SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Bolt failures in the medical industry
Milan van Bree
March 2013
Content
1. Introduction
What makes the medical industry special
Examples failure modes
2. Loose bolts
Root cause/ Design rules
3. Broken bolts
Root cause/Design rules
4. Stuck bolts
Root cause/Design rules
5. Electric conductivity
Root cause/Design rules
6. Human Safety!
What makes it so special
• Reliability, Human Safety
• Clean, High Friction
• & to be cleaned!
• Machined Female parts ( No loose parts)
• Dust/ bacteria
• Corrosion, due to acids
– Puke/vomit
• No (unless sealed)
Loose bolts I
• Root cause:
Low pretension, due to:
Scatter of high friction
Examples Loose & broken bolt
M1,2!
Loose bolts II
Root cause
• High Friction due to
• Material combinations and surface deposition
technologies
• GD&T and smooth surfaces Ra<1.2
• Clean surfaces
• Over constrained parts.
• Material CTE differences
• During bake out
Design rules preventing loose bolts
• Awareness of the friction, MEASURING
Design rules preventing loose bolts
• Calculate the bolted connection with acc. Roloff Matek
Design rules preventing loose bolts
• Bolt can elongation, Lk/d>5
• Do not over constrain parts
• Tolerance play of the physical properties at
cryonic or elevated temperatures
Procedure
• Sequence of tightening
– Cryonic vessel (liquid N -273°C)
Broken bolts
Root cause
• Physical properties at cryonic and elevated temp
change ( bake out “eliminating bacteria”)
• Low (unexpected) friction, Use of Alcohol/ Grease/
adhesives.
• Hydrogen embrittlement, breaking of pretensioned
bolts> between 1-24 hrs after install base
• SCC, breaking of bolts. After > 24 hrs
• Self made bolts! Fatigue strength.
• To high applied torque.
Broken bolts
Customized screw is used, ( turned) during installation is a loctite been applied. (
low friction than expected)
Design rules preventing breaking bolts
• Calculate the bolted connection with help of Roloff Matek
• Use standardized fasteners
• Do not use additional cleaning methods before mounting
• When use: of adhesive/ grease-> in the threaded hole
Galling phenomena
AISI 316 ( A4) bolts in AISI 316 counter materials
Stuck Bolts (Galling)
Root cause of Galling
• Material choice, (clean surfaces) and high pressure
• High Hertzian contacts, use of Metric thread for
hoisting/lifting (screw jack-translation thread)!
• Bending of the screw during mounting
• Damaged threaded parts
• Surface deposition technologies ( e.g. NiP)
• Misalignment ( perpendicular fit)
• Burrs/ chips
– Use of STD fasteners
1
Preventing stuck bolts
• Use different alloys for the connection,
prevent materials which have similar hardness
• Prevent blind holes
• Don’t excessive re-use the fastener
• Don’t use metric thread for translations
• Do ensure the female threaded part is
perpendicular towards the bolted connection
• Use a lubrication (sealed!)
Human Safety
Electrical conductivity
• Electrical discharges in metallic joints: cause
failure of electronic assemblies (PCB) and
human safety.
Root cause:
• Oxidation layers ( Anodized layers)
• Adhesives/ grease
• Material choice
Design rules, provide electrical contact
• Do not use adhesives/ grease.
• Do use suitable materials, electrical
conductive
– Oxidation layers ( Al2O3)
• Do use earthed washers only ones!
Summary
• Provide pretension such that such no slip will occur
• Calculate with the help of Roloff Matek the critical connection
• Include effect of friction and its variation
• Define required active thread length
• Use STD screw
• Provide large lk/D, guide line: lk/D ≥ 3
Bolt calculation
tool, Futek.com
WHAT DETERMINES THE RIGHT
TORQUE
QUESTIONS?

More Related Content

What's hot

Metallic Materials And Processes I
Metallic Materials And Processes IMetallic Materials And Processes I
Metallic Materials And Processes IHites
 
Cswip 3.1 course note 2016 with question & answers
Cswip 3.1 course note 2016 with question & answersCswip 3.1 course note 2016 with question & answers
Cswip 3.1 course note 2016 with question & answersSK PK
 
Metallic Materials And Processes Ii
Metallic Materials And Processes IiMetallic Materials And Processes Ii
Metallic Materials And Processes IiHites
 
Weld Defects
Weld DefectsWeld Defects
Weld Defectsadminn2
 
Armature construction & materials
Armature construction & materialsArmature construction & materials
Armature construction & materialskelv_w
 
Weld defects, causes, and remedies
Weld defects, causes, and remediesWeld defects, causes, and remedies
Weld defects, causes, and remediesemmanyoung
 
