SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Evaluation of Fieldwork Performance: A Critical Tool for Program Evaluation
                                      Michael Roberts, MS, OTR/L, Lisa Tekell, MS, OTR/L, OTD, Mary Alicia Barnes, BS, OTR/L

                                                                                                                                                                                                         MOVING FORWARD:
         Current BENEFITS for Using FWPE for Curricular Outcomes
                                                                                                                                                                                               DIGITAL FORMAT and NATIONAL DATABASE
• Assess performance by setting,    • Correlations between , FWPE,                                                                                              Ability to compare FWPE performance between programs:
  population or practice type         admission assessment, GPA,                                                                                                • Differences correlated with gender, age groups, race/ethnicity, prior work
• Specific ACOTE standards applied    NBCOT, job placements                                                                                                       experience
  to specific FWPE items            • Identify indicators for more                                                                                              • Compare FWPE subgroup scores (e.g. Professional Behavior) to
• Compare performance for different   accurate and efficient intervention                                                                                         benchmarks/national mean
  supervision models                  with students in difficulty                                                                                               • Compare performance in each setting, population, practice type to national
• Correlations with NBCOT pass      • Identify special recognition for                                                                                            benchmarks
  rates                               student performance in practice                                                                                           • Compare/correlate quantitative scoring with subjective comments

             CHALLENGES with Using FWPE for Curricular Outcomes                                                                                                                                             THE NEXT STEP: What We Need

  General                                                             Inter-program Collaboration                                                               Updated and Improved Tools:                                                   Additional Resources:
 • Format: labor intensive                                            • Different fieldwork models                                                              • Digital, Reliable, Valid Fieldwork                                          • Time/release for research
 • Research/Statistical expertise                                     • Different level II durations                                                              Performance Evaluation                                                      • Research expertise, training,
 • Time/Resources                                                     • Different level I preparation                                                           • Online SEFWE and FWPE to ease                                                 mentorship
 • Reliability/Validity                                               • Different licensure expectations                                                          capture of subjective data                                                  • National Fieldwork Research Agenda
                                                                      • Different curricula                                                                     • National access to a national
                                                                      • Communication efficiency                                                                   database of FWPE data


    AOTA Recommendations for Fieldwork Education (AOTA, 2006)                                                                                                                      Examples of Curricular Outcomes from FWPE Analysis
 • “Fieldwork Clearinghouse” - Resource bank for information developed by consortia and/or                                                                      ACOTE Interpretive Guide states “The goal of Level II fieldwork is to develop competent, entry-
   schools                                                                                                                                                      level, generalist occupational therapists”(AOTA, 2012). FWPE data can be analyzed to ensure the
 • Explore technology to support fieldwork education and resource development to make                                                                           curricular output meets this expectation (example data from Tufts University, 2011):
   resources readily accessible and to curtail costs to end user
 • Lifting fieldwork from operational (curriculum and educational standards implementation)                                                                                                      Mean Midterm              Mean Final             FW Setting            N
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Mean Midterm               Mean Final
   boundaries and translating it to the conceptual approaches that guide and develop fieldwork                                                                    Population             N                                                                                        FWPE                     FWPE
                                                                                                                                                                                                    FWPE                    FWPE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Community-
   education to its fullest potential                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   6            100.33                  132.00
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   based
 • Fieldwork education as an empowerment of change to enhance the bridges between                                                                                     Adult             38             103.71                  138.26
   education and practice as well as potentially research                                                                                                                                                                                           Inpatient          34            101.88                  136.65
 • Develop a collaborative research agenda related to fieldwork education (with practice and                                                                                                                                                      Outpatient           12            108.58                  142.75
                                                                                                                                                                   Pediatric            24             102.33                  135.87
   education)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     School            10            102.80                  136.40
 • Establish a “Decade of Fieldwork” to highlight our investment and accomplish the goal of
                                                                                                                                                                                                     0.730 (not              0.442 (not
   the strategic plan to link education, research, and practice.                                                                                                        ANOVA           p=                                                                                         0.583 (not              0.272 (not
                                                                                                                                                                                                    significant)            significant)                ANOVA          p=
 • Request that AOTF recognize the research science of fieldwork education                                                                                                                                                                                                        significant)            significant)

