5. PROBLEMATIC
“THE MAP IS NOT THE TERRITORY”
Alfred Korzybski
PERFORM A MAINTENANCE AND RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT
SO THAT YOUR RELIABILITY INITIATIVES AND STRATEGIC
OBJECTIVES ARE FINALLY LINKED TOGETHER
10. DELIVERABLE
EVOLUTION
Monitor the
improvement of your
plant's maturity while
you are completing
reliability projects.
KPI
Update and display
your OEE or overall
plant uptime on a
dynamic dashboard.
11. DELIVERABLE
DASHBOARDS
AND KPI
Each pillar has its
own dashboard and
its own KPI that can
be updated and
monitored.
ASSET MASTER
DATA
WORK
MANAGEMENT
ASSET HEALTH
MANAGEMENT
LEADERSHIP FOR
RELIABILITY
INVENTORY
MANAGEMENT
DEFECT
ELIMINATION
CRAFT
SKILLS
Data collected
(as a % of all assets)
80%
(Goal: 100%)
Up 20%
12. DELIVERABLE
DASHBOARDS
AND KPI
Each pillar has its
own dashboard and
its own KPI that can
be updated and
monitored.
ASSET MASTER
DATA
WORK
MANAGEMENT
ASSET HEALTH
MANAGEMENT
LEADERSHIP FOR
RELIABILITY
INVENTORY
MANAGEMENT
DEFECT
ELIMINATION
CRAFT
SKILLS
Data collected
(as a % of all assets)
80%
(Goal: 100%)
Up 20%
13. COMPARE YOURSELVES TO THE BEST
Take advantage of 9 years of analysis of published &
private survey data from sources such as SMRP, CMA,
Townsend, Solomon, AISE, SAE, PIMA, TAPPI, EPRI and
AT Kearny. Benchmarks are set for 11 different types
of industries.
1st quartile 2nd quartile 3rd quartile 4th quartile
14. OUR OBSERVATIONS VS. TODAY’S BEST PRACTICES
Observations Best practices
Work Identification Here’s what we found out during our visit…Here’s
what we found out during our visit…Here’s what we
found out during our visit…
Any maintenance employee can create a work order as long as
detailed information is provided. Operators bring feedback to
maintenance personnel and corrective ….
Work Prioritization Here’s what we found out during our visit…Here’s
what we found out during our visit…Here’s what we
found out during our visit…
Work Orders are prioritized thanks to asset criticality ranking,
time to failure and work types. Daily meetings between
maintenance a…..
Planning Here’s what we found out during our visit…Here’s
what we found out during our visit…Here’s what we
found out during our visit…
Planners received a specific training. They exclusively manage
future work and do not get involved into reactive work. Jobs
are planned 2 to 3 weeks in advance. A Job Plan database is
available and includes …………..
Scheduling Here’s what we found out during our visit…Here’s
what we found out during our visit…Here’s what we
found out during our visit…
Schedulers are informed of the available maintenance
workforce, by skillset, for the upcoming weeks. They
coordinate with Operations during a weekly meeting to
schedule planned work, provide spec………
Follow-up and
Analysis
Here’s what we found out during our visit…Here’s
what we found out during our visit…Here’s what we
found out during our visit…
Failure coding is widely used when closing Work Orders to fuel
the failure elimination work process. Feedback from the teams
is recorded on the Work Orders(schedule conflict, parts
missing), planners…..
Details
15. ACTION PLAN
Your dashboard was created
2016-01-05
Reliability analytics definition
At vero eos et accusamus et iusto odio
dignissimos ducimus qui blanditiis
praesentium
Completed on
2016-03-15
Completed
Asset master data workshop
At vero eos et accusamus et iusto odio
dignissimos ducimus qui blanditiis
praesentium
Completed on
2016-04-19
Completed
16. Criticality analysis
At vero eos et accusamus et iusto odio
dignissimos ducimus qui blanditiis
praesentium
End on
2016-09-01
In progress
Data collection
At vero eos et accusamus et iusto odio
dignissimos ducimus qui blanditiis
praesentium
End on
2016-08-19
Late
PMO - FMEA – RCM
At vero eos et accusamus et iusto odio
dignissimos ducimus qui blanditiis
praesentium
Start on
2016-09-15
Not started
!
