Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization (ADAO) U.S. House of Representatives staff briefing presentation. Speakers included: Dr. Richard Lemen, Dr. Barry Castleman, Linda Reinstein, Brent Kynoch, and Barbara Minty McQueen. (July 24, 2012)
2012 House Staff Briefing: "Asbestos: Environmental and Occupational Exposure Continues"
1. Asbestos: Environmental and
Occupational Exposure Continues
Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization (ADAO)
www.adao.us
July 24, 2012
Reinstein 7.24.2012
2. Speakers
Dr. Richard Lemen, PhD, Assistant Surgeon General,
U.S.P.H.S. (ret.)
Dr. Barry Castleman, ScD, Environmental Consultant
Linda Reinstein, ADAO President and Co-Founder
J. Brent Kynoch, Managing Director, Environmental
Information Association
Barbara Minty McQueen, mesothelioma widow
Reinstein 7.24.2012
6. Update:
U.S. Senate Resolution
S. 389
Designating the first week of
April 2012 as `National
Asbestos Awareness Week'.
Resolved, that the Senate urges
the Surgeon General, as a
public health issue, to warn
and educate people that
asbestos exposure may be
hazardous to their health.
Reinstein 7.24.2012
7. “Consequences of Continued
Asbestos Use”
Richard A. Lemen, Ph.D.
Assistant Surgeon General, U.S.P.H.S. (ret.)
July 24, 2012
Lemen 7.24.2012
8. What Happens to Asbestos in the Respiratory System
Nose Filters out
fibers >100µ long
Cilia Clears mucus
(and fibers) from lung
Lung Cancer
Free Alveolar Macrophages
(FAMs): Phagocytize fibers within
Mesothelioma
lung
Lemen 7.24.2012
9. Are Asbestos-Related Diseases a Pandemic?
A pandemic is the excessive occurrence of
a disease in a large portion of the world
H1N1 Pandemic Asbestos-related diseases
14,142 Deaths worldwide More than 107,000* Deaths
worldwide each year
More than 10,000 Deaths in
the U.S. each year**
*107,000 is probably an underestimate because it doesn’t include other cancers (e.g.
Larynx and Ovary)
**EWG
Lemen 7.24.2012
11. Relative Inhalation Toxicity of Chemicals
Listed in the EPA’s Toxic Release Inventory
Asbestos (friable) (1332-21-4) Known Carcinogen 1,000,000
Benzidine (92-87-5) Known Carcinogen 480,000
Bis(chloromethyl) ether (542-88-1) Known Carcinogen 440,000
N-Nitrosodiethylamine (55-18-5) Known Carcinogen 310,000
Propyleneimine (75-55-8) Known Carcinogen 300,000
N-Nitroso-N-ethylurea (759-73-9) Known Carcinogen 280,000
Diisocyanates (N120) Non-Carcinogen 180,000
N-Nitrosodimethylamine (62-75-9) Known Carcinogen 100,000
Acrolein (107-02-8) Non-Carcinogen 90,000
Cadmium and cadmium compounds (7440-43-9) Known Carcinogen* 90,000
Chromium and chromium compounds (7440-47-
3) Known Carcinogen 86,000
Polybrominated biphenyls (PBBs) (N575) Known Carcinogen* 71,000
Lemen 7.24.2012
12. “U.S. Asbestos Product
Imports and Contamination”
Barry Castleman, ScD
Environmental Consultant
July 24, 2012
Castleman 7.24.2012
13. ADAO Product Testing
5 Products Contaminated
With Asbestos Monitoring Needed
Once a ban is enacted, the U.S.
will need to analyze imported
products so that Americans will
not be endangered by unlabeled
asbestos products which may
already be coming in (violating
OSHA regulations).
Castleman 7.24.2012
14. Contaminated Asbestos in Stone and Minerals
NIOSH is looking into contaminant asbestos in talc,
stone, & other minerals.
The California Air Resource Board (CARB 435) limit
of 0.25% asbestos in stone and gravel should be able to
be met nation-wide.
Castleman 7.24.2012
15. Safer Substitutions Exist
No U.S. manufacturers make asbestos brake pads,
gaskets, and A-C pipes. Banning imports of these
asbestos products protects U.S. workers and companies.
Non-asbestos diaphragms and membrane cell
technology are alternatives to discredited asbestos
diaphragm and mercury cell technology.
Castleman 7.24.2012
16. Top Asbestos Facts
1. The US still imports asbestos from Canada and asbestos
products from a large number of countries. Monitoring
of asbestos product imports for OSHA cancer labeling
is needed.
2. There are safer substitutes to asbestos that provide equal
functionality at comparable costs.
3. 55 countries worldwide have banned asbestos. The
United States still has not.
