Observing & Reporting Urban Tree Phenology: What's In It for Community Forestry Partners?
Theresa Crimmins, USA National Phenology Network | Dudley Hartel, USFS
Observing & Reporting Urban Tree Phenology: What's In It for Community Forestry Partners?
1. Theresa Crimmins
USA National Phenology Network
November, 2013
Partners in Community Forestry
Observing & reporting urban tree
phenology: What’s in it for community
forest partners?
Dudley Hartel
USDA Forest Service
2. Urban Tree Phenology for Urban &
Community Forestry
In this presentation …
A word about crowd sourcing
& citizen science
Professional arborists & urban
foresters
How can it help your
organization
What is phenology
Nature’s Notebook
U&CF NGOs & their volunteers
An example: Casey Trees
3. Crowd Sourcing vs.
Citizen Science
Crowd sourcing …
the practice of obtaining needed services, ideas, or
content by soliciting contributions from a large
group of people
distributive problem solving
Citizen science …
scientific research conducted, in whole or in
part, by amateurs or nonprofessionals
public participation in scientific research
(also known as) crowd science, crowd-sourced
science, or networked science
4. Urban Forestry Professionals
& Community Partners
Urban forest managers and arborists…
see direct relationship between their
phenology observations and information
valuable for planning & management
can work regionally (e.g. an ISA chapter)
to leverage their immediate impact
Community Partners for U&CF…
will have volunteer opportunities for a
wide range of interest & ability
provide another level of support to your
community’s U&CF program
9. What is phenology?
• Linked to environmental
conditions
• Integrative
• “Fingerprint” of change
• Easy to observe
…it is the study of recurring
plant and animal life-cycle
stages, or phenophases, and
their relationship to
environmental conditions.
Photo credit: L. Barnett
10. Observing change over time
I observed an unusual circumstance
this spring on the foothill of Moscow
Mountain, northern Idaho, elev. 3000‘.
I have been monitoring the arrival of
hummers for many years here--they
range in arrival from early to late
April. Usually the Calliope is
first, followed by the Rufous. Over the
last few years, the Rufous have been
either arriving at the same time or
before the Calliope. This year the two
were nearly simultaneous on Apr. 23.
About a week later I spotted the Black
Chinned--usually not often
seen, and never before late June/July
(followed in late summer by the
Broadtailed).
12. Value of tracking phenology to
community forestry partners
Generate baseline data
Uncover new patterns or
threats to resources
Schedule management
activities
Engage
members, volunteers, visitors
Photo credit: P. Warren
14. Noticing when something is
“not quite right”
Frequent visits to trees can enable early identification of
developing problems
15. Phenology can guide planning:
Tracking leaf fall to improve water quality
http://kstp.com/news/stories/S2979604.shtml?cat=1
16. USA National Phenology Network
Primary goals
• Observe phenological events
• Understand how plants, animals
& landscapes respond to climate
change
• Create a standardized dataset to
support research and decision
making
Collect, store, and
share phenology data
and information
17. A multi-taxa, national-scale
plant and animal phenology
observation program
• Standardized protocols
• 3,000 observers reporting on 650 plant
and 250 animal species
• Web and mobile apps for data entry
• Data download and visualization
L. Barnett
Nature’s Notebook
is for scientists, naturalists,
volunteers, land
managers, park rangers,
and YOU!
19. The basics of tracking phenology
using Nature’s Notebook
20. The basics of tracking phenology
using Nature’s Notebook
>95%
21. The basics of tracking phenology
using Nature’s Notebook
>95%
22. Using Nature’s Notebook…
• …as a way to engage volunteers
• …to answer urbanization and climate
change questions
• …to better understand seasonal events in
urban trees
Engaging volunteers in two ways:
• Through
• Through continuing education classes
30. Interested? What’s next?
The USA-NPN can support you in…
• Envisioning and implementing your
effort
• Managing and accessing your data
• Connecting with others
• Accessing curriculum and resources
for outreach purposes
We’d love to have you join us!
Photo credit: L. Barnett
31. Thank you!
You’re invited to
connect with USA-NPN…
• Join the Nature’s Notebook
user community: sign up
for our quarterly Partners
Newsletter
• Become a Nature’s
Notebook observer:
Contribute to science while
having fun!
• Discover new tools and
resources for work or play
Theresa Crimmins
theresa@usanpn.org
@TheresaCrimmins
Dudley Hartel
www.UrbanForestrySouth.org
dhartel@fs.fed.us
@ufs_cuif, @treeobs
Leavesofchangeweekly.org
Editor's Notes
Theresa Crimmins coordinates partnerships and outreach communications for the USA National Phenology Network, an organization that serves science and society by promoting broad understanding of plant and animal phenology and its relationship with environmental change. Dudley R. Hartel is Center Manager of Urban Forestry South (Athens, Georgia) which is one of three Urban & Community Forestry (U&CF) Technology Centers in the eastern US. Urban Forestry South provides technical program support for Region 8 U&CF coordinators & their programs. www.UrbanForesrySouth.org & www.LeavesOfChangaeWeekly
In this presentation, Dudley will introduce the topic briefly, and Theresa will provide the phenology background and overview of the on-line reporting systems available for volunteer-based groups.
