2. Why is Netflix Breakthrough? - Outline
• Extreme customization for each user account
• Constant communication of that customization to the users
• Able to rapidly innovate new ideas into working products
• Completely and irreversibly changed the video renting industry for
the better
• Dominates the entire online content market when using
consumption of bandwidth as a metric
• Despite constant apocalyptic rumors for the last decade Netflix has
continued to succeed and typically overpowers its competitors
eventually
3. Cinematch – What is it?
• Currently 23 million subscribers in 47 countries generate 4 million
ratings per day
• The Cinematch algorithm has been adapted in such a way that 75%
of all movies and TV shows viewed on Netflix are chosen due to some
sort of recommendation
• Cinematch communicates personalization through several different
focuses…
• Diversity
– Cinematch is designed to provide recommendations that fit both the
possible different moods of an individual or possibility of many family
members using one Netflix account
4. Cinematch – What is it?
• Awareness
– Netflix reminds you that their product is being customized for you to promote trust in
their product and to get customers more involved in helping the rating system work
– The extremely specific genre’s and placement of your user name in in the Top10 category
are part of the awareness strategy
• Explanation
– There are constant reminder’s that the recommendations are based on your taste
preferences and previously viewed and rated movies and not the interests of Netflix
further increasing your trust in the product
5. Cinematch – What is it?
• Similarities
– “Similarities” is used very broadly in that it can be between movies or
between members and can be from ratings, whether or not the video was
viewed to completion, sequences of different videos viewed, etc.
– Similarities between friends are used in other countries by connecting
through Facebook, but the Video Privacy Protection Act prevents the same
feature from existing in the USA
• The resulting output to the customer mostly comes in the form of
customized rows that show either your Top10, Customized Genres, or
Similar Titles
• Each title in each row is also displayed according to how Cinematch
thinks you would rate that title based on your ratings and your
taste preferences
6. Cinematch – Creating Customer Satisfaction
• At the end of 2010 (before the Netflix blunder in separating their
products and increasing prices) customers were surveyed to
determine what websites pleased their customers the most and
Netflix and Amazon tied for first with a score of 86% satisfaction
(Source: ForeSee)
• Netflix is not afraid of failure, despite the constant apocalyptic
rumors, and perceives their failures as a sign that they are
constantly trying to innovate to improve the Netflix experience
• The Netflix mantra on failure is basically that if you’re going to fail,
fail cheaply, and know when you’ve failed and when you’ve gotten it
right
• Netflix’s Product Development Cycle
– Hypothesis: “Algorithm/feature/design X will increase member engagement
with our service, and ultimately increase member retention”
– Design a test: This might mean building a full scale product or just building
a prototype to test for positive or negative response
– Test it: Prototypes and products are tested on actual members and
compared to a control group
7. Cinematch – Creating Customer Satisfaction
• Features of the Netflix Product Testing
– The main metrics used are customer engagement and retention, but Netflix
claims to use “zillions” of other metrics
– Products can be tested with hundreds of thousands of test subjects and can
be tested in two test cells or twenty test cells with different variations of the
product
– At any given time Netflix is testing about a dozen different products on it’s
customers without them knowing
– Both failures and successes improve Netflix’s product intuition and increase
their chances of hitting it out of the park with the next hypothesis
– They eliminate the tyranny of “or” choices by ensuring that they can test
many different approaches to a problem
• Does the customer-centric development process and customer-zation
employed by Netflix make it breakthrough?
8. Cinematch – The Netflix Prize
• In October 2006 Netflix offered a $1 million prize for anyone who could improve
Cinematch’s movie matching abilities by 10%
• Final products were reduced to their most valuable components, adapted to provide
real-time analysis, and optimized to handle Netflix’s billions of ratings as opposed to
the 100 million used in the competition
• From the final winner only 2 or the 107 algorithms used in BellKor’s program were
added to Cinematch and because during the competition Netflix launched streaming
service they switched to using many different types of data as opposed to just ratings
• Was the money and tens of thousands of man hours really worth it for this
innovation?
