Student NamePro.docx
 
Individual paper_Internet marketing_Hoffman
Individual paper_Internet marketing_HoffmanIndividual paper_Internet marketing_Hoffman
Individual paper_Internet marketing_Hoffman
 
Wp businessmodels in TIME Atos Consulting
Wp businessmodels in TIME Atos ConsultingWp businessmodels in TIME Atos Consulting
Wp businessmodels in TIME Atos Consulting
 
The Influence of Deceptive Advertising and Consumer Loyalty in Telecommunicat...
The Influence of Deceptive Advertising and Consumer Loyalty in Telecommunicat...The Influence of Deceptive Advertising and Consumer Loyalty in Telecommunicat...
The Influence of Deceptive Advertising and Consumer Loyalty in Telecommunicat...
 
Assignment digital (1)
Assignment digital (1)Assignment digital (1)
Assignment digital (1)
 
Brand Equity and Customer Satisfaction as the Mediation of Advertisement infl...
Brand Equity and Customer Satisfaction as the Mediation of Advertisement infl...Brand Equity and Customer Satisfaction as the Mediation of Advertisement infl...
Brand Equity and Customer Satisfaction as the Mediation of Advertisement infl...
 
DETERMINE THE INFLUENCE OF INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION ON CONSUMER DEC...
DETERMINE THE INFLUENCE OF INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION ON CONSUMER DEC...DETERMINE THE INFLUENCE OF INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION ON CONSUMER DEC...
DETERMINE THE INFLUENCE OF INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION ON CONSUMER DEC...
 
Marketing for service quality in jordanian construction project organisation
Marketing for service quality in jordanian construction project organisationMarketing for service quality in jordanian construction project organisation
Marketing for service quality in jordanian construction project organisation
 
New branding challenges and opportunities facing by asian service industry
New branding challenges and opportunities facing by asian service industryNew branding challenges and opportunities facing by asian service industry
New branding challenges and opportunities facing by asian service industry
 
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
 
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
Extended information technology enabled service quality model for life insura...
 
Image Management
Image ManagementImage Management
Image Management
 
03 icec
03 icec03 icec
03 icec
 
Correlation Between an Airline’s Mission Statement, Customer Satisfaction, an...
Correlation Between an Airline’s Mission Statement, Customer Satisfaction, an...Correlation Between an Airline’s Mission Statement, Customer Satisfaction, an...
Correlation Between an Airline’s Mission Statement, Customer Satisfaction, an...
 
The Determinants of Customer Loyalty in Telecommunication Industry of Pakistan
The Determinants of Customer Loyalty in Telecommunication Industry of PakistanThe Determinants of Customer Loyalty in Telecommunication Industry of Pakistan
The Determinants of Customer Loyalty in Telecommunication Industry of Pakistan
 
IRJET- A Study on the different Elements of Customer Loyalty and its Impact o...
IRJET- A Study on the different Elements of Customer Loyalty and its Impact o...IRJET- A Study on the different Elements of Customer Loyalty and its Impact o...
IRJET- A Study on the different Elements of Customer Loyalty and its Impact o...
 
Running head Assignment 3 Part C Marketing PlanAssignment 3 .docx
Running head Assignment 3 Part C Marketing PlanAssignment 3 .docxRunning head Assignment 3 Part C Marketing PlanAssignment 3 .docx
Running head Assignment 3 Part C Marketing PlanAssignment 3 .docx
 
10120140504014 2
10120140504014 210120140504014 2
10120140504014 2
 

More from Arun Shiva K

More from Arun Shiva K (15)

Session evaluation
Session evaluationSession evaluation
Session evaluation
 
Session ethics
Session  ethicsSession  ethics
Session ethics
 
Session 4
Session 4Session 4
Session 4
 
Session 3
Session 3Session 3
Session 3
 
Session 2
Session 2Session 2
Session 2
 
Session 1 my place
Session 1   my placeSession 1   my place
Session 1 my place
 
Marketing works -group-3-24.3.2015-prefinal -version 3
Marketing works -group-3-24.3.2015-prefinal -version 3Marketing works -group-3-24.3.2015-prefinal -version 3
Marketing works -group-3-24.3.2015-prefinal -version 3
 
Digital marketing assignment 30.3.2015- final
Digital marketing assignment   30.3.2015- finalDigital marketing assignment   30.3.2015- final
Digital marketing assignment 30.3.2015- final
 
Seminar 7
Seminar 7Seminar 7
Seminar 7
 
Seminar3
Seminar3Seminar3
Seminar3
 
Seminar 6
Seminar 6Seminar 6
Seminar 6
 
Seminar 5
Seminar 5Seminar 5
Seminar 5
 
Seminar 4
Seminar 4Seminar 4
Seminar 4
 
Seminar 2
Seminar 2Seminar 2
Seminar 2
 
Lecture1
Lecture1Lecture1
Lecture1
 

Recently uploaded

Banana Powder Manufacturing Plant Project Report 2024 Edition.pptx
Banana Powder Manufacturing Plant Project Report 2024 Edition.pptxBanana Powder Manufacturing Plant Project Report 2024 Edition.pptx
Banana Powder Manufacturing Plant Project Report 2024 Edition.pptxgeorgebrinton95
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...lizamodels9
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis UsageNeil Kimberley
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...lizamodels9
 
