SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
RAINWATER CATCHMENT 
SYSTEM 
PROJECT FINAL WRITTEN REPORT 
TEAM 
JARED CORDES 
PAIGE MOLZAHN 
KIET PHUNG 
JUNE 11, 2014 
OREGON STATE UNIVERSITY 
CBEE 416
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
Figure 1: This is a diagram of the catchment area inverted roof 
design. The rainfall will be caught and roll down the slope of the 
system and flow to the flow diverter. 
1 
ABSTRACT 
The project objective is to design a low cost and low maintenance system that can catch and clean water to 
be used for 50 in Haiti for hygienic purposes. The water must be caught, diverted, filtered and stored before 
used by the population. These steps required literature comparisons as well as experimental testing. The 
catchment surface area was determined to be 185 m2 and will be made of aluminum. The flow diverter 
consists of an initial diverter, a clarifier and a bleeder valve. This system will be constructed of 1” PVC 
pipes to handle the maximum amount of flow. There will be two operational sand filters to remove 
particulates and pathogens with diameters of 30 cm and heights of 1.1 m. These filters will have layers of 
fine sand, course sand, gravel, and small rocks. A bio layer will accumulate over time which will assist in 
the pathogen removal. This layer needs to be checked monthly to avoid overgrowth of biota. Finally, there 
will be two 5,000 gallon reservoirs made of polyethylene. They will be UV resistant and opaque to prevent 
bacteria growth within the tank. A bill of materials was created for the overall system design determining 
an expected cost range of $6,700 - $8,200. 
DESIGN BACKGROUND 
Obtaining clean water is a current struggle in undeveloped countries such as Haiti. The World Health 
Organization (WHO) requires 12.5 L/c/d to meet the basic hygiene needs for rural populations. An 
additional 7.5 L/c/d are required to meet water consumption needs. Many water sources used in developing 
countries come from streams containing pathogens. Rainwater harvesting has been one alternative water 
source that provides clean water for hygiene and consumption. Rainwater contains no pathogens or heavy 
metals, but it can be low in pH in deforested regions. Harvesting can only remain viable in areas of heavy 
rainfall with few drought seasons. Heavy droughts lead to an increase in required water holding time which 
increases the chance for contamination. Haiti received an average annual rainfall of 1600 mm between 1999 
and 2009. May, September, and August had the most rainfall while December through March obtained less 
than 100 mm.1 
A rainwater catchment system requires four main 
parts: a catchment area, a piping system, a 
purification filter and a storage reservoir. The 
inverted roof catchment area is a commonly used 
design for rainwater catchment systems. This 
design requires minimal maintenance and has the 
ability to easily divert flow. This system, shown 
in Figure 1,2 is the optimal catchment area 
design. The rainfall will be caught and then flow 
to a diverter system to remove the debris from 
the initial rainfall. Dust will accumulate on the 
catchment area during droughts. These 
particulates must be removed before entering the filter when it finally rains. The cleaner water will then 
move on to a sand filter to be purified. 
The water enters the slow sand filter after the initial flow diverter to catch small debris that passed the initial 
flow diverter and to treat pathogens from the catchment surface. A sand filter is made up of three layers: 
fine sand to trap particles, coarse sand to keep the fine sand from leaving the filter, and gravel to keep the 
1 "Climate Change Knowledge Portal 2.0." Climate Change Knowledge Portal 2.0. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2014. 
2 "1.1 Rainwater Harvesting from Rooftop Catchments." Rainwater Harvesting from Rooftop Catchments.Web. 08 June 2014.
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
coarse sand from leaving the filter. Fine sand is made of particles that have around 100 μm of equivalent 
diameter and the coarse sand has an equivalent length of 200 μm. Pathogen removal is carried out in three 
ways; they will get trapped in between sand particles and die from nutrient loss, they will be too large to go 
through the sand, or be removed through use of a bio layer that will destroy pathogens. Bacteria in this bio 
layer attack incoming contaminants in a process called predation. The bio layer, which grows on the top 
layer of fine sand, takes around one month to develop according to the EPA. This bio layer can be destroyed 
by agitation or removal of the top layer of sand, so it is important that the filter is not mishandled. The bio 
layer requires still water to be present or the bacteria will die. The bio layer will continually grow which 
can cause high pressure loss through the sand filter due to the extra layer. This growth is coined 
schmutzdecke, or dirty layer. 
Finally, the water will be stored in a reservoir. The rainwater reservoir is the most expensive component of 
a rainwater harvesting system. The cost depends on the type of construction materials used, water demand 
for daily consumption, and whether the tank is built above ground or underground. An above ground tank 
is preferred over an underground tank for water storage considering price, maintenance, and convenience. 
The above ground tank can be constructed easily from a wide variety of materials. Pump installation is not 
necessary because water extraction can be done by gravity in many cases. An above ground tank also allows 
easy inspection and maintenance for water leaks. The tank storage, however, must have opaque or dark 
color to block sunlight to stop the growth of algae. The underground cistern requires excavation, a pump 
system to extract water, and a higher cost of construction and maintenance; therefore, an above ground tank 
proves to be a better solution in Haiti. 
2 
METHODS AND MATERIALS 
SYSTEM SCALING 
With the 50 person scope of this project, a total 
of 625 L would be the daily minimum required 
clean water production. This water must be 
caught, diverted, filtered, and stored before 
accessed by the population. The average rainfall 
data3 shown in Figure 2 was used for 
determination of catchment and reservoir 
scaling. Adequate amounts of water must be 
caught and stored through the rainy seasons to 
continuously provide through the drier seasons. 
300 
250 
200 
150 
100 
50 
0 
Rainfall Intemsity (mm) 
The reservoir must fill to a maximum and then 
deplete in the course of one year to prevent the 
Month 
system from overfilling and to maintain the 
Figure 2: The average rainfall data for Haiti, showing both the 
lowest cost possible. The average monthly 
rainy and dry seasons 
rainfall data was divided among 50% of the days 
in the month, assuming that the rain does not fall in even amounts every day and some days have no rainfall. 
This strategy was applied to size both the catchment surface area and the reservoir giving a catchment area 
of 185 m2 and a reservoir size of 10,000 gallons. 
The scaling of the sand filter requires the calculation of the pressure loss through the system. Pressure loss 
was calculated using the Ergun equation shown be Equations 1 and 2. ΔP represents the pressure loss, ε is 
3 Climate Change Knowledge Portal. The World Bank Group, n.d. Web. 5 Apr. 2014.
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
the void space in the bed, ff is the friction factor, L is the length of the sand, ρ is the water density, u is the 
superficial velocity, dpart is the equivalent diameter of sand, and v is the kinematic viscosity of water. These 
calculations were used with experimental data to optimize the diameter of the filter, the required height of 
sand and the number of filters to be in operation. 
3 
Δ푃 = 
1 − 휀 
휀3 푓푓 퐿휌 
푢0 2 
푑푝푎푟푡 
(1) 푓푓 = 
150(1 − 휀) 
푢0 ∗ 푑푝푎푟푡 
( 
푣 
) + 1.75 
(2) 
MATERIALS AND COST 
A bill of materials is attached in the Appendix that details all goods that would need to be purchased to 
complete the catchment system. Services such as construction and maintenance are variable in cost and are 
left out. A 10% decrease and increase was added to the price in the US for an estimate range of the cost for 
Haiti. The catchment is required to be a raised system due to the lack of available house roofs that could 
meet the area required. This drove the cost up to $1,289 for the US. Five beams would have to be anchored 
into concrete on the back of both aluminum sheets. Another five beams would anchor the middle of the 
aluminum sheets. The initial flow diverter was the cheapest at $78 US. The PVC should be shaded and 
wrapped with the drain pipe. This should decrease sun and heat exposure to the system. The filters cost 
$896 US. Obtaining and fabricating the plastic for the filter was costly. The material is reliable and should 
last up to 10 years though. The filters are clear so a basic tub should be put over them to avoid growth of 
photosynthetic bacteria and to reduce the heat on the filter. The reservoirs cost the most at $5,165 US. The 
tank sizes are massive so this cost was unavoidable. Haiti should expect an initial cost, for just the materials, 
