Young Scholars
Finding and Nurturing Gifted Potential
Dr. Carol V. Horn
Horn.carol71@gmail.com
K-12 Coordinator
Advanced Academic
Programs
Fairfax County Public
Schools, Virginia
FCPS serves 186,785 students
10th
largest school district in the
nation
139 elementary schools
26 middle schools
26 high schools
African American 11%
Asian 19%
Hispanic 24%
Multiracial 6%
White 40%
28% FRM
17% receive ESOL services
13% Special Education services
What educators and psychologists recognize as giftedness
in children is really potential giftedness, which denotes
promise rather than fulfillment and probabilities rather
than certainties about future accomplishments. How high
these probabilities are in any given case depends much
upon the match between a child’s budding talents and the
kinds of nurturance provided. ~Dr. Harry Passow
What educators and psychologists recognize as giftedness
in children is really potential giftedness, which denotes
promise rather than fulfillment and probabilities rather
than certainties about future accomplishments. How high
these probabilities are in any given case depends much
upon the match between a child’s budding talents and the
kinds of nurturance provided. ~Dr. Harry Passow
What we teach our kids about responding to
adversity says a lot about our vision of
America. If we believe our nation and our kids
are, like Hamilton’s self-assessment,
“a diamond in the rough, a shiny piece of coal,
trying to reach my goal,” we should proudly
instill a sense of endless striving.
John Laurens on Alexander Hamilton, Hamilton
Underrepresented Populations in
Gifted Education
Outstanding talents are present in children and
youth from all cultural groups, across all
economic strata, and in all areas of human
endeavor.
National excellence: A case for
developing America’s talent
U.S. Department of Education
1993
Issues Recommendations
Underrepresentation of Economically
Disadvantaged and Culturally Diverse Students
Young Scholars is a School Wide Commitment
11
Four Principles of Systemic Change
Richard Allington
Who are the Young Scholars?
Students with gifted potential who may lack
Short Term Goal
To identify students who may not be considered for
advanced academic programs using traditional methods
of identification, and who, without that opportunity, are
less likely to pursue advanced levels of learning on their
own.
Long Term Goal
To nurture high academic
potential at an early age so
that students who have
historically been underserved
in advanced academic
programs will be prepared
to engage in challenging
subject matter and rigorous
courses in upper elementary
school, middle school, and
high school.
4 Key Components of the Model
School Leadership
Committed Professionals
The Leadership Steps to Success…
Vision without action is merely a dream. Action without vision just
passes the time. Vision with action can change the world. Joel Barker
What kind of MINDSET do
your students have?
What kind of MINDSET
do YOU have?
What kind of MINDSET
leads to more learning?
Discuss with a partner:
What are the learning implications for each pairing?
For example, what might be the outcome if a student with a growth
mindset attends a school or has a teacher with a fixed mindset culture?
Find/Identify
What would you say?
23
This student does not
belong in this class.
Intelligence is emergent
What will it take to draw this student out?
This is not a gifted student.
Intelligence is Fluid
What is this student’s strength?
This student does not have
the background knowledge
to be an advanced
academic student.
Cultural influences
How does this student think?
Advanced students should read
and write faster, better, and more
independently than their peers do.
Intelligence is
complex
In what ways does this
student’s ideas show
originality or novelty?
Intelligence is not how much you know or how
fast you learn but
how you behave when you don’t know the
answer.
It is not something more to do; just a different way to engage in the
curriculum you already teach!
Dr. Edward de Bono Dr. Richard Paul
Level I
Nine Strategies for Teaching Critical
and Creative Thinking
adapted from the work of . . .
35
Level I Nine Thinking Strategies
Point of View
Analyzing how different people might look at the same idea, issue,
and/or situation
Fluency, Flexibility, Originality & Elaboration
Production for many ideas, expression of new ideas, and the
recombination of existing ideas
Visualization
Consciously forming mental images of something that is not actually
present in the senses
Kindergarten
Critical and Creative Thinking Lesson
Circles in Your Imagination
• State Standard:
• The student will identify
representations of plane geometric
figures regardless of their position and
orientation in space.
