SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
MARSHALL TEST RESULT’S
 IT IS CONDUCTED IN TWO STAGE’S
 SPECIMEN PREPARATION.
 SPECIMEN TESTING.
SAMPLE
GRADED AND
DRIED
HEATING UP
SAMPLE MIX
WITH BITUMEN
MOULDING SAMPLE
READY FOR
TESTING
SPECIMEN PREPARATION
 WE USED FULLER’S FORMULA FOR GRADING
AND PREPARED SPREADSHEET FOR THAT
ALSO.
 WHERE ‘p’ is PERCENTAGE
PASSING THROUGH SIEVE
UNDER CONSIDERATION
‘D’ is LARGEST PARTICLE SIZE
‘d’ is SIEVE UNDER CONSIDERATION
‘n’ is FULLER INDEX AND TAKEN as 0.45 by
us.
SPECIMEN PHASE DIAGRAM
NOTATIONS
W1, W2, W3 AND Wb ARE
WEIGHT OF COARSE
AGGREGATES, FINE
AGGREGATES, FILLER AND
BITUMEN RESPECTIVELY.
V1, V2, V3, Vb AND Vv ARE
VOLUME OF COARSE
AGGREGATES, FINE
AGGREGATES, FILLER,
BITUMEN AND AIR VOIDS
G1, G2, G3 AND Gb ARE
SPECIFIC GRAVITIES OF
COARSE AGGREGATES,
FINE AGGREGATES,
FILLER AND BITUMEN
FORMULA’S
USED
Gt THEORETICAL
SPECIFIC GRAVITY
Gm BULK SPECIFIC
GRAVITY
Vv AIR VOIDS IN SAMPLE
Vb VOIDS FILLED WITH
BITUMEN
VMA VOIDS IN MINERAL
AGGREGATES
VFB VOIDS FILLED BY
BITUMEN
SPECIMEN TESTING
ANIMATED REAL
TESTING DATA FOR OPTIMUM
BITUMEN CONTENT
Sample
No.
Bitumen
Content
(%)
Marshall
Stability
Value
(kg)
Flow
Value (in
0.25mm
units)
Bulk
Specific
Gravity
Air Voids
(%)
VFB (%)
1) 4 1037.31 10 2.37 3.83 71.54
2) 4.5 1632.62 11 2.39 2.26 83.74
3) 5 2035.48 12 2.40 1.85 86.29
4) 5.5 2084.40 14 2.39 1.53 89.26
5) 6 1379.62 17 2.38 0.93 93.90
CHARTS
 MARSHALL STABILITY VS BITUMEN CONTENT
CHARTS
 FLOW VALUE VS BITUMEN CONTENT
CHARTS
 AIR VOIDS VS BITUMEN CONTENT
CHARTS
 BULK SPECIFIC GRAVITY VS BITUMEN CONTENT
CHARTS
 VFB VS BITUMEN CONTENT
OPTIMUM BITUMEN CONTENT
 BITUMEN CONTENT CORRESPONDING TO
MAXIMUM MARSHALL STABILITY VALUE= 5.5%
 BITUMEN CONTENT CORRESPONDING TO
MAXIMUM BULK SPECIFIC GRAVITY= 5%
 BITUMEN CONTENT CORRESPONDING TO MEDIAN
(4%) OF AIR VOIDS %= 4%
 AVERAGE VALUE= 4.8%
 THEREFORE OPTIMUM BITUMEN CONTENT= 4.8%
“Engineering problems are under-defined, there are many solutions, good, bad and
indifferent. The art is to arrive at a good solution. This is a creative activity,
involving imagination, intuition and deliberate choice.”
OVE ARUP
Engineers … are not superhuman. They make mistakes in their assumptions, in their
calculations, in their conclusions. That they make mistakes is forgivable; that they
catch them is imperative. Thus it is the essence of modern engineering not only to be
able to check one’s own work but also to have one’s work checked and to be able to
check the work of others.
THANK
YOU

More Related Content

What's hot

Soil stabilisation (1)
Soil stabilisation (1)Soil stabilisation (1)
Soil stabilisation (1)Safiullah Khan
 