of $6,685.95 up to $8,171.71. 
EXPERIMENTAL TESTING 
The catchment area and the reservoir system were not tested due to cost and time restrictions. These aspects 
would be constructed following designs obtained from the literature. 
Experimental testing was completed on the flow 
diverter. This testing required the construction 
of a flow diverter system made out of PVC that 
consists of two parallel horizontal pipes with the 
top one linked to a biosand filter and two 
vertical pipes connecting to a clarifier and the 
other to a bleeder valve. The bleeder valve will 
be slightly open during the operation. A first 
flush of contaminated rainwater enters the flow 
diverter system where the debris from collected 
rainwater will travel through the pipes down 
into the clarifier and also deposit above the 
valve. The water level in the flow diverter system rises and the subsequent flow of cleaner rainwater is then 
automatically directed along the pipes to the biosand filters system. The bleeder valve is eventually opened 
after the catchment period to drain contaminated water at the bottom and allow for maintenance and 
cleaning purposes. These visible pollutants can be diverted and removed by initial flow of water into a flow 
diverter system as depicted in Figure 3. A lab-scale flow diverter system was constructed using ½‘’ PVC 
pipes, ½’’ T’s, ½’’ 90o elbow, and small plastic container acting as a clarifier in order to determine the 
feasibility of the system. A sample of 200 mL of imitation rainwater containing debris was introduced to 
Figure 3: : A process flow diagram of a flow diverter composed of 
PVC pipes, a clarifier, and a bleeder valve to remove larger 
contaminants from collected rainwater prior to further treatment from 
biosand filters
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
the flow diverter, subsequently followed by adding 400 mL of DI water. The first experimental trial went 
until no water flowed through the bleeder valve. The second through fourth trial repeated adding imitation 
rainwater and then DI. 
The experiment testing for the sand filter 
dimensions was conducted to determine the 
equivalent diameter of the particles within 
the filter, the flow of water, and the height of 
required sand. The equivalent diameter of 
the sand was the first parameter to be found 
by flowing water through the filter at 100 
mL/min. The height of water remained 
constant at 15 cm above the top of the sand 
which fixed ΔP using Equation 1. The bed 
void space was estimated to be 0.45. The 
sand length was 15 cm. This gave an 
Figure 4: A graph of the pressure loss as head of water through the sand 
equivalent diameter of 115 μm for the fine 
filter. The increase is linear with length, but varies based on diameter. 
The design should be carried out at 30 cm ID. The pressure loss more 
sand. The pressure drop through the system 
than doubles from 30 to 20 cm. 
is taken using this diameter for both sand 
layers which will slightly overestimate the actual pressure drop. This is a small safety factor to account for 
channeling, wall effects, and the effects of the schmutzdecke. The pressure drop through the gravel area is 
much smaller than that of the sand beds. Figure 4 shows the pressure drop through the filter as a function 
of diameter and length. The filter will be operating at a length of 60 cm of total sand with gravel. An ID of 
30 cm is suggested for each filter. At these filter conditions, we expect a required pressure head of 1 m. The 
filter length is 70 cm, so a head of 30 cm is needed to overcome the pressure difference. 
4 
RESULTS 
INITIAL FLOW DIVERTER 
4.5 
4.0 
3.5 
3.0 
2.5 
2.0 
1.5 
1.0 
0.5 
0.0 
Diamater = 50cm 
Diameter = 40cm 
Diameter = 30cm 
Diameter = 20cm 
0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 
Pressure Head (m) 
Filter Length (m) 
The experimental testing on the flow diverter system proved to be feasible as the rainwater condition 
improved significantly at the outlet connecting to biosand filter compared to the original rainwater entering 
the system. The cost of material and installation for constructing a flow diverter system is relatively 
inexpensive as PVC pipes are the primary material and easy to work with. The flow diverter must have 
covered PVC pipes or be made from UV resistant material to avoid PVC degradation from sunlight. The 
potential stress cracking of PVC due to constant thermal exposure is another major problem when using 
PVC. The flow diverter system should be built below the inverted roof system or in the shade to extend the 
in-service life of PVC pipes. Regular maintenance is recommended, for i.e. opening the bleeder valve to 
remove debris settled at the bottom to prevent clogging. Figure 5 below shows the cleanliness of each water 
sample after the experiment.
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
Figure 5: The cleanliness of each water sample during the experimentation to determine the feasibility of the flow diverter system. 
(a): water that was initially introduced to the flow diverter (~200 mL per trial, then ~400 mL of DI), (b): water collected after fully 
opening the bleeder valve on the 4th trial, (c): water collected from the clarifier section, (d): water that left the flow diverter, to head 
to the filter, for the 4th trial 
Figure 6: A picture of two water samples. The sample on 
the right that flowed through the filter had a turbidity of 34 
NTU, and the treated water on the left had a turbidity of 1.3 
NTU. 
5 
(a) (b) (c) (d) 
BIOSAND FILTERS 
Three filters were suggested for the design. This would 
allow two filters to be used at once while the other goes 
through maintenance or repairs. The filters will all be the 
same size for simplicity. The design of the filters are 
based on acceptable pressure loss through the system 
and adequate treatment of turbid water. The first design 
is to find the length of fine sand needed to treat turbid 
water. Turbidity represents the “cloudiness” of a water 
and is directly related to the amount of pathogens that 
could be present. Higher turbidity has an increased 
chance of carrying pathogenic species. The EPA 
suggests that an effective filter for removing pathogens 
can treat turbidity to under 5 Nephelometric Turbid Units 
(NTU). Rainwater was collected from Corvallis using a 
bucket in order to find the approximate turbidity of rain water. The rainwater sample had a turbidity of 22 
NTU. Experiments were run using a solution of water and corn starch in order to create turbid solutions 
that ranged from 10 – 34 NTU, the expected turbidity of rainwater into the filters. Figure 6 shows an 
example of the difference in turbidity. 
Two filters should remain operational at all times. This allows for one filter to work while the other has an 
overflow at the top section in case of heavy rainfall. The highest designed rainfall was for 0.83 mm/hr. An 
outlet at the top of one of the filters will flow straight into a reservoir instead of being filtered. This overflow 
water will accumulate in another reservoir that will need to be treated, ran through a filter, before it should 
be used. The filters will need to 1.1 meters tall to allow space for the water to accumulate. The accumulation 
of water can build up to 20 cm above the top layer of sand before the rain water flows into the overflow. 
The design of the filter is shown by Figure 7.
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
Figure 7: The overall design of the three filters. Each level is 
detailed out with dimensions. The gravel layer can be split into 
5 cm of gravel and 5 cm of larger rocks if needed. The outlet to 
overflow will wither connect two filters together lead to a 
reservoir. That will depend on which filter is hooked to the 
overflow reservoir. A union is suggested to be built on the swan 
neck, which will allow the PVC to easily be removed from the 
filter. The swan neck should use the same materials as the PVC 
flow diverter 
The last part of the filter is the flow diverter that sits inside of the filter. Its purpose is to slightly divert the 
incoming water so that it does not damage the top layer of sand. The plate can also be used to remove the 
top layer of schmutzdecke if it accumulates more than 5 cm on top of the fine sand. The design is shown in 
Figure 8. The filter will be built from polyethylene or any other plastic material. Another cylindrical plastic 
cylinder, with dimensions around 35 cm ID with 1.12 m tall, should be put over the filter to reduce UV 
light damaging the filter. The sides of this cylinder need to have holes in them in order to allow air to enter 
the filters. The bio layer should be run under aerobic conditions where oxygen is present. The filter could 
also be put under constant shade. This doesn’t decrease the heat significantly so the filters would need more 
maintenance. 
Figure 8: The design for the filters flow diverter. This plate, which can be made of an 
aluminum sheet, diverts the initial flow into the filter to minimize damage to the sand layers. 
The teardrop shapes allow the diverter to pick up the top layer of schmutzdecke by simply 
