The document provides inspection details for a green color double net chop saw across 4 trials. Key parameters inspected include thickness, weight, fiber distribution, bore size, straightness of rotation, out of balance, and vibration. Results are reported for each trial as well as min, max, and mean values. Overall, the saw performed well with minimal variation across trials and parameters meeting or close to specifications.
2. APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR
OK 159 272 298 392 279 276 291 302 355 305 329 284
Hold/AUD 3 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 0
Rejected 0 1 2 6 0 8 2 6 5 5 5 2
Incoming RM Inspection FY 22-23
159
272
298
392
279 276
291
302
355
305
329
284
3
0
1 1
0 0
1 1
0
1
0 0
0
1
2
6
0
8
2
6
5 5 5
2
0
4
8
12
16
20
24
28
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR
OK Hold/AUD Rejected
3. Process Control- Blend Analysis FY 22-23
APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB Mar
OK 59 82 52 85 61 54 0
107 113
127 98 112
NOT OK 1 0 2 3 1 0 0
6 3
4 1 0
1 0 2 3 1
0 0
6 3 4 1 0
59
82
52
85
61
54 57
107
113
127
98
112
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB Mar
NOT OK OK
4. New Test for Determination of Corrosion resistivity of Bush
• Bush from all supplier kept in 100ml of water, 35g/L NaCl &
0.1N NaOH Std solution .
• Visual inspection done at every 24 hrs till 72 hrs for all at RT.
• 35g/L NaCl Solution :- 3.5 gm of salt has been dissolved & volume
makeup to 100ml volumetric flask with water .
• 0.1N NaOH Solution :- 400 mg of NaOH flake has been dissolved &
volume makeup to 100ml volumetric flask with water
• 100ml of Normal Water has been taken for water impact.
5. Start Date 12/12/2022,11:00 A.M.
Test Toatl Hrs :-100 hrs.
Departement :- kit section
Close Date 12/16/2022, 3:00 P.M. Product test lab SST
1. Part No. : Tushar Auto
2. Part Name : GRINDING WHEEL Bush
3. Customer : CUMI
4. Process : ZINC BLUE PASSIVATION
5. Qty. : 5 NOS.
6. Result : S. No. Property Specification Actual
1.
Corrosion Protection as per
ASTM B 117
Red Rust 72hrs min
Part is ok, No red rust found
@100 hrs than test stopped.
7. Conclusion : Part is ok test stopped after @100 hrs.
Before Test After Test
Corrosion Test Report (at TIDC)- Tushar Auto
6. Start Date 12/12/2022,11:00 A.M.
Test Toatal Hrs :- 84 hrs.
Department :- kit section
Close Date 12/15/2022, 11:00 P.M. Product test lab SST
1. Part No. : SB Industries
2. Part Name : GRINDING WHEEL Bush
3. Customer : CUMI
4. Process : ZINC BLUE PASSIVATION
5. Qty. : 5 NOS.
6. Result : S. No. Property Specification Actual
1
Corrosion Protection as
per ASTM B 117
Red Rust @72hrs min
Part is ok, Red rust found @84
hrs than test stopped.
7. Conclusion : Part is ok test stopped after @84 hrs.
Before Test After Test
Corrosion Test Report- SB Industries
7. 7
Salt spray Test
After 30 hrs- Bush rusted After 72 hrs- Bush rusted After 72 hrs- Bush not rusted
Supplier- SB industries Supplier- SB industries Supplier- XXXX
Inference- Bush supplied from SB industries failed Salt spray test, Inferior quality of coating is observed in SB industries
compared to supplier XXXX
9. STD CRCA BUSH
(TUSHAR)
CRCA BUSH- TUSHAR
CRCA BUSH
SB
CRCA BUSH
SB
CRCA BUSH
SB
Difference in shining appearance
Appearance Comparison
10. 10
SB Bush – Rough surface finishing
Deformed coating at the edges
Tushar Bush – Mirror like finishing
At the face
At the edge
Micro-structural Analysis- CRCA Bush
11. Taper Gauge for ID measurement
15-30mm GFD ID measurement by taper gauge.
