SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 87
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
1 |
University of Leeds
SCHOOL OF EDUCATION
Online Submission of Assessed Work
Student Name Louisa Pielichaty
Student ID number 200624294
Degree programme Childhood Studies
Module code EDUC 3805
Module title Dissertation
Dissertation Title The Effects of Dietary Intervention on Children with Autism: A
Case Study.
Dissertation
supervisor
Mary Chambers
Word count 10991
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
2 |
The Effects of Dietary Intervention
on Children with Autism: A Case
Study.
LOUISA PIELICHATY
STUDENT NUMBER: 200624294
MODULE CODE: EDUC3805- DISSERTATION
WORD COUNT: 10991
DISSERTATION SUPERVISOR: MARY CHAMBERS
FRIDAY 16TH MAY 2014
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
3 |
Acknowledgements
I must start by acknowledging the special school at which I conducted my research
for this body of work and thank you for allowing me to come into your school and
complete my observations. In particular I would like to thank the Head Teacher for
taking the time to meet with me and provide me with some excellent contextual
information. I would also like to thank the other staff at this school, including the
catering staff who were so helpful in providing information regarding school meals
and showing me how the catering services work. I am so grateful to the teaching
assistants who took the time to complete the requested food diaries. I must also
thank the parent who returned the 7 day food diary, your input provided a new
dimension to the findings.
I extend my thanks to the 3 parents who returned the questionnaires I sent out.
Unfortunately due to the limited amount of returned questionnaires the results had to
be discarded, however the results of these questionnaires were used to inform my
research and provide relevant contextual information for me as a researcher.
I particularly owe thanks to the parents of Child X for not only allowing me to create a
case study on their son but for also being so helpful and forthcoming in the collation
of the case study details. Your help has been invaluable and I thank you for all the
time you have given me in replying to my questions and meeting with me.
I give huge thanks to my dissertation supervisor Mary Chambers for her constant
support and help throughout my studies. She has been my first port of call whenever
I’ve needed help and her guidance has been so reassuring. I would not have had
such a clear direction in my writing had it not been for Mary. Thank you to the other
members or staff at the School of Education who have also had to deal with my
panics.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
4 |
Special thanks goes to my family and friends for supporting me through all my
research and making this difficult task that little bit more enjoyable.
Finally I would like to thank all the children who were observed as part of my
research and all those who were indirectly involved.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
5 |
Contents Page
Abstract……………………………………………………………………………….7
Introduction…………………………………………………………………………..8
1.0Literature Review………………………………………………………………10
1.1Treatment……………………………………………………………….10
1.2Dietary Intervention…………………………………………………….11
1.3Gluten and Casein Free Diets………………………………………..13
1.4Opioid-Excess Theory…………………………………………………15
1.5Biomedical Approach………………………………………………….17
1.6Defeat Autism Now! …………………………………………………...18
1.7Nutritional Standards…………………………………………………..19
1.8Carbohydrates and Candida………………………………………….21
2.0Methodology……………………………………………………………………24
2.1Participants……………………………………………………………..24
2.2Research Methods……………………………………………………..25
2.3Research Instruments………………………………………………….27
2.4Ethical Issues……………………………………………………….…..29
3.0 Presentation and Analysis of Findings………………………………………33
3.1Observational Research Results……………………………………..33
3.2Carbohydrates………………………………………………………….35
3.3Food Diaries…………………………………………………………….36
3.4School Lunch 4 Week Menu…………………………………………..37
3.5Case Study……………………………………………………………...38
3.6Results of Nutrient Supplementation and Dietary Intervention……44
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
6 |
3.7Average Financial Costs of Treatment………………………………45
4.0 Discussion of Findings………………………………………………………..46
4.1Carbohydrates………………………………………………………….46
4.2Connection to Gluten-free Dietary Intervention……………………..49
4.3Connection to Casein-free Dietary Intervention…………………….50
4.4Case Study……………………………………………………………...51
4.5Speech and Language Development……………………..………….51
4.6Cognitive Development and Motor Skills…………………………….52
4.7Limitations……………………………………………………………….53
5.0 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………..54
6.0 References……………………………………………………………………..57
7.0 Appendices……………………………………………………………………..63
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
7 |
Abstract
The purpose of this dissertation is to investigate the link between dietary
interventions and children on the Autistic Spectrum. Through observational research
and the completion of food diaries, the researcher looked at the types of foods
consumed by a sample of children with autism both in a school and a home setting.
Results of this research were compared against findings from a review of literature in
the field of dietary and biomedical interventions. The prevalence of carbohydrate was
a prominent finding in the research, with subsequent detrimental effects on children
with autism discussed in regard to current research. The inclusion of a case study on
a 5 year old boy with autism currently undergoing a dietary intervention provides a
first-hand account of the possible benefits of such intervention. In his case, a gluten
and lactose free diet coupled with nutritional supplement and organic produce has
seen vast improvements on his behavioural, social and emotional development.
Whilst the results of this case study highlight the positive impacts of dietary
intervention on children with autism, further research is imperative to gain a greater
understanding of this relationship as there is a lack of evidence in this field.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
8 |
Introduction
The focus of this body of work was to research the use of dietary interventions for
children with autism; looking at the popularity of such interventions and examples of
biomedical approaches. The prevalence of autism in today’s society is more than 1
in 100 people, with 1.1% of the UK population thought to be on the autistic spectrum
(The National Autistic Society, 2014). Taylor et al, 2013, studied the prevalence of
autism in the UK of children aged 8 between 2004 and 2010. Results found that
during the 1990s, the annual incidence rates of autism increased “fivefold”, before
reaching “a plateau in the early 2000s” (Taylor et al, 2013, page 1). Whilst the
prevalence of autism is high, the awareness of dietary interventions and biomedical
approaches to ‘treating’ autism is not as widely circulated. This lack of awareness
provided the main contextual factor for the research conducted within this body of
work. There was also a personal vested interest in this subject; the researcher has
worked in the field of autism for over half a decade, and therefore much of the
information gathered was relatable to the researcher’s own experience.
The literature review section explores the vast scope of ‘treatment’ available for
children with autism, with particular reference to biomedical and dietary approaches.
The term ‘treatment’ is so highlighted as some people argue that autism is not a
disease as such that needs ‘treatment’, but rather a disorder that needs
‘intervention’. The reader is therefore left to make his/her own mind up vis-à-vis the
proper use of the word ‘treatment’. Gluten and casein-free diets feature throughout
the literature review and the high level of gluten intake in children with autism is an
ongoing theme running throughout this work.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
9 |
The inclusion of a case study adds another dimension to this study as it provides
primary data in terms of the effects of dietary intervention on a young boy with
autism. The information for the case study was gathered first hand by the researcher
and backed up by face to face contact with the child, known in this study as Child-X.
Further research has been used to inform this study; the researcher conducted
observational research in a special school and food diaries were also obtained. All
data bar the food diaries was collected by the researcher first-hand; the food diaries
were collated by each participant’s teaching assistant. Each aspect of the research is
included in the presentation and analysis of findings section and the appendices and
further evaluated in the discussion section. The overall focus of the study looks at
the observational research results and the case study and links both to dietary
interventions and the effects of certain food products on the body of a child with
autism. This body of work aims to provide an informative and explorative study into
the effects of diet and dietary intervention on a child with autism and to increase
awareness of such ‘treatments’.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
10 |
Chapter_1.0
Literature Review
1.1) Treatment
There are numerous therapies and treatments available for children with autism
which vary hugely in their approaches. The variety of approaches can be attributed
to the vast differences and effects treatments have on individuals, as well as
financial and social factors, including the availability of trained and knowledgeable
professionals to deliver treatments or therapies. Green et al, 2006, conducted
research into the plethora of treatments available to establish their typical use and
popularity. They published a study in which they surveyed 552 families of children
with autism, questioning them on their use of different treatments. Overall there were
111 different treatments recorded as used. Green et al 2006 found that on average
“families were using seven treatments at the time they answered the survey, with
one parent employing 47 treatments simultaneously” (Green et al 2006, page 962).
This shows the vast scope of treatments and also suggests that many families are
willing to try more than one treatment for their child. The anomalous result of 47
treatments, whilst an isolated case, provides an interesting platform for further
exploration into why this particular parent needed to use such a large number of
treatments. However Hess et al 2007 record no evidence of this having been
questioned and therefore the article accepts this result as simply anomalous.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
11 |
There is a lack of supporting information to explain the reasons why the families in
this study used their individual number of treatments. This is a clear weakness of the
study as this contextual information would have provided a greater understanding of
parental considerations of treatments. It would have added value to findings; offering
parental opinions on treatments and thus a deeper analysis of causal links between
each child and their parents’ chosen treatments. Results of this study do show that
speech therapy was the most common form of therapy. However Lee 2011
conducted research which disputes the popularity of speech therapy through her
contradictory results. Lee gained feedback from 14 parents/carers of children with
autism on their children’s use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines (CAMs).
The study reported “dietary-based therapies to have been the most common form of
CAM used by the parents for their children with ASD” (Lee, 2011, page 4). The vast
range of 111 treatments recorded in Green et al’s study reflects diversity across
families of autistic children. This review focuses on the effect that dietary and
biomedical treatment can have on children with autism.
1.2) Dietary Intervention
Dietary interventions or diet modification are classed under a group of treatments
known as CAM; (Complementary and Alternative Medicine). CAMs are often used to
“ameliorate the range of theorised biochemical abnormalities” (Angley et al. 2007
page 827) of children with Autistic Spectrum Disorder. They provide a form of
treatment that you would not find in mainstream healthcare. The categorisation of
CAMs covers a number of other treatments such as auditory integration therapy and
craniosacral therapy. In a study conducted by Hanson et al 2006, parents of autistic
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
12 |
children were surveyed to determine the different types of CAM used to ‘treat’ their
children and the parents’ beliefs surrounding these interventions. The study group
consisted of 112 parents of children who were diagnosed with ASD between 1997
and 2003 and were patients of the Developmental Medicine Centre in Boston, USA.
Parents were questioned on numerous factors including their demographic and their
use of CAM. Similarities can be drawn with the aforementioned Green et al 2006
study which surveyed parental use of treatments for children with autism, not
specifically CAMs.
Overall, the findings of the research concluded that 74% of the families involved “had
used interventions categorised by this study as CAM” (Hanson et al, 2006, page
631). Of the 112 parents, 43% recorded a use of diet modification as a biologically
based therapy. These statistics highlight the popularity of biological therapies, yet the
study shows that conventional therapies such as educational and sensory therapies
are still the most widely used by parents. This contradicts Green et al’s results, who
found that speech therapy was the most popular treatment. 94% of the parents
involved in this study reported that they had used conventional therapies, which
includes prescription drugs. According to Hanson et al’s 2006 findings, this form of
therapy was given high rates in terms of usefulness and efficacy yet there is no
explanation as to why they were approved so highly. However the discussion of this
study reveals contradicting results in terms of the issues parents considered when
selecting their therapy. Most families were concerned about “unacceptable side
effects with prescription medication” (Hanson et al, 2006, page 633) and the safety
of this medicine. This contradiction suggests issues with the reliability of this study.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
13 |
The next section will look further into the dietary interventions and diet modification
treatments available for autistic children.
1.3) Gluten and Casein Free Diets
An example of a dietary intervention for children with autism is the gluten/ casein free
diet (GF/CF diet). Gluten is a combination of proteins found commonly in wheat;
casein is a milk protein. Many autistic children find that their bodies are unable to
digest these proteins and therefore they can become harmful to them. Studies have
shown that most children who have autism also have “inflamed gastrointestinal
tracts” (McCandless, 2007, page 27). This can damage the child’s immune system
as “70% of immune cells are in the digestive tract” (Davies, 2012, page 137). When
foods containing gluten and casein are introduced to the intestinal tract, they can
irritate and inflame the intestine causing symptoms such as stomach pains.
According to McCandless 2007, autistic children with inflamed intestines are
particularly susceptible to yeast infections and more specifically a species of yeast
known as Candida. This will be explored further on in the review.
Angley et al, 2007, published an article which highlights the issue of inconsistent
results from research into the efficacy of GF/CF diets. She compared two studies
which look at the results of GF/CF diets and their outcomes on children with autism.
The first study was a randomised single blind study on 20 autistic children,
conducted by Knivsberg et al, 2002. This study assessed the effect of “a gluten-
casein free diet on children with autistic syndrome and urinary peptide abnormalities”
(Elder et al, 2006, page 415). The children were separated into either the control
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
14 |
group or the experimental group. Findings showed that the experimental group who
received the GF/CF diet exhibited improvements in “behaviour, non-verbal cognitive
level and motor problems” (Elder et al, 2006, page 415). The second study was
Elder et al’s 2006 efficacy study of GF/CF dietary interventions for children with
autism. This study was a double-blind randomised study of 15 children conducted
over 12 weeks. Results found “no statistically significant findings even though
several parents reported improvement in their children” (Elder et al, 2006, page 413).
This provides conflicting results to the success of Knivsberg et al’s 2002 study thus
throwing the efficacy of GF/CF dietary interventions for autistic children into the air.
From these results it is not possible to draw a substantial conclusion of the success
of these diets. The difference in the ‘single-blind study’ and ‘double-blind study’ could
provide a reason behind the differing results as the single-blind study conducted by
Knivsberg et al 2002 risks the contamination of bias within its research. Elder et al
2006 have avoided the possibility of bias by using a style of research that renders all
participants and researchers ignorant of which subjects are receiving what.
Therefore it could be argued that Elder et al’s study has more reliability and thus
more efficient results. However the sample sizes of both studies are too small to
represent a sufficient average of the population of autistic children. As stated by
Elder et al 2006, “a need still exists for rigorous controlled clinical trials evaluating
both physiological and behavioural effects” (page 415).
In 1991, Dr Kalle Reichelt studied the urine of children with autism and found that
these children had high levels of peptides in their urine which were not found in the
urine of typically developing children. Peptides are compounds which enable the
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
15 |
breakdown of protein and those found in the urine of the children studied derived
from gluten and casein in the diet. Amongst those peptides found in the urine were
casomorphins, which come from casein. These high levels of casomorphins can be
explained by a lack of the specific enzyme needed to break this peptide down.
Research into this specific enzyme was pioneered by Dr Alan Friedman 2000 and
his colleagues. They looked into the possible role of a lack of the dipeptidyl
peptidase- IV (DPP-IV) enzyme in children with autism. This is “the only known
enzyme to break down casomorphins” (Smeltzer, 2011, page 16) and therefore vital
to ensure the upkeep of protein levels within the body. DPP-IV is also imperative in
the digestion of gluten and casein. According to Friedman et al 2000 this enzyme
can be found in areas such as the small intestine and the blood-brain barrier which
shows how widespread it can be. Through his research, Friedman et al 2000 found
that nearly 100% of the autistic children involved in his studies had “casomorphin
and gliadomorphin peptides in their urine unless they were on the GF/CF diet”
(Smeltzer, 2011, page 16). McCandless 2007 describes how a lack of an active
DPP-IV enzyme in the body can cause a build-up of ‘demorphins’. These are “opioid
or morphine-like substances” (McCandless, 2007, page 27) which when
accumulated in the body can be a contributing factor to autistic children often
appearing “spaced out” (McCandless 2007 page 27).
1.4) Opioid-Excess Theory
“It has been suggested that peptides from gluten and casein may have a role
in the origins of autism and that the physiology and psychology of autism
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
16 |
might be explained by excessive opioid activity linked to these peptides”
(Millward et al, 2008, page 2).
The above quote introduces the theoretical basis for a diet free from gluten and
casein; the ‘opioid excess theory’. McCandless’s 2007 idea that children can appear
‘spaced-out’ can be explained by this theory. It is suggested that the peptides
excreted by the gluten and casein in the child’s diet are incompletely metabolised
and remain active within the body, exhibiting opioid activity. Isherwood et al, 2011
propose that these ‘toxic’ peptides pass through into the central nervous system and
“interfere with the neurotransmission causing altered or disrupted activity and
altered-sensory input” (Isherwood et al, 2011, page 59). The opioid activity of the
peptides can be likened to the effects of opiate drugs and can cause “significant
problems with speech, communication, behaviour and social skills” (Tommey and
Tommey, 2011, page 58). It compares the symptoms of autism with the behaviours
exhibited when one is using opiates, such as heroin. Thus, the opioid-excess theory
attempts to provide an explanation for the different behaviours and symptomatic
tendencies observed in autistic children.
Whilst this theory is being discussed in current society, the link between opiates and
autism was highlighted by Jaak Panksepp 1979. Panksepp used research into the
effect that low doses of narcotics such as morphine can have on emotionally
compromised animals to explore the link between the opioid state of autism and the
long-term effect of narcotics. He reported similarities between the opioid symptoms
noted in children with autism and the effects of long-term morphine use (Shattock;
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
17 |
Whiteley, 2002, page 2). According to Panksepp 1979, the similarities found, which
included a deficient desire for social companionship,
“suggests that the underlying neurochemical imbalance in autistic children
may be excessive, or unusual, activity in their own endogenous brain opiate
systems”. (Panksepp, 1979, page 175)
Whitely and Shattock, 2002, blame the success of these peptides entering into the
central nervous system on an “abnormally permeable intestinal membrane”
(Shattock; Whiteley, 2002, page 1) which allows the peptides to have a detrimental
effect on the brain’s neurotransmitters. It permits the disruption of “a variety of
biochemical and neuroregulatory processes” (Shattock; Whiteley, 2002, page 2).
In context of the opioid-excess theory, Shattock and Whiteley promote the exclusion
of food substances which subject a child to these harmful casomorphins and
gliadomorphins. Thus, Shattock and Whiteley 2002 support the dietary intervention
of removing gluten and casein from the diet of an autistic child. However,
Schreibman wrote in 2007 that this theory “remains speculative at this point”; a
contrasting and sceptical perspective on the opioid-excess theory. Schreibman
draws attention to the fact that this is a ‘theory’ and therefore it will inevitably
encounter scepticism and opposing opinions.
1.5) Biomedical Approach
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
18 |
There is much research and literature that delves deep into the field of biomedical
approaches to treatment for children with autism. The biomedical causes of autism
are widely discussed amongst Defeat Autism Now! (DAN!) Doctors, who believe that
biomedical treatment can be used to positively affect the behavioural and cognitive
symptoms of autism. Jaquelyn McCandless MD, 2007, is a strong supporter of the
biomedical approach to autism, believing that “sometimes the improvement is
dramatic enough for a child to lose his or her ASD diagnosis” (McCandless, 2007,
page 6). This bold statement highlights the end goal that biomedical treatment seeks
to reach, however it must be noted that this is a sweeping statement and will only be
true for a handful of children. However, the idea has now been introduced, thus
further exploration of the possibilities of ASD recovery or symptom improvement is
anticipated.
1.6) Defeat Autism Now!
Defeat Autism Now! (DAN) was formed to “focus activism and attention on identifying
the biological bases of autism and biologically based treatments” (Schreibman, 2007,
page 23). This organisation was set up in 1995 by a combination of parents,
researchers and physicians all with a vested interested or connection to autism. It
provided a new way of thinking about the causes and treatments of children with
ASD from a biological perspective and offered new information about the effects that
factors other than behaviour can have on these children. It focuses on dietary and
biomedical approaches to autism including restrictive diets and nutrient supplements.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
19 |
Tommey and Tommey 2011 present a clear theme throughout their book (Autism: A
practical guide to improving your child’s quality of life) of optimism that a child’s
autistic behaviours and symptoms can be greatly improved. The title itself suggests
that this book will ensure a child with autism will have a better life once they apply
themselves to this guiding piece of literature. However, it must be taken into account
the possibility of bias presented by Tommey and Tommey 2011. A couple, their
eldest son was diagnosed with autism when he was only 2. Together they delved
deep into the world of autism; its causes, treatments and the connections between
biology and medicine, all of which resulted in successful ‘treatment’ of their now high
functioning teenage son. Their individual success story however must not be
accepted as the finding of a general solution to the problems associated with autism.
Whilst this book does provide extensive information on diet and nutrition and the
positive effect this can have on a child with autism, it does not guarantee that all
children will have such positive results. Their own enthusiasm for dietary and
biomedical intervention stems from the success their son has gained from it.
Tommey and Tommey 2011 do acknowledge the uniqueness of every child “we have
learned one very valuable lesson: that each and every child with autism is different”
(Tommey and Tommey, 2011, Page xiv).e topic.
1.7) Nutritional Standards
It is important to acknowledge the legislation that sets out standards for dietary
provisions for children in education. In terms of children’s diet during the school day,
schools have strict nutritional standards to adhere to in what they offer children. In
2005, the School Meals Review Panel (SMRP), chaired by Suzi Leather, released a
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
20 |
report on “the development and implementation of nutritional standards for school
lunches” (DfES, 2005). The report sets out the panel’s recommendations for change
and development of the food served in schools, based on evidence from a variety of
sources including head teachers, school caterers and public health experts. It
provides a framework for school catering staff to follow in order to ensure that they
serve “well-cooked, well-presented meals, made from good-quality ingredients to
accepted nutritional standards”; whilst also ensuring that they are confident in their
own abilities as catering staff.
The SMRP’s 2005 report does not detail the specific nutritional standards that should
be met by special schools or those catering to a special educational needs unit. The
only incidence where Leather explores the relationship between special schools and
the food provided is in the interest of eligibility for free fruit and vegetables in the
School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme. This however is neither a recommendation put
forth by the review panel nor a target; it was put into practice in 2000 by the NHS
and is merely highlighted as a ‘recent development’. It is also not limited solely to
special schools, but rather eligibility for a free piece of fruit or vegetable spans nearly
2 million children in over 16000 infant, primary and special schools in England
(Department of Health, 2010). Therefore it is apparent that Leather 2005 does not
adequately address the difference in dietary needs between typically developing
children and children with autism.
In its recommendations, the panel set forth a table of Nutrient Standards which lists
the proportions of each nutrient that should be present in the school lunches offered
to children and young people. The table states that across the five consecutive
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
21 |
school days, lunches should contain a quantity of carbohydrate that amounts to no
less than 50% of food energy. Carbohydrates provide the body with energy which
according to studies can have positive effects on children. In a study by Vaisman et
al 1996 it was suggested that cognitive performance can be increased in those
children who do not typically eat breakfast just by providing them with breakfast,
which generally includes carbohydrates. This supports Leather’s recommendation
that the Government should prioritise the supplement of breakfast standards in
schools.
This highlights a major lack in the legislation surrounding the nutritional standards
that must be upheld for children with disabilities. Yet the creation of such standards
risks straying into discrimination against children with disabilities and labelling them
as ‘an exception to the dietary norms’ associated with typically developing children.
The fear of being accused of discrimination suggests that this is an area that few are
willing to explore. Instead, all children, regardless of whether they are typically or
atypically developing, are provided for in schools following the same nutritional
standards framework. Literature that proves that this may indeed be harmful to
certain children appears to simply be ignored. Although there is a wide variety of
information on diet and autism available on the internet, this too has been
overlooked in terms of the national dietary nutritional standards set out by the SMRP
2005.
1.8) Carbohydrates and Candida
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
22 |
However, for children with autism, refined carbohydrates such as white bread and
crisps generally prove problematic for their gastrointestinal systems and if consumed
at the rate suggested by Leather 2005 would have negative consequences. Tommey
and Tommey 2011 explain that these refined carbohydrates “provide exactly the right
nutrients (mostly glucose) for Candida to thrive on and can upset the blood sugar
balance” (page 65). An increase in Candida has been suggested by some research
to be “a significant cause of many of the untoward behaviours and health problems
we see in autistic patients” (McCandless, 2007). Shaw, 2002, looked more closely at
the link between yeast and the effects it has on children with autism. He explained
that as Candida multiplies, it excretes toxins into the body. He suggested that these
toxins “are capable of impairing the central nervous and immune systems” (no
pagination). This audacious statement suggests that children with autism who have
an excessive amount of Candida in their bodies could become seriously physically
challenged and unwell. McCandless’s inclusion of this research suggests that she
supports Shaw’s findings. While she includes them as “ground-breaking research”
(McCandless, 2007, page 28), there is a lack of further exploration of the link
between the yeast toxins and the nervous and immune system. This is a bold area of
research which suggests highly negative results on children with autism; therefore
the author may have missed the opportunity to provide further understanding of this
link.
McCandless 2007 also explores other symptoms that can occur from excessive
Candida growth in children with autism. She lists “diarrhoea, stomach ache, gas
pains, constipation, headache, fatigue and depression” (McCandless, 2007,
page28). This cocktail of symptoms would be difficult for a typically developed adult
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
23 |
to deal with, let alone a child with autism whose development has already been
compromised. McCandless also lists behavioural problems that can occur due to
Candida overgrowth, which include “concentration difficulties, hyperactivity, short
attention span, irritability and aggression” (McCandless, 2007, page 28). From these
lists we can deduce that Candida is not only harmful in terms of physical health, but
it can also be damaging to behavioural development. Therefore its importance must
not be overlooked. However, McCandless clearly does not rate the issue of Candida
as highly as there is little further exploration of the subject within her book. The next
section of this body of work is a study of the popularity of dietary interventions