Call Girls In Kishangarh Delhi ❤️8860477959 Good Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delh...
Call Girls In Kishangarh Delhi ❤️8860477959 Good Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delh...Call Girls In Kishangarh Delhi ❤️8860477959 Good Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delh...
Call Girls In Kishangarh Delhi ❤️8860477959 Good Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delh...lizamodels9
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...lizamodels9
 
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT .pdf
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT      .pdfCatalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT      .pdf
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT .pdfOrient Homes
 
Vip Female Escorts Noida 9711199171 Greater Noida Escorts Service
Vip Female Escorts Noida 9711199171 Greater Noida Escorts ServiceVip Female Escorts Noida 9711199171 Greater Noida Escorts Service
Vip Female Escorts Noida 9711199171 Greater Noida Escorts Serviceankitnayak356677
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitHolger Mueller
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
NewBase 22 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi (AutoRe...
NewBase  22 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi  (AutoRe...NewBase  22 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi  (AutoRe...
NewBase 22 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi (AutoRe...Khaled Al Awadi
 
Sales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for Success
Sales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for SuccessSales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for Success
Sales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for SuccessAggregage
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfCatalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfOrient Homes
 
Investment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementInvestment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementJunaidKhan750825
 
A.I. Bot Summit 3 Opening Keynote - Perry Belcher
A.I. Bot Summit 3 Opening Keynote - Perry BelcherA.I. Bot Summit 3 Opening Keynote - Perry Belcher
A.I. Bot Summit 3 Opening Keynote - Perry BelcherPerry Belcher
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCRsoniya singh
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: NOQX's $200k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: NOQX's $200k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: NOQX's $200k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: NOQX's $200k Pre-seed deckHajeJanKamps
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Banana Powder Manufacturing Plant Project Report 2024 Edition.pptx
Banana Powder Manufacturing Plant Project Report 2024 Edition.pptxBanana Powder Manufacturing Plant Project Report 2024 Edition.pptx
Banana Powder Manufacturing Plant Project Report 2024 Edition.pptx
 
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
 
Call Girls In Kishangarh Delhi ❤️8860477959 Good Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delh...
Call Girls In Kishangarh Delhi ❤️8860477959 Good Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delh...Call Girls In Kishangarh Delhi ❤️8860477959 Good Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delh...
Call Girls In Kishangarh Delhi ❤️8860477959 Good Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delh...
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
 
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT .pdf
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT      .pdfCatalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT      .pdf
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT .pdf
 
Vip Female Escorts Noida 9711199171 Greater Noida Escorts Service
Vip Female Escorts Noida 9711199171 Greater Noida Escorts ServiceVip Female Escorts Noida 9711199171 Greater Noida Escorts Service
Vip Female Escorts Noida 9711199171 Greater Noida Escorts Service
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
 
NewBase 22 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi (AutoRe...
NewBase  22 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi  (AutoRe...NewBase  22 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi  (AutoRe...
NewBase 22 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi (AutoRe...
 
Sales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for Success
Sales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for SuccessSales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for Success
Sales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for Success
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfCatalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
 
Investment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementInvestment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio management
 
A.I. Bot Summit 3 Opening Keynote - Perry Belcher
A.I. Bot Summit 3 Opening Keynote - Perry BelcherA.I. Bot Summit 3 Opening Keynote - Perry Belcher
A.I. Bot Summit 3 Opening Keynote - Perry Belcher
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Keshav Puram 🔝 Delhi NCR
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: NOQX's $200k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: NOQX's $200k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: NOQX's $200k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: NOQX's $200k Pre-seed deck
 

