SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
By
Obado J, Labarta R and Thiele G
        4th March 2010
Rapid growth in potato demand in kenya
Low quantity of high quality seed(required
per year 66000 tones, available 89 tons)
Limited capacity to produce high quality
seed(6 generation)
Low yields from local varieties due to low
disease resistance (LB, BW and virus)
Designed to increase production of high
quality seed in Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda
(Ethiopia by extension)
Reduce the period of seed production from 6
to 3 generation (aeroponics)
Increase the availability and accessibility of
high quality seed in the region through
massive seed production through
-aerponics/trained seed multipliers
-PPP in seed production and capacity building
Demonstration of the benefits of using high
quality seed
Increase the availability of High Quality Seed
through massive production (PPP) (from >1%
to 10%)
Reduce cost of seed incurred by the farmer
(seed = 30% of potato income)
Increase adaptability through good potato
mgt
To estimate the adoption of clean seed in
Kenya
To determine whether subsidy is appropriate
to increase adoption of HQS
The study has been done using data collected
from Kenya.
System 1=Ordinary seed data (base system)
System 2=Use of certified/clean seed
Certified seed: yield increase by 35% from the
use of initial ordinary seed
Weights of seed type used are expected to
change with more land allocated for
clean/certified seed
It assumed that land area under ordinary seed
will reduce by 20% hence increase area under
clean/certified seed(20%)
Variable   System 1 (Ordinary seed)   System 2 (certified seed)
Yield                   8.93ton/ha                30% increase
Cost                  665.7USD/ha               812.14USD/ha
Price                      160USD                      160USD
CV                          76.44%                      76.44%
Weight1                      0.711                       0.289
Weight 2                     0.5688                       0.431
88.7% of farmers would shift to clean seed
and good potato management
 an increase in subsidy results in increased
adoption

9000

8000

7000

6000

5000
PES




4000

3000

2000

1000

      0
          88   90   92   94        96   98     100
                         Adopt_A
About 66 acres will be used for clean seed

  9000
  8000
  7000
  6000
  5000
  PES




  4000
  3000
  2000
  1000
        0
            65   66   67   68   69    70       71   72   73   74   75
                                     Eserv_A
Through use of certified seed and proper
potato management, farmers would report an
income of 1,543USD/ha (352USD more)
      9000

      8000

      7000

      6000

      5000
      PES




      4000

      3000

      2000

      1000

            0
                0   2000   4000   6000      8000   10000   12000
                                  IncHa_A
Case 1: CVs is fixed the same for the two
systems
Case 2: CV increases in system 2 by 20%
Adoption rate 82% from 89%
Land under clean seed reduces to 62 from 66
acres
Income per ha reduces from 1543 to
1408USD
More analysis will be done using different
regions and systems
Different countries’ data be analyzed in detail
Application of Trade Off Analysis (TOA) model in 3G potato project

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

El día de las madres
El día de las madresEl día de las madres
El día de las madresclaudirta
 
семінар вчителів історії
семінар вчителів історіїсемінар вчителів історії
семінар вчителів історіїjekah
 
чорнобильська катастрофа зош і ііі. № 9
чорнобильська катастрофа зош і ііі. № 9чорнобильська катастрофа зош і ііі. № 9
чорнобильська катастрофа зош і ііі. № 9jekah
 
Folleto publisher
Folleto publisherFolleto publisher
Folleto publisherMariia29
 
欢迎来欧洲、波兰。 We invite you to Europe and Poland
欢迎来欧洲、波兰。 We invite you to Europe and Poland欢迎来欧洲、波兰。 We invite you to Europe and Poland
欢迎来欧洲、波兰。 We invite you to Europe and PolandTrendmed sp. z o.o.
 
