SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 47
Originally presented March 2012
AGENDA
 Speaker Background
 Relevant Legislation
 “New Buyers”
 Solution Selling – Executive Sales
 Applying “Solution Selling” to Hospice
 Organizational Implications
SPEAKER BACKGROUND
 Over 20 years in home care
 35 years of experience in planning and marketing
 MBA from the Sloan School of Massachusetts Institute
  of Technology
 President, Healthcare Market Resources, a market
  intelligence providing customized market research to
  home health agencies and hospices, including
  MD/facility referral trends
PATIENT PROTECTION &
 AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
 Medicare Re-admission Penalties
   Three DRG sets subject to potential penalties in FY2013, based
    on FY2012 results
        Acute Myocardial Infarction(AMI)
        Pneumonia
        Chronic Heart Failure
    Additional DRG sets in 2015
      Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease(COPD)

      Coronary Artery Bypass Graft(CABG)

      Percutaneous coronary intervention(PTCA)

      Vascular Procedures

    Hospitals judged by all hospital re-admissions in thirty(30)day
     period following discharge, regardless of hospital
PATIENT PROTECTION &
AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
 Medicare Re-admission Penalties
   Worst-case Scenario
       1% of ALL Medicare re-imbursement in 2013
       2% of ALL Medicare re-imbursement in 2014
       3% of ALL Medicare re-imbursement in 2015
   Penalties based on prior year results
PATIENT PROTECTION &
  AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
 Bundled Payments
    Reimbursement of providers based on the basis of expected costs for
     clinically-defined episodes of care
    Medicare proposed 4 models only 2 involved post-discharge services
 Model 2 (inpatient stay plus post-discharge services): Hospitals and
  physicians receive fee-for-service rates that are retrospectively reconciled
  with a target price. CMS requires a 3% minimum discount to Medicare for
  30 to 89 days after discharge and a 2% discount for an episode that is 90
  days or longer.
 Model 3 (post-discharge services only): Hospitals and physicians receive
  fee-for-service rates that are retrospectively reconciled with a target price.
  The applicant proposes the discount amount to Medicare.
 Requests to participate has been oversubscribed versus expectations.
 Additional opportunities to submit proposals may be forthcoming
PATIENT PROTECTION &
AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
 PPACA gave the Sec’y of HHS the ability to create
  Accountable Care Organizations(ACO’s)
 ACO’s are
   Local organizations
   Bring together physicians and hospitals, usually
   Better manage the costs and quality for at least 5K lives
PATIENT PROTECTION &
AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
 Accountable Care Organizations
    Payment and delivery healthcare reform model
    Seeks to tie provider reimbursements to
        Quality metrics
        Reduction in total cost of care
    Managed care for an assigned population
    Usually led by a hospital-physician coalition
 32 Pioneer ACO’s started operation in Jan 2012
 Many participants shied away from participating because
  of upfront costs
    Medicare will now subsidize this investment in exchange for
     smaller returns
PATIENT PROTECTION &
AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
 Medicare Advantage Plans
   Saw a 15% reduction in per-member per month fees and
    mandated medical loss ratio
 Hospice Concurrent Care Demonstration
   Instructed HHS Sec’y to create a concurrent care hospice
    demonstration project
   Include up to 15 hospices, both urban and rural
   Allow patients to receive hospice care while also being
    treated with other Medicare services
HEALTHCARE REFORM
 Key Concepts
    Value-Based Purchasing
    “Tearing Down the Silos”
    Outcomes-Based Reporting
    Post-Acute Integration
“OLD” SALES PROCESS
SIMPLE


    Sales             Referral
“NEW” SALES PROCESS COMPLEX
 Complex “Buying” Team




   Sales                 Referral
SIMPLE VS. COMPLEX SALE
 Numerous individuals to sell each with different
    agendas
   Gaining access to decision participants or committee
    can be difficult
   Fewer chances to sell; buyers collectively
    control/influence more business than an individual
   Communicating, getting feedback
    and implementing decision can be more time
    consuming; need to work thru various layers of the
    organization
DIFFERENCES
SIMPLE                             COMPLEX
Relationship Focused               Solution focused
Target Users                       Target Business People
Product/Service Education          Product Usage
Ask for the Business               Ask for the Next Step
Single Decision-maker              Multiple Decision-makers
Spontaneous Access                 Scheduled Gated Access
Single Agenda                      Different Agendas & Motivations
Can make decision @ sales call     Longer time frame for the decision
Implement decision with the next   Work thru organization to implement
patient
4 D’s OF THE SALES PROCESS
 Discover


