SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 58
Download to read offline
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Characterizing an S-band Marine Radar
Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Mark McFarland, P.E.
Dr. Bob Johnk
U.S. Department of Commerce
National Telecommunications and Information Administration
Institute for Telecommunications Sciences
2012 IEEE International Symposium on EMC
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Outline
What You’ll Learn:
Potential interference risk
between BRS signals and
S-band radar receivers
Our measurement system
enables simple, automated
characterization of interference
effects
Without need for a NLNA
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Outline
1 Motivation
Why?
Interference Considerations
2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics
Overview
Non-linear Network Analysis
3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer
Measurement System
Calibration & Processing
4 Results
Insertion Loss
Insertion Phase
Comparison
5 Summary
What You’ll Learn:
Potential interference risk
between BRS signals and
S-band radar receivers
Our measurement system
enables simple, automated
characterization of interference
effects
Without need for a NLNA
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Outline
1 Motivation
Why?
Interference Considerations
2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics
Overview
Non-linear Network Analysis
3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer
Measurement System
Calibration & Processing
4 Results
Insertion Loss
Insertion Phase
Comparison
5 Summary
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Why Are We Studying This?
Potential Interference Risk
Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may
interfere with S-band marine radars
BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE
∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts
Number of those people using BRS systems increasing!
US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection
Criteria for S-band marine radars
Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want
to understand:
Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics
Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS
signals
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Why Are We Studying This?
Potential Interference Risk
Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may
interfere with S-band marine radars
BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE
∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts
Number of those people using BRS systems increasing!
US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection
Criteria for S-band marine radars
Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want
to understand:
Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics
Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS
signals
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Why Are We Studying This?
Potential Interference Risk
Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may
interfere with S-band marine radars
BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE
∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts
Number of those people using BRS systems increasing!
US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection
Criteria for S-band marine radars
Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want
to understand:
Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics
Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS
signals
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Why Are We Studying This?
Potential Interference Risk
Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may
interfere with S-band marine radars
BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE
∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts
Number of those people using BRS systems increasing!
US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection
Criteria for S-band marine radars
Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want
to understand:
Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics
Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS
signals
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Why Are We Studying This?
Potential Interference Risk
Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may
interfere with S-band marine radars
BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE
∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts
Number of those people using BRS systems increasing!
US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection
Criteria for S-band marine radars
Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want
to understand:
Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics
Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS
signals
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Why Are We Studying This?
Potential Interference Risk
Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may
interfere with S-band marine radars
BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE
∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts
Number of those people using BRS systems increasing!
US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection
Criteria for S-band marine radars
Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want
to understand:
Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics
Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS
signals
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Why Are We Studying This?
Potential Interference Risk
Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may
interfere with S-band marine radars
BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE
∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts
Number of those people using BRS systems increasing!
US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection
Criteria for S-band marine radars
Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want
to understand:
Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics
Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS
signals
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Why Are We Studying This?
Potential Interference Risk
Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may
interfere with S-band marine radars
BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE
∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts
Number of those people using BRS systems increasing!
US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection
Criteria for S-band marine radars
Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want
to understand:
Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics
Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS
signals
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
S-band Radar Basics
S-band Frequencies (MHz)
Marine Band 2900-3100
Radar Channel 3020-3080
RF Input Frequency 3050
IF Output Frequency 60
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
S-band Radar Basics
S-band Frequencies (MHz)
Marine Band 2900-3100
Radar Channel 3020-3080
RF Input Frequency 3050
IF Output Frequency 60
Frequency (MHz)
Gain(dB)
−30
−25
−20
−15
−10
−5
0
2000 2500 3000 3500 4000
Component(s)
Circulator
Limiter
Circulator
and
Limiter
Band
Marine
Radar
Channel
BRS
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
S-band Radar Components
Photograph
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