All of you are familiar with and probably active in some form of social media. While most of these are designed to engage people and disseminate information (i.e. marketing tools), they can also be used as information gathering tools (e.g. what is happening where you are) that can engage people for direct action (e.g. a tree planting event). Two definitions can be used to describe social media when used to collect information or ideas for a specific purpose, objective, or task:crowd sourcing & citizen science. These are related but primarily differentiated by objective, primary beneficiary of the participation, or final products produced. In citizen science there are many examples: including early efforts to virtually network personal computers to collectively solve complex problems (e.g. DNA analysis), Audubon Christmas bird counts, and the national rain gauge & reporting system CoCoRaHS.National phenology networks (there are many around the world) focus on the collection of structured information that can be used by researchers to generate long-term data sets used for scientific discovery (e.g. climate studies) and to support shorter-term decision-making. The information may also be important for more immediate use locally that directly benefits the individual or organization that collects it. Additional benefits of the program can include: professional and volunteer development, community awareness, marketing, and recruitment.Both crowd sourcing and citizen science were concepts before the more recent expansion of social media; but, the internet, and particularly
On Tuesday, Theresa and Dudley made a similar presentation to the Society of Municipal Arborists that focused on professional urban forest managers and their role in observing & reporting data that 1) can be used directly to support research important for their profession and work, and 2) involve themselves and their staff directly in observations that can be important on a weekly or seasonal basis. Professional urban forest managers have opportunities to expand their impact by working regionally with colleagues. Now Theresa will discuss phenology observation for non-profit and other urban & community forestry partners that can 1) provide new volunteer opportunities for a wide range of abilities and interests, and 2) like other organization activities directly support your local U&CF management program.
So… how does that translate into something that I benefit from? Why should I spend my valuable time doing this additional activity??Helpful for groups that plant trees, maintain trees, and engage volunteers, in a variety of ways…
Tracking phenology can be very useful in simply establishing a baseline – that is, getting a more detailed, clearer picture of what’s really happening. I realized this when I began to monitor the desert willow in my backyard, a tree that I see every day, all year round. I didn’t really expect to learn much from this – I actually started to do it so I’d understand this program that I’m out promoting better! But once I started documenting things regularly, I was amazed at what I learned. Here’s a screencap of my observations from our online data visualization tool (orient folks) – you can see I have observations spanning nearly 2 years for this individual. A few things I can take away from this:- Basic natural history: This tree puts on new leaves all through the growing season!In these two years, flowering started at about the same time, but lasted a bit longer in 2013I observed fruits months earlier in 2013!I also saw fruits ripen and drop earlier last year – could it be the weather? *expand on value of having this baseline information; extrapolate to urban forestry applicationsAlso, once I started to really *pay attention* to this tree in my yard, I also began to notice a bunch of tomato hornworms (sphynx moth larva), lynx spiders, and even crab spiders tucked up inside the tubular flowers! Great fun for engaging my little boys…
Nature’s Notebook is the USA National Phenology Network’s plant and animal phenology observation program. Through this program, scientists and non-scientists alike are collecting phenology observations on hundreds of species of plants and animals including birds, frogs, mammals, insects, fish, and herps, following scientifically rigorous protocols. Nature’s Notebook can directly support research and decision-making. The phenology observations collected through Nature’s Notebook are maintained in USA-NPN’s national phenology database made freely available for query, visualization, and download on the USA-NPN website.
Here’s a very concrete example of how one non-profit tree group is using NN…CT mission is to restore, enhance, and protect the tree canopy of the Nation’s CapitalHelpful info to better understand which species will adapt well to CC (and which won’t)The RiverSmart Homes Shade Tree Program is designed to reduce stormwater runoff and erosion on residential property in D.C. Through this program, homeowners can have shade trees planted on their property by Casey Trees for $50 per tree.
We can set things up internally so that when new CT members/volunteers join NN, they affiliate themselves w/CT. Then, any records they submit are tagged with the CT affiliation, and CT can easily track what’s been submitted by CT participants. This is helpful for tracking volunteer hours as well as the “shape” of the dataset being collected (# and distribution of trees being monitored, species being monitored, monitoring frequency, what phenophases are being reported on, etc…)
This talk will provide an introduction to the science of phenology and its importance as well as discuss the USA-NPN’s role in phenology study and data collection. It briefly highlights citizen science and how to use our Nature’s Notebook data collection program. It will provide some background on how the program was designed and who the participants are, as well as the USA-NPN’s role in Education. We will provide examples about how to implement Nature’s Notebook at a site, such as a school, nature area, national park, wildlife refuge, and give you information about the tools you’ll need to do so. Lastly, we will provide a quick overview on how to use Nature’s Notebook, noting that we have many, many resources online to help you navigate the website and online data entry system.