 Diagnose


 Design


 Deliver
PRINCIPLES FOR “SOLUTION”
SELLING Sound Alikes
 Delegated to
   Diagnose before Prescription
   Gain Trust & Appear Competent
   Can’t Sell Non-Buyers
   No Goal No Prospect
   Bad News Early is Good
   Self-Discovery is the Best
   Only the Buyer Can call It a Solution
   Equal then Different
   Emotional Decisions are justified by Value & Logic
   Don’t Close before the Buyer is Ready
“COMPLEX” SALES MISTAKES
 Dancing with only the one that brought you to the
 dance
   Gain access to the other parties as early in the process as
    possible
 Assuming the “buying” team has clearly defined needs
    Survey members to see if you can define the problem
     and solutions in their terms
 Don’t forget the “little” folk and make friends with the
 Gatekeeper
QUESTIONS TO ASK
 Does your customer have a well-defined
    decision/buying process?
   Is the approval process different from the “buying”
    process?
   To what extent does your customer understand the
    problem?
   To what degree do they understand your solution?
   What are the risks involved in implementing your
    solution and how can you mitigate them?
SELLING TO A COMMITTEE
 Know the history of the committee
 More Important to know who decided who will be on
  the committee than knowing who to target
 Whoever invited you to the meeting is your de facto
  champion
 Find out the attitudes and real agenda beforehand
   Pre-survey and ask what concerns are the committee
    likely to have
PRESENTATION TRAPS
 Too much focus on the vendor; discuss the client and
  their issues
 Lecture style usually means limited retention; engage
  in a dialogue
 Will your presentation be the same as your
  competitor’s except for the name will be changed?
  Strive to be memorable and different
 Overcoming objections is an inherently negative
  process; acknowledge concerns and their validity
CUSTOMER ROLES IN “COMPLEX”
SALES PROCESS
 Final Call – Authority
 Interested Parties
    Economic
    User/Functionality
    Integrator
 Power Broker
 Gatekeeper
CURRENT JOB DESCRIPTION
 Relationships/face-to-face contact-referral sources
 Budgetary responsibility-limited
 New program development-recommends
 Education/Background-Associate Deg/LPN
 Key Skills-Excellent Verbal communications
 Measurement – Sales Calls & Referrals
EXECUTIVE SALES JOB
DESCRIPTION
 Relationships/face-to-face contact – Executive/C-level
 Budgetary responsibility-Account P&L
 New program development-Conceives & Develops
 Education/Background-Business Bachelors Degree
 Key Skills – Independent thinker; able to manage
  process & account relationship
 Measurement – Account Penetration
“NEW BUYERS”
 Hospital Administration


 Accountable Care Organization(ACO) Management


 Medicare Managed Care(MCO) Management


          THESE ARE ECONOMIC BUYERS
REASONS NOT TO “BUY” HOSPICE
 Don’t have time to explain
 Not sure if patient is hospice appropriate
 Don’t want to deal with emotionality
 Palliative care is sufficient
 Need to fill my clinical trial
 Don’t want to miss teaching opportunity for
  residents/medical students
INFLUENCES ON THE “BUY”
HOSPICE
 Don’t have time to explain
 Not sure if patient is hospice appropriate
 Don’t want to deal with emotionality
 Palliative care is sufficient
 Need to fill my clinical trial
 Don’t want to miss teaching opportunity for
  residents/medical students
HOSPITAL MORTALITY REPORTING
 In 2008, Medicare began public reporting of 30-day
 risk adjusted mortality rates for patients admitted to a
 hospital for 3 conditions:
   Heart attack(AMI)
   Heart failure(CHF)
   Simple pneumonia
 Will interested parties judge the hospital by publicly
 reported data?
HOSPITAL MORTALITY
 Research if institution has issue
    Hospital Compare
    State Dept of Health and Hospital Association
    Commercial firms
 Identify patients
    Expiring at rates greater than norm
    LOS longer than norms
 Probe key hospital officials to determine if problem is
  internalized—Chief Nursing Officer, Chief Medical Officer,
  Chief Operating Officer
 Calculate benefit in earlier discharge to hospice in terms of
  lower mortality rate and shorter LOS
HOSPITAL RE-ADMISSIONS
 Research if institution has issue
    Hospital Compare
    Commercial firms
 Identify patients
    Chronic Heart Failure
    Secondary Penalty DRG’s -COPD
 Probe key hospital officials to determine if problem is
  internalized—Chief Nursing Officer, Chief Financial
  Officer, Chief Operating Officer
 Calculate benefit in eliminating re-admissions
HOSPITAL RE-ADMISSIONS
 Objection
    It’s worth it to my institution to have the “excess”
     admissions and pay the penalty
 Response
    That may be true in the short term, but the size of
     penalties will rise over time
    This is an issue that cannot be solved overnight and it
     takes time to change institutional behavior
    Expect other payors to follow Medicare’s lead and
     institute similar penalties.
 Quartiles will compress over time
HOSPITAL RE-ADMISSIONS
STRATEGY
 Hospitals are being measured by CMS as we speak
 Focus on CHF; worry about COPD next year
 Does the hospital have a problem? Quantify it.
 Hospice is only one of many solutions
 Explain how hospice prevents re-admissions
 Agree on how to identify terminally ill CHF patient
HOSPITAL RE-ADMISSIONS
STRATEGY
 Set up policies, procedures and protocols regarding
  these patients.
 Offer to in-service cardiac unit physicians and nurses
  on terminal criteria
 Commit to be available for initial hospice consult
  within a given time frame. Must a clinician initiate the
  process?
 If unsuccessful initially, commit to follow up with
  patient within 2 weeks
KEY TO ACO’S
 All about behavior change
 Care about the patient across all settings of care
 Will make money by
    Reducing unnecessary services
    Substituting less expensive services
 The tail that directs the rest of the organization’s
  referral flow
ACO STRATEGY
 Demonstrate cost savings for using hospice in lieu of curative
  care
    Utilize Duke University Medicare End-of-Life to quantify savings
 Request names of primary care physicians, who are part of the
  ACO, and specialists & determine who are under-utilizers of
  hospice
    Agree to make joint sales calls with ACO representative to educate
     physicians about hospice
 Request ACO support in working with their network home
  health agencies in to jointly identify terminally ill Medicare
  patients
    60-70% of these patients could be transferred to hospice; less than
     40% are
 Request “real-time access to ACO patient management
  database to monitor for terminally ill patients
BUNDLED PAYMENT STRATEGY
 Focus on Model 2 – Inpatient and Post Discharge Services
    Hospice’s value-eliminating costly, unnecessary
     hospitalizations
 Identify specific patient populations, where hospice is
  being under-utilized. Conduct literature review for
  support
    Aetna lung study
 Determine if potential hospital partner has sufficient
  volume to warrant interest
 Position proposal as opportunity to learn about “bundled
  payments”.
ROBERT WOOD JOHNSON
FOUNDATION MONOGRAPH
 Promoting Excellence in End-of-Life Care
    Ireland Cancer Center & Hospice of Western Reserve
     program provided palliative transition to patients
     undergoing cancer treatment
       Hospitals admissions dropped 67% from 3,2 to 1.05 per patient
       Univ of Michigan & Hospice of Michigan did concurrent
        cancer treatment and hospice care in a randomized study
          Medicare costs were $7,059 less in study vs. control
ROBERT WOOD JOHNSON
FOUNDATION MONOGRAPH
 Promoting Excellence in End-of-Life Care
    VA Greater Los Angeles offered a palliative care program
     to poor prognosis lung cancer, COPD and CHF patients,
     working with hospices and other home care providers
        Health care costs in the final month were $8605 less
    Mount Sinai, Franklin Health, BCBS Sc utilized existing
    complex case management” system to deliver palliative
    care
        In year 3 of program, savings calculated to be $33K per
         managed case
AETNA CONCURRENT HOSPICE
CARE
 Since 2004, Aetna has been allowing terminally ill
 patients with a 12 month prognosis to receive curative
 care and hospice care simultaneously
   Saw a reduction in medical costs on these patients by
    22% and a 70% increase in hospice admissions
MCO’S
 Highmark created special unit to manage chronic
  terminally ill patients
 Independence Blue Cross hired disease management
  firm to mine its data to develop way of identifying
  terminally ill patients
 A national hospice chains has a senior executive-VP
  Managed Care Sales
     TERMINALLY ILL PATIENTS ARE EXPENSIVE
MCO’S
 Offer to assist MCO in getting their members to sign
  living wills and health care proxies
 Offer to educate health coaches on the benefits of
  hospice
 Discuss concurrent care pilot with MCO to allow
  members to “try” hospice before committing and still
  receive curative care
HOSPICE IN MCO’S
 Medicare Advantage plans(MCO’s) lose money on
  terminally ill patients because of expensive re-
  hospitalizations
 An average ICU day costs $7,000-$15,000, depending
  on the level of equipment and length of stay in the
  unit
 MCO generally pays hospital on a per-day basis
   Assist MCO in transferring patient to GIP bed
MCO SALES APPROACH
 Utilize hospice medical director to broach topic with
 MCO medical director
   Provide articles on success of concurrent care to make
    case
 Determine if MCO has “:complex case management”
  capability and understand their scope
 Determine financially viable concurrent care services
  package
   Goal is breakeven proposition pre-hospice election
ORGANIZATIONAL IMPLICATIONS
 Need to re-vision hospice from calling to an economic
  vehicle, which improves quality of life and lowers costs
 Required resources
   Rainmaker
   Research
   “Complex” Sales Process
   Operational flexibility-No Medicare mindset
CONCLUSIONS
 PPACA created the “economic” buyer for hospice
 This “buyer’ will play a growing role regardless of
  which direction healthcare reform takes
 It requires a different sales process to sell this “buyer”
 This “buyer” has the power to create systemic change
  to encourage the increased use of hospice
CONTACT INFORMATION
Rich Chesney
President, Healthcare Market Resources
rchesney@healthmr.com
215.657.7373
215.657.0395(f)
www.healthmr.com

