This document summarizes a presentation given by Dr. Sadhana Mohan on the development of detector grade silicon technology at BARC. The presentation covers silicon's role in advanced technologies, the criteria for detector grade silicon, and BARC's roadmap for developing silicon technology, including producing trichlorosilane, purifying it, making polysilicon, growing single crystal ingots via float zone pulling, slicing wafers, and characterizing products. It discusses the challenges of growing large, defect-free crystals and maintaining steady operations over long periods. BARC's goal is to demonstrate integrated high-purity silicon wafer production technology.
1. National Symposium on Growth of
Device-Grade Single Crystal
Development of High Purity Detector
Grade Silicon Technology at BARC
Dr. Sadhana Mohan
19th to 21th November 2009 Mumbai
2. 2
Outline of the presentation
1. Role of silicon in advanced technologies
2. Detector Grade Silicon
3. BARC Roadmap of silicon technology development
4. Detector Grade Silicon Production routes
5. Process Selection Criteria
6. Product characterization
7. Status of Detector Grade Silicon Production at BARC
8. Conclusion
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
3. 3
We have entered the age of super computing ,
multimedia and instant communication. In today’ s
scenario, life is unimaginable without these gadgets
Silicon is the foundation of these sophisticated and
advanced technologies .
Over 80% of semiconductor industry base is crystalline
silicon, out of which 5% is the share of detector grade
As on today ,photovoltaic grade silicon production
technology is commercially available while detector
grade technology is still closely guarded
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Role of silicon in advanced technologies
4. 4
Why silicon in general has major share ?
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Silicon is most fascinating semiconductor material due to its
favorable energy gap, insulating properties and the ease with
which its electronic properties can be altered.
It is the second largest element after oxygen in the earth crust
It has better thermo physical properties which determine how
heat and mass transport can be managed at the time of crystal
growth
silicon has reasonably high thermal conductivity, stacking fault
energy and critical resolved shear stress conforming its ability
to make large size dislocation free single crystal.
5. 5
Silicon MEMS
IC
ULSI/VLSI
Solar Cell
Silicon Mirror
Porous
silicon
Radiation
Detector
High Power
Devices
IR Reflectors
& Windows
Overall spectrum of silicon applications
19th Nov, 09 NSRC, Mumbai
6. Applications of High Purity Silicon
Purity of Silicon as determined by concentration of
defects determines its suitability for applications.
High Purity Silicon is used in microelectronics industry
and in manufacturing of radiation detectors.
Solar
Grade
(Cd≈10-6, 5 Ω-cm, 10 µsec)
Microelectronic
Grade
(Cd≈10-6, 1KΩ-cm, 100 µsec)
Detector
Grade
(Cd≈10-6, 30 KΩ-cm, 1000 µsec)
7. 7
Why do we need Detector grade silicon ?
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
To improve Large size integrated circuits (VLSI/ULSI)
efficiency high resistivity defect free single crystal is the parent
material
To improve sensitivity of radiation detectors for detecting small
quantities of high energy neutrons and charged particles needs
negligible leakage current and large sensitive volume .
Economic production of high power devices and high
sensitivity radiation detectors demands large diameter detector
grade single crystal ingot production facility .