International services marketing airtel - brand - personality 11.3.2015

  • 1. Services are now at the heart of everything that is marketed and customer and employee loyalty are at the heart of all service breakthroughs (Heskett, 1990). We live in the post- industrialization era, which rely more on the services and less on the industries. It contributes higher than agriculture and manufacturing industry as a percentage of GDP in the world (WorldBank, 2015). In middle and high-income countries share of the services industry dominates even when agriculture and industrial outputs are combined. This paradigm shift in economy in the past few decades explains consumer demand for services in various fields that includes hotel and tourism, health care, food, retail, information technology, telecommunications, entertainment, legal, consulting and many other areas. Services marketing, the need for concepts evolved in the academic literature since 1977 (Shostack, 1977). This has led to the development of many dimensions and perspectives that focused on intangible resources, relationships and value co-creation (Vargo & Lusch, 2004) ranging from integrative view of products and services to pure service dominant view of marketing. Broadly, Services can be classified into four categories as per Lovelock (1983). They are either directed at people’s bodies or minds or tangible possessions or intangible assets. Unlike products, nature of services is that production and consumption are simultaneous processes for the organization and the consumer. Service dominant logic can offer the solutions through intangible offering and can gain the competitive advantage through clear differentiation and positioning strategies which might be less easy with the physical products alone. In fact, more the dominance of services then more the complexity in terms of consistency, communications, quality, ownership, supply-demand synchronization, pricing and reproducibility (i.e., intangibility, heterogeneity, inseparability and perishability). This complexity deems some additional variables (in addition to 4P’s: Product, Place, Promotion and Price) to be incorporated in the marketing philosophy namely people, physical evidence and process for services. All these elements along with traditional marketing mix elements will be explored in detail for a telecommunication company “AirTel” which is serving millions of customers everyday.
  • 2. 1 Bharti AirTel Limited, an Indian MNC that has its presence felt in 20 countries is ranked 5th telecommunication service operator in the world (AirTel, 2014). Founded in 1995, the vision of the brand “AirTel” is to become the most loved brand by 2015. The company is known for pioneering its unique business model minutes factory to build its 1.85bn customer base worldwide profitably laying the road for many of its competitors to follow its core competency model. Although the company is an international one and offers multi-platform services in telecom, enterprise and digital TV, the focus here will be on telecommunication services in India. Telecommunication services can be regarded as merely service dominant along the Services continuum scale (Shostack, 1977). We examine how AirTel conveys its brand positioning and personality using Service branding model proposed by Berry (2000) and analyse how the brand differentiates its services to its target audience throgh its communications and operations activities. Various models like service blueprint, SERVQUAL attributes and gaps model have been used appropriately in evaluating the services and whereever necessary, recommendations for improving the brand positioning are also suggested alongside the discussion with relevance to the academic literature. Brand Positioning and Personality – AirTel: Brand personality assigns consumers meaning in which they can relate and effectively increase brand awareness and popularity. As described by Aaker (1996), brand personality builds the emotional relationship between the consumer and the brand and is very important in differentiating services (Zeithaml, 1981). The brand lends its appeal to the target audience through recognition (Malhotra, 1988; Sirgy, 1982) and helps to build trust and loyalty amongst them. As proposed by Berry (2000), the components and relationships of the service brand are the presented brand, brand awareness, external brand communications, brand meaning and customer experience as illustrated in the figure 1. Dotted lines show the secondary impact and the solid lines shows the main impact on the dimensions shown in the figure.
  • 3. 2 Figure 1. Berry’s (2000) Service branding model The logo of the brand has been redesigned in 2010 (EconomicTimes, 2010) to appeal to the target global younger consumers. The changed dark red background color is designed to refresh the brand to assign younger, energetic associations and to signify the heritage on a global level. It also indicate the core values of the brand like leadership, performance, dynamism and enthusiasm as this color has got resemblance with global recognizable brands like Coca-Cola and McDonald’s for example. The white color is the recognition for humility. The curved letter “a” is called the wave and highlights warm dynamic and friendly appeal of the brand repositioned to become the most lovable brand by 2015. The current tagline that the brand employs is “The Smartphone Network” to transit from a traditional model to a company dedicated for smartphone (Mankotia, 2014). AirTel’s brand name, logo, uniforms that employees wear and Servicescape contribute to visual identity in brand differentiation which has been acknowledged by several scholars (Aaker, 1996; Boyle, 1996; Kotler, 1973; Onkvisit & Shaw, 1989). Figure 2. AirTel brand current logo (Source: www.airtel.com )