amongst children with autism and a discussion into the efficacy of such interventions.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
24 |
Chapter_2
Methodology
The purpose of this study was to look at the different foods that children with autism
are consuming on a day-to-day basis in their educational setting. The researcher
wanted to gather data that could be analysed and compared to the restrictions of a
gluten-free and casein-free diet, as well as other dietary interventions.
Questionnaires were sent out to parents to determine the level of knowledge on
dietary interventions and to gather information on parental stance concerning a child
with autism’s dietary intake. Finally, a case study was drawn up by the researcher
using a subject who is currently undergoing a dietary intervention to provide a time-
line of intervention and results.
2.1) Participants
School Meal-Time Setting
The research question focuses on the affects that diet can have on ‘children’ with
autism. The first participants involved were a group of Key Stage 3 and Key Stage 4
children with autism aged between 11-16 years. The research was conducted in a
special school with a separate specialised department for children with autism. As
this part of the research was a general observation of a meal-time setting, personal
information including age of each individual was not noted but rather an average age
range was provided. These participants were all on the Autistic Spectrum. Two
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
25 |
different lunch time proceedings were observed on the same day therefore providing
a range of results.
Food Diaries
7 children from this group of participants also participated in another stem of
research. These 7 children were observed by their teaching assistants (TAs) over a
period of 5 consecutive school days. The TAs recorded the data for this aspect of the
research although the children were the subjects of this research. The TAs remained
anonymous and their data collection was passed to the researcher by the Head
Teacher’s PA. The overall number of TAs involved in this research also remained
anonymous as the research was conducted at the school in the absence of the
researcher.
Case Study
The participant in the case study, ‘Child-X’, is a 5 year old autistic child known to the
researcher. The researcher elected to write up a case study of Child-X as he
provided a current and first-hand experience of the effects of dietary intervention.
The parents of Child-X were also included in the collation of information for this case
study.
2.2) Research Methods
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
26 |
Before research was conducted, the researcher met with the Head Teacher of the
chosen school to discuss the proposed research and arrange a time and date to
conduct it. This meeting lasted an hour and allowed the researcher to provide the
Head Teacher with food diary templates to be passed to the TAs for completion. It
was decided during this meeting that the observational research would be
undertaken on one day, therefore allowing for minimal disruption to the children in
the school. As the researcher was looking for qualitative data from educational
research, the choice of observational research correlated with Levin, O’Donnell and
Kratochwill’s 2003 ‘Stages of Programs of Research’. Levin et al 2003 suggested
that the first stage of educational research would involve “observational, focused
exploration” and the second stage would consist of “observational studies of
classrooms” (Brantlinger et al, 2005, page 145). The school has 2 lunch-time sittings
(12:15-12:45 and 12:45-13:15) and the observations were to span both sittings. An
informal meeting with the head chef of the school was scheduled to be held between
the two sittings and after lunch.
The researcher completed the observational research in the dining hall of a school
for children with learning difficulties. The researcher initially observed the food that
was being served as it was delivered to the dining hall. The researcher questioned
the head chef on the menu and noted the food on offer that day. This part of the
observation was conducted in the absence of any children and only involved the
catering staff of the school.
The second part of the observation was completed once the first group of school
children had entered the dining hall for their lunch-time sitting. The researcher
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
27 |
moved around the dining hall, taking a tally of the different food and drink each child
was consuming. The researcher conversed with TAs present in the dining hall to
establish the various dietary restrictions and requirements of some of the children.
As this was only observational research in terms of the children’s participation, there
was no conversation between the researcher and the children. The researcher
observed the main course and desert choices made by the children at the food
station as well as the drinks chosen. Those children who brought a packed lunch
with them were also included in the research checklist tally. This observation
research was repeated for the second group of school children in the second lunch-
time sitting.
2.3) Research Instruments
Observational Research
Pre-observation, the researcher created a ‘research checklist’ to be taken to the
observation and used to note a tally of results. The checklist, shown in Appendix.1
allowed the researcher to make note of the different food groups eaten during the
lunch setting; the individual foods that comprised these food groups; the different
drinks consumed and the quantity of children consuming these foods and drinks.
Whilst there was a column titled ‘solid food’ this was discarded on observation as it
became apparent that it was a redundant variable. The final column on the research
checklist, titled ‘restricted diet’, was completed through observation combined with
conversation with the catering staff. This type of research allowed the collection of
both qualitative and quantitative data. The quantitative data collected through the
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
28 |
tally lent itself to the presentation of findings in graphs and charts. “Graphs and
charts condense large amounts of information into easy-to-understand formats that
clearly and effectively communicate important points” (CDC, 2008, page 1). The
categorical data of food types etc. is best represented in these forms.
Questionnaire
The questionnaire was structured into two sections which were signposted within the
questionnaire. Sectioning ensures that questions “are not constantly shifting back
and forth” (Anderson, Arsenault, 2005, page 187) therefore allowing a fluency to the
questionnaire. The first section aimed to find out about the child in general, therefore
enquiring about age, sex, disability, medication and verbal ability. The second
section of the questionnaire was more related to the research aims and asked
parents about the food habits of their children and their knowledge surrounding
dietary interventions. The questionnaire combined a mixture of closed-questions
such as tick-box style questions; and open-ended questions which provided
descriptive answers. They enabled the researcher to compare the parental
perspectives in the questionnaire to other parts of the research, such as the case
study.
Case Study
The researcher created the case study through an informal meeting with Child-X and
his mother and father. Although the researcher had a vague structure for an
interview regarding the timeline of Child-X’s dietary intervention, the meeting was led
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
29 |
by the parents, with the researcher noting down everything that was said. The
structure consisted of ‘Summary’; ‘Issue to be resolved’; ‘Action taken’; ‘Results’;
‘Next steps’ and ‘Any other information’. This structure was used to gather
information for each section of the timeline. The researcher explained the structure
of the interview to Child-X’s parents and asked that they provide a detailed timeline
of events that set out all intervention Child-X has received along with effects on the
child; behavioural changes; physical changes and the results of all treatment.
2.4) Ethical Issues
Before any research was commenced, the researcher created a parent information
sheet detailing the proposed research and the dissertation question. This was drawn
up to ensure that parents were as fully informed as possible about the intended
research on their children. A separate information letter was also created which
provided information on the questionnaire. Both letters are shown in Appendix.2 and
Appendix.3. The researcher wrote two separate information letters for the different
stems of the research to ensure the elimination of any confusion surrounding the
research. The researcher wanted to make a clear definition between the two stems.
Two separate consent forms were also created for the questionnaire and the
observational research to continue to ensure a consistent definition between the two
branches of research (these are shown in Appendix.4 and Appendix.5).
The questionnaires sent out to parents (see Appendix.7) provided the researcher
with a particular ethical issue. The Head Teacher of the school explained that
roughly 80% of the parents of the pupils did not have English as a first language.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
30 |
The issue then arose of whether they would fully comprehend the information
provided in the information letter and the consent forms. The researcher questioned
whether informed consent would be possible to ascertain if the parents could not
understand English. The decision was made by the Head Teacher that all the letters
would still be sent out as the research involving the children was purely
observational but that the consent forms should be altered to ‘opt out’ forms rather
than ‘opt in’. The change to the forms was made by the Head Teacher as she agreed
she had a greater understanding of the literary and comprehensive backgrounds of
these parents.
An issue arose in the return of the questionnaires. As only 3 were returned from the
entire school, the researcher was faced with a sample-size that was too small to give
a reliable overall view of the parental perspectives. Therefore the researcher had to
decide whether this was valuable research that should be included. It was decided
that the questionnaires provided the researcher with a wider understanding of
parental perspectives on dietary interventions for children with autism, yet the
information did not need to be included in the overall research study. It was to be
used to inform the researcher but not the research.
The researcher had to be particularly sensitive to minimising disruption to the routine
of the autistic children. A trait of many children with autism is their obsessive and
compulsive behaviour and their need for a repetitive routine. Therefore, being a
stranger, the researcher had to be careful not to upset the children by interfering too
much in their daily routine. The researcher observed as much as possible from
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
31 |
outside of the dining hall and when walking around the hall, the researcher was
careful not to invade any child’s personal space.
The dissemination of the information gathered and management of such information
provided an ethical issue of anonymity and confidentiality. Every participant has the
right to remain nameless and also for their input to remain private. Wiles et al, 2006,
describe Oliver 2003 and Gregory 2003’s principle of privacy as a principle that is at
the heart of our society. We believe “that individuals matter and that individuals have
the right for their affairs to be private” (Wiles et al, 2006, page 2), therefore the
researcher upheld complete confidentiality with all participants. Within the case
study, the child was referred to as ‘Child-X’ throughout and the parents were fully
informed of the inclusion of the case study within this research. They agreed to the
display of the case study as a chronological timeline of data on the understanding
that the researcher does “not disclose identifiable information about participants” and
tries “to protect the identity of research participants through various processes
designed to anonymise them” (Wiles et al, 2006, page 2). They were given the
options to create pseudonyms however they opted simply for ‘mum’ and ‘dad’.
The researcher was also aware of the sensitivity surrounding the food diaries sent
out to parents. As these diaries were designed to extract information on what parents
fed their children, there was an issue in ensuring that parents were not being ‘judged’
about what they gave their children. The researcher made it clear that this was an
optional diary and that any information would remain anonymous. However the
researcher was aware of the participants and therefore would know which diary
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
32 |
came from which family. This could explain the lack of returned food diaries that the
researcher received.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
33 |
Chapter_3.0
Presentation and Analysis of Findings
3.1) Observational Research Results
The first part of the research that was collected was the primary data from the school
meal-time setting observation. Appendix.1 shows the research instrument used to
collect the data. Results were converted into graphs and charts to enable clear
portrayal of the results. It is important to note that the results of the meal-time
observation include foods from both the school catering and a few packed lunches
so as to get a rounded view of the
food children eat at lunch. The
following section displays the
results of the research and
provides an explanatory aside to
each.
Figure.1) is a pie chart that
displays the percentages of the different types of consumed nutrients that were
noted during observations of
autistic children during their lunch
break. It shows a majority of
carbohydrates and a minority of
protein. The chart was created from results of the research checklist (Appendix.1).
Carbohydrate Protein Fruit/ Vegetable Dairy
Different types
of nutrient
12 1 5 2
60%
5%
25%
10%
Chart Percentage of different
Nutrients consumed during
school meal-time observation
Carbohydrate
Protein
Fruit/ Vegetable
Dairy
Figure 1) A pie chart showing the quantity of each nutrient consumed
during the meal-time observation
Table 1) The different number of eachindividual nutrient observed.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
34 |
Table 1) shows the raw data from the observational research, before it was
converted into the chart in Figure.1). For example, Table 1 shows that only one type
of protein was consumed compared to a variety of different carbohydrates.
Figure.2) is a graph
showing the amount
of times each
different nutrient
was eaten. For
example, the table
shows that fruit and
vegetables were
eaten 30 different
times throughout
lunch-time. The table provides quantitative data regarding the popularity of each
nutrient. It shows the number of times the different nutrients were actually
consumed, rather than just the number of times they were on offer. The researcher
collected this data to gain an understanding of the foods autistic children eat through
choice and naturally lean towards. It therefore provides a base from which further
food preferences can be guessed.
From Figures.1) and 2) we can see that not only were the carbohydrate rich foods
most readily available, they were also the most popular in terms of consumption.
There were 46 different instances of children eating carbohydrates, compared to only
46
20
30
4
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Instances of
Carbohydrates
consumed
Instances of
Protein
consumed
Instances of
Fruit/Vegetable
consumed
Instances of
Dairy
consumed
Number of instances each nutrient
was consumed
Figure 2) A graph displaying the amount of times each nutrient was eaten.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
35 |
4 instances of dairy consumption. Although there was only 1 type of protein available
to the children observed, it was clearly a popular choice as there were 20 instances
of it being eaten. This indicates that the variety of each nutrient on offer does not
have a direct effect on its overall popularity as the limited option of 1 type of protein
proved more popular than the 2 types of dairy available.
3.2) Carbohydrates
The percentage of carbohydrates consumed by the children observed has been
broken down in Figure.3) into the different food products.
Figure.4) presents the
percentage of the different fruit
and vegetable products
consumed during the meal-time
observation. The pie chart
shows a total of 5 different
35%
7%
20%
2%
2%
2%
2%
18%
2% 4%
4%
2%
Percentage of each different type of
carbohydrate consumed
Spaghetti
Jacket Potato
Garlic Bread
Mashed Potato
Jam Sandwich
Crisps
Tortilla Chips
Rice Pudding
Fairy Cake
Butter Sandwich
Biscuits
Chapati
Figure 3) Chart showing a breakdownof the carbohydrates consumed
36%
37%
17%
7% 3%
Percentage of each different type of
Fruit/ Vegetable consumed
Sweetcorn
Carrot
Salad
Apple
Banana
Figure 4) A pie chart showing the percentage of each fruit/vegetable
consumed during the meal-time observation.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
36 |
fruits/ vegetables. Potato has been eliminated.
Figure.5) shows the
children’s drink
choices. The only drink
option offered by the
school was water. The
Capri Sun and the
juice were provided in
3 packed lunches and
were not offered by the
school. These results
have been included to draw attention to the possible relationship between the drinks
consumed by the children and the ensuing effects upon them. Whilst the majority of
the children drank water; the Capri Sun and the juice are sugary drinks and therefore
should be considered in terms of effect of sugar on children with autism.
3.3) Food Diaries
Appendix.6 and Appendix.7 show eight food diaries that were completed for the
researcher either by a TA (Appendix.6) or a parent (Appendix.7) of an autistic. Seven
of these food diaries provide an overview of the foods children with autism consume
whilst in school; showing show break-time and lunch-time food and drink intake from
Monday- Friday. Appendix.7 is a food diary which shows Child H’s food and drink
intake across a full week, listing breakfast, lunch and dinner in both an educational
11
1 2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Water Capri Sun Juice
NumberofPupils
Type of Drink
Graph showing the number of pupils
consumingdifferent drinks
Type of Drink
Figure 5) A graph showing the number of pupils consuming each type of drink.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
37 |
and a home setting. The layout is different as it spans 7 days (Monday-Sunday). It
has a different colour scheme and layout so as to highlight its separation from the
other diaries and to eliminate confusion with them. Appendix.7 was completed to
provide an insight into the difference between food intake at home and in school.
All food diaries were completed independent of the researcher and returned either to
the child’s school where they were passed on to the researcher, or direct to the
researcher via email. The children whose food diaries were completed by their TAs
are pupils at the same school where the meal-time observation was held and were
also involved in the
observation.
Figure.6) displays the
quantity of each nutrient
present within the 7
school-based food diaries.
The pie chart shows a
fairly even spread across
the five nutrients; the most common nutrient is carbohydrate. It shows that only a
small percentage of the foods were protein, which correlates with the small amount
of protein on offer in the school meal-time setting, as depicted in Figure.1).
3.4) School Lunch 4 Week Menu
Figure 6) A pie chart showing the percentage of each nutrient listed in the 7
school-based food diaries.
36%
14%
26%
19%
5%
Overall Percentage of each food
type from the school-based food
diaries
Carbohydrates
Sugar
Fruit/Vegetable
Dairy
Protein
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
38 |
Appendix.9 is a scanned image of a document that outlines a 4 week menu
framework for the school dinners on offer at the participating school It has been
included to offer an insight into the food and diet provided by mass catering
companies and the education system. It shows an average 4 week menu with a
meat main, a vegetarian option, vegetable sides and a pudding.
3.5) Case Study
A case study was conducted on a 5 year old boy with autism, known as ‘Child-X’,
who now follows a strict dietary intervention as suggested by a Clinical Nutritionist
(CN) following the Defeat Autism Now! (DAN!) protocol. The case study outlines a
chronological timeline starting from the age of 2. Before the age of 2, Child-X’s
development appeared typical and gave mum and dad no cause for concern. The
case study details the treatment and intervention Child-X has received throughout
his life so far. It also explains the developmental obstacles, challenges and
milestones.
 First 13 months-
Child-X was very sick. He contracted a chest infection and was given
antibiotics.
MMR Jab
Child-X received the MMR vaccination. However, due to his compromised
immune system he couldn’t cope with the MMR jab.
 2 years old-
No speech or vocabulary
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
39 |
Example: No verbal communication.
Mum contacted Child-X’s nursery for feedback on Child-X’s development,
behaviour and social interaction. Nursery provided minimal information and
expressed no worries about Child-X’s social and emotional development.
 2 years 6 months-
General Practitioner visit
Mum contacted her GP with concern over Child-X’s lack of speech and
language. GP told mum not to worry; boys are often slower developing. GP
dissuaded a referral to a speech and language therapist and told mum to
return after 3 months as GP felt Child-X’s speech and language would
develop.
 2 years 9 months-
Initial referral to speech and language therapist
After no improvement GP referred Child-X to a speech and language
therapist.
 2 years 10 months-
Visit to South Africa and Tympanometry test
Family visited a doctor friend on holiday in South Africa. Doctor referred Child-
X to a specialist who tested the child’s speech and hearing, using a
tympanometry test. Test concluded normal hearing however the child did not
respond positively to the hearing test.
Observed in play situation
Doctor observed child playing outside. Child-X immediately played on
climbing frame with his father. He also sat on the doctor’s lap. These
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
40 |
observed social skills and behaviours prompted the doctor’s opinion that
Child-X was not autistic.
 3 years
Started speech and language sessions. SALT referred Child-X for a hearing
test and Cognitive Development Assessment.
 3 years 3 months-
Cognitive Development Assessment
Child-X received a Cognitive Development Assessment. Results showed he
was on par with his age group for everything except his manipulative skills
and his speech.
Example: Child unable to draw a circle.
Paediatrician contacted nursery
Even though parents had regularly contacted Child-X’s nursery to discuss any
abnormal behaviour or issues, to which the nursery expressed no concern
and said Child-X played and socialised with his peers, when Child-X’s
paediatrician contacted the nursery, they expressed concern about Child-X’s
social behaviour. Paediatrician suggested that Child-X may have autism but
must wait 6 months for a further assessment.
 During the 6 months between 3 years 3 months and 3 years 9 months-
Physical changes noted with Child-X
Child-X appeared grey; his hair had lost its shine and his behaviour
deteriorated. He had frequent and worsening tantrums. He wouldn’t settle and
woke up throughout the night.
Constipation
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
41 |
Child-X suffered chronic constipation. He was eating normally and taking the
laxative supplement Lactulose (prescribed by his GP).
Appointments for assessment
Child-X received an appointment for a follow up cognitive assessment and for
a multi-disciplinary assessment.
 03/10/2012 4 years old-
Multi-disciplinary assessment and diagnosis
Child-X was assessed in his home setting, his nursery setting and the
paediatrician’s offices. This resulted in a diagnosis of autism. Mum and Dad
only received an information leaflet on autism.
Contacted DAN campaign follower
Mum and Dad rang a contact in America who follows the Defeat Autism Now!
(DAN) protocol who explained the dietary changes that the DAN protocol sets
out and provided her son’s success story from these dietary changes.
 06/10/2012 4 years 3 days-
Child-X began immediate gluten and dairy free diet.
Child-X had processed food and anything with additives especially E-numbers
and unnatural colours removed from his diet.
 07/10/2012 4 years 4 days-
Child-X’s first noted response to instruction and verbal interaction.
Example: Dad gave Child-X a flower and told him to give it to his mummy.
Child-X took the flower to his mother and said “mummy”.
 Commencement of supplements.
Child-X began taking refined cod liver oil, calcium magnesium, multi-vitamins
and a clay mixture. He began bathing in Epsom salts. Prior to Epsom salts
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
42 |
Child-X would only bath alone. First time Child-X soaked in Epsom salts he
allowed Dad to share the bath, laying on him calmly. Child-X began taking a
probiotic a few weeks later.
 10/01/2013 4 years 4 months-
Meeting with Clinical Nutritionist
Child-X’s had a Skype meeting with their CN. Child provided the lab
(recommended by the CN) with a urine, blood, hair and stool sample. CN
requested that Child-X cease all dieting and provide 3 different stool samples
for the months of January and February. CN tested Child-X for gluten and
dairy intolerance; worms and dilated pupils- Child-X tested negative for all.
Beetroot and Urine Test
Child-X drank 250ml of a solution of beetroot. Urine was then examined for a
desired pink hue which would suggest typical bodily functioning. Urine
showed no pink. Child-X also had his urine tested for crystals but none were
found.
Hair Sample
Results showed that Child-X had more toxins in his body than in his hair,
whereas typically the majority of the toxins should be found in the hair.
Biomedical Test Results
Majority of calcium found in hair as opposed to where it should be i.e. body.
Blood Test
Child-X tested for gene mutation and found to have glutathione mutation, a
deficient gene.
 March 2013
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
43 |
Mum and Dad contacted their CN to discuss results of tests and arranged 3
monthly consultations over Skype. They were told to give Child-X a mixture of
different nutrient supplements. Altogether Child-X took 21 nutrient
supplements, listed below.
21 Nutrient Supplements:
 Coenzyme Q10 (COQ10)
 Vitamin A
 Vitamin C
 Vitamin D
 Vitamin E
 Vitamin B12
 Seratonin
 Zinc
 Alpha lipoic acid (detoxifier)
 ADP (oregano)
 Culturelle Probiotic
 Mindlinx Probiotic
 Permatrol
 Phosphatidylserine
 Candiclear
 Aloe Vera juice
 Calcium Magnesium
 Refined Cod Liver oil
 Folinic Acid with B12
 Primal Defence
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
44 |
 Secretin
3.6) Results of Nutrient Supplementation and Dietary Intervention
 Prior to treatment Child-X could only produce a
stool once a week. This progressed to 4 times a
week during intervention. Results are now 13
times in 14 days.
 Child-X had never engaged in play with scooters
before treatment. After watching Dad play on a
scooter for a number of days, child picked up a
scooter and began scooting.
 Child-X’s speech and word recognition is much
improved compared to his total lack before
treatment. Child-X can cite words and read comprehensively.
 Figure.7) shows Child-X’s painting ability. The picture is a self-portrait Child-X
completed at school.
 Child-X goes to mainstream school but receives full support 32 hours a week.
 Child-X has made friends. During play time he interacts with other children.
Child-X used to be unaware of others; now he asks for absent people.
 Child-X understands to line up after break-time at school and shows
understanding of the school bell system.
 Child-X baths himself and washes his own hair. He is also able to dress and
undress himself without help.
Figure 7) A self-portrait painted at school
by Child-X.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
45 |
3.7) Average financial costs of treatment
 On average £300- £550 a month
 £1400 for the tests completed in February 2013
 £500 on products
 £300 on supplements
 Everything given to Child-X is organic, gluten free and dairy free.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
46 |
Chapter_4.0
Discussion of Findings
The results from this piece of research provide many platforms for further exploration
into the relationship between dietary interventions and children with autism. The
findings from the observational research in a school meal-time setting and the food-
diary results offer a base for further study into the effects of individual nutrients on
children with autism. The case study allowed the researcher to delve deeper into the
field of dietary intervention with a link to a gluten-free diet. The following section
discusses the results of the research findings and explores these aforementioned
areas.
4.1) Carbohydrates
The pie chart in Figure.3) shows that the main carbohydrates consumed by the
children were potato, pasta and bread products. Statistics show that 35% of the
carbohydrate food products were spaghetti, which proved the most popular option for
the children with autism. The results of the 7 food diaries completed by the children’s
TA’s showed that the quantity of carbohydrates consumed outweighed the quantities
of other nutrients. In total, 36% of the overall nutrients recorded in the food diaries
were carbohydrate. Whilst this is 24% less carbohydrate than that which was
recorded in the school-meal time setting, it is still the majority percentage compared
to the quantities of protein, dairy, fruit/vegetable and sugar. This highlights the
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
47 |
popularity of carbohydrates and suggests that children with autism have a high
carbohydrate intake.
Potato products such as crisps and bread products made from enriched or bleached
flours such as white bread come under the category of ‘refined carbohydrates’.
These carbohydrates are detrimental to a child with autism in relation to the candida
harvesting they permit. Therefore it is alarming to note that 91% of the carbohydrates
recorded in the school meal-time setting were refined carbohydrates. The only
options for non-refined carbohydrates were the potato products ‘mashed potato’ and
‘jacket potato’. These options are also gluten-free options. The researcher made a
note that most of the autistic children who opted for a potato product carbohydrate
did so due to wheat intolerances preventing them from choosing the pasta and bread
options. This suggests the hypothesis that unless restricted by a particular allergy or
intolerance, the majority of children with autism will choose a refined carbohydrate
product that contains gluten.
What is immediately obvious from the findings of the observational research and the
food diaries is the vast percentage of carbohydrates being consumed. An increase in
candida in the child’s body upsets the blood sugar balance. Srinivasan 2009
explained that the toxins that are produced by the Candida yeast “could cause some
of the symptoms [of autism] directly or by overloading the detoxification pathways”
(Srinivasan 2009 page 242). Candida has also been linked to damage of “the
nervous and immune systems” as well as “a variety of behaviour and health
problems” (Brill, 2001, page 21). Yet carbohydrates were the most commonly
available nutrient for these children to eat. Figure.2) depicts the popularity of each of
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
48 |
the different nutrients and shows that carbohydrates were consumed the most. This
carbohydrate-rich diet guarantees many children with autism a gut filled with
Candida yeast and therefore a plethora of different gastro-intestinal issues as noted
in the Literature Review section.
Edelson 2003 noted some of the behavioural and health effects of Candida
overgrowth on children with autism included irritability, aggression, stomach aches
