SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 37
12M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E
R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3
T
his year the healthcare industry is expected
to account for 15.6% of GDP, and expendi-
tures for physician services are expected to
be $347.9 billion. A large part of that goes to
physician practices, and, because they are
such a large part of the economy, they represent an
opportunity for management accountants to assist
physicians in evaluating contracts with third-party pay-
ers and providing financial information for strategic
decisions. To do so, management accountants need to
understand the unique revenue, cost, and contractual
intricacies of physician practices.
While most businesses’ sources of revenue are sales
and fees, physician practices depend on the organiza-
tional structure of the healthcare revenue reimburse-
ment relationships among provider, patient, and
third-party insurer. Revenue reimbursements can come
from indemnity, preferred provider organizations
(PPOs), and/or healthcare maintenance organizations
(HMOs). In particular, to advise a physician or evaluate
profits, a management accountant must understand the
relationships between a practice’s revenues and its costs.
Because these revenue reimburseme nts are contractual-
ly determined, controlling costs is critical to the survival
of a physician’s practice. A management accountant can
help a physician calculate costs, select the appropriate
cost structure to manage costs, and help make tough
strategic decisions about the financial future of the prac-
tice. Once a management accountant understands the
source of revenues and the cost constraints, he or she
can then help a physician evaluate a revenue reimburse-
ment contract. For example, if the contract is from an
indemnity plan or a PPO, evaluation is relatively
straightforward if the management accountant under-
stands a practice’s organizational structures and cost con-
trol. But if the revenue comes from an HMO capitation
contract—that is, a fixed rate of payment to cover a
specified set of health services and procedures—
evaluating the contract requires additional analysis
because revenues are based on anticipated services.
P H YS I C I A N G R O U P R E V E N U E S
In order to consult with a physician group, a manage-
ment accountant must have a good understanding of
How Management
Accountants Make
Physicians’ Practices
More Profitable
Spring
2005
VOL.6 NO.3
Spring
2005
THE KEY TO PROFITABILITY IS TO USE COST ANALYSIS
BY DETERMINING A PRACTICE’S
COST STRUCTURE AND USING THOSE COSTS TO
EVALUATE CONTRACTS, ALLOCATE
BONUSES EQUITABLY, AND MAKE STRATEGIC
DECISIONS ABOUT THE FINANCIAL FUTURE
OF THE PRACTICE GROUP.
B Y M A R S H A S C H E I D T , D B A , C M A , A N D G
R E G T H I B A D O U X , P H . D .
13M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E
R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3
the sources of practice revenues. As noted previously,
there are three types of organizational structures for
healthcare: indemnity, PPOs, and HMOs. Each organi-
zational structure utilizes distinct methods of revenue
reimbursement: Indemnity uses fee for service, PPOs
use discounted fee for service, and HMOs use salaries,
capitation, and other financial controls.
Indemnity Plans
Under an indemnity plan, physicians historically have
been reimbursed primarily through third-party payers
such as insurance companies. The actual payers—
consumers and businesses—have insurance companies
handle reimbursement for two reasons. First, the insur-
ance company is able to handle the overwhelming
administration of the plan more efficiently, and, second,
it can spread the financial risk over a large pool of indi -
viduals. These plans are called indemnity because they
reimburse physicians after services are rendered, and
the reimbursement method is known as fee for service.
Payment is production based: the more services provid-
ed, the greater the revenues to the physician. Because
the payer is responsible for the cost of the services, the
payer assumes the financial risk. Notice that under an
indemnity plan there are no ties between the payer
(insurance company) and the provider (physician).
But spiraling physician costs led payers to institute
managed care plans that, for the first time, linked physi-
cians who provided medical services with the parties
who paid for those services. Under managed healthcare,
third-party payers, including insurance companies and
the federal government in some of its Medicare and
Medicaid programs, would control the flow of monies
by third-party payers to providers. It also dictated the
number of services that could be provided to the
patient, who could provide those services, and how
much physicians and hospitals would be paid for those
services. The strongest form of managed care is the
HMO, and the weakest is the PPO.
PPOs
In response to rising medical costs during the 1970s,
insurance companies developed a form of payment
known as the PPO. This type of healthcare plan differs
from traditional indemnity insurance in that payments
to physicians are based on a reduced fee schedule, dis-
counted from 10% to 40%. Other controls, such as larger
co-payments and deductibles for out-of-network ser-
vices, are instituted by third-party payers to encourage
patients to use PPO networks.
The system is, however, still production oriented like
traditional indemnity plans. Because revenues are relat-
ed to the number of services provided, PPOs are basical -
ly a form of discounted fee for service. Although PPOs
are less costly than indemnity plans, the payer is still
responsible for the cost of the services and assumes the
financial risk. Today, discounted fee for service plans are
the dominant method of revenue reimbursement.
HMOs
Unlike indemnity and PPO reimbursement plans, the
HMO links the payer and provider together as a team
to guide the patient through the healthcare system.
The HMO collects a premium from the enrolled mem-
ber and contracts with him or her to provide the neces-
sary healthcare services during the period of
enrollment. The HMO then contracts with the physi-
cians and pays them to provide the anticipated services
as needed for the period of enrollment. By agreeing to
accept reimbursement on a prospective basis, the
provider assumes the financial risk for the cost of future
services. Physician revenue reimbursement in an HMO
network is more complex and may be in the form of
salary, capitation, and/or other financial controls.
Salary is used frequently in HMOs. Straight salaries
are used in more than 10% of the groups, and guaran-
teed base salaries are used by about 20%. Under indem-
nity or PPO structures, salaries are used only in certain
scenarios or sectors, such as the Veterans Administration
or, possibly, a hospital for a doctor such as a hospitalist. A
hospitalist is an inpatient physician who directs the flow
of care for hospitalized patients and is paid by the hospi -
tal. HMOs have much greater financial control because
they provide the physician with either a salary or bonus-
es tied to the HMO’s physician productivity goals.
HMO capitation is a method of physician revenue
reimbursement based on a negotiated contract. The
provider receives a set amount of revenue calculated
per member per month for providing the necessary ser-
vices during the covered period of time. The capitation
14M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E
R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3
rate is commonly a fixed amount per member per
month. Most HMO capitation rate calculations take
members’ actuarial data, such as age, gender, geography,
and historical utilization rates, and costs to serve mem-
bers into account to predict the expected costs of ser-
vices. The HMO will then determine the average
monthly cost of services and an average cost of services
on a per member per month basis, which is the capita-
tion rate. Each month, the total revenue reimbursement
to the physician is the per member per month rate
times the number of members actually enrolled for the
month. This per member per month payment means
that a physician is obligated to provide specified ser -
vices to enrolled members as frequently as necessary. If
a member uses more services than expected, the physi-
cian usually is not paid an additional amount. Likewise,
if a member uses fewer services, the physician does not
refund the capitated amount.
HMO contracts for revenue reimbursement may also
include other financial controls, such as withholds
and/or bonuses. These controls are the two major types
of incentives designed to influence physician behavior
regarding ancillary services, such as laboratory tests and
referrals to specialists. A withhold involves keeping a
percentage of the capitation fee to be released only if
the physician group attains HMO productivity goals.
Withholds invoke partner risk, which is the possibility
that one physician’s performance will negatively affect
the group’s compensation. Another financial incentive
HMOs may use is bonuses based on the productivity
and quality of services the physicians provide.
P H YS I C I A N G R O U P S E R V I C E CO S T
Medical office management has changed significantly
with the implementation of managed care. Today physi-
cians operate primarily in a managed care environment,
receiving reimbursement for their services based on
PPO and/or HMO contractual relationships or in the
form of salary an HMO pays. It is estimated that about
85% of all patients today participate in some form of
managed care. Prior to managed care, physician billing
was based on the actual number and type of procedures
performed on patients and was known as fee for service.
In this type of financial environment, physicians’ rev-
enue was related directly to the number of procedures
and services they provided. The more the physician did
to the patient in terms of diagnostic and treatment pro-
cedures, the greater the revenue. In a fee-for-service
environment, low profit margins or, in some cases, nega-
tive profit margins could be offset by increasing the vol -
ume of other, more profitable services and procedures.
In essence, the actual cost of providing a service was
not particularly relevant as long as the physician group
could control the volume of all services provided. This
is not the case today because most physicians receive
reimbursement based on discounted PPO rates and
fixed capitation HMO contracts. Under these systems it
becomes crucial that the physician group knows the
cost of providing services in relation to the revenue
generated by those services.
For example, in a PPO contract, certain procedures
and office visits will provide much higher profit margins
than others. A surgeon might find that one type of
