Transformation That Sticks: Using Mobile Optimized Tools to Accelerate Business Transformation
Mobile optimized SaaS tools that deliver procedure, policy and task management information on any device at any time are replacing legacy training platforms that deliver dense buckets of information a few times per year.
Learn more about:
- Delivering real time updated procedure information for complex and repetitive work
- Using continuous employee feedback provided across mobile devices to continuously improve processes
- Measuring real time employee interaction with expert content and correlating to business results
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Transformation That Sticks - SAI's PEX Week 2016 Presentation
1. PEX CONFERENCE 2016
Mark Dabrowski & Josh Crone
Transformation That Sticks:
Using Mobile Optimized Tools to
Accelerate Business Transformation
January 2016
2. Who we are
Mark Dabrowski
Vice President,
SAI Digital Practice
Josh Crone
Vice President & CTO,
Software Products
3. What we’ll be
discussing
Implementing process change initiatives that
stand the test of time
Root causes of failure
Building blocks of success
Using technology as an enabler
4. What got us thinking about this?
Consulting experience
Content management expertise
Enabling technology for a large-scale process
improvement initiative at Walmart
5. About SAI
Consulting and software products firm
Identified a significant gap in the consistent application
of process change across large organizations
7. Identify/create optimized
processes
Convey those processes to
employees
Ensure employees understand
and execute on those processes
Measure the impact, gather
feedback, identify gaps, make
adjustments
Ongoing reinforcement
….or at least that’s the theory
How do they do it?
8. The real world
Critical processes are not documented
Documented processes are out of date or incorrect
Employees are not aware of processes that exist
Processes exist but are simply ignored
9. Case Study
Baltimore riots
Independent Inquiry
determined:
No clear policies for
making arrests
Failure to follow
federal guidelines to
develop a response
plan
Chain of command
not clear
Insufficient training
& planning
11. Case Study
Walmart process
optimization
GOAL: increase in-store
efficiency
Processes optimized
But how to distribute
to 1M+ employees?
Web-based content
accessible on all
devices
Feedback loop
ROI realized in weeks
12. Key themes from these examples
Information not readily accessible
Processes not documented or disseminated
Organizational, cultural or people failures
Existing policies and procedures were not
reinforced
Bottom line - transformation and processes not
fully developed or ingrained in the organization
13. How can we address these challenges?
Transformation
Doesn't Stick!
Transformation
Doesn't Stick!
15. Reinforcement is key to
behavior change
Old habits die hard…
Transformation
efforts require
behavior change
Think of New Year's
resolutions
Constant
reinforcement of
desired behavior is
key to making
transformation stick
16. Reinforcement: case studies
Baltimore riots:
Changes in procedures couldn’t be reinforced
Lack of training in civil unrest
Fukushima:
The wrong behaviors were reinforced
Behaviors essential to creating a safe work environment were never
reinforced
Walmart example:
Comprehensive training during onboarding
Gap with behaviors that aren't reinforced
Our own consulting experience:
Transformation efforts start out strong but....
Can lose momentum without an advocate reinforcing the new behavior
18. Transformation is impossible if:
Information is not easy to
access or discover
Information is not available on
all devices
Information is not available
when and where you need it
Procedures are
not available
20. “How to” information
at home…
Discoverable in an instant
Single-purpose “Apps” vs
“Applications”
Short form over long form
21. As good as your
systems are…
BYOD is taking hold
Consumer technology is simpler and in many
cases more powerful
Increasingly mobile workforce
More content consumed on smaller screens
Considerable growth in device usage
Pew Research Center, The Demographics
of Device Ownership:
92% of U.S. adults own a cellphone
68% of U.S. adults own a smartphone (up from
35% in 2011)
Nearing saturation in some groups
45% own a tablet
73% own a laptop or desktop
23. Why do these trends
matter?
Your workforce has high
expectations of technology
Content should be web-accessible
It should look great on any device
Content should be concise and
purposeful
It should be easy to consume
Documents should be formatted
in a familiar, consistent format
(more about that later)
Content should be discoverable
via metadata and search
25. Learning styles
Learning styles vary
Training content should support
multiple styles
Traditional format – text – not
always effective
Provide checklists, diagrams,
video, audio
Reinforcement is critical
26. JIT vs. JIC
Identify optimal training mix
Task dependent
Access to resources beyond the
classroom is critical
JIT serves to reinforce traditional
training
29. Make it appealing
Content must be
easy to consume
Simple to access and
understand
Aligned with
learning styles
Less focus on
lengthy text
More video, images,
step-by-step
instructions, or
diagrams
30. Ease of use
Remove barriers to
encourage adoption
Can I quickly find what I
need?