and constipation. Yet Figure.2) shows that the negative effects of carbohydrate
consumption on a child with autism haven’t affected the availability of carbohydrates.
Srinivasan describes a diet that provides an alternative menu. The “Body Ecology
Diet” was initiated by Donna Gates and focuses on “rebuilding immunity and
intestinal flora” (Srinivasan 2009 page 244). It limits carbohydrate consumption and
also focusing on the upkeep of beneficial flora in the gut. The diet challenges the
issue of Candida overgrowth through its very limited allowance of carbohydrates. It
insists on a drastic reduction in consumption of sugar and carbohydrates. In
particular concentrated carbohydrates such as potato and refined sugars must be
removed.
Williams et al 2011 researched the gastrointestinal symptoms of children with autism
and the different deficiencies exhibited. Their findings indicated that children with
autism have “impairments of the primary pathway for carbohydrate digestion”
(Williams et al, 2011, page 1). This indication combined with the high percentage of
carbohydrate listed in both the meal-time observations and the school-based food
diaries would suggest a cause for concern. These children are consuming a nutrient
which Williams et al 2011 found to be difficult for autistic children to properly digest.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
49 |
According to Williams et al this was due to a deficiency in “at least one of the 5
genes involved in carbohydrate digestion or transport” (Williams et al, 2011, page 3),
which was noted in 93.3% of the children they studied.
4.2) Connection to Gluten-free dietary intervention
In terms of the gluten content, 73% of the carbohydrates the researcher observed
consumed during the meal-time setting contained gluten. The remaining 27% gluten-
free carbohydrates were rice or potato products. The food diaries in Appendix.6
depict a bleak scene in relation to a gluten-free diet; 6/7 children’s school-based food
diaries contain gluten, thus showing that the majority of these children’s weekly diets
include gluten. The only child that appears to have eliminated gluten from their diet is
Child F (Appendix.6.6) however this is due to a wheat intolerance. Therefore the
child has consciously had wheat removed from their diet and the lack of gluten is
merely a by-product of this intolerance. There is no information to suggest that Child
F does not eat gluten in other aspects of his life, for example in the home setting.
From these results it can be concluded that no participants were actively following a
gluten-free diet specifically as a dietary intervention for autism. This suggests that
either the parents of these children were not aware of information regarding gluten-
free dietary intervention, or that they had actively chosen not to pursue this form of
intervention. Regardless of the reason it indicates that in this study gluten-free
dietary interventions were not a common choice amongst families of children with
autism. According to the Interactive Autism Network (IAN) 2014, an online project
involving families of children with autism in the United States found that “more than
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
50 |
16% of participating families are using special diets to treat their child’s autism” (IAN,
2014). Whilst the geographical factor of the IAN project differs from that of the
research within this study it still provides a comparable overview of the popularity of
dietary interventions. IAN 2014 found that diets which removed certain substances
were most common. The most frequent dietary interventions they noted were gluten-
free diets, casein-free diets or a combined GF/CF diet.
4.3) Connection to Casein-free dietary intervention
As Isherwood et al 2011 highlight, many children with autism will only eat certain
foods. “The majority of foods they will accept are gluten/casein containing foods eg:
bread and milk” (Isherwood et al, 2011, page 58). It isn’t uncommon for typically
developing children to want foods that are not as nutritionally beneficial as foods
such as fruits or vegetables, but it is easier in terms of their cognitive development to
explain why they must consume a balanced diet. For children with autism, the
cognitive and comprehensive skills needed to elicit an understanding of the
importance of balanced nutritional intake are often lacking or even non-existent.
Therefore it becomes difficult to wean them onto a diet that eliminates these foods.
Milk in particular is a food that children receive from birth therefore the connection
with milk is often very well established by the time the child is diagnosed with autism.
When looking at the data collected in the observational research, the low number of
instances of dairy consumption shown in Figure.2) would please many DAN doctors
and believers in a casein-free diet for autistic children. Figure.1) shows that only 10%
of the overall nutrient consumption was comprised of dairy products. As casein is a
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
51 |
milk protein it is found in most dairy products including cheese, butter, milk and
yoghurt, however according to Table 1) there were only 2 types of dairy available in
the school meal-time setting.
4.4) Case Study
The Case Study of Child X provides a vital insight into the possible success that
dietary interventions can have for children with autism. It outlines the strict regime
and lengthy process that is involved in a gluten and dairy-free diet and nutritional
supplementation as set out by a Clinical Nutritionist (CN). The findings of the case
study clearly show that changing the diet of a child with autism can have positive and
beneficial effects on the child’s behaviour, cognitive processed and socio-emotional
development. The next section will break down these effects and the results of Child
X’s dietary intervention.
4.5) Speech and Language Development
Child X had a severe language delay and was still not talking by the age of 4. The
case study shows that Child X’s first noted correct use of speech and language
appeared the day after Child X began to follow a gluten and dairy free diet. The
child’s father asked him to take a flower to his mother and utter the word “mummy”.
His compliance with this instruction proved that not only did he understand the
language used by his father; he also correctly used the word “mummy”. Although
there is no direct proof that Child X’s sudden language acquisition is linked to him
commencing the dietary intervention, it appears too much of a coincidence to
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
52 |
disregard it. After a complete lack of verbal communication and language skills whilst
on a normal, un-intervened diet, Child X’s dietary change appears to have been
caused by, or at least encouraged by, the removal of gluten and dairy products in his
diet.
4.6) Cognitive Development and Motor Skills
Figure.7) shows a self-portrait that Child X painted at his school. It shows that Child
X has good hand-eye coordination and motor skills and a clear comprehension of the
‘self’. The case study shows that at 2 years 10 months, Child X was demonstrating
good playing skills and the ability to climb on a climbing frame. This indicates that his
motor skills were already developing. However the case study shows that at 3 years
and 3 months he wasn’t able to ‘draw a circle’ as his fine motor skills were not yet
mature enough. Ozonoff et al 2008 conducted a study on the early development of
children later diagnosed with autism in which they found “a delay in the appearance
of motor milestones” (Ozonoff et al 2008). However, Figure.7) indicates that Child
X’s fine motor skills have progressed greatly in correlation with his dietary
intervention. Results of the intervention listed in the case study also include the
ability to ride a scooter. Not only does this involve motor skills and balance; he learnt
and understood how to use the scooter from watching his father play on it. This
demonstrates good cognitive development and maturation of motor skills. Baranek
2002 conducted a study on the efficacy of sensory and motor interventions for
autistic children. She found that “empirical evidence converges to confirm the
existence of sensory and motor difficulties for many children with autism at some
point in their early development” (Baranek, 2002, page 397). This quote supports
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
53 |
Child X’s initial inability to perform small tasks that require motor skills. Whilst
Baranek found some beneficial effects from motor and sensory interventions, the
case study focuses on the dietary intervention that Child X received and the positive
effects this change in diet had on his motor skills.
4.7) Limitations
It must be noted that there were limitations to this research study. Firstly, in the
observational research, the overall number of participants was not noted. This was
due to the open plan style of the dining hall which allowed the children to come and
go throughout the lunch sitting. On reflection, a head count of the children as they
entered the dining hall would have solved this issue.
A second limitation of the research was the questionnaires. Whilst they would have
provided a further contextual dimension to the research, the lack of response to the
questionnaires meant that they had to be discarded. This limitation could be
attributed to the scope of parents the questionnaire was sent to. A high percentage
of parents of children at the school used for research did not have English as a first
language therefore could not fully comprehend the questions being asked.
The final limitation of this body of work has been the vast spectrum of information
accumulated through research and the restricted word count of this study. The
researcher found that prioritisation of data and information meant that other
contextual information and interesting findings had to be omitted.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
54 |
Chapter_5.0
Conclusion
In regards to the findings from the observational research and the food diaries
produced in this body of work it can be clearly determined that dietary interventions
are by no means commonly used for children with autism. The only form of restricted
diet found during this research was the removal of wheat products due to a wheat
intolerance. However, the fact that research was only conducted on one day and
results of the school-based food diaries only spanned 5 days means that the results
are restricted. There is a platform here for further research to be conducted on a
much wider scale to determine the incidence rate of dietary interventions for children
with autism.
Results from this paper found that carbohydrates, in particular refined carbohydrates,
were the most common food choice amongst children with autism and their intake
was high, yet they can have detrimental effects on the child’s body. The literature
review section explored the effects of a Candida increase in the body, which can
lead to gastro-intestinal issues including constipation and more serious effects on the
nervous and immune systems. Further study on the link between carbohydrates and
children with autism could be conducted to determine the exact (or differing) effects
of a carbohydrate rich diet on the body of an autistic child, and whether refining the
carbohydrate makes any difference.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
55 |
The case study of Child-X provides a true example of the positive effects that dietary
interventions can have on a child with autism. The improvement in his speech and
language skills is remarkable; Child-X transformed from a child with a complete lack
of verbal skills to a child able to cite words and use words properly. His motor skills
also improved dramatically; initially prior to intervention Child-X couldn’t draw a
circle. Figure.7) illustrates his ability now to paint a self-portrait, using matured fine
motor skills.
Although the case study on Child-X highlights the benefits of dietary intervention for
a child with autism, it also reveals the financial impact it can have on this child’s
family. A cost of £300- £550 a month plus supplements and tests and the added
expense of buying organic, gluten free and dairy free products puts this form of
dietary intervention beyond the reach of many families with autistic children. As it is
unavailable on the NHS it makes this form of dietary intervention impossible for
families of restricted income to afford. This is an area that could particularly benefit
from further research into ways of limiting the financial strains of dietary interventions
and the accompanying lifestyle changes for children with autism and their families.
Overall, it can be concluded that intervening in the diet of a child with autism can
have a positive and beneficial effect. The case study provides evidence to support
this statement, whilst the review of literature reveals the numerous effects that
different nutrients and diets can have on these children. As the researcher intended,
an insight into the vast scope of different dietary ‘treatments’ has been provided and
the subsequent success of such ‘treatments’ has been discussed. To fully
understand the extent of the positive effects dietary interventions on autistic children
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
56 |
further research and a longitudinal study are imperative. The main objective of this
study however was to provide a deeper understanding of dietary interventions with
particular reference to GF/CF diets, as an informative document for anyone with a
link to autism.
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
57 |
References:
1. Anderson. G, Arsenault. N, 2005, Fundamentals of Educational Research, 2nd
ed. London: The Falmer Press
2. Angley. M, Semple. S, Hewton. C, Paterson. F, McKinnon. R, 2007, Children
and autism: Part 2- management with complementary medicines and dietary
interventions, Australian Family Physician, Volume 36, Issue No. 10
3. Baranek. GT, 2002, Efficacy of Sensory and Motor Interventions for Children
with Autism, Journal of Autism and Development Disorders, Volume 32, Issue
No. 5, Kluwer Academic Publishers
4. Brantlinger. E, Odom. SL, Gersten. R, Horner. RH, Thompson. B, Harris. KR,
Research in Special Education: Scientific Methods and Evidence-Based
Practices, Council for Exceptional Children, Volume 71, Issue No. 2, Pages
137-148
5. Brill. MT, 2001, Keys to Parenting the Child with Autism, Barron’s Educational
Series, 2nd Ed. Hauppauge, NY: Barron’s Educational Series Inc.
6. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 2008. Using Graphs and
Charts to Illustrate Quantitative Data, Issue No.12, Atlanta: Department of
Health and Human Services, Pages 1-2
7. Davies. MB, 2007, Doing a Successful Research Project: Using qualitative or
quantitative methods, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan
8. Davies. S, 2012, Parallel Universe, Bloomington: Xlibris Corporation
9. Department for Education and Skills (DFES), 2005, Turning the tables:
transforming school food: main report : a report on the development and
implementation of nutritional standards for school lunches, [Online] [Accessed
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
58 |
20/03/2014] Available from:
http://dera.ioe.ac.uk/5584/3/SMRP%20Report%20FINAL.pdf
10.Department of Health, 2010, School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme, The
National Archives, [Online] [Accessed 17/03/2014] Available from:
http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publichealth/H
ealthimprovement/FiveADay/FiveADaygeneralinformation/DH_4002149
11.Edelson. SM, 2003, The Candida Yeast-Autism Connection, Oregon: Centre
for the Study of Autism
12.Elder. JH, Shankar. M, Shuster. J, Theriaque. D, Burns. S, Sherrill. L, 2006.
The Gluten-Free, Casein-Free Diet In Autism: Results of A Preliminary Double
Blind Clinical Trial, Journal of Autism and Development Disorders, Volume 36,
Issue No. 3, 413-420
13.Green. VA, Pituch. KA, Itchon. J, Choi. A, O’Reilly. M, Sigafoos. J, 2006 as
cited in Hess. KL, MJ. Morrier, LJ. Heflin, ML. Ivey, 2008, Autism Treatment
Survey: Services Received by Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders in
Public School Classrooms, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,
Volume 38, Issue No. 5, Page 962
14.Gregory. I, 2003, as cited in Wiles. R, Crow. G, Heath. S, Charles. V, 2006,
Anonymity and Confidentiality, [Online] Accessed: 01/03/2014] Available from:
http://www.ccsr.ac.uk/methods/festival/programme/aac/documents/anonandc
onfpaperRMF06.pdf
15.Hanson. E, Kalish. LA, Bunce. E, Curtis. C, McDaniel. S, Ware. J, Petry. J,
2006, Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine among Children
Diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder, Journal of Autism and
Developmental Disorders, Volume 37, [Accessed Online: 01/03/2014]
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
59 |
Available from:
http://download.springer.com/static/pdf/754/art%253A10.1007%252Fs10803-
006-0192-
0.pdf?auth66=1395319284_72b13904e64ebf0713af9bd81b881d20&ext=.pdf
16.Hess. KL, MJ. Morrier, LJ. Heflin, ML. Ivey, 2008, Autism Treatment Survey:
Services Received by Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders in Public
School Classrooms, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, Volume
38, Issue No. 5, Page 962
17.Interactive Autism Network (IAN), 2014, IAN Research Report: Special Diets,
[Online] [Accessed 01/04/2014] Available from:
http://www.autismspeaks.org/news/news-item/ian-research-report-special-
diets
18.Isherwood. E, Spicer. B, Thomas. K, 2011, Dietary Management of Autism
Spectrum Disorder, The British Dietetic Association, Accessed Online
[24/03/2014] Available from:
http://www.bda.uk.com/publications/statements/DietaryManagementAutism.pd
f
19.Knivsberg. AM, Reichelt. KL, Hoien. T, Nodland. M, 2002, A randomized,
controlled study of dietary intervention in autistic syndromes, Nutritional
Neuroscience, Volume 5, Issue No. 4, 251-261
20.Lee. R, 2011, Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) and Autistic
Spectrum Disorders: Feedback From Parents and Carers Following Child’s
CAM Intervention, Children’s Complementary Therapy Network, Accessed
Online [10/04/2014] Available from:
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
60 |
http://freshwinds.org.uk/publications/CAM-and-Autistic-Spectrum-Disorder-
feedback-report_FINAL.pdf
21.Levin. JR, O’Donnell. AM, Kratochwill. TR, 2003, as cited in Brantlinger. E,
Odom. SL, Gersten. R, Horner. RH, Thompson. B, Harris. KR, Research in
Special Education: Scientific Methods and Evidence-Based Practices, Council
for Exceptional Children, Volume 71, Issue No. 2, Pages 137-148
22.McCandless. J, 2007, Children with Starving Brains: A Medical Treatment
Guide for Autism Spectrum Disorder, 3rd Edition, Florida: Bramble Books
23.Millward. C, Ferriter. M, Calver. SJ, Connell-Jones. GG, 2008, Gluten- and
casein-free diets for autistic spectrum disorder, Cochrane Database of
Systematic Reviews, Issue No. 2.
24.Oliver. P, 2003, as cited in Wiles. R, Crow. G, Heath. S, Charles. V, 2006,
Anonymity and Confidentiality, [Online] Accessed: 01/03/2014] Available from:
http://www.ccsr.ac.uk/methods/festival/programme/aac/documents/anonandc
onfpaperRMF06.pdf
25.Ozonoff. S, Young. GS, Goldring. S, Greiss-Hess. L, Herrera. AM, Steele. J,
Macari. S, Hepburn. S, Rogers. SJ, 2008, as cited in Haywood. K, Roberton.
M, Getchell. N, 2012, Advanced analysis of Motor Development, Leeds:
Human Kinetics
26.Panksepp. J, 1979, A neurochemical theory of autism, Point of View,
Amsterdam: Elsevier/North Holland Biomedical Press, Pages 174-177
27.Schreibman. L E, 2007, The Science and Fiction of Autism, Cambridge
Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, Page 23
28.Shattock. P, Whiteley. P, 2002, Biochemical aspects in autism spectrum
disorders: updating the opioid-excess theory and presenting new
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
61 |
opportunities for biomedical intervention, Expert opinion on therapeutic
targets, Volume 6, Issue No.2, Pages 175-183
29.Shaw. W, 2002, Biological Treatments for Autism and PDD, 2nd ed. Lenexa:
Great Plain Laboratory Inc.
30.Smeltzer. B, 2011, The Medical Side of the GF/CF Diet for Autism: What is
being treated and why it isn’t just “Autism”, Autism Science Digest: The
Journal of Autism One, Issue 01, [Accessed Online: 27/02/2014] Available
from: http://www.healingprovisions.net/PDF/ASD01p19-15_Smeltzer.pdf
31.Srinivasan. P, 2009, A review of dietary interventions in autism, Dietary
Interventions in Autism, Annals of Clinical Psychiatry, Volume 21, Issue No. 4
American Academy of Clinical Psychiatrists, Abingdon: Taylor & Francis,
Pages 237-247
32.Taylor. B, Jick. H, MacLaughlin. D, 2013, Prevalence and incidence rates of
autism in the UK: time trend from 2004-2010 in children aged 8 years, British
Medical Journal: London, Volume 3, Issue No. 10. Pages 1-8
33.The National Autistic Society, 2014, Statistics: how many people have autism
spectrum disorders? Autism.org.uk, [Online] 27th February [Accessed
05/05/2014] Available from: http://www.autism.org.uk/about-autism/myths-
facts-and-statistics/statistics-how-many-people-have-autism-spectrum-
disorders.aspx
34.Tommey. J, Tommey. P, 2011, Autism: A practical guide to improving your
child’s quality of life, London: Piatkus
35.Vaisman. N, Voet. H, Akivis. A, Vakil. E, 1996, Effect of breakfast timing on
the cognitive functions of elementary school students, Archives of Paediatrics
and Adolescent Medicine, Volume 150, Issue No. 10, 1089-1092
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
62 |
36.Wiles. R, Crow. G, Heath. S, Charles. V, 2006, Anonymity and Confidentiality,
[Online] Accessed: 01/03/2014] Available from:
http://www.ccsr.ac.uk/methods/festival/programme/aac/documents/anonandc
onfpaperRMF06.pdf
37.Williams. BL, Hornig. M, Buie. T, Bauman. ML, Paik. MC, Wick. I, Bennett. A,
Jabado. O, Hirschberg. DL, Lipkin. IW, 2011, Impaired Carbohydrate
Digestion and Transport and Mucosal Dysbiosis in the Intestines of Children
with Autism and Gastrointestinal Disturbances, Plos One, [Online] [Accessed
10/04/2014] Available from:
http://www.plosone.org/article/fetchObject.action?uri=info%3Adoi%2F10.1371
%2Fjournal.pone.0024585&representation=PDF
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
63 |
Appendices
The following pages comprise Appendix.1 to Appendix.9.
 Appendix.1- Research Checklist
 Appendix.2- Parent Information Letter
 Appendix.3- Secondary Information Letter
 Appendix.4- Consent Form (Observation)
 Appendix.5- Consent Form (Questionnaire/ Food Diary)
 Appendix.6-
6.1 Child A Food Diary
6.2 Child B Food Diary
6.3 Child C Food Diary
6.4 Child D Food Diary
6.5 Child E Food Diary
6.6 Child F Food Diary
6.7 Child G Food Diary
 Appendix.7- Child H Food Diary
 Appendix.8- Research Questionnaire
 Appendix.9- Scanned Menu Image
Chapter_7.0
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
64 |
Food
Group
(eg carb,
protein)
Individual
Food (eg
crisps,
chocolate)
No. of
Children
Eating This
Food
Drink (eg
water,
juice,
coke)
No. of
Children
Drinking
This Drink
Solid
Food
Blended
Food
Restricted
Diet
Appendix.1
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
65 |
Dear Parent/ Carer
Dietary Intervention for Children with Autism Questionnaire
Observation of Children During Meal-Time
I would like to invite you to take part in a questionnaire as part of a research project
from the School of Education at the University of Leeds. I am looking into the positive
effect that dietary interventions can have on children with Autism. The topic is
informed by the Defeat Autism Now (DAN) campaign which is a biomedical approach
to treating autism that focuses on the child’s diet. It involves various intervention
approaches ranging from removing certain ingredients from the diet, for example
yeast and gluten; and testing for hidden food allergies. My questionnaire is designed
to gather information on the typical diets that children with autism have and the food
that they eat at home. I also want to know if you are aware of the DAN campaign or
have even tried any of the dietary interventions with your children.
I would like to ask your permission also to include your child in my research. I would
like to observe your child during their lunch-time at school, to establish their attitudes
towards their food and to see which foods they generally seem to prefer. I will be
asking a few questions if appropriate on what they are eating and what foods/ drinks
they like but there will be no formal interview, only observational interaction. If you do
not give your consent for my observation, your child will be removed from any
research however if you do return the questionnaire I will still be able to use your
answers within the research project. Any information given by your child will only be
used to inform my research; I will uphold complete anonymity within my data.
I have a DBS form from the University of Leeds and 5 years’ experience working with
children with Autism and other disabilities, running holiday play-schemes for the
children where I have responsibilities such as feeding, changing, entertaining and
playing with the children. It is anticipated that this research project will shed some
light on an intervention approach that has been little researched and provide positive
results that could potentially benefit future approaches to interventions for Autism.
25/11/2013
Appendix.2
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
66 |
If you would like to participate in this questionnaire and agree to the use of your
answers within this research project please sign the consent form paired with this
information letter. If you have any further questions concerning this project or the
way in which your input will be used do not hesitate to contact me. In the meantime, I
thank you for any help you are able to give me. If for any reason you wish to be
removed from the research you are entitled to do so without providing a reason.
If you give consent for your child to be observed in their meal time setting and for
these observations to be used within the research project please sign the second
part of the consent form. It is not essential that you consent to both parts of this
research project; you can choose to opt out of it completely or to only consent to one
part. Complete anonymity will be upheld throughout the research and I will make the
findings accessible to you once they have been drawn up so you will be kept
informed throughout the research process. If you have any further queries please
contact Mary Chambers who will be supervising this project.
Dr Mary Chambers (M.E.Chambers@education.leeds.ac.uk)
Room G.04, School of Education (Hillary Place)
University of Leeds
LS2 9JT
0113 343 3576
Kind regards,
Louisa Pielichaty
62 Harold Terrace
Leeds
West Yorkshire
LS61LD
07799200253
Louisapielichaty@gmail.com
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
67 |
Dear Parent/ Carer
Dietary Intervention for Children with Autism Questionnaire/ Food Diary
I would like to invite you to take part in a questionnaire and/or a food diary as part of
a research project for my dissertation at the School of Education at the University of
Leeds. I am looking into the effect that dietary interventions can have on children
with Autism. The topic is informed by the Defeat Autism Now (DAN) campaign which
is a biomedical approach to treating autism that focuses on the child’s diet. It
involves various intervention approaches ranging from removing certain ingredients
from the diet, for example yeast and gluten; and testing children for hidden food
allergies. My questionnaire is designed to gather information on the typical diets that
children with autism have and the food that they eat at home. My food diary is
designed to gather an example of a typical week’s food and drink for your child. I
want to outline immediately that there are no right or wrong answers and that the
results of this questionnaire will be completely anonymous and that the food diary is
to be completed however you see fit.
I am also looking to find out if you are aware at all of the ‘DAN’ campaign or have
whether you have ever tried any dietary interventions with your children. I would like
to know if you have ever tried restricted diets or simply cutting out certain foods or
food groups for your children. The attached questionnaire explores this in more
detail.
I have a DBS form from the University of Leeds and 5 years’ experience working with
children with Autism and other disabilities, running holiday play-schemes for the
children where I have responsibilities such as feeding, changing, entertaining and
playing with the children. It is anticipated that this research project will shed some
light on an intervention approach that has been little researched and provide positive
results that could potentially benefit future approaches to interventions for Autism.
If you would like to participate in this questionnaire/ food diary and agree to the use
of your answers within this research project please sign the consent form paired with
02/01/2014
Appendix.3
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
68 |
this information letter. If you have any further questions concerning this project or the
way in which your input will be used do not hesitate to contact me. In the meantime, I
thank you for any help you are able to give me. If for any reason you wish to be
removed from the research you are entitled to do so without providing a reason.
Complete anonymity will be upheld throughout the research and I will make the
findings accessible to you once they have been drawn up so you will be kept
informed throughout the research process. If you have any further queries please
contact Mary Chambers who will be supervising this project:
Dr Mary Chambers (M.E.Chambers@education.leeds.ac.uk)
Room G.04, School of Education (Hillary Place)
University of Leeds
LS2 9JT
0113 343 3576
Kind regards,
Louisa Pielichaty
62 Harold Terrace
Leeds
West Yorkshire
LS61LD
07799200253
Ed11lp@leeds.ac.uk
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
69 |
Consent to Observations of my Child in Meal Time Setting
Add your initials next to the
statements you agree with
I confirm that I have read and understand the information letter
dated 25/11/2013 explaining the above research project and I
have had the opportunity to ask questions about the project.
I understand that my child’s participation is voluntary and that
they are free to withdraw at any time without giving any reason
and without there being any negative consequences. In
addition, should they not wish to answer any particular
question or questions, they are free to decline.
Contact: Louisa Pielichaty Louisapielichaty@gmail.com
07799200253
By agreeing for your child to take part in the research project
you are agreeing for data collected by the research team to be
used in publications and future research.
I consent to my child taking part in (initial all which apply):
a. every aspect of the research project including
questions during observations.
b. just observations with no questions.
I do not want my child to be involved in the research project at
all.
I give permission formembers of the research team to have access to
my child’s anonymised responses. I understand that their name will
not be linked with the research materials, and they will not be
identified or identifiable in the report or reports that result from the
research.
I understand that my child’s research responses willbe kept strictly
confidential.
I agree for the data collectedfrom my child to be used in relevant
future research.
I give permission formy answers to the questionnaire to be used to
inform the research project. I understand that my name willnot be
linked with the research materials, and I will not be identified or
identifiable in the report or reports that result from the research. I
understand that my research responses will be kept strictly
confidential.
By agreeing to take part in the research project I am agreeing
for data collected by the research team to be used in
publications and future research.
I do not wish to be part of this research project and will not be
Appendix.4
Louisa Pielichaty 200624294
70 |
returning the questionnaire.
Consent to take part in Meal-Time Observations and
Questionnaire
Name of parent / carer
Parent / carer’s
signature
Date
Name of lead
researcher
Louisa Pielichaty
Signature
Date*
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation
Dissertation

