There's a worrying trend out there in storytelling land. Too many non-profits either don’t have a case for support at all or have put a huge amount of effort and expense into creating one that, well... kinda sucks.
But cases for support are critically important to non-profit fundraising, and every non-profit should have one. No longer tied solely to capital campaigns, a strong case will pull your stakeholders together, touch people’s hearts, and elevate philanthropy.
And what's the most important element of an exceptionally effective case? The story that you weave into it. Stories are uniquely yours. They uniquely illustrate the problem and the solution. They are at the heart of everything you do.
Leah shares the secrets to case-specific storytelling, along with lots of really great examples.
Presented at the 2018 Nonprofit Storytelling Conference
1. Your Case for
Support
is a Story
Leah Eustace, CFRE, ACFRE
President and Head Paddler
Blue Canoe Philanthropy
www.yourbluecanoe.ca
Tweet @LeahEustace
6. The best cases for
support focus on
the ‘why’ of the
cause, rather than
the ‘how.’
7. They talk less
about the
institution, and
more about the
donor as the
hero of a story
that concludes
with a
transformational
solution to a
problem.
8. “If a story is not about the hearer
he [or she] will not listen . . . A great
lasting story is about everyone or it
will not last. The strange and foreign
is not interesting--only the deeply
personal and familiar.”
― John Steinbeck, East of Eden
9. • Capital Campaign
• Project
• Endowment
• Organizational
• Other?
Types of case:
15. What to include in your case
• Emotional and powerful opening
• Mission and vision
• History of impact (brief)
• Problems that need solutions
• Outcomes/solutions
• Sense of urgency
• Call to action
19. A frame story is a story set
within a story. In novels, a
character starts telling a story
to other characters, or he sits
down to write a story, telling
the details to the audience.
The Canterbury Tales is the
best known example.
24. • How would sport be different if
your organization didn’t exist?
• Tell me about your pivotal
moment?
• Take me on a walk through xxx
• Tell me about a particular person
you've met, or a program you've
been involved with (or a story
you've read) involving
[organization’s] work that has
stood out for you
• Why should donors care?
25. What’s the Frame Narrative?
Love, respect and dignity for Chinese seniors
28. Stories used in
this case:
• Love and respect for elders
• The transformation that culturally-
relevant care brings to loved ones
• Building falling down around them
• Cultural pride (mah-jong, familiar
food)
• True caring (the red cup)
• True love (Mr. & Mrs. Li)
• The vision of the home they deserve
Love + Respect + Caring
How many of you have a case for support?
How many wish they had a case for support?
How many don’t think they need a case for support, but the title of the session caught their eye
Are you happy with your case?
Why are you here?
Every single one
Put your hand up if every single person in your organization knows what you’re raising money for?
The argument for supporting your cause
“making your case”
Your rallying cry
The music plays seamlessly
The audience is enthralled… they may laugh, they may be moved to tears… they’re all in
But what goes into that piece of music?
Many people playing different instruments and different times
A conductor pulling it all together
You’re the conductor
Your musicians are your beneficiaries, board, volunteers,
Donor-sized hole
Donors
Prospective donors
Board members
Other volunteers
As much an internal rallying cry as anything else
Your wealthiest donor, your CEO, your bookkeeper and your receptionist should all be equally inspired by it, and should equally understand it
Internal or external?
the importance of PCCF;
an outline of the problems that need solutions;
the solutions to the problems;
the expected outcomes of a successful campaign;
PCCF’s history, track record, impact, and accountability;
a brief menu of ‘purchase choices’ outlining what the donor’s investment will ‘buy;’
a sense of urgency; and;
a clear and compelling call to action.
Were you wondering when I’d get to the point?
Storytelling with cases is different
The prologue sets the narrative, introduces the characters and explains why they’ve all come together
Someone who knows history/impact
Someone who can talk about future vision
Program people
Donors
Beneficiaries
Other?
Interviews for political purposes
Lots of emotion
Donor is at the centre of the story
Write at a grade 6 or 7 level
Don’t try to educate
Try writing a first draft without mentioning the name of your organization
Write when you’re feeling emotional