Can I access reference
materials and best
practices without
stopping what I'm doing?
Don’t interrupt the flow of
work
32. Enable feedback
Make employees part of
the process
Provide simple feedback
mechanism
Reward employees who
provide feedback that
directly improves a
process
34. Puzzle exercise
Time to break up
the monotony of a
long presentation
Let’s illustrate the
importance of
accurate, relevant
instructions
35. Puzzle exercise - what we learned
Accurate instructions matter
Inaccurate instructions need to be corrected
Multiple formats matter (images, text, video)
36. Content is not accurate or relevant
What we've found:
There are multiple sources of information in the
organization
Information is likely to be outdated
Process documentation doesn't reflect practical
execution
Content is difficult to update
Content isn't reviewed on a regular basis
Content is in varying format
37. Multiple sources of
information
There should be "One Version
of the Truth"
Information is spread
throughout an organization,
often with conflicting
information
Document system should
inspire confidence in the
material
38. Outdated information
Information evolves as we
learn along the way
Internal and external factors
cause change in process
Iterative approach increases
the rate of change
Having a process often isn't
enough, you need a system
to ensure content is
reviewed at the same rate
39. Feedback based on
practical execution
Feedback is an effective
way to ensure processes
evolve
Valuable information in the
heads of folks on the floor
In addition to helping you
find "the one best way", a
feedback mechanism can
uncover external
operational issues
40. Approval process
Speaking of guitars and
feedback: How to build an
electric guitar
Information is easily
accessible, but how do we
know it's accurate?
Crowdsourced information
great - but it needs to be
vetted
Feedback loop with an
approval process provides
perfect balance
41. Ease of creation &
updates
Documenting processes can
be seen as "overhead" and not
valuable
If creating and updating
content is a chore, it won't get
done
SMEs don't want to worry
about the format of
documents, just their content
Template-based content
creation allows document
owners to focus on procedure
details
42. Fill the gap: scheduled
content review
Infrequently used processes
can be “out of sight, out of
mind”
Regularly-scheduled content
review ensures that documents
are updated on a consistent
basis
People need to be reminded
when documents are up for
review
Regulations require proof that a
document has been reviewed
43. Consistent format
Procedures should be easy to follow, consistent, and
engaging
Familiarity allows the content to be digested and
internalized more quickly
To do this, documents should be built from predefined
templates
We use templates all the time:
Email
Forms
Instructions…
44. Recipe
Preheat oven to 375 degrees F
Combine 2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour, 1 teaspoon baking soda, and 1
teaspoon salt in a small bowl
Beat 1 cup softened butter, 3/4 cup granulated sugar, 3/4 cup
packed brown sugar, and 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract in large mixer
bowl until creamy
Add two large eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition
Gradually Beat in flour mixture. Stir in 2 cups semi-sweet chocolate
morsels and 1 cup of chopped nuts
Drop by rounded tablespoon onto ungreased baking sheets
Bake for 9 to 11 minutes or until golden brown
Cool on baking sheets for 2 minutes; Remove to wire racks
to cool completely
45. Same recipe
Ingredients
2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon salt
1 cup (2 sticks) butter, softened
3/4 cup granulated sugar
3/4 cup packed brown sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 large eggs
2 cups semi-sweet chocolate morsels
1 cup chopped nuts
Instructions
PREHEAT oven to 375° F.
COMBINE flour, baking soda and salt in
small bowl. Beat butter, granulated
sugar, brown sugar and vanilla extract
in large mixer bowl until creamy. Add
eggs, one at a time, beating well after
each addition. Gradually beat in flour
mixture. Stir in morsels and nuts. Drop
by rounded tablespoon onto ungreased
baking sheets.
BAKE for 9 to 11 minutes or until
golden brown. Cool on baking sheets
for 2 minutes; remove to wire racks to
cool completely.
47. Execution of
procedures is not
measured
You can’t control a
process you don’t
measure
Need to understand the
current state and
measure progress to the
desired state
What tools and
techniques can we use?
49. Task management
Having procedures
doesn’t mean they’ll
be followed
Assign tasks to
employees
Work instructions for
the optimized way to
complete those tasks
Track when completed
Receive verification
50. Reporting
Who is looking at the
materials?
Which resources are used
the most?
In what context are these
materials being used?
Employee feedback?
Who has acknowledged?
When was it reviewed?