9. End of The Netflix Prize – A Loss of a Brilliant
Innovation Strategy
• The Brokeback Mountain Factor
– The development model of outsourcing to free lance developers or inspiring
teams of developers to form and compete with each other was a brilliant
strategy to keep Netflix at the fore-front of development
– It had to be shutdown because it was quickly discovered that you could
correlate the “anonymous” ratings data to other available data
– Using the date a rating was made and the movie rating data could be
compared to public ratings on IMDb during the same time and the identity
of the users could be discovered along with fairly accurate assumptions
about their sexual orientation and political views
– The law suites the followed and increased interest from the FTC have
prevented Netflix from ever running another program like this
• The change in data being collected
– After the launch of the Netflix streaming service in 2006 the data collection
included more than just ratings
– Even if the Netflix Prize program would have continued it would have
needed to be completely revamped to include all of the additional data
available from streaming
11. Netflix by Mail – Eliminating Managed
Dissatisfaction
• What was the POG for Netflix’s mail service?
– Video stores cannot stock large quantities of new releases because demand is so fleeting
that it is not cost effective
– Video stores accept that a certain amount of dissatisfaction must exist when customers
cannot rent the movies they desire
– Video stores have to impose late fees that seem outrageously high to ensure that their
videos are returned in order to maintain their ability to predict whether or not they will
be able to rent a given movie to a customer that desires it
• How has Netflix eliminated the need to manage dissatisfaction?
– The video queue
• Eliminates customers realization that they aren’t getting the movie they wanted
when there aren’t any available copies in inventory
• Allows customers to store movies they want to see rather then deciding every time
they enter a store
12. Netflix by Mail – Eliminating Managed
Dissatisfaction
• How has Netflix eliminated the need to manage dissatisfaction?
– The change in Blockbuster film preferences
• In video stores 80% of the movies rented come from 200 “blockbuster”
titles at any given time
• Due to the Netflix Cinematch system this preferences for blockbusters
was changed so that 80% of all movies came from 2000 titles
• With less demand for extremely popular films Netflix could carry less
copies of new releases and still provide a much higher number of people
with their first choice of movie
– The subscription service
• Completely eliminated late fees and thus eliminated another reason
customers could be dissatisfied
• Eliminates the guilt felt by customers who are late returning movies
13. Netflix Streaming (2006)
SET Factors
Product Opportunity Gap
So we’ve made it easier to get DVDs without leaving your home… now it’s time we let
you get movies without needing a DVD…
Technology:
Expansion of Bandwidth
that would allow for
quality image streaming
with minimal (or no)
buffering
Social and Economic:
Advent of the
“staycation”
14. The Importance of Bandwidth
to Netflix’s success
Technology:
Expansion of Bandwidth that would
allow for quality image streaming with
minimal (or no) buffering
“We took our spreadsheets and we figured
we’d get 14 megabits/sec to the home by 2012,
which turns out is about what we will get… If
you drag it out to 2021, we will all have a
gigabit to the home.” -R Hastings, CEO
15. Netflix Streaming: Features
Crushing managed dissatisfaction one stream at a
time…
•Unlimited Streaming of both movies and TV
shows for a monthly subscription fee (can
select a plan with just streaming or can
combine with DVD-by-mail)
•Cinematch uses the survey as well as your
previously viewed material to help you find
more TV shows or movies for you to stream
•New contract will allow users to stream
DreamWorks films (2013); continuously
trying to expand streaming content
•Exclusive Streaming Content
•Lillyhammer
•House of Cards (2012)
•New episodes of Arrested Development
(2013)
“Binge Watching”
16. Netflix Streaming – Creating Unlimited Availability
• One of the major focuses of
Netflix is to make their service
available across as many
platforms as possible and to limit
their development cost in the
process
• In 2008 Netflix made their
