SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 23
Download to read offline
About Me
1
Bachelors Degree in Mechanical Engineering -Graduated in 1992.
24 years experience in Oil and Gas Industry.
Presently working as Head of Mechanical Static in PETRONAS Carigali
in the Production International Division.
Technical Authority of International Operations in various part of the
world.
Worked in Various Capacities - Mechanical Design Engineer, Project
Execution & Commissioning
Experienced in Piping, pipeline, pressure vessel, tanks and mechanical
static equipment
Won various innovation Awards & HSE Award.
Following are some of the works done over the years
 Prior to commencing operation activities, an operation meeting was held at 0630 to
discuss JHA & Permit to Work (PTW). As per operation log there were 10 PTW opened for
activities on that day. One of the activities were Startup Gas Compressor Train(GTC).
 Control room operator started up GTC and continued to increase speed and put on
load. At full load status , the field operator heard the sound of gas leak above the after-
cooler train and confirmed the gas leak from the incoming flange of the after-cooler
train.
 Control room operator activated Plant Shutdown manually and the GTC was
immediately stopped – the pressure immediately was reduced to 0 psi.
 As a result of this incident, 3 flange gaskets of inlet cooler GTC were damage in normal
operating condition.
3/23/2016
2
Carried out Axisymmetric contact flange leak analysis- Finite Element Analysis and Caesar II analysis to
identify deficiencies in design - FEED phase to implementation of the project
3/23/2016
3 Underlying Causes
Design Engineering (DE):
• Failed to conduct a proper review of the stress analysis report and failed to recognize
the importance of the differential thermal load on dissimilar nozzle material.
• Failed to review standards during detail engineering. Data sheet of the insulating
gasket is incomplete and does not have the process design data.
• In the detailed engineering material selection did not follow manufacture standard for
the insulating gasket as Neophenolic can only installed in piping flanges of 300# or
below and temperature less than 107deg
Incompatible Goals (IG):
• Failed to communicate important issues on design (stress analysis & process
parameter) from detailed engineering to PCIC contractor.
• Failed on the part of management to bridge between detailed engineering phase and
PCIC phase
Error Enforcing Conditions (EC):
• Management Failed to review Special Item. The Insulation Gasket are special items,
however, these were treated as bulk material by the PCIC contractor.
• Verify Bolt tensioning calculation by the contractor. Bolting by the specialist flange
management contractor on critical test limit tie-in flanged joints were carried out
without proper calculations and review.
• Insufficient resources to conduct proper Line Design Review(LDR)
Hydrostatic load on vertical vessel Skid
3/23/2016
4
Usually the hydrotest of vessels during the fabrication
is not carried out on the skid. Temporary arrangements
are made in the workshop and the vessel is
hydrotested before painting.
Due to this, the vessel’s skids and the supporting
arrangements are not particularly designed for
hydrostatic test loads.
Careful calculations should be done to check the
components and their suitability to handle these
occasional loads.
Below is a check done on a vertical pressure vessel
which was going to be subjected to hydrotest load at
field and a potential incident was avoided.
Location of High stress
and local failure expected
2015
3/23/2016
5
• This is a loss of containment incident due to a ruptured Utility Gas
Heater -an Electrical heat exchanger.
• The incident occurred during the process of starting-up of the Vapor
Recovery Compressor (VRC)
• The incident resulted in total damage of the shell and local damage to
nearby lighting, fitting, insulation and cladding.
• The exchanger was replaced with a newly designed one.
LOSS OF PRIMARY CONTAINMENT (LOPC)
INCIDENT AT UTILITY GAS HEATER
3/23/2016
6
• Fortunately, there was no one near the equipment during the incident or
it could have resulted in a more severe impact as the incident involved a
high-pressure release of natural gas at 90 BarG.
• It was also fortunate that the release was stopped through manual
activation of Emergency Shut Down (ESD) before it could get in contact
with any source of ignition.
• This study was trigger by photographical evidences of the site which had
a heat exchanger with missing bolts on the support.
LOSS OF PRIMARY CONTAINMENT (LOPC)
INCIDENT AT UTILITY GAS HEATER
Offshore Crash/Rescue Fire Trainer – Helicopter Simulator
7
 UAE’s First Offshore Crash/ Rescue
Helicopter Simulator
Complete with Helideck
Features of the Simulator:
 The helicopter simulator will be placed
on the steel Helideck structure as this
will give the offshore fire fighting team a
realistic simulation
 The simulator will be gas fired as it will
have HSE advantage over the oil fired
simulator.
Future:
 It can be used to Train Other companies offshore Fire fighting Teams, and this concept can also be
used by other companies to train their personnel.
 The Simulator will be used to simulate engine fire, cockpit fire, baggage/ compartment fire and pool fire
 Used to Train Offshore Fire Fighting Teams and external fire fighting teams.
 In-house design - Built to international Standards
Introduction
Innovations of 2013
Buckling Analysis on Tank with Distortion-2011
8 Background
Tank was built in 1980 and has been in
operation for 31years
Service was sour oily water
Tank was used as Surge tank in the sour
water treatment plant
The tank was built to BSI – 2654 version
1973 & NACE