161553.pantry organizer
161553.pantry organizer161553.pantry organizer
161553.pantry organizerAlex Leung
 
Oil Field Supplies presentation
Oil Field Supplies presentationOil Field Supplies presentation
Oil Field Supplies presentationRaj Sharma
 
Bulk flow woven container liners
Bulk flow woven container linersBulk flow woven container liners
Bulk flow woven container linersBULK-FLOW
 
2012 Bolted joints - Bolted joints in real conditions
2012 Bolted joints - Bolted joints in real conditions2012 Bolted joints - Bolted joints in real conditions
2012 Bolted joints - Bolted joints in real conditionsErik Galdames
 
Welding101 tips-information
Welding101 tips-informationWelding101 tips-information
Welding101 tips-informationClark Heintz
 
Pipe gasket. RTJ, Sprial, Metal Jacketed
Pipe gasket. RTJ, Sprial, Metal JacketedPipe gasket. RTJ, Sprial, Metal Jacketed
Pipe gasket. RTJ, Sprial, Metal JacketedVarun Patel
 

What's hot (18)

Metallic Materials And Processes I
Metallic Materials And Processes IMetallic Materials And Processes I
Metallic Materials And Processes I
 
Cswip 3.1 course note 2016 with question & answers
Cswip 3.1 course note 2016 with question & answersCswip 3.1 course note 2016 with question & answers
Cswip 3.1 course note 2016 with question & answers
 
Metallic Materials And Processes Ii
Metallic Materials And Processes IiMetallic Materials And Processes Ii
Metallic Materials And Processes Ii
 
Welding defects
Welding defectsWelding defects
Welding defects
 
Weld Defects
Weld DefectsWeld Defects
Weld Defects
 
Armature construction & materials
Armature construction & materialsArmature construction & materials
Armature construction & materials
 
CSWIP Intro
CSWIP IntroCSWIP Intro
CSWIP Intro
 
Weld defects, causes, and remedies
Weld defects, causes, and remediesWeld defects, causes, and remedies
Weld defects, causes, and remedies
 
161553.pantry organizer
161553.pantry organizer161553.pantry organizer
161553.pantry organizer
 
Oil Field Supplies presentation
Oil Field Supplies presentationOil Field Supplies presentation
Oil Field Supplies presentation
 
Welding
WeldingWelding
Welding
 
Bulk flow woven container liners
Bulk flow woven container linersBulk flow woven container liners
Bulk flow woven container liners
 
2012 Bolted joints - Bolted joints in real conditions
2012 Bolted joints - Bolted joints in real conditions2012 Bolted joints - Bolted joints in real conditions
2012 Bolted joints - Bolted joints in real conditions
 
Titanium and titanium alloys
Titanium and titanium alloysTitanium and titanium alloys
Titanium and titanium alloys
 
TheisSummaryJan14th2016
TheisSummaryJan14th2016TheisSummaryJan14th2016
TheisSummaryJan14th2016
 
Welding Inspection
Welding InspectionWelding Inspection
Welding Inspection
 
Welding101 tips-information
Welding101 tips-informationWelding101 tips-information
Welding101 tips-information
 
Pipe gasket. RTJ, Sprial, Metal Jacketed
Pipe gasket. RTJ, Sprial, Metal JacketedPipe gasket. RTJ, Sprial, Metal Jacketed
Pipe gasket. RTJ, Sprial, Metal Jacketed
 

Similar to Presentation3 aangepast

Weld introduction.ppt
Weld introduction.pptWeld introduction.ppt
Weld introduction.pptprabhu857493
 
Cswipday1 slide71-email-1-130121013355-phpapp02
Cswipday1 slide71-email-1-130121013355-phpapp02Cswipday1 slide71-email-1-130121013355-phpapp02
Cswipday1 slide71-email-1-130121013355-phpapp02MDSHAHID8797
 
Workshop Practice.pdf
Workshop Practice.pdfWorkshop Practice.pdf
Workshop Practice.pdfNahomMeles
 
Exothermic Welding & Pinbrazing - Kevin Jones
Exothermic Welding & Pinbrazing - Kevin JonesExothermic Welding & Pinbrazing - Kevin Jones
Exothermic Welding & Pinbrazing - Kevin Jonesnacetwincities
 
Banding procedure and general principles of bonding pdf
Banding procedure and general principles of bonding pdfBanding procedure and general principles of bonding pdf
Banding procedure and general principles of bonding pdfSwetasaran18
 
Fsw friction stir welding
Fsw friction stir weldingFsw friction stir welding
Fsw friction stir weldingVaibhav Patil
 
Orthodontics archwaire & treatment plan
Orthodontics archwaire & treatment plan Orthodontics archwaire & treatment plan
Orthodontics archwaire & treatment plan jojo smn
 