More Related Content

What's hot

School health services
School health servicesSchool health services
School health servicesShivraj Dandgi
 
Sa'sha Moody - Systematic Review
Sa'sha Moody - Systematic ReviewSa'sha Moody - Systematic Review
Sa'sha Moody - Systematic ReviewSa'sha Moody
 
Community health worker
Community health  workerCommunity health  worker
Community health workerPamela Salong
 
Research proposal second draft
Research proposal second draftResearch proposal second draft
Research proposal second draftAmal Hayati
 
Enhancing academic development through school health education and promotion
Enhancing academic development through school health education and promotionEnhancing academic development through school health education and promotion
Enhancing academic development through school health education and promotionUte Inegbenebor
 
Httpwww.ijsr.netarchivev3i3 md iwmtmxmdiy.pdf
Httpwww.ijsr.netarchivev3i3 md iwmtmxmdiy.pdfHttpwww.ijsr.netarchivev3i3 md iwmtmxmdiy.pdf
Httpwww.ijsr.netarchivev3i3 md iwmtmxmdiy.pdfmahadeoshinde
 
School health 1234
School health 1234School health 1234
School health 1234Rahman Shuvo
 
MHNE 650 Thesis - Nutrition & Garden Education
MHNE 650 Thesis - Nutrition & Garden EducationMHNE 650 Thesis - Nutrition & Garden Education
MHNE 650 Thesis - Nutrition & Garden EducationJill Parsh
 
Maternal perception about neonatal jaundice in eastern nepal a qualitative study
Maternal perception about neonatal jaundice in eastern nepal a qualitative studyMaternal perception about neonatal jaundice in eastern nepal a qualitative study
Maternal perception about neonatal jaundice in eastern nepal a qualitative studydineshdharel13
 
Capstone powerpoint-Fever education in pediatric Emergency Room patients
Capstone powerpoint-Fever education in pediatric Emergency Room patientsCapstone powerpoint-Fever education in pediatric Emergency Room patients
Capstone powerpoint-Fever education in pediatric Emergency Room patientsElizabeth Hall
 
Preventive Pediatrics
Preventive PediatricsPreventive Pediatrics
Preventive PediatricsLiniVivek
 
Full Report Technical Writing
Full Report Technical Writing Full Report Technical Writing
Full Report Technical Writing Mal Mai
 
McLain Research Summary
McLain Research SummaryMcLain Research Summary
McLain Research SummaryMaggie McLain
 
Project Proposal Sample
Project Proposal SampleProject Proposal Sample
Project Proposal SampleThesally Sosa
 
Why Mothers Stop Breastfeeding Mothers Self Reported Reasons For Stopping Dur...
Why Mothers Stop Breastfeeding Mothers Self Reported Reasons For Stopping Dur...Why Mothers Stop Breastfeeding Mothers Self Reported Reasons For Stopping Dur...
Why Mothers Stop Breastfeeding Mothers Self Reported Reasons For Stopping Dur...Biblioteca Virtual
 

What's hot (20)

School health services
School health servicesSchool health services
School health services
 
Sa'sha Moody - Systematic Review
Sa'sha Moody - Systematic ReviewSa'sha Moody - Systematic Review
Sa'sha Moody - Systematic Review
 
Childhood Obesity EBR
Childhood Obesity EBRChildhood Obesity EBR
Childhood Obesity EBR
 
Community health worker
Community health  workerCommunity health  worker
Community health worker
 
Research proposal second draft
Research proposal second draftResearch proposal second draft
Research proposal second draft
 
Enhancing academic development through school health education and promotion
Enhancing academic development through school health education and promotionEnhancing academic development through school health education and promotion
Enhancing academic development through school health education and promotion
 
Httpwww.ijsr.netarchivev3i3 md iwmtmxmdiy.pdf
Httpwww.ijsr.netarchivev3i3 md iwmtmxmdiy.pdfHttpwww.ijsr.netarchivev3i3 md iwmtmxmdiy.pdf
Httpwww.ijsr.netarchivev3i3 md iwmtmxmdiy.pdf
 
School health 1234
School health 1234School health 1234
School health 1234
 
Addiction_Families
Addiction_FamiliesAddiction_Families
Addiction_Families
 
MHNE 650 Thesis - Nutrition & Garden Education
MHNE 650 Thesis - Nutrition & Garden EducationMHNE 650 Thesis - Nutrition & Garden Education
MHNE 650 Thesis - Nutrition & Garden Education
 
Maternal perception about neonatal jaundice in eastern nepal a qualitative study
Maternal perception about neonatal jaundice in eastern nepal a qualitative studyMaternal perception about neonatal jaundice in eastern nepal a qualitative study
Maternal perception about neonatal jaundice in eastern nepal a qualitative study
 
Capstone powerpoint-Fever education in pediatric Emergency Room patients
Capstone powerpoint-Fever education in pediatric Emergency Room patientsCapstone powerpoint-Fever education in pediatric Emergency Room patients
Capstone powerpoint-Fever education in pediatric Emergency Room patients
 
Preventive Pediatrics
Preventive PediatricsPreventive Pediatrics
Preventive Pediatrics
 
Full Report Technical Writing
Full Report Technical Writing Full Report Technical Writing
Full Report Technical Writing
 
School health,ra
School health,raSchool health,ra
School health,ra
 
McLain Research Summary
McLain Research SummaryMcLain Research Summary
McLain Research Summary
 
Project Proposal Sample
Project Proposal SampleProject Proposal Sample
Project Proposal Sample
 
Resume 2016 MLS
Resume 2016 MLSResume 2016 MLS
Resume 2016 MLS
 
Why Mothers Stop Breastfeeding Mothers Self Reported Reasons For Stopping Dur...
Why Mothers Stop Breastfeeding Mothers Self Reported Reasons For Stopping Dur...Why Mothers Stop Breastfeeding Mothers Self Reported Reasons For Stopping Dur...
Why Mothers Stop Breastfeeding Mothers Self Reported Reasons For Stopping Dur...
 