• The student will compare the size and
shape of plane geometric figures.
• Materials: circular objects, circles,
paper, crayons
LINK
• What shapes can you find in our classroom?
• Use your hands to make a circle.
• Look through your circle lens.
• What round things do you see?
• What is the biggest circle you can find?
Smallest?
• Can you name circles that people use? (wheel,
sun, pizza, globe, etc.)
37
Accommodations for ESOL students: Visual aids provided for the LINK portion of the lesson.
38
39
40
41
QuestioningQuestioning
• Students who ask questions are more productive and
engaged.
• Questioning helps us solve problems by developing,
implementing, and evaluating plans of action.
43
Analogies: Gives students a structure for generating creative
ideas, seeing complex relationships, and making unusual
comparisons. Analogies may be used to deepen understanding of
topics or concepts.
Young Scholars are like __________ because _______________.
Thinking Strategies (continued)
Encapsulation: Stating ideas in precise and concise form
In ten or fewer words write a sentence to encapsulate your
understanding of the term “gifted”.
Decisions and Outcomes: Understanding that choosing from
alternatives affects events which follow
By a show of hands, how many of you have made a decision that
you wish you could change? Did you make your decision before
you gathered all the facts or was your decision based on impulse/
reaction to the situation?
What Works
44
Screening for Young Scholars and
Advanced Academic Services
How are Young Scholars (YS) Identified?
Assessment of Observable
Behaviors
Gifted Behaviors
Rating Scale (GBRS)
Ratings
Each category is
assigned a rating based
on how often behaviors
are observed
Highest score = 16
Lowest score = 4
• Math &/or reading accommodations are noted
• Comments in bulleted form provide specific examples of student
behaviors
• Completed by teachers who work with the student
Gifted Behaviors Rating Scale:
4 Categories
52
Screening Committees
53
Nurture, Guide and Support
Pedagogy of Poverty vs. Plenty
Educating Everybody’s Children: We Know What We Need to Do by Robert W. Cole
Interventions for Young Scholars in
Elementary School
57
Essential Elements
59
Professional Development for K- 12 Teachers
60
“The fact is we all have biases against what’s
different, what’s different to our social norms. The
thing is if we want to live in a world where the
circumstances of your birth do not dictate your
future and where equal opportunity is ubiquitous,
then each and every one of us has a role to play in
making sure unconscious bias does not determine
our lives.”
Yassmin Abdel-Magied TED talk
What does my headscarf mean to you?
https://www.ted.com/talks/yassmin_abdel_magied_what_does_my_headscarf_mean_to_yo
Cultural proficient educators must always
navigate between two frames:
Treat all
people as
human
beings rather
than
members of
various
cultural
groups.
Recognize people’s
real experiences as
members of various
cultural groups in
order to better
understand them,
assist them, and/or to
treat them equitably.
Family Resources
64
Summer School
Primary Grade Choices
Upper Elementary Choices
67
Summer school provides
powerful learning experiences
Summer school provides
powerful learning experiences
https://w
ww.youtu
be.com/
watch?
v=SbjnW
D-hk50
High School Volunteers
After School Partnership with
Thomas Jefferson High School
for Science and Technology
(TJHSST)
The Model in Schools
71
SY 2016-17
6,581 Young Scholars in Grades K -8
Level IV Services 30%
Level III Services 24%
Level II Services 46%
56% on free and reduced price lunch
5% special education
13% LEP
What the Students Say
Summer school provided the Young Scholars
the opportunity to shine in a smaller
group setting. They additionally
participated in self-reflection which
boosted their confidence in their
abilities.
Students are immersed in learning
sessions that go deep rather
than surface and they can
develop inquiries that truly
interest and engage
them.
What do elementary
teachers say about
the impact of Young
Scholars?
Since I’ve worked with Young
Scholars, my expectations have been
broader; I have higher
expectations for children who
are able to perform better. Everyone
has an idea of what giftedness is, but
Young Scholars has broadened
my perspective about who is
brought into that category.