More Related Content

What's hot

16 co, eimee 10_stepmarketingplan
16 co, eimee 10_stepmarketingplan16 co, eimee 10_stepmarketingplan
16 co, eimee 10_stepmarketingplanEimee Co
 
Alternative health market deck v2.19 f
Alternative health market deck v2.19 fAlternative health market deck v2.19 f
Alternative health market deck v2.19 fMaureenPeltonMSSWLIC
 
Module 3 the guest experience hard copy
Module 3 the guest experience hard copyModule 3 the guest experience hard copy
Module 3 the guest experience hard copyNorwegian Cruise Line
 
Market probe pre customers and former customers white paper
Market probe pre customers and former customers white paperMarket probe pre customers and former customers white paper
Market probe pre customers and former customers white paperMichael Lowenstein
 
consumer behaviour- Unit IV
consumer behaviour- Unit IVconsumer behaviour- Unit IV
consumer behaviour- Unit IVLamay Sabir
 
Solutionreach Webinar: Will Your Practice Be Ready for EMV by October 2015?
Solutionreach Webinar: Will Your Practice Be Ready for EMV by October 2015?Solutionreach Webinar: Will Your Practice Be Ready for EMV by October 2015?
Solutionreach Webinar: Will Your Practice Be Ready for EMV by October 2015?Solutionreach
 
Artigo - The moderating role of perceived justice and satisfaction outcomes o...
Artigo - The moderating role of perceived justice and satisfaction outcomes o...Artigo - The moderating role of perceived justice and satisfaction outcomes o...
Artigo - The moderating role of perceived justice and satisfaction outcomes o...Fundação Dom Cabral - FDC
 
Analytics retention must-have analytics for your retention tool kit
Analytics retention must-have analytics for your retention tool kitAnalytics retention must-have analytics for your retention tool kit
Analytics retention must-have analytics for your retention tool kitBullsEye Internet Marketing
 