surgery is much more profitable than another even
though he or she may feel that each required a similar
amount of time, expertise, and diligence. Also under a
capitation contract, the fewer services rendered, the
greater the profit margin because, as noted above, rev-
enues do not vary with the volume of services per-
formed, only with the number of enrolled members. As
revenues are determined only by the number of
enrollees, profit margins will depend on how well the
group is able to control costs. In essence, the more ser-
vices and time spent per patient than is medically pru-
dent, the lower the profit margin.
Therefore, under managed care it is crucial that the
physician group knows the relative cost of its physi-
cians’ time and procedures to be able to make
informed decisions about how it wants to focus its prac-
tice. For example, a surgery group may make a strate-
gic decision based in part on financial considerations to
concentrate its efforts on a well-defined group of
patients. In order to make informed financial-based
decisions, physicians need crucial information about
the cost structures of their practice that management
accountants can provide.
D E T E R M I N I N G T H E CO S T O F S E R V I C E S
To make informed decisions about contracts or the
strategic direction of the practice, physicians need, at a
15M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E
R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3
minimum, information about the average cost of ser-
vices they provide. In fact, to evaluate the contract
effectively, physicians should know the average cost of
services, the marginal costs of treating the new patients,
and whether any additional fixed costs will be incurred
by accepting the contract.
Traditionally, physician groups have tracked costs on
a line-item basis by classifying costs in functional cate-
gories such as salary, equipment costs, depreciation, cost
of materials, and drugs. Unfortunately, this type of
information is not particularly useful in relating a prac-
tice’s costs to the services it provides. In fact, for any
cost accounting system to be effective it must fulfill the
following criteria:
◆A product must be carefully defined,
◆The type and quantity of inputs required for prod-
ucts must be defined, and
◆The costs must be attached to the inputs and the
product costed out.
Traditionally, physician groups have been concerned
only with tracking costs on a line-item basis, so there
has been no effective way to attach these costs to the
services produced. The problem is that, under this sys-
tem of accounting, there has been no defined product
measure, no measure of inputs, and no way to attach
the cost of inputs to the product. Fortunately, all this
changed in 1992, when Medicare changed the way it
reimbursed for physician services. Instead of paying on
a fee-for-service basis, it began to base its payment on a
resource-based relative value scale system. Under this
methodology, the amount of payment is tied to the
amount of resources that are expected to be used to
provide the service rendered. The actual product, ser -
vice, or office visit rendered is defined by the CPT
(common procedural terminology) code, the accepted
procedural codes used to bill patients. Each CPT code
represents an office visit, a service provided, a lab test,
or a procedure.
Relative value units (RVU) are the inputs required to
provide the service. A relative value unit takes into
account the amount of physician work required to pro-
vide the service, the practice expense, and the expense
of liability insurance. The code values were created rel -
ative to value of a standard office visit, which has a code
value of 1.00 RVU. A code allowing reimbursement for
four RVUs implies that it took an average of four times
more effort and cost to provide that service.
Today, most physician software billing systems will
allow the practice to link its billing codes to a database
that contains the number of RVUs allowed for each pro-
cedural billing code. By using such software, the prac-
tice can keep a running total of the number of RVUs
generated for any time period. The management
accountant can use these RVU totals to calculate the
cost per RVU and then calculate the cost per procedure
provided. For example, if it is determined that an aver-
age RVU costs $30 to provide, then an uncomplicated
office visit with an RVU of one would cost $30. In sum-
mary, by costing out the inputs (RVUs) required to pro-
duce a service (CPT code), a management accountant
can determine the actual cost to the practice of provid-
ing that service. This information can then be used to
evaluate PPO and capitation contracts and to make
strategic decisions.
Calculating Costs
To carry out an analysis of costs, the management
accountant must first calculate the average and marginal
costs per RVU. With the number of RVUs required by
the contract per CPT code known, a management
accountant can calculate the total average cost and the
total marginal cost per CPT code. He or she can use
this information to help the physicians make informed
decisions.
The following is a discussion of the steps required to
analyze physician group practice costs.
Step 1. Calculate the average and marginal costs per
RVU.
In cost accounting, there are two primary methods for
analyzing costs: the high-low method and regression.
The high-low method is an approximation based on two
points, and regression is a statistical method requiring at
least 30 points and one or more independent variables.
Because medical practices typically do not capture
information that lends itself to regression analysis, the
high-low method is usually more appropriate. We will
use it to illustrate a cost analysis, as follows.
High-low cost analysis of monthly data requires sev-
eral procedures.
16M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E
R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3
Procedure 1. Determine the Variable Cost for the Production of
One RVU:
a. Select the high production (the month with the
highest volume of RVUs).
b. Select the low production (the month with the
lowest volume of RVUs).
c. Subtract the difference between the total cost
incurred during the highest production (Y2) and
the total cost incurred during the lowest produc-
tion (Y1). Total costs will include all costs of the
practice, such as salary, depreciation, insurance,
drugs, supplies, etc.
d. Take the difference between the total RVUs
incurred during the highest production (X2) and
the total RVUs incurred during the lowest
production (X1).
e. Divide step c (the cost difference) by step d (the
RVUs difference).
f. The result is the variable cost for one RVU.
Procedure 2. Determine the Total Fixed Costs:
a. Take the total cost incurred during the highest pro-
duction (Y2) and subtract the estimated total vari-
able costs for the highest production (total variable
costs equals the variable cost per RVU times the
number of RVUs).
b. The remainder is the total fixed cost.
Procedure 3. Determine the Total Cost Formula:
Total Costs = Total Fixed Costs plus (variable cost
per RVU times number of RVUs).
Procedure 4. Calculate the Average and Marginal Costs per
RVU:
The average cost per RVU is calculated as follows:
Using the total cost formula determined in Procedure
3 and the number of RVUs expected, a management
accountant can calculate total costs expected for that
level of RVUs. The average cost per RVU is simply
the total costs as calculated above divided by the
expected level of RVUs. The marginal cost per RVU is
the incremental costs of producing an RVU. At a mini-
mum, marginal costs are the variable cost per RVU as
calculated in Procedure 1(f). If a new contract requires
additional fixed or variable costs, then those incremen-
tal costs will be averaged over the new contract RVUs
and increase the marginal costs.
Step 2. Determine the number of RVUs required.
The contract will specify the number of RVUs per ser-
vice CPT code. The number of RVUs allowed will be
defined by the contract under consideration or the gov-
ernmental healthcare reimbursement scheme, such as
Medicare.
Step 3. Calculate the total average cost and the total
marginal cost per CPT code.
The full cost of a visit or procedure is calculated by
multiplying the average cost per RVU times the num-
ber of RVUs that are allowed per procedure. The mar-
ginal cost of a visit or procedure is simply the variable
costs per RVU times the number of RVUs that are
allowed per procedure.
Step 4. Assist the physicians in using these costs
appropriately in making informed decisions.
Management accountants can provide a wealth of infor-
mation to physicians to assist them in evaluating con-
tracts and making strategic decisions.
The following is an example of the four steps man-
agement accountants can use to analyze a physician’s
practice.
Assume that during 20X1, U.R. Well, P.C.’s costs
were historical $672,000 when 10,000 RVUs were pro-
duced and $782,000 when 12,000 RVUs were produced.
Step 1. Calculate the average and marginal costs per
RVU.
Procedure 1. Determine the Variable Cost for the Production of
One RVU:
Y2 – Y1 = $782,000 – $672,000 = $110,000
X2 – X1 = 12,000 RVUs – 10,000 RVUs = 2,000 RVUs
Variable cost per unit = Cost difference divided by
production difference
= $110,000 ÷ 2,000 RVUs = $55 per RVU
Procedure 2. Determine the Total Fixed Costs:
Fixed Costs = $782,000 – ($55 * 12,000 RVUs)
= $782,000 – $660,000 = $122,000
17M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E
R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3
Procedure 3. Determine the Total Cost Formula:
Total Costs = Total Fixed Costs plus (variable cost
per RVU times number of RVUs).
Total = $122,000 + $55 per RVU times number of
RVUs
Procedure 4. Calculate the average and marginal cost per proce-
dure. The average cost per relative value unit is deter -
mined using the projected number of RVUs for the
coming month in the above formula. For example, if
during the coming month it is expected that the prac-
tice will generate 11,000 RVUs, the average cost would
be as follows:
Average cost per RVU = {$122,000 + ($55)(11,000)} ÷
11,000 RVUs = $66.09 per RVU.
The marginal cost per RVU is simply the variable
costs or $55.00 per RVU.
Step 2. Determine the number of RVUs required by
the contract per CPT code:
For example, the contract may state that a particular
CPT code allows six RVUs.
Step 3. Calculate the total average cost and the total
marginal cost per CPT code.
The cost per procedure is the cost per RVU times the
number of relative value units allowed per procedure.
For example, if a procedure allows six RVUs then the
average cost for the procedure would be 6 * $66.09 =
$396.55, and the marginal costs would be 6 * $55 =
$330.00.
Step 4. Assist the physicians in using these costs
