SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Review comments:
Regarding to the data of Table 1, The authors explained that WINDIG 2.5, the extracted data software,
was used to extract the data from the Figure 4 of reference 9 (S.H. Byun, W.V. Prestwich, K. Chin, F.E.
McNeill, D.R. Chettle, “Efficiency calibration and coincidence summing correction for a 4π NaI(Tl)
detector array”, Nucl. Instr. Meth. Phys. Res. A, 535, 3 (2004);
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2004.06.174).
I have checked the performance of WINDIG by reference some technical papers about WINDIG, and I
have also installed WINDIG and tried to extract data from the Figure 4 of Reference 9. I recognized
that some problems arise as:
1. WINDIG do not return the error of extracting data, but in Table 1 including the errors
2. In Figure 4 of reference 9, the total efficiencies of the experiment were depicted by square dots, but
the curved line presented the simulated data of total efficiency. By using WINDIG, It is not correct to
extract the data from the simulation.
I also wonder why in the Reference 9, the data were presented clearly in Table 1 with including the
errors, but the author did not use it? Also, when comparison between the data from the Table 1 of the
manuscript and the date from Table 1 of reference 9, I recognized that the measured and simulated data
between two tables are different. With the differences, it affected to the correctness of final results.
In addition, if this manuscript will be published, the readers will wonder why the data in the reference
are not same within the manuscript.
In Table 1. the radioisotope with energy 0.662 MeV is 137Cs, not Ba. Please correct it again.

More Related Content

Similar to Review comments nt

Rubrics & Self Assessments Online Submission
Rubrics & Self Assessments Online SubmissionRubrics & Self Assessments Online Submission
Rubrics & Self Assessments Online SubmissionStephen Taylor
 
Excel 2016 Chapter 6 Exploring the Function Library Last U.docx
Excel 2016 Chapter 6 Exploring the Function Library Last U.docxExcel 2016 Chapter 6 Exploring the Function Library Last U.docx
Excel 2016 Chapter 6 Exploring the Function Library Last U.docxcravennichole326
 
viriology1) Describe and explain the structure , genomic org.docx
viriology1) Describe and explain the structure , genomic org.docxviriology1) Describe and explain the structure , genomic org.docx
viriology1) Describe and explain the structure , genomic org.docxdickonsondorris
 
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATIONDATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATIONijcsity
 
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION ijcsity
 
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATIONDATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATIONijcsity
 
IE332Engineering Statistics IINOTES· Show your work,
IE332Engineering Statistics IINOTES· Show your work,IE332Engineering Statistics IINOTES· Show your work,
IE332Engineering Statistics IINOTES· Show your work,MalikPinckney86
 
Biology Lab Book
Biology Lab BookBiology Lab Book
Biology Lab Bookbfurlong
 
Lab report templante for 10th and 9th grade
Lab report templante for 10th and 9th gradeLab report templante for 10th and 9th grade
Lab report templante for 10th and 9th gradeSofia Paz
 
Lab report templete
Lab report templeteLab report templete
Lab report templeteSofia Paz
 

Similar to Review comments nt (11)

Rubrics & Self Assessments Online Submission
Rubrics & Self Assessments Online SubmissionRubrics & Self Assessments Online Submission
Rubrics & Self Assessments Online Submission
 
Excel 2016 Chapter 6 Exploring the Function Library Last U.docx
Excel 2016 Chapter 6 Exploring the Function Library Last U.docxExcel 2016 Chapter 6 Exploring the Function Library Last U.docx
Excel 2016 Chapter 6 Exploring the Function Library Last U.docx
 
viriology1) Describe and explain the structure , genomic org.docx
viriology1) Describe and explain the structure , genomic org.docxviriology1) Describe and explain the structure , genomic org.docx
viriology1) Describe and explain the structure , genomic org.docx
 
Validating Automated Structure Confirmation Using NMR Prediction in a Blind S...
Validating Automated Structure Confirmation Using NMR Prediction in a Blind S...Validating Automated Structure Confirmation Using NMR Prediction in a Blind S...
Validating Automated Structure Confirmation Using NMR Prediction in a Blind S...
 