application programming
interface (API) available to the
public allowing device makers to
program their own Netflix apps
• Netflix claims there service is
available on over 700 devices
today
17. Brand Management and the Envelope
• The Netflix brand is mostly centered around trust
• The red envelope has changed the emotions associated with video
renting from guilt and disappointment to excitement and
anticipation making a walk to your mailbox seem like Christmas
morning
18. Let’s Play a Game…
Amazon Prime
•Yearly Subscription
•Available on fewer devices
•Late in the game; trying to
play “catch-up”
•2000 titles
Xfinity Streaming
•Must have Xfinity and already be paying for
their cable service
•Limited archive, often has the “current”
shows but not “last season” shows
Cable “On Demand”
•Menu can be difficult to navigate
•Limited archive
•Most movies are pay-per-view; free movies are limited
to TV movies; can get movies with
HBO/Cinemax/Starz, but these are premium channels
for most cable plans
•Talk of Netflix partnering with cable companies
•Commercials; fast forward may be locked
Network Apps
•Only TV shows
•Each network has their
own app
•Limited archive
•Commercials
Walmart Streaming (“Vudu”)
•Purchased, not created
•Pay-per-view; limited selection of free videos
•Rumors of Walmart breaking into this business
were around in 2001; Vudu purchase in 2011 (10
year gap)
Blockbuster Streaming
•Blockbuster “Freedom Pass” tried to
compete with Netflix subscription, but
barely made a dent in Netflix’s success
•Talks of Blockbuster streaming service
has been around for a while and it has
only recently gotten off the ground
19. Qwikster: Sign of Demise or a Small Blemish?
• Lost 800,000 subscribers in the third quarter
• Regained 600,000 subscribers by Dec 31st 2011
(2/3 of those lost)
• Currently trading $101.15; dropped to around $64
through December 2011 but then has been going
up since then and consistently between $100-
$120
Too much too soon?
• Weaning customers in: isn’t that
incremental innovation?
• Was the Qwikster brand too undeveloped
for marketing?
Was it really as stupid as people say it was?
• Now that we’ve been studying Netflix’s business,
we can appreciate that these are different
companies; perhaps the true issue was
communication with the subscribers
Phasing out DVDs
• People are speculating that this was
partly to phase out the DVD
service; was this the right action for
the desired results?
20. The Qwikster Failure
• Why should a separation of the mail and streaming businesses work?
– The business strategy for each services is becoming increasingly different
because the competitors for each product are totally different
– The costs associated with each product are not the same so the prices must
be different
– The streaming business is expected to completely take-over the mail service
eventually
– The information collected by Cinematch for the two services is almost
completely different
Editor's Notes
Netflix is not unlike Skype in that they aim to provide their service as cheaply as possible, to as many people as possible, and across as many devices as possible. In that sense, if we consider Skype to be a breakthrough company, we must consider Netflix to be a breakthrough company if their behavior shows a strong desire to focus on the customer and receive feedback from the customer
“CineMatch may not be as ambitious or as well executed as Amazon's engine, but it’s more effective, because customers are more likely to accept the suggestions. Amazon's tool has the
feel of a slick Circuit City salesman engaged in the hard sell. On Netflix, the recommendations are included in the cost of a subscription, making CineMatch seem more like the geeky clerk at a small video store. He sets aside titles he knows you'll like and tells you to return them whenever.”
Cinematch is the program responsible for customizing the Netflix experience for each user account, but another important output of the Cinematch product is that it also reminds the users that it is customizing for them and causes an increased perceived value of the product.
Mention how explaining the recommendations is key to maintaining the customers trust in Netflix
Eventually describe the output as Top10, Genres, and Similar
Netflix is down to 79% in 2011, and Amazon rose to 88%.
The loss of customer satisfaction with Netflix is one of the largest of any web-based firm ever reported by ForeSee in one year.