Castleman 7.24.2012
17. “Asbestos, Still Legal and Lethal”
Linda Reinstein
President/Co-Founder
Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization (ADAO)
July 24, 2012
Reinstein 7.24.2012
18. ADAO Memorial Dedication
Alan Reinstein
1939 - 2006
Mesothelioma Victim
United States
www.AsbestosDiseaseAwareness.org
19. How Small is Asbestos?
2-3 rice grains 20,000 Asbestos Fibers
5-6 human hairs
Reinstein 7.24.2012
20. Asbestos is a Proven Human Carcinogen and
There is No Safe Level of Exposure
Reinstein 7.24.2012
24. The Human Face of Disease
• New Patient Profile
• Woman
• Under the age of 50
• Environmental or Take-Home Exposure
• 10,000 annual asbestos-caused deaths in the USA
• 107,000 annual asbestos-caused deaths globally
• 3,000 new cases of mesothelioma are diagnosed each
year in the United States
Reinstein 7.26.2012
27. “Asbestos: Regulatory Concerns
and Violations”
J. Brent Kynoch
Managing Director, EIA
July 24, 2012
“Our multi-disciplinary membership collects, generates and disseminates
information about environmental issues in buildings and facilities.”
Kynoch 7.24.2012
28. Existing Regulations
TSCA
• AHERA – Asbestos in Schools Rule.
Accreditation requirements extended to public and
commercial buildings.
NESHAP
• The 1% rule.
• All buildings must be inspected for asbestos prior
to demolition or renovation.
OSHA – Exposure limits regardless of %.
Kynoch 7.24.12
29. Enforcement?
By EPA’s own admission, enforcement is “dismal.”1
Existing regulations are sufficient to protect worker
and environmental health.
Budgets (for inspectors) continue to be cut, but
“encouragement” can and should be pushed
downhill.
Kynoch 7.24.2012
30. Enforcement Issues
Marco Island, FL – June 5, 2010 settlement - $81,772
– neither contractor nor city take liability
Kynoch 7.24.2012
31. What Can Be Done?
Beef Up TSCA, NESHAP, and OSHA, Enforcement
• Current enforcement is handcuffed by red tape and lack of power.
• Provides jobs.
• Pays for itself.
• Enforcement will stem violations that lead to exposures, disease and
death.
Increase education and encourage funding.
• Demolition and renovation permits.
• Greater involvement at local level
Kynoch 7.24.2012
32. “Get Off the Bench, Get in the
Game, and Immediately Ban
Asbestos”
Barbara Minty McQueen
McQueen 7.24.2012 July 24, 2012
33. ADAO Memorial Dedication
Steve McQueen
1930 - 1980
Mesothelioma Victim
United States
McQueen 7.24.2012
Toxicity weight:is a proportional numerical weight applied to a chemical based on its toxicity. The toxicity of a chemical is assessed using EPA-established standard methodologies. For each exposure route, chemicals are weighted based on their single, most sensitive adverse chronic human health effect (cancer or the most sensitive noncancer effect). In the absence of data, the toxicity weight for one pathway is adopted for the other pathway. The range of toxicity weights is approximately 0.01 to 1,000,000.
The United States imported 1,100 metric tons of asbestos between July 2010 – July 2011. 92% of this asbestos comes from Canada. Though this figure is the lowest amount of asbestos imported by the U.S. since 1909, consumption increased by 6% over this last calendar year. By continuing to allow asbestos to be imported and used within the United States, more and more people will be exposed through everyday products, such as roofing materials
With the help of industrial hygienist Tony Rich, ADAO has started the “Asbestos: See For Yourself” campaign, which aims to educate the public through pictures of asbestos in homes, offices, and of improper removal techniques. Phase I: http://slidesha.re/Jmdytq
Good morning. Hi, I'm Barbie McQueen, widow of actor Steve McQueen, who died from mesothelioma.
As is customary with all ADAO speeches and presentations, I would like to begin with a memorial dedication, to my husband, Steve.
These are photocopies of my late husband’s U.S. Marine Corps Service Record Book. Steve served in the Marine Corps from 1947-1950, finding himself in Washington D.C. at the Naval Yard, where he was charged with removing asbestos-filled insulation from massive pipes in the ship’s hold. It is here that Steve and I believe he was first exposed to asbestos, though it is possible he was exposed while on film sets or from the protective suits he wore while racing
Asbestos is a known carcinogen causing terminal illnesses including mesothelioma. The love of my life and soul mate, a global icon and world renowned “King of Cool,” was taken from us because of a preventable disease.Asbestos is already banned in 55 countries around the world and it's time for the United States to get off the bench, get in the game, and immediately ban asbestos.
The medical communities in the United States and around the world, including the US Surgeon General, Environmental Protection Agency, the World Health Organization and International Labour Organization agree asbestos is a human carcinogen and there is no safe level of exposure.