Training module welding.pptx
Training module welding.pptxTraining module welding.pptx
Training module welding.pptxVinayakGouda5
 
Visual Inspection of Welding Process
Visual Inspection of Welding ProcessVisual Inspection of Welding Process
Visual Inspection of Welding ProcessGaurav Singh Rajput
 
Friction stir welding (sfw)
Friction stir welding (sfw)Friction stir welding (sfw)
Friction stir welding (sfw)Lahiru Dilshan
 
Presentation on expolisive welding and safety measures
Presentation on expolisive welding and safety measuresPresentation on expolisive welding and safety measures
Presentation on expolisive welding and safety measuresThirupatiBachali
 
Rotary Sealing for Improved Downhole Equipment Performance
Rotary Sealing for Improved Downhole Equipment PerformanceRotary Sealing for Improved Downhole Equipment Performance
Rotary Sealing for Improved Downhole Equipment PerformanceBSEmarketing
 

Similar to Presentation3 aangepast (20)

Welding joints ,GTAW
Welding joints ,GTAW Welding joints ,GTAW
Welding joints ,GTAW
 
Weld introduction.ppt
Weld introduction.pptWeld introduction.ppt
Weld introduction.ppt
 
lap joint .ppt
lap joint .pptlap joint .ppt
lap joint .ppt
 
Cswipday1 slide71-email-1-130121013355-phpapp02
Cswipday1 slide71-email-1-130121013355-phpapp02Cswipday1 slide71-email-1-130121013355-phpapp02
Cswipday1 slide71-email-1-130121013355-phpapp02
 
Workshop Practice.pdf
Workshop Practice.pdfWorkshop Practice.pdf
Workshop Practice.pdf
 
Exothermic Welding & Pinbrazing - Kevin Jones
Exothermic Welding & Pinbrazing - Kevin JonesExothermic Welding & Pinbrazing - Kevin Jones
Exothermic Welding & Pinbrazing - Kevin Jones
 
Banding procedure and general principles of bonding pdf
Banding procedure and general principles of bonding pdfBanding procedure and general principles of bonding pdf
Banding procedure and general principles of bonding pdf
 
Raviteja gangisetty
Raviteja gangisettyRaviteja gangisetty
Raviteja gangisetty
 
Soldering.ppt
Soldering.pptSoldering.ppt
Soldering.ppt
 
Fsw friction stir welding
Fsw friction stir weldingFsw friction stir welding
Fsw friction stir welding
 
Orthodontics archwaire & treatment plan
Orthodontics archwaire & treatment plan Orthodontics archwaire & treatment plan
Orthodontics archwaire & treatment plan
 
Training module welding.pptx
Training module welding.pptxTraining module welding.pptx
Training module welding.pptx
 
Visual Inspection of Welding Process
Visual Inspection of Welding ProcessVisual Inspection of Welding Process
Visual Inspection of Welding Process
 
Dg mf mold components
Dg mf mold componentsDg mf mold components
Dg mf mold components
 
Welding fixtures
Welding fixturesWelding fixtures
Welding fixtures
 
Friction stir welding (sfw)
Friction stir welding (sfw)Friction stir welding (sfw)
Friction stir welding (sfw)
 
Brazing and soldering
Brazing and solderingBrazing and soldering
Brazing and soldering
 
PPE for welders
PPE for weldersPPE for welders
PPE for welders
 
Presentation on expolisive welding and safety measures
Presentation on expolisive welding and safety measuresPresentation on expolisive welding and safety measures
Presentation on expolisive welding and safety measures
 
Rotary Sealing for Improved Downhole Equipment Performance
Rotary Sealing for Improved Downhole Equipment PerformanceRotary Sealing for Improved Downhole Equipment Performance
Rotary Sealing for Improved Downhole Equipment Performance
 

More from Milan Van Bree

design rules flow drilling
design rules flow drillingdesign rules flow drilling
design rules flow drillingMilan Van Bree
 
Surface Treatments for ...
Surface Treatments for ... Surface Treatments for ...
Surface Treatments for ... Milan Van Bree
 
design rules bolts_grounding
design rules bolts_grounding design rules bolts_grounding
design rules bolts_grounding Milan Van Bree
 
Microstructurally_Modified_TiAl6V[1]
Microstructurally_Modified_TiAl6V[1]Microstructurally_Modified_TiAl6V[1]
Microstructurally_Modified_TiAl6V[1]Milan Van Bree
 
Thin_Film_Technology_introduction[1]
Thin_Film_Technology_introduction[1]Thin_Film_Technology_introduction[1]
Thin_Film_Technology_introduction[1]Milan Van Bree
 

