3. 台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
電影獨立精神獎提名 (2004)
Independent Spirit Awards Nominee
最佳長片 | 最佳劇本 | 最佳攝影 | 最佳男配⾓角
華盛頓特區影評⼈人協會獎提名 (2003)
Washington DC Area Film Critics Association
Awards Nominee
最佳改編劇本 | 最佳男配⾓角
⾦金金球獎提名 (2003)
Golden Globe Awards Nominee
最佳男配⾓角
芝加哥影評⼈人協會獎提名 (2004)
Chicago Film Critics Association Awards
最具潛⼒力力電影⼈人 | 最佳男配⾓角
鄉村之聲影片票選 (2003)
Village Voice Film Poll
最佳⾸首部長片提名 | 最佳男配⾓角獲獎
鳳凰城影評⼈人協會獎提名 (2004)
Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards
年年度遺珠電影 (Overlooked Film of the Year)
http://www.impawards.com/2003/
posters/shattered_glass_xlg.jpg
Shattered Glass (2003) 電影海海報
4. His penalty has been five years in therapy and a six-
figure advance for a novel about a cheating journalist.
Mackie, R. (2004). Shattered Glass. The Guardian, p. DVD and
video reviews. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/
film/2004/oct/01/dvdreviews1
‘Shattered Glass’, DVD and Film Review
The Guardian
1 October 2004
《欲蓋彌彰》
Rob Mackie
台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
他受到的處罰包括五年年治療，還
有⼀一本⼩小說的六位數預付版稅，
是關於⼀一名作弊的記者。
5. Why did I--vain skeptic--fall for the too-good-to-be-
true journalism of Stephen Glass?
Glass Houses. (1998). Retrieved from http://www.slate.com/
articles/news_and_politics/flame_posies/1998/05/
glass_houses.html
‘Glass Houses’
Slate Magazine
15 May 1998
玻璃房屋
Jack Shafer
台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
為什什麼我會被 Stephen Glass 寫
的那些太過美好，以⾄至於不可能
為真的報導騙到？
6. ‘Deceived’, The Current Cinema
The New Yorker
3 November 2003
被騙
Anthony Lane
台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
但是，如果光是對於不誠實的報
導，你就⽤用上全部的憤怒和哀嚎，
那麼對於真正的惡惡意——真正在
腐蝕我們⽣生活的危害和疏忽——
你還剩下什什麼？
If, however, you expend all your wrath and
lamentation on dodgy reporting, what on earth have
you got left over for actual malevolence—for the
strains of harm and negligence that genuinely corrode
our lives?
Lane, A. (2003). Deceived. The New Yorker, The Current Cinema.
Retrieved from https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/
2003/11/03/deceived
7. As purveyors of myth, however, movies do not always
necessarily ‘serve and preserve social order’; they
also potentially ‘have the capacity to change the
social order’ (Lule, 2001: 191–2), or at least highlight
the contradictions within it.
Lule, Jack (2001) Daily News, Eternal Stories. New York: Guilford.
Ehrlich, M. (2006). Facts, truth and bad journalists in the movies.
Journalism: Theory, Practice & Criticism, 7(4), 501-519. doi:
10.1177/1464884906068364
‘Facts, truth, and bad journalists in the movies’
Journalism: Theory, Practice & Criticism
2006
提問
Mathew C. Ehrlich
台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
就像電影不總是散布迷思，電影並
不總是必需「服務並保存社會秩
序」；它們也有潛在的能⼒力力改變社
會秩序 (Lule, 2001: 191–2)，或⾄至
少標誌存在社會內部的衝突。
8. Is it possible that there is a need for some kind of an
ethic rooted in a critique of liberalism and based on a
democratic, multicultural, humane ideal?
Judith Grant, Morality and Liberal Legal Culture: Woody Allen's
Crimes and Misdemeanors, in LEGAL REELISM, supra note 2, at
169.
‘Hollywood and Journalistic Truthtelling’
Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy
Issue 2, Volume 19, February 2014
提問
Mathew C. Ehrlich
台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
有沒有可能，我們需要基於⼀一個
⺠民主、多元⽂文化和⼈人道理理想，將
某種道德植入在⾃自由主義的批評
當中？
9. 台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
https://media.vanityfair.com/photos/5ada6111de74d449f8c771b6/master/pass/
09-1998-Shattered-Glass.png
The New Republic 雜誌封⾯面 (November&December 2014)
標題： Hello, My name is Stephen Glass and I’m a plagiarist.