Driving to consumerism
Driving to consumerismDriving to consumerism
Driving to consumerismDan Wellisch
 
[White Paper] Patient Engagement ROI
[White Paper] Patient Engagement ROI[White Paper] Patient Engagement ROI
[White Paper] Patient Engagement ROIUbiCare
 
A detailed investigation to validate the popular marketing concept of custome...
A detailed investigation to validate the popular marketing concept of custome...A detailed investigation to validate the popular marketing concept of custome...
A detailed investigation to validate the popular marketing concept of custome...Charm Rammandala
 
Medical Practice Accounting and Financial Modeling
Medical Practice Accounting and Financial ModelingMedical Practice Accounting and Financial Modeling
Medical Practice Accounting and Financial ModelingJason Deshayes
 

What's hot (15)

16 co, eimee 10_stepmarketingplan
16 co, eimee 10_stepmarketingplan16 co, eimee 10_stepmarketingplan
16 co, eimee 10_stepmarketingplan
 
Alternative health market deck v2.19 f
Alternative health market deck v2.19 fAlternative health market deck v2.19 f
Alternative health market deck v2.19 f
 
Module 3 the guest experience hard copy
Module 3 the guest experience hard copyModule 3 the guest experience hard copy
Module 3 the guest experience hard copy
 
Clients Speak on Client Protection- Findings from ASKI- the Philippines
Clients Speak on Client Protection- Findings from ASKI- the PhilippinesClients Speak on Client Protection- Findings from ASKI- the Philippines
Clients Speak on Client Protection- Findings from ASKI- the Philippines
 
Market probe pre customers and former customers white paper
Market probe pre customers and former customers white paperMarket probe pre customers and former customers white paper
Market probe pre customers and former customers white paper
 
consumer behaviour- Unit IV
consumer behaviour- Unit IVconsumer behaviour- Unit IV
consumer behaviour- Unit IV
 
Solutionreach Webinar: Will Your Practice Be Ready for EMV by October 2015?
Solutionreach Webinar: Will Your Practice Be Ready for EMV by October 2015?Solutionreach Webinar: Will Your Practice Be Ready for EMV by October 2015?
Solutionreach Webinar: Will Your Practice Be Ready for EMV by October 2015?
 
Artigo - The moderating role of perceived justice and satisfaction outcomes o...
Artigo - The moderating role of perceived justice and satisfaction outcomes o...Artigo - The moderating role of perceived justice and satisfaction outcomes o...
Artigo - The moderating role of perceived justice and satisfaction outcomes o...
 
Analytics retention must-have analytics for your retention tool kit
Analytics retention must-have analytics for your retention tool kitAnalytics retention must-have analytics for your retention tool kit
Analytics retention must-have analytics for your retention tool kit
 
Driving to consumerism
Driving to consumerismDriving to consumerism
Driving to consumerism
 
Practicing to Win
Practicing to WinPracticing to Win
Practicing to Win
 
[White Paper] Patient Engagement ROI
[White Paper] Patient Engagement ROI[White Paper] Patient Engagement ROI
[White Paper] Patient Engagement ROI
 
A detailed investigation to validate the popular marketing concept of custome...
A detailed investigation to validate the popular marketing concept of custome...A detailed investigation to validate the popular marketing concept of custome...
A detailed investigation to validate the popular marketing concept of custome...
 
Medical Practice Accounting and Financial Modeling
Medical Practice Accounting and Financial ModelingMedical Practice Accounting and Financial Modeling
Medical Practice Accounting and Financial Modeling
 
Health insurance theory 2018
Health insurance theory 2018Health insurance theory 2018
Health insurance theory 2018
 

Viewers also liked (12)

Materi presentasi i life new update 2
Materi presentasi i life new update 2Materi presentasi i life new update 2
Materi presentasi i life new update 2
 
AMBIENT: AIXÒ ERA I NO ERA.
AMBIENT: AIXÒ ERA I NO ERA.AMBIENT: AIXÒ ERA I NO ERA.
AMBIENT: AIXÒ ERA I NO ERA.
 
Market factors influencing access to care
Market factors influencing access to careMarket factors influencing access to care
Market factors influencing access to care
 
Animales vivíparos y ovíparos
Animales vivíparos y ovíparosAnimales vivíparos y ovíparos
Animales vivíparos y ovíparos
 
Conte os panda
Conte os pandaConte os panda
Conte os panda
 
The value of local benchmarking
The value of local benchmarkingThe value of local benchmarking
The value of local benchmarking
 
Blue ocean strategy
Blue ocean strategyBlue ocean strategy
Blue ocean strategy
 
Buy facebook likes
Buy facebook likesBuy facebook likes
Buy facebook likes
 
Home health and hospice survival test - Carevoyant Oct 2015
Home health and hospice survival test - Carevoyant Oct 2015Home health and hospice survival test - Carevoyant Oct 2015
Home health and hospice survival test - Carevoyant Oct 2015
 
Crap Detection
Crap DetectionCrap Detection
Crap Detection
 
RACONS: MATEMÀTIQUES
RACONS: MATEMÀTIQUESRACONS: MATEMÀTIQUES
RACONS: MATEMÀTIQUES
 
Better understanding your personal care market
Better understanding your personal care marketBetter understanding your personal care market
Better understanding your personal care market
 