More from Milan Van Bree (7)

design rules flow drilling
design rules flow drillingdesign rules flow drilling
design rules flow drilling
 
Surface Treatments for ...
Surface Treatments for ... Surface Treatments for ...
Surface Treatments for ...
 
design rules bolts_grounding
design rules bolts_grounding design rules bolts_grounding
design rules bolts_grounding
 
uitvinders
uitvindersuitvinders
uitvinders
 
bolts 8.8
bolts 8.8bolts 8.8
bolts 8.8
 
Microstructurally_Modified_TiAl6V[1]
Microstructurally_Modified_TiAl6V[1]Microstructurally_Modified_TiAl6V[1]
Microstructurally_Modified_TiAl6V[1]
 
Thin_Film_Technology_introduction[1]
Thin_Film_Technology_introduction[1]Thin_Film_Technology_introduction[1]
Thin_Film_Technology_introduction[1]
 

Presentation3 aangepast

  • 1. Bolt failures in the medical industry Milan van Bree March 2013
  • 2. Content 1. Introduction What makes the medical industry special Examples failure modes 2. Loose bolts Root cause/ Design rules 3. Broken bolts Root cause/Design rules 4. Stuck bolts Root cause/Design rules 5. Electric conductivity Root cause/Design rules 6. Human Safety!
  • 3. What makes it so special • Reliability, Human Safety • Clean, High Friction • & to be cleaned! • Machined Female parts ( No loose parts) • Dust/ bacteria • Corrosion, due to acids – Puke/vomit • No (unless sealed)
  • 4. Loose bolts I • Root cause: Low pretension, due to: Scatter of high friction
  • 5. Examples Loose & broken bolt M1,2!
  • 6. Loose bolts II Root cause • High Friction due to • Material combinations and surface deposition technologies • GD&T and smooth surfaces Ra<1.2 • Clean surfaces • Over constrained parts. • Material CTE differences • During bake out
  • 7. Design rules preventing loose bolts • Awareness of the friction, MEASURING
  • 8. Design rules preventing loose bolts • Calculate the bolted connection with acc. Roloff Matek
  • 9. Design rules preventing loose bolts • Bolt can elongation, Lk/d>5 • Do not over constrain parts • Tolerance play of the physical properties at cryonic or elevated temperatures
  • 10. Procedure • Sequence of tightening – Cryonic vessel (liquid N -273°C)
  • 11. Broken bolts Root cause • Physical properties at cryonic and elevated temp change ( bake out “eliminating bacteria”) • Low (unexpected) friction, Use of Alcohol/ Grease/ adhesives. • Hydrogen embrittlement, breaking of pretensioned bolts> between 1-24 hrs after install base • SCC, breaking of bolts. After > 24 hrs • Self made bolts! Fatigue strength. • To high applied torque.
  • 12. Broken bolts Customized screw is used, ( turned) during installation is a loctite been applied. ( low friction than expected)
  • 13. Design rules preventing breaking bolts • Calculate the bolted connection with help of Roloff Matek • Use standardized fasteners • Do not use additional cleaning methods before mounting • When use: of adhesive/ grease-> in the threaded hole
  • 14. Galling phenomena AISI 316 ( A4) bolts in AISI 316 counter materials
  • 15. Stuck Bolts (Galling) Root cause of Galling • Material choice, (clean surfaces) and high pressure • High Hertzian contacts, use of Metric thread for hoisting/lifting (screw jack-translation thread)! • Bending of the screw during mounting • Damaged threaded parts • Surface deposition technologies ( e.g. NiP) • Misalignment ( perpendicular fit) • Burrs/ chips – Use of STD fasteners 1
  • 16. Preventing stuck bolts • Use different alloys for the connection, prevent materials which have similar hardness • Prevent blind holes • Don’t excessive re-use the fastener • Don’t use metric thread for translations • Do ensure the female threaded part is perpendicular towards the bolted connection • Use a lubrication (sealed!)
  • 18. Electrical conductivity • Electrical discharges in metallic joints: cause failure of electronic assemblies (PCB) and human safety. Root cause: • Oxidation layers ( Anodized layers) • Adhesives/ grease • Material choice
  • 19. Design rules, provide electrical contact • Do not use adhesives/ grease. • Do use suitable materials, electrical conductive – Oxidation layers ( Al2O3) • Do use earthed washers only ones!
  • 20. Summary • Provide pretension such that such no slip will occur • Calculate with the help of Roloff Matek the critical connection • Include effect of friction and its variation • Define required active thread length • Use STD screw • Provide large lk/D, guide line: lk/D ≥ 3 Bolt calculation tool, Futek.com
  • 21. WHAT DETERMINES THE RIGHT TORQUE QUESTIONS?