appropriately to make informed decisions.
The management accountant can help the physician
group make informed financial decisions about poten-
tial contracts. The nature of the decision will depend
on whether it is a PPO or HMO contract under
consideration.
CO N S I D E R AT I O N S O F CA P I TAT I O N CO N T R
AC T
Once the cost of the RVU has been calculated, this
information can be used to evaluate PPO contracts. If
the group is operating at full capacity, then any addi-
tional contracts either will have to replace existing con-
tracts or will require the practice to expand. In order to
justify accepting a contract, the proposed reimburse-
ment per procedure should generate an acceptable mar-
gin in excess of the average practice cost per procedure.
Any reimbursement less than the average cost per pro-
cedure will result in lower margins and will endanger
the recovery of fixed costs. If the practice is considering
adding physicians, the contracts must provide adequate
volume and reimbursement to cover these incremental
costs. In any case, if the group does not receive a fair
recovery of its cost in delivering its services, the other
considerations of the contract are irrelevant.
If the practice is operating at less than full capacity,
the contract must provide reimbursement in excess of
the marginal costs per procedure. In this situation, the
group may be willing to forego expected profit margins
in order to cover existing fixed costs. In either case, a
physician practice cannot make an informed decision
without the type of cost information that only a man-
agement accountant can provide.
Additionally, the RVU cost data for a physician’s group
can be used as a method for allocating bonuses based pri -
marily on PPO revenues. When a physician group
receives the bulk of its revenues from a PPO, it may dis-
tribute bonuses equitably based on office productivity.
Typically, physicians receive salaries from the practice
and share in year-end bonuses if the practice has a net
profit and if they are partners in the medical group. Allo-
cation of such bonuses can be a point of contention in a
partnership. This problem can be especially troublesome
if the relationship between physician-generated revenues
and their associated costs are unknown. Allocating profits
based on the ratio of physician revenue to total practice
revenue or as a percentage of treated patients can be
grossly unfair, particularly if there are significant differ -
ences among the physicians based on either the type of
patients they treat or services they perform. This prob-
lem can exist in a single specialty group if physicians
have different preferences in regard to types of patients
they treat. The problem will always exist in a multispe-
cialty practice setting where physicians with different
specialties are practicing.
With the same software used to calculate RVU costs,
the management accountant can track the total RVUs
generated over any time frame by each physician. The
18M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E
R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3
ratio of physician RVUs to total practice RVUs is an
excellent measure of productivity and can—at least in
part—be used as a measure for determining year-end
bonuses. Alternatively, one could calculate the gross
margin generated by each physician:
Revenue per physician – (Physician RVUs * average
cost per RVU) = Gross margin per physician.
This is a much more equitable method for allocating
bonuses than simply an equal distribution.
CONSIDERATIONS OF A CAPITATION CONTRACT
A physician’s profit management under an HMO capita-
tion contract is unique to the healthcare industry. Man-
agement accountants and physicians are more attuned to
analysis for discounted fee for service or salary revenues,
but capitation is a totally different scenario.
Evaluation on an HMO capitated contract requires
both financial evaluation of the capitation rate and
examination of the procedural aspects of the contract.
There are two factors to consider in a capitation rate: (1)
the structure of the plan and (2) the practice’s costs of
the covered services.
Financial Evaluation
The structure of the relationship between the HMO
and a practice depends on whether the contract
involves a closed HMO network or point-of-service
providers. In a closed HMO network, enrolled mem-
bers will have no out-of-network coverage, only pre-
authorized services, fixed-dollar copayments, and
service limits. In an HMO with a point-of-service
option, patients may utilize network and out-of-network
physicians and some nonauthorized services with per-
centage copayments. Because of out-of-network utiliza-
tion, deductibles, and copayment variation, the
capitation rate is more difficult to calculate for point of
service. One factor in analyzing the capitation rate is
that both copayments and deductibles are subtracted
from the service cost, so the lower the copayment or
deductible level, the higher the capitation rate. An
increase in either will decrease utilization. Management
accountants will need to be able to discuss in broad
terms how these various factors will impact the practice
financially.
The second factor in analyzing the capitation rate
is the cost of the covered services from the practice’s
perspective. In determining the number of covered
services, the management accountant should provide
the group with a rough estimate of the costs that
may be incurred in providing medical treatment for
the enrolled population. This will involve projecting
the number of procedures that will be provided to
the enrolled population times the average cost per
procedure. In order to do this, the management
accountant will have to make use of historical data
generated by the group from previous capitation
contracts or may need to work with other consultants
such as actuaries.
Procedural Issues
After the management accountant has determined the
financial viability of the capitation contract, he or she
may also want to consider procedural issues such as
terms of the contract, risks, and reporting requirements.
While a management accountant will not have all the
needed expertise to evaluate these issues, he or she
should be aware of their importance for evaluating any
potential contract. Capitation contract terms should
include:
a. Clearly stated terms and conditions for payment.
b. Definitions of how patient eligibility is to be deter-
mined. Determination of when and who is eligible
should be assumed by the payer, preferably online
and in real-time.
c. Requirement that the payer provide a policies and
procedures manual and agree to revisions by mutual
consent only.
d. Specification of how and when rates may be
renegotiated.
e. Allowance for terminations with and without cause.
“With cause” means a breach in the terms; “without
cause” means giving notice. Some obligations will
continue after termination, so it is important to
understand the provisions.
f. A requirement for a minimum amount of paperwork
and time to administer it.
g. Clear explanation how withholds and bonuses are to
be determined.
19M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E
R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3
CO S T AC C O U N T I N G N E E D E D
Today the majority of physician groups are dependent
for their revenues on third-party payers such as insur-
ance companies and state and federal governmental
healthcare organizations. Under managed care plans
such as PPOs and HMOs, the financial and strategic
success of physician group practices is dependent on
successful contract negotiation and cost control. In this
environment, management accountants have a vital role
to play in helping physicians determine the costs of the
services they provide and in assisting them in evaluat-
ing potential contracts. Management accountants can
provide these services by using traditional cost account-
ing techniques such as cost-volume-profit analysis and
product costing. Today most physicians have software
in place that can provide a wealth of useful but under-
utilized information for anyone with appropriate analyti -
cal skills. ■
Marsha Scheidt, DBA, CMA, is a UC professor in account-
ing at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga. She can be
reached at (423) 425-2112 or [email protected]
Greg Thibadoux, Ph.D., is a professor in accounting at the
University of Tennessee at Chattanooga. He can be reached
at (423) 425-4408 or [email protected]
Sample Physician RVU analysis.
To carry out an analysis of costs, the management accountant
must first calculate the average and marginal
costs per RVU. With the number of RVUs required by the
contract per CPT code known, a management
accountant can calculate the total average cost and the total
marginal cost per CPT code. He or she can use
this information to help the physicians make informed
decisions.
Example of Calculations
Assume that during 2016, XYZ P.C.s costs were historical
$672,000 when 10,000 RVUs were produced and $782,000 when
12,000 RVUs were produced.
Step 1.
a) Calculate the average and marginal costs per RVU.
Y2 – Y1 = $782,000 – $672,000 = $110,000
X2 – X1 = 12,000 RVUs – 10,000 RVUs = 2,000 RVUs
b) Calculate the variable cost per unit
Cost difference divided by production difference =
$110,000 ÷ 2,000 RVUs = $55 per RVU
c) Calculate the total fixed costs.
Fixed Costs = $782,000 – ($55 * 12,000 RVUs)
= $782,000 – $660,000 = $122,000
d) Calculate total costs
Total fixed costs + (variable cost per RVU times number of
RVUs).
Total = $122,000 + ($55 * 12,000 RVUs)
=$122,000 + 660,000 = $782,000
e) Calculate average cost per RVU
The average cost per relative value unit is determined using the
projected number of RVUs for the
coming month in the above formula. For example, if during the
coming month it is expected that the practice will generate
11,000 RVUs, the average cost would be as follows:
Average cost per RVU = {$122,000 + ($55)(11,000)} ÷ 11,000
RVUs = $66.09 per RVU.
The marginal cost per RVU is simply the variable costs or
$55.00 per RVU.
Step 2. Determine the number of RVUs required by the contract
per CPT code:
For example, the contract may state that a particular CPT code
allows six RVUs.
Step 3. Calculate the total average cost and the total marginal
cost per CPT code.
The cost per procedure is the cost per RVU times the number of
relative value units allowed per procedure.
For example, if a procedure allows six RVUs then the average
cost for the procedure would be 6 * $66.09 =
$396.55, and the marginal costs would be 6 * $55 = $330.00.
Step 4. Assist the physicians in using these costs appropriately
to make informed decisions.
The management accountant can help the physician group make
informed financial decisions about potential
contracts. The nature of the decision will depend on whether it
is a PPO or HMO contract under consideration.