8. 8
PREPARATION OF HR SINGLE CRYSTAL SILICON INGOT
Metallurgical grade
silicon
CO
Si
C
SiO 2
2
2
TCS Production
2
3
3 H
SiHCl
HCl
Si
TCS Purification
TCS purification by distillation
Si: 98%
Polysilicon Production in
a CVD reactor
HCl
Si
H
SiHCl 3
2
3
Si: 99.999999999%
HR Single crystal silicon
ingot production in a FZ
crystal puller
9. 9
Front End
facility
development
Backend
Facility
development
Poly silicon
production
BARC Parallel approach to technology development
UHP grade TCS
purification
TCS
production
Float Zone
Crystal pulling
Wafer production
Wafer Characterization
Detector
Fabrication
Central
Crystal
Pulling
Facility
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Neutron
Transmutation
Single Crystal
Pulling
Facility
Detector
Testing
10. 10
Major Commercially viable Technology options
20th Nov, 09
• Siemens process
• Trichlorosilane as volatile precursor
• Most preferred process as 80% of commercial
market is captured by Siemens process
• Major :Wacker chemie, Hemlock,
• Union carbide process
• Silane as volatile precursor
• ASIMI taken over union carbide and komatsu
Front End Facility Development
11. 11
Union carbide process
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
• Distinct advantages
• Better purification due to large
separation factors for major
impurities
• Non corrosive system
• Less recycled product handling at
poly step
• Major issues
• Difficult to manufacture with low
yield and large recycle
• Handling of Non target deposition
at poly step
• Gas at room temperature high
pressure storage
• Pyrophoric in nature
Front End Facility Development
Mg-Si
Intermediate
SiH4
HR Silicon
UNION CARBIDE PROECSS
12. 12
Siemens process
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Distinct advantages
• Less number of process steps
• Better overall production yield
• Liquid at room temperature
• Non pyrophoric
Major issues:
• Highly corrosive in presence of
moisture
• Hardens most of the sealing materials
• Clogs small sample tubes if left open
after use
• Needs proper ventilated secondary
containment
Front End Facility Development
Mg-Si
Intermediate
SiHCl3
HR Silicon
SIEMENS PROECSS
13. 13
TCS production
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Properties of TCS:
Boiling Point: 32 oC
Flammability Range: 7 to 86%
DOT Class: 4.3
(dangerous when wet)
TLV: 5 ppm
STEL: 100 ppm
Heat of Combustion: 494 kJ/mol
Flash Point: -17 oC
Auto Ignition Point: 170 oC
Front End Facility Development
Mg-Si
HCl (g)
TCS (g)
+ STC(g)
+ H2 (g)
+HCl (g)
Condenser
H2 (g)
+HCl (g)
TCS (l)
+ STC(l)
FBR
14. 14
TCS purification
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Design intent
High integrity helium leak tested joints highly
electropolished SS surface, ppt level purification in five stage
squared off distillation cascade, enough redundancy
Key issues
ppt level analysis
Sustained operation of Boiling TCS handling pump
Arresting TCS leak in case of abnormalities
Handling clogging in case of improper purging
Front End Facility Development
15. 15
Polysilicon production
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Cold wall CVD reactor
Specific advantages :No scale up
issues ,No joining issues to base
plate and reactor wall, No operating
pressure limit
Preferred in Photovoltaic grade
silicon production
Quartz CVD reactors
Specific advantage
Better purity of poly produced
preferred for detector grade
Front End Facility Development
16. 16
Influence of operating parameters
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Simulation Results :
Increasing pressure decreases
Equillibrium yield but increases rate of
production
Increasing TCS to Hydrogen ration decreses
equillibrium yield but increases production
Yield increases substantially upto 1100c
At low scale low pressure low TCS is better
while at large scale it is higher pressure higher
TCS concentration is preferred one
Specific issues:
Temperature contol of growing surface
Deposition control with time
acrobolite formation of quartz making it opaque
Preheating of near insulating slim rod at
room temperatureCore meltdown in case
of improper heat transfer
Front End Facility Development
17. 17
Large size Single crystal pulling
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Cz process photo its distinct advantages
Gravity stablised molten zone
Less operators control
less steep temperature gradient
Central crystal pulling facility
18. 18
Large size Single crystal pulling
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Cz process photo its
distinct advantages
Gravity stablised molten
zone
Less operators control
less steep temperature
gradient
Crystal seed
Molten
polysilic
on
Heat shield
Water jacket
Single
crystal
silicon
Quartz
crucible
Carbon
heating
element
Crystal
puller and
rotation
mechanism
19. 19
Float zone crystal pulling
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Distinct advantages