rotating the plate. Water entering the filter should be directed toward the center of the diverter. 
Two filters were used for this experiment. One 
filter had an internal diameter (ID) of 13 cm and 
the other 18 cm. Both filters contained the same 
length of sand. Flow rates were set at 1 m3/hr 
making a superficial velocity of 2.1 cm/s for the 
13 cm ID filter and 1.1 cm/s for the 18 cm ID 
filter. A Vernier turbid meter was used to find the 
turbidity of the water samples. The outflow 
turbidity of water from the filters ranged from 10 
to 30 NTU with only the coarse sand. The length 
of the coarse sand was reduced, and 15 cm of fine 
sand was added to the system. The new filters 
treated the 10 – 34 NTU solutions to less than 5 
NTU for all runs that were conducted. This was 
based on 3 trial runs for 3 different turbidities. Figure 9 shows the data with a 90% confidence interval. 
6 
4.0 
3.0 
2.0 
1.0 
0.0 
18 cm ID Filter 
13 cm ID Filter 
0 10 20 30 40 
Outlet Turbidity (NTU) 
Inlet Turbidity (NTU) 
Figure 9: A graph of the turbidity of the water that went into the 
filter on the x axis, and the turbidity of the treated water out of the 
filter on the y axis. All runs contained treated water under the EPA 
standards of 5 NTU.
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
The suggested design is to use 50 cm of fine sand for the scaled up version. This would allow the 
schmutzdecke to form on the top layer of sand, which was not accounted for in the turbidity tests. The extra 
amount will also account for increased flows which can occur during large rain events. 
7 
MAINTENANCE 
The required maintenance on the filters is minimal under ideal conditions. The initial sand used for the filter 
can be bought from a local store for simplicity. Sand from beaches and other areas can be used, but they 
would require cleaning with safe water before they can be used. The top layer of the bio layer will have to 
be looked at monthly. This is to avoid overgrowth of the bio layer. The filters flow diverter can be used to 
take out some of the top layer of schmutzdecke without disturbing the top layer of sand. Every four months 
the schmutzdecke should be scraped to a low level if the flow diverter can’t remove it. The layer needs to 
be minimally disturbed in order to have the best treatment. The bio layer will take about 1 month to 
accumulate, so the filters should collect rainwater for one month before the water can be used for hygiene. 
This procedure applies to any filter that hasn’t been used in over a month. The sand is suggested to be 
replaced yearly. This should be done at different times of the year for each filter. The sand can be replaced 
by simply removing the contents of the filter, cleaning the sand off, and replacing it back in the filter. The 
layer of fine sand may fall into the coarse sand, so it is important to check the filters every year. The plastic 
closed cylinder around the filter should be repaired, or replaced, yearly. The sun quickly damages the 
material so it is best used in a shaded area. The filters should be inspected every month, by eye, to make 
sure that there are no cracks or leaks. 
OVERALL SYSTEM DESIGN 
The overall design of the system is shown in Figure 10 (Page 8). This design includes the overall surface 
area of the catchment system, the initial flow diverter design, the sand filter dimensions and the sizing of 
the reservoirs. The specifics of the design are provided in previous sections of the report. 
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 
The rainwater catchment team would like to thank the project sponsor, Dr. Yokochi, for providing this 
opportunity, Dr. Harding for weekly advising to ensure our work stays on task, Andy Brickman for 
assistance in obtaining materials, Manfred Dittrich for assistance with construction tools, OSU Engineers 
Without Borders for cost analysis insight and Lauren Kelly for providing access to the turbid meter.
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
8 
Figure 10: Overall design of a rainwater catchment system to be 
used in Haiti, which consists of a catchment area, an initial flow 
diverter, two biosand filters, and two main reservoirs.
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
9 
APPENDIX 
Bill Of Materials 
BOM Item Number Item Name Quantity Size US price Procurment Haiti Low Haiti High Notes 
1 10-001 Aluminum Sheet 2 92 m2 
$644.00 Metals Depot $579.60 $708.40 
2 10-002 High Wood Posts 10 1.7 m $89.70 Home Depot $80.73 $98.67 4 in by 4 in beams 
3 10-003 Low Wood Posts 10 1.3 m $89.70 Home Depot $80.73 $98.67 Same beams that will need to be cut 
4 10-004 Concrete 20 60 lbs $247.00 Home Depot $222.30 $271.70 Rapid set concrete to hold posts 
5 10-005 Post Anchors 20 4 by 4" $159.40 Home Depot $143.46 $175.34 
6 10-006 Joist Hanger 20 18 gauge $7.00 Home Depot $6.30 $7.70 Simpson Strong Tie A21Z Z-MAX 
7 10-007 Deck Screws 3 inch $30.00 Home Depot $27.00 $33.00 
8 10-008 Hinged Gutter Screen 10 6 by 36" $22.30 Home Depot $20.07 $24.53 
9 10 Catchment Total $1,289.10 $1,160.19 $1,418.01 
10 20-001 PVC Pipe 3 1" ID, 10' $10.92 Home Depot $9.83 $12.01 
11 20-002 Drain Pipe 3 4" ID, 10' $19.65 Home Depot $17.69 $21.62 
12 20-003 90o PVC Elbow 3 1" $5.91 Home Depot $5.32 $6.50 
13 20-004 PVC Tee 6 1" $4.44 Home Depot $4.00 $4.88 
14 20-005 Ball Valve 1 1" $5.15 Home Depot $4.64 $5.67 
15 20-006 PVC Glue 3 8 oz. $9.74 Home Depot $8.77 $10.71 
16 20-007 Container 1 1 L $0.00 $0.00 
17 20-008 Bulkhead Fitting 1 1" $16.24 Home Depot $14.62 $17.86 
18 20-009 Gutter 1 10' $5.23 Home Depot $4.71 $5.75 
19 20 Flow Diverter Total $77.28 $69.55 $85.01 
20 30-001 Acrylic Clear Sheet 3 1.1 by 0.94 m $531.36 Plas-Tech $478.22 $584.50 Rough estimate based on professional plastic 
21 30-002 Acrylic base 3 0.6 by 0.6 m $90.00 Plas-Tech $81.00 $99.00 
22 30-003 Plastic Circle 3 30 cm D $60.00 Plas-Tech $54.00 $66.00 Used for filter flow diverter 
23 30-004 Silicone Sealant 2 300 mL $25.98 Ace Hardware $23.38 $28.58 Red Devil heat resistant industrial grade 
24 30-005 Fine Sand 10 50 lbs $32.50 Home Depot $29.25 $35.75 Can also use local sand that is treated 
25 30-006 Coarse Sand 8 1 ft3 
$59.92 Agri Supply $53.93 $65.91 " " 
26 30-007 Gravel 15 0.5 ft3 
$45.00 Home Depot $40.50 $49.50 
27 30-008 Union 3 1" $14.58 Home Depot $13.12 $16.04 
28 30-009 90o PVC Elbow 6 1" $11.82 Home Depot $10.64 $13.00 
29 30-010 PVC Male Adapter 6 1" $3.54 Home Depot $3.19 $3.89 Connect slip PVC with threaded hole on filter 
30 30-011 PVC Cutter 1 $6.48 Home Depot $5.83 $7.13 
31 30-012 Cylindrical Tub 3 $0.00 $0.00 Put over filters to reduce sun exposure 
32 30 Filter Total $881.18 $793.06 $969.30 
33 40-001 Storage Tank 2 5000 L $4,711.26 Tanksforless.com $4,240.13 $5,182.39 
34 40-002 Overflow Tank 1 500 L $418.52 Tanksforless.com $376.67 $460.37 
35 40-003 Brass Gate Valve 3 1" $33.72 Home Depot $30.35 $37.09 
36 40-004 PVC Male Adapter 3 1" $1.77 Home Depot $1.59 $1.95 Connects PVC 
37 40 Reservoir Total $5,165.27 $4,648.74 $5,681.80 
38 50 Total Cost $7,412.83 $6,671.55 $8,154.11
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
10 
Required Volume of Reservoir: 
*The value calculated will be based on the rainfal intensity per month. 
Future calculations may be done to find daily rainfal intensitys. 
**Assume that the catchment system will be built in April 
Month Total Days Rainfall 
Rain 
captured 
Rain 
Consumed 
Reservoir 
Volume 
[mm] [m3] [m3] [m3] 
April 30 136 19.26 18.8 0.51 
May 31 243 34.43 19.4 15.57 
June 30 123 17.46 18.8 14.28 
July 31 114 16.17 19.4 11.08 
August 31 124 17.60 19.4 9.31 
September 30 184 26.13 18.8 16.69 
October 31 280 39.68 19.4 36.99 
November 30 149 21.12 18.8 39.37 
December 31 68 9.67 19.4 29.67 
January 31 60 8.55 19.4 18.84 
February 28 54 7.70 17.5 9.05 
March 31 73 10.33 19.4 0.00 
*Excess was calculated by: rain captured - rain used + previous month excess 
The largest excess was at 39.37 m3. This value can be used for a one year cycle 
Suggested volume of reservoir for a one year cycle [m3]: 43 
% filterdesign.m 
% a file in order to find a suitable filter design to minimize 
%pressure loss and calculate the required head 
%to offset the pressure loss 
% Team Rainwater Catchment, CBEE 416, 6/11/14 
clear all, format compact 
A = 141.9; % minimum required catchment area (m^2) 
dpart = 0.0001148; % equivalent diameter (m) 
eps = 0.45; % void space of bed 
ro = 1000; %density of water (kg/m^3) 
kvisc = 0.995*10^(-6); % kinematic viscosity of water 20 C (m^2/s) 
r = input('Estimation of daily rain intensity (18.65) : '); % (mm/d) 
d = input('Diameter of filter estimate (0.4-0.7) : '); % (m) 
L = input('Desired length of filter (0.3-0.6) : '); % (m) 
V = r/1000/86400 * A % volumetric flow of rain (m^3/s) 
u = V /((d/2)^2*pi) % velocity of water throught the filter (m/s) 
Re = u * dpart / kvisc % Reynolds number
CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 
11 
f = 150*(1-eps) / Re + 1.75 % friction factor 
F = (1-eps)/eps^3 * f*L*u^2/dpart %friction losses (m^2/s^2) 
Ploss = F * ro % Pressure lost across filter (pa) 
% a mechanical energy balance can be done for the required catchment 
% height by setting g*z = F. All other losses are negligible. 
z = F / 9.8 % Catchment height to maintain atm pressure (m)