AOTA. (2006). Report to the President: Ad hoc committee to explore and develop resources for OT fieldwork educators. (Unpublished committee report, personal   AOTA. (2012). 2011 ACOTE Standards and Interpretive Guide (effective July 31, 2013) January 2012 Interpretive Guide Version. Bethesda, MD: author.
     communication). Bethesda, MD: author.

More Related Content

Similar to Evaluation Of Fwpe A Critical Tool For Progam Evaluation Aota Conf 2012

PEPFAR Vietnam Indicator Database
PEPFAR Vietnam Indicator DatabasePEPFAR Vietnam Indicator Database
PEPFAR Vietnam Indicator DatabaseMEASURE Evaluation
 
Well br wbl maturity toolkit v 0.7
Well br wbl maturity toolkit v 0.7Well br wbl maturity toolkit v 0.7
Well br wbl maturity toolkit v 0.7balham
 
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.2
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.2Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.2
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.2balham
 
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.1
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.1Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.1
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.1balham
 
Referral floatchart arpil 10 draft
Referral floatchart   arpil 10 draftReferral floatchart   arpil 10 draft
Referral floatchart arpil 10 draftqrobertson
 
Aligning Curriculum to the Common Core
Aligning Curriculum to the Common CoreAligning Curriculum to the Common Core
Aligning Curriculum to the Common CoreMike Fisher
 
Lessons Learned: Our Journey to Digital
Lessons Learned: Our Journey to DigitalLessons Learned: Our Journey to Digital
Lessons Learned: Our Journey to DigitalCurriculum Associates
 
Dlfan v2 bethel admin share
Dlfan v2 bethel admin shareDlfan v2 bethel admin share
Dlfan v2 bethel admin shareEdAdvance
 
Academic assessment plan. under construction
Academic assessment plan. under constructionAcademic assessment plan. under construction
Academic assessment plan. under constructionOAAVFAC
 
ACGME/RRC Update on NAS
ACGME/RRC Update on NASACGME/RRC Update on NAS
ACGME/RRC Update on NASjakinyi
 
Performance Management Brochure 2010
Performance Management Brochure 2010Performance Management Brochure 2010
Performance Management Brochure 2010bcb5026
 
Uconn Mission, Focus and Coherence Share
Uconn Mission, Focus and Coherence ShareUconn Mission, Focus and Coherence Share
Uconn Mission, Focus and Coherence ShareEdAdvance
 
Central Sacramento Regional Workshop
Central Sacramento Regional WorkshopCentral Sacramento Regional Workshop
Central Sacramento Regional Workshopncook
 
Multimedia Needs Assessment
Multimedia Needs AssessmentMultimedia Needs Assessment
Multimedia Needs AssessmentFarzad Jahedi
 
Moodle competencies a hidden gem
Moodle competencies   a hidden gemMoodle competencies   a hidden gem
Moodle competencies a hidden gemGavin Henrick
 
CMMI High Maturity Best Practices HMBP 2010: Deploying High Maturity Practice...
CMMI High Maturity Best Practices HMBP 2010: Deploying High Maturity Practice...CMMI High Maturity Best Practices HMBP 2010: Deploying High Maturity Practice...
CMMI High Maturity Best Practices HMBP 2010: Deploying High Maturity Practice...QAI
 
Curriculum updates for schools
Curriculum updates for schoolsCurriculum updates for schools
Curriculum updates for schoolsdowelld
 

Similar to Evaluation Of Fwpe A Critical Tool For Progam Evaluation Aota Conf 2012 (20)

