This workshop helps students get to grips with what it means to be a Master’s student by considering questions such as:
•What is the difference between undergraduate and Master’s level work?
•What might you need to do differently and how might you adapt?
•What do markers expect from Master’s level writing?
We will also focus on developing critical reading and writing skills, and consider academic writing style.
1. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
The Writing Development Centre
Robinson Library
An introduction to writing at
Master’s level
Contact: wdc@ncl.ac.uk
2. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Part One: What is a Master’s and what is expected of
Master’s students?
3. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Session outline
Clarifying expectations of Master’s level study: what is the
‘step up’?
Identifying strategies to help make the transition and
manage your workload
Focusing on critical reading and writing techniques
4. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
What is expected of Master’s students?
Working in pairs, consider the following:
What is a Master’s for?
How do you think a Master’s will differ from an
undergraduate degree?
5. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
What is a Master’s for?
Preparation to enter a profession: academic research (PhD
study), industry, business, etc.
To understand how knowledge is constructed in your
subject (and how you might contribute to this)
To understand and evaluate the relationships between
theory and practice in your discipline
6. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
How does a Master’s differ?
Differs in many ways
Not just a continuation of undergraduate study: not just a
case of ‘more of the same’
8. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
How does a Master’s differ?
Greater level of criticality
Evaluate the extent to which theories can be mapped onto reality
How is knowledge constructed in your subject? What do we know?
How do we know it? How sure are we that we know it? What don’t
we know?
Identifying gaps in the existing research and setting your own
research questions in order to address them.
9. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
How does a Master’s differ?
Identity
Becoming an independent researcher
Moving towards a professional identity
Training to become a researcher/practitioner: your work may be
read differently. Higher expectations re. referencing, avoiding
plagiarism and accurate writing?
Becoming part of an academic community
Discussing ideas with fellow researchers (including your tutors!)
Different working relationships with tutors?
10. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
How does a Master’s differ?
Intensity and workload
PGT courses are often the most demanding and intense, and have
the steepest learning curve
May involve adjusting to a new teaching and learning style
More reading and research
Multiple assessment deadlines
11. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Smoothing the transition: useful strategies
Creating a planner with an overview of the year
Avoiding spending too much time on one assignment
Never too early to start thinking about your dissertation:
keep an ideas file
Give yourself time to adjust
13. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Why is being critical important?
Example tutor comments on Master’s level assignments:
“Too descriptive”
“More analysis needed”
“Needs less description, more critique”
“This is descriptive rather than analytical”
“You have told me what the theory is rather than how you evaluate
it”
14. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Defining criticality
Skim the questions on your handouts
Focus on the question most appropriate to your discipline
and consider the following:
What are students being asked to do?
How are they being encouraged to demonstrate criticality? What
does this even mean?!
15. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Defining criticality
Briefly describe a method for measuring
the hardness of a metal. To which
important engineering property does
the hardness relate? What are the
advantages of the hardness test?
Compare and contrast two
abstract works of your choice in
terms of their form and
significance.
Critically assess the claim that civil
servants, and not politicians, drive the
integration process in the Commission
and Council of Ministers.
What is heritage and, if you
believe in preserving it, who
should pay?
16. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
What does being ‘critical’ mean?
Not just describing theories, but considering how they can be
applied (and the implications of applying them)
Considering the relationship between theory and practice
Not just learning or presenting information but ‘doing something
with it’: selecting, ranking, comparing, evaluating
Having a particular stance or viewpoint; developing arguments
Justifying and/or supporting this viewpoint: explanations,
reasons, evidence
Engaging in existing critical/theoretical debates, rather than just
reporting them
Being objective: being critical does not mean being negative
Asking questions: not taking information sources at ‘face value’
17. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Reading critically
Use the extract on your handouts as a starting point or
‘trigger’
List all of the critical questions it is useful to ask of your
source material: think about every stage of the reading
process
18. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Critical Questions
Stage One: being selective and getting focused
Is this relevant?
What am I looking to get from this?
Stage Two: establishing credibility
Who is the author?
What is their background?
Where was this text published?
19. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Critical Questions
Stage Three: identifying the text’s aims and objectives
What is the purpose of this text?
Who is the target audience?
20. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Critical Questions
Stage Four: looking beyond the information presented
What is the text’s main claims?
How are they argued?
Are there any gaps, leaps in logic, and/or inconsistencies?
How is evidence used and interpreted?
Are the conclusions consistent with the evidence presented?
21. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Critical Questions
Stage Five: Your own agenda
How are you going to use this source?
How does it fit into your own work?
22. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Writing critically
What does critical writing look like?
How can we signal criticality in our writing?
23. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Writing critically: editing for
criticality
Skim the extracts on your handouts (both taken from the
same essay)
Is this writer sufficiently critical? Think about their use of
language, as well as the points they make. Are there any
points that could be developed? If so, how might they
develop these?
24. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Editing for criticality: looking for the
‘gaps’
Reviewing your own work is not just about checking for
spelling, punctuation and grammatical errors
Writing is dialogue not monologue
Have you answered all of your reader’s questions?
25. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
Summary
Critical reading is about asking questions
Critical writing is about anticipating and addressing
readers’ questions
26. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
The Writing Development Centre
Develop your academic skills
Take effective notes
Think critically
Interpret essay questions
Understand assessment
criteria
Read efficiently
Argue convincingly
Plan assignments
Manage your time
Express ideas confidently
• Revise effectively
• Critically review literature
• Structure essays
• Use drafting & editing
techniques
• Make the most of lectures
& seminars
• Manage your dissertation
or PhD thesis
• Avoid plagiarism
• Improve your exam
technique
27. Writing Development Centre
University Library
facebook.com/NUlibraries
@ncl_wdc
The Writing Development Centre
Level 2, Robinson Library
Undergraduate - Masters - PhD
Our team of expert tutors offers:
- Individual tutorials
- Workshops
- Online resources
Visit us online to book: http://www.ncl.ac.uk/students/wdc/
HASS – SAgE - FMS
Editor's Notes
Bloom’s Taxomony: Cognitive Domain (1956) as revised by Anderson & Krathwohl (2001)
Ask the audience first!
Okay, so we’ve read some texts critically: now we have to turn those critical thoughts into critical writing/ But what does critical writing look like? How do we signal criticality in our writing? How do we know when we have been critical enough?