Netflix lost about 2 million subscribers
There is a limit to how much the customer-zation of the Netflix UI for each account can compensate for the relatively low amounts of premium content Netflix can provide when their users are on average paying 27 cents per hour of internet video
Netflix’s confidence with it’s knowledge of it’s consumer may have led to over-confidence in their control over their brand. When they effectively increased the price of their service they didn’t communicate the VO to the consumer and the consumer lost faith in the Netflix brand.
Hastings tells me that Netflix has its roots in a computer science course he took as a graduate student at Stanford. "The professor said, 'Never underestimate the bandwidth of a station wagon filled with backup tapes,'" Hastings remembers. Moving small bits of data at light speed can be far less efficient — and more expensive — than moving that information in bulk.
If we think about the mood and emotions of people who have decided to stay in and sit on their couch and watch a movie then we could easily determine that the task of going to a video store and being disappointed for a higher cost would be an inferior product experience to the Netflix experience.
“We took our spreadsheets and we figured we’d get 14 megabits/sec to the home by 2012, which turns out is about what we will get… If you drag it out to 2021, we will all have a gigabit to the home.”
Expansion of Bandwidth
Drastic difference between dial up and the newer alternatives
Could not support large video content
Netflix trick- reduces the quality enough that the image is still good but does not require as much bandwidth
Usage
Netflix streaming takes up much of the downstream usage
Shows customer loyalty, effectiveness of actual technology of streaming, etc
Why is it breakthrough?
Theme of “managed dissatisfaction” – ultimate goal was to allow people to get movies more conveniently. What is more convenient than instant access? Do not have to wait for mail and do not have to leave your home. Can stream both TV and movies.
Cinematch helps subscribers find more titles
Includes unique titles that you may not be able to get elsewhere (indy films)
Always trying to broaden the viewer experience- new contract with DreamWorks
Exclusive Streaming Content
Lillyhammer
Ex-gangster becomes part of the Witness Protection program for testifying against a mob boss and moves to Norway- doesn’t take long for him to get into trouble
House of Cards (2012)
Based on a British drama from the 90s. This is currently available; they are now remaking set against modern US politics
New episodes of Arrested Development (2013)
Popular TV show, last episodes in 2005- starting with a new season that will lead to a movie- used to be on Fox
“Binge watching”
I remember being sick in college and watching an entire season of a TV show
Can literally watch video all day if you want to
The API caused an explosion in app development for Netflix from availability on about 200 different devices in 2008 to over 700 devices in 2012
Bits of source code are available from Netflix to help programmers emulate the Netflix experience in their own programs and so that programmers can work with the data being processed output by Cinematch.
Hit how the customer owns the brand and the company manages it
Stats for subscribers during Qwikster change
Too much too soon?
I said that Netflix threw too much at the consumer at one time- increase price AND a new business model? No wonder consumers had a fit! They were overwhelmed. George commented that this is an “incremental” change, and Netflix is a breakthrough company. So where does we draw the line? Breakthrough has a high risk that customers will not accept the product. Is that what happened? Or did they blow it because incremental would have been more appropriate in this case?
The split caused the heaviest burden on the subscribers who use both DVD-by-mail and streaming; 12 million of its customers use both- which is nearly half of its subscribers
Complete split- not linked at all
Brand of Qwikster- undeveloped? We talked about brand management and how a product/brand could fail if it was not totally thought through; is this the case? Issue with the name of the service: someone has this name on Twitter already (epic social media fail)
Phasing out DVDs
Some speculations that Qwikster was the first step of phasing out the DVD service. If this is true, was this really the way to go?
Was it really as stupid as everyone says?
Business models truly are different
Change in Cinematch (ratings vs. detailed stats)
Communication with customers
Hastings did put out a more detailed explanation of how it would change, and even still Qwikster was abandoned
Ultimately, if no VALUE to customers great ideas are not successful.
Purchase of DVD.com (March 30) – speculation this is the spin off, part 2- more success? I didn’t notice…