Similar to The new buyers of hospice under healthcare reform

20091207 Elements to Consider for Alternative Treatment Centers
20091207 Elements to Consider for Alternative Treatment Centers20091207 Elements to Consider for Alternative Treatment Centers
20091207 Elements to Consider for Alternative Treatment Centersguestcf34e2
 
The Aequitas Group Capabilities Overview Q409
The Aequitas Group Capabilities Overview Q409The Aequitas Group Capabilities Overview Q409
The Aequitas Group Capabilities Overview Q409bmeunier9
 
HLU Presentation.Email.Secure
HLU Presentation.Email.SecureHLU Presentation.Email.Secure
HLU Presentation.Email.SecureTad Krafft, CEBS
 
Overview of an Open-Platform Health Plan that Lowers Costs and Improves Perfo...
Overview of an Open-Platform Health Plan that Lowers Costs and Improves Perfo...Overview of an Open-Platform Health Plan that Lowers Costs and Improves Perfo...
Overview of an Open-Platform Health Plan that Lowers Costs and Improves Perfo...Mark Gall
 
Sample Employer Health Plan Proposal
Sample Employer Health Plan ProposalSample Employer Health Plan Proposal
Sample Employer Health Plan ProposalMark Gall
 
SPI Insight: Taking the Pulse of Big Changes in Healthcare Sales
SPI Insight: Taking the Pulse of Big Changes in Healthcare SalesSPI Insight: Taking the Pulse of Big Changes in Healthcare Sales
SPI Insight: Taking the Pulse of Big Changes in Healthcare SalesDario Priolo
 
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010archanasunil
 
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010archanasunil
 
Novel and proactive CRM for companies
Novel and proactive CRM for companiesNovel and proactive CRM for companies
Novel and proactive CRM for companiessyeddurezahmed
 
AMA Houston Healthcare SIG: Health Reform and Brand Management
AMA Houston Healthcare SIG: Health Reform and Brand ManagementAMA Houston Healthcare SIG: Health Reform and Brand Management
AMA Houston Healthcare SIG: Health Reform and Brand ManagementEndeavor Management
 
2013 10 utilizing member engagement to improve cahps scores
2013 10 utilizing member engagement to improve cahps scores2013 10 utilizing member engagement to improve cahps scores
2013 10 utilizing member engagement to improve cahps scoresimagine.GO
 
New Financial And Performance Metrics For Healthcare Industry From Brian Walker
New Financial And Performance Metrics For Healthcare Industry From Brian WalkerNew Financial And Performance Metrics For Healthcare Industry From Brian Walker
New Financial And Performance Metrics For Healthcare Industry From Brian WalkerBrian Walker
 
Retaining members in the digital era
Retaining members in the digital eraRetaining members in the digital era
Retaining members in the digital eraKevin John
 
Easy Ways to Segment Your Customers and Create Actions
Easy Ways to Segment Your Customers and Create ActionsEasy Ways to Segment Your Customers and Create Actions
Easy Ways to Segment Your Customers and Create Actionsimagine.GO
 
Leveraging Data To Drive Strategy And Revenue Bw.Feb2011
Leveraging Data To Drive Strategy And Revenue Bw.Feb2011Leveraging Data To Drive Strategy And Revenue Bw.Feb2011
Leveraging Data To Drive Strategy And Revenue Bw.Feb2011Brian Walker
 
LOOKING AHEAD: Insights from the Reform Debate
LOOKING AHEAD: Insights from the Reform DebateLOOKING AHEAD: Insights from the Reform Debate
LOOKING AHEAD: Insights from the Reform DebateSocial Health Institute
 
Strategic Plaaning Presentation - MGMA Nashville 2/11/2014
Strategic Plaaning Presentation - MGMA Nashville  2/11/2014Strategic Plaaning Presentation - MGMA Nashville  2/11/2014
Strategic Plaaning Presentation - MGMA Nashville 2/11/2014William Cockrell
 
AmWINS Group Benefits Overview
AmWINS Group Benefits OverviewAmWINS Group Benefits Overview
AmWINS Group Benefits Overviewhsantos1022
 

Similar to The new buyers of hospice under healthcare reform (20)

20091207 Elements to Consider for Alternative Treatment Centers
20091207 Elements to Consider for Alternative Treatment Centers20091207 Elements to Consider for Alternative Treatment Centers
20091207 Elements to Consider for Alternative Treatment Centers
 
The Aequitas Group Capabilities Overview Q409
The Aequitas Group Capabilities Overview Q409The Aequitas Group Capabilities Overview Q409
The Aequitas Group Capabilities Overview Q409
 
HLU Presentation.Email.Secure
HLU Presentation.Email.SecureHLU Presentation.Email.Secure
HLU Presentation.Email.Secure
 
Overview of an Open-Platform Health Plan that Lowers Costs and Improves Perfo...
Overview of an Open-Platform Health Plan that Lowers Costs and Improves Perfo...Overview of an Open-Platform Health Plan that Lowers Costs and Improves Perfo...
Overview of an Open-Platform Health Plan that Lowers Costs and Improves Perfo...
 