Austin Public Health
Austin Public HealthAustin Public Health
Austin Public Health
 

Similar to Dissertation

Childhood obesity-Qafqaz University .ppt
Childhood obesity-Qafqaz University .pptChildhood obesity-Qafqaz University .ppt
Childhood obesity-Qafqaz University .pptCeyhun Teymurzade
 
Summer Internships 2015
Summer Internships 2015Summer Internships 2015
Summer Internships 2015Emily Wasson
 
Aracy unsettled infant behaviour report final (2)
Aracy unsettled infant behaviour report final (2)Aracy unsettled infant behaviour report final (2)
Aracy unsettled infant behaviour report final (2)Tweddle Australia
 
Local Determinants of Malnutrition: An Expanded Positive Deviance Study
Local Determinants of Malnutrition: An Expanded Positive Deviance StudyLocal Determinants of Malnutrition: An Expanded Positive Deviance Study
Local Determinants of Malnutrition: An Expanded Positive Deviance Studyjehill3
 
Teenage Mothers Care Practices_Summary
Teenage Mothers Care Practices_SummaryTeenage Mothers Care Practices_Summary
Teenage Mothers Care Practices_SummaryKrystle Lai
 
Template Childhood Obesity ECE 2023 - EN.pdf
Template Childhood Obesity ECE 2023 - EN.pdfTemplate Childhood Obesity ECE 2023 - EN.pdf
Template Childhood Obesity ECE 2023 - EN.pdfDanielMedina870602
 
Kessler Research Issue Brief
Kessler Research Issue BriefKessler Research Issue Brief
Kessler Research Issue BriefJordan Kessler
 
Teaching Experience Nursing Question.pdf
Teaching Experience Nursing Question.pdfTeaching Experience Nursing Question.pdf
Teaching Experience Nursing Question.pdfsdfghj21
 
research proposal final
research proposal  finalresearch proposal  final
research proposal finalRabia Bashir
 
ASD Food Lab This Way to Sustainability
ASD Food Lab This Way to SustainabilityASD Food Lab This Way to Sustainability
ASD Food Lab This Way to SustainabilityVeronica VanCleave
 
Chappell_OT674_Poster
Chappell_OT674_PosterChappell_OT674_Poster
Chappell_OT674_PosterAnya Chappell
 
Spotting and Supporting Eating Disorders in School - Recommendations from Sch...
Spotting and Supporting Eating Disorders in School - Recommendations from Sch...Spotting and Supporting Eating Disorders in School - Recommendations from Sch...
Spotting and Supporting Eating Disorders in School - Recommendations from Sch...Pooky Knightsmith
 
Overview of autism and woods edge
Overview of autism and woods edgeOverview of autism and woods edge
Overview of autism and woods edgePrepracticum
 
Running head SOURCE SUMMARY 1SOURCE SUMARRY.docx
Running head SOURCE SUMMARY                    1SOURCE SUMARRY.docxRunning head SOURCE SUMMARY                    1SOURCE SUMARRY.docx
Running head SOURCE SUMMARY 1SOURCE SUMARRY.docxagnesdcarey33086
 
Overview of autism and WoodsEdge
Overview of autism and WoodsEdgeOverview of autism and WoodsEdge
Overview of autism and WoodsEdgeColette Gillis
 

Similar to Dissertation (20)

Childhood obesity-Qafqaz University .ppt
Childhood obesity-Qafqaz University .pptChildhood obesity-Qafqaz University .ppt
Childhood obesity-Qafqaz University .ppt
 
Summer Internships 2015
Summer Internships 2015Summer Internships 2015
Summer Internships 2015
 
Aracy unsettled infant behaviour report final (2)
Aracy unsettled infant behaviour report final (2)Aracy unsettled infant behaviour report final (2)
Aracy unsettled infant behaviour report final (2)
 
Local Determinants of Malnutrition: An Expanded Positive Deviance Study
Local Determinants of Malnutrition: An Expanded Positive Deviance StudyLocal Determinants of Malnutrition: An Expanded Positive Deviance Study
Local Determinants of Malnutrition: An Expanded Positive Deviance Study
 
Teenage Mothers Care Practices_Summary
Teenage Mothers Care Practices_SummaryTeenage Mothers Care Practices_Summary
Teenage Mothers Care Practices_Summary
 
Template Childhood Obesity ECE 2023 - EN.pdf
Template Childhood Obesity ECE 2023 - EN.pdfTemplate Childhood Obesity ECE 2023 - EN.pdf
Template Childhood Obesity ECE 2023 - EN.pdf
 
Kessler Research Issue Brief
Kessler Research Issue BriefKessler Research Issue Brief
Kessler Research Issue Brief
 
Teaching Experience Nursing Question.pdf
Teaching Experience Nursing Question.pdfTeaching Experience Nursing Question.pdf
Teaching Experience Nursing Question.pdf
 
research proposal final
research proposal  finalresearch proposal  final
research proposal final
 
ASD Food Lab This Way to Sustainability
ASD Food Lab This Way to SustainabilityASD Food Lab This Way to Sustainability
ASD Food Lab This Way to Sustainability
 
Health supervision
Health supervisionHealth supervision
Health supervision
 
Chappell_OT674_Poster
Chappell_OT674_PosterChappell_OT674_Poster
Chappell_OT674_Poster
 
Spotting and Supporting Eating Disorders in School - Recommendations from Sch...
Spotting and Supporting Eating Disorders in School - Recommendations from Sch...Spotting and Supporting Eating Disorders in School - Recommendations from Sch...
Spotting and Supporting Eating Disorders in School - Recommendations from Sch...
 
Overview of autism and woods edge
Overview of autism and woods edgeOverview of autism and woods edge
Overview of autism and woods edge
 
Running head SOURCE SUMMARY 1SOURCE SUMARRY.docx
Running head SOURCE SUMMARY                    1SOURCE SUMARRY.docxRunning head SOURCE SUMMARY                    1SOURCE SUMARRY.docx
Running head SOURCE SUMMARY 1SOURCE SUMARRY.docx
 
Written lesson plan
Written lesson planWritten lesson plan
Written lesson plan
 
Obesity 1
Obesity 1Obesity 1
Obesity 1
 
Overview of autism and WoodsEdge
Overview of autism and WoodsEdgeOverview of autism and WoodsEdge
Overview of autism and WoodsEdge
 