Knowledge Integration and Language relativism–Of the triade knowledge,languag...
Knowledge Integration and Language relativism–Of the triade knowledge,languag...Knowledge Integration and Language relativism–Of the triade knowledge,languag...
Knowledge Integration and Language relativism–Of the triade knowledge,languag...Oliver Krone-Franken
 
Mothers Day Gift Baskets Delivery Online
Mothers Day Gift Baskets Delivery OnlineMothers Day Gift Baskets Delivery Online
Mothers Day Gift Baskets Delivery OnlineGiftblooms Patel
 
La familia de sra l
La familia de sra l La familia de sra l
La familia de sra l mariannewal
 
[2016 체인지온@GNTech] 발달장애인과 비장애인이 함께하는 청춘드라마 동구밭_노순호 동구밭 대표
[2016 체인지온@GNTech] 발달장애인과 비장애인이 함께하는 청춘드라마 동구밭_노순호 동구밭 대표[2016 체인지온@GNTech] 발달장애인과 비장애인이 함께하는 청춘드라마 동구밭_노순호 동구밭 대표
[2016 체인지온@GNTech] 발달장애인과 비장애인이 함께하는 청춘드라마 동구밭_노순호 동구밭 대표ChangeON@
 
Information Technology
Information TechnologyInformation Technology
Information TechnologyAman Purohit
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Santuario 090216 1
Santuario 090216 1Santuario 090216 1
Santuario 090216 1
 
El día de las madres
El día de las madresEl día de las madres
El día de las madres
 
семінар вчителів історії
семінар вчителів історіїсемінар вчителів історії
семінар вчителів історії
 
чорнобильська катастрофа зош і ііі. № 9
чорнобильська катастрофа зош і ііі. № 9чорнобильська катастрофа зош і ііі. № 9
чорнобильська катастрофа зош і ііі. № 9
 
Folleto publisher
Folleto publisherFolleto publisher
Folleto publisher
 
Health
HealthHealth
Health
 
欢迎来欧洲、波兰。 We invite you to Europe and Poland
欢迎来欧洲、波兰。 We invite you to Europe and Poland欢迎来欧洲、波兰。 We invite you to Europe and Poland
欢迎来欧洲、波兰。 We invite you to Europe and Poland
 
Knowledge Integration and Language relativism–Of the triade knowledge,languag...
Knowledge Integration and Language relativism–Of the triade knowledge,languag...Knowledge Integration and Language relativism–Of the triade knowledge,languag...
Knowledge Integration and Language relativism–Of the triade knowledge,languag...
 
Mothers Day Gift Baskets Delivery Online
Mothers Day Gift Baskets Delivery OnlineMothers Day Gift Baskets Delivery Online
Mothers Day Gift Baskets Delivery Online
 
La familia de sra l
La familia de sra l La familia de sra l
La familia de sra l
 
Marcela
MarcelaMarcela
Marcela
 
[2016 체인지온@GNTech] 발달장애인과 비장애인이 함께하는 청춘드라마 동구밭_노순호 동구밭 대표
[2016 체인지온@GNTech] 발달장애인과 비장애인이 함께하는 청춘드라마 동구밭_노순호 동구밭 대표[2016 체인지온@GNTech] 발달장애인과 비장애인이 함께하는 청춘드라마 동구밭_노순호 동구밭 대표
[2016 체인지온@GNTech] 발달장애인과 비장애인이 함께하는 청춘드라마 동구밭_노순호 동구밭 대표
 
Contract Negotiation
Contract NegotiationContract Negotiation
Contract Negotiation
 
Information Technology
Information TechnologyInformation Technology
Information Technology
 

Similar to Application of Trade Off Analysis (TOA) model in 3G potato project

Farming System Approach
Farming System ApproachFarming System Approach
Farming System Approachjhoraram
 
Soil fertility management for improved wheat production in Uganda
Soil fertility management for improved wheat production in UgandaSoil fertility management for improved wheat production in Uganda
Soil fertility management for improved wheat production in UgandaCIMMYT
 
Policy impacts on land use and agricultural practices in North-West India. Ni...
Policy impacts on land use and agricultural practices in North-West India. Ni...Policy impacts on land use and agricultural practices in North-West India. Ni...
Policy impacts on land use and agricultural practices in North-West India. Ni...Joanna Hicks
 
Final credit seminar sandeep
Final credit seminar sandeepFinal credit seminar sandeep
Final credit seminar sandeepjhoraram
 
Options for Improving rural poultry and pig production
Options for Improving rural poultry and pig productionOptions for Improving rural poultry and pig production
Options for Improving rural poultry and pig productionafrica-rising
 
Research advances in pulses and benefit to stakeholders dr. c. l. gowda
Research advances in pulses and benefit to stakeholders   dr. c. l. gowdaResearch advances in pulses and benefit to stakeholders   dr. c. l. gowda
Research advances in pulses and benefit to stakeholders dr. c. l. gowdaipga
 