副標題：WHAT HAPPENED TO THE TROUBLED YOUNG REPORTER WHO ALMOST
BROUGHT THIS MAGAZINE DOWN?
10. 1972 出⽣生
1993 在 The Daily Pennsylvanian 擔任 Executive Editor
共執筆超過 150 篇⽂文章
1994 畢業⾃自 University of Penn. (University Scholar)
1995 加入 The New Republic (TNR) 雜誌
25y Y1 1998.5 被 Forbes 記者 Adam L. Penenberg 揭發造假
被 TNR 開除
Y3 2000 畢業⾃自 Georgetown University Law Center
Juris Doctor (magna cum laude)
通過紐約州律律師執照考試
考試委員會拒發證書
30y Y6 2003 出版⾃自傳⼩小說 The Fabulist
2003.10.31 電影 Shattered Glass 在美國院線⾸首映
2003.11.7 出席新聞倫倫理理座談會 (George Washington University)
前 TNR 編輯 A. Sullivan
Y7 2004 加入 Carpenter, Zuckerman& Rowley 事務所
36y Y10 2009 申請加入加州律律師公會
考試委員會拒發證書
41y Y17 2014.1.27 加州最⾼高法院駁回上訴
Y18 2015.10.11 致函 Harper’s 雜誌繳回稿費
台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
The New Republic 雜誌封⾯面 (November&December 2014)，同前⾴頁。
12. References
參參考⽂文獻
Page 1 of 2
台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
Bissinger, B. (1998). Shattered Glass. Vanity Fair, 176&180. Retrieved from https://www.vanityfair.com/magazine/1998/09/
bissinger199809
Ebert, R. (2003). Shattered Glass Movie Review & Film Summary (2003) | Roger Ebert. Retrieved from https://
www.rogerebert.com/reviews/shattered-glass-2003
Ehrlich, M. (2005). Hollywood and Journalistic Truthtelling. Notre Dame J.L. Ethics & Pub. Pol'y, 19(2), 519-539. Retrieved from
https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/ndjlepp/vol19/iss2/9
Ehrlich, M. (2006). Facts, truth and bad journalists in the movies. Journalism: Theory, Practice & Criticism, 7(4), 501-519. doi:
10.1177/1464884906068364
Glass, S. (2015). Stephen Glass Letter to Harper’s Magazine. Retrieved from https://nyti.ms/2K5b6Qt
Kasinitz, A., Popper, D., Miller, D., Oates, S., Welcome, R., Eichensehr, M., & Popper, D. (2014). Glass Still 'Shattered,' 16 Years Later -
American Journalism Review. Retrieved from http://ajr.org/2014/11/12/stephen-glass-new-republic-anniversary/
Lane, A. (2003). Deceived. The New Yorker, (November 3, 2003). Retrieved from https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/
2003/11/03/deceived
13. References
參參考⽂文獻
Page 2 of 2
台灣新聞記者協會 | 電影《欲蓋彌彰》放映暨映後座談會 | 國家⼈人權博物館⾔言論⾃自由⽇日特展 | 01-09-2018
Lizza, R. (2014). Inside the Collapse of The New Republic. The New Yorker. Retrieved from https://www.newyorker.com/news/
news-desk/inside-collapse-new-republic
Mackie, R. (2004). Shattered Glass. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/film/2004/oct/01/dvdreviews1
Plotz, D. (2003). Steve and Me. Retrieved from http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/life_and_art/2003/09/
steve_and_me.html
Postscript. (2007). Vanity Fair. Retrieved from https://www.vanityfair.com/magazine/2007/10/postscript200710
Ray, B. (2003). 'SHATTERED GLASS'; Defending an Editor. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2003/11/16/arts/l-
shattered-glass-defending-an-editor-119563.html
Rosin, H. (2014). Hello, My Name is Stephen Glass and I'm Sorry. The New Republic. Retrieved from https://newrepublic.com/
article/120145/stephen-glass-new-republic-scandal-still-haunts-his-law-career
Schonfeld, Z. (2014). Let Stephen Glass back into journalism. Retrieved from https://archives.cjr.org/the_kicker/
let_stephen_glass_back_into_jo.php
Shafer, J. (1998). Glass Houses. Retrieved from http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/flame_posies/1998/05/
glass_houses.html
Stephen Glass. (2018). Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Glass