More Related Content

What's hot

Water harvesting
Water harvestingWater harvesting
Water harvestingMd Faiz Ali
 
Rainwaterharvesting by...prabhunath sharma
Rainwaterharvesting by...prabhunath sharmaRainwaterharvesting by...prabhunath sharma
Rainwaterharvesting by...prabhunath sharmaPrabhunath Sharma
 
Rainwater harvesting
Rainwater harvestingRainwater harvesting
Rainwater harvestingFayaz Uddin
 
Roof Top Rain Water Harvesting - tgswater.in -
Roof Top Rain Water Harvesting - tgswater.in -Roof Top Rain Water Harvesting - tgswater.in -
Roof Top Rain Water Harvesting - tgswater.in -TGSEcom -TGS Water-
 
Rain water harvesting
Rain water harvestingRain water harvesting
Rain water harvestingAbsar Ahmed
 
130618_ CF_rainwater harvest_report_issue 2
130618_ CF_rainwater harvest_report_issue 2130618_ CF_rainwater harvest_report_issue 2
130618_ CF_rainwater harvest_report_issue 2Gordon Hirst
 
Rooftop Rainwater Harvesting -Natural resource management
Rooftop Rainwater Harvesting -Natural resource managementRooftop Rainwater Harvesting -Natural resource management
Rooftop Rainwater Harvesting -Natural resource managementRevadhBalraj
 
Rainwater Harvesting 201
Rainwater Harvesting 201Rainwater Harvesting 201
Rainwater Harvesting 201D4Z
 
Rainwater harvesting an alternative source of water
Rainwater harvesting  an alternative source of waterRainwater harvesting  an alternative source of water
Rainwater harvesting an alternative source of waterShabarinath R
 
Rainwater harvesting
Rainwater harvestingRainwater harvesting
Rainwater harvestingnishantphysio
 
Rainwater harvesting & irrigation
Rainwater harvesting & irrigationRainwater harvesting & irrigation
Rainwater harvesting & irrigationseanmullarkey
 
Methods of Rainwater Harvesting, Types of Rural Sanitation and Types of Plumb...
Methods of Rainwater Harvesting, Types of Rural Sanitation and Types of Plumb...Methods of Rainwater Harvesting, Types of Rural Sanitation and Types of Plumb...
Methods of Rainwater Harvesting, Types of Rural Sanitation and Types of Plumb...Pradyumna Panikker
 
Whole House Rainwater Harvesting: Capturing and Using Rainwater for Potable ...
Whole House Rainwater Harvesting:  Capturing and Using Rainwater for Potable ...Whole House Rainwater Harvesting:  Capturing and Using Rainwater for Potable ...
Whole House Rainwater Harvesting: Capturing and Using Rainwater for Potable ...Brian Gregson
 
Rain water harvesting hyderabad
Rain water harvesting hyderabadRain water harvesting hyderabad
Rain water harvesting hyderabadshilpani
 
RAIN WATER HARVESTING
RAIN WATER HARVESTINGRAIN WATER HARVESTING
RAIN WATER HARVESTINGNamitha M R
 

What's hot (20)

Water harvesting
Water harvestingWater harvesting
Water harvesting
 
Hydro531 o
Hydro531 oHydro531 o
Hydro531 o
 
Rainwaterharvesting by...prabhunath sharma
Rainwaterharvesting by...prabhunath sharmaRainwaterharvesting by...prabhunath sharma
Rainwaterharvesting by...prabhunath sharma
 
Rainwater harvesting
Rainwater harvestingRainwater harvesting
Rainwater harvesting
 
Roof Top Rain Water Harvesting - tgswater.in -
Roof Top Rain Water Harvesting - tgswater.in -Roof Top Rain Water Harvesting - tgswater.in -
Roof Top Rain Water Harvesting - tgswater.in -
 
Rain water harvesting
Rain water harvestingRain water harvesting
Rain water harvesting
 
130618_ CF_rainwater harvest_report_issue 2
130618_ CF_rainwater harvest_report_issue 2130618_ CF_rainwater harvest_report_issue 2
130618_ CF_rainwater harvest_report_issue 2
 
Rooftop Rainwater Harvesting -Natural resource management
Rooftop Rainwater Harvesting -Natural resource managementRooftop Rainwater Harvesting -Natural resource management
Rooftop Rainwater Harvesting -Natural resource management
 
Rainwater Harvesting 201
Rainwater Harvesting 201Rainwater Harvesting 201
Rainwater Harvesting 201
 
Rainwater harvesting an alternative source of water
Rainwater harvesting  an alternative source of waterRainwater harvesting  an alternative source of water
Rainwater harvesting an alternative source of water
 
RAIN WATER HARVESTING
RAIN WATER HARVESTING RAIN WATER HARVESTING
RAIN WATER HARVESTING
 
Rainwater harvesting
Rainwater harvestingRainwater harvesting
Rainwater harvesting
 
Rainwater harvesting & irrigation
Rainwater harvesting & irrigationRainwater harvesting & irrigation
Rainwater harvesting & irrigation
 
rain water harvesting ppt slideshare
rain water harvesting ppt slidesharerain water harvesting ppt slideshare
rain water harvesting ppt slideshare
 
Methods of Rainwater Harvesting, Types of Rural Sanitation and Types of Plumb...
Methods of Rainwater Harvesting, Types of Rural Sanitation and Types of Plumb...Methods of Rainwater Harvesting, Types of Rural Sanitation and Types of Plumb...
Methods of Rainwater Harvesting, Types of Rural Sanitation and Types of Plumb...
 
ROOFTOP RAIN WATER HARVESTING
ROOFTOP RAIN WATER HARVESTINGROOFTOP RAIN WATER HARVESTING
ROOFTOP RAIN WATER HARVESTING
 
Whole House Rainwater Harvesting: Capturing and Using Rainwater for Potable ...
Whole House Rainwater Harvesting:  Capturing and Using Rainwater for Potable ...Whole House Rainwater Harvesting:  Capturing and Using Rainwater for Potable ...
Whole House Rainwater Harvesting: Capturing and Using Rainwater for Potable ...
 
Rain water harvesting hyderabad
Rain water harvesting hyderabadRain water harvesting hyderabad
Rain water harvesting hyderabad
 
stormwater management
 stormwater management stormwater management
stormwater management
 
RAIN WATER HARVESTING
RAIN WATER HARVESTINGRAIN WATER HARVESTING
RAIN WATER HARVESTING
 

Viewers also liked

UN; Summary of Field and Laboratory Testing for the Biosand Filter
UN;  Summary of Field and Laboratory Testing for the Biosand Filter  UN;  Summary of Field and Laboratory Testing for the Biosand Filter
UN; Summary of Field and Laboratory Testing for the Biosand Filter D2Z
 
Coates Offshore Product Brochure
Coates Offshore Product BrochureCoates Offshore Product Brochure
Coates Offshore Product Brochurecraigcon
 
Biosand filter manual version 10 2010-05
Biosand filter manual version 10 2010-05Biosand filter manual version 10 2010-05
Biosand filter manual version 10 2010-05Mumbai Ngo
 
Biomass:- slide for presentatio in a detail way
Biomass:- slide for presentatio in a detail way Biomass:- slide for presentatio in a detail way
Biomass:- slide for presentatio in a detail way Anwesha Banerjee
 
Biomass power point
Biomass power pointBiomass power point
Biomass power pointpnm940
 
Bio Energy Presentation
Bio Energy PresentationBio Energy Presentation
Bio Energy Presentationlaipeng
 
BIOMASS as renewable energy resource
BIOMASS as renewable energy resourceBIOMASS as renewable energy resource
BIOMASS as renewable energy resourceUzair Khan
 