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATIONDATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
 
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
 
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATIONDATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
DATA TABLE, EQUATION FIT OR INTERPOLATION
 
IE332Engineering Statistics IINOTES· Show your work,
IE332Engineering Statistics IINOTES· Show your work,IE332Engineering Statistics IINOTES· Show your work,
IE332Engineering Statistics IINOTES· Show your work,
 
Biology Lab Book
Biology Lab BookBiology Lab Book
Biology Lab Book
 
Lab report templante for 10th and 9th grade
Lab report templante for 10th and 9th gradeLab report templante for 10th and 9th grade
Lab report templante for 10th and 9th grade
 
Lab report templete
Lab report templeteLab report templete
Lab report templete
 

Recently uploaded

Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...shyamraj55
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
Neo4j - How KGs are shaping the future of Generative AI at AWS Summit London ...
Neo4j - How KGs are shaping the future of Generative AI at AWS Summit London ...Neo4j - How KGs are shaping the future of Generative AI at AWS Summit London ...
Neo4j - How KGs are shaping the future of Generative AI at AWS Summit London ...Neo4j
 
Artificial intelligence in the post-deep learning era
Artificial intelligence in the post-deep learning eraArtificial intelligence in the post-deep learning era
Artificial intelligence in the post-deep learning eraDeakin University
 
Benefits Of Flutter Compared To Other Frameworks
Benefits Of Flutter Compared To Other FrameworksBenefits Of Flutter Compared To Other Frameworks
Benefits Of Flutter Compared To Other FrameworksSoftradix Technologies
 
Understanding the Laravel MVC Architecture
Understanding the Laravel MVC ArchitectureUnderstanding the Laravel MVC Architecture
Understanding the Laravel MVC ArchitecturePixlogix Infotech
 
Breaking the Kubernetes Kill Chain: Host Path Mount
Breaking the Kubernetes Kill Chain: Host Path MountBreaking the Kubernetes Kill Chain: Host Path Mount
Breaking the Kubernetes Kill Chain: Host Path MountPuma Security, LLC
 
Kotlin Multiplatform & Compose Multiplatform - Starter kit for pragmatics
Kotlin Multiplatform & Compose Multiplatform - Starter kit for pragmaticsKotlin Multiplatform & Compose Multiplatform - Starter kit for pragmatics
Kotlin Multiplatform & Compose Multiplatform - Starter kit for pragmaticscarlostorres15106
 
Transcript: #StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
Transcript: #StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024Transcript: #StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
Transcript: #StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024BookNet Canada
 
Install Stable Diffusion in windows machine
Install Stable Diffusion in windows machineInstall Stable Diffusion in windows machine
Install Stable Diffusion in windows machinePadma Pradeep
 
Human Factors of XR: Using Human Factors to Design XR Systems
Human Factors of XR: Using Human Factors to Design XR SystemsHuman Factors of XR: Using Human Factors to Design XR Systems
Human Factors of XR: Using Human Factors to Design XR SystemsMark Billinghurst
 
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | DelhiFULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhisoniya singh
 
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):comworks
 
Azure Monitor & Application Insight to monitor Infrastructure & Application
Azure Monitor & Application Insight to monitor Infrastructure & ApplicationAzure Monitor & Application Insight to monitor Infrastructure & Application
Azure Monitor & Application Insight to monitor Infrastructure & ApplicationAndikSusilo4
 
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure serviceWhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure servicePooja Nehwal
 
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024Scott Keck-Warren
 
Pigging Solutions Piggable Sweeping Elbows
Pigging Solutions Piggable Sweeping ElbowsPigging Solutions Piggable Sweeping Elbows
Pigging Solutions Piggable Sweeping ElbowsPigging Solutions
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men
 
Neo4j - How KGs are shaping the future of Generative AI at AWS Summit London ...
Neo4j - How KGs are shaping the future of Generative AI at AWS Summit London ...Neo4j - How KGs are shaping the future of Generative AI at AWS Summit London ...
Neo4j - How KGs are shaping the future of Generative AI at AWS Summit London ...
 