Employee proficiency
51. Alignment with KPIs
Process optimization should be
tied to business objectives
Align KPIs with measurable
outcomes
Answer these questions
objectively - have we made
progress? What’s the impact on
the business?
52. One version of the truth
Relevant and timely
content
Measure
Parting thoughts
Make it easy and accessible
Motivate
Support multiple learning
models
Transformation
Doesn't Stick!
54. Thank You!
Build a better, higher performing workforce
Visit us in booth 17 or at acadia-software.com
Editor's Notes
Mark
Mark
Josh
Take Bullets 2 & 4 out
IT Consulting and Software Products firm
Helping organizations across industries improve processes and operations
Identified a significant gap in the consistent application of process change across large organizations
Developed enabling technology to help organizations make transformation stick
Mark
emphasize increased revenue
Mark then transition to Josh
Josh
Failures to capitalize on process optimization opportunities are abundant
Critical processes not documented
Documented processes are out of date or incorrect
Employees not aware of processes that exist
And the most challenging issue - processes exist but are simply ignored
Josh
Between April 18, 2015 and May 3, 2015 a series of protests, rioting, arson, and looting erupted in Baltimore City following the death of Freddie Gray in Police custody
Independent Query determined:
No clear policies for making arrests
Failure to follow federal guidelines to develop a response plan
Chain of command not clear
Insufficient training / planning
http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2012/07/05/156295055/report-bad-procedures-caused-the-fukushima-nuclear-disaster
Josh
on March 11, 2011, an earthquake and tsunami triggered the flooding of the Fukishima Dai-ichi nuclear plant, resulting in total system failure and leaks of nuclear material.
Japanese officials released the following findings:
"disaster was due to bad policies and procedures"
Culture of acceptance and "reflexive obedience" -
No one questioned that the plant would be unable to withstand a disaster, or that there was no evacuation plan
Safety team shared operational responsibility - no separation of duties
Some very basic process and policy changes could have reduced the impact of the flooded plant
Mark
Feedback loop, "All they needed was a browser, not software to install" = Fast ROI
Goal was to increase efficiency - get more done without increasing work hours (cost)
Processes were optimized and documented
But the key challenge was disseminate to staff, and influence them to actually execute based on those optimized process
Solution was a custom application that made content available when and where associates worked. Easy to access, simple to use, no interruption to flow of work
Feedback from client - ROI was realized in a matter of weeks
Mark
Mark
Mark
Josh
Transformation efforts require behavior change across your organization
"Old habits die hard"
Default behaviors are ones that have been reinforced over extended periods of time
Think of New Year's resolutions
Difficult at first, but if you stick with them:
"New" behavior becomes "Default" behavior
What required conscious effort at first becomes new habit
Constant reinforcement of desired behavior is key to making transformation stick
Josh
Baltimore Riots:
Arrest policies changed in response to civil unrest
Chain of command not clear when resources outside of the city responded
Making changes during a crisis compounded the issue
Limited experience in civil unrest meant that tactics were not reinforced, leading to poor decisions:
ie. Decision to not use riot gear = injured police
Fukushima:
The *wrong* behaviors were reinforced.
"Acceptance and Obedience" was reinforced at the expense of safety
Retailer Example:
Comprehensive training during onboarding
Gap with behaviors that aren't reinforced
Comprehensive training at onboarding only partially-effective.
"Daily" activities are reinforced and therefore retained
less-frequent activities are forgotten and may require assistance and retraining
Our own consulting experience:
Transformation efforts start out strong but....
Can lose momentum without an advocate reinforcing the new behavior
Mark
Josh
Josh
Employees can't use information they can't find or access
At Work:
Tacit Knowledge is spread across the organization:
Sr. Employees, SMEs hold critical business knowledge.
Subject to Employee availability and willingness to share
Identifying the SME is Tacit knowledge in and of itself
Explicit knowledge is still difficult to find:
Email, File Servers, Distributed on systems
Handouts, Visual aids
Tough to navigate, not available when you need it
Josh
At Home:
Shift in where folks find information
"Why should I learn this when I can Google it"
Information is immediately discoverable, shift is to vetting the information
Shift in information and technology:
"Apps" have replaced "applications"
continued trend towards simplification and built-to-purpose apps
Information is consumed in "Snippets" instead of long form
Josh
BYOD is now the norm, in many cases personal technology is more advanced than corporate end-user tech
Users are more accustomed to their own technology
Most cases they would prefer their own tech Vs. Corporate device.
Increasingly mobile workforce
More content consumed on smaller screens.