Unlocking Emergent Talent: Supporting High Achievement of Low-
Income, High-Ability Students
Paula Olszewski-Kubilius and Jane Clarenbach
https://www.fcps.edu/academics/academic-overview/advanced-academic-programs
Pathways
in Advanced Academic Programs
Pathways
in Advanced Academic Programs
Pathways
in Advanced Academic Programs
Pathways
in Advanced Academic Programs
White Black Hispanic Asian Other Total
2001 3,288 240 189 651 185 4,553
change Up
56.1%
Up
185.4%
Up
571.9%
Up
205.6%
Up
235.1%
Up
113.0%
2016 5,134 685 1,270 1,990 620 9,699
Change in part-time school-based Level III
services Grades K-8
White Black Hispanic Asian Other Total
2001 2,566 76 66 584 106 3,429
change Up
176.2%
Up
800%
Up
1630.3%
Up
744.7%
Up
903.7%
Up
334.9%
2015 7,089 684 1,142 4,933 1,064 14,912
Change in full-time Level IV services
Grades 3-8
Who is Responsible for Young
Scholars?
83
Counselors can help build growth mindsets and nurture
academic potential so students will choose and succeed
in advanced courses.
The Young Scholars Model is a “pipeline” to
advanced courses in middle and high school.
YS in Level IV and Honors Classes SY16
In High School…
76% in high school AP/IB courses
98% reported planning to attend college in Student
Learning Plan
7th
Grade 8th
Grade 9th
Grade
Proven Strategies for Success
86
Being [a] Young Scholar [gave] me a
boost of confidence. I feel
that I have been given
opportunities to improve my
knowledge and skills. From the
group projects, to the individual
activities, being a Young Scholar
has shaped me for the better.
Young Scholars has helped boost
my confidence, which has
encouraged me to try harder over the
years. I feel more resilient and
more likely to take on
challenges, such as AP classes,
thanks to Young Scholars.
What do Young Scholars who are now in
high school say about how it impacted
them?
Yosaph Boku
“Seeing brilliant students that
were like myself made me
realize I had the same potential
for success.”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=Bw4TFJKNZH8&feature=youtu.be
89
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IosvUh7g17o
90
What questions have I created?

Young Scholars Model: Finding & Nurturing Advanced Academic Potential from Historically Underserved Populations

  • 1.
    Young Scholars Finding andNurturing Gifted Potential Dr. Carol V. Horn Horn.carol71@gmail.com K-12 Coordinator Advanced Academic Programs Fairfax County Public Schools, Virginia
  • 2.
    FCPS serves 186,785students 10th largest school district in the nation 139 elementary schools 26 middle schools 26 high schools African American 11% Asian 19% Hispanic 24% Multiracial 6% White 40% 28% FRM 17% receive ESOL services 13% Special Education services
  • 3.
    What educators andpsychologists recognize as giftedness in children is really potential giftedness, which denotes promise rather than fulfillment and probabilities rather than certainties about future accomplishments. How high these probabilities are in any given case depends much upon the match between a child’s budding talents and the kinds of nurturance provided. ~Dr. Harry Passow
  • 4.
    What educators andpsychologists recognize as giftedness in children is really potential giftedness, which denotes promise rather than fulfillment and probabilities rather than certainties about future accomplishments. How high these probabilities are in any given case depends much upon the match between a child’s budding talents and the kinds of nurturance provided. ~Dr. Harry Passow
  • 6.
    What we teachour kids about responding to adversity says a lot about our vision of America. If we believe our nation and our kids are, like Hamilton’s self-assessment, “a diamond in the rough, a shiny piece of coal, trying to reach my goal,” we should proudly instill a sense of endless striving. John Laurens on Alexander Hamilton, Hamilton
  • 7.
    Underrepresented Populations in GiftedEducation Outstanding talents are present in children and youth from all cultural groups, across all economic strata, and in all areas of human endeavor. National excellence: A case for developing America’s talent U.S. Department of Education 1993
  • 9.
    Issues Recommendations Underrepresentation ofEconomically Disadvantaged and Culturally Diverse Students
  • 10.
    Young Scholars isa School Wide Commitment
  • 11.
    11 Four Principles ofSystemic Change Richard Allington
  • 12.
    Who are theYoung Scholars? Students with gifted potential who may lack
  • 13.
