The article explores the evolving concept of digital privacy, debating whether it is a right or a privilege, while addressing internet surveillance and the implications of a 'pay-for-privacy' system. It highlights John Dewey's vision of privacy and its crucial role in protecting individuals' rights, dignity, and freedoms in a complex digital landscape. Concerns are raised about a proposed pay-for-privacy model that may perpetuate power imbalances and encourage mass data collection despite users' financial contributions for privacy.