More Related Content

Similar to 12M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y

Health and Mediclaim policies
Health and Mediclaim policiesHealth and Mediclaim policies
Health and Mediclaim policiesBhavikd7
 
Healthcare ReimbursementI need help on the following assignment C.docx
Healthcare ReimbursementI need help on the following assignment C.docxHealthcare ReimbursementI need help on the following assignment C.docx
Healthcare ReimbursementI need help on the following assignment C.docxCristieHolcomb793
 
Hello, I need assistance with the following I need assistance.docx
Hello, I need assistance with the following I need assistance.docxHello, I need assistance with the following I need assistance.docx
Hello, I need assistance with the following I need assistance.docxisaachwrensch
 
Myanmar Strategic Purchasing 2: Calculating a Capitation Payment
Myanmar Strategic Purchasing 2: Calculating a Capitation PaymentMyanmar Strategic Purchasing 2: Calculating a Capitation Payment
Myanmar Strategic Purchasing 2: Calculating a Capitation PaymentHFG Project
 
Current System Issues and Their ImpactsIntroductionBefore we .docx
Current System Issues and Their ImpactsIntroductionBefore we .docxCurrent System Issues and Their ImpactsIntroductionBefore we .docx
Current System Issues and Their ImpactsIntroductionBefore we .docxalanrgibson41217
 
Pendulum Physician ACO
Pendulum Physician ACOPendulum Physician ACO
Pendulum Physician ACOBill DeMarco
 
1. Responsibility accounting in modern health care organization is.docx
1. Responsibility accounting in modern health care organization is.docx1. Responsibility accounting in modern health care organization is.docx
1. Responsibility accounting in modern health care organization is.docxjackiewalcutt
 
I need the follwoing assignmentThe project is the creation of a w.docx
I need the follwoing assignmentThe project is the creation of a w.docxI need the follwoing assignmentThe project is the creation of a w.docx
I need the follwoing assignmentThe project is the creation of a w.docxnatishahaen
 
Healthcare domain PPT
Healthcare domain PPTHealthcare domain PPT
Healthcare domain PPTDivya Tadi
 
QuestionIn what settings is UCR utilized Do you think the .docx
QuestionIn what settings is UCR utilized Do you think the .docxQuestionIn what settings is UCR utilized Do you think the .docx
QuestionIn what settings is UCR utilized Do you think the .docxcatheryncouper
 
Change the Future Today
Change the Future TodayChange the Future Today
Change the Future TodayGmoney4307
 
An Investigation of the Factors Affecting Capitation Programme in Provision ...
	An Investigation of the Factors Affecting Capitation Programme in Provision ...	An Investigation of the Factors Affecting Capitation Programme in Provision ...
An Investigation of the Factors Affecting Capitation Programme in Provision ...inventionjournals
 
Read the scenario that you will use for the Individual Projects in ea.pdf
Read the scenario that you will use for the Individual Projects in ea.pdfRead the scenario that you will use for the Individual Projects in ea.pdf
Read the scenario that you will use for the Individual Projects in ea.pdfashokarians
 
Clinical Co-Management Arrangements: Trends, Issues and FMV Considerations
Clinical Co-Management Arrangements: Trends, Issues and FMV ConsiderationsClinical Co-Management Arrangements: Trends, Issues and FMV Considerations
Clinical Co-Management Arrangements: Trends, Issues and FMV ConsiderationsCBIZ, Inc.
 
Medicare Advantage 3 Day Rule and Funds Flow White Paper
Medicare Advantage 3 Day Rule and Funds Flow White PaperMedicare Advantage 3 Day Rule and Funds Flow White Paper
Medicare Advantage 3 Day Rule and Funds Flow White PaperAlex Valdes, CPA
 
Financial mana of healthcare 7th lec
Financial mana of healthcare  7th lec Financial mana of healthcare  7th lec
Financial mana of healthcare 7th lec Mahmoud Shaqria
 
Revenue Cycle Management: Market Dynamics & Opportunities in a Changing Healt...
Revenue Cycle Management: Market Dynamics & Opportunities in a Changing Healt...Revenue Cycle Management: Market Dynamics & Opportunities in a Changing Healt...
Revenue Cycle Management: Market Dynamics & Opportunities in a Changing Healt...Cognizant
 

Similar to 12M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y (20)

Health and Mediclaim policies
Health and Mediclaim policiesHealth and Mediclaim policies
Health and Mediclaim policies
 
Healthcare ReimbursementI need help on the following assignment C.docx
Healthcare ReimbursementI need help on the following assignment C.docxHealthcare ReimbursementI need help on the following assignment C.docx
Healthcare ReimbursementI need help on the following assignment C.docx
 
Hello, I need assistance with the following I need assistance.docx
Hello, I need assistance with the following I need assistance.docxHello, I need assistance with the following I need assistance.docx
Hello, I need assistance with the following I need assistance.docx
 
Myanmar Strategic Purchasing 2: Calculating a Capitation Payment
Myanmar Strategic Purchasing 2: Calculating a Capitation PaymentMyanmar Strategic Purchasing 2: Calculating a Capitation Payment
Myanmar Strategic Purchasing 2: Calculating a Capitation Payment
 
Current System Issues and Their ImpactsIntroductionBefore we .docx
Current System Issues and Their ImpactsIntroductionBefore we .docxCurrent System Issues and Their ImpactsIntroductionBefore we .docx
Current System Issues and Their ImpactsIntroductionBefore we .docx
 
Pendulum Physician ACO
Pendulum Physician ACOPendulum Physician ACO
Pendulum Physician ACO
 
1. Responsibility accounting in modern health care organization is.docx
1. Responsibility accounting in modern health care organization is.docx1. Responsibility accounting in modern health care organization is.docx
1. Responsibility accounting in modern health care organization is.docx
 
I need the follwoing assignmentThe project is the creation of a w.docx
I need the follwoing assignmentThe project is the creation of a w.docxI need the follwoing assignmentThe project is the creation of a w.docx
I need the follwoing assignmentThe project is the creation of a w.docx
 
Healthcare domain PPT
Healthcare domain PPTHealthcare domain PPT
Healthcare domain PPT
 
QuestionIn what settings is UCR utilized Do you think the .docx
QuestionIn what settings is UCR utilized Do you think the .docxQuestionIn what settings is UCR utilized Do you think the .docx
QuestionIn what settings is UCR utilized Do you think the .docx
 
Change the Future Today
Change the Future TodayChange the Future Today
Change the Future Today
 
An Investigation of the Factors Affecting Capitation Programme in Provision ...
	An Investigation of the Factors Affecting Capitation Programme in Provision ...	An Investigation of the Factors Affecting Capitation Programme in Provision ...
An Investigation of the Factors Affecting Capitation Programme in Provision ...
 
Read the scenario that you will use for the Individual Projects in ea.pdf
Read the scenario that you will use for the Individual Projects in ea.pdfRead the scenario that you will use for the Individual Projects in ea.pdf
Read the scenario that you will use for the Individual Projects in ea.pdf
 
Transitional care ceu
Transitional care ceu Transitional care ceu
Transitional care ceu
 
Ac os
Ac osAc os
Ac os
 
PAYMENT MODELS
PAYMENT MODELSPAYMENT MODELS
PAYMENT MODELS
 
Clinical Co-Management Arrangements: Trends, Issues and FMV Considerations
Clinical Co-Management Arrangements: Trends, Issues and FMV ConsiderationsClinical Co-Management Arrangements: Trends, Issues and FMV Considerations
Clinical Co-Management Arrangements: Trends, Issues and FMV Considerations
 
Medicare Advantage 3 Day Rule and Funds Flow White Paper
Medicare Advantage 3 Day Rule and Funds Flow White PaperMedicare Advantage 3 Day Rule and Funds Flow White Paper
Medicare Advantage 3 Day Rule and Funds Flow White Paper
 
Financial mana of healthcare 7th lec
Financial mana of healthcare  7th lec Financial mana of healthcare  7th lec
Financial mana of healthcare 7th lec
 
Revenue Cycle Management: Market Dynamics & Opportunities in a Changing Healt...
Revenue Cycle Management: Market Dynamics & Opportunities in a Changing Healt...Revenue Cycle Management: Market Dynamics & Opportunities in a Changing Healt...
Revenue Cycle Management: Market Dynamics & Opportunities in a Changing Healt...
 

