1. 1
Some recent SAVvy Engineering projects include the following;
Advanced Burner Technologies and Nagel Rice & Mazie
Expert witness in litigation involving contract for low NOx burners.
Contacts: Joel Vatsky 908-470-0470 and Jay Rice 975-535-3100
American Electric Power Service Corporation
Annually renewed contract to provide engineering design input and testing
technical support for all combustion related NOx control projects.
Design and implementation of OFA system (including cyclone burner
modifications), for Indiana and Michigan Power’s Tanners Creek Unit 4,
500 MW supercritical cyclone fired unit. Achieved approximately 80%
reduction in full load NOx emission rate.
Design and implementation of OFA system and burner zone
modifications for Kentucky Power’s Big Sandy Unit 1, 265 MW opposed
wall, pulverized coal fired unit. Unit achieves an additional 30%
reduction in NOx emissions. Riley Power’s CCV low NOx burners
installed in 1998. Project also included development and application of
hopper purge air.
Design and implementation of OFA system (including cyclone burner
modifications), for Columbus and Southern Power’s Conesville Units 1
and 2, 2x125 MW cyclone fired units. Achieved approximately 65%
reduction in full load NOx emission rate.
Design and implementation of burner modifications for Indiana and
Michigan Power’s Tanners Creek Units 1-3 (2x150 MW and 1x200
MW), Ohio Power’s Philip Sporn Units 1-4 (4x150 MW), and
Appalachian Power’s Kanawha River Units 1and 2 (2x200 MW) and
Clinch River Units 1-3 (3x200 MW). All are roof-fired steam generators,
originally designed by B&W. Original low NOx combustion system was
designed and patented while an AEP employee. Recent modifications
were to accommodate deeper staging levels for further NOx emission rate
reductions.
Provide technical review of Alstom LNCFS Level II NOx control
installation for Columbus and Southern Power’s Conesville Unit 4, 800
MW.
Developed minimal cost cyclone scroll burner modifications, including
CFD modeling supervision, to mitigate carbon in flyash and carry-over of
granular ash particles to electrostatic precipitator at Ohio Power’s
Kammer Units 1-3, 3x210 MW front wall cyclone fired. Data to date
indicates that LOI reduced by a third at consistent cyclone staging and
NOx emissions. Granular ash carry-over has been reported to be minimal
and slag coating within the cyclone barrels has been notably improved.
On-site technical and analytical support of NOx and combustion
optimization efforts at AEP’s eastern fleet, including cyclone fired units
and pulverized coal fired units with Riley Power CCV, Foster Wheeler
CF/SF and CF/IFS, B&W XCL-hybrid, and in-house designed roof-fired
2. 2
low NOx combustion systems, with and without OFA and on a range of
eastern bituminous and western sub-bituminous coals.
On-site technical and analytical support of NOx and combustion
optimization efforts at AEP’s western fleet, including pulverized coal
fired units with Foster Wheeler CF/SF and CF/IFS, ABT Opti-flow and
T-fired low NOx combustion systems, with and without OFA with an
emphasis on slagging control with western sub-bituminous coals.
Contact: John J. Letcavits 614-716-3287
Bechtel Power
Technical support for burner modifications at Louisville Gas & Electric’s
Trimble County Unit 2 to alleviate burner deposition and coking. Effort
expanded to duct modifications to produce improved secondary and primary air
flow measurement capabilities, reduce pressure drop, improve flow distributions
and develop operational changes to mitigate furnace exit gas temperature
excursions and improve fuel flexibility.
Contact: Mel Watkins 240-793-4490
Cinergy (Now Duke)
Contracted to provide assistance regarding low NOx burners on Miami Fort Unit
7.
Contacts: Doug Ginn 513-313-5248, Chris Huber or Marty Schafer 812-949-
6448 or Jason Clanin 513-467-5874
Dayton Power & Light
Contracted to provide combustion, fuel and steam generator island oversight and
support for the DP&L coal fired fleet. Projects have included fuel switching,
low NOx combustion system retrofits, and operational modifications to increase
unit turndown capabilities. Pulverizer modifications to improve air flow control
and pulverizer turn-down without need for supplemental fuels. Combustion
testing and evaluations for optimized efficiencies and emission controls. Air
heater air and gas side leakage testing and equipment analyses. Evaluation and
development of alternatives for gas temperature control for selective catalytic
reduction catalyst operation. Modification of pulverizers, coal feeders and
primary air flow indication. Also intimately involved in renewable energy
projects, including biomass co-firing, CO2 sequestration demonstration projects,
and the burning of engineered fuels.
Contact: Mark Least 937-549-2641 (ext. 5817)
Electric Power Research Institute
Contracted to support the efforts of the Waterwall Wastage Interest Group and
the Pulverizer Interest Group.
Contacts: Anthony Facchiano 650-855-2494 and Jose Sanchez 650-855-2580
3. 3
FMC Corporation
Design modifications provided for both Westvaco and Granger facilities to
improve NOx emission controls without detrimental impact to CO emissions for
industrial MACT compliance.
Contact: Kelly Radtke 307-872-2244
Grand Haven Board of Light and Power
Initially contracted to design an overfire air system for Sims Unit 3 to address
Title IV requirements in 2000. Later (2003) contracted to evaluate bid
specifications and bids to upgrade milling system, burners and advanced overfire
air installations. Also hired in 2004/2005 to review post installation design and
testing efforts for potential deficiencies in design details. Flaws in OFA duct
details found to introduce excessive pressure drop. Primary air fans also
determined to be operating near peak of performance curve, creating
considerable flow sensitivity to pressure fluctuations.
Contact: Daniel Bush 616-842-6355
Hoosier Energy Cooperative
Proposed combustion modifications to mitigate CO emissions and improve NOx
control at Merom Station.