obesity
obesityobesity
obesity
 
feasibility study
feasibility studyfeasibility study
feasibility study
 

Dissertation

  • 1. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 1 | University of Leeds SCHOOL OF EDUCATION Online Submission of Assessed Work Student Name Louisa Pielichaty Student ID number 200624294 Degree programme Childhood Studies Module code EDUC 3805 Module title Dissertation Dissertation Title The Effects of Dietary Intervention on Children with Autism: A Case Study. Dissertation supervisor Mary Chambers Word count 10991
  • 2. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 2 | The Effects of Dietary Intervention on Children with Autism: A Case Study. LOUISA PIELICHATY STUDENT NUMBER: 200624294 MODULE CODE: EDUC3805- DISSERTATION WORD COUNT: 10991 DISSERTATION SUPERVISOR: MARY CHAMBERS FRIDAY 16TH MAY 2014
  • 3. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 3 | Acknowledgements I must start by acknowledging the special school at which I conducted my research for this body of work and thank you for allowing me to come into your school and complete my observations. In particular I would like to thank the Head Teacher for taking the time to meet with me and provide me with some excellent contextual information. I would also like to thank the other staff at this school, including the catering staff who were so helpful in providing information regarding school meals and showing me how the catering services work. I am so grateful to the teaching assistants who took the time to complete the requested food diaries. I must also thank the parent who returned the 7 day food diary, your input provided a new dimension to the findings. I extend my thanks to the 3 parents who returned the questionnaires I sent out. Unfortunately due to the limited amount of returned questionnaires the results had to be discarded, however the results of these questionnaires were used to inform my research and provide relevant contextual information for me as a researcher. I particularly owe thanks to the parents of Child X for not only allowing me to create a case study on their son but for also being so helpful and forthcoming in the collation of the case study details. Your help has been invaluable and I thank you for all the time you have given me in replying to my questions and meeting with me. I give huge thanks to my dissertation supervisor Mary Chambers for her constant support and help throughout my studies. She has been my first port of call whenever I’ve needed help and her guidance has been so reassuring. I would not have had such a clear direction in my writing had it not been for Mary. Thank you to the other members or staff at the School of Education who have also had to deal with my panics.
  • 4. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 4 | Special thanks goes to my family and friends for supporting me through all my research and making this difficult task that little bit more enjoyable. Finally I would like to thank all the children who were observed as part of my research and all those who were indirectly involved.
  • 5. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 5 | Contents Page Abstract……………………………………………………………………………….7 Introduction…………………………………………………………………………..8 1.0Literature Review………………………………………………………………10 1.1Treatment……………………………………………………………….10 1.2Dietary Intervention…………………………………………………….11 1.3Gluten and Casein Free Diets………………………………………..13 1.4Opioid-Excess Theory…………………………………………………15 1.5Biomedical Approach………………………………………………….17 1.6Defeat Autism Now! …………………………………………………...18 1.7Nutritional Standards…………………………………………………..19 1.8Carbohydrates and Candida………………………………………….21 2.0Methodology……………………………………………………………………24 2.1Participants……………………………………………………………..24 2.2Research Methods……………………………………………………..25 2.3Research Instruments………………………………………………….27 2.4Ethical Issues……………………………………………………….…..29 3.0 Presentation and Analysis of Findings………………………………………33 3.1Observational Research Results……………………………………..33 3.2Carbohydrates………………………………………………………….35 3.3Food Diaries…………………………………………………………….36 3.4School Lunch 4 Week Menu…………………………………………..37 3.5Case Study……………………………………………………………...38 3.6Results of Nutrient Supplementation and Dietary Intervention……44
  • 6. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 6 | 3.7Average Financial Costs of Treatment………………………………45 4.0 Discussion of Findings………………………………………………………..46 4.1Carbohydrates………………………………………………………….46 4.2Connection to Gluten-free Dietary Intervention……………………..49 4.3Connection to Casein-free Dietary Intervention…………………….50 4.4Case Study……………………………………………………………...51 4.5Speech and Language Development……………………..………….51 4.6Cognitive Development and Motor Skills…………………………….52 4.7Limitations……………………………………………………………….53 5.0 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………..54 6.0 References……………………………………………………………………..57 7.0 Appendices……………………………………………………………………..63
  • 7. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 7 | Abstract The purpose of this dissertation is to investigate the link between dietary interventions and children on the Autistic Spectrum. Through observational research and the completion of food diaries, the researcher looked at the types of foods consumed by a sample of children with autism both in a school and a home setting. Results of this research were compared against findings from a review of literature in the field of dietary and biomedical interventions. The prevalence of carbohydrate was a prominent finding in the research, with subsequent detrimental effects on children with autism discussed in regard to current research. The inclusion of a case study on a 5 year old boy with autism currently undergoing a dietary intervention provides a first-hand account of the possible benefits of such intervention. In his case, a gluten and lactose free diet coupled with nutritional supplement and organic produce has seen vast improvements on his behavioural, social and emotional development. Whilst the results of this case study highlight the positive impacts of dietary intervention on children with autism, further research is imperative to gain a greater understanding of this relationship as there is a lack of evidence in this field.
  • 8. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 8 | Introduction The focus of this body of work was to research the use of dietary interventions for children with autism; looking at the popularity of such interventions and examples of biomedical approaches. The prevalence of autism in today’s society is more than 1 in 100 people, with 1.1% of the UK population thought to be on the autistic spectrum (The National Autistic Society, 2014). Taylor et al, 2013, studied the prevalence of autism in the UK of children aged 8 between 2004 and 2010. Results found that during the 1990s, the annual incidence rates of autism increased “fivefold”, before reaching “a plateau in the early 2000s” (Taylor et al, 2013, page 1). Whilst the prevalence of autism is high, the awareness of dietary interventions and biomedical approaches to ‘treating’ autism is not as widely circulated. This lack of awareness provided the main contextual factor for the research conducted within this body of work. There was also a personal vested interest in this subject; the researcher has worked in the field of autism for over half a decade, and therefore much of the information gathered was relatable to the researcher’s own experience. The literature review section explores the vast scope of ‘treatment’ available for children with autism, with particular reference to biomedical and dietary approaches. The term ‘treatment’ is so highlighted as some people argue that autism is not a disease as such that needs ‘treatment’, but rather a disorder that needs ‘intervention’. The reader is therefore left to make his/her own mind up vis-à-vis the proper use of the word ‘treatment’. Gluten and casein-free diets feature throughout the literature review and the high level of gluten intake in children with autism is an ongoing theme running throughout this work.
  • 9. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 9 | The inclusion of a case study adds another dimension to this study as it provides primary data in terms of the effects of dietary intervention on a young boy with autism. The information for the case study was gathered first hand by the researcher and backed up by face to face contact with the child, known in this study as Child-X. Further research has been used to inform this study; the researcher conducted observational research in a special school and food diaries were also obtained. All data bar the food diaries was collected by the researcher first-hand; the food diaries were collated by each participant’s teaching assistant. Each aspect of the research is included in the presentation and analysis of findings section and the appendices and further evaluated in the discussion section. The overall focus of the study looks at the observational research results and the case study and links both to dietary interventions and the effects of certain food products on the body of a child with autism. This body of work aims to provide an informative and explorative study into the effects of diet and dietary intervention on a child with autism and to increase awareness of such ‘treatments’.
  • 10. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 10 | Chapter_1.0 Literature Review 1.1) Treatment There are numerous therapies and treatments available for children with autism which vary hugely in their approaches. The variety of approaches can be attributed to the vast differences and effects treatments have on individuals, as well as financial and social factors, including the availability of trained and knowledgeable professionals to deliver treatments or therapies. Green et al, 2006, conducted research into the plethora of treatments available to establish their typical use and popularity. They published a study in which they surveyed 552 families of children with autism, questioning them on their use of different treatments. Overall there were 111 different treatments recorded as used. Green et al 2006 found that on average “families were using seven treatments at the time they answered the survey, with one parent employing 47 treatments simultaneously” (Green et al 2006, page 962). This shows the vast scope of treatments and also suggests that many families are willing to try more than one treatment for their child. The anomalous result of 47 treatments, whilst an isolated case, provides an interesting platform for further exploration into why this particular parent needed to use such a large number of treatments. However Hess et al 2007 record no evidence of this having been questioned and therefore the article accepts this result as simply anomalous.
  • 11. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 11 | There is a lack of supporting information to explain the reasons why the families in this study used their individual number of treatments. This is a clear weakness of the study as this contextual information would have provided a greater understanding of parental considerations of treatments. It would have added value to findings; offering parental opinions on treatments and thus a deeper analysis of causal links between each child and their parents’ chosen treatments. Results of this study do show that speech therapy was the most common form of therapy. However Lee 2011 conducted research which disputes the popularity of speech therapy through her contradictory results. Lee gained feedback from 14 parents/carers of children with autism on their children’s use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines (CAMs). The study reported “dietary-based therapies to have been the most common form of CAM used by the parents for their children with ASD” (Lee, 2011, page 4). The vast range of 111 treatments recorded in Green et al’s study reflects diversity across families of autistic children. This review focuses on the effect that dietary and biomedical treatment can have on children with autism. 1.2) Dietary Intervention Dietary interventions or diet modification are classed under a group of treatments known as CAM; (Complementary and Alternative Medicine). CAMs are often used to “ameliorate the range of theorised biochemical abnormalities” (Angley et al. 2007 page 827) of children with Autistic Spectrum Disorder. They provide a form of treatment that you would not find in mainstream healthcare. The categorisation of CAMs covers a number of other treatments such as auditory integration therapy and craniosacral therapy. In a study conducted by Hanson et al 2006, parents of autistic
  • 12. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 12 | children were surveyed to determine the different types of CAM used to ‘treat’ their children and the parents’ beliefs surrounding these interventions. The study group consisted of 112 parents of children who were diagnosed with ASD between 1997 and 2003 and were patients of the Developmental Medicine Centre in Boston, USA. Parents were questioned on numerous factors including their demographic and their use of CAM. Similarities can be drawn with the aforementioned Green et al 2006 study which surveyed parental use of treatments for children with autism, not specifically CAMs. Overall, the findings of the research concluded that 74% of the families involved “had used interventions categorised by this study as CAM” (Hanson et al, 2006, page 631). Of the 112 parents, 43% recorded a use of diet modification as a biologically based therapy. These statistics highlight the popularity of biological therapies, yet the study shows that conventional therapies such as educational and sensory therapies are still the most widely used by parents. This contradicts Green et al’s results, who found that speech therapy was the most popular treatment. 94% of the parents involved in this study reported that they had used conventional therapies, which includes prescription drugs. According to Hanson et al’s 2006 findings, this form of therapy was given high rates in terms of usefulness and efficacy yet there is no explanation as to why they were approved so highly. However the discussion of this study reveals contradicting results in terms of the issues parents considered when selecting their therapy. Most families were concerned about “unacceptable side effects with prescription medication” (Hanson et al, 2006, page 633) and the safety of this medicine. This contradiction suggests issues with the reliability of this study.
  • 13. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 13 | The next section will look further into the dietary interventions and diet modification treatments available for autistic children. 1.3) Gluten and Casein Free Diets An example of a dietary intervention for children with autism is the gluten/ casein free diet (GF/CF diet). Gluten is a combination of proteins found commonly in wheat; casein is a milk protein. Many autistic children find that their bodies are unable to digest these proteins and therefore they can become harmful to them. Studies have shown that most children who have autism also have “inflamed gastrointestinal tracts” (McCandless, 2007, page 27). This can damage the child’s immune system as “70% of immune cells are in the digestive tract” (Davies, 2012, page 137). When foods containing gluten and casein are introduced to the intestinal tract, they can irritate and inflame the intestine causing symptoms such as stomach pains. According to McCandless 2007, autistic children with inflamed intestines are particularly susceptible to yeast infections and more specifically a species of yeast known as Candida. This will be explored further on in the review. Angley et al, 2007, published an article which highlights the issue of inconsistent results from research into the efficacy of GF/CF diets. She compared two studies which look at the results of GF/CF diets and their outcomes on children with autism. The first study was a randomised single blind study on 20 autistic children, conducted by Knivsberg et al, 2002. This study assessed the effect of “a gluten- casein free diet on children with autistic syndrome and urinary peptide abnormalities” (Elder et al, 2006, page 415). The children were separated into either the control
  • 14. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 14 | group or the experimental group. Findings showed that the experimental group who received the GF/CF diet exhibited improvements in “behaviour, non-verbal cognitive level and motor problems” (Elder et al, 2006, page 415). The second study was Elder et al’s 2006 efficacy study of GF/CF dietary interventions for children with autism. This study was a double-blind randomised study of 15 children conducted over 12 weeks. Results found “no statistically significant findings even though several parents reported improvement in their children” (Elder et al, 2006, page 413). This provides conflicting results to the success of Knivsberg et al’s 2002 study thus throwing the efficacy of GF/CF dietary interventions for autistic children into the air. From these results it is not possible to draw a substantial conclusion of the success of these diets. The difference in the ‘single-blind study’ and ‘double-blind study’ could provide a reason behind the differing results as the single-blind study conducted by Knivsberg et al 2002 risks the contamination of bias within its research. Elder et al 2006 have avoided the possibility of bias by using a style of research that renders all participants and researchers ignorant of which subjects are receiving what. Therefore it could be argued that Elder et al’s study has more reliability and thus more efficient results. However the sample sizes of both studies are too small to represent a sufficient average of the population of autistic children. As stated by Elder et al 2006, “a need still exists for rigorous controlled clinical trials evaluating both physiological and behavioural effects” (page 415). In 1991, Dr Kalle Reichelt studied the urine of children with autism and found that these children had high levels of peptides in their urine which were not found in the urine of typically developing children. Peptides are compounds which enable the
  • 15. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 15 | breakdown of protein and those found in the urine of the children studied derived from gluten and casein in the diet. Amongst those peptides found in the urine were casomorphins, which come from casein. These high levels of casomorphins can be explained by a lack of the specific enzyme needed to break this peptide down. Research into this specific enzyme was pioneered by Dr Alan Friedman 2000 and his colleagues. They looked into the possible role of a lack of the dipeptidyl peptidase- IV (DPP-IV) enzyme in children with autism. This is “the only known enzyme to break down casomorphins” (Smeltzer, 2011, page 16) and therefore vital to ensure the upkeep of protein levels within the body. DPP-IV is also imperative in the digestion of gluten and casein. According to Friedman et al 2000 this enzyme can be found in areas such as the small intestine and the blood-brain barrier which shows how widespread it can be. Through his research, Friedman et al 2000 found that nearly 100% of the autistic children involved in his studies had “casomorphin and gliadomorphin peptides in their urine unless they were on the GF/CF diet” (Smeltzer, 2011, page 16). McCandless 2007 describes how a lack of an active DPP-IV enzyme in the body can cause a build-up of ‘demorphins’. These are “opioid or morphine-like substances” (McCandless, 2007, page 27) which when accumulated in the body can be a contributing factor to autistic children often appearing “spaced out” (McCandless 2007 page 27). 1.4) Opioid-Excess Theory “It has been suggested that peptides from gluten and casein may have a role in the origins of autism and that the physiology and psychology of autism
  • 16. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 16 | might be explained by excessive opioid activity linked to these peptides” (Millward et al, 2008, page 2). The above quote introduces the theoretical basis for a diet free from gluten and casein; the ‘opioid excess theory’. McCandless’s 2007 idea that children can appear ‘spaced-out’ can be explained by this theory. It is suggested that the peptides excreted by the gluten and casein in the child’s diet are incompletely metabolised and remain active within the body, exhibiting opioid activity. Isherwood et al, 2011 propose that these ‘toxic’ peptides pass through into the central nervous system and “interfere with the neurotransmission causing altered or disrupted activity and altered-sensory input” (Isherwood et al, 2011, page 59). The opioid activity of the peptides can be likened to the effects of opiate drugs and can cause “significant problems with speech, communication, behaviour and social skills” (Tommey and Tommey, 2011, page 58). It compares the symptoms of autism with the behaviours exhibited when one is using opiates, such as heroin. Thus, the opioid-excess theory attempts to provide an explanation for the different behaviours and symptomatic tendencies observed in autistic children. Whilst this theory is being discussed in current society, the link between opiates and autism was highlighted by Jaak Panksepp 1979. Panksepp used research into the effect that low doses of narcotics such as morphine can have on emotionally compromised animals to explore the link between the opioid state of autism and the long-term effect of narcotics. He reported similarities between the opioid symptoms noted in children with autism and the effects of long-term morphine use (Shattock;
  • 17. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 17 | Whiteley, 2002, page 2). According to Panksepp 1979, the similarities found, which included a deficient desire for social companionship, “suggests that the underlying neurochemical imbalance in autistic children may be excessive, or unusual, activity in their own endogenous brain opiate systems”. (Panksepp, 1979, page 175) Whitely and Shattock, 2002, blame the success of these peptides entering into the central nervous system on an “abnormally permeable intestinal membrane” (Shattock; Whiteley, 2002, page 1) which allows the peptides to have a detrimental effect on the brain’s neurotransmitters. It permits the disruption of “a variety of biochemical and neuroregulatory processes” (Shattock; Whiteley, 2002, page 2). In context of the opioid-excess theory, Shattock and Whiteley promote the exclusion of food substances which subject a child to these harmful casomorphins and gliadomorphins. Thus, Shattock and Whiteley 2002 support the dietary intervention of removing gluten and casein from the diet of an autistic child. However, Schreibman wrote in 2007 that this theory “remains speculative at this point”; a contrasting and sceptical perspective on the opioid-excess theory. Schreibman draws attention to the fact that this is a ‘theory’ and therefore it will inevitably encounter scepticism and opposing opinions. 1.5) Biomedical Approach
  • 18. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 18 | There is much research and literature that delves deep into the field of biomedical approaches to treatment for children with autism. The biomedical causes of autism are widely discussed amongst Defeat Autism Now! (DAN!) Doctors, who believe that biomedical treatment can be used to positively affect the behavioural and cognitive symptoms of autism. Jaquelyn McCandless MD, 2007, is a strong supporter of the biomedical approach to autism, believing that “sometimes the improvement is dramatic enough for a child to lose his or her ASD diagnosis” (McCandless, 2007, page 6). This bold statement highlights the end goal that biomedical treatment seeks to reach, however it must be noted that this is a sweeping statement and will only be true for a handful of children. However, the idea has now been introduced, thus further exploration of the possibilities of ASD recovery or symptom improvement is anticipated. 1.6) Defeat Autism Now! Defeat Autism Now! (DAN) was formed to “focus activism and attention on identifying the biological bases of autism and biologically based treatments” (Schreibman, 2007, page 23). This organisation was set up in 1995 by a combination of parents, researchers and physicians all with a vested interested or connection to autism. It provided a new way of thinking about the causes and treatments of children with ASD from a biological perspective and offered new information about the effects that factors other than behaviour can have on these children. It focuses on dietary and biomedical approaches to autism including restrictive diets and nutrient supplements.
  • 19. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 19 | Tommey and Tommey 2011 present a clear theme throughout their book (Autism: A practical guide to improving your child’s quality of life) of optimism that a child’s autistic behaviours and symptoms can be greatly improved. The title itself suggests that this book will ensure a child with autism will have a better life once they apply themselves to this guiding piece of literature. However, it must be taken into account the possibility of bias presented by Tommey and Tommey 2011. A couple, their eldest son was diagnosed with autism when he was only 2. Together they delved deep into the world of autism; its causes, treatments and the connections between biology and medicine, all of which resulted in successful ‘treatment’ of their now high functioning teenage son. Their individual success story however must not be accepted as the finding of a general solution to the problems associated with autism. Whilst this book does provide extensive information on diet and nutrition and the positive effect this can have on a child with autism, it does not guarantee that all children will have such positive results. Their own enthusiasm for dietary and biomedical intervention stems from the success their son has gained from it. Tommey and Tommey 2011 do acknowledge the uniqueness of every child “we have learned one very valuable lesson: that each and every child with autism is different” (Tommey and Tommey, 2011, Page xiv).e topic. 1.7) Nutritional Standards It is important to acknowledge the legislation that sets out standards for dietary provisions for children in education. In terms of children’s diet during the school day, schools have strict nutritional standards to adhere to in what they offer children. In 2005, the School Meals Review Panel (SMRP), chaired by Suzi Leather, released a
  • 20. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 20 | report on “the development and implementation of nutritional standards for school lunches” (DfES, 2005). The report sets out the panel’s recommendations for change and development of the food served in schools, based on evidence from a variety of sources including head teachers, school caterers and public health experts. It provides a framework for school catering staff to follow in order to ensure that they serve “well-cooked, well-presented meals, made from good-quality ingredients to accepted nutritional standards”; whilst also ensuring that they are confident in their own abilities as catering staff. The SMRP’s 2005 report does not detail the specific nutritional standards that should be met by special schools or those catering to a special educational needs unit. The only incidence where Leather explores the relationship between special schools and the food provided is in the interest of eligibility for free fruit and vegetables in the School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme. This however is neither a recommendation put forth by the review panel nor a target; it was put into practice in 2000 by the NHS and is merely highlighted as a ‘recent development’. It is also not limited solely to special schools, but rather eligibility for a free piece of fruit or vegetable spans nearly 2 million children in over 16000 infant, primary and special schools in England (Department of Health, 2010). Therefore it is apparent that Leather 2005 does not adequately address the difference in dietary needs between typically developing children and children with autism. In its recommendations, the panel set forth a table of Nutrient Standards which lists the proportions of each nutrient that should be present in the school lunches offered to children and young people. The table states that across the five consecutive
  • 21. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 21 | school days, lunches should contain a quantity of carbohydrate that amounts to no less than 50% of food energy. Carbohydrates provide the body with energy which according to studies can have positive effects on children. In a study by Vaisman et al 1996 it was suggested that cognitive performance can be increased in those children who do not typically eat breakfast just by providing them with breakfast, which generally includes carbohydrates. This supports Leather’s recommendation that the Government should prioritise the supplement of breakfast standards in schools. This highlights a major lack in the legislation surrounding the nutritional standards that must be upheld for children with disabilities. Yet the creation of such standards risks straying into discrimination against children with disabilities and labelling them as ‘an exception to the dietary norms’ associated with typically developing children. The fear of being accused of discrimination suggests that this is an area that few are willing to explore. Instead, all children, regardless of whether they are typically or atypically developing, are provided for in schools following the same nutritional standards framework. Literature that proves that this may indeed be harmful to certain children appears to simply be ignored. Although there is a wide variety of information on diet and autism available on the internet, this too has been overlooked in terms of the national dietary nutritional standards set out by the SMRP 2005. 1.8) Carbohydrates and Candida
  • 22. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 22 | However, for children with autism, refined carbohydrates such as white bread and crisps generally prove problematic for their gastrointestinal systems and if consumed at the rate suggested by Leather 2005 would have negative consequences. Tommey and Tommey 2011 explain that these refined carbohydrates “provide exactly the right nutrients (mostly glucose) for Candida to thrive on and can upset the blood sugar balance” (page 65). An increase in Candida has been suggested by some research to be “a significant cause of many of the untoward behaviours and health problems we see in autistic patients” (McCandless, 2007). Shaw, 2002, looked more closely at the link between yeast and the effects it has on children with autism. He explained that as Candida multiplies, it excretes toxins into the body. He suggested that these toxins “are capable of impairing the central nervous and immune systems” (no pagination). This audacious statement suggests that children with autism who have an excessive amount of Candida in their bodies could become seriously physically challenged and unwell. McCandless’s inclusion of this research suggests that she supports Shaw’s findings. While she includes them as “ground-breaking research” (McCandless, 2007, page 28), there is a lack of further exploration of the link between the yeast toxins and the nervous and immune system. This is a bold area of research which suggests highly negative results on children with autism; therefore the author may have missed the opportunity to provide further understanding of this link. McCandless 2007 also explores other symptoms that can occur from excessive Candida growth in children with autism. She lists “diarrhoea, stomach ache, gas pains, constipation, headache, fatigue and depression” (McCandless, 2007, page28). This cocktail of symptoms would be difficult for a typically developed adult
  • 23. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 23 | to deal with, let alone a child with autism whose development has already been compromised. McCandless also lists behavioural problems that can occur due to Candida overgrowth, which include “concentration difficulties, hyperactivity, short attention span, irritability and aggression” (McCandless, 2007, page 28). From these lists we can deduce that Candida is not only harmful in terms of physical health, but it can also be damaging to behavioural development. Therefore its importance must not be overlooked. However, McCandless clearly does not rate the issue of Candida as highly as there is little further exploration of the subject within her book. The next section of this body of work is a study of the popularity of dietary interventions amongst children with autism and a discussion into the efficacy of such interventions.