Before:-
GFD ID measurement used to be done by using venire calipers.
Accuracy dependent on operator skills.
Used to get variation in measurement
After:-
Taper gauge with 0.1mm (15-30mm range) taken for GFD ID
measurement
Accuracy not much dependent on operator skills.
Used to get no variation in measurement.
Easy & fast method.
Fit for all of our 4”-14” GFD’s.
Before After
12. 123 x 23 BPS (85 GSM) -14o14
Problem Description in 123x23mm BPS (CG -85)
• Baking fleece is not sticking properly to the poly.
• During operation, backing is coming out from BPS
• Also mix is filtering out through BPS during molding.
High density baking Low density baking
Low Density fleece (204
mg)
High Density fleece
(284mg)
• Baking fleece is not sticking properly to the poly.
• fleece quality is not consistent throughout the lot.
• We find two type of baking fleece (say high density & low density)
• There is wt. variation in fleece (123x23mm)
• Generally low wt. fleece is creating mix filtration issue in all sizes.
S No. Fleece Wt (in mg)
1 257
2 276
3 284
4 204
5 188
13. #1: VELVET PAPER GFDs
ACTION PLAN
1. Sourced new Velvet paper of higher GSM and better consistency – current velvet paper is 20gsm quality, we have now
purchased heavier GSM (25) which is in line with Chinese suppliers – 25 December 2022
Update: The new velvet paper sourced from Supreme Industries was rejected by our team during trials (attached in email).
After trying three suppliers from India, we have concluded the quality is consistently below par from all. Hence, we have
ordered trial lot of fleece paper from China along with our rovings which will arrive at our factory in the first week of February.
1. Providing refresher training to Coating & Lamination operators – 12 December 2022.
DESCRIPTION OF COMPLAINT
Velvet paper lamination quality is inconsistent and there are GFDs with tearing /
loose fleece.
Velvet paper is inconsistent and has density variation.
14. #2: HARDNESS / SOFTNESS IN FABRIC
DESCRIPTION OF COMPLAINT
Variation in fabric stiffness. Hard fabric leads to bend issue and extremely soft fabric leads to sticky GFD issue.
ACTION PLAN – target date 15 February 2022
• Variation in fabric stiffness is an inherent property of the product. It is affected by various parameters – coating
speed, coating temperature, ambient humidity, ambient temperature and resin formulation.
• Our resin formulation is adjusted seasonally based on our historic experience and we are not facing any issues on
that front. Based on our analysis, the variation is occurring due to variation in coating speed & temperature.
• We have a reference chart for Speed & Temperature based on which the machine is operated. We also have
installed a data logger which measures the zonal temperature inside the Coating oven.
• However, we do not have the current facility to get complete realtime data of the set point vs live data, due to
which any operator adjustments or machine fluctuations cannot be captured in realtime. The same is captured
post process through the current data logger.
• To have better control on the same, our team is working on a realtime data logger monitoring solution (PLC to
HMI) wherein the live speed and temperature can be captured and cross referenced with the set parameters.
Currently. this is being done manually. By automating this process we will improve our process and create higher
operator accountability.
15. CAPA REPORT - RESITEX
Awarness training provided to all
checking
Sample cutting in coating
for Resin content as SOP
Cutting sample area punched in disc punching process
16. Drop Test for carton box
Side -1
Side -2
Drop 1 Impact Drop 2 Impact Drop 3 Impact
Initial
Box has been dropped freely from a height of 100 cm & impact has been observed.