Cooperation Workshop
Cooperation WorkshopCooperation Workshop
Cooperation Workshop
 
PEPFAR Vietnam Indicator Database
PEPFAR Vietnam Indicator DatabasePEPFAR Vietnam Indicator Database
PEPFAR Vietnam Indicator Database
 
Well br wbl maturity toolkit v 0.7
Well br wbl maturity toolkit v 0.7Well br wbl maturity toolkit v 0.7
Well br wbl maturity toolkit v 0.7
 
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.2
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.2Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.2
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.2
 
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.1
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.1Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.1
Well br wfd maturity toolkit v 0.1
 
Referral floatchart arpil 10 draft
Referral floatchart   arpil 10 draftReferral floatchart   arpil 10 draft
Referral floatchart arpil 10 draft
 
Aligning Curriculum to the Common Core
Aligning Curriculum to the Common CoreAligning Curriculum to the Common Core
Aligning Curriculum to the Common Core
 
Lessons Learned: Our Journey to Digital
Lessons Learned: Our Journey to DigitalLessons Learned: Our Journey to Digital
Lessons Learned: Our Journey to Digital
 
Dlfan v2 bethel admin share
Dlfan v2 bethel admin shareDlfan v2 bethel admin share
Dlfan v2 bethel admin share
 
Ddips edtpa exe
Ddips edtpa exeDdips edtpa exe
Ddips edtpa exe
 
Academic assessment plan. under construction
Academic assessment plan. under constructionAcademic assessment plan. under construction
Academic assessment plan. under construction
 
Blue ribbon
Blue ribbonBlue ribbon
Blue ribbon
 
ACGME/RRC Update on NAS
ACGME/RRC Update on NASACGME/RRC Update on NAS
ACGME/RRC Update on NAS
 
Performance Management Brochure 2010
Performance Management Brochure 2010Performance Management Brochure 2010
Performance Management Brochure 2010
 
Uconn Mission, Focus and Coherence Share
Uconn Mission, Focus and Coherence ShareUconn Mission, Focus and Coherence Share
Uconn Mission, Focus and Coherence Share
 
Central Sacramento Regional Workshop
Central Sacramento Regional WorkshopCentral Sacramento Regional Workshop
Central Sacramento Regional Workshop
 
Multimedia Needs Assessment
Multimedia Needs AssessmentMultimedia Needs Assessment
Multimedia Needs Assessment
 
Moodle competencies a hidden gem
Moodle competencies   a hidden gemMoodle competencies   a hidden gem
Moodle competencies a hidden gem
 
CMMI High Maturity Best Practices HMBP 2010: Deploying High Maturity Practice...
CMMI High Maturity Best Practices HMBP 2010: Deploying High Maturity Practice...CMMI High Maturity Best Practices HMBP 2010: Deploying High Maturity Practice...
CMMI High Maturity Best Practices HMBP 2010: Deploying High Maturity Practice...
 
Curriculum updates for schools
Curriculum updates for schoolsCurriculum updates for schools
Curriculum updates for schools
 

More from Michael Roberts, MS, OTR/L

More from Michael Roberts, MS, OTR/L (6)

Neotec consortium research data
Neotec consortium research dataNeotec consortium research data
Neotec consortium research data
 
Mao tposter 1 ready to print
Mao tposter 1 ready to printMao tposter 1 ready to print
Mao tposter 1 ready to print
 
2012 AOTA PD AFC Presentation Roberts
2012 AOTA PD AFC Presentation Roberts2012 AOTA PD AFC Presentation Roberts
2012 AOTA PD AFC Presentation Roberts
 
Tufts Fwpe Data Analysis For Aota Pd Afc
Tufts Fwpe Data Analysis For Aota Pd AfcTufts Fwpe Data Analysis For Aota Pd Afc
Tufts Fwpe Data Analysis For Aota Pd Afc
 