  • 24. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 24 | Chapter_2 Methodology The purpose of this study was to look at the different foods that children with autism are consuming on a day-to-day basis in their educational setting. The researcher wanted to gather data that could be analysed and compared to the restrictions of a gluten-free and casein-free diet, as well as other dietary interventions. Questionnaires were sent out to parents to determine the level of knowledge on dietary interventions and to gather information on parental stance concerning a child with autism’s dietary intake. Finally, a case study was drawn up by the researcher using a subject who is currently undergoing a dietary intervention to provide a time- line of intervention and results. 2.1) Participants School Meal-Time Setting The research question focuses on the affects that diet can have on ‘children’ with autism. The first participants involved were a group of Key Stage 3 and Key Stage 4 children with autism aged between 11-16 years. The research was conducted in a special school with a separate specialised department for children with autism. As this part of the research was a general observation of a meal-time setting, personal information including age of each individual was not noted but rather an average age range was provided. These participants were all on the Autistic Spectrum. Two
  • 25. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 25 | different lunch time proceedings were observed on the same day therefore providing a range of results. Food Diaries 7 children from this group of participants also participated in another stem of research. These 7 children were observed by their teaching assistants (TAs) over a period of 5 consecutive school days. The TAs recorded the data for this aspect of the research although the children were the subjects of this research. The TAs remained anonymous and their data collection was passed to the researcher by the Head Teacher’s PA. The overall number of TAs involved in this research also remained anonymous as the research was conducted at the school in the absence of the researcher. Case Study The participant in the case study, ‘Child-X’, is a 5 year old autistic child known to the researcher. The researcher elected to write up a case study of Child-X as he provided a current and first-hand experience of the effects of dietary intervention. The parents of Child-X were also included in the collation of information for this case study. 2.2) Research Methods
  • 26. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 26 | Before research was conducted, the researcher met with the Head Teacher of the chosen school to discuss the proposed research and arrange a time and date to conduct it. This meeting lasted an hour and allowed the researcher to provide the Head Teacher with food diary templates to be passed to the TAs for completion. It was decided during this meeting that the observational research would be undertaken on one day, therefore allowing for minimal disruption to the children in the school. As the researcher was looking for qualitative data from educational research, the choice of observational research correlated with Levin, O’Donnell and Kratochwill’s 2003 ‘Stages of Programs of Research’. Levin et al 2003 suggested that the first stage of educational research would involve “observational, focused exploration” and the second stage would consist of “observational studies of classrooms” (Brantlinger et al, 2005, page 145). The school has 2 lunch-time sittings (12:15-12:45 and 12:45-13:15) and the observations were to span both sittings. An informal meeting with the head chef of the school was scheduled to be held between the two sittings and after lunch. The researcher completed the observational research in the dining hall of a school for children with learning difficulties. The researcher initially observed the food that was being served as it was delivered to the dining hall. The researcher questioned the head chef on the menu and noted the food on offer that day. This part of the observation was conducted in the absence of any children and only involved the catering staff of the school. The second part of the observation was completed once the first group of school children had entered the dining hall for their lunch-time sitting. The researcher
  • 27. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 27 | moved around the dining hall, taking a tally of the different food and drink each child was consuming. The researcher conversed with TAs present in the dining hall to establish the various dietary restrictions and requirements of some of the children. As this was only observational research in terms of the children’s participation, there was no conversation between the researcher and the children. The researcher observed the main course and desert choices made by the children at the food station as well as the drinks chosen. Those children who brought a packed lunch with them were also included in the research checklist tally. This observation research was repeated for the second group of school children in the second lunch- time sitting. 2.3) Research Instruments Observational Research Pre-observation, the researcher created a ‘research checklist’ to be taken to the observation and used to note a tally of results. The checklist, shown in Appendix.1 allowed the researcher to make note of the different food groups eaten during the lunch setting; the individual foods that comprised these food groups; the different drinks consumed and the quantity of children consuming these foods and drinks. Whilst there was a column titled ‘solid food’ this was discarded on observation as it became apparent that it was a redundant variable. The final column on the research checklist, titled ‘restricted diet’, was completed through observation combined with conversation with the catering staff. This type of research allowed the collection of both qualitative and quantitative data. The quantitative data collected through the
  • 28. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 28 | tally lent itself to the presentation of findings in graphs and charts. “Graphs and charts condense large amounts of information into easy-to-understand formats that clearly and effectively communicate important points” (CDC, 2008, page 1). The categorical data of food types etc. is best represented in these forms. Questionnaire The questionnaire was structured into two sections which were signposted within the questionnaire. Sectioning ensures that questions “are not constantly shifting back and forth” (Anderson, Arsenault, 2005, page 187) therefore allowing a fluency to the questionnaire. The first section aimed to find out about the child in general, therefore enquiring about age, sex, disability, medication and verbal ability. The second section of the questionnaire was more related to the research aims and asked parents about the food habits of their children and their knowledge surrounding dietary interventions. The questionnaire combined a mixture of closed-questions such as tick-box style questions; and open-ended questions which provided descriptive answers. They enabled the researcher to compare the parental perspectives in the questionnaire to other parts of the research, such as the case study. Case Study The researcher created the case study through an informal meeting with Child-X and his mother and father. Although the researcher had a vague structure for an interview regarding the timeline of Child-X’s dietary intervention, the meeting was led
  • 29. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 29 | by the parents, with the researcher noting down everything that was said. The structure consisted of ‘Summary’; ‘Issue to be resolved’; ‘Action taken’; ‘Results’; ‘Next steps’ and ‘Any other information’. This structure was used to gather information for each section of the timeline. The researcher explained the structure of the interview to Child-X’s parents and asked that they provide a detailed timeline of events that set out all intervention Child-X has received along with effects on the child; behavioural changes; physical changes and the results of all treatment. 2.4) Ethical Issues Before any research was commenced, the researcher created a parent information sheet detailing the proposed research and the dissertation question. This was drawn up to ensure that parents were as fully informed as possible about the intended research on their children. A separate information letter was also created which provided information on the questionnaire. Both letters are shown in Appendix.2 and Appendix.3. The researcher wrote two separate information letters for the different stems of the research to ensure the elimination of any confusion surrounding the research. The researcher wanted to make a clear definition between the two stems. Two separate consent forms were also created for the questionnaire and the observational research to continue to ensure a consistent definition between the two branches of research (these are shown in Appendix.4 and Appendix.5). The questionnaires sent out to parents (see Appendix.7) provided the researcher with a particular ethical issue. The Head Teacher of the school explained that roughly 80% of the parents of the pupils did not have English as a first language.
  • 30. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 30 | The issue then arose of whether they would fully comprehend the information provided in the information letter and the consent forms. The researcher questioned whether informed consent would be possible to ascertain if the parents could not understand English. The decision was made by the Head Teacher that all the letters would still be sent out as the research involving the children was purely observational but that the consent forms should be altered to ‘opt out’ forms rather than ‘opt in’. The change to the forms was made by the Head Teacher as she agreed she had a greater understanding of the literary and comprehensive backgrounds of these parents. An issue arose in the return of the questionnaires. As only 3 were returned from the entire school, the researcher was faced with a sample-size that was too small to give a reliable overall view of the parental perspectives. Therefore the researcher had to decide whether this was valuable research that should be included. It was decided that the questionnaires provided the researcher with a wider understanding of parental perspectives on dietary interventions for children with autism, yet the information did not need to be included in the overall research study. It was to be used to inform the researcher but not the research. The researcher had to be particularly sensitive to minimising disruption to the routine of the autistic children. A trait of many children with autism is their obsessive and compulsive behaviour and their need for a repetitive routine. Therefore, being a stranger, the researcher had to be careful not to upset the children by interfering too much in their daily routine. The researcher observed as much as possible from
  • 31. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 31 | outside of the dining hall and when walking around the hall, the researcher was careful not to invade any child’s personal space. The dissemination of the information gathered and management of such information provided an ethical issue of anonymity and confidentiality. Every participant has the right to remain nameless and also for their input to remain private. Wiles et al, 2006, describe Oliver 2003 and Gregory 2003’s principle of privacy as a principle that is at the heart of our society. We believe “that individuals matter and that individuals have the right for their affairs to be private” (Wiles et al, 2006, page 2), therefore the researcher upheld complete confidentiality with all participants. Within the case study, the child was referred to as ‘Child-X’ throughout and the parents were fully informed of the inclusion of the case study within this research. They agreed to the display of the case study as a chronological timeline of data on the understanding that the researcher does “not disclose identifiable information about participants” and tries “to protect the identity of research participants through various processes designed to anonymise them” (Wiles et al, 2006, page 2). They were given the options to create pseudonyms however they opted simply for ‘mum’ and ‘dad’. The researcher was also aware of the sensitivity surrounding the food diaries sent out to parents. As these diaries were designed to extract information on what parents fed their children, there was an issue in ensuring that parents were not being ‘judged’ about what they gave their children. The researcher made it clear that this was an optional diary and that any information would remain anonymous. However the researcher was aware of the participants and therefore would know which diary
  • 32. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 32 | came from which family. This could explain the lack of returned food diaries that the researcher received.
  • 33. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 33 | Chapter_3.0 Presentation and Analysis of Findings 3.1) Observational Research Results The first part of the research that was collected was the primary data from the school meal-time setting observation. Appendix.1 shows the research instrument used to collect the data. Results were converted into graphs and charts to enable clear portrayal of the results. It is important to note that the results of the meal-time observation include foods from both the school catering and a few packed lunches so as to get a rounded view of the food children eat at lunch. The following section displays the results of the research and provides an explanatory aside to each. Figure.1) is a pie chart that displays the percentages of the different types of consumed nutrients that were noted during observations of autistic children during their lunch break. It shows a majority of carbohydrates and a minority of protein. The chart was created from results of the research checklist (Appendix.1). Carbohydrate Protein Fruit/ Vegetable Dairy Different types of nutrient 12 1 5 2 60% 5% 25% 10% Chart Percentage of different Nutrients consumed during school meal-time observation Carbohydrate Protein Fruit/ Vegetable Dairy Figure 1) A pie chart showing the quantity of each nutrient consumed during the meal-time observation Table 1) The different number of eachindividual nutrient observed.
  • 34. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 34 | Table 1) shows the raw data from the observational research, before it was converted into the chart in Figure.1). For example, Table 1 shows that only one type of protein was consumed compared to a variety of different carbohydrates. Figure.2) is a graph showing the amount of times each different nutrient was eaten. For example, the table shows that fruit and vegetables were eaten 30 different times throughout lunch-time. The table provides quantitative data regarding the popularity of each nutrient. It shows the number of times the different nutrients were actually consumed, rather than just the number of times they were on offer. The researcher collected this data to gain an understanding of the foods autistic children eat through choice and naturally lean towards. It therefore provides a base from which further food preferences can be guessed. From Figures.1) and 2) we can see that not only were the carbohydrate rich foods most readily available, they were also the most popular in terms of consumption. There were 46 different instances of children eating carbohydrates, compared to only 46 20 30 4 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Instances of Carbohydrates consumed Instances of Protein consumed Instances of Fruit/Vegetable consumed Instances of Dairy consumed Number of instances each nutrient was consumed Figure 2) A graph displaying the amount of times each nutrient was eaten.
  • 35. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 35 | 4 instances of dairy consumption. Although there was only 1 type of protein available to the children observed, it was clearly a popular choice as there were 20 instances of it being eaten. This indicates that the variety of each nutrient on offer does not have a direct effect on its overall popularity as the limited option of 1 type of protein proved more popular than the 2 types of dairy available. 3.2) Carbohydrates The percentage of carbohydrates consumed by the children observed has been broken down in Figure.3) into the different food products. Figure.4) presents the percentage of the different fruit and vegetable products consumed during the meal-time observation. The pie chart shows a total of 5 different 35% 7% 20% 2% 2% 2% 2% 18% 2% 4% 4% 2% Percentage of each different type of carbohydrate consumed Spaghetti Jacket Potato Garlic Bread Mashed Potato Jam Sandwich Crisps Tortilla Chips Rice Pudding Fairy Cake Butter Sandwich Biscuits Chapati Figure 3) Chart showing a breakdownof the carbohydrates consumed 36% 37% 17% 7% 3% Percentage of each different type of Fruit/ Vegetable consumed Sweetcorn Carrot Salad Apple Banana Figure 4) A pie chart showing the percentage of each fruit/vegetable consumed during the meal-time observation.
  • 36. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 36 | fruits/ vegetables. Potato has been eliminated. Figure.5) shows the children’s drink choices. The only drink option offered by the school was water. The Capri Sun and the juice were provided in 3 packed lunches and were not offered by the school. These results have been included to draw attention to the possible relationship between the drinks consumed by the children and the ensuing effects upon them. Whilst the majority of the children drank water; the Capri Sun and the juice are sugary drinks and therefore should be considered in terms of effect of sugar on children with autism. 3.3) Food Diaries Appendix.6 and Appendix.7 show eight food diaries that were completed for the researcher either by a TA (Appendix.6) or a parent (Appendix.7) of an autistic. Seven of these food diaries provide an overview of the foods children with autism consume whilst in school; showing show break-time and lunch-time food and drink intake from Monday- Friday. Appendix.7 is a food diary which shows Child H’s food and drink intake across a full week, listing breakfast, lunch and dinner in both an educational 11 1 2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Water Capri Sun Juice NumberofPupils Type of Drink Graph showing the number of pupils consumingdifferent drinks Type of Drink Figure 5) A graph showing the number of pupils consuming each type of drink.
  • 37. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 37 | and a home setting. The layout is different as it spans 7 days (Monday-Sunday). It has a different colour scheme and layout so as to highlight its separation from the other diaries and to eliminate confusion with them. Appendix.7 was completed to provide an insight into the difference between food intake at home and in school. All food diaries were completed independent of the researcher and returned either to the child’s school where they were passed on to the researcher, or direct to the researcher via email. The children whose food diaries were completed by their TAs are pupils at the same school where the meal-time observation was held and were also involved in the observation. Figure.6) displays the quantity of each nutrient present within the 7 school-based food diaries. The pie chart shows a fairly even spread across the five nutrients; the most common nutrient is carbohydrate. It shows that only a small percentage of the foods were protein, which correlates with the small amount of protein on offer in the school meal-time setting, as depicted in Figure.1). 3.4) School Lunch 4 Week Menu Figure 6) A pie chart showing the percentage of each nutrient listed in the 7 school-based food diaries. 36% 14% 26% 19% 5% Overall Percentage of each food type from the school-based food diaries Carbohydrates Sugar Fruit/Vegetable Dairy Protein
  • 38. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 38 | Appendix.9 is a scanned image of a document that outlines a 4 week menu framework for the school dinners on offer at the participating school It has been included to offer an insight into the food and diet provided by mass catering companies and the education system. It shows an average 4 week menu with a meat main, a vegetarian option, vegetable sides and a pudding. 3.5) Case Study A case study was conducted on a 5 year old boy with autism, known as ‘Child-X’, who now follows a strict dietary intervention as suggested by a Clinical Nutritionist (CN) following the Defeat Autism Now! (DAN!) protocol. The case study outlines a chronological timeline starting from the age of 2. Before the age of 2, Child-X’s development appeared typical and gave mum and dad no cause for concern. The case study details the treatment and intervention Child-X has received throughout his life so far. It also explains the developmental obstacles, challenges and milestones.  First 13 months- Child-X was very sick. He contracted a chest infection and was given antibiotics. MMR Jab Child-X received the MMR vaccination. However, due to his compromised immune system he couldn’t cope with the MMR jab.  2 years old- No speech or vocabulary
  • 39. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 39 | Example: No verbal communication. Mum contacted Child-X’s nursery for feedback on Child-X’s development, behaviour and social interaction. Nursery provided minimal information and expressed no worries about Child-X’s social and emotional development.  2 years 6 months- General Practitioner visit Mum contacted her GP with concern over Child-X’s lack of speech and language. GP told mum not to worry; boys are often slower developing. GP dissuaded a referral to a speech and language therapist and told mum to return after 3 months as GP felt Child-X’s speech and language would develop.  2 years 9 months- Initial referral to speech and language therapist After no improvement GP referred Child-X to a speech and language therapist.  2 years 10 months- Visit to South Africa and Tympanometry test Family visited a doctor friend on holiday in South Africa. Doctor referred Child- X to a specialist who tested the child’s speech and hearing, using a tympanometry test. Test concluded normal hearing however the child did not respond positively to the hearing test. Observed in play situation Doctor observed child playing outside. Child-X immediately played on climbing frame with his father. He also sat on the doctor’s lap. These
  • 40. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 40 | observed social skills and behaviours prompted the doctor’s opinion that Child-X was not autistic.  3 years Started speech and language sessions. SALT referred Child-X for a hearing test and Cognitive Development Assessment.  3 years 3 months- Cognitive Development Assessment Child-X received a Cognitive Development Assessment. Results showed he was on par with his age group for everything except his manipulative skills and his speech. Example: Child unable to draw a circle. Paediatrician contacted nursery Even though parents had regularly contacted Child-X’s nursery to discuss any abnormal behaviour or issues, to which the nursery expressed no concern and said Child-X played and socialised with his peers, when Child-X’s paediatrician contacted the nursery, they expressed concern about Child-X’s social behaviour. Paediatrician suggested that Child-X may have autism but must wait 6 months for a further assessment.  During the 6 months between 3 years 3 months and 3 years 9 months- Physical changes noted with Child-X Child-X appeared grey; his hair had lost its shine and his behaviour deteriorated. He had frequent and worsening tantrums. He wouldn’t settle and woke up throughout the night. Constipation
  • 41. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 41 | Child-X suffered chronic constipation. He was eating normally and taking the laxative supplement Lactulose (prescribed by his GP). Appointments for assessment Child-X received an appointment for a follow up cognitive assessment and for a multi-disciplinary assessment.  03/10/2012 4 years old- Multi-disciplinary assessment and diagnosis Child-X was assessed in his home setting, his nursery setting and the paediatrician’s offices. This resulted in a diagnosis of autism. Mum and Dad only received an information leaflet on autism. Contacted DAN campaign follower Mum and Dad rang a contact in America who follows the Defeat Autism Now! (DAN) protocol who explained the dietary changes that the DAN protocol sets out and provided her son’s success story from these dietary changes.  06/10/2012 4 years 3 days- Child-X began immediate gluten and dairy free diet. Child-X had processed food and anything with additives especially E-numbers and unnatural colours removed from his diet.  07/10/2012 4 years 4 days- Child-X’s first noted response to instruction and verbal interaction. Example: Dad gave Child-X a flower and told him to give it to his mummy. Child-X took the flower to his mother and said “mummy”.  Commencement of supplements. Child-X began taking refined cod liver oil, calcium magnesium, multi-vitamins and a clay mixture. He began bathing in Epsom salts. Prior to Epsom salts
  • 42. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 42 | Child-X would only bath alone. First time Child-X soaked in Epsom salts he allowed Dad to share the bath, laying on him calmly. Child-X began taking a probiotic a few weeks later.  10/01/2013 4 years 4 months- Meeting with Clinical Nutritionist Child-X’s had a Skype meeting with their CN. Child provided the lab (recommended by the CN) with a urine, blood, hair and stool sample. CN requested that Child-X cease all dieting and provide 3 different stool samples for the months of January and February. CN tested Child-X for gluten and dairy intolerance; worms and dilated pupils- Child-X tested negative for all. Beetroot and Urine Test Child-X drank 250ml of a solution of beetroot. Urine was then examined for a desired pink hue which would suggest typical bodily functioning. Urine showed no pink. Child-X also had his urine tested for crystals but none were found. Hair Sample Results showed that Child-X had more toxins in his body than in his hair, whereas typically the majority of the toxins should be found in the hair. Biomedical Test Results Majority of calcium found in hair as opposed to where it should be i.e. body. Blood Test Child-X tested for gene mutation and found to have glutathione mutation, a deficient gene.  March 2013
  • 43. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 43 | Mum and Dad contacted their CN to discuss results of tests and arranged 3 monthly consultations over Skype. They were told to give Child-X a mixture of different nutrient supplements. Altogether Child-X took 21 nutrient supplements, listed below. 21 Nutrient Supplements:  Coenzyme Q10 (COQ10)  Vitamin A  Vitamin C  Vitamin D  Vitamin E  Vitamin B12  Seratonin  Zinc  Alpha lipoic acid (detoxifier)  ADP (oregano)  Culturelle Probiotic  Mindlinx Probiotic  Permatrol  Phosphatidylserine  Candiclear  Aloe Vera juice  Calcium Magnesium  Refined Cod Liver oil  Folinic Acid with B12  Primal Defence
  • 44. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 44 |  Secretin 3.6) Results of Nutrient Supplementation and Dietary Intervention  Prior to treatment Child-X could only produce a stool once a week. This progressed to 4 times a week during intervention. Results are now 13 times in 14 days.  Child-X had never engaged in play with scooters before treatment. After watching Dad play on a scooter for a number of days, child picked up a scooter and began scooting.  Child-X’s speech and word recognition is much improved compared to his total lack before treatment. Child-X can cite words and read comprehensively.  Figure.7) shows Child-X’s painting ability. The picture is a self-portrait Child-X completed at school.  Child-X goes to mainstream school but receives full support 32 hours a week.  Child-X has made friends. During play time he interacts with other children. Child-X used to be unaware of others; now he asks for absent people.  Child-X understands to line up after break-time at school and shows understanding of the school bell system.  Child-X baths himself and washes his own hair. He is also able to dress and undress himself without help. Figure 7) A self-portrait painted at school by Child-X.
  • 45. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 45 | 3.7) Average financial costs of treatment  On average £300- £550 a month  £1400 for the tests completed in February 2013  £500 on products  £300 on supplements  Everything given to Child-X is organic, gluten free and dairy free.
  • 46. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 46 | Chapter_4.0 Discussion of Findings The results from this piece of research provide many platforms for further exploration into the relationship between dietary interventions and children with autism. The findings from the observational research in a school meal-time setting and the food- diary results offer a base for further study into the effects of individual nutrients on children with autism. The case study allowed the researcher to delve deeper into the field of dietary intervention with a link to a gluten-free diet. The following section discusses the results of the research findings and explores these aforementioned areas. 4.1) Carbohydrates The pie chart in Figure.3) shows that the main carbohydrates consumed by the children were potato, pasta and bread products. Statistics show that 35% of the carbohydrate food products were spaghetti, which proved the most popular option for the children with autism. The results of the 7 food diaries completed by the children’s TA’s showed that the quantity of carbohydrates consumed outweighed the quantities of other nutrients. In total, 36% of the overall nutrients recorded in the food diaries were carbohydrate. Whilst this is 24% less carbohydrate than that which was recorded in the school-meal time setting, it is still the majority percentage compared to the quantities of protein, dairy, fruit/vegetable and sugar. This highlights the
  • 47. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 47 | popularity of carbohydrates and suggests that children with autism have a high carbohydrate intake. Potato products such as crisps and bread products made from enriched or bleached flours such as white bread come under the category of ‘refined carbohydrates’. These carbohydrates are detrimental to a child with autism in relation to the candida harvesting they permit. Therefore it is alarming to note that 91% of the carbohydrates recorded in the school meal-time setting were refined carbohydrates. The only options for non-refined carbohydrates were the potato products ‘mashed potato’ and ‘jacket potato’. These options are also gluten-free options. The researcher made a note that most of the autistic children who opted for a potato product carbohydrate did so due to wheat intolerances preventing them from choosing the pasta and bread options. This suggests the hypothesis that unless restricted by a particular allergy or intolerance, the majority of children with autism will choose a refined carbohydrate product that contains gluten. What is immediately obvious from the findings of the observational research and the food diaries is the vast percentage of carbohydrates being consumed. An increase in candida in the child’s body upsets the blood sugar balance. Srinivasan 2009 explained that the toxins that are produced by the Candida yeast “could cause some of the symptoms [of autism] directly or by overloading the detoxification pathways” (Srinivasan 2009 page 242). Candida has also been linked to damage of “the nervous and immune systems” as well as “a variety of behaviour and health problems” (Brill, 2001, page 21). Yet carbohydrates were the most commonly available nutrient for these children to eat. Figure.2) depicts the popularity of each of