    Short Term Goal Toidentify students who may not be considered for advanced academic programs using traditional methods of identification, and who, without that opportunity, are less likely to pursue advanced levels of learning on their own.
  • 14.
    Long Term Goal Tonurture high academic potential at an early age so that students who have historically been underserved in advanced academic programs will be prepared to engage in challenging subject matter and rigorous courses in upper elementary school, middle school, and high school.
  • 15.
    4 Key Componentsof the Model
  • 16.
  • 17.
    The Leadership Stepsto Success… Vision without action is merely a dream. Action without vision just passes the time. Vision with action can change the world. Joel Barker
  • 19.
    What kind ofMINDSET do your students have? What kind of MINDSET do YOU have? What kind of MINDSET leads to more learning?
  • 20.
    Discuss with apartner: What are the learning implications for each pairing? For example, what might be the outcome if a student with a growth mindset attends a school or has a teacher with a fixed mindset culture?
  • 21.
  • 23.
  • 24.
    This student doesnot belong in this class.
  • 25.
    Intelligence is emergent Whatwill it take to draw this student out?
  • 26.
    This is nota gifted student.
  • 27.
    Intelligence is Fluid Whatis this student’s strength?
  • 28.
    This student doesnot have the background knowledge to be an advanced academic student.
  • 29.
    Cultural influences How doesthis student think?
  • 30.
    Advanced students shouldread and write faster, better, and more independently than their peers do.
  • 31.
    Intelligence is complex In whatways does this student’s ideas show originality or novelty?
  • 33.
    Intelligence is nothow much you know or how fast you learn but how you behave when you don’t know the answer.
  • 34.
    It is notsomething more to do; just a different way to engage in the curriculum you already teach! Dr. Edward de Bono Dr. Richard Paul Level I Nine Strategies for Teaching Critical and Creative Thinking adapted from the work of . . .
  • 35.
    35 Level I NineThinking Strategies Point of View Analyzing how different people might look at the same idea, issue, and/or situation Fluency, Flexibility, Originality & Elaboration Production for many ideas, expression of new ideas, and the recombination of existing ideas Visualization Consciously forming mental images of something that is not actually present in the senses
  • 36.
    Kindergarten Critical and CreativeThinking Lesson Circles in Your Imagination • State Standard: • The student will identify representations of plane geometric figures regardless of their position and orientation in space. • The student will compare the size and shape of plane geometric figures. • Materials: circular objects, circles, paper, crayons
  • 37.
    LINK • What shapescan you find in our classroom? • Use your hands to make a circle. • Look through your circle lens. • What round things do you see? • What is the biggest circle you can find? Smallest? • Can you name circles that people use? (wheel, sun, pizza, globe, etc.) 37 Accommodations for ESOL students: Visual aids provided for the LINK portion of the lesson.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
    QuestioningQuestioning • Students whoask questions are more productive and engaged. • Questioning helps us solve problems by developing, implementing, and evaluating plans of action.
  • 43.
    43 Analogies: Gives studentsa structure for generating creative ideas, seeing complex relationships, and making unusual comparisons. Analogies may be used to deepen understanding of topics or concepts. Young Scholars are like __________ because _______________. Thinking Strategies (continued) Encapsulation: Stating ideas in precise and concise form In ten or fewer words write a sentence to encapsulate your understanding of the term “gifted”. Decisions and Outcomes: Understanding that choosing from alternatives affects events which follow By a show of hands, how many of you have made a decision that you wish you could change? Did you make your decision before you gathered all the facts or was your decision based on impulse/ reaction to the situation?
  • 44.
  • 45.
    Screening for YoungScholars and Advanced Academic Services
  • 47.
    How are YoungScholars (YS) Identified?
  • 49.
  • 50.
  • 51.
    Ratings Each category is assigneda rating based on how often behaviors are observed Highest score = 16 Lowest score = 4 • Math &/or reading accommodations are noted • Comments in bulleted form provide specific examples of student behaviors • Completed by teachers who work with the student
  • 52.
    Gifted Behaviors RatingScale: 4 Categories 52
  • 53.
  • 55.