S-band Radar Components
Photograph
Circulator
Limiter
LNFE
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
S-band Radar Components
Photograph
Circulator
RFin
Tx
(50 Ω load)
Limiter
LNFE
LOin
power
IFout
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
S-band Radar Components
Photograph
Circulator
RFin
Tx
(50 Ω load)
Limiter
LNFE
LOin
power
IFout
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Interference Considerations
Susceptibility
LNFE receivers (used in radar, also GPS)
Sensitive receivers
Multi-stage gain
“Wide-open” or filtered front ends
Probability of interference between radar & BRS signals
increasing
Contributors
WiMAX LTE Others?
Impact on LNFE Receivers
Analyzed via receiver’s AM-AM and AM-PM characteristics
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Outline
1 Motivation
Why?
Interference Considerations
2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics
Overview
Non-linear Network Analysis
3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer
Measurement System
Calibration & Processing
4 Results
Insertion Loss
Insertion Phase
Comparison
5 Summary
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Overview
AM-AM and AM-PM
AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of
input power levels
AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of
input power levels
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Overview
AM-AM and AM-PM
AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of
input power levels
AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of
input power levels
Lots of Data Required for Characterization
15 interferer power levels
−50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments
8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps)
15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements
+ 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements
TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings)
Not a manual task!
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Overview
AM-AM and AM-PM
AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of
input power levels
AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of
input power levels
Lots of Data Required for Characterization
15 interferer power levels
−50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments
8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps)
15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements
+ 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements
TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings)
Not a manual task!
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Overview
AM-AM and AM-PM
AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of
input power levels
AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of
input power levels
Lots of Data Required for Characterization
15 interferer power levels
−50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments
8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps)
15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements
+ 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements
TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings)
Not a manual task!
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Overview
AM-AM and AM-PM
AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of
input power levels
AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of
input power levels
Lots of Data Required for Characterization
15 interferer power levels
−50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments
8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps)
15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements
+ 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements
TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings)
Not a manual task!
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Overview
AM-AM and AM-PM
AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of
input power levels
AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of
input power levels
Lots of Data Required for Characterization
15 interferer power levels
−50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments
8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps)
15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements
+ 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements
TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings)
Not a manual task!
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Overview
AM-AM and AM-PM
AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of
input power levels
AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of
input power levels
Lots of Data Required for Characterization
15 interferer power levels
−50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments
8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps)
15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements
+ 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements
TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings)
Not a manual task!
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Non-linear Network Analysis
AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network
analyzer
Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion
RF Input = 3050 MHz
IF Output = 60 MHz
Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed
How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis?
With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA)
A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one
frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency
Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Non-linear Network Analysis
AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network
analyzer
Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion
RF Input = 3050 MHz
IF Output = 60 MHz
Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed
How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis?
With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA)
A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one
frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency
Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Non-linear Network Analysis
AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network
analyzer
Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion
RF Input = 3050 MHz
IF Output = 60 MHz
Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed
How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis?
With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA)
A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one
frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency
Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Non-linear Network Analysis
AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network
analyzer
Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion
RF Input = 3050 MHz
IF Output = 60 MHz
Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed
How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis?
With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA)
A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one
frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency
Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Non-linear Network Analysis
AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network
analyzer
Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion
RF Input = 3050 MHz
IF Output = 60 MHz
Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed
How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis?
With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA)
A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one
frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency
Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Non-linear Network Analysis
AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network
analyzer
Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion
RF Input = 3050 MHz
IF Output = 60 MHz
Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed
How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis?
With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA)
A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one
frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency
Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Tradeoffs
Problem
NLNAs cost ∼$250,000
Solution
Build a NLNA using:
commonly available lab
equipment
open source software
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Tradeoffs
Problem
NLNAs cost ∼$250,000
Solution
Build a NLNA using:
commonly available lab
equipment
open source software
Do-it-Yourself Non-linear Network Analyzer
VSG DUT VSA Processing
AM-AM
AM-PM
Rb clock
AutoHotkey Control
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Outline
1 Motivation
Why?
Interference Considerations
2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics
Overview
Non-linear Network Analysis
3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer
Measurement System
Calibration & Processing
4 Results
Insertion Loss
Insertion Phase
Comparison
5 Summary
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
Block Diagram
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
Block Diagram
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
Provides interferer signal (varying frequency and power)
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
Block Diagram
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
Synchronizes VSG, VSA, and DUT (if applicable)
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
Block Diagram
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
Records IF output
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
Block Diagram
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
PC running VSA GUI control software
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
Block Diagram
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
AutoHotkey controls the VSA’s GUI
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
Block Diagram
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
AutoHotkey Automation
Open source
GNU General Public License
No cost or license fees
Automate almost any computer task
Send keystrokes and/or mouse movements & clicks to
applications
Offers a scripting language
Simple
Low development time
Can monitor VSA GUI
See http://www.autohotkey.com
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
AutoHotkey Automation - Sample Code
§ ¤
1 $F5::
prefix=in -band.3050
startPower = -50
stopPower = 20
6 dbStep = 5
numIter := (stopPower - startPower)/dbStep + 1
Loop %numIter%
{
11 power := startPower + dbStep *( a_index -1)
; STARTUP - Data from hardware , then restart
Send !ifh ; select: Input -dataFrom -Hardware
Sleep , 1000
16
Send !cr ; select: Control -Restart -- to restart measurement
Sleep , 8000 ; wait for filters ...
; START RECORDING
21 Send !cd ; start recording
Sleep , 10000 ; wait for filters to settle and recording to finish
; SAVE RECORDING
Send !fsr %prefix %.% power %{ Enter }{ Enter}
26
Sleep , 5000 ; wait for recording to write and VSG to change output power
}
¦ ¥
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Measurement System
Photograph
LO
Rb clock
VSG
AHK/control
VSA
not used
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Calibration & Processing
Block Diagrams
Baseline
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Calibration & Processing
Block Diagrams
Baseline
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Calibration & Processing
Block Diagrams
Baseline
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
RF
VSG VSA
Rb clock
AutoHotkey Control
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Calibration & Processing
Block Diagrams
Baseline
Radar System Components
VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA
Rb clock
LO
ControlAutoHotkey
RF
VSG VSA
Rb clock
AutoHotkey Control
IF
VSG BPF VSA
Rb clock
AutoHotkey Control
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Outline
1 Motivation
Why?
Interference Considerations
2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics
Overview
Non-linear Network Analysis
3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer
Measurement System
Calibration & Processing
4 Results
Insertion Loss
Insertion Phase
Comparison
5 Summary
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Insertion Loss
Interferer Power (dBm)
InsertionLoss(dB)
1
2
3
4
5
G G
G
G G G G G G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G G
G
G G
G G
G
G
G
G
G
G G
G
G G
G
G G
G G
G
G
G G G
G
G
G
−50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20
Frequency
(MHz)
3250
G 3200
3150
3100
3000
2950
G 2900
2850
G 60
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Insertion Phase
Interferer Power (dBm)
InsertionPhase(rad.)
−π
−
π
2
0
π
2
π
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G G G G G G G G G G G
G
G
G
G
−50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20
Frequency
(MHz)
3250
G 3200
3150
3100
3000
2950
G 2900
2850
G 60
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Calibrated vs. Uncalibrated Measurements
OoB Input Power (dBm)
In−BandOutputPower(dBm)
−124
−122
−120
−118
−120
−115
−110
−105
−125
−120
−115
−110
−120
−100
−80
−60
−125
−120
−115
−110
−120
−115
−110
−105
−120
−115
−110
−120
−115
−110
−105
−100
−50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20
32503200315031003000295029002850
Calibrated Uncalibrated
OoB Input Power (dBm)
In−BandOutputPhase(rad.)
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20
32503200315031003000295029002850
Calibrated Uncalibrated
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Calibrated vs. Uncalibrated Measurements
OoB Input Power (dBm)
In−BandOutputPower(dBm)
−124
−122
−120
−118
−120
−115
−110
−105
−125
−120
−115
−110
−120
−100
−80
−60
−125
−120
−115
−110
−120
−115
−110
−105
−120
−115
−110
−120
−115
−110
−105
−100
−50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20
32503200315031003000295029002850
Calibrated Uncalibrated
OoB Input Power (dBm)
In−BandOutputPhase(rad.)
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−π
0
π
−50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20
32503200315031003000295029002850
Calibrated Uncalibrated
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Outline
1 Motivation
Why?
Interference Considerations
2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics
Overview
Non-linear Network Analysis
3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer
Measurement System
Calibration & Processing
4 Results
Insertion Loss
Insertion Phase
Comparison
5 Summary
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
Summary
Potential interference risk between BRS signals and S-band
radar receivers
Can easily acquire AM-AM and AM-PM characteristics
Frequency conversion not a problem
NLNA not needed
DiY NLNA can be build using common lab equipment
AutoHotkey can automate the collection of data
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary
The End
THANK YOU!
McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference

More Related Content

What's hot

Introduction to the analog mobile phone system
Introduction to the analog mobile phone systemIntroduction to the analog mobile phone system
Introduction to the analog mobile phone system
simonandisa
 
Nec 2000 series
Nec 2000 seriesNec 2000 series
Nec 2000 series
Walter1111
 
Cellular network presentation
Cellular network presentationCellular network presentation
Cellular network presentation
Aditya Pandey
 

What's hot (20)

Unit 1 Introduction to wireless telecommunication system and networks
Unit  1 Introduction to wireless telecommunication system and networksUnit  1 Introduction to wireless telecommunication system and networks
Unit 1 Introduction to wireless telecommunication system and networks
 
Mobile communication
Mobile communicationMobile communication
Mobile communication
 
Co-channel and adjacent-channel interference evaluation of an outdoor telecom...
Co-channel and adjacent-channel interference evaluation of an outdoor telecom...Co-channel and adjacent-channel interference evaluation of an outdoor telecom...
Co-channel and adjacent-channel interference evaluation of an outdoor telecom...
 
It 802 d_intro&wlan
It 802 d_intro&wlanIt 802 d_intro&wlan
It 802 d_intro&wlan
 
Cellular Communication Report
Cellular Communication ReportCellular Communication Report
Cellular Communication Report
 
Introduction to the analog mobile phone system
Introduction to the analog mobile phone systemIntroduction to the analog mobile phone system
Introduction to the analog mobile phone system
 
Ch 02 telecommunications terminology
Ch 02 telecommunications terminology Ch 02 telecommunications terminology
Ch 02 telecommunications terminology
 
Frequency bands
Frequency bandsFrequency bands
Frequency bands
 
Radio individual presentation
Radio individual presentationRadio individual presentation
Radio individual presentation
 
Introduction wireless communication network
Introduction wireless communication networkIntroduction wireless communication network
Introduction wireless communication network
 
wireless cellular network
wireless cellular networkwireless cellular network
wireless cellular network
 
High frequency of communication
High frequency of communicationHigh frequency of communication
High frequency of communication
 
Wireless communication for 8th sem EC VTU students
Wireless communication for 8th sem EC VTU studentsWireless communication for 8th sem EC VTU students
Wireless communication for 8th sem EC VTU students
 
Ch 03 quality of service and telecommunication impairments.
Ch 03   quality of service and telecommunication impairments.Ch 03   quality of service and telecommunication impairments.
Ch 03 quality of service and telecommunication impairments.
 
Chapter 2
Chapter 2Chapter 2
Chapter 2
 
A complete guide for pcb 2.4G antenna design
A complete guide for pcb 2.4G antenna designA complete guide for pcb 2.4G antenna design
A complete guide for pcb 2.4G antenna design
 
Nec 2000 series
Nec 2000 seriesNec 2000 series
Nec 2000 series
 
Chapter 1 intro
Chapter 1 introChapter 1 intro
Chapter 1 intro
 
Cellular network presentation
Cellular network presentationCellular network presentation
Cellular network presentation
 
Wireless generations
Wireless generationsWireless generations
Wireless generations
 

Similar to a

8 wcdma rf optimization&case study-60
8 wcdma rf optimization&case study-608 wcdma rf optimization&case study-60
8 wcdma rf optimization&case study-60
Ba Quynh Nguyen
 
98780537 gsm-fundamentals
98780537 gsm-fundamentals98780537 gsm-fundamentals
98780537 gsm-fundamentals
Adzadogo Louis
 
3_Igarss2011RFI.ppt
3_Igarss2011RFI.ppt3_Igarss2011RFI.ppt
3_Igarss2011RFI.ppt
grssieee
 
digitalmicrowavecommunicationprinciples-131014163928-phpapp02 (1).pdf
digitalmicrowavecommunicationprinciples-131014163928-phpapp02 (1).pdfdigitalmicrowavecommunicationprinciples-131014163928-phpapp02 (1).pdf
digitalmicrowavecommunicationprinciples-131014163928-phpapp02 (1).pdf
SaraSwas
 

