A brief overview about the green building strategy known as green roofing. This presentation was originally prepared for St. Louis regional educators who attended the 2014 Sustainability Institute for P12 Educators.
1. An Introduction to
Green Roofs
Mark Ostendorf
MS Environmental Sciences
LEED Green Associate
http://www.linkedin.com/in/mostendorf
2. Background
• 2008, BGS emphasizing Sustainability
– MSSU, Joplin, MO
• 2012, MS Environmental Sciences
– SIUE, Edwardsville, IL
– SIUE G.R.E.E.N. Member
(Green Roof Environmental Evaluation Network)
– Thesis: Evaluating the Environmental Benefits
of Green Retaining Walls
• 2012-2014, Living Wall Company
– Product Manager
– Worked on numerous green wall projects
• LEED Green Associate
3. Overview
1. What is a green roof?
1. Composition of a Green Roof
2. Types of Green Roofs
2. Advantages of green roofs
1. Stormwater Benefits
2. Other Benefits
3. Feasibility for green roofs at schools
1. Defining Goals and Purpose
2. Budget, for installation and maintenance
3. Selecting the correct green roof system
4. Green Roof Examples around the St. Louis region
1. St. Louis Zoo
2. SIU Edwardsville
3. Shaw Nature Reserve
4. NGRREC
4. Living Architecture
Old Concept, New Technology
• Hanging Gardens of Babylon
One of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient
World
– Green Roofs
– Living Walls
• Sod Homes
– Europe
– North America
• Modern Green Roofs
– Germany in the 1970s
– Established building standards (see FLL)
– Becoming popular in North America
• Philadelphia
• Chicago
• Washington, D.C.
• New York
• Seattle
• Vancouver
6. What is a green roof?
• A building roof that is covered with vegetation,
which is planted into engineered growth medium
– Rooftop Garden
– Living Roof
– Vegetated Roof
– Eco-Roof
– Nature Roof
7. How does a green roof work?
← Vegetation
← Soil or Growing Medium
← Root Reinforcement Mat
← Water Storage/Drainage
← Root Barrier
← Roof Membrane
← Roof Structure
Built-in-place system
9. What is ‘engineered’ growth
medium?
Not really soil…too heavy, too much
organic stuff
• Green Roofs
>20 lbs per sq ft, saturated
• Less organic material
– Increases longevity of ‘soil’
– Organic material degrades
– Decreases weeds
• Engineered media holds more
moisture
10. What grows on a green roof?
Characteristics
• Hardy
• Drought-tolerant
• Shallow root
systems
• Sun-tolerant
Types
• Groundcovers
• Succulents
• Grasses
• Native Plants
• Shrubs
• Small Trees
• Vegetables
St. Louis Zoo
Succulent Groundcover
Grasses, Natives, Trees
Wheat-covered Green Roof
12. Extensive Green Roofs
• Growing Medium
<6 in depth
• Vegetation:
– Typically Sedum
(Stonecrops)
• Low Maintenance
• Little to no structural
reinforcement
– 15-45 lbs per sq ft
• Designed for no or
infrequent irrigation
• Easier to install on existing
buildings
• $10-15 per sf, installed
Sedum: Drought-tolerant, Succulent, Shallow Roots
Ford Factory, Sedum-covered Green Roof
13. Intensive Green Roofs
• Growing Medium
>6 in depth
• Vegetation:
– Sedum, Grasses, Native plants,
shrubs, small trees
• Higher Maintenance
• Requires careful engineering
– 50+ lbs per sq ft
• Requires irrigation
• Easier to install on new
buildings
• $25+ per sf, installed
Green Roof, Washington, D.C.
Shaw Nature Reserve, Native Green Roof
18. Stormwater Benefits
Surface Runoff and Pollution
• Urban runoff can impair water
quality
– Road grime washes into streams, often
untreated!
– Unsafe to swim or fish
– Stormwater from warm urban areas can cause
stream temperatures to RISE
– Impact fish, insects, and plants
OLDER SOLUTIONS:
Quickly Drain the Stormwater
• Channelize Waterways
– River Des Peres
• Stormwater Sewers
– Combined Wastewater & Stormwater sewers
Down the drain…
PROBLEMS:
• Concentrated Pollution channels
• Biodiversity Loss
• Combined Sewer Overflows
• Basement Backups
19. Stormwater Benefits
Utilizing Plants
Plants do an amazing job handling
rainwater!