No containment impurity pickup by molten silicon
Less power requirement due to small molten zone
Less silicon inventory loss
No problem of crucible cracking due to volume expansion after solidification
Most Suited for Large size defect free crystal detector grade silicon
Key issues
Floating molten zone instability
Vibration control
Arching control
Argon purity control
Class 10 environment control
Proper Engagement of support system for large weight support system
less steep temperature gradient
Our observations:
Central crystal pulling facility
20. 20
Float zone crystal pulling
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Distinct advantages
• No containment impurity pickup
by molten silicon
• Less power requirement due to
small molten zone
• Less silicon inventory loss
• No problem of crucible cracking
due to volume expansion after
solidification
• Most Suited for Large size defect
free crystal detector grade silicon
Central crystal pulling facility
21. 21
Float zone crystal pulling
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Key issues
• Floating molten zone instability
• Vibration control
• Arching control
• Argon purity control
• Class 10 environment control
• Proper Engagement of support
system for large weight support
system
• less steep temperature gradient
Our observations:
Central crystal pulling facility
23. 23
Complexities involved in Silicon crystal pulling
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Maintenance of Steady & Uninterrupted Power Supply to the
Reactor for Very Long Time (continuously 15 days)
Very Fine & Vibration free Control of Moving and Rotating parts
Arching Problem during Crystal Pulling
Very Fine Control of Power Input is Required because of
Solidification or Spillage problem
Minimization of Crystal Structural Defects
Making Long Single Crystal (1000 mm)
Mechanical Fabrication (Turning, Grinding etc.) Difficulties of 1000
mm long and 100 mm dia. Rods
Providing Cooling to Coil and other Structural parts
Central crystal pulling facility
24. 24
Wafer preparation: Slicing
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Central crystal pulling facility
Single Crystal silicon ingot End Cutting OD Grinding
Flat Grinding
Wafer Slicing
Wafer Polishing
Wafer Lapping Edge Rounding
PRIME GRADE Si
WAFER
25. Cropping is the first step for preparing
the crystal for wafering. In this step end
conical portions of ingot is sliced off.
Purpose:
– to cut the crystal to a suitable length to fit the
saw capacity.
– to obtain samples for oxygen and carbon
measurements.
– to select portions of the crystal which meet
desired resistivity specification.
Wafer preparation: Cropping
Important Aspects
– Commercial cropping equipment
ranges from simple hand-operated
cut-off machines to those which
hydraulically clamp the crystal and
move the blade through the crystal
– The blade diameter must be
sufficiently large to cut completely
through the crystal in one pass in
order to obtain a smooth and
straight cut.
– ID saw machine is mostly preferred
to minimize kerf loss and material
damage and for smooth cutting.
26. OD Grinding: Crystal outer diameter is
ground to the required diameter using a
fixed abrasive grinding wheel.
Purpose:
• to obtain wafers of precise diameter.
Issues
• Improper grinding may create problem of
exit chipping in wafering and lattice slip in
thermal processing.
Wafer preparation: OD Grinding
Center less Grinding
Grinding on Centers
27. Wafer preparation: Flat Grinding
Flat Grinding: Silicon crystals are grown with
either the crystallographic <loo> or <111>
direction parallel to the cylindrical axis of the
crystal. The identification flats (there may be
one or two on a crystal) are ground lengthwise
along the crystal according the to the crystal
orientation and the dopant type. The largest flat
is called the primary flat, and is used for
positioning the wafer for front end processing
such as patterning or dicing. A secondary flat
may also be ground on the crystal. The specific
arrangements of flats make it easy to identify
the orientation (111 or 100) and the material (n-
or p-type).
SEMI locations for
orientation/identification flats
28. Wafer preparation: Wafer slicing
28
Inner Diameter Sawing
Imbedded
diamond
particles
350-400 μm
(kerf loss)
wafer
ID saw blade (rotating)
Material properties: Silicon is a
very hard and brittle material
(Mohs’ hardness scale: 7-8 )
Diamond coated blades used for
wafer slicing
Specification of the final
prepared wafers:
Wafer thickness: 300-1000 µm
TTV: <10 µm
Kerf loss: < 0.4 mm
Bow: < 30 µm
Surface damage: <2 µm
Preparation of work
piece for mounting
ingot
Work piece
guide (graphite)
Adhesive
29. 29
Wafer preparation: Slicing
20th Nov, 09 Dr. Sadhana Mohan, BARC, Mumbai
Central crystal pulling facility
Wafer Slicing: Wafer slicing from silicon block
are mainly performed by ID saw machine