Evidence-informed decision making – process and results to inform a breastfeeding program in a public health unit in Ontario

Uploaded on

Presented at the Canadian Public Health Association Centenary Conference Public Health in Canada: Shaping the Future Together, June 16, 2010 …

Presented at the Canadian Public Health Association Centenary Conference Public Health in Canada: Shaping the Future Together, June 16, 2010

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads


Total Views
On Slideshare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds



Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

    No notes for slide


  • 1. Outline • About the partners • Project background • Objectives • Methods • Results • Learning
  • 2. Project Partners Region of Peel Public Health • West of Toronto • 2nd largest public health unit in Ontario Health Evidence • Based at McMaster University • Dedicated to a Canadian public health system informed by the best-available evidence
  • 3. Peel Public Health• Cities of Mississauga, Brampton and Town of Caledon – population >1.25 million• Higher proportion of children, young families and immigrants than rest of Ontario
  • 4. Baby-friendly Designation • Baby Friendly Community Health Service - in June 2009: – seven Point Plan outcome criteria were met; 5 years to achieve – awarded by the Breastfeeding Committee for Canada, the national authority for WHO/UNICEF – Baby-friendly Initiative
  • 5. Health Evidence Funders
  • 6. Health Evidence Provide and promote access to the best available evidence – Registry – Literature searches & summaries – Facilitated evidence reviews Provide knowledge‐brokering services – Customized EIDM training – Mentoring and Knowledge Broker
  • 7. Health Evidence• online registry – 1900 reviews• evaluated interventions• updated quarterly• quality-assessed• searchable by commonly-used public health terms• two page summaries
  • 8. FormulaNOthanks.ca
  • 9. Next Step?
  • 10. Key Message Development Goal: To provide the best available evidence about the health consequences of formula feeding and to support informed decision-making with a comprehensive website to build efficacy and confidence to breastfeed
  • 11. EIDM Model National Collaborating Centre for Methods and Tools Haynes B, DiCenso, A., Ciliska D., & Guyatt, G. 2005
  • 12. EIDM Process Assess applicability Interpret Appraise the quality Search for evidence Define the questio n
  • 13. Objective • Determine if the available research literature supported a claim of improved cognitive development due to breastfeeding.
  • 14. Methods • Define the question • Search the literature • Relevance & quality assessment • Critical appraisal • Interpretation • Decision-making
  • 15. The Question Is breastfeeding exclusively for 6 months associated with enhanced cognitive development outcomes in children when compared with formula feeding?
  • 16. The Search • Database searches of Medline, Embase, CINAHL (2005-2009), searches run June 10, 2009 • Search terms were limited to results relating to humans, and English language
  • 17. Findings 1261 articles 1221 40 excluded retrieved (design, relevance) 10 30 excluded included (quality)
  • 18. Findings 4 studies moderate quality 6 had serious methodological flaws Good quality evidence suggested: - No relationship between breastfeeding and cognitive development when you control for maternal characteristics including IQ, socio-environmental factors
  • 19. Decision Factors • Research evidence define question • Public health search & appraise experience, beliefs context apply • Public health credibility Evidence-informed decision • Audience assessment
  • 20. Decision - Concept for the ‘IQ’ poster was deferred - Continued with infection, weight
  • 21. Learning and Next Steps • Crafting messaging to explain these findings • Continue to mine the literature • For Clients: create web pages with information about findings in language that is suitable to all literacy levels and add to the FormulaNOthanks.ca website • For Staff: Ongoing EIDM training, organizational supports and opportunities
  • 22. Thank you!Peel Health Health Evidence Beverley Bryant, Maureen Dobbins Manager of Education and Research Director Beverley.bryant@peelregion.ca dobbinsm@mcmaster.ca Angela Garrison, Lori Greco Family Health Supervisor Knowledge Broker, Angela.garrison@peelregion.ca lgreco@mcmaster.ca