Biomass Power Point
Biomass Power PointBiomass Power Point
Biomass Power Pointguestcc80f8
 

Viewers also liked (14)

UN; Summary of Field and Laboratory Testing for the Biosand Filter
UN;  Summary of Field and Laboratory Testing for the Biosand Filter  UN;  Summary of Field and Laboratory Testing for the Biosand Filter
UN; Summary of Field and Laboratory Testing for the Biosand Filter
 
Coates Offshore Product Brochure
Coates Offshore Product BrochureCoates Offshore Product Brochure
Coates Offshore Product Brochure
 
Orica_Binder
Orica_BinderOrica_Binder
Orica_Binder
 
Child Fund
Child FundChild Fund
Child Fund
 
Biosand filter manual version 10 2010-05
Biosand filter manual version 10 2010-05Biosand filter manual version 10 2010-05
Biosand filter manual version 10 2010-05
 
The biosand filter
The biosand filterThe biosand filter
The biosand filter
 
Biomass:- slide for presentatio in a detail way
Biomass:- slide for presentatio in a detail way Biomass:- slide for presentatio in a detail way
Biomass:- slide for presentatio in a detail way
 
Shoring
ShoringShoring
Shoring
 
Biomass power point
Biomass power pointBiomass power point
Biomass power point
 
Biomass
BiomassBiomass
Biomass
 
Bio Energy Presentation
Bio Energy PresentationBio Energy Presentation
Bio Energy Presentation
 
BIOMASS as renewable energy resource
BIOMASS as renewable energy resourceBIOMASS as renewable energy resource
BIOMASS as renewable energy resource
 
Biomass Power Point
Biomass Power PointBiomass Power Point
Biomass Power Point
 
Biomass presentation by Mr. Hauber 2013
Biomass presentation by Mr. Hauber 2013Biomass presentation by Mr. Hauber 2013
Biomass presentation by Mr. Hauber 2013
 

Similar to Final Report_Edited by JC and KP

Green Buildings-reduce resue and recycle
Green Buildings-reduce resue and recycleGreen Buildings-reduce resue and recycle
Green Buildings-reduce resue and recyclectlachu
 
443047949-Rain-water-Harvesting-Project-Report-docx.docx
443047949-Rain-water-Harvesting-Project-Report-docx.docx443047949-Rain-water-Harvesting-Project-Report-docx.docx
443047949-Rain-water-Harvesting-Project-Report-docx.docxParthNanu
 
Gem ppt-9-rainwater harvesting
Gem ppt-9-rainwater harvestingGem ppt-9-rainwater harvesting
Gem ppt-9-rainwater harvestingijcparish
 
An introduction to rainwater harvesting
An introduction to rainwater harvestingAn introduction to rainwater harvesting
An introduction to rainwater harvestingTaranjot Ubhi
 
METHODS AND USERS OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING
METHODS AND USERS OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING METHODS AND USERS OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING
METHODS AND USERS OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING BURLAVENKATAKRISHNA
 
Development and Performance Evaluation of Cost Effective Roof Water Purificat...
Development and Performance Evaluation of Cost Effective Roof Water Purificat...Development and Performance Evaluation of Cost Effective Roof Water Purificat...
Development and Performance Evaluation of Cost Effective Roof Water Purificat...IRJET Journal
 
Agadir, Morocco Vishwanath IRCSA Rainwater Club
Agadir, Morocco  Vishwanath IRCSA Rainwater ClubAgadir, Morocco  Vishwanath IRCSA Rainwater Club
Agadir, Morocco Vishwanath IRCSA Rainwater Clubzenrain man
 
Constructed wetland
Constructed wetlandConstructed wetland
Constructed wetlandAnkit Jain
 
Ensuring a Safe, Sustainable Future Water Supply--Case Study
Ensuring a Safe, Sustainable Future Water Supply--Case StudyEnsuring a Safe, Sustainable Future Water Supply--Case Study
Ensuring a Safe, Sustainable Future Water Supply--Case StudyTeresa Long
 
CSA Symposium 2016 -Shawn Miller Day 1 Session 3
CSA Symposium 2016 -Shawn Miller  Day 1 Session 3CSA Symposium 2016 -Shawn Miller  Day 1 Session 3
CSA Symposium 2016 -Shawn Miller Day 1 Session 3ACDI/VOCA
 
Finding Water Through Rain
Finding Water Through RainFinding Water Through Rain
Finding Water Through Rainrainsaver
 
Rainwaterharvestingby prabhunath-120911061513-phpapp02
Rainwaterharvestingby prabhunath-120911061513-phpapp02Rainwaterharvestingby prabhunath-120911061513-phpapp02
Rainwaterharvestingby prabhunath-120911061513-phpapp02muhammed ajeeb
 
IRJET - Application of Water Conservation Technique to Low Income Group H...
IRJET -  	  Application of Water Conservation Technique to Low Income Group H...IRJET -  	  Application of Water Conservation Technique to Low Income Group H...
IRJET - Application of Water Conservation Technique to Low Income Group H...IRJET Journal
 
ranjith_major_project_2333.pptx
ranjith_major_project_2333.pptxranjith_major_project_2333.pptx
ranjith_major_project_2333.pptx19TK1132
 
Rain water harvesting presentation
Rain water harvesting presentationRain water harvesting presentation
Rain water harvesting presentationsuraj vishwakarma
 
Presentation 2 student z
Presentation 2 student zPresentation 2 student z
Presentation 2 student zAsma Wasim
 
Presentation 2 student z
Presentation 2 student zPresentation 2 student z
Presentation 2 student zAsma Wasim
 

Similar to Final Report_Edited by JC and KP (20)

Green Buildings-reduce resue and recycle
Green Buildings-reduce resue and recycleGreen Buildings-reduce resue and recycle
Green Buildings-reduce resue and recycle
 
443047949-Rain-water-Harvesting-Project-Report-docx.docx
443047949-Rain-water-Harvesting-Project-Report-docx.docx443047949-Rain-water-Harvesting-Project-Report-docx.docx
443047949-Rain-water-Harvesting-Project-Report-docx.docx
 
Gem ppt-9-rainwater harvesting
Gem ppt-9-rainwater harvestingGem ppt-9-rainwater harvesting
Gem ppt-9-rainwater harvesting
 
An introduction to rainwater harvesting
An introduction to rainwater harvestingAn introduction to rainwater harvesting
An introduction to rainwater harvesting
 
METHODS AND USERS OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING
METHODS AND USERS OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING METHODS AND USERS OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING
METHODS AND USERS OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING
 
Development and Performance Evaluation of Cost Effective Roof Water Purificat...
Development and Performance Evaluation of Cost Effective Roof Water Purificat...Development and Performance Evaluation of Cost Effective Roof Water Purificat...
Development and Performance Evaluation of Cost Effective Roof Water Purificat...
 
Purification Final Report
Purification Final ReportPurification Final Report
Purification Final Report
 
Agadir, Morocco Vishwanath IRCSA Rainwater Club
Agadir, Morocco  Vishwanath IRCSA Rainwater ClubAgadir, Morocco  Vishwanath IRCSA Rainwater Club
Agadir, Morocco Vishwanath IRCSA Rainwater Club
 
Constructed wetland
Constructed wetlandConstructed wetland
Constructed wetland
 
Ensuring a Safe, Sustainable Future Water Supply--Case Study
Ensuring a Safe, Sustainable Future Water Supply--Case StudyEnsuring a Safe, Sustainable Future Water Supply--Case Study
Ensuring a Safe, Sustainable Future Water Supply--Case Study
 
Efficient Auto Regulative Subsurface Irrigation
Efficient Auto Regulative Subsurface IrrigationEfficient Auto Regulative Subsurface Irrigation
Efficient Auto Regulative Subsurface Irrigation
 
CSA Symposium 2016 -Shawn Miller Day 1 Session 3
CSA Symposium 2016 -Shawn Miller  Day 1 Session 3CSA Symposium 2016 -Shawn Miller  Day 1 Session 3
CSA Symposium 2016 -Shawn Miller Day 1 Session 3
 
Finding Water Through Rain
Finding Water Through RainFinding Water Through Rain
Finding Water Through Rain
 
Rainwaterharvestingby prabhunath-120911061513-phpapp02
Rainwaterharvestingby prabhunath-120911061513-phpapp02Rainwaterharvestingby prabhunath-120911061513-phpapp02
Rainwaterharvestingby prabhunath-120911061513-phpapp02
 
