1) Die wear from abrasion and adhesion is the most frequent cause of part quality issues in hot forming processes like forging, extrusion, and rolling. Mechanical fatigue, plastic deformation, and thermal fatigue are also common issues.
2) Catastrophic die failure poses the most severe risk, followed by part defects and different types of die breakage.
3) Proper die material selection and coatings can improve die life by increasing hardness, wear and fatigue resistance at high temperatures. Process factors like temperature control and lubrication also impact die life.
2. Hot Forming Processes
In hot forming, the work-piece is heated above
its recrystallization temperature thus avoiding
strain hardening.
Types of hot forming processes
• Hot Forging
• Hot Extrusion
• Hot Rolling
3. Different causes of die wear
Causes
Wear
Abrasive
Adhesive
Corrosive
Erosive
Fatigue
Mechanical
Thermal
Catastrophic
Fracture
Extreme Thermal
shock
Extreme
mechanical strains
Poor material
properties
Poor die design
4. Wear Mechanisms
• Abrasive wear: occurs when a hard rough surface slides
across a softer surface. Two modes of abrasive wear are
known as two-body and three-body abrasive wear.
• Corrosive Wear: loss of materials due to the electrochemical
attack.
5. • Adhesive wear: Micro-junctions caused by welding between
the opposing asperities on the rubbing surfaces of the
counter bodies.
• Erosive wear: Impingement of particles (solid, liquid or
gaseous), which remove fragments of materials from the
surface due to momentum effect.
6. HOT FORGING
Main Cause/Factor Effect on Part
Die Wear Out-of-tolerance, inferior appearance
Thermal Fatigue Surface roughening, inferior appearance
Plastic Deformation Out-of-tolerance
Die Breakage Production stoppage
Part Defects Inferior appearance, out-of-tolerance
Effect of main causes on part quality
7. Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
Factor
Die Wear
Die Breakage (Mechanical
Fatigue)
Plastic Deformation
Thermal Fatigue
Part Defects
Die Breakage (Catastrophic
Failure)
Rank
1
2
3
4
4
4
Factor
Die Breakage
(Catastrophic Failure)
Part Defects
Die Breakage
(Mechanical Fatigue)
Plastic Deformation
Thermal Fatigue
Die Wear
Factors ranked according to frequency Factors ranked according to severity
8. Die Life in Hot forging
• Hot work die steels are used due to their ability to retain their hardness at
elevated temperatures with sufficient strength and toughness to
withstand the stresses that are imposed during forging.
• The property of the die materials can be locally influenced by the surface
engineering techniques such as heat treatments and surface coating
techniques.
• Molybdenum increases resistance to thermal softening, vanadium
improves wear and thermal fatigue characteristics.
• Chromium hot work steels retain their hardness up to 425 °C, tungsten hot
work steels retain their hardness up to 620°C and molybdenum based hot
work steels is in between that of chromium based and tungsten based hot
work die steels.
9. Hot Extrusion
• Extreme temperatures due to heat
transfer between the dies and work
piece.
• The three most commonly reported
modes of die failure are fatigue based
fracture, wear and plastic deformation/
deflection.
10. Failure modes of extrusion dies
• With the large number of sharp corners,
projections and protrusions, slots and
grooves, hollow profiles, fatigue-based
failures (both thermal and mechanical)
the principal failure mode.
• Continually repeated friction between the
extremely hard aluminum-oxide layer on
the billet and the iron-oxide layer at the
bearing surface, and the repeated
renitriding during die maintenance cycles,
wear at the die land should be the likely
second major failure mode.
• The elevated temperatures and pressures
involved, and the necessity of relatively
high extrusion speeds aimed at higher
productivity, plastic deformation and
deflection of critical sections should
closely follow the other two failure
modes.
11. Hot Rolling
• In continuous hot rolling process, billets are processed into rods with
acceptable dimensional tolerance as they pass through the rolling stands,
with the cross sectional shape being progressively altered by the roll
groove.
• The abrasive-wear theory has been generally applied to the die-wear
mechanism in various metals forming process.
Operational factors
• Overloading
• Insufficient stock removal
• Thermal stresses due to insufficient roll
cooling
• Severe bruising of rolls
• Mill chatter, improper crowning and
mechanical alignment problems
• Sharp temperature gradient on the surface
of the rolls (e.g. near strip edge)
• Pickling quality of hot rolled coil
Manufacturer’s factors
• Non metallic inclusions
• Heat treatment faults such as
poor carbide morphology, coarse
martensite, retained austenite
and residual stress
12. Modeling
• Model proposed by Archard is based on the assumption that wear is
proportional to the contact pressure and sliding length of the die material.
This model is presented in the following formula
Where: dV is the wear volume , dp is contact load , dL is the sliding length and H
is tool hardness and k is experimental constant.
dV = k
𝑑𝑝.𝑑𝐿
𝐻
13. Conclusions
• According to Frequency Die wear (Abrasive & Adhesive Mostly) is prominent
factor. Following to this Mechanical Fatigue, Plastic Deformation, Thermal Fatigue,
Part Defects and Catastrophic failure.
• According to severity catastrophic failure is prominent factor. Following to this Part
Defects, Mechanical Fatigue, Plastic Deformation, Thermal Fatigue, Die Wear.
• Factors such as thermal expansion coefficient and thermal conductivity also affect
the die life.
• The dies should also have adequate toughness and fatigue resistance.
• To keep uniform exit cross-sectional area during hot rolling process considering roll
wear, To predict the wear profile of roll for round-oval and oval round passes in hot
rolling process, a modified Archard’s wear model has been proposed.
14. References
• A. F. M. Arif, A. K. Sheikh, S. Z. Qamar, “A Study of die failure mechanisms in aluminum
extrusion”, Journal of Material Processing Technology 134 (2003), 318-328.
• Dong-Hwan Kim, Byung-Min Kim and Youngseog Lee, “Adjustment of Roll Gap for the
Dimension Accuracy of Bar in Hot Bar Rolling Process”, International Journal of the Korean
Society of Precision Engineering, Vol. 4, No. 1, January 2003, 56-62.
• Mayur Deshpande, Dr. Taylan Altan, “Selection of die materials and surface treatments for
increasing die life in hot and warm forging”, The Ohio state University.
• Y. Mae, P. Poonnayom, and A. Wongkrajang, “Wear Mechanism of Hot Forging Die from the
Viewpoint of Diffusion”, Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance, Volume 18(1)
February 2009, 16-20.
• D.H. Kim, H.C. Lee, B.M. Kim, K.H. Kim, “Estimation of die service life against plastic
deformation and wear during hot forging processes”, Journal of Material Processing
Technology 166 (2005), 372-380.