Introduction
Tank was under major overhaul in Jan 2011
Cause of this distortion was not known
Inspection revealed distortions on both the
Shell and Dome
A fitness for service evaluation of the flaw
was required to be carried out to put back
the tank into operation




Buckling Analysis on Tank with Distortion -2011
9
Assumptions made
There was no thickness loss/variation - as
inspection reports did not reveal any such defect
The tank has a suitable monitoring / inspection
program


Concerns Raised Resolution
The original design
data and
calculation were not
available
A finite element model of the
design case (without any
flaw/base case) was generated
to look at the maximum stress at
the relevant part and compare
with the flaw assessment
No established
standard to carry
out buckling analysis
for tanks built to BSI
standards.
Above Base Case Model help in
looking at the compatibility with
API620 & API 579 was used for
Fitness for Service assessment.
Effect of nozzle load on the shell was not
considered as no data is available. (Note : There are
no piping attachments on the dome.)
It was not the basis of this study to identify the root
cause of the buckling - as no information was
provided to carry out such a study


Buckling Analysis on Tank with Distortions
10 Analysis Procedure
STEP 1 – Flaw and Damage Mechanism Identification
STEP 3 – Data Requirements
STEP 2 – Applicability and Limitations of the FFS Assessment Procedures
STEP 4 – Assessment Techniques and Acceptance Criteria




STEP 5 – Remaining Life Evaluation
STEP 6 – Remediation
STEP 7 – In-Service Monitoring of the Flaw
STEP 8 – Documentation
Methodology as per API579
 Applicability and Limitations of the FFS Assessment Procedures was to be
established
Data Requirements for the FFS was to be established
Available Original Equipment Design Data required
Required Data/Measurements for a FFS Assessment.
Assessment Techniques and Acceptance Criteria’s were to be established
Based on the above, carry out buckling analysis of the distortions.
Provide Recommendations.
Buckling Analysis in Tank with Distortion
11
Assessment to API579 – Level 3
Base Case Model (model without any distortion)
Buckling Analysis on Tank
12
Assessment to API579 – Level 3
Limit-Load Analysis Method (refer B1.2.3
of API579)

This technique used in determining
the maximum vacuum/external
pressure required to reach the
minimum yield stress i.e. to
determine the load required to
reach the plastic deformation.
The base case established that a
vacuum/external pressure of
0.04N/mm2 was required to be applied
uniformly on the tank at 37degC to
cause the yield point to be reached
Buckling Analysis in Tank
13
 All the four flaw locations were mapped with a grid of 100 x 100mm
 The grid were plotted with the use of Autocad and transferred to Algor.
 Algor software was used for the refined mesh generations and final
assessment of the flaws
 Elastic Stress Analysis Method was used in the buckling analysis.
 The equivalent stress equal to the von Mises equivalent stress was used.
Assessment to API579 – Level 3
 Carry out repair on location-3 and location-4 on the Dome
 Recommendation were issued on how to avoid vacuum
load.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis -2011
14
The Failure of Mooring Hawser
at SPM-February 2011
No personal injuries and no oil spill / pollution
Property Damage resulted: Parting of the mooring
hawser and damage to the thimble eye on the SPM
side



A multidiscipline team was formed to investigate the
incident.

Introduction
Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis
15
Dynamic Analysis
The load on the hawser was plotted against the
actual load on the hawser at the time of the
incident to simulate the actual scenario.
A realistic model was created to look at the snatch
effect on the hawser.

Load Cell Reading at the berth at the time of the incident
Dynamic Simulation Load Input
84 sec – 130.8ton & 90 sec – 400ton
Inspection revealed no anomalies for this
particular hawser.
The hawser was loaded 53 (75% of normal
uses) out 70 times with 1117hrs working (93%
of operational life span of 1200 hrs) & 4month
19days since installation


Static Analysis
A static analysis was also carried out on the
hawser with two case
 Case with a load of 130t
 Case with a load of 250t