Design Project EWB
Design Project EWBDesign Project EWB
Design Project EWB
 
IRJET - Application of Water Conservation Technique to Low Income Group H...
IRJET -  	  Application of Water Conservation Technique to Low Income Group H...IRJET -  	  Application of Water Conservation Technique to Low Income Group H...
IRJET - Application of Water Conservation Technique to Low Income Group H...
 
ranjith_major_project_2333.pptx
ranjith_major_project_2333.pptxranjith_major_project_2333.pptx
ranjith_major_project_2333.pptx
 
Rain water harvesting presentation
Rain water harvesting presentationRain water harvesting presentation
Rain water harvesting presentation
 
Presentation 2 student z
Presentation 2 student zPresentation 2 student z
Presentation 2 student z
 
Presentation 2 student z
Presentation 2 student zPresentation 2 student z
Presentation 2 student z
 

Final Report_Edited by JC and KP

  • 1. RAINWATER CATCHMENT SYSTEM PROJECT FINAL WRITTEN REPORT TEAM JARED CORDES PAIGE MOLZAHN KIET PHUNG JUNE 11, 2014 OREGON STATE UNIVERSITY CBEE 416
  • 2. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report Figure 1: This is a diagram of the catchment area inverted roof design. The rainfall will be caught and roll down the slope of the system and flow to the flow diverter. 1 ABSTRACT The project objective is to design a low cost and low maintenance system that can catch and clean water to be used for 50 in Haiti for hygienic purposes. The water must be caught, diverted, filtered and stored before used by the population. These steps required literature comparisons as well as experimental testing. The catchment surface area was determined to be 185 m2 and will be made of aluminum. The flow diverter consists of an initial diverter, a clarifier and a bleeder valve. This system will be constructed of 1” PVC pipes to handle the maximum amount of flow. There will be two operational sand filters to remove particulates and pathogens with diameters of 30 cm and heights of 1.1 m. These filters will have layers of fine sand, course sand, gravel, and small rocks. A bio layer will accumulate over time which will assist in the pathogen removal. This layer needs to be checked monthly to avoid overgrowth of biota. Finally, there will be two 5,000 gallon reservoirs made of polyethylene. They will be UV resistant and opaque to prevent bacteria growth within the tank. A bill of materials was created for the overall system design determining an expected cost range of $6,700 - $8,200. DESIGN BACKGROUND Obtaining clean water is a current struggle in undeveloped countries such as Haiti. The World Health Organization (WHO) requires 12.5 L/c/d to meet the basic hygiene needs for rural populations. An additional 7.5 L/c/d are required to meet water consumption needs. Many water sources used in developing countries come from streams containing pathogens. Rainwater harvesting has been one alternative water source that provides clean water for hygiene and consumption. Rainwater contains no pathogens or heavy metals, but it can be low in pH in deforested regions. Harvesting can only remain viable in areas of heavy rainfall with few drought seasons. Heavy droughts lead to an increase in required water holding time which increases the chance for contamination. Haiti received an average annual rainfall of 1600 mm between 1999 and 2009. May, September, and August had the most rainfall while December through March obtained less than 100 mm.1 A rainwater catchment system requires four main parts: a catchment area, a piping system, a purification filter and a storage reservoir. The inverted roof catchment area is a commonly used design for rainwater catchment systems. This design requires minimal maintenance and has the ability to easily divert flow. This system, shown in Figure 1,2 is the optimal catchment area design. The rainfall will be caught and then flow to a diverter system to remove the debris from the initial rainfall. Dust will accumulate on the catchment area during droughts. These particulates must be removed before entering the filter when it finally rains. The cleaner water will then move on to a sand filter to be purified. The water enters the slow sand filter after the initial flow diverter to catch small debris that passed the initial flow diverter and to treat pathogens from the catchment surface. A sand filter is made up of three layers: fine sand to trap particles, coarse sand to keep the fine sand from leaving the filter, and gravel to keep the 1 "Climate Change Knowledge Portal 2.0." Climate Change Knowledge Portal 2.0. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2014. 2 "1.1 Rainwater Harvesting from Rooftop Catchments." Rainwater Harvesting from Rooftop Catchments.Web. 08 June 2014.
  • 3. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report coarse sand from leaving the filter. Fine sand is made of particles that have around 100 μm of equivalent diameter and the coarse sand has an equivalent length of 200 μm. Pathogen removal is carried out in three ways; they will get trapped in between sand particles and die from nutrient loss, they will be too large to go through the sand, or be removed through use of a bio layer that will destroy pathogens. Bacteria in this bio layer attack incoming contaminants in a process called predation. The bio layer, which grows on the top layer of fine sand, takes around one month to develop according to the EPA. This bio layer can be destroyed by agitation or removal of the top layer of sand, so it is important that the filter is not mishandled. The bio layer requires still water to be present or the bacteria will die. The bio layer will continually grow which can cause high pressure loss through the sand filter due to the extra layer. This growth is coined schmutzdecke, or dirty layer. Finally, the water will be stored in a reservoir. The rainwater reservoir is the most expensive component of a rainwater harvesting system. The cost depends on the type of construction materials used, water demand for daily consumption, and whether the tank is built above ground or underground. An above ground tank is preferred over an underground tank for water storage considering price, maintenance, and convenience. The above ground tank can be constructed easily from a wide variety of materials. Pump installation is not necessary because water extraction can be done by gravity in many cases. An above ground tank also allows easy inspection and maintenance for water leaks. The tank storage, however, must have opaque or dark color to block sunlight to stop the growth of algae. The underground cistern requires excavation, a pump system to extract water, and a higher cost of construction and maintenance; therefore, an above ground tank proves to be a better solution in Haiti. 2 METHODS AND MATERIALS SYSTEM SCALING With the 50 person scope of this project, a total of 625 L would be the daily minimum required clean water production. This water must be caught, diverted, filtered, and stored before accessed by the population. The average rainfall data3 shown in Figure 2 was used for determination of catchment and reservoir scaling. Adequate amounts of water must be caught and stored through the rainy seasons to continuously provide through the drier seasons. 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Rainfall Intemsity (mm) The reservoir must fill to a maximum and then deplete in the course of one year to prevent the Month system from overfilling and to maintain the Figure 2: The average rainfall data for Haiti, showing both the lowest cost possible. The average monthly rainy and dry seasons rainfall data was divided among 50% of the days in the month, assuming that the rain does not fall in even amounts every day and some days have no rainfall. This strategy was applied to size both the catchment surface area and the reservoir giving a catchment area of 185 m2 and a reservoir size of 10,000 gallons. The scaling of the sand filter requires the calculation of the pressure loss through the system. Pressure loss was calculated using the Ergun equation shown be Equations 1 and 2. ΔP represents the pressure loss, ε is 3 Climate Change Knowledge Portal. The World Bank Group, n.d. Web. 5 Apr. 2014.