More from EttaBenton28

1Comparing Humanistic-Existential Psychotherapy with Oth
1Comparing Humanistic-Existential Psychotherapy with Oth1Comparing Humanistic-Existential Psychotherapy with Oth
1Comparing Humanistic-Existential Psychotherapy with OthEttaBenton28
 
1Comment by Perjessy, Caroline Substan
1Comment by Perjessy, Caroline Substan1Comment by Perjessy, Caroline Substan
1Comment by Perjessy, Caroline SubstanEttaBenton28
 
1College Student’s DepressionJasmin LinthicumCours
1College Student’s DepressionJasmin LinthicumCours1College Student’s DepressionJasmin LinthicumCours
1College Student’s DepressionJasmin LinthicumCoursEttaBenton28
 
1Close Looking Analysis Visual ArtArtist’s Self-Portrait Analys
1Close Looking Analysis Visual ArtArtist’s Self-Portrait Analys1Close Looking Analysis Visual ArtArtist’s Self-Portrait Analys
1Close Looking Analysis Visual ArtArtist’s Self-Portrait AnalysEttaBenton28
 
1CLA1Xueyao DongWestcliff UniversityINT 501 EF
1CLA1Xueyao DongWestcliff UniversityINT 501 EF1CLA1Xueyao DongWestcliff UniversityINT 501 EF
1CLA1Xueyao DongWestcliff UniversityINT 501 EFEttaBenton28
 
1CJ 550 2-2 Milestone One Southern New Ha
1CJ 550 2-2 Milestone One        Southern New Ha1CJ 550 2-2 Milestone One        Southern New Ha
1CJ 550 2-2 Milestone One Southern New HaEttaBenton28
 
1CLA 1Every organization aims at achieving a cer
1CLA 1Every organization aims at achieving a cer1CLA 1Every organization aims at achieving a cer
1CLA 1Every organization aims at achieving a cerEttaBenton28
 
1CHAPTER ONEThe What and Why of BudgetingAn Introduction
1CHAPTER ONEThe What and Why of BudgetingAn Introduction1CHAPTER ONEThe What and Why of BudgetingAn Introduction
1CHAPTER ONEThe What and Why of BudgetingAn IntroductionEttaBenton28
 
1Child Development Observation and Reflection
1Child Development Observation and Reflection1Child Development Observation and Reflection
1Child Development Observation and ReflectionEttaBenton28
 
1CHAPTER4BUSINESS-LEVEL STRATEGYChapter 2The Exter
1CHAPTER4BUSINESS-LEVEL STRATEGYChapter 2The Exter1CHAPTER4BUSINESS-LEVEL STRATEGYChapter 2The Exter
1CHAPTER4BUSINESS-LEVEL STRATEGYChapter 2The ExterEttaBenton28
 
1CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, RADIOLOGICAL AND NUCLEAR (CBR
1CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, RADIOLOGICAL AND NUCLEAR (CBR1CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, RADIOLOGICAL AND NUCLEAR (CBR
1CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, RADIOLOGICAL AND NUCLEAR (CBREttaBenton28
 
1CHAPTER 01G L O B A L R E P O R T O N2G
1CHAPTER 01G L O B A L  R E P O R T  O N2G1CHAPTER 01G L O B A L  R E P O R T  O N2G
1CHAPTER 01G L O B A L R E P O R T O N2GEttaBenton28
 
1Child Growth and DevelopmentYohana MangiaficoHous
1Child Growth and DevelopmentYohana MangiaficoHous1Child Growth and DevelopmentYohana MangiaficoHous
1Child Growth and DevelopmentYohana MangiaficoHousEttaBenton28
 
1CHAPTER2THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTOPPORTUNITIES, THREATS
1CHAPTER2THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTOPPORTUNITIES, THREATS1CHAPTER2THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTOPPORTUNITIES, THREATS
1CHAPTER2THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTOPPORTUNITIES, THREATSEttaBenton28
 
1Chapter Two Literature ReviewStudents NameName of the
1Chapter Two Literature ReviewStudents NameName of the1Chapter Two Literature ReviewStudents NameName of the
1Chapter Two Literature ReviewStudents NameName of theEttaBenton28
 
1CHAPTER 6 CHINAChinaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J. (
1CHAPTER 6 CHINAChinaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J. (1CHAPTER 6 CHINAChinaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J. (
1CHAPTER 6 CHINAChinaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J. (EttaBenton28
 
1Chapter 9TelevisionBroadcast and Beyond2
1Chapter 9TelevisionBroadcast and Beyond21Chapter 9TelevisionBroadcast and Beyond2
1Chapter 9TelevisionBroadcast and Beyond2EttaBenton28
 
1CHAPTER 5 RUSSIARussiaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J.
1CHAPTER 5 RUSSIARussiaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J.1CHAPTER 5 RUSSIARussiaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J.
1CHAPTER 5 RUSSIARussiaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J.EttaBenton28
 
1Chapter 6Newspapers and the NewsReflections of a
1Chapter 6Newspapers and the NewsReflections of a1Chapter 6Newspapers and the NewsReflections of a
1Chapter 6Newspapers and the NewsReflections of aEttaBenton28
 
1CHAPTER 4 SOUTH AFRICA South AfricaConcepts to Know·
1CHAPTER 4 SOUTH AFRICA South AfricaConcepts to Know·1CHAPTER 4 SOUTH AFRICA South AfricaConcepts to Know·
1CHAPTER 4 SOUTH AFRICA South AfricaConcepts to Know·EttaBenton28
 

More from EttaBenton28 (20)

1Comparing Humanistic-Existential Psychotherapy with Oth
1Comparing Humanistic-Existential Psychotherapy with Oth1Comparing Humanistic-Existential Psychotherapy with Oth
1Comparing Humanistic-Existential Psychotherapy with Oth
 
1Comment by Perjessy, Caroline Substan
1Comment by Perjessy, Caroline Substan1Comment by Perjessy, Caroline Substan
1Comment by Perjessy, Caroline Substan
 
1College Student’s DepressionJasmin LinthicumCours
1College Student’s DepressionJasmin LinthicumCours1College Student’s DepressionJasmin LinthicumCours
1College Student’s DepressionJasmin LinthicumCours
 
1Close Looking Analysis Visual ArtArtist’s Self-Portrait Analys
1Close Looking Analysis Visual ArtArtist’s Self-Portrait Analys1Close Looking Analysis Visual ArtArtist’s Self-Portrait Analys
1Close Looking Analysis Visual ArtArtist’s Self-Portrait Analys
 
1CLA1Xueyao DongWestcliff UniversityINT 501 EF
1CLA1Xueyao DongWestcliff UniversityINT 501 EF1CLA1Xueyao DongWestcliff UniversityINT 501 EF
1CLA1Xueyao DongWestcliff UniversityINT 501 EF
 
1CJ 550 2-2 Milestone One Southern New Ha
1CJ 550 2-2 Milestone One        Southern New Ha1CJ 550 2-2 Milestone One        Southern New Ha
1CJ 550 2-2 Milestone One Southern New Ha
 
1CLA 1Every organization aims at achieving a cer
1CLA 1Every organization aims at achieving a cer1CLA 1Every organization aims at achieving a cer
1CLA 1Every organization aims at achieving a cer
 
1CHAPTER ONEThe What and Why of BudgetingAn Introduction
1CHAPTER ONEThe What and Why of BudgetingAn Introduction1CHAPTER ONEThe What and Why of BudgetingAn Introduction
1CHAPTER ONEThe What and Why of BudgetingAn Introduction
 
1Child Development Observation and Reflection
1Child Development Observation and Reflection1Child Development Observation and Reflection
1Child Development Observation and Reflection
 
1CHAPTER4BUSINESS-LEVEL STRATEGYChapter 2The Exter
1CHAPTER4BUSINESS-LEVEL STRATEGYChapter 2The Exter1CHAPTER4BUSINESS-LEVEL STRATEGYChapter 2The Exter
1CHAPTER4BUSINESS-LEVEL STRATEGYChapter 2The Exter
 
1CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, RADIOLOGICAL AND NUCLEAR (CBR
1CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, RADIOLOGICAL AND NUCLEAR (CBR1CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, RADIOLOGICAL AND NUCLEAR (CBR
1CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, RADIOLOGICAL AND NUCLEAR (CBR
 
1CHAPTER 01G L O B A L R E P O R T O N2G
1CHAPTER 01G L O B A L  R E P O R T  O N2G1CHAPTER 01G L O B A L  R E P O R T  O N2G
1CHAPTER 01G L O B A L R E P O R T O N2G
 
1Child Growth and DevelopmentYohana MangiaficoHous
1Child Growth and DevelopmentYohana MangiaficoHous1Child Growth and DevelopmentYohana MangiaficoHous
1Child Growth and DevelopmentYohana MangiaficoHous
 
1CHAPTER2THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTOPPORTUNITIES, THREATS
1CHAPTER2THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTOPPORTUNITIES, THREATS1CHAPTER2THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTOPPORTUNITIES, THREATS
1CHAPTER2THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTOPPORTUNITIES, THREATS
 
1Chapter Two Literature ReviewStudents NameName of the
1Chapter Two Literature ReviewStudents NameName of the1Chapter Two Literature ReviewStudents NameName of the
1Chapter Two Literature ReviewStudents NameName of the
 
1CHAPTER 6 CHINAChinaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J. (
1CHAPTER 6 CHINAChinaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J. (1CHAPTER 6 CHINAChinaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J. (
1CHAPTER 6 CHINAChinaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J. (
 
1Chapter 9TelevisionBroadcast and Beyond2
1Chapter 9TelevisionBroadcast and Beyond21Chapter 9TelevisionBroadcast and Beyond2
1Chapter 9TelevisionBroadcast and Beyond2
 
1CHAPTER 5 RUSSIARussiaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J.
1CHAPTER 5 RUSSIARussiaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J.1CHAPTER 5 RUSSIARussiaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J.
1CHAPTER 5 RUSSIARussiaBook ReferenceTerrill, R. J.
 