Discussion
Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis
16
Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis
17
In Conclusion the Immediate cause:
Ship Approach during the Berthing Operation:
The final approach was not conducted as per standard approach which created transverse motion and
high rate of turn that consequently resulted in heavy snatch load effect on the hawser.
Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis
18
Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis
19 Load=130ton
Innovation -2009
GRE Piggable Pipeline – ASME B31.4
20
Barred TeeBarred Tee
Introduction:
 First GRE piggable pipeline to ASME B31.4
Features of the Line:
 The 20” pipeline will consist of GRE Barred tee for branch Connection upto 8”.
 The bends used will be piggable.
 Line will be buried except at tie-in locations.
 Criss-cross poly foam will be used for pigging the line.
 Resistance to Corrosion thereby extending the life of the pipeline.
 Lead the Stress Analysis to find a suitable solution to
avoid shutdown of the platform.
 Gas Leaks on bellow convolutions were identified -
with one out of three trains forced to shutdown and
another train was running under continuous
monitoring with leak from cracked convolutions.
 No spare available of the bellows in stores.
 Provide engineered solution to run both trains till
replacement bellows arrives from abroad.
 Performed static analysis of the 16” x 10” discharge
piping Gas compressor & Dehydration Trains of Gas
Compressor to find a suitable alternative temporary
solution
Gas Compressor bellow Leak (year 2007)
Introduction
 The condition of the train at the start of the analysis was
 Train A was shutdown with one upper vertical Gimbal bellow and the horizontal
Hinged bellow found leaking.
 Train B was running with a leaking bellow (crack on Horizontal Bellow).
 The life cycle(7000cycles) of the bellows have exceeded and no spare bellows
available.
 Avoid shutdown
 Purpose of Analysis
 to check the feasibility of replacing the leaking vertical Gimbal & hinged bellows with
a rigid pipe spool piece.
 Carry out static stress analysis to ASME B31.8 & check reaction at the compressor
nozzle (discharge side - are within the allowable of API617) with the existing piping
configurations
 Conclusion and Recommendation:
 The stress analysis is valid for the proposed modification of utilizing Cold Spring to enable
the operation of Train A and B on a temporary basis till the replacement bellow are
available in 3 week time.
22
Gas Compressor bellow Leak (year 2007)
Discussion
FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS -2002
FITNESS FOR SERVICE
23
Scaled Acad Model of Spheroid
Drawn by Bijoy
Featured article &
Picture from Company
Magazine
Thank You

More Related Content

What's hot

Subsea pipelines the remotely welded retrofit tee for hot tap applications ...
Subsea pipelines the remotely welded retrofit tee for hot tap applications   ...Subsea pipelines the remotely welded retrofit tee for hot tap applications   ...
Subsea pipelines the remotely welded retrofit tee for hot tap applications ...Neil Woodward
 
RA- Pressure Testing Of Pipe Works
RA- Pressure Testing Of Pipe WorksRA- Pressure Testing Of Pipe Works
RA- Pressure Testing Of Pipe WorksSajid Ali
 
Analyzer Engineer Process Hydrocarbons
Analyzer Engineer Process HydrocarbonsAnalyzer Engineer Process Hydrocarbons
Analyzer Engineer Process HydrocarbonsKamran Saeed
 
Analyzer Maintenance Engineer.
Analyzer Maintenance Engineer.Analyzer Maintenance Engineer.
Analyzer Maintenance Engineer.Amit Seladiya
 
Your Field is Getting Older: Is your Process Engineering Still Cost Effective?
Your Field is Getting Older: Is your Process Engineering Still Cost Effective?Your Field is Getting Older: Is your Process Engineering Still Cost Effective?
Your Field is Getting Older: Is your Process Engineering Still Cost Effective?Society of Petroleum Engineers
 
In-Place Pipe Support Load Testing and Hanger Surveys_Part of a Best in Class...
In-Place Pipe Support Load Testing and Hanger Surveys_Part of a Best in Class...In-Place Pipe Support Load Testing and Hanger Surveys_Part of a Best in Class...
In-Place Pipe Support Load Testing and Hanger Surveys_Part of a Best in Class...Britt Bettell
 
Effect of boron content on steels and recommended practice for welding Sasank...
Effect of boron content on steels and recommended practice for welding Sasank...Effect of boron content on steels and recommended practice for welding Sasank...
Effect of boron content on steels and recommended practice for welding Sasank...NSW Environment and Planning
 
RA- Flushing - Chemical Treatment
RA- Flushing - Chemical TreatmentRA- Flushing - Chemical Treatment
RA- Flushing - Chemical TreatmentSajid Ali
 
Sample rel assement a company -sov reliability assessment criteria
Sample rel assement   a company -sov reliability assessment criteriaSample rel assement   a company -sov reliability assessment criteria
Sample rel assement a company -sov reliability assessment criteriaTom Jacyszyn
 
( Itp ag pipe) rapid p006 a scs qac itp 3200 0007
( Itp ag pipe) rapid p006 a scs qac itp 3200 0007( Itp ag pipe) rapid p006 a scs qac itp 3200 0007
( Itp ag pipe) rapid p006 a scs qac itp 3200 0007Tonni Bruce
 
The Digital Oilfield - Collaborative Working at Global Scale
The Digital Oilfield - Collaborative Working at Global ScaleThe Digital Oilfield - Collaborative Working at Global Scale
The Digital Oilfield - Collaborative Working at Global ScaleSociety of Petroleum Engineers
 