How Regenerative Agriculture Can Save Your Bacon!
How Regenerative Agriculture Can Save Your Bacon! How Regenerative Agriculture Can Save Your Bacon!
How Regenerative Agriculture Can Save Your Bacon! John Roulac
 
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...ILRI
 
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...Humidtropics, a CGIAR Research Program
 

Similar to Application of Trade Off Analysis (TOA) model in 3G potato project (20)

1309 - The System of Rice Intensification (SRI) in the Context of ‘Sustainabl...
1309 - The System of Rice Intensification (SRI) in the Context of ‘Sustainabl...1309 - The System of Rice Intensification (SRI) in the Context of ‘Sustainabl...
1309 - The System of Rice Intensification (SRI) in the Context of ‘Sustainabl...
 
0908 Strategies and Options for Agriculture in the Context of 21st Century Su...
0908 Strategies and Options for Agriculture in the Context of 21st Century Su...0908 Strategies and Options for Agriculture in the Context of 21st Century Su...
0908 Strategies and Options for Agriculture in the Context of 21st Century Su...
 
Dr.p.r.pande
Dr.p.r.pande Dr.p.r.pande
Dr.p.r.pande
 
Farming System Approach
Farming System ApproachFarming System Approach
Farming System Approach
 
0956 Increasing Both Quantity and Quality of Rice Production with Reduced Inp...
0956 Increasing Both Quantity and Quality of Rice Production with Reduced Inp...0956 Increasing Both Quantity and Quality of Rice Production with Reduced Inp...
0956 Increasing Both Quantity and Quality of Rice Production with Reduced Inp...
 
Uphoff Sri
Uphoff SriUphoff Sri
Uphoff Sri
 
Soil fertility management for improved wheat production in Uganda
Soil fertility management for improved wheat production in UgandaSoil fertility management for improved wheat production in Uganda
Soil fertility management for improved wheat production in Uganda
 
Policy impacts on land use and agricultural practices in North-West India. Ni...
Policy impacts on land use and agricultural practices in North-West India. Ni...Policy impacts on land use and agricultural practices in North-West India. Ni...
Policy impacts on land use and agricultural practices in North-West India. Ni...
 
1018 The Emerging Shape of a Post-Modern Agriculture: Indications from the S...
1018 The Emerging Shape of  a Post-Modern Agriculture: Indications from the S...1018 The Emerging Shape of  a Post-Modern Agriculture: Indications from the S...
1018 The Emerging Shape of a Post-Modern Agriculture: Indications from the S...
 
Final credit seminar sandeep
Final credit seminar sandeepFinal credit seminar sandeep
Final credit seminar sandeep
 
Options for Improving rural poultry and pig production
Options for Improving rural poultry and pig productionOptions for Improving rural poultry and pig production
Options for Improving rural poultry and pig production
 
1305 - Agroecological Crop Management for Increased Productivity
1305 - Agroecological Crop Management for Increased Productivity 1305 - Agroecological Crop Management for Increased Productivity
1305 - Agroecological Crop Management for Increased Productivity
 
Research advances in pulses and benefit to stakeholders dr. c. l. gowda
Research advances in pulses and benefit to stakeholders   dr. c. l. gowdaResearch advances in pulses and benefit to stakeholders   dr. c. l. gowda
Research advances in pulses and benefit to stakeholders dr. c. l. gowda
 
Technologies to Improve Livestock Productivity in Drylands, Dr. Barbara Risch...
Technologies to Improve Livestock Productivity in Drylands, Dr. Barbara Risch...Technologies to Improve Livestock Productivity in Drylands, Dr. Barbara Risch...
Technologies to Improve Livestock Productivity in Drylands, Dr. Barbara Risch...
 
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...
 
How Regenerative Agriculture Can Save Your Bacon!
How Regenerative Agriculture Can Save Your Bacon! How Regenerative Agriculture Can Save Your Bacon!
How Regenerative Agriculture Can Save Your Bacon!
 
IFPRI - Food Secure Bihar, P K Joshi, IFPRI
IFPRI - Food Secure Bihar, P K Joshi, IFPRIIFPRI - Food Secure Bihar, P K Joshi, IFPRI
IFPRI - Food Secure Bihar, P K Joshi, IFPRI
 
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
 
1003 Study and Utilization of the SRI Technology
1003 Study and Utilization of the SRI Technology 1003 Study and Utilization of the SRI Technology
1003 Study and Utilization of the SRI Technology
 
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...
A Situation Analysis of Small-scale Farming Systems in West Kenya Action Site...
 

