3. Viewability Definitions and Status
• The IAB definition for “In-View”: >50% of an ad’s pixels in view for > one
continuous second
• On March 30th, the MRC lifted its advisory against trading on viewability,
and in its opinion, the measurement ecosystem has reached a state where
parties can begin to move towards trading on viewability.
• On June 30th, the MRC released its standard for In-StreamVideo
advertising, which currently stands at the same 50% of pixels,
but for two seconds.
4. Moat:Time Inc Ad Campaigns, 2014
Viewability Can be Good for Publishers,Too
In-View Rate vs. Engagement Rate
Time Inc Campaign Placements: 2014
InteractionRate%
Viewability Rate %
5. Source:
Integral Ad Science; Q2, 2014
ComScore vCE; Q2,2014
MOAT; Q2, 2014
So What’s Average?
47.6%
45.9%
49.4%
Exchanges Networks Direct Publishers
45.9%
PremiumNon-Premium
45.4%
728x90 300x250 970x250 300x1050
45.9% 48.4%
55.5%43.5%
54.8%
59.6% 61.4%
6. 19.7
10.3
5.4
4.0
Out of Sight Out of Focus Missed Opportunity
Time
Missed Opportunity
Area
Out-of-View Impressions
Moat Analytics: Q2-2014 Benchmarks
Website X Search
Headline - #1
Lorem ipsum dolor sit
amet, consectetur
adipiscing elit, sed
Article Number 2 Headline
Article Number 3 Headline
Article Number 4 Headline
Article Number 5 Headline
Article Number 6 Headline
Ad Unit
#1
Video’s of the day
Trending
What’s Hot
Article Number 2 Headline
Article Number 3 Headline
Article Number 4 Headline
Article Number 5 Headline
Article Number 6 Headline
Tweet #1
Tweet #2
Tweet #3
Tweet #4
Tweet #5
Newsletter
Signup
Content Feature #1 Content Feature #2
From around the Web
email
Company Info
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
Out of
View
What’s Driving this Non-Viewable Rate?
7. What’s Driving this Non-Viewable Rate?
Moat Analytics: Q2-2014 Benchmarks
19.7
10.3
5.4
4.0
Out of Sight Out of Focus Missed Opportunity
Time
Missed Opportunity
Area
Out-of-View Impressions
8. What’s Driving this Non-Viewable Rate?
Moat Analytics: Q2-2014 Benchmarks
19.7
10.3
5.4
4.0
Out of Sight Out of Focus Missed Opportunity
Time
Missed Opportunity
Area
Out-of-View Impressions
9. Website X Search
Headline - #1
Lorem ipsum dolor sit
amet, consectetur
adipiscing elit, sed
Article Number 2 Headline
Article Number 3 Headline
Article Number 4 Headline
Article Number 5 Headline
Article Number 6 Headline
Ad Unit
#1
Trending
What’s Hot
Article Number 2 Headline
Article Number 3 Headline
Article Number 4 Headline
Article Number 5 Headline
Article Number 6 Headline
Tweet #1
Tweet #2
What’s Driving this Non-Viewable Rate?
Moat Analytics: Q2-2014 Benchmarks
19.7
10.3
5.4
4.0
Out of Sight Out of Focus Missed Opportunity
Time
Missed Opportunity
Area
Out-of-View Impressions
11. So How isTime Inc. Addressing this Issue?
Analyze Optimize
2.1. 3.
Audit
12. Network Audit
Worked with many of the leading players in the viewability
measurement space, including ComScore’s vCE, vME, Nielsen’s
OCR, MOAT, and Double Click’s ActiveView
14. Website X Search
Tweet #1
Tweet #2
Tweet #3
Tweet #4
Tweet #5
From around the Web
email
ATF
Ad Unit
Learnings & Best Practices
• Above-the-Fold ad, adjacent to
the content.
• Still subject to potential issues
due to Out of Focus, Opportunity
Time.
• Another important consideration
is the screen resolution, and
specifically browser height.
15. Website X Search
Tweet #1
Tweet #2
Tweet #3
Tweet #4
Tweet #5
From around the Web
email
Company Info
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
BTF
Ad Unit
• Every page has, or should have,
an intended consumer path.
• Ads that are aligned with that
primary path do well in terms of
viewability
• This is probably more important
than the Above-the-Fold/Below-
the-Fold delineations.
Learnings & Best Practices
16. Website X Search
Tweet #1
Tweet #2
Tweet #3
Tweet #4
Tweet #5
From around the Web
email
BTF
Ad Unit
ATF Ad Unit
Learnings & Best Practices
18. Website X Search
Photo Caption
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet,
consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
ATF
Ad Unit
Video’s of the day
Content Feature #1 Content Feature #2
From around the Web
Company Info
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
Learnings & Best Practices
Website X Search
19. Photo Caption
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet,
consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
BTF
Ad Unit
Video’s of the day
Content Feature #1 Content Feature #2
From around the Web
Company Info
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed
Website X Search
Learnings & Best Practices
Website X Search
21. Time.com Redesign: Home Page
Home Page StoryWell.