  • 4. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report the void space in the bed, ff is the friction factor, L is the length of the sand, ρ is the water density, u is the superficial velocity, dpart is the equivalent diameter of sand, and v is the kinematic viscosity of water. These calculations were used with experimental data to optimize the diameter of the filter, the required height of sand and the number of filters to be in operation. 3 Δ푃 = 1 − 휀 휀3 푓푓 퐿휌 푢0 2 푑푝푎푟푡 (1) 푓푓 = 150(1 − 휀) 푢0 ∗ 푑푝푎푟푡 ( 푣 ) + 1.75 (2) MATERIALS AND COST A bill of materials is attached in the Appendix that details all goods that would need to be purchased to complete the catchment system. Services such as construction and maintenance are variable in cost and are left out. A 10% decrease and increase was added to the price in the US for an estimate range of the cost for Haiti. The catchment is required to be a raised system due to the lack of available house roofs that could meet the area required. This drove the cost up to $1,289 for the US. Five beams would have to be anchored into concrete on the back of both aluminum sheets. Another five beams would anchor the middle of the aluminum sheets. The initial flow diverter was the cheapest at $78 US. The PVC should be shaded and wrapped with the drain pipe. This should decrease sun and heat exposure to the system. The filters cost $896 US. Obtaining and fabricating the plastic for the filter was costly. The material is reliable and should last up to 10 years though. The filters are clear so a basic tub should be put over them to avoid growth of photosynthetic bacteria and to reduce the heat on the filter. The reservoirs cost the most at $5,165 US. The tank sizes are massive so this cost was unavoidable. Haiti should expect an initial cost, for just the materials, of $6,685.95 up to $8,171.71. EXPERIMENTAL TESTING The catchment area and the reservoir system were not tested due to cost and time restrictions. These aspects would be constructed following designs obtained from the literature. Experimental testing was completed on the flow diverter. This testing required the construction of a flow diverter system made out of PVC that consists of two parallel horizontal pipes with the top one linked to a biosand filter and two vertical pipes connecting to a clarifier and the other to a bleeder valve. The bleeder valve will be slightly open during the operation. A first flush of contaminated rainwater enters the flow diverter system where the debris from collected rainwater will travel through the pipes down into the clarifier and also deposit above the valve. The water level in the flow diverter system rises and the subsequent flow of cleaner rainwater is then automatically directed along the pipes to the biosand filters system. The bleeder valve is eventually opened after the catchment period to drain contaminated water at the bottom and allow for maintenance and cleaning purposes. These visible pollutants can be diverted and removed by initial flow of water into a flow diverter system as depicted in Figure 3. A lab-scale flow diverter system was constructed using ½‘’ PVC pipes, ½’’ T’s, ½’’ 90o elbow, and small plastic container acting as a clarifier in order to determine the feasibility of the system. A sample of 200 mL of imitation rainwater containing debris was introduced to Figure 3: : A process flow diagram of a flow diverter composed of PVC pipes, a clarifier, and a bleeder valve to remove larger contaminants from collected rainwater prior to further treatment from biosand filters
  • 5. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report the flow diverter, subsequently followed by adding 400 mL of DI water. The first experimental trial went until no water flowed through the bleeder valve. The second through fourth trial repeated adding imitation rainwater and then DI. The experiment testing for the sand filter dimensions was conducted to determine the equivalent diameter of the particles within the filter, the flow of water, and the height of required sand. The equivalent diameter of the sand was the first parameter to be found by flowing water through the filter at 100 mL/min. The height of water remained constant at 15 cm above the top of the sand which fixed ΔP using Equation 1. The bed void space was estimated to be 0.45. The sand length was 15 cm. This gave an Figure 4: A graph of the pressure loss as head of water through the sand equivalent diameter of 115 μm for the fine filter. The increase is linear with length, but varies based on diameter. The design should be carried out at 30 cm ID. The pressure loss more sand. The pressure drop through the system than doubles from 30 to 20 cm. is taken using this diameter for both sand layers which will slightly overestimate the actual pressure drop. This is a small safety factor to account for channeling, wall effects, and the effects of the schmutzdecke. The pressure drop through the gravel area is much smaller than that of the sand beds. Figure 4 shows the pressure drop through the filter as a function of diameter and length. The filter will be operating at a length of 60 cm of total sand with gravel. An ID of 30 cm is suggested for each filter. At these filter conditions, we expect a required pressure head of 1 m. The filter length is 70 cm, so a head of 30 cm is needed to overcome the pressure difference. 4 RESULTS INITIAL FLOW DIVERTER 4.5 4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 Diamater = 50cm Diameter = 40cm Diameter = 30cm Diameter = 20cm 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 Pressure Head (m) Filter Length (m) The experimental testing on the flow diverter system proved to be feasible as the rainwater condition improved significantly at the outlet connecting to biosand filter compared to the original rainwater entering the system. The cost of material and installation for constructing a flow diverter system is relatively inexpensive as PVC pipes are the primary material and easy to work with. The flow diverter must have covered PVC pipes or be made from UV resistant material to avoid PVC degradation from sunlight. The potential stress cracking of PVC due to constant thermal exposure is another major problem when using PVC. The flow diverter system should be built below the inverted roof system or in the shade to extend the in-service life of PVC pipes. Regular maintenance is recommended, for i.e. opening the bleeder valve to remove debris settled at the bottom to prevent clogging. Figure 5 below shows the cleanliness of each water sample after the experiment.
  • 6. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report Figure 5: The cleanliness of each water sample during the experimentation to determine the feasibility of the flow diverter system. (a): water that was initially introduced to the flow diverter (~200 mL per trial, then ~400 mL of DI), (b): water collected after fully opening the bleeder valve on the 4th trial, (c): water collected from the clarifier section, (d): water that left the flow diverter, to head to the filter, for the 4th trial Figure 6: A picture of two water samples. The sample on the right that flowed through the filter had a turbidity of 34 NTU, and the treated water on the left had a turbidity of 1.3 NTU. 5 (a) (b) (c) (d) BIOSAND FILTERS Three filters were suggested for the design. This would allow two filters to be used at once while the other goes through maintenance or repairs. The filters will all be the same size for simplicity. The design of the filters are based on acceptable pressure loss through the system and adequate treatment of turbid water. The first design is to find the length of fine sand needed to treat turbid water. Turbidity represents the “cloudiness” of a water and is directly related to the amount of pathogens that could be present. Higher turbidity has an increased chance of carrying pathogenic species. The EPA suggests that an effective filter for removing pathogens can treat turbidity to under 5 Nephelometric Turbid Units (NTU). Rainwater was collected from Corvallis using a bucket in order to find the approximate turbidity of rain water. The rainwater sample had a turbidity of 22 NTU. Experiments were run using a solution of water and corn starch in order to create turbid solutions that ranged from 10 – 34 NTU, the expected turbidity of rainwater into the filters. Figure 6 shows an example of the difference in turbidity. Two filters should remain operational at all times. This allows for one filter to work while the other has an overflow at the top section in case of heavy rainfall. The highest designed rainfall was for 0.83 mm/hr. An outlet at the top of one of the filters will flow straight into a reservoir instead of being filtered. This overflow water will accumulate in another reservoir that will need to be treated, ran through a filter, before it should be used. The filters will need to 1.1 meters tall to allow space for the water to accumulate. The accumulation of water can build up to 20 cm above the top layer of sand before the rain water flows into the overflow. The design of the filter is shown by Figure 7.
  • 7. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report Figure 7: The overall design of the three filters. Each level is detailed out with dimensions. The gravel layer can be split into 5 cm of gravel and 5 cm of larger rocks if needed. The outlet to overflow will wither connect two filters together lead to a reservoir. That will depend on which filter is hooked to the overflow reservoir. A union is suggested to be built on the swan neck, which will allow the PVC to easily be removed from the filter. The swan neck should use the same materials as the PVC flow diverter The last part of the filter is the flow diverter that sits inside of the filter. Its purpose is to slightly divert the incoming water so that it does not damage the top layer of sand. The plate can also be used to remove the top layer of schmutzdecke if it accumulates more than 5 cm on top of the fine sand. The design is shown in Figure 8. The filter will be built from polyethylene or any other plastic material. Another cylindrical plastic cylinder, with dimensions around 35 cm ID with 1.12 m tall, should be put over the filter to reduce UV light damaging the filter. The sides of this cylinder need to have holes in them in order to allow air to enter the filters. The bio layer should be run under aerobic conditions where oxygen is present. The filter could also be put under constant shade. This doesn’t decrease the heat significantly so the filters would need more maintenance. Figure 8: The design for the filters flow diverter. This plate, which can be made of an aluminum sheet, diverts the initial flow into the filter to minimize damage to the sand layers. The teardrop shapes allow the diverter to pick up the top layer of schmutzdecke by simply rotating the plate. Water entering the filter should be directed toward the center of the diverter. Two filters were used for this experiment. One filter had an internal diameter (ID) of 13 cm and the other 18 cm. Both filters contained the same length of sand. Flow rates were set at 1 m3/hr making a superficial velocity of 2.1 cm/s for the 13 cm ID filter and 1.1 cm/s for the 18 cm ID filter. A Vernier turbid meter was used to find the turbidity of the water samples. The outflow turbidity of water from the filters ranged from 10 to 30 NTU with only the coarse sand. The length of the coarse sand was reduced, and 15 cm of fine sand was added to the system. The new filters treated the 10 – 34 NTU solutions to less than 5 NTU for all runs that were conducted. This was based on 3 trial runs for 3 different turbidities. Figure 9 shows the data with a 90% confidence interval. 