  • 4. 3 Service companies have only cues such as service’s price and the physical appearance of the facilities (Zeithmal, 1981) and it is similar to the package of the physical product. Price comparison is easier than the physical evidence cues, which are quiet hard to be compared by the customers. AirTel’s physical evidence is linked to the organisation’s vision and goals. This so called Servicescape takes the role in the form of package, facilitator, socializer and differentiator as mentioned by Bitner (1992). There are three kinds of servicescape namely self-service, interpersonal and remote servicescape. Self-service affects only consumers who use the service. Interpersonal servicescape affects both the consumers and employees whereas a remote servicescape in which only the environment affects only the employees. In the interpersonal servicescape aspect, AirTel’s physical complexity is more elaborate, which facilitates the interaction between the employees and consumers to deliver its pre-paid, post-paid, data and digital TV services under one roof. The warm and cool interior facility design and lighting in the relationship center differentiates from the competitor’s physical appearance. This is the only tangible aspect among the five dimensions of service quality (i.e., SERVQUAL attributes – reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy and tangibles) as mentioned by Parasuraman (1993) to have a significant impact on the consumers’ perceptions of service quality (Bitner, 1992). It is also a proof of service delivery in relation to the price which determines the level of customer satisfaction. The AirTel iconic ringtone that was composed by music director A.R. Rahman is still being used by AirTel today in all its customer relationship centers, advertisements and also during the call waiting time for any query in the remote servicescape. This music is clearly a consistent socializing and differentiating element for the brand to convey its eternal youth identity through communicating the personality status. Positioning services effectively involve more than marketing efforts such as the designing the service blueprint and the process itself is the product (Heskett, 1990,p. 53). In the remote and self-service servicescape, AirTel is supported by IBM support processes and has good relationship with the company for integrating the customer facing process alongside all platforms. Examples can include customer SIM card activation time reduction from days to hours, customer self-service through USSD/SMS facility, web and interactive voice response system, generation of unbilled information to the postpaid customers via SMS. Although these support systems are invisible to the customer as seen in the service blueprint figure 3, the company integrates information from the websites, social media, retail outlet, advertising and promotion, billing to communicate the Service Quality Proposition (SQP) to the
  • 5. 4 customers in a seamless and flawless way (Srikapardhi, 2014). Websites today are very useful for consumers to find the information they needed and also is a very powerful judgmental tool for the Indian consumers to perceive the service quality in terms of competitive edge, efficiency, fulfillment and reliability (Santos, 2003; Zeithaml, et al., 1996). An examination of AirTel’s Servicescape (including e-servicescape like website) can be very useful in understanding consumers’ perception formation that can be used to position itself from the competition. This will be discussed with recommendations to improve the positioning of the brand. Figure 3. Service Blueprint – AirTel AirTel uses various platforms like advertising in radio, television, social media, news stories and signage consistently to provide tangible cues, capitalize on WOM, advertise to employees and create advertising continuity to make the service understood (Mortimer, 2002). The brand creates pervasiveness by making impossible for customers to get the advertisements unnoticed. AirTel’s ads scores reasonably well on the grounds of imagery and music. The communications that have been grasped by the consumers about the company like WOM and publicity are the most common forms of external brand communications (Berry, 2000; Hill & Gandhi, 1992). Advertising literature indicates that cognitive, emotion and experience are key intermediate advertising effects. AirTel recognizes this fact and incorporates intangibility and emotions in its external communications for the consumers to discern its brand identity. Also, the high quality service promise which is its functional core
  • 6. 5 protects itself from against the unlikely consumer experiences as suggested by Aaker (2004). External brand communications are moderately effective for AirTel because of the firm’s limited efforts to manage the internal marketing communications to the employees to deliver the promise as shown in the figure 4. An example is, facilitating internal channels of coordination between front end executives in relationship centers, retailers who sell the company products and back end support staff pays-off to reduce the gap between service delivery and customer expectations. Figure 4. Services Marketing triangle (Kotler, 1997) Consumer Service Experience: Service always comes with an experience (Carbone & Haeckel, 1994). Dr. Jai Menon (2007), Director of IT and Innovation, AirTel, said “Our new strategy is all about delivering a truly differentiated experience and having the flexibility to continually improve the customer experience”. AirTel’s advanced capabilities of integration enables to transform core aspects of customer experience. One of the examples is the ability to cut down the time required to activate the accounts by 90% through maximum efficiency. AirTel’s consumer experience encompasses every aspect of company’s offering such as customer care quality, advertising, servicescape, service features (not limited to Value-added features and 4G), connectivity, ease of use and reliability. The company also understands that secret to a good experience lies in embedding the core or fundamental value proposition in its offerings and not in the multiplicity of features as described by Meyer & Schwager (2007). As we have seen about advertising and servicescape above, the following will be addressed in context to operations or quality of services being offered by AirTel. The five key dimensions that is used to assess the service company are reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy and tangibles. It is a revised model by Parasuraman et al.,