18. Parameter Spec (ABR) ABR 24 GBW 24
Appearance - Dark brownish Whitish
LUX VALUE Min 600 Lux 1050, 900, 800 880, 950, 750
Bulk Density 1.82 - 2.00 Gm/CC 1.89 1.82
Specific Gravity 3.8 - 4.0 3.96 3.83
Friability 35 - 47% 36 46
Iron Content 0.3% Max 0.09 0.008
PSD - ASTM 25 Max 25 % Retention 10.05 9.7
PSD - ASTM 25 Min 45 % Retention 53.55 52.3
PSD - ASTM 30 Min 65 % Retention (in
#25+30)
27.69 32.68
Comparison- ABR & GWB
Parameter Spec (ABR) ABR 30 GBW 30
Appearance - Dark brownish Whitish
LUX VALUE Min 600 Lux 1150, 980 680, 675
Bulk Density 1.82 - 2.00 Gm/CC 1.82 1.73
Specific Gravity 3.8 - 4.0 3.90 3.84
Friability 40 - 51% 42 48
Iron Content 0.3% Max 0.01 0.001
PSD - ASTM 25 Max 25 % Retention 9.23 8.0
PSD - ASTM 25 Min 45 % Retention 54.69 52.66
PSD - ASTM 30 Min 65 % Retention (in
#25+30)
31.38 35.64
19. 19
Internal evaluation report– LWG 30
Parameter Spec S 1 S 2 S 3
Dust (in Lux) Min 600 Lux 190 60 50
Bulk Density 1.48 - 1.76 1.50 1.63 1.64
Sp Gravity - 3.30 3.61 3.63
Iron content 0.3 % Max 0.250 % 0.345 % 0.375%
Friability 40 - 50 % 59.36 % 55.60 % 51.27
PSD - ASTM
#18
Nil Nil Nil Nil
ASTM #30 36 -56 % 37.82 % 40.25 % 38.50%
ASTM #35 46-79 % in #
(30+35) mesh
58.76% 67.09% 68.75
Supplier – Impex Abrasive
Parameter Spec S 1 S 2
Dust (in Lux) Min 600 Lux 80 180
Bulk Density 1.48 - 1.76 1.40 1.41
Sp Gravity - 3.10 3.12
Iron content 0.3 % Max 0.365 % 0.360 %
Friability 40 - 50 % 45.67 % 44.60 %
PSD - ASTM #20 Nil Nil Nil
ASTM #35 20 -44 % 30.5 % 33.02 %
ASTM #40 22-69 % in # (35+40)
mesh
48.37 % 46.61%
Supplier – CUMI TVT
20. 20
RE GRAIN Quality Improvement Requirement
Parameter Spec Im-pex Abrasive Indian Abrasive Remark
Dust (in Lux) Min 600 Lux 20 - 60 20 - 60 ~ 1% dust observed by wt.
Lux value should be >500
Bulk Density 1.48 - 1.76 Gm/cc 1.40 – 1.50 1.60 - 1.67 BD should be > 1.65 Gm/cc for better life.
Impex need to improve
Sp. Gravity 3.4 - 3.6 3.2-3.3 3.4-3.5 Impex to increase BD > 3.40
Iron content 0.3 % Max 0.30- 0.37 % 0.30- 0.37 % Iron content need to reduce to both the supplier
Friability 40 - 50 % 50-60 % 40-55 % Impex need to reduce their friability.
Keep ~ 45%
SIC content - High Moderate to low SIC content reduce Grain’s BD & thus cutting action.
Need to eliminate or reduce.
21. Operator feedback - Grinding Action & life are same as regular wheel. No chipping or vibration.
Supervisor are more concern about chipping & vibrations instead of performance in upcoming supply.
Feedback from Production Head - Trial wheel is ok & as per previous supply. Only concern about chipping and vibration if any.
They are convinced to use this trial wheel.
