Low GI carbs – Can sugars play a role? The example of Palatinose™ (isomaltulose)
1. 17004p-SUN_Low GI carbs_FDIN 20170307
Low GI carbs
Can sugars play a role?
The example of Palatinose™ (isomaltulose)
Silke Ullmann, MPH, Registered Dietitian
Manager Nutrition Communication
The nutrition and health challenges that lead to the public health message on sugar reduction
Noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), also known as chronic diseases, are not passed from person to person. They are of long duration and generally slow progression. The 4 main types of noncommunicable diseases are cardiovascular diseases (like heart attacks and stroke), cancers, chronic respiratory diseases (such as chronic obstructed pulmonary disease and asthma) and diabetes.
Small mistakes in what we eat on a daily basis may lead to major health problems later in life!
Doing small things right may help to prevent non-communicable diseases or delay their onset
http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/128038/1/9789241507509_eng.pdf?ua=1 (newer data?)
Today, ~80% of the world depends on 4 (carb) staples:
- wheat
rice
corn
potato
Most carbohydrate-based foods of a modern diet have a medium to high Glycaemic Index which leads to high blood glucose levels throughout the day
There is years and years of research on the benefits of a low GI diet compared to a high GI diet. I could talk about this for the next 2 hrs…here is a snapshot of several studies to show that there is sufficient evidence…you get the picture
Livesey was among the 18 key academics
Health benefits of reduced glycemia also acknowledged by science & academia; and from survey we see that consumers are also interested in it & see the benefit → the environment/setting/surrounding is set/here: everyone sees it & accepts/acknowledges it
Lowering blood glucose levels connected to lower insulin levels counts!
Scientific Consensus Committee
Chairs:
David J.A. Jenkins (University of Toronto)
Walter C. Willett (Harvard School of Public Health)
Members:
Additional 18 key academics of the GI and GL research field
Folie reinnehmen und nur kurz key message erwähnen:
Science experts see benefits of reducing glycaemia (previous slides)
Science experts from EFSA likewise see „reducing glycaemia“ as a benefit to health for the general population, corresponding claims have been approved for several food ingredients, respectively, like – among others – Palatinose™
Legal authorities also acknowledged the health benefit of reducing glycaemia => Positive EFSA opinions (polyols/P‘ose, fibers)
EFSA has acknowledged the health benefit of reducing glycaemia
Claims can be made…
EFSA approved the following claim for sugar replacers where Palatinose™ (isomaltulose) is included:
“Consumption of foods/drinks containing isomaltulose instead of other sugars induces a lower blood glucose rise after their consumption compared to sugar-containing foods/drinks”
All data compiled and sent to EFSA as 13(5) dossier
Positive opinion
EFSA approved the following claim for non-digestible carbohydrates where inulin and oligofructose are included:
“Consumption of foods/drinks containing inulin/oligofructose instead of sugars induces a lower blood glucose rise after meals compared to sugar-containing foods/drinks”,
“The Panel considers that the reduction of post-prandial glycaemic responses (as long as post-prandial insulinaemic responses are not disproportionally increased) may be a beneficial physiological effect.”
EFSA evaluation of the scientific substantiation from initially 3 human intervention studies with inulin,
showing that sugars replacement with chicory root fibres reduces the postprandial glycaemic response.
Conditions for the claim: 30% sugars replacement for chicory root fibres.
Note: The application referred to inulin, whereas the EFSA opinion confirmed the substance effect relationship more broadly and thus all chicory root fibres are included.
Conditions for the claim: 30% sugars replacement for chicory root fibres
Similar to Livesey before, the authors here see the problem that higher GI/GL diets differ in many ways other than…focus on the fact that there is more to it besides the GI/GL to have a beneficial health effect => make transition to next slide: blood glucose response as a direct effect to insulin vs. GI/GL have indirect effect
Glycaemia defines as blood glucose level or area under the curve following a two-hour glucose tolerance test.
Effects have been seen, but limited outcome because too many influencing factors for a straight link to GI or GL that‘s why insulin matters
Association exists for cohort studies
Effects exists for randomised controlled trials
Evidence is based on the availability of data
Authors‘ conclusions:
“There are, however, many influences on glycaemic index and glycaemic load over and above the content and quality of carbohydrates in a food, both physiological and dietary, not all of which are understood.”
“Higher and lower GI/GL diets will, in most cases, differ in many ways other than the carbohydrate fraction therefore the majority of the literature on GI and GL does not allow for certainty that the carbohydrate content of an exposure is the sole influence on the GI or GL of a diet.”
“Consequently, the effects and associations on health described in the meta-analyses cannot be specifically attributed to the GI or GL and may be a result of other associated factors such as dietary fibre, protein or fat content, as well as cooking methods, food processing, and storage.”
The relevance of a high glycemic diet vs a low glycemic diet becomes evident from the role of insulin and its metabolic effects:
Insulin is the key hormone for the metabolic regulation after a carbohydrate-rich meal.
High blood glucose levels trigger a high insulin release. Insulin facilitates the uptake of glucose from the blood into the cells and normalizes blood glucose levels.
Furthermore, in the muscle, insulin promotes carbohydrate oxidation on the expense of fat oxidation in energy metabolism,
It also inhibits fat utilization in the liver and promotes the conversion of excess nutrients into fat, and
In fat tissue it promotes fat storage and prevents the mobilisation and “melting” of fat stores.
Overall, insulin a “storage hormone” that favors the use of carbohydrate sources and the storage of fat. Having this in mind, it becomes evident that lower blood glucose levels and respective lower insulin profiles lead to an improved metabolic conditions with physiological benefits.