Artificial intelligence in the post-deep learning era
Artificial intelligence in the post-deep learning eraArtificial intelligence in the post-deep learning era
Artificial intelligence in the post-deep learning era
 
Benefits Of Flutter Compared To Other Frameworks
Benefits Of Flutter Compared To Other FrameworksBenefits Of Flutter Compared To Other Frameworks
Benefits Of Flutter Compared To Other Frameworks
 
Understanding the Laravel MVC Architecture
Understanding the Laravel MVC ArchitectureUnderstanding the Laravel MVC Architecture
Understanding the Laravel MVC Architecture
 
Breaking the Kubernetes Kill Chain: Host Path Mount
Breaking the Kubernetes Kill Chain: Host Path MountBreaking the Kubernetes Kill Chain: Host Path Mount
Breaking the Kubernetes Kill Chain: Host Path Mount
 
Vulnerability_Management_GRC_by Sohang Sengupta.pptx
Vulnerability_Management_GRC_by Sohang Sengupta.pptxVulnerability_Management_GRC_by Sohang Sengupta.pptx
Vulnerability_Management_GRC_by Sohang Sengupta.pptx
 
Kotlin Multiplatform & Compose Multiplatform - Starter kit for pragmatics
Kotlin Multiplatform & Compose Multiplatform - Starter kit for pragmaticsKotlin Multiplatform & Compose Multiplatform - Starter kit for pragmatics
Kotlin Multiplatform & Compose Multiplatform - Starter kit for pragmatics
 
Transcript: #StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
Transcript: #StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024Transcript: #StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
Transcript: #StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
 
Install Stable Diffusion in windows machine
Install Stable Diffusion in windows machineInstall Stable Diffusion in windows machine
Install Stable Diffusion in windows machine
 
Human Factors of XR: Using Human Factors to Design XR Systems
Human Factors of XR: Using Human Factors to Design XR SystemsHuman Factors of XR: Using Human Factors to Design XR Systems
Human Factors of XR: Using Human Factors to Design XR Systems
 
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | DelhiFULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
 
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
CloudStudio User manual (basic edition):
 
Azure Monitor & Application Insight to monitor Infrastructure & Application
Azure Monitor & Application Insight to monitor Infrastructure & ApplicationAzure Monitor & Application Insight to monitor Infrastructure & Application
Azure Monitor & Application Insight to monitor Infrastructure & Application
 
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure serviceWhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
 
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
 
Pigging Solutions Piggable Sweeping Elbows
Pigging Solutions Piggable Sweeping ElbowsPigging Solutions Piggable Sweeping Elbows
Pigging Solutions Piggable Sweeping Elbows
 
E-Vehicle_Hacking_by_Parul Sharma_null_owasp.pptx
E-Vehicle_Hacking_by_Parul Sharma_null_owasp.pptxE-Vehicle_Hacking_by_Parul Sharma_null_owasp.pptx
E-Vehicle_Hacking_by_Parul Sharma_null_owasp.pptx
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
 

Review comments nt

  • 1. Review comments: Regarding to the data of Table 1, The authors explained that WINDIG 2.5, the extracted data software, was used to extract the data from the Figure 4 of reference 9 (S.H. Byun, W.V. Prestwich, K. Chin, F.E. McNeill, D.R. Chettle, “Efficiency calibration and coincidence summing correction for a 4π NaI(Tl) detector array”, Nucl. Instr. Meth. Phys. Res. A, 535, 3 (2004); http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2004.06.174). I have checked the performance of WINDIG by reference some technical papers about WINDIG, and I have also installed WINDIG and tried to extract data from the Figure 4 of Reference 9. I recognized that some problems arise as: 1. WINDIG do not return the error of extracting data, but in Table 1 including the errors 2. In Figure 4 of reference 9, the total efficiencies of the experiment were depicted by square dots, but the curved line presented the simulated data of total efficiency. By using WINDIG, It is not correct to extract the data from the simulation. I also wonder why in the Reference 9, the data were presented clearly in Table 1 with including the errors, but the author did not use it? Also, when comparison between the data from the Table 1 of the manuscript and the date from Table 1 of reference 9, I recognized that the measured and simulated data between two tables are different. With the differences, it affected to the correctness of final results. In addition, if this manuscript will be published, the readers will wonder why the data in the reference are not same within the manuscript. In Table 1. the radioisotope with energy 0.662 MeV is 137Cs, not Ba. Please correct it again.