Construction of flexible pavements
Construction of flexible pavementsConstruction of flexible pavements
Construction of flexible pavementspradip dangar
 
Pavement materials in Road Construction
Pavement materials in Road ConstructionPavement materials in Road Construction
Pavement materials in Road Constructionsrinivas2036
 
Flexible pavement presentation
Flexible pavement presentationFlexible pavement presentation
Flexible pavement presentationPawan Kumar
 
ground improvement with admixtures
ground improvement with admixturesground improvement with admixtures
ground improvement with admixturesINDRANIL BANERJEE
 
Ground improvement techniques compaction vibration
Ground improvement techniques  compaction vibrationGround improvement techniques  compaction vibration
Ground improvement techniques compaction vibrationAnjana R Menon
 
Rigid pavement
Rigid pavementRigid pavement
Rigid pavementpjainrahul
 
Plate load test ppt
Plate load test pptPlate load test ppt
Plate load test pptsayan sarkar
 
Cement stabilization of soils ppt
Cement stabilization of soils pptCement stabilization of soils ppt
Cement stabilization of soils pptVeluppillai Mohan
 
Stone columns - an overview(Ground improvement)
Stone columns -  an overview(Ground improvement)Stone columns -  an overview(Ground improvement)
Stone columns - an overview(Ground improvement)Tarachand Veeragattapu
 
Ground Improvement Techniques
Ground Improvement TechniquesGround Improvement Techniques
Ground Improvement TechniquesNilesh Bhosale
 
Determining equivalent single wheel load.(ESWL)
Determining equivalent single wheel load.(ESWL) Determining equivalent single wheel load.(ESWL)
Determining equivalent single wheel load.(ESWL) Imran Nawaz
 
Bearing capacity_of_soil
 Bearing capacity_of_soil Bearing capacity_of_soil
Bearing capacity_of_soilShivarajteggi
 
CONSTRUCTION OF ROADS
CONSTRUCTION OF ROADSCONSTRUCTION OF ROADS
CONSTRUCTION OF ROADSreemajadwani
 

What's hot (20)

Bitumen
BitumenBitumen
Bitumen
 
Soil stabilisation (1)
Soil stabilisation (1)Soil stabilisation (1)
Soil stabilisation (1)
 
Construction of flexible pavements
Construction of flexible pavementsConstruction of flexible pavements
Construction of flexible pavements
 
Pavement materials in Road Construction
Pavement materials in Road ConstructionPavement materials in Road Construction
Pavement materials in Road Construction
 
Design of rigid pavements
Design of rigid pavementsDesign of rigid pavements
Design of rigid pavements
 
Cbr test
Cbr testCbr test
Cbr test
 
Flexible pavement presentation
Flexible pavement presentationFlexible pavement presentation
Flexible pavement presentation
 
ground improvement with admixtures
ground improvement with admixturesground improvement with admixtures
ground improvement with admixtures
 
Ground improvement techniques compaction vibration
Ground improvement techniques  compaction vibrationGround improvement techniques  compaction vibration
Ground improvement techniques compaction vibration
 
Rigid pavement
Rigid pavementRigid pavement
Rigid pavement
 
Plate load test ppt
Plate load test pptPlate load test ppt
Plate load test ppt
 
Proportioning of concrete mix
Proportioning of concrete mixProportioning of concrete mix
Proportioning of concrete mix
 
Cement stabilization of soils ppt
Cement stabilization of soils pptCement stabilization of soils ppt
Cement stabilization of soils ppt
 
Stone columns - an overview(Ground improvement)
Stone columns -  an overview(Ground improvement)Stone columns -  an overview(Ground improvement)
Stone columns - an overview(Ground improvement)
 
Ground Improvement Techniques
Ground Improvement TechniquesGround Improvement Techniques
Ground Improvement Techniques
 
Hardened Concrete
Hardened ConcreteHardened Concrete
Hardened Concrete
 
Determining equivalent single wheel load.(ESWL)
Determining equivalent single wheel load.(ESWL) Determining equivalent single wheel load.(ESWL)
Determining equivalent single wheel load.(ESWL)
 