Understanding the hazards at your mine and an enforceable undertaking - Clint...
Understanding the hazards at your mine and an enforceable undertaking - Clint...Understanding the hazards at your mine and an enforceable undertaking - Clint...
Understanding the hazards at your mine and an enforceable undertaking - Clint...NSW Environment and Planning
 

What's hot (20)

Engineering & Design - April
Engineering & Design - April Engineering & Design - April
Engineering & Design - April
 
Subsea pipelines the remotely welded retrofit tee for hot tap applications ...
Subsea pipelines the remotely welded retrofit tee for hot tap applications   ...Subsea pipelines the remotely welded retrofit tee for hot tap applications   ...
Subsea pipelines the remotely welded retrofit tee for hot tap applications ...
 
RA- Pressure Testing Of Pipe Works
RA- Pressure Testing Of Pipe WorksRA- Pressure Testing Of Pipe Works
RA- Pressure Testing Of Pipe Works
 
TPI - Example Report.
TPI - Example Report.TPI - Example Report.
TPI - Example Report.
 
edward jacob cv
edward jacob cvedward jacob cv
edward jacob cv
 
Well test procedures manual
Well test procedures manualWell test procedures manual
Well test procedures manual
 
Analyzer Engineer Process Hydrocarbons
Analyzer Engineer Process HydrocarbonsAnalyzer Engineer Process Hydrocarbons
Analyzer Engineer Process Hydrocarbons
 
Analyzer Maintenance Engineer.
Analyzer Maintenance Engineer.Analyzer Maintenance Engineer.
Analyzer Maintenance Engineer.
 
Your Field is Getting Older: Is your Process Engineering Still Cost Effective?
Your Field is Getting Older: Is your Process Engineering Still Cost Effective?Your Field is Getting Older: Is your Process Engineering Still Cost Effective?
Your Field is Getting Older: Is your Process Engineering Still Cost Effective?
 
In-Place Pipe Support Load Testing and Hanger Surveys_Part of a Best in Class...
In-Place Pipe Support Load Testing and Hanger Surveys_Part of a Best in Class...In-Place Pipe Support Load Testing and Hanger Surveys_Part of a Best in Class...
In-Place Pipe Support Load Testing and Hanger Surveys_Part of a Best in Class...
 
Pipe Support Field Examples & Case Studies
Pipe Support Field Examples & Case StudiesPipe Support Field Examples & Case Studies
Pipe Support Field Examples & Case Studies
 
Effect of boron content on steels and recommended practice for welding Sasank...
Effect of boron content on steels and recommended practice for welding Sasank...Effect of boron content on steels and recommended practice for welding Sasank...
Effect of boron content on steels and recommended practice for welding Sasank...
 
RA- Flushing - Chemical Treatment
RA- Flushing - Chemical TreatmentRA- Flushing - Chemical Treatment
RA- Flushing - Chemical Treatment
 
Sample rel assement a company -sov reliability assessment criteria
Sample rel assement   a company -sov reliability assessment criteriaSample rel assement   a company -sov reliability assessment criteria
Sample rel assement a company -sov reliability assessment criteria
 
( Itp ag pipe) rapid p006 a scs qac itp 3200 0007
( Itp ag pipe) rapid p006 a scs qac itp 3200 0007( Itp ag pipe) rapid p006 a scs qac itp 3200 0007
( Itp ag pipe) rapid p006 a scs qac itp 3200 0007
 
Malkin Panel: Blade Root Cause Analysis Processes and Inspection Methods
Malkin Panel: Blade Root Cause Analysis Processes and Inspection MethodsMalkin Panel: Blade Root Cause Analysis Processes and Inspection Methods
Malkin Panel: Blade Root Cause Analysis Processes and Inspection Methods
 
Sandia 2014 Wind Turbine Blade Workshop- Malkin
Sandia 2014 Wind Turbine Blade Workshop- MalkinSandia 2014 Wind Turbine Blade Workshop- Malkin
Sandia 2014 Wind Turbine Blade Workshop- Malkin
 
The Digital Oilfield - Collaborative Working at Global Scale
The Digital Oilfield - Collaborative Working at Global ScaleThe Digital Oilfield - Collaborative Working at Global Scale
The Digital Oilfield - Collaborative Working at Global Scale
 
Understanding the hazards at your mine and an enforceable undertaking - Clint...
Understanding the hazards at your mine and an enforceable undertaking - Clint...Understanding the hazards at your mine and an enforceable undertaking - Clint...
Understanding the hazards at your mine and an enforceable undertaking - Clint...
 