More from International Potato Center

Learning approaches in enhancing farmers’ capacity to link with market
Learning approaches in enhancing farmers’ capacity to link with marketLearning approaches in enhancing farmers’ capacity to link with market
Learning approaches in enhancing farmers’ capacity to link with marketInternational Potato Center
 
Ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies in resource-poor c...
Ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies in resource-poor c...Ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies in resource-poor c...
Ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies in resource-poor c...International Potato Center
 
Rooting out Hunger in Malawi with Nutritious Orange-fleshed Sweetpotato
Rooting out Hunger in Malawi with Nutritious Orange-fleshed SweetpotatoRooting out Hunger in Malawi with Nutritious Orange-fleshed Sweetpotato
Rooting out Hunger in Malawi with Nutritious Orange-fleshed SweetpotatoInternational Potato Center
 
Challenges to sustainable potato production in a changing climate: A research...
Challenges to sustainable potato production in a changing climate: A research...Challenges to sustainable potato production in a changing climate: A research...
Challenges to sustainable potato production in a changing climate: A research...International Potato Center
 
Challenges to potato-based systems under climate variability/change conditions
Challenges to potato-based systems under climate variability/change conditionsChallenges to potato-based systems under climate variability/change conditions
Challenges to potato-based systems under climate variability/change conditionsInternational Potato Center
 
La Papa, Tesoro de los Andes: De la Agricultura a la Cultura
La Papa, Tesoro de los Andes: De la Agricultura a la Cultura La Papa, Tesoro de los Andes: De la Agricultura a la Cultura
La Papa, Tesoro de los Andes: De la Agricultura a la Cultura International Potato Center
 
La Papa: El sector papa en la region andina: situacion actual y desafios
La Papa: El sector papa en la region andina: situacion actual y desafiosLa Papa: El sector papa en la region andina: situacion actual y desafios
La Papa: El sector papa en la region andina: situacion actual y desafiosInternational Potato Center
 
Deep Sequencing of Small RNA: a Generic Method for Diagnosis, Discovery and S...
Deep Sequencing of Small RNA: a Generic Method for Diagnosis, Discovery and S...Deep Sequencing of Small RNA: a Generic Method for Diagnosis, Discovery and S...
Deep Sequencing of Small RNA: a Generic Method for Diagnosis, Discovery and S...International Potato Center
 
Selección Participativa de Clones de Papa con Resistencia a Phytophthora infe...
Selección Participativa de Clones de Papa con Resistencia a Phytophthora infe...Selección Participativa de Clones de Papa con Resistencia a Phytophthora infe...
Selección Participativa de Clones de Papa con Resistencia a Phytophthora infe...International Potato Center
 
Dos nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena (B1C5), con resi...
Dos nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena (B1C5), con resi...Dos nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena (B1C5), con resi...
Dos nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena (B1C5), con resi...International Potato Center
 
Nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena(B1C5), obtenidas a t...
Nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena(B1C5), obtenidas a t...Nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena(B1C5), obtenidas a t...
Nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena(B1C5), obtenidas a t...International Potato Center
 
Contribución del EPCP al mercado de las papas nativas en los andes
Contribución del EPCP al mercado de las papas nativas en los andesContribución del EPCP al mercado de las papas nativas en los andes
Contribución del EPCP al mercado de las papas nativas en los andesInternational Potato Center
 
Fortaleciendo Capacidades para la Innovación -Una Estrategia para Reducir la ...
Fortaleciendo Capacidades para la Innovación -Una Estrategia para Reducir la ...Fortaleciendo Capacidades para la Innovación -Una Estrategia para Reducir la ...
Fortaleciendo Capacidades para la Innovación -Una Estrategia para Reducir la ...International Potato Center
 
Diversidad y Conservación in-situ de Papas Nativas
Diversidad y Conservación in-situ de Papas NativasDiversidad y Conservación in-situ de Papas Nativas
Diversidad y Conservación in-situ de Papas NativasInternational Potato Center
 