Sample Employer Health Plan Proposal
Sample Employer Health Plan ProposalSample Employer Health Plan Proposal
Sample Employer Health Plan Proposal
 
SPI Insight: Taking the Pulse of Big Changes in Healthcare Sales
SPI Insight: Taking the Pulse of Big Changes in Healthcare SalesSPI Insight: Taking the Pulse of Big Changes in Healthcare Sales
SPI Insight: Taking the Pulse of Big Changes in Healthcare Sales
 
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
 
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
VBBD Webinar Dec 2010
 
Novel and proactive CRM for companies
Novel and proactive CRM for companiesNovel and proactive CRM for companies
Novel and proactive CRM for companies
 
AMA Houston Healthcare SIG: Health Reform and Brand Management
AMA Houston Healthcare SIG: Health Reform and Brand ManagementAMA Houston Healthcare SIG: Health Reform and Brand Management
AMA Houston Healthcare SIG: Health Reform and Brand Management
 
2013 10 utilizing member engagement to improve cahps scores
2013 10 utilizing member engagement to improve cahps scores2013 10 utilizing member engagement to improve cahps scores
2013 10 utilizing member engagement to improve cahps scores
 
New Financial And Performance Metrics For Healthcare Industry From Brian Walker
New Financial And Performance Metrics For Healthcare Industry From Brian WalkerNew Financial And Performance Metrics For Healthcare Industry From Brian Walker
New Financial And Performance Metrics For Healthcare Industry From Brian Walker
 
Retaining members in the digital era
Retaining members in the digital eraRetaining members in the digital era
Retaining members in the digital era
 
John young cigna cdhp
John young cigna cdhpJohn young cigna cdhp
John young cigna cdhp
 
179882
179882179882
179882
 
Easy Ways to Segment Your Customers and Create Actions
Easy Ways to Segment Your Customers and Create ActionsEasy Ways to Segment Your Customers and Create Actions
Easy Ways to Segment Your Customers and Create Actions
 
Leveraging Data To Drive Strategy And Revenue Bw.Feb2011
Leveraging Data To Drive Strategy And Revenue Bw.Feb2011Leveraging Data To Drive Strategy And Revenue Bw.Feb2011
Leveraging Data To Drive Strategy And Revenue Bw.Feb2011
 
LOOKING AHEAD: Insights from the Reform Debate
LOOKING AHEAD: Insights from the Reform DebateLOOKING AHEAD: Insights from the Reform Debate
LOOKING AHEAD: Insights from the Reform Debate
 
Strategic Plaaning Presentation - MGMA Nashville 2/11/2014
Strategic Plaaning Presentation - MGMA Nashville  2/11/2014Strategic Plaaning Presentation - MGMA Nashville  2/11/2014
Strategic Plaaning Presentation - MGMA Nashville 2/11/2014
 
AmWINS Group Benefits Overview
AmWINS Group Benefits OverviewAmWINS Group Benefits Overview
AmWINS Group Benefits Overview
 

