3. How to define Quality Assurance
“Quality is the means through which an
institution can guarantee with
confidence and certainty, that the
standards of its educational provision
are being maintained and enhanced”
4. Quality Assurance
Quality in Higher Education is a dynamic
entity which is the outcome of interacting
among many factors that determine state of
equilibrium reached at various levels.
These include, inter alia, leadership, quality
of faculty, quality of students, infrastructure,
facilities, research and learning environment,
governance, strategic planning, assessment
procedures and market forces.
5. Quality Assurance System at HEC
HEC
QAC
QA-Department/
QAA
International
Linkages
QEC
HEIs
Accreditation
Councils
6. 3 Major Components of Quality
Assurance Programme
Development of Quality Assurance Criteria.
Development of Processes & Capacity
Building
Monitoring and Evaluation
7. Development of Quality Assurance
Criteria
Minimum Quality Criteria for PhD level
studies
Eligibility Criteria for Faculty Appointment
Eligibility Criteria for Meritorious Professors
Eligibility Criteria for Professor Emeritus
8. Continued…
Tenure Track System of appointments
Criteria for Recognition of Journals
Affiliation Criteria
Ranking Criteria
9. Continued…
Accreditation Criteria for Institutions (in
progress)
Quality Criteria for Teaching in various
disciplines (Accreditation Councils)
National Committee on Examination Systems
Liaison with International Networks on QA
(INQAAHE/APQN)
10. Development of Processes &
Capacity Building
QAA Setup
Establishment of QECs
Monthly meetings of QECs
Training Workshops/Seminars
1st International Conference on QA in
Pakistan
Self Assessment Guidelines distributed
12. Accreditation Councils
For Accreditation at Programme level:
Linkages with already existing Councils
(PMDC, PEC, PVMC, PCTAP, PBC and
Pharmacy Council)
Establishment of new Accreditation
Councils
i. NCEAC
ii. NAEAC
iii. PTEAC
iv. NBEAC
13. Monitoring and Evaluation
Self Assessment by the Universities
External Academic Audit by HEC
Monitoring Teams by HEC
14. Evaluation System for QA in HE
QEC
Student/Staff
Consultative
Committee
HEC
Departmental
Committee
Vice Chancellor
University
Learning &
Teaching
Committee
16. Continued…
Proforma 5: Research Student Progress
Review Form
Proforma 6: University Learning & Teaching
Committee: Possible Remit & Membership
Proforma 7: University Learning, Teaching &
Quality Enhancement Strategy: Template
17. Committee for Evaluation of M.Phil
/PhD Programmes
Committee constituted with eminent
educationists and policy makers
Total 20 Universities have been visited
Evaluation Reports compiled and follow up
started
18. Public Information
“Good Practices for Quality Assurance for
Accreditation Councils in Pakistan”
“A Toolkit for Quality Enhancement Cells”
“Self Assessment Manual”
Website Development for Quality Assurance
in HEC