ดิจิทัลไทยแลนด์: Innovative Approaches to Smart City Development ดิจิทัลไทยแลนด์ 2016: วิธีการใหม่ การพัฒนาเมืองอัจฉิริยา Trends and case studies from Germany, UK, and rest of Europe. Focus on how to get started and medium sized cities. Presented at Digital Thailand Days on 27 May 2016. www.digitalthailand.in.th/ #digitalthailand #digitalthailand2016

1. Innovative Approaches to Smart City Development
(and how to get started)
Martin Venzky-Stalling
martin@venzky-stalling.com
Strategy and Policy Advisor, Innovation & ICT
martin@venzky-stalling.com
May 2016

2. 2
Germany‘s Digitale Agenda 2014-2017
www.digitale-agenda.de – similar goals to Thailand!
 Digital Infrastructure
 Digital Economy and work
 Innovative Government
 Digital Society
 Education / R&D / Culture / Media
 Security / Protection /Trust
 International Aspects

3. 3
Digital Agenda - EU

4. 4
Renewed interest in cities and urban areas

5. 5
Ranking of German Cities
- Digitalization
Key problems
Strategy
Funding (municipalities)
Broadband (rollout)
E-Government Services
Privacy, data protection
issues
Key Recommendations
Strategy
Leadership
City CIO
Digital culture
People focus
www.pwc.de/de/offentliche-unternehmen/smart-cities-content.html

6. 6
Cities with a stronger commitment to digitalization (across all areas
of activity) are more attractive and grow, other cities shrink
www.pwc.de/de/offentliche-unternehmen/smart-cities-content.html

7. 7
Morgenstadt Initiative
by Fraunhofer Institute
www.morgenstadt.de/en.html

8. 8
Details on the Morgenstadt
approach by Fraunhofer
 Members of the Morgenstadt-
Initiative share three important
convictions:
 Cities are the key to a sustainable
future.
 Technical, social, and financial
innovations are the key to sustainable
cities. Interdisciplinary collaboration
lies at the heart of urban
innovation.

9. 9
From the work, a methodology and solutions portfolio was
developed – as well as detailed reports about several cities

10. 10
Examples of Smart Cities Project in Germany and Austria - 1
http://www.energate.de/e21digital/
www.bundesverband-smart-city.de

11. 11
Examples of Smart Cities Project in Germany and Austria - 2
http://www.energate.de/e21digital/

12. 12
www.smartcity-cologne.de

13. 13
Reallabore: http://www.r-n-m.net/
Labs about urban problems at universities and with cities
https://mwk.baden-
wuerttemberg.de/de/forschung/forschungs
politik/wissenschaft-fuer-
nachhaltigkeit/reallabore/

14. 14
Data for London Project
http://data.london.gov.uk/city-data/

15. 15
Berlin Open Data Strategy
https://www.fokus.fraunhofer.de/

16. 16
“Technology is the answer, but what was the question?”
Cedric Price, Architect 1934-2003
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FCptJm9_SIw

17. 17
“70 percent of corporate transformation projects fail”
McKinsey, ca 2013
Something similar can be said about e-government projects,
what can we learn from this?
Also: www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/organization/our-insights/what-successful-transformations-share-mckinsey-
global-survey-results

18. 18
Key findings by NESTA, a UK think tank
Many ‘top down’ smart city ideas have failed to
deliver on their promise, combining high costs and
low returns.
‘Collaborative technologies’ offer cities another
way to make smarter use of resources, smarter
ways of collecting data and smarter ways to make
decisions.
Collaborative technologies can also help citizens
themselves shape the future of their cities.
www.nesta.org.uk/publications/rethinking-smart-cities-
ground#sthash.cFg9lfDA.dpuf

19. 19
www.nesta.org.uk/blog/whats-missing-city-data-debate
PurposePurpose
Purpose
Purpose
Big data vs small data
Inclusiveness
Privacy and citizen buy-in
Impact on decision-making /
how is it used?
Corporate date / role
Leadership to address urban
challenges
Skills availability

20. 20

21. 21
Smart City Initiatives
www.nesta.org.uk/news/10-people-centred-smart-city-initiatives

22. 22
https://4thenollsummerschool.files.wordpress.com/2013/0
6/enoll-27-aug-2013.pdf
City as a Living Lab - examples

23. 23
Smart City / Open Innovation Challenges and Competitions

24. 24
Urban Acupuncture

25. 25
Ignite through a small set of catalyst actions
Use the urban acupuncture as a catalyst, a small set of significant actions that bring together the
various ingredients in such a way that they "ignite" and create sustainable momentum
Bring all parts
together and ignite
to create
sustainable
momentum that
changes the
economy

26. 26
Citymart – matching solutions with cities’ problems
www.citymart.com/impact-index/#sharing-proven-solutions

27. 27
Thailand is on the right track with many of its initiatives,
there are opportunities for
 More diverse international cooperation
 incorporating an open innovation / city as lab and collaborative technology based approach from start
 focused pilots,
 roll out smart city program more widely (more cities),
 demand creation for digital technologies in SMEs,
 capacity and skill development in government
 integrate different policy initiatives
Startup Thailand,
Science Park, Startup
Districts
Digital Economy
Smart CitiesE-Government Services
Integrate different policy initiatives