Similar to a (20)

Introduction to RADAR by NI
Introduction to RADAR by NIIntroduction to RADAR by NI
Introduction to RADAR by NI
 
Optimización de red_de_acceso-final
Optimización de red_de_acceso-finalOptimización de red_de_acceso-final
Optimización de red_de_acceso-final
 
Sesion 01 cip_a de la sesion 1 - 3
Sesion 01 cip_a de la sesion 1 - 3Sesion 01 cip_a de la sesion 1 - 3
Sesion 01 cip_a de la sesion 1 - 3
 
Point to point microwave
Point to point microwavePoint to point microwave
Point to point microwave
 
8 wcdma rf optimization&case study-60
8 wcdma rf optimization&case study-608 wcdma rf optimization&case study-60
8 wcdma rf optimization&case study-60
 
Digital processing of today’s radar signals
Digital processing of today’s radar signalsDigital processing of today’s radar signals
Digital processing of today’s radar signals
 
KinPhy
KinPhyKinPhy
KinPhy
 
Radar by abhishek mahajan
Radar by abhishek mahajanRadar by abhishek mahajan
Radar by abhishek mahajan
 
Antenna Field Handbook 1999.pdf
Antenna Field Handbook 1999.pdfAntenna Field Handbook 1999.pdf
Antenna Field Handbook 1999.pdf
 
Field Antenna Handbook.pdf
Field Antenna Handbook.pdfField Antenna Handbook.pdf
Field Antenna Handbook.pdf
 
wbn2007-hella-talk.ppt
wbn2007-hella-talk.pptwbn2007-hella-talk.ppt
wbn2007-hella-talk.ppt
 
98780537 gsm-fundamentals
98780537 gsm-fundamentals98780537 gsm-fundamentals
98780537 gsm-fundamentals
 
3_Igarss2011RFI.ppt
3_Igarss2011RFI.ppt3_Igarss2011RFI.ppt
3_Igarss2011RFI.ppt
 
Mueller_Massucci_Antenna_and_Mobile_Network_Testing_Challenges.pdf
Mueller_Massucci_Antenna_and_Mobile_Network_Testing_Challenges.pdfMueller_Massucci_Antenna_and_Mobile_Network_Testing_Challenges.pdf
Mueller_Massucci_Antenna_and_Mobile_Network_Testing_Challenges.pdf
 
Umts
UmtsUmts
Umts
 
FM IBOC Coverage Prediction
FM IBOC Coverage PredictionFM IBOC Coverage Prediction
FM IBOC Coverage Prediction
 
digitalmicrowavecommunicationprinciples-131014163928-phpapp02 (1).pdf
digitalmicrowavecommunicationprinciples-131014163928-phpapp02 (1).pdfdigitalmicrowavecommunicationprinciples-131014163928-phpapp02 (1).pdf
digitalmicrowavecommunicationprinciples-131014163928-phpapp02 (1).pdf
 
Laser Communication
Laser CommunicationLaser Communication
Laser Communication
 
FUNDAMENTALS OF MICROWAVE RADIO COMMUNICATION FOR IP AND TDM
FUNDAMENTALS OF MICROWAVE RADIO COMMUNICATION FOR IP AND TDMFUNDAMENTALS OF MICROWAVE RADIO COMMUNICATION FOR IP AND TDM
FUNDAMENTALS OF MICROWAVE RADIO COMMUNICATION FOR IP AND TDM
 
Digital_Microwave_Communication_Principl (1).ppt
Digital_Microwave_Communication_Principl (1).pptDigital_Microwave_Communication_Principl (1).ppt
Digital_Microwave_Communication_Principl (1).ppt
 