The new buyers of hospice under healthcare reform

  • 2. AGENDA  Speaker Background  Relevant Legislation  “New Buyers”  Solution Selling – Executive Sales  Applying “Solution Selling” to Hospice  Organizational Implications
  • 3. SPEAKER BACKGROUND  Over 20 years in home care  35 years of experience in planning and marketing  MBA from the Sloan School of Massachusetts Institute of Technology  President, Healthcare Market Resources, a market intelligence providing customized market research to home health agencies and hospices, including MD/facility referral trends
  • 4. PATIENT PROTECTION & AFFORDABLE CARE ACT  Medicare Re-admission Penalties  Three DRG sets subject to potential penalties in FY2013, based on FY2012 results  Acute Myocardial Infarction(AMI)  Pneumonia  Chronic Heart Failure  Additional DRG sets in 2015  Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease(COPD)  Coronary Artery Bypass Graft(CABG)  Percutaneous coronary intervention(PTCA)  Vascular Procedures  Hospitals judged by all hospital re-admissions in thirty(30)day period following discharge, regardless of hospital
  • 5. PATIENT PROTECTION & AFFORDABLE CARE ACT  Medicare Re-admission Penalties  Worst-case Scenario  1% of ALL Medicare re-imbursement in 2013  2% of ALL Medicare re-imbursement in 2014  3% of ALL Medicare re-imbursement in 2015  Penalties based on prior year results
  • 6. PATIENT PROTECTION & AFFORDABLE CARE ACT  Bundled Payments  Reimbursement of providers based on the basis of expected costs for clinically-defined episodes of care  Medicare proposed 4 models only 2 involved post-discharge services  Model 2 (inpatient stay plus post-discharge services): Hospitals and physicians receive fee-for-service rates that are retrospectively reconciled with a target price. CMS requires a 3% minimum discount to Medicare for 30 to 89 days after discharge and a 2% discount for an episode that is 90 days or longer.  Model 3 (post-discharge services only): Hospitals and physicians receive fee-for-service rates that are retrospectively reconciled with a target price. The applicant proposes the discount amount to Medicare.  Requests to participate has been oversubscribed versus expectations.  Additional opportunities to submit proposals may be forthcoming
  • 7. PATIENT PROTECTION & AFFORDABLE CARE ACT  PPACA gave the Sec’y of HHS the ability to create Accountable Care Organizations(ACO’s)  ACO’s are  Local organizations  Bring together physicians and hospitals, usually  Better manage the costs and quality for at least 5K lives
  • 8. PATIENT PROTECTION & AFFORDABLE CARE ACT  Accountable Care Organizations  Payment and delivery healthcare reform model  Seeks to tie provider reimbursements to  Quality metrics  Reduction in total cost of care  Managed care for an assigned population  Usually led by a hospital-physician coalition  32 Pioneer ACO’s started operation in Jan 2012  Many participants shied away from participating because of upfront costs  Medicare will now subsidize this investment in exchange for smaller returns
  • 9. PATIENT PROTECTION & AFFORDABLE CARE ACT  Medicare Advantage Plans  Saw a 15% reduction in per-member per month fees and mandated medical loss ratio  Hospice Concurrent Care Demonstration  Instructed HHS Sec’y to create a concurrent care hospice demonstration project  Include up to 15 hospices, both urban and rural  Allow patients to receive hospice care while also being treated with other Medicare services
  • 10. HEALTHCARE REFORM  Key Concepts  Value-Based Purchasing  “Tearing Down the Silos”  Outcomes-Based Reporting  Post-Acute Integration
  • 12. “NEW” SALES PROCESS COMPLEX Complex “Buying” Team Sales Referral
  • 13. SIMPLE VS. COMPLEX SALE  Numerous individuals to sell each with different agendas  Gaining access to decision participants or committee can be difficult  Fewer chances to sell; buyers collectively control/influence more business than an individual  Communicating, getting feedback  and implementing decision can be more time consuming; need to work thru various layers of the organization
  • 14. DIFFERENCES SIMPLE COMPLEX Relationship Focused Solution focused Target Users Target Business People Product/Service Education Product Usage Ask for the Business Ask for the Next Step Single Decision-maker Multiple Decision-makers Spontaneous Access Scheduled Gated Access Single Agenda Different Agendas & Motivations Can make decision @ sales call Longer time frame for the decision Implement decision with the next Work thru organization to implement patient
  • 15. 4 D’s OF THE SALES PROCESS  Discover  Diagnose  Design  Deliver
  • 16. PRINCIPLES FOR “SOLUTION” SELLING Sound Alikes  Delegated to  Diagnose before Prescription  Gain Trust & Appear Competent  Can’t Sell Non-Buyers  No Goal No Prospect  Bad News Early is Good  Self-Discovery is the Best  Only the Buyer Can call It a Solution  Equal then Different  Emotional Decisions are justified by Value & Logic  Don’t Close before the Buyer is Ready
  • 17. “COMPLEX” SALES MISTAKES  Dancing with only the one that brought you to the dance  Gain access to the other parties as early in the process as possible  Assuming the “buying” team has clearly defined needs  Survey members to see if you can define the problem and solutions in their terms  Don’t forget the “little” folk and make friends with the Gatekeeper
  • 18. QUESTIONS TO ASK  Does your customer have a well-defined decision/buying process?  Is the approval process different from the “buying” process?  To what extent does your customer understand the problem?  To what degree do they understand your solution?  What are the risks involved in implementing your solution and how can you mitigate them?
  • 19. SELLING TO A COMMITTEE  Know the history of the committee  More Important to know who decided who will be on the committee than knowing who to target  Whoever invited you to the meeting is your de facto champion  Find out the attitudes and real agenda beforehand  Pre-survey and ask what concerns are the committee likely to have
  • 20. PRESENTATION TRAPS  Too much focus on the vendor; discuss the client and their issues  Lecture style usually means limited retention; engage in a dialogue  Will your presentation be the same as your competitor’s except for the name will be changed? Strive to be memorable and different  Overcoming objections is an inherently negative process; acknowledge concerns and their validity
  • 21. CUSTOMER ROLES IN “COMPLEX” SALES PROCESS  Final Call – Authority  Interested Parties  Economic  User/Functionality  Integrator  Power Broker  Gatekeeper
  • 22. CURRENT JOB DESCRIPTION  Relationships/face-to-face contact-referral sources  Budgetary responsibility-limited  New program development-recommends  Education/Background-Associate Deg/LPN  Key Skills-Excellent Verbal communications  Measurement – Sales Calls & Referrals
  • 23. EXECUTIVE SALES JOB DESCRIPTION  Relationships/face-to-face contact – Executive/C-level  Budgetary responsibility-Account P&L  New program development-Conceives & Develops  Education/Background-Business Bachelors Degree  Key Skills – Independent thinker; able to manage process & account relationship  Measurement – Account Penetration
  • 24. “NEW BUYERS”  Hospital Administration  Accountable Care Organization(ACO) Management  Medicare Managed Care(MCO) Management THESE ARE ECONOMIC BUYERS