1Chapter 6Newspapers and the NewsReflections of a
1Chapter 6Newspapers and the NewsReflections of a1Chapter 6Newspapers and the NewsReflections of a
1Chapter 6Newspapers and the NewsReflections of a
 
1CHAPTER 4 SOUTH AFRICA South AfricaConcepts to Know·
1CHAPTER 4 SOUTH AFRICA South AfricaConcepts to Know·1CHAPTER 4 SOUTH AFRICA South AfricaConcepts to Know·
1CHAPTER 4 SOUTH AFRICA South AfricaConcepts to Know·
 

Recently uploaded

Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfBiting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfadityarao40181
 
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17Celine George
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementHierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementmkooblal
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsanshu789521
 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)eniolaolutunde
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxNirmalaLoungPoorunde1
 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxGaneshChakor2
 
EPANDING THE CONTENT OF AN OUTLINE using notes.pptx
EPANDING THE CONTENT OF AN OUTLINE using notes.pptxEPANDING THE CONTENT OF AN OUTLINE using notes.pptx
EPANDING THE CONTENT OF AN OUTLINE using notes.pptxRaymartEstabillo3
 
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfFraming an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfUjwalaBharambe
 
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,Virag Sontakke
 
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17Celine George
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfSumit Tiwari
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxiammrhaywood
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxSayali Powar
 
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentMeghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptxCapitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptxCapitolTechU
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxVS Mahajan Coaching Centre
 
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxCELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxJiesonDelaCerna
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfBiting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
 
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
 
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementHierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
 
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
 
EPANDING THE CONTENT OF AN OUTLINE using notes.pptx
EPANDING THE CONTENT OF AN OUTLINE using notes.pptxEPANDING THE CONTENT OF AN OUTLINE using notes.pptx
EPANDING THE CONTENT OF AN OUTLINE using notes.pptx
 
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfFraming an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
 
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
 
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
 
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentMeghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
 
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptxCapitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
 
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxCELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
 