Bearing capacity_of_soil
 Bearing capacity_of_soil Bearing capacity_of_soil
Bearing capacity_of_soil
 
Pavement design
Pavement designPavement design
Pavement design
 
CONSTRUCTION OF ROADS
CONSTRUCTION OF ROADSCONSTRUCTION OF ROADS
CONSTRUCTION OF ROADS
 

More from Davinderpal Singh

FINENESS TEST OF CEMENT (DRY SIEVING)
FINENESS TEST OF CEMENT (DRY SIEVING)FINENESS TEST OF CEMENT (DRY SIEVING)
FINENESS TEST OF CEMENT (DRY SIEVING)Davinderpal Singh
 
Determination of free swell index of soils
Determination of free swell index of soilsDetermination of free swell index of soils
Determination of free swell index of soilsDavinderpal Singh
 
USE OF WASTE PLASTIC IN BITUMINOUS ROADS
USE OF WASTE PLASTIC IN BITUMINOUS ROADSUSE OF WASTE PLASTIC IN BITUMINOUS ROADS
USE OF WASTE PLASTIC IN BITUMINOUS ROADSDavinderpal Singh
 
Pre-tensioning Prestresssed Devices
Pre-tensioning Prestresssed DevicesPre-tensioning Prestresssed Devices
Pre-tensioning Prestresssed DevicesDavinderpal Singh
 
Post-tensioning in Prestressed Concrete
Post-tensioning in Prestressed ConcretePost-tensioning in Prestressed Concrete
Post-tensioning in Prestressed ConcreteDavinderpal Singh
 
Traffic studies ORIGIN AND DESTINATION STUDIES
Traffic studies ORIGIN AND DESTINATION STUDIESTraffic studies ORIGIN AND DESTINATION STUDIES
Traffic studies ORIGIN AND DESTINATION STUDIESDavinderpal Singh
 
Introduction to Railway Engineering
Introduction to Railway EngineeringIntroduction to Railway Engineering
Introduction to Railway EngineeringDavinderpal Singh
 

More from Davinderpal Singh (7)

FINENESS TEST OF CEMENT (DRY SIEVING)
FINENESS TEST OF CEMENT (DRY SIEVING)FINENESS TEST OF CEMENT (DRY SIEVING)
FINENESS TEST OF CEMENT (DRY SIEVING)
 
Determination of free swell index of soils
Determination of free swell index of soilsDetermination of free swell index of soils
Determination of free swell index of soils
 
USE OF WASTE PLASTIC IN BITUMINOUS ROADS
USE OF WASTE PLASTIC IN BITUMINOUS ROADSUSE OF WASTE PLASTIC IN BITUMINOUS ROADS
USE OF WASTE PLASTIC IN BITUMINOUS ROADS
 
Pre-tensioning Prestresssed Devices
Pre-tensioning Prestresssed DevicesPre-tensioning Prestresssed Devices
Pre-tensioning Prestresssed Devices
 
Post-tensioning in Prestressed Concrete
Post-tensioning in Prestressed ConcretePost-tensioning in Prestressed Concrete
Post-tensioning in Prestressed Concrete
 
Traffic studies ORIGIN AND DESTINATION STUDIES
Traffic studies ORIGIN AND DESTINATION STUDIESTraffic studies ORIGIN AND DESTINATION STUDIES
Traffic studies ORIGIN AND DESTINATION STUDIES
 
Introduction to Railway Engineering
Introduction to Railway EngineeringIntroduction to Railway Engineering
Introduction to Railway Engineering
 

Recently uploaded

IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024Mark Billinghurst
 
INFLUENCE OF NANOSILICA ON THE PROPERTIES OF CONCRETE
INFLUENCE OF NANOSILICA ON THE PROPERTIES OF CONCRETEINFLUENCE OF NANOSILICA ON THE PROPERTIES OF CONCRETE
INFLUENCE OF NANOSILICA ON THE PROPERTIES OF CONCRETEroselinkalist12
 