6 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0 18 cm ID Filter 13 cm ID Filter 0 10 20 30 40 Outlet Turbidity (NTU) Inlet Turbidity (NTU) Figure 9: A graph of the turbidity of the water that went into the filter on the x axis, and the turbidity of the treated water out of the filter on the y axis. All runs contained treated water under the EPA standards of 5 NTU.
  • 8. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report The suggested design is to use 50 cm of fine sand for the scaled up version. This would allow the schmutzdecke to form on the top layer of sand, which was not accounted for in the turbidity tests. The extra amount will also account for increased flows which can occur during large rain events. 7 MAINTENANCE The required maintenance on the filters is minimal under ideal conditions. The initial sand used for the filter can be bought from a local store for simplicity. Sand from beaches and other areas can be used, but they would require cleaning with safe water before they can be used. The top layer of the bio layer will have to be looked at monthly. This is to avoid overgrowth of the bio layer. The filters flow diverter can be used to take out some of the top layer of schmutzdecke without disturbing the top layer of sand. Every four months the schmutzdecke should be scraped to a low level if the flow diverter can’t remove it. The layer needs to be minimally disturbed in order to have the best treatment. The bio layer will take about 1 month to accumulate, so the filters should collect rainwater for one month before the water can be used for hygiene. This procedure applies to any filter that hasn’t been used in over a month. The sand is suggested to be replaced yearly. This should be done at different times of the year for each filter. The sand can be replaced by simply removing the contents of the filter, cleaning the sand off, and replacing it back in the filter. The layer of fine sand may fall into the coarse sand, so it is important to check the filters every year. The plastic closed cylinder around the filter should be repaired, or replaced, yearly. The sun quickly damages the material so it is best used in a shaded area. The filters should be inspected every month, by eye, to make sure that there are no cracks or leaks. OVERALL SYSTEM DESIGN The overall design of the system is shown in Figure 10 (Page 8). This design includes the overall surface area of the catchment system, the initial flow diverter design, the sand filter dimensions and the sizing of the reservoirs. The specifics of the design are provided in previous sections of the report. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The rainwater catchment team would like to thank the project sponsor, Dr. Yokochi, for providing this opportunity, Dr. Harding for weekly advising to ensure our work stays on task, Andy Brickman for assistance in obtaining materials, Manfred Dittrich for assistance with construction tools, OSU Engineers Without Borders for cost analysis insight and Lauren Kelly for providing access to the turbid meter.
  • 9. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 8 Figure 10: Overall design of a rainwater catchment system to be used in Haiti, which consists of a catchment area, an initial flow diverter, two biosand filters, and two main reservoirs.
  • 10. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 9 APPENDIX Bill Of Materials BOM Item Number Item Name Quantity Size US price Procurment Haiti Low Haiti High Notes 1 10-001 Aluminum Sheet 2 92 m2 $644.00 Metals Depot $579.60 $708.40 2 10-002 High Wood Posts 10 1.7 m $89.70 Home Depot $80.73 $98.67 4 in by 4 in beams 3 10-003 Low Wood Posts 10 1.3 m $89.70 Home Depot $80.73 $98.67 Same beams that will need to be cut 4 10-004 Concrete 20 60 lbs $247.00 Home Depot $222.30 $271.70 Rapid set concrete to hold posts 5 10-005 Post Anchors 20 4 by 4" $159.40 Home Depot $143.46 $175.34 6 10-006 Joist Hanger 20 18 gauge $7.00 Home Depot $6.30 $7.70 Simpson Strong Tie A21Z Z-MAX 7 10-007 Deck Screws 3 inch $30.00 Home Depot $27.00 $33.00 8 10-008 Hinged Gutter Screen 10 6 by 36" $22.30 Home Depot $20.07 $24.53 9 10 Catchment Total $1,289.10 $1,160.19 $1,418.01 10 20-001 PVC Pipe 3 1" ID, 10' $10.92 Home Depot $9.83 $12.01 11 20-002 Drain Pipe 3 4" ID, 10' $19.65 Home Depot $17.69 $21.62 12 20-003 90o PVC Elbow 3 1" $5.91 Home Depot $5.32 $6.50 13 20-004 PVC Tee 6 1" $4.44 Home Depot $4.00 $4.88 14 20-005 Ball Valve 1 1" $5.15 Home Depot $4.64 $5.67 15 20-006 PVC Glue 3 8 oz. $9.74 Home Depot $8.77 $10.71 16 20-007 Container 1 1 L $0.00 $0.00 17 20-008 Bulkhead Fitting 1 1" $16.24 Home Depot $14.62 $17.86 18 20-009 Gutter 1 10' $5.23 Home Depot $4.71 $5.75 19 20 Flow Diverter Total $77.28 $69.55 $85.01 20 30-001 Acrylic Clear Sheet 3 1.1 by 0.94 m $531.36 Plas-Tech $478.22 $584.50 Rough estimate based on professional plastic 21 30-002 Acrylic base 3 0.6 by 0.6 m $90.00 Plas-Tech $81.00 $99.00 22 30-003 Plastic Circle 3 30 cm D $60.00 Plas-Tech $54.00 $66.00 Used for filter flow diverter 23 30-004 Silicone Sealant 2 300 mL $25.98 Ace Hardware $23.38 $28.58 Red Devil heat resistant industrial grade 24 30-005 Fine Sand 10 50 lbs $32.50 Home Depot $29.25 $35.75 Can also use local sand that is treated 25 30-006 Coarse Sand 8 1 ft3 $59.92 Agri Supply $53.93 $65.91 " " 26 30-007 Gravel 15 0.5 ft3 $45.00 Home Depot $40.50 $49.50 27 30-008 Union 3 1" $14.58 Home Depot $13.12 $16.04 28 30-009 90o PVC Elbow 6 1" $11.82 Home Depot $10.64 $13.00 29 30-010 PVC Male Adapter 6 1" $3.54 Home Depot $3.19 $3.89 Connect slip PVC with threaded hole on filter 30 30-011 PVC Cutter 1 $6.48 Home Depot $5.83 $7.13 31 30-012 Cylindrical Tub 3 $0.00 $0.00 Put over filters to reduce sun exposure 32 30 Filter Total $881.18 $793.06 $969.30 33 40-001 Storage Tank 2 5000 L $4,711.26 Tanksforless.com $4,240.13 $5,182.39 34 40-002 Overflow Tank 1 500 L $418.52 Tanksforless.com $376.67 $460.37 35 40-003 Brass Gate Valve 3 1" $33.72 Home Depot $30.35 $37.09 36 40-004 PVC Male Adapter 3 1" $1.77 Home Depot $1.59 $1.95 Connects PVC 37 40 Reservoir Total $5,165.27 $4,648.74 $5,681.80 38 50 Total Cost $7,412.83 $6,671.55 $8,154.11
  • 11. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 10 Required Volume of Reservoir: *The value calculated will be based on the rainfal intensity per month. Future calculations may be done to find daily rainfal intensitys. **Assume that the catchment system will be built in April Month Total Days Rainfall Rain captured Rain Consumed Reservoir Volume [mm] [m3] [m3] [m3] April 30 136 19.26 18.8 0.51 May 31 243 34.43 19.4 15.57 June 30 123 17.46 18.8 14.28 July 31 114 16.17 19.4 11.08 August 31 124 17.60 19.4 9.31 September 30 184 26.13 18.8 16.69 October 31 280 39.68 19.4 36.99 November 30 149 21.12 18.8 39.37 December 31 68 9.67 19.4 29.67 January 31 60 8.55 19.4 18.84 February 28 54 7.70 17.5 9.05 March 31 73 10.33 19.4 0.00 *Excess was calculated by: rain captured - rain used + previous month excess The largest excess was at 39.37 m3. This value can be used for a one year cycle Suggested volume of reservoir for a one year cycle [m3]: 43 % filterdesign.m % a file in order to find a suitable filter design to minimize %pressure loss and calculate the required head %to offset the pressure loss % Team Rainwater Catchment, CBEE 416, 6/11/14 clear all, format compact A = 141.9; % minimum required catchment area (m^2) dpart = 0.0001148; % equivalent diameter (m) eps = 0.45; % void space of bed ro = 1000; %density of water (kg/m^3) kvisc = 0.995*10^(-6); % kinematic viscosity of water 20 C (m^2/s) r = input('Estimation of daily rain intensity (18.65) : '); % (mm/d) d = input('Diameter of filter estimate (0.4-0.7) : '); % (m) L = input('Desired length of filter (0.3-0.6) : '); % (m) V = r/1000/86400 * A % volumetric flow of rain (m^3/s) u = V /((d/2)^2*pi) % velocity of water throught the filter (m/s) Re = u * dpart / kvisc % Reynolds number
  • 12. CBEE 416 Cordes, Molzahn, and Phung Project Final Report 11 f = 150*(1-eps) / Re + 1.75 % friction factor F = (1-eps)/eps^3 * f*L*u^2/dpart %friction losses (m^2/s^2) Ploss = F * ro % Pressure lost across filter (pa) % a mechanical energy balance can be done for the required catchment % height by setting g*z = F. All other losses are negligible. z = F / 9.8 % Catchment height to maintain atm pressure (m)