12M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y

  • 1. 12M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3 T his year the healthcare industry is expected to account for 15.6% of GDP, and expendi- tures for physician services are expected to be $347.9 billion. A large part of that goes to physician practices, and, because they are such a large part of the economy, they represent an opportunity for management accountants to assist physicians in evaluating contracts with third-party pay- ers and providing financial information for strategic decisions. To do so, management accountants need to understand the unique revenue, cost, and contractual intricacies of physician practices. While most businesses’ sources of revenue are sales and fees, physician practices depend on the organiza-
  • 2. tional structure of the healthcare revenue reimburse- ment relationships among provider, patient, and third-party insurer. Revenue reimbursements can come from indemnity, preferred provider organizations (PPOs), and/or healthcare maintenance organizations (HMOs). In particular, to advise a physician or evaluate profits, a management accountant must understand the relationships between a practice’s revenues and its costs. Because these revenue reimburseme nts are contractual- ly determined, controlling costs is critical to the survival of a physician’s practice. A management accountant can help a physician calculate costs, select the appropriate cost structure to manage costs, and help make tough strategic decisions about the financial future of the prac- tice. Once a management accountant understands the source of revenues and the cost constraints, he or she can then help a physician evaluate a revenue reimburse- ment contract. For example, if the contract is from an
  • 3. indemnity plan or a PPO, evaluation is relatively straightforward if the management accountant under- stands a practice’s organizational structures and cost con- trol. But if the revenue comes from an HMO capitation contract—that is, a fixed rate of payment to cover a specified set of health services and procedures— evaluating the contract requires additional analysis because revenues are based on anticipated services. P H YS I C I A N G R O U P R E V E N U E S In order to consult with a physician group, a manage- ment accountant must have a good understanding of How Management Accountants Make Physicians’ Practices More Profitable Spring 2005 VOL.6 NO.3 Spring 2005 THE KEY TO PROFITABILITY IS TO USE COST ANALYSIS
  • 4. BY DETERMINING A PRACTICE’S COST STRUCTURE AND USING THOSE COSTS TO EVALUATE CONTRACTS, ALLOCATE BONUSES EQUITABLY, AND MAKE STRATEGIC DECISIONS ABOUT THE FINANCIAL FUTURE OF THE PRACTICE GROUP. B Y M A R S H A S C H E I D T , D B A , C M A , A N D G R E G T H I B A D O U X , P H . D . 13M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3 the sources of practice revenues. As noted previously, there are three types of organizational structures for healthcare: indemnity, PPOs, and HMOs. Each organi- zational structure utilizes distinct methods of revenue reimbursement: Indemnity uses fee for service, PPOs use discounted fee for service, and HMOs use salaries, capitation, and other financial controls. Indemnity Plans
  • 5. Under an indemnity plan, physicians historically have been reimbursed primarily through third-party payers such as insurance companies. The actual payers— consumers and businesses—have insurance companies handle reimbursement for two reasons. First, the insur- ance company is able to handle the overwhelming administration of the plan more efficiently, and, second, it can spread the financial risk over a large pool of indi - viduals. These plans are called indemnity because they reimburse physicians after services are rendered, and the reimbursement method is known as fee for service. Payment is production based: the more services provid- ed, the greater the revenues to the physician. Because the payer is responsible for the cost of the services, the payer assumes the financial risk. Notice that under an indemnity plan there are no ties between the payer (insurance company) and the provider (physician). But spiraling physician costs led payers to institute
  • 6. managed care plans that, for the first time, linked physi- cians who provided medical services with the parties who paid for those services. Under managed healthcare, third-party payers, including insurance companies and the federal government in some of its Medicare and Medicaid programs, would control the flow of monies by third-party payers to providers. It also dictated the number of services that could be provided to the patient, who could provide those services, and how much physicians and hospitals would be paid for those services. The strongest form of managed care is the HMO, and the weakest is the PPO. PPOs In response to rising medical costs during the 1970s, insurance companies developed a form of payment known as the PPO. This type of healthcare plan differs from traditional indemnity insurance in that payments to physicians are based on a reduced fee schedule, dis-
  • 7. counted from 10% to 40%. Other controls, such as larger co-payments and deductibles for out-of-network ser- vices, are instituted by third-party payers to encourage patients to use PPO networks. The system is, however, still production oriented like traditional indemnity plans. Because revenues are relat- ed to the number of services provided, PPOs are basical - ly a form of discounted fee for service. Although PPOs are less costly than indemnity plans, the payer is still responsible for the cost of the services and assumes the financial risk. Today, discounted fee for service plans are the dominant method of revenue reimbursement. HMOs Unlike indemnity and PPO reimbursement plans, the HMO links the payer and provider together as a team to guide the patient through the healthcare system. The HMO collects a premium from the enrolled mem- ber and contracts with him or her to provide the neces-
  • 8. sary healthcare services during the period of enrollment. The HMO then contracts with the physi- cians and pays them to provide the anticipated services as needed for the period of enrollment. By agreeing to accept reimbursement on a prospective basis, the provider assumes the financial risk for the cost of future services. Physician revenue reimbursement in an HMO network is more complex and may be in the form of salary, capitation, and/or other financial controls. Salary is used frequently in HMOs. Straight salaries are used in more than 10% of the groups, and guaran- teed base salaries are used by about 20%. Under indem- nity or PPO structures, salaries are used only in certain scenarios or sectors, such as the Veterans Administration or, possibly, a hospital for a doctor such as a hospitalist. A hospitalist is an inpatient physician who directs the flow of care for hospitalized patients and is paid by the hospi - tal. HMOs have much greater financial control because
  • 9. they provide the physician with either a salary or bonus- es tied to the HMO’s physician productivity goals. HMO capitation is a method of physician revenue reimbursement based on a negotiated contract. The provider receives a set amount of revenue calculated per member per month for providing the necessary ser- vices during the covered period of time. The capitation 14M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3 rate is commonly a fixed amount per member per month. Most HMO capitation rate calculations take members’ actuarial data, such as age, gender, geography, and historical utilization rates, and costs to serve mem- bers into account to predict the expected costs of ser- vices. The HMO will then determine the average monthly cost of services and an average cost of services on a per member per month basis, which is the capita-
  • 10. tion rate. Each month, the total revenue reimbursement to the physician is the per member per month rate times the number of members actually enrolled for the month. This per member per month payment means that a physician is obligated to provide specified ser - vices to enrolled members as frequently as necessary. If a member uses more services than expected, the physi- cian usually is not paid an additional amount. Likewise, if a member uses fewer services, the physician does not refund the capitated amount. HMO contracts for revenue reimbursement may also include other financial controls, such as withholds and/or bonuses. These controls are the two major types of incentives designed to influence physician behavior regarding ancillary services, such as laboratory tests and referrals to specialists. A withhold involves keeping a percentage of the capitation fee to be released only if the physician group attains HMO productivity goals.
  • 11. Withholds invoke partner risk, which is the possibility that one physician’s performance will negatively affect the group’s compensation. Another financial incentive HMOs may use is bonuses based on the productivity and quality of services the physicians provide. P H YS I C I A N G R O U P S E R V I C E CO S T Medical office management has changed significantly with the implementation of managed care. Today physi- cians operate primarily in a managed care environment, receiving reimbursement for their services based on PPO and/or HMO contractual relationships or in the form of salary an HMO pays. It is estimated that about 85% of all patients today participate in some form of managed care. Prior to managed care, physician billing was based on the actual number and type of procedures performed on patients and was known as fee for service. In this type of financial environment, physicians’ rev- enue was related directly to the number of procedures
  • 12. and services they provided. The more the physician did to the patient in terms of diagnostic and treatment pro- cedures, the greater the revenue. In a fee-for-service environment, low profit margins or, in some cases, nega- tive profit margins could be offset by increasing the vol - ume of other, more profitable services and procedures. In essence, the actual cost of providing a service was not particularly relevant as long as the physician group could control the volume of all services provided. This is not the case today because most physicians receive reimbursement based on discounted PPO rates and fixed capitation HMO contracts. Under these systems it becomes crucial that the physician group knows the cost of providing services in relation to the revenue generated by those services. For example, in a PPO contract, certain procedures and office visits will provide much higher profit margins than others. A surgeon might find that one type of
  • 13. surgery is much more profitable than another even though he or she may feel that each required a similar amount of time, expertise, and diligence. Also under a capitation contract, the fewer services rendered, the greater the profit margin because, as noted above, rev- enues do not vary with the volume of services per- formed, only with the number of enrolled members. As revenues are determined only by the number of enrollees, profit margins will depend on how well the group is able to control costs. In essence, the more ser- vices and time spent per patient than is medically pru- dent, the lower the profit margin. Therefore, under managed care it is crucial that the physician group knows the relative cost of its physi- cians’ time and procedures to be able to make informed decisions about how it wants to focus its prac- tice. For example, a surgery group may make a strate- gic decision based in part on financial considerations to
  • 14. concentrate its efforts on a well-defined group of patients. In order to make informed financial-based decisions, physicians need crucial information about the cost structures of their practice that management accountants can provide. D E T E R M I N I N G T H E CO S T O F S E R V I C E S To make informed decisions about contracts or the strategic direction of the practice, physicians need, at a 15M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3 minimum, information about the average cost of ser- vices they provide. In fact, to evaluate the contract effectively, physicians should know the average cost of services, the marginal costs of treating the new patients, and whether any additional fixed costs will be incurred by accepting the contract.
  • 15. Traditionally, physician groups have tracked costs on a line-item basis by classifying costs in functional cate- gories such as salary, equipment costs, depreciation, cost of materials, and drugs. Unfortunately, this type of information is not particularly useful in relating a prac- tice’s costs to the services it provides. In fact, for any cost accounting system to be effective it must fulfill the following criteria: ◆A product must be carefully defined, ◆The type and quantity of inputs required for prod- ucts must be defined, and ◆The costs must be attached to the inputs and the product costed out. Traditionally, physician groups have been concerned only with tracking costs on a line-item basis, so there has been no effective way to attach these costs to the services produced. The problem is that, under this sys- tem of accounting, there has been no defined product
  • 16. measure, no measure of inputs, and no way to attach the cost of inputs to the product. Fortunately, all this changed in 1992, when Medicare changed the way it reimbursed for physician services. Instead of paying on a fee-for-service basis, it began to base its payment on a resource-based relative value scale system. Under this methodology, the amount of payment is tied to the amount of resources that are expected to be used to provide the service rendered. The actual product, ser - vice, or office visit rendered is defined by the CPT (common procedural terminology) code, the accepted procedural codes used to bill patients. Each CPT code represents an office visit, a service provided, a lab test, or a procedure. Relative value units (RVU) are the inputs required to provide the service. A relative value unit takes into account the amount of physician work required to pro- vide the service, the practice expense, and the expense
  • 17. of liability insurance. The code values were created rel - ative to value of a standard office visit, which has a code value of 1.00 RVU. A code allowing reimbursement for four RVUs implies that it took an average of four times more effort and cost to provide that service. Today, most physician software billing systems will allow the practice to link its billing codes to a database that contains the number of RVUs allowed for each pro- cedural billing code. By using such software, the prac- tice can keep a running total of the number of RVUs generated for any time period. The management accountant can use these RVU totals to calculate the cost per RVU and then calculate the cost per procedure provided. For example, if it is determined that an aver- age RVU costs $30 to provide, then an uncomplicated office visit with an RVU of one would cost $30. In sum- mary, by costing out the inputs (RVUs) required to pro- duce a service (CPT code), a management accountant
  • 18. can determine the actual cost to the practice of provid- ing that service. This information can then be used to evaluate PPO and capitation contracts and to make strategic decisions. Calculating Costs To carry out an analysis of costs, the management accountant must first calculate the average and marginal costs per RVU. With the number of RVUs required by the contract per CPT code known, a management accountant can calculate the total average cost and the total marginal cost per CPT code. He or she can use this information to help the physicians make informed decisions. The following is a discussion of the steps required to analyze physician group practice costs. Step 1. Calculate the average and marginal costs per RVU. In cost accounting, there are two primary methods for