La biodiversidad de la papa como oportunidad para facilitar el acceso de pequ...
La biodiversidad de la papa como oportunidad para facilitar el acceso de pequ...La biodiversidad de la papa como oportunidad para facilitar el acceso de pequ...
La biodiversidad de la papa como oportunidad para facilitar el acceso de pequ...International Potato Center
 
Sustaining and projecting genetic diversity: Potatoes adapted to changing needs
Sustaining and projecting genetic diversity: Potatoes adapted to changing needsSustaining and projecting genetic diversity: Potatoes adapted to changing needs
Sustaining and projecting genetic diversity: Potatoes adapted to changing needsInternational Potato Center
 
Scaling Up Technology Development Focused on the Poor and Hungry
Scaling Up Technology Development Focused on the Poor and HungryScaling Up Technology Development Focused on the Poor and Hungry
Scaling Up Technology Development Focused on the Poor and HungryInternational Potato Center
 

More from International Potato Center (20)

Learning approaches in enhancing farmers’ capacity to link with market
Learning approaches in enhancing farmers’ capacity to link with marketLearning approaches in enhancing farmers’ capacity to link with market
Learning approaches in enhancing farmers’ capacity to link with market
 
Ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies in resource-poor c...
Ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies in resource-poor c...Ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies in resource-poor c...
Ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies in resource-poor c...
 
Rooting out Hunger in Malawi with Nutritious Orange-fleshed Sweetpotato
Rooting out Hunger in Malawi with Nutritious Orange-fleshed SweetpotatoRooting out Hunger in Malawi with Nutritious Orange-fleshed Sweetpotato
Rooting out Hunger in Malawi with Nutritious Orange-fleshed Sweetpotato
 
Challenges to sustainable potato production in a changing climate: A research...
Challenges to sustainable potato production in a changing climate: A research...Challenges to sustainable potato production in a changing climate: A research...
Challenges to sustainable potato production in a changing climate: A research...
 
Challenges to potato-based systems under climate variability/change conditions
Challenges to potato-based systems under climate variability/change conditionsChallenges to potato-based systems under climate variability/change conditions
Challenges to potato-based systems under climate variability/change conditions
 
Innovaciones en el Mejoramiento de la Papa
Innovaciones en el Mejoramiento de la PapaInnovaciones en el Mejoramiento de la Papa
Innovaciones en el Mejoramiento de la Papa
 
La Papa, Tesoro de los Andes: De la Agricultura a la Cultura
La Papa, Tesoro de los Andes: De la Agricultura a la Cultura La Papa, Tesoro de los Andes: De la Agricultura a la Cultura
La Papa, Tesoro de los Andes: De la Agricultura a la Cultura
 
La Papa: El sector papa en la region andina: situacion actual y desafios
La Papa: El sector papa en la region andina: situacion actual y desafiosLa Papa: El sector papa en la region andina: situacion actual y desafios
La Papa: El sector papa en la region andina: situacion actual y desafios
 
Deep Sequencing of Small RNA: a Generic Method for Diagnosis, Discovery and S...
Deep Sequencing of Small RNA: a Generic Method for Diagnosis, Discovery and S...Deep Sequencing of Small RNA: a Generic Method for Diagnosis, Discovery and S...
Deep Sequencing of Small RNA: a Generic Method for Diagnosis, Discovery and S...
 
Selección Participativa de Clones de Papa con Resistencia a Phytophthora infe...
Selección Participativa de Clones de Papa con Resistencia a Phytophthora infe...Selección Participativa de Clones de Papa con Resistencia a Phytophthora infe...
Selección Participativa de Clones de Papa con Resistencia a Phytophthora infe...
 
Dos nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena (B1C5), con resi...
Dos nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena (B1C5), con resi...Dos nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena (B1C5), con resi...
Dos nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena (B1C5), con resi...
 
Nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena(B1C5), obtenidas a t...
Nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena(B1C5), obtenidas a t...Nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena(B1C5), obtenidas a t...
Nuevas variedades de papa Solanum tuberosum spp Andígena(B1C5), obtenidas a t...
 
Contribución del EPCP al mercado de las papas nativas en los andes
Contribución del EPCP al mercado de las papas nativas en los andesContribución del EPCP al mercado de las papas nativas en los andes
Contribución del EPCP al mercado de las papas nativas en los andes
 
Fortaleciendo Capacidades para la Innovación -Una Estrategia para Reducir la ...
Fortaleciendo Capacidades para la Innovación -Una Estrategia para Reducir la ...Fortaleciendo Capacidades para la Innovación -Una Estrategia para Reducir la ...
Fortaleciendo Capacidades para la Innovación -Una Estrategia para Reducir la ...
 