Cleaner design encourages deeper
engagement with the content
Home Page ContentWell
300 x 250 Ad Unit Fixed
Position Above-the-
Fold
Responsive design that optimizes
to accommodate desktop, tablet
and mobile form factors
22. Time.com Redesign: Article Page
Fixed above the fold
300 x 250 unit.
Viewable until new article loaded
and then ad refreshes
Flex UnitAd Position
embedded in the Content
Well. “Lazy-loaded” within
20 pixels of being in view
ContentWell, unlimited
scroll format encourages
deeper engagement with
the content
StoryWell, contains most
recently published and top
trending articles.
23. SI Redesign: Home Page
Premium Positioning
for 300 x 250
Premium Positioning
for 300 x 140
Units below the fold
– “lazy loaded” to
improve viewability
Flexible content modules
that facilitate full range of
desktop, tablet and mobile
form factors
24. SI.com Redesign: Photo Galleries
Opens into a full screen Gallery.
Superior consumer experience for
photos, plus offers more real
estate for ad units
Fixed iFrame for photo
captions creates fixed
position for ad unit
Above the fold, fixed
position 300 x 250.
Intended consumer path is
to click the next button, and
therefore no ads below
the fold
Time Inc is in the business of creating unique, premium content experiences across our 21 digital brands, that deliver incredible value to loyal audiences and advertising partners.
The assumptions going in to this initiative were that viewability was an known, but unspoken issue across the industry – and that collectively, premium publishers will probably benefit to a greater extent vs other publishers, who may have had less emphasis on servicing advertisers through their direct relationships.
While most responsible publishers had traditionally designed their experiences to ensure advertising was given prominent positioning within that experience, there was very little data available to evaluate and optimize how well they were doing.
Enter the new ecosystem of vendors promising a single line of code that would solve all the problems of viewability.
While this technology has been available for some time, a lack of standards and inconsistency in reporting have prevented this a fully embraced action plan by many publishers.
Time Inc has been working with a broad range of vendors to measure, analyze and optimize their websites to deliver the best possible advertising experiences for you, our advertising partners
The IAB definition for “In-View”: >50% of a Ad’s pixels in view for > 1 continuous second. Large ad units @ 30%
On March 30th, the MRC lifted it’s advisory against trading on viewability, and in it’s opinion, the measurement ecosystem has reached a state where parties can begin to move towards trading on viewability.
On June 30th, the MRC released it’s standard for in-Stream Video advertising, which currently stands at the same 50% of pixels, but for 2 seconds.
Measure:
Have conducted a number of Site and Campaign audits leveraging many of the key MRC certified vendors in the space, including DoubleClick’s Active View, ComScore’s vCE, Integral Ad Science, and MOAT.
Process has helped us to develop a deeper appreciation for the differences in methodology and challenges inherent in viewability measurement.
Analyze
Leveraging multiple data streams, Time Inc performed a detailed analysis across our 21 web brands, drilling down to the site, channel, sub-channel, creative size, position on page.
What we found was both good and bad.
Good: Most of our sites were built with templates that delivered strong viewability ratings that were significantly above industry averages.
Bad: nearly every site had at least one or 2 placements that were dragging overall site performance below what should be the natural rate for the site.
Our inventory was ranked from top to bottom – according to performance and scale to help us prioritize an action plan.
Optimize:
The good news about the audit, is that all of these problematic placements are adressable through a combination of
Inventory management
Technology
Design
Measure:
Have conducted a number of Site and Campaign audits leveraging many of the key MRC certified vendors in the space, including DoubleClick’s Active View, ComScore’s vCE, Integral Ad Science, and MOAT. Process has helped us to develop a deeper appreciation for the differences in methodology and the many challenges inherent in viewability measurement.
While the MRC certification process helps to ensure the various vendors speak about viewability in a common language, we still see the vendors speaking different dialects, of that same language, which will hopefully evolve to a more consistent view of the issue.
Having completed our audit we classified every placement across our network into 4 priority buckets, based on current viewability rating and size/value of the placement. In the dark green quadrant, these are the placements that have been prioritized as they have scale and value, but operating below where we would like. Focusing on this quadrant will address the most immediate needs and given that many of the recommended best practices are design based, some of the template changes implemented here, will also impact the viewability of placements in other quadrants.
The second priority was placed on those smaller placement that had lower viewability ratings, followed by the larger, high viewability placements where we might squeeze additional efficiency points form these placements, which would have significant impact due to their scale.
Let’s start with some one the more basic findings – which is not big revelation. Ads that sit above the fold and are adjacent to meaningful content, will have high viewability ratings. Still subject to potential issues due to Out of Focus, Opportunity Time.
Another important consideration is the screen resolution, and specifically browser height.
However – we have also found that those ad placements that are directly aligned with