– They intercept rainfall
– Plants can store water for use during dry
conditions
– Plants can uptake, use, and
evapotranspire water
– Plants also uptake, store, and remediate
pollution
– Leaves, stems, and roots slow
stormwater runoff
Cactus, on a green roof, stores water
SOLUTIONS:
• Retention/detention basins
• Constructed wetlands
• Grass swales
• Rain Gardens
Re-establish natural hydrology
PROBLEMS:
• Lack of space
• High property value
• Cost of implementing
BMPs
20. Addressing stormwater with green roofs
• Stormwater Runoff Reduction
– 100% during light precipitation
– Intensive 65-94% runoff reduction
– Extensive 45-90% runoff reduction
– Green roof slope decreases retention
• Delay runoff
– Delay runoff by 1 to 10 minutes
– Delaying flash flooding
– Store water for irrigation
• Cisterns, rain barrels
Sloped Green Roof, California
SIUe
21. Other Benefits: Urban Heat Island Effect
Up to 5-7 degrees hotter!
CONTRIBUTORS
– Roads, parking lots, roof tops
– Reduced vegetation
– Reduced blue space
– Reduced wind
– Anthropogenic heat sources
• Industry, Automobiles, HVAC, etc.
GREEN ROOFS
– Reflect more sunlight than blacktop roofs
– Shade the building roof
– Provide extra insulation
• Reduce AC use, minimizing cost and pollution
Modified from http://www.epa.gov/hiri/resources/pdf/BasicsCompendium.pdf
Temperatures in urban areas are generally higher
than temperatures in surrounding rural areas.
22. Other Benefits: Economic
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS: Green Roof vs Black Roof
• The longevity of green roofs = savings factor
• Installation and maintenance = cost factor
• Fewer floors a building = greater energy savings
• More surface area= greater stormwater management
savings
• Cost savings will increase as:
– Stormwater regulations become more stringent and
– Green roofs become more acceptable as mitigation measures
24. Feasibility of green roofs at
schools
1. Define Goals/Purpose
2. Budget, for installation and maintenance
3. Green roof selection
25. Feasibility: Goals and Purpose
1. Reduce Stormwater Runoff
1. Intensive=75% retention
2. Extensive=45% retention
3. Stormwater/sewer fees or incentives
4. Plants affect performance
2. Improve water and air quality
1. Plants Selected affect performance
3. Increase biodiversity
1. Extensive < intensive
2. Native Plants
3. Pollinating insects, nesting birds
4. Outdoor classroom
1. Will it be accessible or at least viewable?
2. Outdoor Lab, or just outdoor learning
3. Safety!
5. Grow food
1. Another opportunity to learn about gardening
26. Feasibility: Budget
1. Installing Green Roofs
1. Intensive= $25+ per sq ft
2. Extensive= $10-15 per sq ft
3. Stormwater/sewer rebates
4. Gov’t incentives
2. Remember the maintenance
1. Extensive green roofs are cheaper to maintain!
2. $0.75–$1.50 per square foot, per year
3. Cost/Benefit
1. Outdoor Classroom
1. Vs field trip costs
2. Design to last 2x longer than a conventional roof
3. Reduced Stormwater Fees
4. Energy cost reduction
27. Feasibility: Select Green Roof
System
1. Consult Engineers
1. For new construction
2. For retrofits
2. Consult Horticulturists
3. Choose a product that matches your goals and your
budget
4. Green Roof Installers
1. Regional/Local
2. Provide Maintenance Expertise
28. Places to see Green Roofs
A few from the St. Louis area
29. Places to see Green Roofs
St. Louis Zoo, River’s Edge Exhibit
30. Places to see Green Roofs
Southern Illinois University Edwardsville,
Student Success Center
Numerous Green Roof and Green Wall Projects
31. Places to see Green Roofs
Shaw Nature Reserve, Near Bascom House
32. Places to see Green Roofs
National Great Rivers Research and Educational Center
Alton, IL
33. Resources
• Green Roofs, EPA.
http://www.epa.gov/heatisland/mitigation/greenroofs.htm
• Green Infrastructure, EPA
http://water.epa.gov/infrastructure/greeninfrastructure/index.cfm
• Low Impact Development, EPA
http://water.epa.gov/polwaste/green/index.cfm
• Green Roofs 101, GreenRoofs.com
http://www.greenroofs.com/Greenroofs101/index.html
• Cost Benefit Analysis, Green Roofs, GSA
http://www.gsa.gov/portal/mediaId/167839/fileName/Cost_Benefit_Analysis.action
• Green Roof Resources (for Teachers)
http://teachers.egfi-k12.org/green-roof-resources/
Editor's Notes
Technological and engineering feat! Bringing nature to the built environment.
EX: St. Charles County Urban Space
1982: 3.4%
2003: 27.3%
Stormwater Runoff:
Increased by 70%
IMPACTS
Elevated temperature
Increased energy use for air conditioning
Development of secondary air pollutants
Public health hazards
Over a 50-year period, stormwater, energy, equivalent carbon dioxide and community earnings of green roofs more than made up for the increased premium of installing, maintaining and replacing them.