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...asadnawaz62
 
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdfAsst.prof M.Gokilavani
 
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)Dr SOUNDIRARAJ N
 
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning Unit II Notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning Unit II Notes with Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning Unit II Notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning Unit II Notes with Question bank .pdfAsst.prof M.Gokilavani
 
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...Chandu841456
 
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptxApplication of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx959SahilShah
 
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call GirlsCall Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girlsssuser7cb4ff
 
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting .
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting  .Churning of Butter, Factors affecting  .
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting .Satyam Kumar
 
Study on Air-Water & Water-Water Heat Exchange in a Finned Tube Exchanger
Study on Air-Water & Water-Water Heat Exchange in a Finned Tube ExchangerStudy on Air-Water & Water-Water Heat Exchange in a Finned Tube Exchanger
Study on Air-Water & Water-Water Heat Exchange in a Finned Tube ExchangerAnamika Sarkar
 
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.eptoze12
 
Past, Present and Future of Generative AI
Past, Present and Future of Generative AIPast, Present and Future of Generative AI
Past, Present and Future of Generative AIabhishek36461
 
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdfAsst.prof M.Gokilavani
 
GDSC ASEB Gen AI study jams presentation
GDSC ASEB Gen AI study jams presentationGDSC ASEB Gen AI study jams presentation
GDSC ASEB Gen AI study jams presentationGDSCAESB
 
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdfElectronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdfme23b1001
 
Gurgaon ✡️9711147426✨Call In girls Gurgaon Sector 51 escort service
Gurgaon ✡️9711147426✨Call In girls Gurgaon Sector 51 escort serviceGurgaon ✡️9711147426✨Call In girls Gurgaon Sector 51 escort service
Gurgaon ✡️9711147426✨Call In girls Gurgaon Sector 51 escort servicejennyeacort
 
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfidmain PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfidNikhilNagaraju
 

Recently uploaded (20)

IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
 
INFLUENCE OF NANOSILICA ON THE PROPERTIES OF CONCRETE
INFLUENCE OF NANOSILICA ON THE PROPERTIES OF CONCRETEINFLUENCE OF NANOSILICA ON THE PROPERTIES OF CONCRETE
INFLUENCE OF NANOSILICA ON THE PROPERTIES OF CONCRETE
 
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
 
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
 
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
 
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning Unit II Notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning Unit II Notes with Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning Unit II Notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning Unit II Notes with Question bank .pdf
 
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
 
Call Us -/9953056974- Call Girls In Vikaspuri-/- Delhi NCR
Call Us -/9953056974- Call Girls In Vikaspuri-/- Delhi NCRCall Us -/9953056974- Call Girls In Vikaspuri-/- Delhi NCR
Call Us -/9953056974- Call Girls In Vikaspuri-/- Delhi NCR
 
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptxApplication of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
 
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call GirlsCall Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
 
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting .
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting  .Churning of Butter, Factors affecting  .
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting .
 
Study on Air-Water & Water-Water Heat Exchange in a Finned Tube Exchanger
Study on Air-Water & Water-Water Heat Exchange in a Finned Tube ExchangerStudy on Air-Water & Water-Water Heat Exchange in a Finned Tube Exchanger
Study on Air-Water & Water-Water Heat Exchange in a Finned Tube Exchanger
 
9953056974 Call Girls In South Ex, Escorts (Delhi) NCR.pdf
9953056974 Call Girls In South Ex, Escorts (Delhi) NCR.pdf9953056974 Call Girls In South Ex, Escorts (Delhi) NCR.pdf
9953056974 Call Girls In South Ex, Escorts (Delhi) NCR.pdf
 
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
 
Past, Present and Future of Generative AI
Past, Present and Future of Generative AIPast, Present and Future of Generative AI
Past, Present and Future of Generative AI
 
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
 
GDSC ASEB Gen AI study jams presentation
GDSC ASEB Gen AI study jams presentationGDSC ASEB Gen AI study jams presentation
GDSC ASEB Gen AI study jams presentation
 
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdfElectronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
 