Poniendo en valor las papas nativas en el Perú
Poniendo en valor las papas nativas en el PerúPoniendo en valor las papas nativas en el Perú
Poniendo en valor las papas nativas en el Perú
 
Diversidad y Conservación in-situ de Papas Nativas
Diversidad y Conservación in-situ de Papas NativasDiversidad y Conservación in-situ de Papas Nativas
Diversidad y Conservación in-situ de Papas Nativas
 
La biodiversidad de la papa como oportunidad para facilitar el acceso de pequ...
La biodiversidad de la papa como oportunidad para facilitar el acceso de pequ...La biodiversidad de la papa como oportunidad para facilitar el acceso de pequ...
La biodiversidad de la papa como oportunidad para facilitar el acceso de pequ...
 
Biofortified Sweetpotato
Biofortified SweetpotatoBiofortified Sweetpotato
Biofortified Sweetpotato
 
Sustaining and projecting genetic diversity: Potatoes adapted to changing needs
Sustaining and projecting genetic diversity: Potatoes adapted to changing needsSustaining and projecting genetic diversity: Potatoes adapted to changing needs
Sustaining and projecting genetic diversity: Potatoes adapted to changing needs
 
Scaling Up Technology Development Focused on the Poor and Hungry
Scaling Up Technology Development Focused on the Poor and HungryScaling Up Technology Development Focused on the Poor and Hungry
Scaling Up Technology Development Focused on the Poor and Hungry
 

Application of Trade Off Analysis (TOA) model in 3G potato project

  • 1. By Obado J, Labarta R and Thiele G 4th March 2010
  • 2. Rapid growth in potato demand in kenya Low quantity of high quality seed(required per year 66000 tones, available 89 tons) Limited capacity to produce high quality seed(6 generation) Low yields from local varieties due to low disease resistance (LB, BW and virus)
  • 3. Designed to increase production of high quality seed in Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda (Ethiopia by extension) Reduce the period of seed production from 6 to 3 generation (aeroponics) Increase the availability and accessibility of high quality seed in the region through massive seed production through -aerponics/trained seed multipliers -PPP in seed production and capacity building
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6. Demonstration of the benefits of using high quality seed Increase the availability of High Quality Seed through massive production (PPP) (from >1% to 10%) Reduce cost of seed incurred by the farmer (seed = 30% of potato income) Increase adaptability through good potato mgt
  • 7. To estimate the adoption of clean seed in Kenya To determine whether subsidy is appropriate to increase adoption of HQS
  • 8. The study has been done using data collected from Kenya. System 1=Ordinary seed data (base system) System 2=Use of certified/clean seed
  • 9. Certified seed: yield increase by 35% from the use of initial ordinary seed Weights of seed type used are expected to change with more land allocated for clean/certified seed It assumed that land area under ordinary seed will reduce by 20% hence increase area under clean/certified seed(20%)
  • 10. Variable System 1 (Ordinary seed) System 2 (certified seed) Yield 8.93ton/ha 30% increase Cost 665.7USD/ha 812.14USD/ha Price 160USD 160USD CV 76.44% 76.44% Weight1 0.711 0.289 Weight 2 0.5688 0.431
  • 11. 88.7% of farmers would shift to clean seed and good potato management an increase in subsidy results in increased adoption 9000 8000 7000 6000 5000 PES 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 88 90 92 94 96 98 100 Adopt_A
  • 12. About 66 acres will be used for clean seed 9000 8000 7000 6000 5000 PES 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 Eserv_A
  • 13. Through use of certified seed and proper potato management, farmers would report an income of 1,543USD/ha (352USD more) 9000 8000 7000 6000 5000 PES 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 IncHa_A
  • 14. Case 1: CVs is fixed the same for the two systems Case 2: CV increases in system 2 by 20%
  • 15. Adoption rate 82% from 89% Land under clean seed reduces to 62 from 66 acres Income per ha reduces from 1543 to 1408USD
  • 16. More analysis will be done using different regions and systems Different countries’ data be analyzed in detail