Parameter Trial Wheel Regular Wheel Trial Wheel Regular Wheel
Work Piece 75*60*6 mm MS L angle 6*5 MS Flange ( bus window frame)
Wheel Size 180 x 6.7 x 22.23 MM 180 x 6.7 x 22.23 MM 180 x 6.7 x 22.23 MM 180 x 6.7 x 22.23 MM
Grinding Action Good Good Good Good
Wear out Normal Normal Normal Normal
Chipping No No No No
Burn mark No No No No
Vibration No No No No
Wheel Life 2 No’s 2 No’s 11-12 No’s 13-14 No’s
Finishing time 10-12 min/piece 10-12 min/piece 2-3 min 2-3 min
Field Evaluation of New 7” DC SP2 in Jaipur
22. Parameter Trial Wheel-1 Trial Wheel-2 Regular Wheel-1 Regular Wheel-2
Work Piece ACE Cabin Frame (MS)
Wheel Size 180 x 6.7 x 22.23 MM
Application Weld removal & surface finishing
Power Tool Makitta AG 7”
Grinding
Action
V. Good (Smooth
grinding)
V. Good (Smooth
grinding)
Good Good
Wear out Normal Normal Normal Normal
Chipping No No No No
Burn mark No No No No
Vibration No No No No
Wheel Life 1 No’s 0.8 No’s 1 No’s 1 No’s
Finishing time 110-120 min 100-110 min 120-130min 120-130min
Field Evaluation of New 7” DC Cumi Sleek Universal In Faridabad
Operator feedback - Grinding Action is good & no need to put pressure/load during working
but life is little bit low compared to regular wheel.
No chipping, vibration or burn mark has been observed.
Feedback from Plant Head – Wheel life is 10-15% lower side. One wheel should finish one
cabin. Require to improve wheel life.
23. Green Color Double Net Chop saw- Analysis Report
Inspection Details
S.No. T1 T2 T3 T/A T/T Weight FDg/ci Bore SRO OOB Vibration
1 3.00 3.05 3.02 3.02 0.05 643 35.86 √ 0.7 1.2 17.3
2 3.00 3.10 2.92 3.01 0.18 640 35.89 √ 0.9 2.2 15.7
3 2.96 2.90 2.98 2.95 0.08 638 36.51 √ 0.5 1.7 18.2
4 2.90 2.90 3.10 2.97 0.20 643 36.55 √ 1.1 0.5 21.8
Min 2.95 0.05 638 35.86 0.5 0.50 15.70
Max 3.02 0.20 643 36.55 1.1 2.20 21.80
Mean 2.99 0.13 641 36.20 0.8 1.40 18.25
Median 2.99 0.13 642 36.20 0.8 1.45 17.75
Range 0.08 0.15 5 .0 0.69 0.6 1.70 6.10
Plunger Type - Both side metal
24. Performance Report
Date 25-11-22 Report No. Full wheel test
Product 14" Green Chopsaw DF Work Piece 2.5" MS Pipe RPM 4400
Product size 350 2.8 25.4 Machine details Dewalt 14" Cutter As received Inhouse
Dimension and test report
S.NO
Wheel Type OD ID Thick Weight Density SRO OOB No of cuts Final dia Cutting time Dia loss CR
mm mm mm gms g/ci mm gms Avg mm Sec avg mm
Type - 41 Lower better Higher better Lower better
1
GREEN DF
353 25.4 3.02 643 35.62 0.7 1.2 180
180
216.5 12.0
12.1
136.5 0.76
2 353 25.4 3.01 640 35.57 0.9 2.2 187 206.5 12.2 146.5 0.78
3 353 25.4 2.95 638 36.18 0.5 1.7 175 223 12.0 130 0.74
4 353 25.4 2.97 643 36.22 1.1 0.5 178 214 12.2 139 0.78
Operator feedback / Observation - Smooth cutting Burn mark / Burr level - No Burn or burr Mark .
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
No
of
cuts
Time in Sec
GREEN DF CHOPSAW
25. Grain Bond Analysis
Material %
Grain 71.41
Bond 15.59
Filler 13.00
Coarse
Fines
Grain Type %
CWA #30 ~ 60-65%
ABR #36 ~ 35-40 %
White creamish
powdered filler
Glass Fabric Disk
FABRIC GSM 260 GSM - 2 FABRIC
FABRIC CONSTRUCTION LENO WEAVE
STRUCTURE 5o5
Bush
Material MS BNP Type
OD 40.0 mm
ID 25.5 MM
Lip Height 2.36 mm
Anchorage 1.91 mm
Sheet Thickness 0.23mm
Hole 4 holes of irregular round shape