SACN states that food chemical classification does not reflect physiological properties
Isomaltulose (Palatinose™), das besondere Kohlenhydrat mit langsamer Resorption, niedriger Blutzuckerwirkung und vorteilhafter Energieverbrennung!
What is Palatinose™?
Palatinose™ is a slow release carbohydrate. It supplies the body with the full carbohydrate energy in a slower more balanced way over a longer period of time than conventional carbohydrates.
Like sucrose, Palatinose™ is a disaccharide carbohydrate, more specifically a sugar, composed of glucose and fructose.
Its generic name is isomaltulose and it occurs naturally, for instance, in honey.
On commercial scale Palatinose™ is made from sucrose by rearrangement of the linkage turning the alpha-1,2 glycosidic linkage in sucrose into a more stable alpha 1,6 glycosidic linkage in Palatinose™.
Isomaltulose is a sugar-type carbohydrate with a
unique combination of physiological properties:
• Completely available carbohydrate and glucose
supplier (4 kcal/g)
• Slow release of energy
• Low effect on blood glucose (GI: 32) and insulin
(insulin index [II]: 30)
• Balanced and prolonged glucose supply
• Higher contribution to fat oxidation in energy
metabolism
• Kind to teeth
This different linkage turns Palatinose™ into a fully digestible carbohydrate with “slow release” properties.
This means: In the small intestine, Palatinose™ is more slowly digested by human enzymes. And its digestion and absorption takes place along the entire small intestine. The result is a slower and sustained release of glucose into the blood.
Palatinose™ is nevertheless fully digested and absorbed by the end of the small intestine. It provides the full carbohydrate energy of 4 kcal/g.
The full availability is substantiated by digestibility studies showing a full absorption. Further, it has been observed at there was no colonic fermentation after the consumption of Palatinose™, another proof point for the full availability.
Toothfriendliness: Food provides fermentable CHO. Bacteria living in the plaque on the tooth surface use these CHO as a source of energy for themselves. CHO are fermented to gain energy and at the same time produce acids.
Acids accumulate on tooth surface which leads to a drop in pH on surface below 5,7. This is when demineralisation on tooth occurs and carcinogenic lesions are formed. During the time between meals, pH levels return to neutral and remineralisation can occur. This means calcium and phosphate from saliva brought back in and used to form to remineralize the carcinogenic lesion, a natural repair process.
BENEO offers a number of ingredients and solutions for the development of foods with reduced glycemic properties. These include
The slow release sugar Palatinose™
The chicory root fibres inulin and oligofructose and
(The polyol and sugar repacer isomalt.)
These ingredients work through different mechanism.
All of these studies consistently show a lower blood glucose response with Palatinose™ in comparison with sucrose or other references. And this is associated with lower insulin levels in studies, where this has been determined in parallel.
Thus, Palatinose™ can replace higher glycemic sugars in a food and by this reduced the blood glucose response of that food.
Palatinose™ has a different incretin response compared to sucrose
GIP = glucose-dependent insulinotropic peptide
GLP-1 = glucagon-like peptide 1
Glucagon is a peptide hormone, produced by alpha cells of the pancreas. It works to raise the concentration of glucose in the bloodstream. It is also used as a medication to treat a number of health conditions. Its effect is opposite to that of insulin, which lowers the glucose.
In adipose tissues, GIP but not GLP-1 facilitates fat deposition
Long-term studies suggest benefits of Palatinose™ vs high GI carbohydrates
Arrow stands for “aim”
Glycogen is a multibranched polysaccharide of glucose that serves as a form of energy storage in humans. The polysaccharide structure represents the main storage form of glucose in the body. In humans, glycogen is made and stored primarily in the cells of the liver and the muscles.
Blood glucose, insulin, carbohydrate oxidation and fat oxidation are connected like sprocket-wheels.
With increased blood glucose level, insulin rises which leads to increased carb oxidation and decreased fat oxidation
Rate of energy supply makes a difference: With Palatinose™ more steady glucose supply
Endurance exercise: Fat ox is known to spare glycogen sources and enhance performance
Side note:
@ intake before physical activity:
Insulin plays a key role in the regulatory mechnism
Tell the story with insulin.
@ intake during physical activity:
The role of insulin is suppressed by antagonistic hormones like adrenalin). Here, the rate of glucose availability on cellular level determines the rate of carbohydrate and fat oxidation.
Tell story without emphasis on insulin: slower, more steady rate of glucose supply leads to higher fat ox.
Short-term
What else did we see with PSE in sports
Side note:
@ intake before physical activity:
Insulin plays a key role in the regulatory mechnism
Tell the story with insulin.
@ intake during physical activity:
The role of insulin is suppressed by antagonistic hormones like adrenalin). Here, the rate of glucose availability on cellular level determines the rate of carbohydrate and fat oxidation.
Tell story without emphasis on insulin: slower, more steady rate of glucose supply leads to higher fat ox.
Exercise intensity is expressed as a percentage of an individual‘s VO2max.
VO2max = the highest rate at which oxygen can be taken up and utilised during exercise by a person
Side note:
@ intake before physical activity:
Insulin plays a key role in the regulatory mechnism
Tell the story with insulin.
@ intake during physical activity:
The role of insulin is suppressed by antagonistic hormones like adrenalin). Here, the rate of glucose availability on cellular level determines the rate of carbohydrate and fat oxidation.
Tell story without emphasis on insulin: slower, more steady rate of glucose supply leads to higher fat ox.
Time to complete the time trial (mean ± SD):
Maltodextrin: 31.08 ± 6.27 min
Palatinose™: 30.05 ± 4.70 min
P = 0,147
The type of carbohydrate consumed before exercise can influence fuel use and endurance performance
Low glycaemic response is important to our health
It’s the curve that matters