Pipe Support Engineering & Design - June
Pipe Support Engineering & Design - JunePipe Support Engineering & Design - June
Pipe Support Engineering & Design - June
 

Similar to 24 years experience in Oil and Gas Industry

Episode 34 : Project Execution Part (5)
Episode 34 :  Project Execution Part (5)Episode 34 :  Project Execution Part (5)
Episode 34 : Project Execution Part (5)SAJJAD KHUDHUR ABBAS
 
Atf marketing segment sorc meeting 14.05.2020 atf rev01
Atf marketing segment sorc meeting  14.05.2020   atf rev01Atf marketing segment sorc meeting  14.05.2020   atf rev01
Atf marketing segment sorc meeting 14.05.2020 atf rev01Amardeep Jadeja
 
Who Else Owns This Loss Course
Who Else Owns This Loss CourseWho Else Owns This Loss Course
Who Else Owns This Loss CourseWarren Forensics
 
Texas oil refinary explosion
Texas oil refinary explosionTexas oil refinary explosion
Texas oil refinary explosionNeha Baheti
 
Texas oil refinary explosion
Texas oil refinary explosionTexas oil refinary explosion
Texas oil refinary explosionNeha Baheti
 
RV Thuwal - Refit project overview by Maritime Survey Australia
RV Thuwal - Refit project overview by Maritime Survey AustraliaRV Thuwal - Refit project overview by Maritime Survey Australia
RV Thuwal - Refit project overview by Maritime Survey AustraliaMichaelUberti
 
Alignment of-kiln
Alignment of-kilnAlignment of-kiln
Alignment of-kilnmkpq pasha
 
Hazard Assessment Methodology of Liquid Hydrocarbon Tank | Risk Assessment of...
Hazard Assessment Methodology of Liquid Hydrocarbon Tank | Risk Assessment of...Hazard Assessment Methodology of Liquid Hydrocarbon Tank | Risk Assessment of...
Hazard Assessment Methodology of Liquid Hydrocarbon Tank | Risk Assessment of...Gaurav Singh Rajput
 
BVAA presentation 2015: The Use of CFD to assess valve performance and operat...
BVAA presentation 2015: The Use of CFD to assess valve performance and operat...BVAA presentation 2015: The Use of CFD to assess valve performance and operat...
BVAA presentation 2015: The Use of CFD to assess valve performance and operat...Linsley Charlton
 
Sathiyaprabhu Piping Stress Engineer CV 2015
Sathiyaprabhu Piping Stress Engineer CV 2015Sathiyaprabhu Piping Stress Engineer CV 2015
Sathiyaprabhu Piping Stress Engineer CV 2015sathiya prabhu
 
EC6 design improvements and confirmatory testing
EC6 design improvements and confirmatory testingEC6 design improvements and confirmatory testing
EC6 design improvements and confirmatory testingSNC-Lavalin
 
IRJET- Preventive Maintenance and Root Cause Analysis of Sealed Quench Furnac...
IRJET- Preventive Maintenance and Root Cause Analysis of Sealed Quench Furnac...IRJET- Preventive Maintenance and Root Cause Analysis of Sealed Quench Furnac...
IRJET- Preventive Maintenance and Root Cause Analysis of Sealed Quench Furnac...IRJET Journal
 
Static load test method statement cm - ms- bw - 003
Static load test method statement  cm - ms- bw - 003Static load test method statement  cm - ms- bw - 003
Static load test method statement cm - ms- bw - 003Minh Bui Si
 
Root Cause Of Piping Failures | COMPRESSORtech2
Root Cause Of Piping Failures | COMPRESSORtech2 Root Cause Of Piping Failures | COMPRESSORtech2
Root Cause Of Piping Failures | COMPRESSORtech2 dieselpub
 
CD 2016 March - Advisian Showcase
CD 2016 March - Advisian ShowcaseCD 2016 March - Advisian Showcase
CD 2016 March - Advisian ShowcaseComit Projects Ltd
 

Similar to 24 years experience in Oil and Gas Industry (20)

Episode 34 : Project Execution Part (5)
Episode 34 :  Project Execution Part (5)Episode 34 :  Project Execution Part (5)
Episode 34 : Project Execution Part (5)
 
Episode 22 : PROJECT EXECUTION
Episode 22 : PROJECT EXECUTION Episode 22 : PROJECT EXECUTION
Episode 22 : PROJECT EXECUTION
 
Atf marketing segment sorc meeting 14.05.2020 atf rev01
Atf marketing segment sorc meeting  14.05.2020   atf rev01Atf marketing segment sorc meeting  14.05.2020   atf rev01
Atf marketing segment sorc meeting 14.05.2020 atf rev01
 
Imcasf12 14
Imcasf12 14Imcasf12 14
Imcasf12 14
 
Who Else Owns This Loss Course
Who Else Owns This Loss CourseWho Else Owns This Loss Course
Who Else Owns This Loss Course
 
