Order 389717 read the three attached articles, summarize main argument of each, and then compare and contrast conclusions of each, stating which one of them you find most convincing and or you find dissatisfying
Order 389717 read the three attached articles, summarize main argument of each, and then compare and contrast conclusions of each, stating which one of them you find most convincing and or you find dissatisfying
2. POLITICAL SCIENCE 2
Political science
Downes Lawrence article begins by mobilizing immigrants to get ready for some harsh
experiences. He explains to immigrants that it has come to a time that has to accept and declare
themselves as a sanctuary. According to Trump unauthorized immigrants are vicious criminals and
have dangerous desirables. This led to the intimidation and arrest of immigrants. Downes argues
that the word sanctuary refers to the immigrant loving communities that facilitate unregistered
immigrant roams freely.
However, the authors focus on states that have gone contradictory to Trump's order on
deportation and detaining undocumented immigrants. The Santa Ana State have distanced itself
from Trumps wishes of detaining immigrants by arguing that here are various Asians and other
immigrants who have worked hard to live in America hence cannot detain. The state has faced
threats of not federal funds but has chosen to protect the undocumented immigrants. Additionally,
the state’s local government has made other efforts of helping out immigrants by providing lawyers
for individuals who are likely to get deported or detained. Downes argues that there other cities
that also have shown to go against Trump's order on immigrants. He concludes by challenging
states that do not show any effort of protecting and providing help to undocumented immigrants.
Feldman’s article, Beyond Liminal Legality, begins by showing the arrest of 600
immigrants in a series of actions that are nationally coordinated. Fieldman explains that Trump
made executive orders that called for increased cooperation between federal immigration
enforcement and police as well as penalties for sanctuary jurisdictions limiting the cooperation.
The immigration justice movement is focusing on fighting deportations via the creating and
defending Sanctuary Cities. According to Elliot Young, the sanctuary city concept faces major
3. POLITICAL SCIENCE 3
risks without consistency in grassroots mobilizations. According to Harvey, while regional
resistances, struggle for local place bound and local autonomy organization could be excellent
based on political action. A major key demand for sanctuary cities had full refugee status for all
individuals forced to get away from Central America. This led to the development of the TPS in
1990. Additionally, Fieldman man also that Trump's government aims at promoting the buy
American hire Americano order. However, he also gives a chance to immigrants with an
employment history to acquire American citizenship. However, with this, more than five million
immigrants will face the threat of being deported or detained by this administration. Therefore,
Fieldman mobilizes the American community to not only make use of the sanctuary cities but also
resist deportations through legalization for all as well as stopping the stopping rule of capital.
In Blitzer Jonathan's article, The Hard-Liners Standing behind Trump against Sanctuary
Cities, he begins by giving a case of a woman who was short by an immigrant. However, the
federal government could not take the case since the City the woman is from is a sanctuary city.
Blitzer introduces the Remembrance organization led by Maria Espinoza whose main roles is
showing the number of crimes caused by undocumented immigrants. He argued that this
organization has been a major tool used by Trump to campaign and mobilize the American
community on the necessity to drive immigrants away. However, critics and anti-immigrants have
argued that this organization mislead the community. Maria argued that the presence of
undocumented immigrants leads to increase in criminal activities. On the contrary, another study
showed that the presence of undocumented immigrants is related to minimal criminal activities.
Jonathan shows that the major barrier to Trump's objective of deporting immigrants is the
sanctuary cities. He alleges that Trump and the Remembrance organization have affirmed that
sanctuary cities could be the major hindrance in the deportation of immigrants.
4. POLITICAL SCIENCE 4
The three articles provide significant information on how to resist deportation of
immigrants. Downes article shows that sanctuary cities are effective enough in protecting
undocumented immigrants. Fieldman's article mobilizes the American communities to make use
of sanctuary cities to resists immigrant deportation and detaining while Jonathan's article shows
those sanctuary cities are the only major way to defeat Trump's objectives of deporting immigrants.
All the articles are well explained and provide different bits of information that sum up to show
that the sanctuary cities are an effective counter measure to trumps immigration policies.