Adjustments to burners to improve oil lighter and flame scanner operation and
improve combustion efficiency at Ratts Station.
Contact: Stephan Martin 812-935-4709
Indianapolis Power & Light
Support of legal matters involving pulverizer puffs at South Harding Street
Station. Update/develop standard operating practices for pulverizer related
operation.
Contact: Norman (Tom) Funk, Krieg Devault Legal, 317-636-4341
LP Amina
Providing technical support and product development for LP Amina in China for
application of NOx emission reductions and performance enhancements.
Projects to date have included YiXing Units 8 and 9 separated overfire air
addition and burner modifications, ShaoGuan Unit 10 and XingTai separated
overfire air addition and burner modifications. Development of static external
classifier for improved efficiency and low differential pressure on ball tube mill
applications (patent pending). Development of new static classifier design for
vertical spindle mills to provide improved classifier efficiency and reduced
differential pressure (patent pending). Linking of calcium carbide and electric
energy production utilizing cyclone furnaces (patent pending).
Contact: William Latta 86 10 64107220
4. 4
Nalco-MobotecUSA Inc.
Contracted to evaluate the impacts of staging and the application of Nalco-
MobotecUSA’s ROFA system on the burner zone combustion and provide
options to mitigate any negative impacts for Allegheny Power’s Armstrong
Station, Nevada Power’s Reid Gardner Unit 4, Progress Energy’s Lee Unit 2 and
Bremo Bluff Unit 4, Hoosier Energy’s Ratts Station, AES’s Beaver Valley Units
2-4, Minnesota Power And Light’s Boswell Energy Center Units 1 and 2, Basin
Electric’s Leland Olds Station, Smurfit-Stone Container Corporation’s
Ontonagon Unit 1, Rochester Public Utility’s Silver Lake Unit 4, BOT
Elektownia Opole S.A.’s Unit 3 and others.
Contacts: Jamie Fessenden 925-935-2500 (ext. 17), Mark Shilling 919-291-1216
or Dr. Brian S. Higgins 919-465-3830
NiSource (NIPSCo)
Review burner and OFA design provided by Burns & McDonnell and Power &
Industrial for R.M.Schahfer Generating Station Unit 15. Provided
recommendations for burner modifications and OFA system to provide estimated
5-10 and 30% incremental reductions in NOx emissions, respectively. Also
reviewed SNCR trim provided by Fuel Tech and proposed testing to further
optimize.
Contact: John Loden 219-956-5115
Reaction Engineering International
Involved with several projects involving the CFD modeling of steam generators
for the purpose of reducing emissions and/or erosion. Provided input into
appropriate modeling inputs and evaluation of modeling results. Supported
development and application of overfire air to Allegheny Energy’s Willow Island
Unit 2, cyclone fired unit.
Contacts: Bradley Adams 801-364-6925 (ext. 18), Marc Cremer 801-364-6925
(ext. 14) or Kevin Davis 801-364-6925 (ext. 23)
Recycled Energy Development (RED)
Investigated cyclone fired units at Kodak Park, Rochester, NY and provided
recommendations to improve unit operations and turn-down capability.
Contact: Eric Gottung 630-590-6045
Tennessee Valley Authority
Performed technical evaluation of Paradise Unit 3 cyclone operation and OFA
system to determine needs to further reduce NOx emissions while mitigating
furnace corrosion potentials.
Contact: Forrest Cunningham 370-476-4068
5. 5
Other less recent projects have included:
Arizona Public Service (1999)
Four Corners Unit 2 opacity ascendances due to combustion modifications:
severe levels of unburned carbon in ash particularly during load cycling was
producing very dark stack plume, visible for miles. This problem was attributed
to the operation of the milling system producing end to end flow swings. This
coupled with the segregation of the mill ends to the left and right side of the units
during the burner modifications was creating corresponding excess air swings
left to right on the unit. The rich conditions that resulted produced unburned
char in the flue gas. With no electrostatic precipitator and the wet scrubber’s
ineffectiveness in collecting the carbon, the dark plume conditions were
produced. SAVvy Engineering was contracted to help evaluate the combustion
problem and adjust burners to help mitigate the problem. Elevating the excess
air in anticipation of load swings was recommended as a short term measure.
Restoration of the milling system to help mitigate end to end flow swings from
the ball tube mill were included in long term recommendations. This included
restoration of heated air to the pocket/overshot feeders to minimize coal
caking within the feeders,
restoring the inlet crushers and pre-dryer and/or adding specified
perforated inlet plates to the primary air supply ducts to improve
measurement and balance of primary airflow to the two ends of the mill’
upgrade the original heart style classifier to centrifugal classifiers, and
restore original coal conduit layout that blends any flow mal-distribution
from a mill within the furnace.
Contacts: Dennis Delgrosso 602-371-7260 or Duane V. Pilcher 505-598-8406
Consumers Energy (1999-2001)
Contracted to provide technical support to Consumer Energy’s Title I NOx
Compliance efforts. Scope of efforts were expanded into providing project
engineering support for specific efforts related to B&W, Mitsui Babcock and
Alstom scopes of supply, as well as, Black & Veatch balance of plant efforts for
the Campbell Station.
Contacts: Jim Pomaranski or Brian Low 616-738-3499
Michigan Municipal Electric Association (2000-2001)
Contracted to provide technical support to the members of MMEA in their Title I
compliance planning efforts as they pertained to both combustion related NOx
emission controls and post combustion SNCR and SCR options. This included
evaluation of the combined generating assets of the MMEA members to
determine most cost effective compliance strategies and benefits potentially
available through combined compliance efforts.
Contact:
6. 6
American Electric Power (2000-2002)
Provided technical support for counsel representing AEP versus EPA in
litigation. Contact: Janet J. Henry 614-716-1000