This document summarizes the results of a survey of 55 insurance brokers on tools and challenges for serving small and medium-sized businesses. Key findings include: brokers have little time after initial sale to engage clients; clients want tailored commercial products but often receive standardized personal lines; brokers need immediate online access to client policy, billing and claims data; and both brokers and clients want simpler processes and a wider variety of specialized coverage options. Overall, the survey highlights the need for insurers to improve digital tools and customize products and services to better meet the unique risks and demands of small and medium commercial customers.
2. About NICC
• What is it?
• Who attends?
• The purpose of the panel
• Survey of ORBiT members/non-members open July
to August 30, 2014
• 55 respondents took part in the survey
2
3. CFIB Shares Member Feedback on Insurance
About CFIB:
•Non-partisan advocacy organization representing privately-
owned Canadian businesses
•109,000 members in all industry sectors
•50% have < 20 employees; 80% have <5 employees
3
4. Small Business Sector in Canada
• Make up 50% of the Canadian economy in terms of GDP
and employment
• Create 50 – 75 % of total net new jobs
• Represents a larger proportion of the economy than in
U.S. and other developed countries
• Churn at a rate of 30-60% every 5 years
• Almost 50% of jobs created in next 15 years will be from
businesses not yet started
• <1% of businesses are fast growing
• High growth firms are more common in low and medium
tech sectors
• Entrepreneurial sweet spot are ages 45-65
4
5. The Market Stratification Challenge in
Canada
Which metric do we use to define the strata?
Sources
Note 1: Industry Canada
Other: Premium, Sales and Broker revenue stratification is based on experience in the Canadian commercial
marketplace.
5
Canada Premium Sales Employee
Size
Broker
Revenue
Micro < $5K < 5M 1-4 < 1K
Small $5K – $25K $5M - $50M 5-99 $1K - $5K
Medium $25K -
$100K
$50M -
$100M
100-499 $5K - $50K
Large $100K+ $100M+ 500+ $50+
6. Challenges for Small/Medium Sized Business
• Small firms want to be treated as businesses but often
conform more to a retail customer profile
• Costly to serve so tendency is to have a one-size fits all
approach
• Take-up of technology likely to be slower than large
business sector
• Most are not well-informed consumers of insurance
products/services
• Highly price-sensitive
6
7. Important Learning from past CFIB
Surveys…
CFIB members say:
•Primary concern is cost
•Packages are not tailored to small business needs
•Heavily reliant upon insurance brokers
•Not being given the full range of options in coverage/cost
•Red tape in claims process is burdensome
•Very loyal to broker/agent
•High satisfaction level with their broker
•Need advice on controlling/managing insurance costs
•Very satisfied with claims service
•Unclear on their rights as a consumer of insurance
7
24. What Tools do you need?
“Other” responses:
•Client self-serve quote and bind new business online
•Competitive rates that do not increase annually except for
inflation
•Higher commission on smaller accounts. How possibly can
a professional brokerage manage a client's expectations for
$200 per year in commission. To provide broker services
either requires higher commission or less responsibility
(perhaps like more of an "agent")
24
27. Why aren’t you using the tools you have?
“Other” responses:
•Having a clearly defined process for small business
•Comprehensive knowledge and coordination of all the various
ways that the insurance companies offer tools.
•Products are too complex
•Service issues @ the company side - small commercial should be
quick and easy - staffing issues at the company side often draw
the process out
•Dealing with too many renewal questionnaires
•Delivery of tools to the broker for one touch service
•How can a brokerage "commoditize" i.e. have clients DIY when
we are held 100% legally accountable for our clients risks? You
can't provide "RIBO/Broker" type services (think E&O) on a
commoditized/call centre type basis.
27
29. What tools are key to write NEW
BUSINESS?
“Other” responses:
•SEMCI is key to future success
•Sales ability and professional counselling to prospects
29
31. Acquiring the Small Business
Insurance Customer
“Other” responses:
•Companies only offer online broker tools. need to offer
online client facing quotes
•I may not be aware of the risk appetite
31
38. What are clients asking for today?
“Other” responses:
•paying monthly with credit card
•I do not believe demands of small business owners are
changing. I believe the IT world would like us to believe
that. I do not know of any business owner who would
want to manage their own insurance
38
39. Survey Conclusions
• Little time to touch their clients after new the sale
• Touch points are on administrative issues
• Products do not meet client needs of
• Standard concepts/ techniques for personal lines
don’t work for small commercial business
• Better segmentation for new specialized coverages
• Liability coverages more popular than property
• Need to move away from the package concept
• Need immediate access claims, billing, and policy
information
• Product lines have little impact on placement
39
Editor's Notes
Survey respondents from national and regional insurance brokerages
34.55% of participants are managers of small commercial business units in the brokerage
24.45% of participants are principals
34.55% have 1-5 dedicated staff in their commercial lines department
13.21% their personal lines staff to handle their small commercial lines clients
21.82% of brokerages manage $500,000 to $2,000,000 in commercial premiums
52.73% of brokerages manage $2,000,000 in commercial premiums
16.67% do not have a Commercial Management System that services the small commercial client
37.04% of respondents have a dedicated system outside of their Broker Management Systems ( BMS) designed to manage the unique requirements of commercial insurance policies
79.25% view the small commercial client equally as important as their personal lines client
88.46% of respondents are focused to grow this business segment
54.35% of respondents use premium to determine this business segment
41.30% of respondents use class of risk to determine this business segment
36.96% of respondents use complexity of the risk to determine this business segment
4.35% of respondents use commission to determine this business segment
84.31% deal with the small business client by phone
45.10 deal with the small business client by email
83.33% believe that better efficiencies for the small business clients should be driven by Real-time technology efficiencies in policy, billing and claims
41.67% believe that risk management information online or self service of insurance certificates would help in better efficiencies
91.84% of service requests from a small business client to their broker is on certificates of insurance request
69.39% of service request from a small business client is on policy change
33.33% of respondents indicated it takes 1-7 hours to acquire a new small business client
38.78% of respondents indicated on average per year they spend 1-3 hours servicing the small business client
80% of respondents indicated that insurance companies do not offer the proper tools to service the small business client
68.75% of respondents believe that there is too much duplicate entry for on-line quoting tools that exist today for new business
60.42% of respondents already know prior to quoting the market that will be the most competitive
84.78% say ease of doing business with a company
58.78% say competitive pricing by company
41.30% said relationship with company Underwriter
36.96% said products that a company offers
52.27% want a more refined class segmentation and associated pricing
52.17% want better specialized coverages and services for :
Worldwide Coverage
Legal Defence Coverage
Cyber Liability
66.67 of respondents said their clients want credit card and debit payment options
44.44% of respondents said their clients want on– line payment options
Less then 30% of respondents said their clients want 24/7 Service
Less then 30% of respondents said their clients want on-line self-service (i.e. reporting changes/request a certificate of insurance, review payment schedule)
Less then 30% of respondents said their clients want electronic delivery of documents
Less then 30% of respondents said their clients want risk management services
Think about this for our discussion later on 2015 Trajectory