  • 7. 6 (1993), which was based on a study on five service companies including a telecommunication firm. The five dimensions will be explained as follows with respect to AirTel, India. Tangibles: The Company uses modern equipment in the relationship centers including mobile handsets and kiosks that gives consumers a good perception about the brand. This element is very important in the emerging countries like India, where the consumers evaluate strongly based on the amount of sophisticated technology elements that is employed. Especially, the younger consumer segments has a positive affinity to the brand. Employee uniforms which are modestly formal and neat looking (not many service providers other than Vodafone and AirTel stresses so much importance on this), bill desks at touch points and overall visually appealing interior servicescape actually associates the brand meaning in the minds of the consumers. The company uses its campaign information on its floor walls in most of the relationship centers. Reliability: As noted through observation, Value added services (VAS) are the highest contributor of revenues for telecommunication companies in India including AirTel. The consumers’ service perception of VAS is more for Vodafone, and AirTel is trailing behind which is due to fact of lack of personalization, reliability and comfort in use attributes (Gupta & Nagpal, 2014). AirTel brand has been modestly reliable for more than a decade for its network clarity and customer care services as promised. This dimension has been the most important for the brand to communicate its consistency through keeping its promises, services delivered appropriately with provision and resolving the consumer problems. Consumers are also highly dependable on the company to resolve their problems. The reliability and trust factor is also amplified by the brand ambassadors with names of few like A.R. Rahman, cricket legend Sachin Tendulkar, Shah Rukh Khan from the company’s advertising strategies. Responsiveness: In telecommunication, responsiveness is communicated by the length of time customers wait in the relationship centers or in the customer care call(s) for assistance, promptness of answers to questions and the level of detailed attention to the problems and understanding of the issue.
  • 8. 7 Assurance: AirTel has sustainable high performance culture that assures the best innovative quality services available in the country at an affordable cost. Assurance is an important factor in delivering services especially in telecommunication queries where customers expect a level of technical expertise and courtesy from the customer care executives as well. Assurance creates customers confidence and is likely to be affected when the issue is repetitive in nature even after the query is thought to be solved by the customer care executive. In the digital world today, where people want to stay connected by every second, this makes customers perceive it as moderate risk if the communication fails and the feel of uncertainty might erode the customers’ loyalty and trust of the brand. Empathy: The brand deliver services with its individualised plans, for instance, “myPlan” in which customers can choose their proposition of talk time hours, mobile data, text messaging limit, STD calls with in the country and roaming plans. Understanding that India is a collectivist culture, the brand offers “One family one plan” to signify that this brand recognises the culture and family values and provides to fulfil the gap through offering uniquely in its first place. The Company empathizes with people in its promotion through emotional campaign like “Barriers break when people talk”. This makes the customers feel themselves unique and special.
  • 9. 8 Assessmentof Organisation’s activities and recommendations to improve AirTel’s brand positioning: Service Quality: AirTel is ranked 2nd amongst the most valuable Indian brands in 2014 and 1st in the telecommunication sector. Although, this is a credible result for an organisation that is operating for almost two decades, it is really essential for the brand to build its positioning for a sustainable competitive advantage and attain the personality status of the most loved brand by 2015. Based on observation and secondary data, recommendations will be made wherever necessary to improve its service quality to satisfy customers or exceed expectations. As illustrated by Parasuraman et al., (1985), SERVQUAL model is commonly used to assess the service quality. Figure 5 illustrates the SERVQUAL gaps model of Service quality. Figure 5. “SERVQUAL” Gaps model of Service quality (Parasuraman, et al., 1985)
  • 10. 9 Customer gap is the difference between perceptions and expectations of the customer (Parasuraman, 1993). Based on the observation, expectations from customers are to have a consistent pricing, clear communication messages and promises being delivered to them in a consistent manner. Price is an easy way to compare alternative services (Aaker, 1996) and on pricing, the company has changed its strategies from time to time which affect the service reliability dimension. For example, AirTel’s VoIP- voice over internet protocol service plan which was introduced by the company (Krishnamurthy & Abrar, 2014) to avoid the internet services cannibalizing the voice services revenue made customers dissatisfied with this move even though none of the competitors introduced a plan to provoke customers by charging consumers differently for using Skype or similar ones. Although this has been rolled back within few days, the perceived cause of events will influence the perceptions of customers’ satisfaction as well. Another example which may disrupt consumers’ perception is “AirTel’s 4G Plans are lower than 3G plans” (Mahajan, 2014) which might seem over delivering the promises but infact aggragating desired service levels by the current 3G consumers. It is the customers’ perceptions of service that determines the true brand values. Apart from the customer gap, there are four other gaps that might exist within the service organisation and hence referred to as provider gaps. They are knowledge gap, service design and standards gap, service performance gap and communications gap. Gap 1: Knowledge gap Employees’ lack of first-hand information about the services offered was observed during the conversation with the customer care executives on a query regarding automatic balance deduction from the virtual account. This might be due to the improper knowledge of employees who delivers the services or there is limited empowerment of the frontline personnel. This is also true in queries related to Value Added Services (VAS) queries where frontline executives facing customers directly can’t resolve the issue due to the insufficient authority provided to them but know a great deal about customers. The gap widens due to lack of upward communication to the management who can address it. Since Consumers experiences are collected at “touch points” (Meyer & Schwager, 2007), each touch point gives opportunities or challenges to the company to vary the expected and actual service levels to delight the customer or anything less. This understanding of customer experience requires capturing rich information across all customer interactions with the service provider and even other service providers that support the overall customer activity (Teixeira, et al.,
  • 11. 10 2012) and also must know to act when customers expereince a service failure. Technology must be used to build powerful relationship management and tailor the services uniquely to the individuals (Bitner, et al., 2010) Gap 2: Service design and standards gap Service encounters are much more than the point of staff-customer interactions, sometimes referred to as “moment of truth” or simply “customer contact” (Chase, 1981) and provide an opportunity for emotional engagement (Berry & Carbone, 2007). It has been observed during a tele conversation with the customer care executives that a customer who is waiting for a query to be resolved, is then enquired and diverted to the concerned technical team for resolution which is in total makes the wait time hectic for the customers. A key recommendation to address this issue is the adequate training of frontline customer contact staff with basic technical skills to use the technology as a customer-driven standard so that a significant amount of calls can be dealt by a single executive contact point for the customers. This facilitates measurement of service operations through customer defined service standards rather than company driven service standards and incorporating as a measure of hard standards in service blueprinting. This is expected to make changes in the overall turnaround time by the renovation in the service process design for the average call wait time and in turn reduce the service design and standards gap. In examining the company’s website, having an online chat seems to be a viable option that can be incorporated in the service blueprint to depict the possibility of serving the customer more effectively with the use of technology (Bitner, et al., 2010). Customers must be communicated how the progress might look like and the company must set goals and criteria to be examined at times. Gap 3: Service performance gap A good example of service performance gap is an issue (example) of delivering a promised service which is “100% bill guarantee”. It has been noted that a chunk of consumers complaining to the company for exaggerating the bill statements inaccurately in the post-paid usage and a few complaints related to the data services charges in the pre-paid service delivery. This underperformance of not living up to the promises might backfire what have been regularly promised to consumers through various channels of communications by the brand. AirTel needs to manage the customer expectation (CEM – Customer Experience Management) in delivering the services of this kind. It has been noted from many instances (Mouthshut, 2015) that the area that impacts most on the customer satisfaction is spontaneity
  • 12. 11 and coping of employee to the consumers’ problems in relevance to the service performance gap. Gap 4: Communications gap Communications gap exist in terms of poor process depiction to customers on process and physical evidence of touch points, inconsistency in updating information across relationship centers and in brand communications. Process depiction to the consumers via Service blueprint is missing in the relationship centers (physical evidence). For example, photographs or videos can be used to depict the process to the consumers who can understand how to get the query solved in a relatively easier way at all relationship centers. Inconsistency in regularly updating the information (i.e., tangibles) between the relationship centers was noted demographically. Although this might be due to the fact that customers don’t expect much from the relationship centers in the semi-urban areas, this might create a mixed perception of the brand in the consumers’ minds. Servicescape although more functional in its role, AirTel needs to have it incorporated in the facility design uniquely so that customers have the clear line of recognition of the brand from the competition (for example: Vodafone’s logo – red color background is also similar to AirTel, which is the second largest network operator in India and can disrupt the consumer perceptions in the brand recall and recognition). Renovating the evidence combines with clear presentation of the brand with an element of youth fashion will send clear external communication