Wii Habilitation Scientific Poster Final
Wii Habilitation Scientific Poster FinalWii Habilitation Scientific Poster Final
Wii Habilitation Scientific Poster Final
 
Aota 2010 Slides
Aota 2010 SlidesAota 2010 Slides
Aota 2010 Slides
 

Evaluation Of Fwpe A Critical Tool For Progam Evaluation Aota Conf 2012

  • 1. Evaluation of Fieldwork Performance: A Critical Tool for Program Evaluation Michael Roberts, MS, OTR/L, Lisa Tekell, MS, OTR/L, OTD, Mary Alicia Barnes, BS, OTR/L MOVING FORWARD: Current BENEFITS for Using FWPE for Curricular Outcomes DIGITAL FORMAT and NATIONAL DATABASE • Assess performance by setting, • Correlations between , FWPE, Ability to compare FWPE performance between programs: population or practice type admission assessment, GPA, • Differences correlated with gender, age groups, race/ethnicity, prior work • Specific ACOTE standards applied NBCOT, job placements experience to specific FWPE items • Identify indicators for more • Compare FWPE subgroup scores (e.g. Professional Behavior) to • Compare performance for different accurate and efficient intervention benchmarks/national mean supervision models with students in difficulty • Compare performance in each setting, population, practice type to national • Correlations with NBCOT pass • Identify special recognition for benchmarks rates student performance in practice • Compare/correlate quantitative scoring with subjective comments CHALLENGES with Using FWPE for Curricular Outcomes THE NEXT STEP: What We Need General Inter-program Collaboration Updated and Improved Tools: Additional Resources: • Format: labor intensive • Different fieldwork models • Digital, Reliable, Valid Fieldwork • Time/release for research • Research/Statistical expertise • Different level II durations Performance Evaluation • Research expertise, training, • Time/Resources • Different level I preparation • Online SEFWE and FWPE to ease mentorship • Reliability/Validity • Different licensure expectations capture of subjective data • National Fieldwork Research Agenda • Different curricula • National access to a national • Communication efficiency database of FWPE data AOTA Recommendations for Fieldwork Education (AOTA, 2006) Examples of Curricular Outcomes from FWPE Analysis • “Fieldwork Clearinghouse” - Resource bank for information developed by consortia and/or ACOTE Interpretive Guide states “The goal of Level II fieldwork is to develop competent, entry- schools level, generalist occupational therapists”(AOTA, 2012). FWPE data can be analyzed to ensure the • Explore technology to support fieldwork education and resource development to make curricular output meets this expectation (example data from Tufts University, 2011): resources readily accessible and to curtail costs to end user • Lifting fieldwork from operational (curriculum and educational standards implementation) Mean Midterm Mean Final FW Setting N Mean Midterm Mean Final boundaries and translating it to the conceptual approaches that guide and develop fieldwork Population N FWPE FWPE FWPE FWPE Community- education to its fullest potential 6 100.33 132.00 based • Fieldwork education as an empowerment of change to enhance the bridges between Adult 38 103.71 138.26 education and practice as well as potentially research Inpatient 34 101.88 136.65 • Develop a collaborative research agenda related to fieldwork education (with practice and Outpatient 12 108.58 142.75 Pediatric 24 102.33 135.87 education) School 10 102.80 136.40 • Establish a “Decade of Fieldwork” to highlight our investment and accomplish the goal of 0.730 (not 0.442 (not the strategic plan to link education, research, and practice. ANOVA p= 0.583 (not 0.272 (not significant) significant) ANOVA p= • Request that AOTF recognize the research science of fieldwork education significant) significant) AOTA. (2006). Report to the President: Ad hoc committee to explore and develop resources for OT fieldwork educators. (Unpublished committee report, personal AOTA. (2012). 2011 ACOTE Standards and Interpretive Guide (effective July 31, 2013) January 2012 Interpretive Guide Version. Bethesda, MD: author. communication). Bethesda, MD: author.