Considerable growth in device usage:
(Pew Research Center, The Demographics of Device Ownership)
92% of U.S. Adults own a cellphone
68% of U.S. Adults own a smartphone (up from 35% in 2011)
Nearing saturation in some groups
45% own a tablet
73% own a laptop or desktop
http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/10/29/the-demographics-of-device-ownership/?utm_expid=53098246-2.Lly4CFSVQG2lphsg-KopIg.0
Josh
Your workforce has high expectations of technology:
Content Should be web-accessible (Available when and where they need it)
Flexible content format
Responsive design:
Should look great on any device
Content should be concise and purposeful
easy to consume for folks used to "instant gratification"
Documents should be formatted in a familiar, consistent format. (more about that later)
Content should be searchable
Content should leverage metadata tagging
Mark
Mark
Mark
Mark
Goldfish 9 seconds, people 8 according to MSFT
Josh - Mention how no one wants to sit in a workshop listening to us ramble on for 1.5 hours
Mark
Mark
Make it appealing by leveraging tactics previously talked about: learning styles, different content, etc.
Mark
iPhone example: ease of use trumped more full-featured options
Cumbersome systems and processes contribute to waste
Mark
Audit trail vs. "claim"?
Mark
Everyone here knows feedback is important to process improvement
Make the connection between feedback and measured indicators from before as the ultimate reward for contributing good feedback.
Mark
Josh
Josh
Show the list but talk around it
Assumptions:
There are multiple sources of information in the organization
Information is likely to be outdated
Process documentation doesn't reflect practical execution
Content is difficult to update
Content isn't reviewed on a regular basis
Content is in varying format
Josh
Information is spread throughout an organization:
File servers, email, websites, intranets, physical documents
In the heads of employees
There should be "One Version of the Truth".
Central location answers question as to where to find critical policies, procedures, and tasks.
Document versions and revision history should be maintained so employees know which version is the "right" version.
Document system should inspire confidence in the material
Josh
Information evolves
We learn along the way.
Documents become irrelevant if they're not reviewed on a regular basis
Internal and External factors impact processes and procedures (Transformation efforts, Software updates change application behavior, hardware refreshed)
Agile / iterative approach to tech, business, all increase the rate of change
Having a process often isn't enough, you need a system to ensure content is reviewed on a reasonable schedule
Josh
Feedback is an effective way to ensure processes evolve
We learned how feedback creates a sense of ownership, it is also helpful because:
Sometimes the SME doesn't have all of the practical knowledge of a worker "on the floor".
In addition to helping you find "the one best way", a feedback mechanism can uncover external operational issues.
Josh
Information is easily accessible, but how do we know it's accurate?
Crowdsourced information great - but it needs to be vetted.
Some well-meaning instructions may not be accurate for example: How to build an electric guitar
Incorrect policies and procedures can be a risk to the organization
Feedback loop with an approval process provides perfect balance.
Josh
Documenting processes can be seen as "overhead" and not valuable. Decreasing the time to create and update Process / Procedure documentation is essential.
If creating and updating content is a chore, it won't get done. (it's the last thing people want to do anyway)
SMEs don't want to worry about the format of documents, just their content.
Template-based content creation allows document owners to focus on procedure details.
This problem is an extension of the "not available/discoverable" problem. without system of record, you don't know where to update documentation.
Josh
Infrequently used processes can be “out of sight, out of mind”
Regularly-scheduled content review ensures that documents are updated on a consistent basis.
People need to be reminded when documents are up for review
Regulations require proof that a document has been reviewed
This version is actually shorter and more concise than the next recipe, yet the standard format works better .
Josh
Josh
Mark
Mark
Mark
Mark
Mark
Mark
Motivation
Make it easy to find
Make it convenient to use
Hold staff accountable
Reinforce!
Measurement
Capture acknowledgement to hold staff accountable
Use quizzing to validate knowledge skills
Track how content is accessed
Tie process change to KPI measurement
Enable feedback loop - is the content correct and relevant
Learning Model
Learning is not one size fits all
Provide multiple means to convey knowledge - step by step instructions, video, etc.
Multimedia knowledge delivery increases effectiveness and engagement - and it's a key aspect of millennial communication experience
One Version of the Truth
One electronic source of key process and policy information
Discourage printing where possible since documents are at that point uncontrolled
Updates are immediately available to all staff
Relevant and Timely
Efficient content creation and approval
Simple, rapid electronic distribution
Integrated feedback loop
Make it Easy and Accessible
Accessible across many devices
Straightforward user interface
Powerful and effective search