messages to the consumers as a good advertising strategy. Simply to put, Services are the way forward for companies to clearly differentiate their offerings in the marketplace because of its intangibility, heterogeneity, perishability and inseparability. AirTel conveys its brand personality as mentioned by Berry (2000) through the company’s presented brand, external brand communications, customer experience with the company, brand awareness and brand meaning. On Brand expression, the company is recommended to change its logo with a mixture of black and red instead of just red bacground to reduce the imitation cue of rival brand Vodafone and as a measure to increase its uniqueness. Brand’s advertising strategy of Airtel is a plausible one and it communicates the messages promptly to the consumers in all possible medium mainly via WOM because of its good service quality and loyal customer base. Logo, name and advertising are just the visible tip of the brand iceberg to signify “what the brand stands for”. For any brand to communicate “who we are” it must keep its promises by creating customer experiential
  • 13. 12 values such as service quality, customer relations, service recovery strategies, personnel and other operations. It is the later that creates brand loyalty and confidence. As the evaluation of consumer experience depends on the customer’s expectations and his/her interaction with the company’s offering in correspondence to the different moments of touch-points (Mouncey,2003), the brand should try to reduce the customer gap by focusing on its servicescapes for instance, on virtual servicescape, creation of interactive websites that are to the customers are very important in appealing to customers with rich content (eg: videos) as suggested by Luís, et al., (2013) to communicate the market leadership in its service offerings. Customer gaps can be addressed through consistency across all brand touch points like advertising, employee partners, social media, review sites, website, signage and WOM. Provider gaps can be reduced by interpreting customers’ expecations and customer activity through adequate market research, service operations by customer defined standards and appropriate physcial evidence including virutal servicescape i.e., 24 hour online chat via website, focus on customer relationship management through employee-technology job fit and manage the service expectations, service recovery strategies and communication strategies like upward communication and proper customer education through process depiction via service blueprinting in the relationship centers. A study suggests that Indian consumers are willing to spend more for good services (BestmediaInfo, 2014). This adds an argument for the brand to employ the recommendations to attain the desired brand personality status “to become the most loved brand by 2015”. As the saying goes “There is no business without emotions” and customer experience must be created in a way that will mutually benefit the company and the customer through an eternal relationship.
  • 14. 13 References: (2014), M., 2014. HDFC BankNamed India'sMostValuableBrand in BrandZ™ Ranking,asService Sector BrandsDominate- See moreat: http://www.millwardbrown.com/global- navigation/news/press-releases/full-release/2014/08/19/hdfc-bank-named-india's-most-valuable- brand-in-bran. [Online] Available at:http://www.millwardbrown.com/global-navigation/news/press-releases/full- release/2014/08/19/hdfc-bank-named-india's-most-valuable-brand-in-brandz-ranking-as-service- sector-brands-dominate [Accessed07 March 2015]. (2015), M., 2015. Airtel Mobile OperatorReviews. [Online] Available at:http://www.mouthshut.com/airtel [Accessed09 March 2015]. Aaker,D.,1996. Measuringbrandequityacrossproductsand markets. California management review, 38(3), pp.102-120. Aaker,D. A.,2004. Leveragingthe corporate brand. California managementreview , 46(3), pp.6-18. Airtel,2014. ManagementPresentationBhartiAirtel limited May 2014. [Online] Available at:http://www.airtel.in/wps/wcm/connect/7cb62734-9f86-4265-9da8- 6dccd8f37be1/Bharti-Management-Presentation_vfc- May+2014.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&CONVERT_TO=url&CACHEID=7cb62734-9f86-4265-9da8- 6dccd8f37be1 [Accessed22 February2015]. Alamro,Ahmed&Rowley,J.,2011. Antecedentsof brandpreference formobiletelecommunications services. Journalof Product&Brand Management, 20(6),pp.475-486. Berry,L. L., 2000. Cultivatingservice brandequity. Journalof theacademy of Marketing Science, 28(1), pp. 128-137. Berry,L. L. & Carbone,L.P., 2007. Buildloyaltythroughexperience management. Quality progress, 40(9), pp. 26-32. BestmediaInfo,2014. Indian customerwilling to pay premiumfor‘excellent service’: AmEx study. [Online] Available at:http://www.bestmediainfo.com/2014/10/indian-customer-willing-to-pay-premium-for- excellent-service-amex-study/ [Accessed08 March 2015]. Bitner,M. J.,1992. Servicescapes:the impactof physical surroundingsoncustomersandemployees. The Journalof Marketing, pp.57-71. Bitner,M. J.,Zeithaml,V.A.& Gremler,D.D., 2010. Technology’simpactonthe gaps model of service quality. Handbookof servicescience, pp. 197-218. Boyle,E.,1996. "Anexperimentinchangingcorporate image inthe financialservicesindustryinthe UK", Journal of. Journalof ServicesMarketing, 10(4), pp.56-69.