17. VIZUALISE YOUR IMPROVEMENT
ASSESSMENT
250 QUESTIONS
Question 1: ………….
Question 2: ……
Question 3: ………………………..
Question 4: ………….
Question 5: …………….
Question 6: ………….
Question 7: …………………………
Question 8: ………….
Question 9: ………….
Question 10: …………………
Question 11: ……….
Question 12: …….
Question 13: ………….
Question 14: …….
RECOMMENDATION #1
A PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE OPTIMIZATION PROCESS SHOULD BE PUT IN PLACE FOLLOWING THE
CRITICALITY ANALYSIS OF THE EQUIPMENT. THE OPTIMIZATION PROCESS SHOULD BE BASED ON THE
ANALYSIS OF THE FAILURE MODES AND THEIR EFFECTS FOR EACH EQUIPMENT CLASS (EG, AC MOTOR,
CENTRIFUGAL PUMP, RECIPROCATING COMPRESSOR). A CUSTOMIZED MAINTENANCE STRATEGY SHOULD BE
BUILT TAKING INTO ACCOUNT OF EACH FAILURE MODE AND THE CRITICALITY OF EACH ASSET. PREVENTIVE
MAINTENANCE FREQUENCIES SHOULD BE OPTIMIZED AND RELATED TASKS SHOULD BE FORMULATED
OBJECTIVELY. THE USE OF PREDICTIVE TECHNOLOGIES MUST BE MAXIMIZED AND ALL NON-VALUE ADDED
TASKS SHOULD BE ELIMINATED.
START DATE: JAN 1ST 2017
END DATE: MAR 31ST 2017
MIN COST: 25000$
MAX COST: 36000$
EDIT AND UPDATE STATUS, ENTER PROGRESSION,
COMMENTS, ETC.
COMPLETE
20. MONITOR WHAT MATTERS
VIBRATION
OIL ANALYSIS
THERMOGRAPHY
ULTRASONICS
PRIORITIZE YOUR ACTIONS THANKS TO A
DYNAMIC DASHBOARD THAT INCLUDES
OPERATIONAL RISK AND GLOBAL PLANT HEALTH
24. HEALTH DEFINED AT EACH LEVEL OF THE HIERARCHY
FOCUS ON WHAT MATTERS
FAILURE CODES, OBSERVATIONS,
RECOMMENDATIONS
!
EXPORT IN PDF AND ATTACH TO
YOUR WORK ORDERS
PDF
25. MANAGE CLIENTS/SITES/HIERARCHY
PLANT A
0100 – RECEIVING
0200 – REFINING
0300 – PAPER MACHINE
0200-AGI-001 AGITATOR 1
0200-PUL-030 PULPER 3
MOTOR AC
GEARBOX
ETC.
PLANT
AREA
AREA
AREA
EQUIPMENT
EQUIPMENT
COMPONENT
COMPONENT
COMPONENT
CLIENT CLIENT
26. OVERALL WORKFLOW
RESULT ENTERED IN
SPARTAKUS
NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED
YES
NO, RESULT IS NORMAL
FREQUENCY
BASED
REQUIRED
ACTION?
VIB. MEASUREMENT
TAKEN BY TECH
OPEN
ALERT
CORRECTIVE ACTION
PLANNED
IN PROGRESS
ACTION
CORRECTIVE ACTION
PERFORMED
COMPLETED
ACTION
VALIDATION
READING
REQUIRED
SUCCESS APPROVAL.
SAVINGS ARE
RECORDED
RESULT CONFIRMS
PREVIOUS PROBLEM HAS
BEEN FIXED
!
27. RESULTS AND ALERTS CLASSIFICATION
COLORS
Urgency Urgent Critical Attention Abnormal Normal
Action
Immediate action
required
Plan for next
shutdown
Follow
recommendation
Monitor closely -
Severity 25% 50% 75% 95% 100%
ALERTS/ACTIONS
!
OPEN IN PROGRESS COMPLETED APPROVED