8. Abstract
Positive Negative
Background objective given Outcomes are given in outcome measures
Methods mentioned One of the outcome not given in abstract
Result and conclusion given Nothing about Study registration
Keywords given Used exercise in keywords
9. Introduction
Positive Negative
Prevalence of peripheral arterial disease
given
Introduction not given in separate headings
About intermittent claudication mentioned
in background
Stated objective of their study
10. Methods
Positive Negative
Search engines like MEDLINE, EMBASE,&
CENTRAL DATABASES given
Search terms mentioned Rutherford stage 1 in inclusion criteria
Inclusion & exclusion criteria given Not mentioned ABPI in exclusion criteria
Data extraction and screened by 2
reviewers and conflict solved by another
reviewer
Outcome measures given
Rob assessed by Cochrane collaboration
tool
Quality assessment of study by PEDro scale
score
11. Results
Positive Negative
Search results and characteristics of study
given
2023 in search result & in flow chart 2027
Result of quality assessment mentioned One study is excluded but given in summary
of studies
Prisma flow chart and risk of bias summary
chart given
Risk of bias not mentioned in result
Summary of studies mentioned in table Excluded 1 article for not having ABPI
12.
13.
14.
15. Discussion & conclusion
Positive Negative
Discussed about the study results Not mentioned in the discussion reasons for
getting these results
Limitation & conclusion given Limitation is given before conclusion
Future recommendation given Clinical implication ?
16. References
▪ References are given in APA & VANCOUVER STYLE
▪ All citations are proper except citation no . 33
▪ References and text reference are matching