Texas oil refinary explosion
Texas oil refinary explosionTexas oil refinary explosion
Texas oil refinary explosion
 
Texas oil refinary explosion
Texas oil refinary explosionTexas oil refinary explosion
Texas oil refinary explosion
 
RV Thuwal - Refit project overview by Maritime Survey Australia
RV Thuwal - Refit project overview by Maritime Survey AustraliaRV Thuwal - Refit project overview by Maritime Survey Australia
RV Thuwal - Refit project overview by Maritime Survey Australia
 
Compressors
CompressorsCompressors
Compressors
 
Used fuel andrew sowder - epri
Used fuel   andrew sowder - epriUsed fuel   andrew sowder - epri
Used fuel andrew sowder - epri
 
Alignment of-kiln
Alignment of-kilnAlignment of-kiln
Alignment of-kiln
 
Hazard Assessment Methodology of Liquid Hydrocarbon Tank | Risk Assessment of...
Hazard Assessment Methodology of Liquid Hydrocarbon Tank | Risk Assessment of...Hazard Assessment Methodology of Liquid Hydrocarbon Tank | Risk Assessment of...
Hazard Assessment Methodology of Liquid Hydrocarbon Tank | Risk Assessment of...
 
BVAA presentation 2015: The Use of CFD to assess valve performance and operat...
BVAA presentation 2015: The Use of CFD to assess valve performance and operat...BVAA presentation 2015: The Use of CFD to assess valve performance and operat...
BVAA presentation 2015: The Use of CFD to assess valve performance and operat...
 
Sathiyaprabhu Piping Stress Engineer CV 2015
Sathiyaprabhu Piping Stress Engineer CV 2015Sathiyaprabhu Piping Stress Engineer CV 2015
Sathiyaprabhu Piping Stress Engineer CV 2015
 
EC6 design improvements and confirmatory testing
EC6 design improvements and confirmatory testingEC6 design improvements and confirmatory testing
EC6 design improvements and confirmatory testing
 
IRJET- Preventive Maintenance and Root Cause Analysis of Sealed Quench Furnac...
IRJET- Preventive Maintenance and Root Cause Analysis of Sealed Quench Furnac...IRJET- Preventive Maintenance and Root Cause Analysis of Sealed Quench Furnac...
IRJET- Preventive Maintenance and Root Cause Analysis of Sealed Quench Furnac...
 
Static load test method statement cm - ms- bw - 003
Static load test method statement  cm - ms- bw - 003Static load test method statement  cm - ms- bw - 003
Static load test method statement cm - ms- bw - 003
 
Root Cause Of Piping Failures | COMPRESSORtech2
Root Cause Of Piping Failures | COMPRESSORtech2 Root Cause Of Piping Failures | COMPRESSORtech2
Root Cause Of Piping Failures | COMPRESSORtech2
 
CD 2016 March - Advisian Showcase
CD 2016 March - Advisian ShowcaseCD 2016 March - Advisian Showcase
CD 2016 March - Advisian Showcase
 