  • 48. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 48 | the different nutrients and shows that carbohydrates were consumed the most. This carbohydrate-rich diet guarantees many children with autism a gut filled with Candida yeast and therefore a plethora of different gastro-intestinal issues as noted in the Literature Review section. Edelson 2003 noted some of the behavioural and health effects of Candida overgrowth on children with autism included irritability, aggression, stomach aches and constipation. Yet Figure.2) shows that the negative effects of carbohydrate consumption on a child with autism haven’t affected the availability of carbohydrates. Srinivasan describes a diet that provides an alternative menu. The “Body Ecology Diet” was initiated by Donna Gates and focuses on “rebuilding immunity and intestinal flora” (Srinivasan 2009 page 244). It limits carbohydrate consumption and also focusing on the upkeep of beneficial flora in the gut. The diet challenges the issue of Candida overgrowth through its very limited allowance of carbohydrates. It insists on a drastic reduction in consumption of sugar and carbohydrates. In particular concentrated carbohydrates such as potato and refined sugars must be removed. Williams et al 2011 researched the gastrointestinal symptoms of children with autism and the different deficiencies exhibited. Their findings indicated that children with autism have “impairments of the primary pathway for carbohydrate digestion” (Williams et al, 2011, page 1). This indication combined with the high percentage of carbohydrate listed in both the meal-time observations and the school-based food diaries would suggest a cause for concern. These children are consuming a nutrient which Williams et al 2011 found to be difficult for autistic children to properly digest.
  • 49. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 49 | According to Williams et al this was due to a deficiency in “at least one of the 5 genes involved in carbohydrate digestion or transport” (Williams et al, 2011, page 3), which was noted in 93.3% of the children they studied. 4.2) Connection to Gluten-free dietary intervention In terms of the gluten content, 73% of the carbohydrates the researcher observed consumed during the meal-time setting contained gluten. The remaining 27% gluten- free carbohydrates were rice or potato products. The food diaries in Appendix.6 depict a bleak scene in relation to a gluten-free diet; 6/7 children’s school-based food diaries contain gluten, thus showing that the majority of these children’s weekly diets include gluten. The only child that appears to have eliminated gluten from their diet is Child F (Appendix.6.6) however this is due to a wheat intolerance. Therefore the child has consciously had wheat removed from their diet and the lack of gluten is merely a by-product of this intolerance. There is no information to suggest that Child F does not eat gluten in other aspects of his life, for example in the home setting. From these results it can be concluded that no participants were actively following a gluten-free diet specifically as a dietary intervention for autism. This suggests that either the parents of these children were not aware of information regarding gluten- free dietary intervention, or that they had actively chosen not to pursue this form of intervention. Regardless of the reason it indicates that in this study gluten-free dietary interventions were not a common choice amongst families of children with autism. According to the Interactive Autism Network (IAN) 2014, an online project involving families of children with autism in the United States found that “more than
  • 50. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 50 | 16% of participating families are using special diets to treat their child’s autism” (IAN, 2014). Whilst the geographical factor of the IAN project differs from that of the research within this study it still provides a comparable overview of the popularity of dietary interventions. IAN 2014 found that diets which removed certain substances were most common. The most frequent dietary interventions they noted were gluten- free diets, casein-free diets or a combined GF/CF diet. 4.3) Connection to Casein-free dietary intervention As Isherwood et al 2011 highlight, many children with autism will only eat certain foods. “The majority of foods they will accept are gluten/casein containing foods eg: bread and milk” (Isherwood et al, 2011, page 58). It isn’t uncommon for typically developing children to want foods that are not as nutritionally beneficial as foods such as fruits or vegetables, but it is easier in terms of their cognitive development to explain why they must consume a balanced diet. For children with autism, the cognitive and comprehensive skills needed to elicit an understanding of the importance of balanced nutritional intake are often lacking or even non-existent. Therefore it becomes difficult to wean them onto a diet that eliminates these foods. Milk in particular is a food that children receive from birth therefore the connection with milk is often very well established by the time the child is diagnosed with autism. When looking at the data collected in the observational research, the low number of instances of dairy consumption shown in Figure.2) would please many DAN doctors and believers in a casein-free diet for autistic children. Figure.1) shows that only 10% of the overall nutrient consumption was comprised of dairy products. As casein is a
  • 51. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 51 | milk protein it is found in most dairy products including cheese, butter, milk and yoghurt, however according to Table 1) there were only 2 types of dairy available in the school meal-time setting. 4.4) Case Study The Case Study of Child X provides a vital insight into the possible success that dietary interventions can have for children with autism. It outlines the strict regime and lengthy process that is involved in a gluten and dairy-free diet and nutritional supplementation as set out by a Clinical Nutritionist (CN). The findings of the case study clearly show that changing the diet of a child with autism can have positive and beneficial effects on the child’s behaviour, cognitive processed and socio-emotional development. The next section will break down these effects and the results of Child X’s dietary intervention. 4.5) Speech and Language Development Child X had a severe language delay and was still not talking by the age of 4. The case study shows that Child X’s first noted correct use of speech and language appeared the day after Child X began to follow a gluten and dairy free diet. The child’s father asked him to take a flower to his mother and utter the word “mummy”. His compliance with this instruction proved that not only did he understand the language used by his father; he also correctly used the word “mummy”. Although there is no direct proof that Child X’s sudden language acquisition is linked to him commencing the dietary intervention, it appears too much of a coincidence to
  • 52. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 52 | disregard it. After a complete lack of verbal communication and language skills whilst on a normal, un-intervened diet, Child X’s dietary change appears to have been caused by, or at least encouraged by, the removal of gluten and dairy products in his diet. 4.6) Cognitive Development and Motor Skills Figure.7) shows a self-portrait that Child X painted at his school. It shows that Child X has good hand-eye coordination and motor skills and a clear comprehension of the ‘self’. The case study shows that at 2 years 10 months, Child X was demonstrating good playing skills and the ability to climb on a climbing frame. This indicates that his motor skills were already developing. However the case study shows that at 3 years and 3 months he wasn’t able to ‘draw a circle’ as his fine motor skills were not yet mature enough. Ozonoff et al 2008 conducted a study on the early development of children later diagnosed with autism in which they found “a delay in the appearance of motor milestones” (Ozonoff et al 2008). However, Figure.7) indicates that Child X’s fine motor skills have progressed greatly in correlation with his dietary intervention. Results of the intervention listed in the case study also include the ability to ride a scooter. Not only does this involve motor skills and balance; he learnt and understood how to use the scooter from watching his father play on it. This demonstrates good cognitive development and maturation of motor skills. Baranek 2002 conducted a study on the efficacy of sensory and motor interventions for autistic children. She found that “empirical evidence converges to confirm the existence of sensory and motor difficulties for many children with autism at some point in their early development” (Baranek, 2002, page 397). This quote supports
  • 53. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 53 | Child X’s initial inability to perform small tasks that require motor skills. Whilst Baranek found some beneficial effects from motor and sensory interventions, the case study focuses on the dietary intervention that Child X received and the positive effects this change in diet had on his motor skills. 4.7) Limitations It must be noted that there were limitations to this research study. Firstly, in the observational research, the overall number of participants was not noted. This was due to the open plan style of the dining hall which allowed the children to come and go throughout the lunch sitting. On reflection, a head count of the children as they entered the dining hall would have solved this issue. A second limitation of the research was the questionnaires. Whilst they would have provided a further contextual dimension to the research, the lack of response to the questionnaires meant that they had to be discarded. This limitation could be attributed to the scope of parents the questionnaire was sent to. A high percentage of parents of children at the school used for research did not have English as a first language therefore could not fully comprehend the questions being asked. The final limitation of this body of work has been the vast spectrum of information accumulated through research and the restricted word count of this study. The researcher found that prioritisation of data and information meant that other contextual information and interesting findings had to be omitted.
  • 54. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 54 | Chapter_5.0 Conclusion In regards to the findings from the observational research and the food diaries produced in this body of work it can be clearly determined that dietary interventions are by no means commonly used for children with autism. The only form of restricted diet found during this research was the removal of wheat products due to a wheat intolerance. However, the fact that research was only conducted on one day and results of the school-based food diaries only spanned 5 days means that the results are restricted. There is a platform here for further research to be conducted on a much wider scale to determine the incidence rate of dietary interventions for children with autism. Results from this paper found that carbohydrates, in particular refined carbohydrates, were the most common food choice amongst children with autism and their intake was high, yet they can have detrimental effects on the child’s body. The literature review section explored the effects of a Candida increase in the body, which can lead to gastro-intestinal issues including constipation and more serious effects on the nervous and immune systems. Further study on the link between carbohydrates and children with autism could be conducted to determine the exact (or differing) effects of a carbohydrate rich diet on the body of an autistic child, and whether refining the carbohydrate makes any difference.
  • 55. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 55 | The case study of Child-X provides a true example of the positive effects that dietary interventions can have on a child with autism. The improvement in his speech and language skills is remarkable; Child-X transformed from a child with a complete lack of verbal skills to a child able to cite words and use words properly. His motor skills also improved dramatically; initially prior to intervention Child-X couldn’t draw a circle. Figure.7) illustrates his ability now to paint a self-portrait, using matured fine motor skills. Although the case study on Child-X highlights the benefits of dietary intervention for a child with autism, it also reveals the financial impact it can have on this child’s family. A cost of £300- £550 a month plus supplements and tests and the added expense of buying organic, gluten free and dairy free products puts this form of dietary intervention beyond the reach of many families with autistic children. As it is unavailable on the NHS it makes this form of dietary intervention impossible for families of restricted income to afford. This is an area that could particularly benefit from further research into ways of limiting the financial strains of dietary interventions and the accompanying lifestyle changes for children with autism and their families. Overall, it can be concluded that intervening in the diet of a child with autism can have a positive and beneficial effect. The case study provides evidence to support this statement, whilst the review of literature reveals the numerous effects that different nutrients and diets can have on these children. As the researcher intended, an insight into the vast scope of different dietary ‘treatments’ has been provided and the subsequent success of such ‘treatments’ has been discussed. To fully understand the extent of the positive effects dietary interventions on autistic children
  • 56. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 56 | further research and a longitudinal study are imperative. The main objective of this study however was to provide a deeper understanding of dietary interventions with particular reference to GF/CF diets, as an informative document for anyone with a link to autism.
  • 57. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 57 | References: 1. Anderson. G, Arsenault. N, 2005, Fundamentals of Educational Research, 2nd ed. London: The Falmer Press 2. Angley. M, Semple. S, Hewton. C, Paterson. F, McKinnon. R, 2007, Children and autism: Part 2- management with complementary medicines and dietary interventions, Australian Family Physician, Volume 36, Issue No. 10 3. Baranek. GT, 2002, Efficacy of Sensory and Motor Interventions for Children with Autism, Journal of Autism and Development Disorders, Volume 32, Issue No. 5, Kluwer Academic Publishers 4. Brantlinger. E, Odom. SL, Gersten. R, Horner. RH, Thompson. B, Harris. KR, Research in Special Education: Scientific Methods and Evidence-Based Practices, Council for Exceptional Children, Volume 71, Issue No. 2, Pages 137-148 5. Brill. MT, 2001, Keys to Parenting the Child with Autism, Barron’s Educational Series, 2nd Ed. Hauppauge, NY: Barron’s Educational Series Inc. 6. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 2008. Using Graphs and Charts to Illustrate Quantitative Data, Issue No.12, Atlanta: Department of Health and Human Services, Pages 1-2 7. Davies. MB, 2007, Doing a Successful Research Project: Using qualitative or quantitative methods, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan 8. Davies. S, 2012, Parallel Universe, Bloomington: Xlibris Corporation 9. Department for Education and Skills (DFES), 2005, Turning the tables: transforming school food: main report : a report on the development and implementation of nutritional standards for school lunches, [Online] [Accessed
  • 58. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 58 | 20/03/2014] Available from: http://dera.ioe.ac.uk/5584/3/SMRP%20Report%20FINAL.pdf 10.Department of Health, 2010, School Fruit and Vegetable Scheme, The National Archives, [Online] [Accessed 17/03/2014] Available from: http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publichealth/H ealthimprovement/FiveADay/FiveADaygeneralinformation/DH_4002149 11.Edelson. SM, 2003, The Candida Yeast-Autism Connection, Oregon: Centre for the Study of Autism 12.Elder. JH, Shankar. M, Shuster. J, Theriaque. D, Burns. S, Sherrill. L, 2006. The Gluten-Free, Casein-Free Diet In Autism: Results of A Preliminary Double Blind Clinical Trial, Journal of Autism and Development Disorders, Volume 36, Issue No. 3, 413-420 13.Green. VA, Pituch. KA, Itchon. J, Choi. A, O’Reilly. M, Sigafoos. J, 2006 as cited in Hess. KL, MJ. Morrier, LJ. Heflin, ML. Ivey, 2008, Autism Treatment Survey: Services Received by Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders in Public School Classrooms, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, Volume 38, Issue No. 5, Page 962 14.Gregory. I, 2003, as cited in Wiles. R, Crow. G, Heath. S, Charles. V, 2006, Anonymity and Confidentiality, [Online] Accessed: 01/03/2014] Available from: http://www.ccsr.ac.uk/methods/festival/programme/aac/documents/anonandc onfpaperRMF06.pdf 15.Hanson. E, Kalish. LA, Bunce. E, Curtis. C, McDaniel. S, Ware. J, Petry. J, 2006, Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine among Children Diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, Volume 37, [Accessed Online: 01/03/2014]
  • 59. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 59 | Available from: http://download.springer.com/static/pdf/754/art%253A10.1007%252Fs10803- 006-0192- 0.pdf?auth66=1395319284_72b13904e64ebf0713af9bd81b881d20&ext=.pdf 16.Hess. KL, MJ. Morrier, LJ. Heflin, ML. Ivey, 2008, Autism Treatment Survey: Services Received by Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders in Public School Classrooms, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, Volume 38, Issue No. 5, Page 962 17.Interactive Autism Network (IAN), 2014, IAN Research Report: Special Diets, [Online] [Accessed 01/04/2014] Available from: http://www.autismspeaks.org/news/news-item/ian-research-report-special- diets 18.Isherwood. E, Spicer. B, Thomas. K, 2011, Dietary Management of Autism Spectrum Disorder, The British Dietetic Association, Accessed Online [24/03/2014] Available from: http://www.bda.uk.com/publications/statements/DietaryManagementAutism.pd f 19.Knivsberg. AM, Reichelt. KL, Hoien. T, Nodland. M, 2002, A randomized, controlled study of dietary intervention in autistic syndromes, Nutritional Neuroscience, Volume 5, Issue No. 4, 251-261 20.Lee. R, 2011, Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) and Autistic Spectrum Disorders: Feedback From Parents and Carers Following Child’s CAM Intervention, Children’s Complementary Therapy Network, Accessed Online [10/04/2014] Available from:
  • 60. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 60 | http://freshwinds.org.uk/publications/CAM-and-Autistic-Spectrum-Disorder- feedback-report_FINAL.pdf 21.Levin. JR, O’Donnell. AM, Kratochwill. TR, 2003, as cited in Brantlinger. E, Odom. SL, Gersten. R, Horner. RH, Thompson. B, Harris. KR, Research in Special Education: Scientific Methods and Evidence-Based Practices, Council for Exceptional Children, Volume 71, Issue No. 2, Pages 137-148 22.McCandless. J, 2007, Children with Starving Brains: A Medical Treatment Guide for Autism Spectrum Disorder, 3rd Edition, Florida: Bramble Books 23.Millward. C, Ferriter. M, Calver. SJ, Connell-Jones. GG, 2008, Gluten- and casein-free diets for autistic spectrum disorder, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Issue No. 2. 24.Oliver. P, 2003, as cited in Wiles. R, Crow. G, Heath. S, Charles. V, 2006, Anonymity and Confidentiality, [Online] Accessed: 01/03/2014] Available from: http://www.ccsr.ac.uk/methods/festival/programme/aac/documents/anonandc onfpaperRMF06.pdf 25.Ozonoff. S, Young. GS, Goldring. S, Greiss-Hess. L, Herrera. AM, Steele. J, Macari. S, Hepburn. S, Rogers. SJ, 2008, as cited in Haywood. K, Roberton. M, Getchell. N, 2012, Advanced analysis of Motor Development, Leeds: Human Kinetics 26.Panksepp. J, 1979, A neurochemical theory of autism, Point of View, Amsterdam: Elsevier/North Holland Biomedical Press, Pages 174-177 27.Schreibman. L E, 2007, The Science and Fiction of Autism, Cambridge Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, Page 23 28.Shattock. P, Whiteley. P, 2002, Biochemical aspects in autism spectrum disorders: updating the opioid-excess theory and presenting new
  • 61. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 61 | opportunities for biomedical intervention, Expert opinion on therapeutic targets, Volume 6, Issue No.2, Pages 175-183 29.Shaw. W, 2002, Biological Treatments for Autism and PDD, 2nd ed. Lenexa: Great Plain Laboratory Inc. 30.Smeltzer. B, 2011, The Medical Side of the GF/CF Diet for Autism: What is being treated and why it isn’t just “Autism”, Autism Science Digest: The Journal of Autism One, Issue 01, [Accessed Online: 27/02/2014] Available from: http://www.healingprovisions.net/PDF/ASD01p19-15_Smeltzer.pdf 31.Srinivasan. P, 2009, A review of dietary interventions in autism, Dietary Interventions in Autism, Annals of Clinical Psychiatry, Volume 21, Issue No. 4 American Academy of Clinical Psychiatrists, Abingdon: Taylor & Francis, Pages 237-247 32.Taylor. B, Jick. H, MacLaughlin. D, 2013, Prevalence and incidence rates of autism in the UK: time trend from 2004-2010 in children aged 8 years, British Medical Journal: London, Volume 3, Issue No. 10. Pages 1-8 33.The National Autistic Society, 2014, Statistics: how many people have autism spectrum disorders? Autism.org.uk, [Online] 27th February [Accessed 05/05/2014] Available from: http://www.autism.org.uk/about-autism/myths- facts-and-statistics/statistics-how-many-people-have-autism-spectrum- disorders.aspx 34.Tommey. J, Tommey. P, 2011, Autism: A practical guide to improving your child’s quality of life, London: Piatkus 35.Vaisman. N, Voet. H, Akivis. A, Vakil. E, 1996, Effect of breakfast timing on the cognitive functions of elementary school students, Archives of Paediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, Volume 150, Issue No. 10, 1089-1092
  • 62. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 62 | 36.Wiles. R, Crow. G, Heath. S, Charles. V, 2006, Anonymity and Confidentiality, [Online] Accessed: 01/03/2014] Available from: http://www.ccsr.ac.uk/methods/festival/programme/aac/documents/anonandc onfpaperRMF06.pdf 37.Williams. BL, Hornig. M, Buie. T, Bauman. ML, Paik. MC, Wick. I, Bennett. A, Jabado. O, Hirschberg. DL, Lipkin. IW, 2011, Impaired Carbohydrate Digestion and Transport and Mucosal Dysbiosis in the Intestines of Children with Autism and Gastrointestinal Disturbances, Plos One, [Online] [Accessed 10/04/2014] Available from: http://www.plosone.org/article/fetchObject.action?uri=info%3Adoi%2F10.1371 %2Fjournal.pone.0024585&representation=PDF
  • 63. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 63 | Appendices The following pages comprise Appendix.1 to Appendix.9.  Appendix.1- Research Checklist  Appendix.2- Parent Information Letter  Appendix.3- Secondary Information Letter  Appendix.4- Consent Form (Observation)  Appendix.5- Consent Form (Questionnaire/ Food Diary)  Appendix.6- 6.1 Child A Food Diary 6.2 Child B Food Diary 6.3 Child C Food Diary 6.4 Child D Food Diary 6.5 Child E Food Diary 6.6 Child F Food Diary 6.7 Child G Food Diary  Appendix.7- Child H Food Diary  Appendix.8- Research Questionnaire  Appendix.9- Scanned Menu Image Chapter_7.0
  • 64. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 64 | Food Group (eg carb, protein) Individual Food (eg crisps, chocolate) No. of Children Eating This Food Drink (eg water, juice, coke) No. of Children Drinking This Drink Solid Food Blended Food Restricted Diet Appendix.1
  • 65. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 65 | Dear Parent/ Carer Dietary Intervention for Children with Autism Questionnaire Observation of Children During Meal-Time I would like to invite you to take part in a questionnaire as part of a research project from the School of Education at the University of Leeds. I am looking into the positive effect that dietary interventions can have on children with Autism. The topic is informed by the Defeat Autism Now (DAN) campaign which is a biomedical approach to treating autism that focuses on the child’s diet. It involves various intervention approaches ranging from removing certain ingredients from the diet, for example yeast and gluten; and testing for hidden food allergies. My questionnaire is designed to gather information on the typical diets that children with autism have and the food that they eat at home. I also want to know if you are aware of the DAN campaign or have even tried any of the dietary interventions with your children. I would like to ask your permission also to include your child in my research. I would like to observe your child during their lunch-time at school, to establish their attitudes towards their food and to see which foods they generally seem to prefer. I will be asking a few questions if appropriate on what they are eating and what foods/ drinks they like but there will be no formal interview, only observational interaction. If you do not give your consent for my observation, your child will be removed from any research however if you do return the questionnaire I will still be able to use your answers within the research project. Any information given by your child will only be used to inform my research; I will uphold complete anonymity within my data. I have a DBS form from the University of Leeds and 5 years’ experience working with children with Autism and other disabilities, running holiday play-schemes for the children where I have responsibilities such as feeding, changing, entertaining and playing with the children. It is anticipated that this research project will shed some light on an intervention approach that has been little researched and provide positive results that could potentially benefit future approaches to interventions for Autism. 25/11/2013 Appendix.2
  • 66. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 66 | If you would like to participate in this questionnaire and agree to the use of your answers within this research project please sign the consent form paired with this information letter. If you have any further questions concerning this project or the way in which your input will be used do not hesitate to contact me. In the meantime, I thank you for any help you are able to give me. If for any reason you wish to be removed from the research you are entitled to do so without providing a reason. If you give consent for your child to be observed in their meal time setting and for these observations to be used within the research project please sign the second part of the consent form. It is not essential that you consent to both parts of this research project; you can choose to opt out of it completely or to only consent to one part. Complete anonymity will be upheld throughout the research and I will make the findings accessible to you once they have been drawn up so you will be kept informed throughout the research process. If you have any further queries please contact Mary Chambers who will be supervising this project. Dr Mary Chambers (M.E.Chambers@education.leeds.ac.uk) Room G.04, School of Education (Hillary Place) University of Leeds LS2 9JT 0113 343 3576 Kind regards, Louisa Pielichaty 62 Harold Terrace Leeds West Yorkshire LS61LD 07799200253 Louisapielichaty@gmail.com
  • 67. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 67 | Dear Parent/ Carer Dietary Intervention for Children with Autism Questionnaire/ Food Diary I would like to invite you to take part in a questionnaire and/or a food diary as part of a research project for my dissertation at the School of Education at the University of Leeds. I am looking into the effect that dietary interventions can have on children with Autism. The topic is informed by the Defeat Autism Now (DAN) campaign which is a biomedical approach to treating autism that focuses on the child’s diet. It involves various intervention approaches ranging from removing certain ingredients from the diet, for example yeast and gluten; and testing children for hidden food allergies. My questionnaire is designed to gather information on the typical diets that children with autism have and the food that they eat at home. My food diary is designed to gather an example of a typical week’s food and drink for your child. I want to outline immediately that there are no right or wrong answers and that the results of this questionnaire will be completely anonymous and that the food diary is to be completed however you see fit. I am also looking to find out if you are aware at all of the ‘DAN’ campaign or have whether you have ever tried any dietary interventions with your children. I would like to know if you have ever tried restricted diets or simply cutting out certain foods or food groups for your children. The attached questionnaire explores this in more detail. I have a DBS form from the University of Leeds and 5 years’ experience working with children with Autism and other disabilities, running holiday play-schemes for the children where I have responsibilities such as feeding, changing, entertaining and playing with the children. It is anticipated that this research project will shed some light on an intervention approach that has been little researched and provide positive results that could potentially benefit future approaches to interventions for Autism. If you would like to participate in this questionnaire/ food diary and agree to the use of your answers within this research project please sign the consent form paired with 02/01/2014 Appendix.3
  • 68. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 68 | this information letter. If you have any further questions concerning this project or the way in which your input will be used do not hesitate to contact me. In the meantime, I thank you for any help you are able to give me. If for any reason you wish to be removed from the research you are entitled to do so without providing a reason. Complete anonymity will be upheld throughout the research and I will make the findings accessible to you once they have been drawn up so you will be kept informed throughout the research process. If you have any further queries please contact Mary Chambers who will be supervising this project: Dr Mary Chambers (M.E.Chambers@education.leeds.ac.uk) Room G.04, School of Education (Hillary Place) University of Leeds LS2 9JT 0113 343 3576 Kind regards, Louisa Pielichaty 62 Harold Terrace Leeds West Yorkshire LS61LD 07799200253 Ed11lp@leeds.ac.uk
  • 69. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 69 | Consent to Observations of my Child in Meal Time Setting Add your initials next to the statements you agree with I confirm that I have read and understand the information letter dated 25/11/2013 explaining the above research project and I have had the opportunity to ask questions about the project. I understand that my child’s participation is voluntary and that they are free to withdraw at any time without giving any reason and without there being any negative consequences. In addition, should they not wish to answer any particular question or questions, they are free to decline. Contact: Louisa Pielichaty Louisapielichaty@gmail.com 07799200253 By agreeing for your child to take part in the research project you are agreeing for data collected by the research team to be used in publications and future research. I consent to my child taking part in (initial all which apply): a. every aspect of the research project including questions during observations. b. just observations with no questions. I do not want my child to be involved in the research project at all. I give permission formembers of the research team to have access to my child’s anonymised responses. I understand that their name will not be linked with the research materials, and they will not be identified or identifiable in the report or reports that result from the research. I understand that my child’s research responses willbe kept strictly confidential. I agree for the data collectedfrom my child to be used in relevant future research. I give permission formy answers to the questionnaire to be used to inform the research project. I understand that my name willnot be linked with the research materials, and I will not be identified or identifiable in the report or reports that result from the research. I understand that my research responses will be kept strictly confidential. By agreeing to take part in the research project I am agreeing for data collected by the research team to be used in publications and future research. I do not wish to be part of this research project and will not be Appendix.4
  • 70. Louisa Pielichaty 200624294 70 | returning the questionnaire. Consent to take part in Meal-Time Observations and Questionnaire Name of parent / carer Parent / carer’s signature Date Name of lead researcher Louisa Pielichaty Signature Date*