Gurgaon ✡️9711147426✨Call In girls Gurgaon Sector 51 escort service
Gurgaon ✡️9711147426✨Call In girls Gurgaon Sector 51 escort serviceGurgaon ✡️9711147426✨Call In girls Gurgaon Sector 51 escort service
Gurgaon ✡️9711147426✨Call In girls Gurgaon Sector 51 escort service
 
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfidmain PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
 

Marshall test

  • 1. MARSHALL TEST RESULT’S  IT IS CONDUCTED IN TWO STAGE’S  SPECIMEN PREPARATION.  SPECIMEN TESTING.
  • 2. SAMPLE GRADED AND DRIED HEATING UP SAMPLE MIX WITH BITUMEN MOULDING SAMPLE READY FOR TESTING
  • 3. SPECIMEN PREPARATION  WE USED FULLER’S FORMULA FOR GRADING AND PREPARED SPREADSHEET FOR THAT ALSO.  WHERE ‘p’ is PERCENTAGE PASSING THROUGH SIEVE UNDER CONSIDERATION ‘D’ is LARGEST PARTICLE SIZE ‘d’ is SIEVE UNDER CONSIDERATION ‘n’ is FULLER INDEX AND TAKEN as 0.45 by us.
  • 5. NOTATIONS W1, W2, W3 AND Wb ARE WEIGHT OF COARSE AGGREGATES, FINE AGGREGATES, FILLER AND BITUMEN RESPECTIVELY. V1, V2, V3, Vb AND Vv ARE VOLUME OF COARSE AGGREGATES, FINE AGGREGATES, FILLER, BITUMEN AND AIR VOIDS G1, G2, G3 AND Gb ARE SPECIFIC GRAVITIES OF COARSE AGGREGATES, FINE AGGREGATES, FILLER AND BITUMEN
  • 6. FORMULA’S USED Gt THEORETICAL SPECIFIC GRAVITY Gm BULK SPECIFIC GRAVITY Vv AIR VOIDS IN SAMPLE Vb VOIDS FILLED WITH BITUMEN VMA VOIDS IN MINERAL AGGREGATES VFB VOIDS FILLED BY BITUMEN
  • 8. TESTING DATA FOR OPTIMUM BITUMEN CONTENT Sample No. Bitumen Content (%) Marshall Stability Value (kg) Flow Value (in 0.25mm units) Bulk Specific Gravity Air Voids (%) VFB (%) 1) 4 1037.31 10 2.37 3.83 71.54 2) 4.5 1632.62 11 2.39 2.26 83.74 3) 5 2035.48 12 2.40 1.85 86.29 4) 5.5 2084.40 14 2.39 1.53 89.26 5) 6 1379.62 17 2.38 0.93 93.90
  • 9. CHARTS  MARSHALL STABILITY VS BITUMEN CONTENT
  • 10. CHARTS  FLOW VALUE VS BITUMEN CONTENT
  • 11. CHARTS  AIR VOIDS VS BITUMEN CONTENT
  • 12. CHARTS  BULK SPECIFIC GRAVITY VS BITUMEN CONTENT
  • 13. CHARTS  VFB VS BITUMEN CONTENT
  • 14. OPTIMUM BITUMEN CONTENT  BITUMEN CONTENT CORRESPONDING TO MAXIMUM MARSHALL STABILITY VALUE= 5.5%  BITUMEN CONTENT CORRESPONDING TO MAXIMUM BULK SPECIFIC GRAVITY= 5%  BITUMEN CONTENT CORRESPONDING TO MEDIAN (4%) OF AIR VOIDS %= 4%  AVERAGE VALUE= 4.8%  THEREFORE OPTIMUM BITUMEN CONTENT= 4.8%
  • 15. “Engineering problems are under-defined, there are many solutions, good, bad and indifferent. The art is to arrive at a good solution. This is a creative activity, involving imagination, intuition and deliberate choice.” OVE ARUP Engineers … are not superhuman. They make mistakes in their assumptions, in their calculations, in their conclusions. That they make mistakes is forgivable; that they catch them is imperative. Thus it is the essence of modern engineering not only to be able to check one’s own work but also to have one’s work checked and to be able to check the work of others.