a

  • 1. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Characterizing an S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference Mark McFarland, P.E. Dr. Bob Johnk U.S. Department of Commerce National Telecommunications and Information Administration Institute for Telecommunications Sciences 2012 IEEE International Symposium on EMC McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 2. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Outline What You’ll Learn: Potential interference risk between BRS signals and S-band radar receivers Our measurement system enables simple, automated characterization of interference effects Without need for a NLNA McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 3. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Outline 1 Motivation Why? Interference Considerations 2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics Overview Non-linear Network Analysis 3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Measurement System Calibration & Processing 4 Results Insertion Loss Insertion Phase Comparison 5 Summary What You’ll Learn: Potential interference risk between BRS signals and S-band radar receivers Our measurement system enables simple, automated characterization of interference effects Without need for a NLNA McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 4. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Outline 1 Motivation Why? Interference Considerations 2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics Overview Non-linear Network Analysis 3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Measurement System Calibration & Processing 4 Results Insertion Loss Insertion Phase Comparison 5 Summary McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 5. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Why Are We Studying This? Potential Interference Risk Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may interfere with S-band marine radars BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE ∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts Number of those people using BRS systems increasing! US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection Criteria for S-band marine radars Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want to understand: Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS signals McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 6. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Why Are We Studying This? Potential Interference Risk Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may interfere with S-band marine radars BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE ∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts Number of those people using BRS systems increasing! US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection Criteria for S-band marine radars Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want to understand: Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS signals McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 7. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Why Are We Studying This? Potential Interference Risk Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may interfere with S-band marine radars BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE ∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts Number of those people using BRS systems increasing! US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection Criteria for S-band marine radars Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want to understand: Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS signals McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 8. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Why Are We Studying This? Potential Interference Risk Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may interfere with S-band marine radars BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE ∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts Number of those people using BRS systems increasing! US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection Criteria for S-band marine radars Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want to understand: Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS signals McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 9. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Why Are We Studying This? Potential Interference Risk Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may interfere with S-band marine radars BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE ∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts Number of those people using BRS systems increasing! US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection Criteria for S-band marine radars Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want to understand: Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS signals McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 10. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Why Are We Studying This? Potential Interference Risk Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may interfere with S-band marine radars BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE ∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts Number of those people using BRS systems increasing! US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection Criteria for S-band marine radars Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want to understand: Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS signals McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 11. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Why Are We Studying This? Potential Interference Risk Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may interfere with S-band marine radars BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE ∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts Number of those people using BRS systems increasing! US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection Criteria for S-band marine radars Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want to understand: Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS signals McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 12. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Why Are We Studying This? Potential Interference Risk Broadband radio service (BRS) spectrum allocations may interfere with S-band marine radars BRS includes Wi-MAX and LTE ∼50% of US population located within a few miles of coasts Number of those people using BRS systems increasing! US Coast Guard seeking to develop Interference Protection Criteria for S-band marine radars Over a range of interferer power levels & frequencies, we want to understand: Radar receiver’s AM-AM/PM characteristics Gain compression and changes in noise statistics due to BRS signals McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 13. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary S-band Radar Basics S-band Frequencies (MHz) Marine Band 2900-3100 Radar Channel 3020-3080 RF Input Frequency 3050 IF Output Frequency 60 McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 14. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary S-band Radar Basics S-band Frequencies (MHz) Marine Band 2900-3100 Radar Channel 3020-3080 RF Input Frequency 3050 IF Output Frequency 60 Frequency (MHz) Gain(dB) −30 −25 −20 −15 −10 −5 0 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 Component(s) Circulator Limiter Circulator and Limiter Band Marine Radar Channel BRS McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 15. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary S-band Radar Components Photograph McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 16. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary S-band Radar Components Photograph Circulator Limiter LNFE McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 17. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary S-band Radar Components Photograph Circulator RFin Tx (50 Ω load) Limiter LNFE LOin power IFout McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 18. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary S-band Radar Components Photograph Circulator RFin Tx (50 Ω load) Limiter LNFE LOin power IFout McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 19. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Interference Considerations Susceptibility LNFE receivers (used in radar, also GPS) Sensitive receivers Multi-stage gain “Wide-open” or filtered front ends Probability of interference between radar & BRS signals increasing Contributors WiMAX LTE Others? Impact on LNFE Receivers Analyzed via receiver’s AM-AM and AM-PM characteristics McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 20. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Outline 1 Motivation Why? Interference Considerations 2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics Overview Non-linear Network Analysis 3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Measurement System Calibration & Processing 4 Results Insertion Loss Insertion Phase Comparison 5 Summary McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 21. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Overview AM-AM and AM-PM AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of input power levels AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of input power levels McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 22. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Overview AM-AM and AM-PM AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of input power levels AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of input power levels Lots of Data Required for Characterization 15 interferer power levels −50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments 8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps) 15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements + 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings) Not a manual task! McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 23. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Overview AM-AM and AM-PM AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of input power levels AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of input power levels Lots of Data Required for Characterization 15 interferer power levels −50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments 8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps) 15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements + 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings) Not a manual task! McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 24. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Overview AM-AM and AM-PM AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of input power levels AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of input power levels Lots of Data Required for Characterization 15 interferer power levels −50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments 8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps) 15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements + 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings) Not a manual task! McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 25. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Overview AM-AM and AM-PM AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of input power levels AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of input power levels Lots of Data Required for Characterization 15 interferer power levels −50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments 8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps) 15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements + 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings) Not a manual task! McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 26. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Overview AM-AM and AM-PM AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of input power levels AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of input power levels Lots of Data Required for Characterization 15 interferer power levels −50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments 8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps) 15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements + 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings) Not a manual task! McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 27. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Overview AM-AM and AM-PM AM-AM Describes system’s output power over a range of input power levels AM-PM Describes system’s output phase over a range of input power levels Lots of Data Required for Characterization 15 interferer power levels −50 to +20 dBm in 5 dB increments 8 interferer frequencies (2850-3250 MHz, 50 MHz steps) 15 × 8 = 120 baseline measurements + 120 RF cal measurements, + 15 IF cal measurements TOTAL: 255 measurements (or VSA recordings) Not a manual task! McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 28. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Non-linear Network Analysis AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network analyzer Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion RF Input = 3050 MHz IF Output = 60 MHz Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis? With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA) A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 29. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Non-linear Network Analysis AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network analyzer Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion RF Input = 3050 MHz IF Output = 60 MHz Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis? With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA) A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 30. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Non-linear Network Analysis AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network analyzer Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion RF Input = 3050 MHz IF Output = 60 MHz Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis? With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA) A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 31. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Non-linear Network Analysis AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network analyzer Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion RF Input = 3050 MHz IF Output = 60 MHz Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis? With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA) A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 32. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Non-linear Network Analysis AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network analyzer Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion RF Input = 3050 MHz IF Output = 60 MHz Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis? With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA) A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 33. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Non-linear Network Analysis AM-AM/PM characteristics usually acquired with a network analyzer Not possible in this case due to frequency conversion RF Input = 3050 MHz IF Output = 60 MHz Thus, non-linear network analysis is needed How to Perform Non-linear Network Analysis? With a non-linear network analyzer (NLNA) A NLNA can measure output power and phase at one frequency as a function of input power at a different frequency Accommodates frequency conversion in the DUT McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 34. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Tradeoffs Problem NLNAs cost ∼$250,000 Solution Build a NLNA using: commonly available lab equipment open source software McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 35. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Tradeoffs Problem NLNAs cost ∼$250,000 Solution Build a NLNA using: commonly available lab equipment open source software Do-it-Yourself Non-linear Network Analyzer VSG DUT VSA Processing AM-AM AM-PM Rb clock AutoHotkey Control McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 36. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Outline 1 Motivation Why? Interference Considerations 2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics Overview Non-linear Network Analysis 3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Measurement System Calibration & Processing 4 Results Insertion Loss Insertion Phase Comparison 5 Summary McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 37. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System Block Diagram Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 38. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System Block Diagram Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey Provides interferer signal (varying frequency and power) McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 39. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System Block Diagram Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey Synchronizes VSG, VSA, and DUT (if applicable) McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 40. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System Block Diagram Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey Records IF output McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 41. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System Block Diagram Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey PC running VSA GUI control software McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 42. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System Block Diagram Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey AutoHotkey controls the VSA’s GUI McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 43. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System Block Diagram Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 44. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System AutoHotkey Automation Open source GNU General Public License No cost or license fees Automate almost any computer task Send keystrokes and/or mouse movements & clicks to applications Offers a scripting language Simple Low development time Can monitor VSA GUI See http://www.autohotkey.com McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 45. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System AutoHotkey Automation - Sample Code § ¤ 1 $F5:: prefix=in -band.3050 startPower = -50 stopPower = 20 6 dbStep = 5 numIter := (stopPower - startPower)/dbStep + 1 Loop %numIter% { 11 power := startPower + dbStep *( a_index -1) ; STARTUP - Data from hardware , then restart Send !ifh ; select: Input -dataFrom -Hardware Sleep , 1000 16 Send !cr ; select: Control -Restart -- to restart measurement Sleep , 8000 ; wait for filters ... ; START RECORDING 21 Send !cd ; start recording Sleep , 10000 ; wait for filters to settle and recording to finish ; SAVE RECORDING Send !fsr %prefix %.% power %{ Enter }{ Enter} 26 Sleep , 5000 ; wait for recording to write and VSG to change output power } ¦ ¥ McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 46. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Measurement System Photograph LO Rb clock VSG AHK/control VSA not used McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 47. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Calibration & Processing Block Diagrams Baseline Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 48. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Calibration & Processing Block Diagrams Baseline Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 49. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Calibration & Processing Block Diagrams Baseline Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey RF VSG VSA Rb clock AutoHotkey Control McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 50. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Calibration & Processing Block Diagrams Baseline Radar System Components VSG circ. limiter LNFE BPF VSA Rb clock LO ControlAutoHotkey RF VSG VSA Rb clock AutoHotkey Control IF VSG BPF VSA Rb clock AutoHotkey Control McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 51. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Outline 1 Motivation Why? Interference Considerations 2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics Overview Non-linear Network Analysis 3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Measurement System Calibration & Processing 4 Results Insertion Loss Insertion Phase Comparison 5 Summary McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 52. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Insertion Loss Interferer Power (dBm) InsertionLoss(dB) 1 2 3 4 5 G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G −50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 Frequency (MHz) 3250 G 3200 3150 3100 3000 2950 G 2900 2850 G 60 McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 53. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Insertion Phase Interferer Power (dBm) InsertionPhase(rad.) −π − π 2 0 π 2 π G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G G −50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 Frequency (MHz) 3250 G 3200 3150 3100 3000 2950 G 2900 2850 G 60 McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 54. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Calibrated vs. Uncalibrated Measurements OoB Input Power (dBm) In−BandOutputPower(dBm) −124 −122 −120 −118 −120 −115 −110 −105 −125 −120 −115 −110 −120 −100 −80 −60 −125 −120 −115 −110 −120 −115 −110 −105 −120 −115 −110 −120 −115 −110 −105 −100 −50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 32503200315031003000295029002850 Calibrated Uncalibrated OoB Input Power (dBm) In−BandOutputPhase(rad.) −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 32503200315031003000295029002850 Calibrated Uncalibrated McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 55. Calibrated vs. Uncalibrated Measurements OoB Input Power (dBm) In−BandOutputPower(dBm) −124 −122 −120 −118 −120 −115 −110 −105 −125 −120 −115 −110 −120 −100 −80 −60 −125 −120 −115 −110 −120 −115 −110 −105 −120 −115 −110 −120 −115 −110 −105 −100 −50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 32503200315031003000295029002850 Calibrated Uncalibrated OoB Input Power (dBm) In−BandOutputPhase(rad.) −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −π 0 π −50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 32503200315031003000295029002850 Calibrated Uncalibrated McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 56. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Outline 1 Motivation Why? Interference Considerations 2 Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics Overview Non-linear Network Analysis 3 DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Measurement System Calibration & Processing 4 Results Insertion Loss Insertion Phase Comparison 5 Summary McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 57. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary Summary Potential interference risk between BRS signals and S-band radar receivers Can easily acquire AM-AM and AM-PM characteristics Frequency conversion not a problem NLNA not needed DiY NLNA can be build using common lab equipment AutoHotkey can automate the collection of data McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference
  • 58. Motivation Acquiring AM-AM/PM Characteristics DiY Non-linear Network Analyzer Results Summary The End THANK YOU! McFarland, Johnk S-band Marine Radar Receiver in the Presence of Interference