mcd_SOAR A
mcd_SOAR Amcd_SOAR A
mcd_SOAR A
 

24 years experience in Oil and Gas Industry

  • 1. About Me 1 Bachelors Degree in Mechanical Engineering -Graduated in 1992. 24 years experience in Oil and Gas Industry. Presently working as Head of Mechanical Static in PETRONAS Carigali in the Production International Division. Technical Authority of International Operations in various part of the world. Worked in Various Capacities - Mechanical Design Engineer, Project Execution & Commissioning Experienced in Piping, pipeline, pressure vessel, tanks and mechanical static equipment Won various innovation Awards & HSE Award. Following are some of the works done over the years
  • 2.  Prior to commencing operation activities, an operation meeting was held at 0630 to discuss JHA & Permit to Work (PTW). As per operation log there were 10 PTW opened for activities on that day. One of the activities were Startup Gas Compressor Train(GTC).  Control room operator started up GTC and continued to increase speed and put on load. At full load status , the field operator heard the sound of gas leak above the after- cooler train and confirmed the gas leak from the incoming flange of the after-cooler train.  Control room operator activated Plant Shutdown manually and the GTC was immediately stopped – the pressure immediately was reduced to 0 psi.  As a result of this incident, 3 flange gaskets of inlet cooler GTC were damage in normal operating condition. 3/23/2016 2 Carried out Axisymmetric contact flange leak analysis- Finite Element Analysis and Caesar II analysis to identify deficiencies in design - FEED phase to implementation of the project
  • 3. 3/23/2016 3 Underlying Causes Design Engineering (DE): • Failed to conduct a proper review of the stress analysis report and failed to recognize the importance of the differential thermal load on dissimilar nozzle material. • Failed to review standards during detail engineering. Data sheet of the insulating gasket is incomplete and does not have the process design data. • In the detailed engineering material selection did not follow manufacture standard for the insulating gasket as Neophenolic can only installed in piping flanges of 300# or below and temperature less than 107deg Incompatible Goals (IG): • Failed to communicate important issues on design (stress analysis & process parameter) from detailed engineering to PCIC contractor. • Failed on the part of management to bridge between detailed engineering phase and PCIC phase Error Enforcing Conditions (EC): • Management Failed to review Special Item. The Insulation Gasket are special items, however, these were treated as bulk material by the PCIC contractor. • Verify Bolt tensioning calculation by the contractor. Bolting by the specialist flange management contractor on critical test limit tie-in flanged joints were carried out without proper calculations and review. • Insufficient resources to conduct proper Line Design Review(LDR)
  • 4. Hydrostatic load on vertical vessel Skid 3/23/2016 4 Usually the hydrotest of vessels during the fabrication is not carried out on the skid. Temporary arrangements are made in the workshop and the vessel is hydrotested before painting. Due to this, the vessel’s skids and the supporting arrangements are not particularly designed for hydrostatic test loads. Careful calculations should be done to check the components and their suitability to handle these occasional loads. Below is a check done on a vertical pressure vessel which was going to be subjected to hydrotest load at field and a potential incident was avoided. Location of High stress and local failure expected 2015
  • 5. 3/23/2016 5 • This is a loss of containment incident due to a ruptured Utility Gas Heater -an Electrical heat exchanger. • The incident occurred during the process of starting-up of the Vapor Recovery Compressor (VRC) • The incident resulted in total damage of the shell and local damage to nearby lighting, fitting, insulation and cladding. • The exchanger was replaced with a newly designed one. LOSS OF PRIMARY CONTAINMENT (LOPC) INCIDENT AT UTILITY GAS HEATER
  • 6. 3/23/2016 6 • Fortunately, there was no one near the equipment during the incident or it could have resulted in a more severe impact as the incident involved a high-pressure release of natural gas at 90 BarG. • It was also fortunate that the release was stopped through manual activation of Emergency Shut Down (ESD) before it could get in contact with any source of ignition. • This study was trigger by photographical evidences of the site which had a heat exchanger with missing bolts on the support. LOSS OF PRIMARY CONTAINMENT (LOPC) INCIDENT AT UTILITY GAS HEATER
  • 7. Offshore Crash/Rescue Fire Trainer – Helicopter Simulator 7  UAE’s First Offshore Crash/ Rescue Helicopter Simulator Complete with Helideck Features of the Simulator:  The helicopter simulator will be placed on the steel Helideck structure as this will give the offshore fire fighting team a realistic simulation  The simulator will be gas fired as it will have HSE advantage over the oil fired simulator. Future:  It can be used to Train Other companies offshore Fire fighting Teams, and this concept can also be used by other companies to train their personnel.  The Simulator will be used to simulate engine fire, cockpit fire, baggage/ compartment fire and pool fire  Used to Train Offshore Fire Fighting Teams and external fire fighting teams.  In-house design - Built to international Standards Introduction Innovations of 2013
  • 8. Buckling Analysis on Tank with Distortion-2011 8 Background Tank was built in 1980 and has been in operation for 31years Service was sour oily water Tank was used as Surge tank in the sour water treatment plant The tank was built to BSI – 2654 version 1973 & NACE     Introduction Tank was under major overhaul in Jan 2011 Cause of this distortion was not known Inspection revealed distortions on both the Shell and Dome A fitness for service evaluation of the flaw was required to be carried out to put back the tank into operation    