  • 15. 14 Carbone,L. P.& Haeckel,S.H.,1994. Engineeringcustomerexperiences. MarketingManagement, 3(3), pp.8-19. Chase,R. B.,1981. The customercontact approach to services:theoretical basesandpractical extensions. Operationsresearch, 29(4),pp.698-706. Corporation,I.,2007. Bharti growsata stunning paceby keeping its, New York: IBMCorporation 2007. EconomicTimes,T.,2010. Newlogo more global,youngerand aspirational:Sanjay Kapoor,CEO Bharti Airtel. [Online] Available at:http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-11-18/news/27612278_1_new- logo-symbol-ceo-bharti-airtel [Accessed22 February2015]. Gupta, G. & Nagpal,S.,2014. Value AddedTelecomServices:Examiningthe ImpactandLinkages. IM QUEST, 10(1), pp. 1-10. Haucap, J. & Ulrich, H., 2011. Consumerbehaviortowardson-net/off-netprice differentiation. TelecommunicationsPolicy, 35(4), pp.325-332. Heskett,J.L., 1990. Service breakthroughs. s.l.:SimonandSchuster. Hill,D.J. & Gandhi,N.,1992. Service Advertising:A Framework toItsEffectiveness. Journalof Services Marketing, 6(4),pp.63-76. Kotler,P.,1973. Atmosphericsasa marketingtool. Journalof retailing, 49(4), pp. 48-64. Kotler,P.,1997. Marketing Management:Analysis,Planning,Implementation,and Control. 9thed. s.l.:PearsonEducation. Krishnamurthy,K.&Abrar,P., 2014. Startupsworried aboutAirtel’sVoIPmove,despiterollback. [Online] Available at:http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/tech/tech-news/Startups-worried-about-Airtels- VoIP-move-despite-rollback/articleshow/45687438.cms [Accessed07 March 2015]. Lovelock,C.H.,1983. Classifyingservicestogainstrategicmarketinginsights. TheJournalof Marketing, pp.9-20. Luís, J. etal.,2013. Driversof in-groupandoutof-group. European Journalof Marketing, 47(7),pp. 1067-1088. Mahajan, A.C., 2014. Airtel Slashes4G Rates.Gets Cheaperthan 3G!. [Online] Available at:http://trak.in/tags/business/2014/11/26/airtel-4g-rates-slashed/ [Accessed08 March 2015]. Mahit, 2014. Airtel leadsthe leaguewhen it comesto Highest RuralSubscribersBase,forthe month of July 2014. [Online] Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-leads-highest-rural-subscribers-base-july2014/121813/ [Accessed27 February2015]. Malhotra,N. K.,1988. Self-conceptandproduct choice:anintegratedperspective. Journalof EconomicPsychology, 9(1),pp.1-28.
  • 16. 15 Mankotia,A.S., 2014. Airtel turning itself into a company builton and fora smartphonenetwork. [Online] Available at:http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2014-09- 03/news/53522512_1_smartphone-network-srinivasan-gopalan-bharti-airtel [Accessed25 February2015]. Menon,J.,2008. Bharti Airtel growsat a stunning paceby keeping its focuson the customer. [Online] Available at:www.ibm.com/services/us/.../tc_bharti_ariel_grows_odc03064-usen.pdf [Accessed23 February2015]. Meyer,C. & Schwager,A.,2007. Understandingcustomerexperience. Harvard businessreview, 85(2), p. 116. Mortimer,K.,2002. Integratingadvertisingtheorieswithconceptualmodelsof servicesadvertising. Journalof Services Marketing, 16(5),pp.460-468. Mouncey,P.,2003. BuildingGreatCustomerExperiences. InteractiveMarketing, 5(1),pp.93-95. Onkvisit,S.&Shaw,J. J.,1989. Service Marketing:Image,Branding,andCompetition. Business Horizons, 32(1), pp.13-18. Parasuraman,A.L. L. B. a. V.A. Z.,1993. More on improvingservice qualitymeasurement. Journalof retailing, 69(1), pp.140-147. Parasuraman,A.,Zeithaml,V.A.&Berry, L. L., 1985. A conceptual model of service qualityandits implicationsforfuture research. TheJournalof Marketing, pp.41-50. Reichheld,F.F.,2003. The One NumberYouNeedtoGrow. Harvard BusinessReview, 81(2), pp. 46- 55. Santos,J.,2003. E-service quality:amodel of virtual service qualitydimensions. Managing Service Quality:An InternationalJournal, 13(3),pp.233-246. Shostack,G. L., 1977. Breakingfree fromproductmarketing. TheJournalof Marketing, pp. 73-80. Shostack,G. L., 1984. DesigningServicesThatDeliver. Harvard BusinessReview, 133(February),p.9. Sirgy,M. J., 1982. Self-conceptinconsumerbehavior:A critical review. Journalof consumerresearch , 9(3), pp.287-300. Srikapardhi,2014. Airtel,IBM 2014 Deal – Whatis it all about:Our indepth Analysis. [Online] Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-ibm-2014-deal-what-is-it-all-about-our-indepth- analysis/115632/ [Accessed27 February2015]. Teixeira,J.etal.,2012. Customerexperiencemodeling:fromcustomerexperience toservice design. Journalof Service Management, 23(3),pp.362-376. Telecominfo,2013. VodafoneIndia and Idea OffersBetterFriendly Self CareServices Than Airtel. [Online] Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/vodafone-india-and-idea-offers-better-friendly-self-care- services-than-airtel-infographics/112313/ [Accessed08 March 2015].
  • 17. 16 TelecomInfo,2014. Airtel customersfeelcheated with misleading 3G rechargebenefiton its official portal.[Online] Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-cheating-customers/122963 [Accessed08 March 2015]. Telecominfo,2014. Airtel hikes it’s 2G Data packsfor Postpaid users,Now 2GBData CostRs.278 approx. [Online] Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-2g-data-pack-postpaid/122808/ [Accessed08 March 2015]. Telecominfo,2014. TT Analysis: 76% of subscribersare notwilling to switch to Airtel myPlan orIdea iPlan. [Online] Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/76subscribers-are-not-willing-to-switch-to-airtel-myplan-or- idea-iplan/127718/ [Accessed08 March 2015]. Telecominfo,2015. Airtel Web Based self care services forPrepaid CustomersNotreliable : Our Experience. [Online] Available at:http://telecomtalk.info/airtel-web-based-self-care-services-for-prepaid-customers-not- reliable-our-experience/114186/ [Accessed08 March 2015]. Uniyal,P.,2014. Can yourwifebe yourbossand cookat the sametime? Airtel ad confusesTwitterati, evokesmixed reaction. [Online] Available at:http://indianexpress.com/article/lifestyle/feelings/can-your-wife-be-your-boss-and- cook-at-the-same-time-airtel-ad-confuses-twitterati-evokes-mixed-reaction/ [Accessed08 March 2015]. Vargo,S. L. & Lusch, R. F.,2004. Evolvingtoa new dominantlogicformarketing. Journalof marketing, 68(1),pp. 1-17. WorldBank,2015. Growthof theService Sector. [Online] Available at:http://www.worldbank.org/depweb/english/beyond/global/chapter9.html [Accessed14 February2015]. Yadav, K,R. & Dabhade,N.,2013. Impactof service qualityoncustomersatisfactionof mobileusers: a case studyof Airtel. InternationalJournalof InnovativeResearch and Studies, pp.139-163. Zeithaml,V.A.,1981. Howconsumerevaluationprocessesdifferbetweengoodsandservices. Marketing of services, 9(1), pp.25-32. Zeithaml,V.A.,Berry,L.L. & Parasuraman,A.,1996. The behavioral consequencesof servicequality. the Journalof Marketing, 60(2),pp.31-46.