1. „ Testing the acceptance of e-participation in
France “
Noam Bercovici – nb@ontopica.de
BODDY 24.06.2013

2. Agenda
About ontopica
Search of topics for participation
Experimentation in Vanves
Open data endpoint in Cologne
02
03
01
04

3. About ontopica
• Founded in 2003
• e-participation
• mainly public sector

4. Search of topics for participation02
11/12
First
contact
with open
cities
02/12
Finalizing
the topic
04-07/12
Convincing
10/12
Beta-test
In Vanves
12/12
Debriefing
And learning

5. Search of topics for participation02
11/12
First contact
with open cities
02/12
Finalizing
the topic
04-07/12
Convincing
10/12
Beta-test
In Vanves
12/12
Debriefing
And learning
•proposing 2 scenarios
• French presidential election
• Noise reduction planning

6. Search of topics for participation02

7. Search of topics for participation02
Bonn Mayors
election
2009

8. Search of topics for participation02
• feedback dimensions
• affirmation
• proficiency requirement
• (credibility?)

9. Search of topics for participation02
11/12
First contact
with open cities
02/12
Finalizing
the topic
04-07/12
Convincing
10/12
Beta-test
In Vanves
12/12
Debriefing
And learning
• French presidential election
• Potentially too polemic
• Gaulois Vs. German
• Noise reduction planning
• Consensual topic
Rejected
Approved

10. Search of topics for participation02
11/12
First
contact
with open
cities
02/12
Finalizing
the topic
04-07/12
Convincing
10/12
Beta-test
In Vanves
12/12
Debriefing
And learning
• French NGO specialized for noise
• Critical towards e-participation
• Authority of the “real” measurements (administration ><
Bruitparif)

11. Search of topics for participation02
11/12
First
contact
with open
cities
02/12
Finalizing
the topic
04-07/12
Convincing
10/12
Beta-test
In Vanves
12/12
Debriefing
And learning
• Administration
• Preferred a safe test bed
• Restricted and protected environment
• Do a simulation of participation first

12. Experimentation in Vanves03
11/12
First
contact
with open
cities
02/12
Finalizing
the topic
04-07/12
Convincing
10/12
Beta-test
In Vanves
12/12
Debriefing
And learning

13. Experimentation in Vanves03

14. Experimentation in Vanves03

15. Experimentation in Vanves03

16. Experimentation in Vanves03

17. Experimentation in Vanves (numbers)03
Number of participants: 49
Number of weeks 3
Number of votes: 37
Page impressions 1165

18. Experimentation in Vanves (Summary)
• Vanves’ administration
• Start to think to make use of online dialog
• But not at one year of the election
• Citizens are asking
• for such tools to speed up the reactivity of the
administrations
03

19. Experimentation in Vanves (Summary)
• Excellent support from opencites’ partners
• Cap digital and Institut mine télécom
• Lobbying
• Men force
• Bearstech
• Technical advice and support
• Server infrastructure
• Reactivity
03

20. Consuming and producing structured data04

21. Open data endpoint in Cologne
• First linked open data endpoint for e-
participation data
• Open data endpoint in Feb 2013
• Sparql endpoint which allow querying cross
dataset
• Extensible via facade services
• compatible to workflow systems
• Open311
• Example of query: retrieve me all type of
noise which was positively voted 200 meter
around “Kölner Dom”
04

22. Noam Bercovici
E-Mail:
noam.bercovici@ontopica.de
Tel.: 0228 / 227229-11
ontopica GmbH
Prinz-Albert-Str. 2b
53113 Bonn
Tel.: 0228 / 227229-0
Fax: 0228 / 227229-77
Web: http://www.ontopica.de
Contact