  • 9. Buckling Analysis on Tank with Distortion -2011 9 Assumptions made There was no thickness loss/variation - as inspection reports did not reveal any such defect The tank has a suitable monitoring / inspection program   Concerns Raised Resolution The original design data and calculation were not available A finite element model of the design case (without any flaw/base case) was generated to look at the maximum stress at the relevant part and compare with the flaw assessment No established standard to carry out buckling analysis for tanks built to BSI standards. Above Base Case Model help in looking at the compatibility with API620 & API 579 was used for Fitness for Service assessment. Effect of nozzle load on the shell was not considered as no data is available. (Note : There are no piping attachments on the dome.) It was not the basis of this study to identify the root cause of the buckling - as no information was provided to carry out such a study  
  • 10. Buckling Analysis on Tank with Distortions 10 Analysis Procedure STEP 1 – Flaw and Damage Mechanism Identification STEP 3 – Data Requirements STEP 2 – Applicability and Limitations of the FFS Assessment Procedures STEP 4 – Assessment Techniques and Acceptance Criteria     STEP 5 – Remaining Life Evaluation STEP 6 – Remediation STEP 7 – In-Service Monitoring of the Flaw STEP 8 – Documentation Methodology as per API579  Applicability and Limitations of the FFS Assessment Procedures was to be established Data Requirements for the FFS was to be established Available Original Equipment Design Data required Required Data/Measurements for a FFS Assessment. Assessment Techniques and Acceptance Criteria’s were to be established Based on the above, carry out buckling analysis of the distortions. Provide Recommendations.
  • 11. Buckling Analysis in Tank with Distortion 11 Assessment to API579 – Level 3 Base Case Model (model without any distortion)
  • 12. Buckling Analysis on Tank 12 Assessment to API579 – Level 3 Limit-Load Analysis Method (refer B1.2.3 of API579)  This technique used in determining the maximum vacuum/external pressure required to reach the minimum yield stress i.e. to determine the load required to reach the plastic deformation. The base case established that a vacuum/external pressure of 0.04N/mm2 was required to be applied uniformly on the tank at 37degC to cause the yield point to be reached
  • 13. Buckling Analysis in Tank 13  All the four flaw locations were mapped with a grid of 100 x 100mm  The grid were plotted with the use of Autocad and transferred to Algor.  Algor software was used for the refined mesh generations and final assessment of the flaws  Elastic Stress Analysis Method was used in the buckling analysis.  The equivalent stress equal to the von Mises equivalent stress was used. Assessment to API579 – Level 3  Carry out repair on location-3 and location-4 on the Dome  Recommendation were issued on how to avoid vacuum load. RECOMMENDATIONS
  • 14. Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis -2011 14 The Failure of Mooring Hawser at SPM-February 2011 No personal injuries and no oil spill / pollution Property Damage resulted: Parting of the mooring hawser and damage to the thimble eye on the SPM side    A multidiscipline team was formed to investigate the incident.  Introduction
  • 15. Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis 15 Dynamic Analysis The load on the hawser was plotted against the actual load on the hawser at the time of the incident to simulate the actual scenario. A realistic model was created to look at the snatch effect on the hawser.  Load Cell Reading at the berth at the time of the incident Dynamic Simulation Load Input 84 sec – 130.8ton & 90 sec – 400ton Inspection revealed no anomalies for this particular hawser. The hawser was loaded 53 (75% of normal uses) out 70 times with 1117hrs working (93% of operational life span of 1200 hrs) & 4month 19days since installation   Static Analysis A static analysis was also carried out on the hawser with two case  Case with a load of 130t  Case with a load of 250t  Discussion
  • 16. Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis 16
  • 17. Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis 17
  • 18. In Conclusion the Immediate cause: Ship Approach during the Berthing Operation: The final approach was not conducted as per standard approach which created transverse motion and high rate of turn that consequently resulted in heavy snatch load effect on the hawser. Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis 18
  • 19. Hawser Incident Investigation– Dynamic Analysis 19 Load=130ton
  • 20. Innovation -2009 GRE Piggable Pipeline – ASME B31.4 20 Barred TeeBarred Tee Introduction:  First GRE piggable pipeline to ASME B31.4 Features of the Line:  The 20” pipeline will consist of GRE Barred tee for branch Connection upto 8”.  The bends used will be piggable.  Line will be buried except at tie-in locations.  Criss-cross poly foam will be used for pigging the line.  Resistance to Corrosion thereby extending the life of the pipeline.
  • 21.  Lead the Stress Analysis to find a suitable solution to avoid shutdown of the platform.  Gas Leaks on bellow convolutions were identified - with one out of three trains forced to shutdown and another train was running under continuous monitoring with leak from cracked convolutions.  No spare available of the bellows in stores.  Provide engineered solution to run both trains till replacement bellows arrives from abroad.  Performed static analysis of the 16” x 10” discharge piping Gas compressor & Dehydration Trains of Gas Compressor to find a suitable alternative temporary solution Gas Compressor bellow Leak (year 2007) Introduction
  • 22.  The condition of the train at the start of the analysis was  Train A was shutdown with one upper vertical Gimbal bellow and the horizontal Hinged bellow found leaking.  Train B was running with a leaking bellow (crack on Horizontal Bellow).  The life cycle(7000cycles) of the bellows have exceeded and no spare bellows available.  Avoid shutdown  Purpose of Analysis  to check the feasibility of replacing the leaking vertical Gimbal & hinged bellows with a rigid pipe spool piece.  Carry out static stress analysis to ASME B31.8 & check reaction at the compressor nozzle (discharge side - are within the allowable of API617) with the existing piping configurations  Conclusion and Recommendation:  The stress analysis is valid for the proposed modification of utilizing Cold Spring to enable the operation of Train A and B on a temporary basis till the replacement bellow are available in 3 week time. 22 Gas Compressor bellow Leak (year 2007) Discussion
  • 23. FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS -2002 FITNESS FOR SERVICE 23 Scaled Acad Model of Spheroid Drawn by Bijoy Featured article & Picture from Company Magazine Thank You