  • 19. analyzing costs: the high-low method and regression. The high-low method is an approximation based on two points, and regression is a statistical method requiring at least 30 points and one or more independent variables. Because medical practices typically do not capture information that lends itself to regression analysis, the high-low method is usually more appropriate. We will use it to illustrate a cost analysis, as follows. High-low cost analysis of monthly data requires sev- eral procedures. 16M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3 Procedure 1. Determine the Variable Cost for the Production of One RVU: a. Select the high production (the month with the highest volume of RVUs). b. Select the low production (the month with the
  • 20. lowest volume of RVUs). c. Subtract the difference between the total cost incurred during the highest production (Y2) and the total cost incurred during the lowest produc- tion (Y1). Total costs will include all costs of the practice, such as salary, depreciation, insurance, drugs, supplies, etc. d. Take the difference between the total RVUs incurred during the highest production (X2) and the total RVUs incurred during the lowest production (X1). e. Divide step c (the cost difference) by step d (the RVUs difference). f. The result is the variable cost for one RVU. Procedure 2. Determine the Total Fixed Costs: a. Take the total cost incurred during the highest pro- duction (Y2) and subtract the estimated total vari- able costs for the highest production (total variable
  • 21. costs equals the variable cost per RVU times the number of RVUs). b. The remainder is the total fixed cost. Procedure 3. Determine the Total Cost Formula: Total Costs = Total Fixed Costs plus (variable cost per RVU times number of RVUs). Procedure 4. Calculate the Average and Marginal Costs per RVU: The average cost per RVU is calculated as follows: Using the total cost formula determined in Procedure 3 and the number of RVUs expected, a management accountant can calculate total costs expected for that level of RVUs. The average cost per RVU is simply the total costs as calculated above divided by the expected level of RVUs. The marginal cost per RVU is the incremental costs of producing an RVU. At a mini- mum, marginal costs are the variable cost per RVU as calculated in Procedure 1(f). If a new contract requires
  • 22. additional fixed or variable costs, then those incremen- tal costs will be averaged over the new contract RVUs and increase the marginal costs. Step 2. Determine the number of RVUs required. The contract will specify the number of RVUs per ser- vice CPT code. The number of RVUs allowed will be defined by the contract under consideration or the gov- ernmental healthcare reimbursement scheme, such as Medicare. Step 3. Calculate the total average cost and the total marginal cost per CPT code. The full cost of a visit or procedure is calculated by multiplying the average cost per RVU times the num- ber of RVUs that are allowed per procedure. The mar- ginal cost of a visit or procedure is simply the variable costs per RVU times the number of RVUs that are allowed per procedure. Step 4. Assist the physicians in using these costs
  • 23. appropriately in making informed decisions. Management accountants can provide a wealth of infor- mation to physicians to assist them in evaluating con- tracts and making strategic decisions. The following is an example of the four steps man- agement accountants can use to analyze a physician’s practice. Assume that during 20X1, U.R. Well, P.C.’s costs were historical $672,000 when 10,000 RVUs were pro- duced and $782,000 when 12,000 RVUs were produced. Step 1. Calculate the average and marginal costs per RVU. Procedure 1. Determine the Variable Cost for the Production of One RVU: Y2 – Y1 = $782,000 – $672,000 = $110,000 X2 – X1 = 12,000 RVUs – 10,000 RVUs = 2,000 RVUs Variable cost per unit = Cost difference divided by production difference
  • 24. = $110,000 ÷ 2,000 RVUs = $55 per RVU Procedure 2. Determine the Total Fixed Costs: Fixed Costs = $782,000 – ($55 * 12,000 RVUs) = $782,000 – $660,000 = $122,000 17M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3 Procedure 3. Determine the Total Cost Formula: Total Costs = Total Fixed Costs plus (variable cost per RVU times number of RVUs). Total = $122,000 + $55 per RVU times number of RVUs Procedure 4. Calculate the average and marginal cost per proce- dure. The average cost per relative value unit is deter - mined using the projected number of RVUs for the coming month in the above formula. For example, if during the coming month it is expected that the prac-
  • 25. tice will generate 11,000 RVUs, the average cost would be as follows: Average cost per RVU = {$122,000 + ($55)(11,000)} ÷ 11,000 RVUs = $66.09 per RVU. The marginal cost per RVU is simply the variable costs or $55.00 per RVU. Step 2. Determine the number of RVUs required by the contract per CPT code: For example, the contract may state that a particular CPT code allows six RVUs. Step 3. Calculate the total average cost and the total marginal cost per CPT code. The cost per procedure is the cost per RVU times the number of relative value units allowed per procedure. For example, if a procedure allows six RVUs then the average cost for the procedure would be 6 * $66.09 = $396.55, and the marginal costs would be 6 * $55 = $330.00.
  • 26. Step 4. Assist the physicians in using these costs appropriately to make informed decisions. The management accountant can help the physician group make informed financial decisions about poten- tial contracts. The nature of the decision will depend on whether it is a PPO or HMO contract under consideration. CO N S I D E R AT I O N S O F CA P I TAT I O N CO N T R AC T Once the cost of the RVU has been calculated, this information can be used to evaluate PPO contracts. If the group is operating at full capacity, then any addi- tional contracts either will have to replace existing con- tracts or will require the practice to expand. In order to justify accepting a contract, the proposed reimburse- ment per procedure should generate an acceptable mar- gin in excess of the average practice cost per procedure. Any reimbursement less than the average cost per pro- cedure will result in lower margins and will endanger
  • 27. the recovery of fixed costs. If the practice is considering adding physicians, the contracts must provide adequate volume and reimbursement to cover these incremental costs. In any case, if the group does not receive a fair recovery of its cost in delivering its services, the other considerations of the contract are irrelevant. If the practice is operating at less than full capacity, the contract must provide reimbursement in excess of the marginal costs per procedure. In this situation, the group may be willing to forego expected profit margins in order to cover existing fixed costs. In either case, a physician practice cannot make an informed decision without the type of cost information that only a man- agement accountant can provide. Additionally, the RVU cost data for a physician’s group can be used as a method for allocating bonuses based pri - marily on PPO revenues. When a physician group receives the bulk of its revenues from a PPO, it may dis-
  • 28. tribute bonuses equitably based on office productivity. Typically, physicians receive salaries from the practice and share in year-end bonuses if the practice has a net profit and if they are partners in the medical group. Allo- cation of such bonuses can be a point of contention in a partnership. This problem can be especially troublesome if the relationship between physician-generated revenues and their associated costs are unknown. Allocating profits based on the ratio of physician revenue to total practice revenue or as a percentage of treated patients can be grossly unfair, particularly if there are significant differ - ences among the physicians based on either the type of patients they treat or services they perform. This prob- lem can exist in a single specialty group if physicians have different preferences in regard to types of patients they treat. The problem will always exist in a multispe- cialty practice setting where physicians with different specialties are practicing.
  • 29. With the same software used to calculate RVU costs, the management accountant can track the total RVUs generated over any time frame by each physician. The 18M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3 ratio of physician RVUs to total practice RVUs is an excellent measure of productivity and can—at least in part—be used as a measure for determining year-end bonuses. Alternatively, one could calculate the gross margin generated by each physician: Revenue per physician – (Physician RVUs * average cost per RVU) = Gross margin per physician. This is a much more equitable method for allocating bonuses than simply an equal distribution. CONSIDERATIONS OF A CAPITATION CONTRACT A physician’s profit management under an HMO capita-
  • 30. tion contract is unique to the healthcare industry. Man- agement accountants and physicians are more attuned to analysis for discounted fee for service or salary revenues, but capitation is a totally different scenario. Evaluation on an HMO capitated contract requires both financial evaluation of the capitation rate and examination of the procedural aspects of the contract. There are two factors to consider in a capitation rate: (1) the structure of the plan and (2) the practice’s costs of the covered services. Financial Evaluation The structure of the relationship between the HMO and a practice depends on whether the contract involves a closed HMO network or point-of-service providers. In a closed HMO network, enrolled mem- bers will have no out-of-network coverage, only pre- authorized services, fixed-dollar copayments, and service limits. In an HMO with a point-of-service
  • 31. option, patients may utilize network and out-of-network physicians and some nonauthorized services with per- centage copayments. Because of out-of-network utiliza- tion, deductibles, and copayment variation, the capitation rate is more difficult to calculate for point of service. One factor in analyzing the capitation rate is that both copayments and deductibles are subtracted from the service cost, so the lower the copayment or deductible level, the higher the capitation rate. An increase in either will decrease utilization. Management accountants will need to be able to discuss in broad terms how these various factors will impact the practice financially. The second factor in analyzing the capitation rate is the cost of the covered services from the practice’s perspective. In determining the number of covered services, the management accountant should provide the group with a rough estimate of the costs that
  • 32. may be incurred in providing medical treatment for the enrolled population. This will involve projecting the number of procedures that will be provided to the enrolled population times the average cost per procedure. In order to do this, the management accountant will have to make use of historical data generated by the group from previous capitation contracts or may need to work with other consultants such as actuaries. Procedural Issues After the management accountant has determined the financial viability of the capitation contract, he or she may also want to consider procedural issues such as terms of the contract, risks, and reporting requirements. While a management accountant will not have all the needed expertise to evaluate these issues, he or she should be aware of their importance for evaluating any potential contract. Capitation contract terms should
  • 33. include: a. Clearly stated terms and conditions for payment. b. Definitions of how patient eligibility is to be deter- mined. Determination of when and who is eligible should be assumed by the payer, preferably online and in real-time. c. Requirement that the payer provide a policies and procedures manual and agree to revisions by mutual consent only. d. Specification of how and when rates may be renegotiated. e. Allowance for terminations with and without cause. “With cause” means a breach in the terms; “without cause” means giving notice. Some obligations will continue after termination, so it is important to understand the provisions. f. A requirement for a minimum amount of paperwork and time to administer it.
  • 34. g. Clear explanation how withholds and bonuses are to be determined. 19M A N A G E M E N T A C C O U N T I N G Q U A R T E R L Y S P R I N G 2 0 0 5 , V O L . 6 , N O . 3 CO S T AC C O U N T I N G N E E D E D Today the majority of physician groups are dependent for their revenues on third-party payers such as insur- ance companies and state and federal governmental healthcare organizations. Under managed care plans such as PPOs and HMOs, the financial and strategic success of physician group practices is dependent on successful contract negotiation and cost control. In this environment, management accountants have a vital role to play in helping physicians determine the costs of the services they provide and in assisting them in evaluat- ing potential contracts. Management accountants can provide these services by using traditional cost account-
  • 35. ing techniques such as cost-volume-profit analysis and product costing. Today most physicians have software in place that can provide a wealth of useful but under- utilized information for anyone with appropriate analyti - cal skills. ■ Marsha Scheidt, DBA, CMA, is a UC professor in account- ing at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga. She can be reached at (423) 425-2112 or [email protected] Greg Thibadoux, Ph.D., is a professor in accounting at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga. He can be reached at (423) 425-4408 or [email protected] Sample Physician RVU analysis. To carry out an analysis of costs, the management accountant must first calculate the average and marginal costs per RVU. With the number of RVUs required by the contract per CPT code known, a management accountant can calculate the total average cost and the total marginal cost per CPT code. He or she can use this information to help the physicians make informed decisions. Example of Calculations
  • 36. Assume that during 2016, XYZ P.C.s costs were historical $672,000 when 10,000 RVUs were produced and $782,000 when 12,000 RVUs were produced. Step 1. a) Calculate the average and marginal costs per RVU. Y2 – Y1 = $782,000 – $672,000 = $110,000 X2 – X1 = 12,000 RVUs – 10,000 RVUs = 2,000 RVUs b) Calculate the variable cost per unit Cost difference divided by production difference = $110,000 ÷ 2,000 RVUs = $55 per RVU c) Calculate the total fixed costs. Fixed Costs = $782,000 – ($55 * 12,000 RVUs) = $782,000 – $660,000 = $122,000 d) Calculate total costs Total fixed costs + (variable cost per RVU times number of RVUs). Total = $122,000 + ($55 * 12,000 RVUs) =$122,000 + 660,000 = $782,000 e) Calculate average cost per RVU The average cost per relative value unit is determined using the projected number of RVUs for the coming month in the above formula. For example, if during the coming month it is expected that the practice will generate 11,000 RVUs, the average cost would be as follows: Average cost per RVU = {$122,000 + ($55)(11,000)} ÷ 11,000 RVUs = $66.09 per RVU. The marginal cost per RVU is simply the variable costs or $55.00 per RVU.
  • 37. Step 2. Determine the number of RVUs required by the contract per CPT code: For example, the contract may state that a particular CPT code allows six RVUs. Step 3. Calculate the total average cost and the total marginal cost per CPT code. The cost per procedure is the cost per RVU times the number of relative value units allowed per procedure. For example, if a procedure allows six RVUs then the average cost for the procedure would be 6 * $66.09 = $396.55, and the marginal costs would be 6 * $55 = $330.00. Step 4. Assist the physicians in using these costs appropriately to make informed decisions. The management accountant can help the physician group make informed financial decisions about potential contracts. The nature of the decision will depend on whether it is a PPO or HMO contract under consideration.