  • 25. REASONS NOT TO “BUY” HOSPICE  Don’t have time to explain  Not sure if patient is hospice appropriate  Don’t want to deal with emotionality  Palliative care is sufficient  Need to fill my clinical trial  Don’t want to miss teaching opportunity for residents/medical students
  • 26. INFLUENCES ON THE “BUY” HOSPICE  Don’t have time to explain  Not sure if patient is hospice appropriate  Don’t want to deal with emotionality  Palliative care is sufficient  Need to fill my clinical trial  Don’t want to miss teaching opportunity for residents/medical students
  • 27. HOSPITAL MORTALITY REPORTING  In 2008, Medicare began public reporting of 30-day risk adjusted mortality rates for patients admitted to a hospital for 3 conditions:  Heart attack(AMI)  Heart failure(CHF)  Simple pneumonia  Will interested parties judge the hospital by publicly reported data?
  • 28. HOSPITAL MORTALITY  Research if institution has issue  Hospital Compare  State Dept of Health and Hospital Association  Commercial firms  Identify patients  Expiring at rates greater than norm  LOS longer than norms  Probe key hospital officials to determine if problem is internalized—Chief Nursing Officer, Chief Medical Officer, Chief Operating Officer  Calculate benefit in earlier discharge to hospice in terms of lower mortality rate and shorter LOS
  • 29.
  • 30. HOSPITAL RE-ADMISSIONS  Research if institution has issue  Hospital Compare  Commercial firms  Identify patients  Chronic Heart Failure  Secondary Penalty DRG’s -COPD  Probe key hospital officials to determine if problem is internalized—Chief Nursing Officer, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Operating Officer  Calculate benefit in eliminating re-admissions
  • 31. HOSPITAL RE-ADMISSIONS  Objection  It’s worth it to my institution to have the “excess” admissions and pay the penalty  Response  That may be true in the short term, but the size of penalties will rise over time  This is an issue that cannot be solved overnight and it takes time to change institutional behavior  Expect other payors to follow Medicare’s lead and institute similar penalties.
  • 32.  Quartiles will compress over time
  • 33. HOSPITAL RE-ADMISSIONS STRATEGY  Hospitals are being measured by CMS as we speak  Focus on CHF; worry about COPD next year  Does the hospital have a problem? Quantify it.  Hospice is only one of many solutions  Explain how hospice prevents re-admissions  Agree on how to identify terminally ill CHF patient
  • 34. HOSPITAL RE-ADMISSIONS STRATEGY  Set up policies, procedures and protocols regarding these patients.  Offer to in-service cardiac unit physicians and nurses on terminal criteria  Commit to be available for initial hospice consult within a given time frame. Must a clinician initiate the process?  If unsuccessful initially, commit to follow up with patient within 2 weeks
  • 35. KEY TO ACO’S  All about behavior change  Care about the patient across all settings of care  Will make money by  Reducing unnecessary services  Substituting less expensive services  The tail that directs the rest of the organization’s referral flow
  • 36. ACO STRATEGY  Demonstrate cost savings for using hospice in lieu of curative care  Utilize Duke University Medicare End-of-Life to quantify savings  Request names of primary care physicians, who are part of the ACO, and specialists & determine who are under-utilizers of hospice  Agree to make joint sales calls with ACO representative to educate physicians about hospice  Request ACO support in working with their network home health agencies in to jointly identify terminally ill Medicare patients  60-70% of these patients could be transferred to hospice; less than 40% are  Request “real-time access to ACO patient management database to monitor for terminally ill patients
  • 37. BUNDLED PAYMENT STRATEGY  Focus on Model 2 – Inpatient and Post Discharge Services  Hospice’s value-eliminating costly, unnecessary hospitalizations  Identify specific patient populations, where hospice is being under-utilized. Conduct literature review for support  Aetna lung study  Determine if potential hospital partner has sufficient volume to warrant interest  Position proposal as opportunity to learn about “bundled payments”.
  • 38. ROBERT WOOD JOHNSON FOUNDATION MONOGRAPH  Promoting Excellence in End-of-Life Care  Ireland Cancer Center & Hospice of Western Reserve program provided palliative transition to patients undergoing cancer treatment  Hospitals admissions dropped 67% from 3,2 to 1.05 per patient  Univ of Michigan & Hospice of Michigan did concurrent cancer treatment and hospice care in a randomized study  Medicare costs were $7,059 less in study vs. control
  • 39. ROBERT WOOD JOHNSON FOUNDATION MONOGRAPH  Promoting Excellence in End-of-Life Care  VA Greater Los Angeles offered a palliative care program to poor prognosis lung cancer, COPD and CHF patients, working with hospices and other home care providers  Health care costs in the final month were $8605 less  Mount Sinai, Franklin Health, BCBS Sc utilized existing complex case management” system to deliver palliative care  In year 3 of program, savings calculated to be $33K per managed case
  • 40. AETNA CONCURRENT HOSPICE CARE  Since 2004, Aetna has been allowing terminally ill patients with a 12 month prognosis to receive curative care and hospice care simultaneously  Saw a reduction in medical costs on these patients by 22% and a 70% increase in hospice admissions
  • 41. MCO’S  Highmark created special unit to manage chronic terminally ill patients  Independence Blue Cross hired disease management firm to mine its data to develop way of identifying terminally ill patients  A national hospice chains has a senior executive-VP Managed Care Sales TERMINALLY ILL PATIENTS ARE EXPENSIVE
  • 42. MCO’S  Offer to assist MCO in getting their members to sign living wills and health care proxies  Offer to educate health coaches on the benefits of hospice  Discuss concurrent care pilot with MCO to allow members to “try” hospice before committing and still receive curative care
  • 43. HOSPICE IN MCO’S  Medicare Advantage plans(MCO’s) lose money on terminally ill patients because of expensive re- hospitalizations  An average ICU day costs $7,000-$15,000, depending on the level of equipment and length of stay in the unit  MCO generally pays hospital on a per-day basis  Assist MCO in transferring patient to GIP bed
  • 44. MCO SALES APPROACH  Utilize hospice medical director to broach topic with MCO medical director  Provide articles on success of concurrent care to make case  Determine if MCO has “:complex case management” capability and understand their scope  Determine financially viable concurrent care services package  Goal is breakeven proposition pre-hospice election
  • 45. ORGANIZATIONAL IMPLICATIONS  Need to re-vision hospice from calling to an economic vehicle, which improves quality of life and lowers costs  Required resources  Rainmaker  Research  “Complex” Sales Process  Operational flexibility-No Medicare mindset
  • 46. CONCLUSIONS  PPACA created the “economic” buyer for hospice  This “buyer’ will play a growing role regardless of which direction healthcare reform takes  It requires a different sales process to sell this “buyer”  This “buyer” has the power to create systemic change to encourage the increased use of hospice
  • 47. CONTACT INFORMATION Rich Chesney President, Healthcare Market Resources rchesney@healthmr.com 215.657.7373 215.657.0395(f) www.healthmr.com