  • 56.
    Pedagogy of Povertyvs. Plenty Educating Everybody’s Children: We Know What We Need to Do by Robert W. Cole
  • 57.
    Interventions for YoungScholars in Elementary School 57
  • 58.
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 61.
    “The fact iswe all have biases against what’s different, what’s different to our social norms. The thing is if we want to live in a world where the circumstances of your birth do not dictate your future and where equal opportunity is ubiquitous, then each and every one of us has a role to play in making sure unconscious bias does not determine our lives.” Yassmin Abdel-Magied TED talk What does my headscarf mean to you? https://www.ted.com/talks/yassmin_abdel_magied_what_does_my_headscarf_mean_to_yo
  • 62.
    Cultural proficient educatorsmust always navigate between two frames: Treat all people as human beings rather than members of various cultural groups. Recognize people’s real experiences as members of various cultural groups in order to better understand them, assist them, and/or to treat them equitably.
  • 63.
  • 64.
  • 65.
  • 66.
  • 67.
    67 Summer school provides powerfullearning experiences Summer school provides powerful learning experiences
  • 68.
  • 69.
  • 70.
    After School Partnershipwith Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology (TJHSST)
  • 71.
    The Model inSchools 71
  • 72.
    SY 2016-17 6,581 YoungScholars in Grades K -8 Level IV Services 30% Level III Services 24% Level II Services 46% 56% on free and reduced price lunch 5% special education 13% LEP
  • 73.
  • 74.
    Summer school providedthe Young Scholars the opportunity to shine in a smaller group setting. They additionally participated in self-reflection which boosted their confidence in their abilities. Students are immersed in learning sessions that go deep rather than surface and they can develop inquiries that truly interest and engage them. What do elementary teachers say about the impact of Young Scholars? Since I’ve worked with Young Scholars, my expectations have been broader; I have higher expectations for children who are able to perform better. Everyone has an idea of what giftedness is, but Young Scholars has broadened my perspective about who is brought into that category.
  • 75.
    Unlocking Emergent Talent:Supporting High Achievement of Low- Income, High-Ability Students Paula Olszewski-Kubilius and Jane Clarenbach
  • 76.
  • 77.
  • 78.
  • 79.
  • 80.
  • 81.
    White Black HispanicAsian Other Total 2001 3,288 240 189 651 185 4,553 change Up 56.1% Up 185.4% Up 571.9% Up 205.6% Up 235.1% Up 113.0% 2016 5,134 685 1,270 1,990 620 9,699 Change in part-time school-based Level III services Grades K-8
  • 82.
    White Black HispanicAsian Other Total 2001 2,566 76 66 584 106 3,429 change Up 176.2% Up 800% Up 1630.3% Up 744.7% Up 903.7% Up 334.9% 2015 7,089 684 1,142 4,933 1,064 14,912 Change in full-time Level IV services Grades 3-8
  • 83.
    Who is Responsiblefor Young Scholars? 83
  • 84.
    Counselors can helpbuild growth mindsets and nurture academic potential so students will choose and succeed in advanced courses. The Young Scholars Model is a “pipeline” to advanced courses in middle and high school.
  • 85.
    YS in LevelIV and Honors Classes SY16 In High School… 76% in high school AP/IB courses 98% reported planning to attend college in Student Learning Plan 7th Grade 8th Grade 9th Grade
  • 86.
  • 87.
    Being [a] YoungScholar [gave] me a boost of confidence. I feel that I have been given opportunities to improve my knowledge and skills. From the group projects, to the individual activities, being a Young Scholar has shaped me for the better. Young Scholars has helped boost my confidence, which has encouraged me to try harder over the years. I feel more resilient and more likely to take on challenges, such as AP classes, thanks to Young Scholars. What do Young Scholars who are now in high school say about how it impacted them?
  • 88.
    Yosaph Boku “Seeing brilliantstudents that were like myself made me realize I had the same potential for success.” https://www.youtube.com/watch? v=Bw4TFJKNZH8&feature=youtu.be
  • 89.
  • 90.
  • 91.

Editor's Notes

  • #4 This quote embodies the philosophy of advanced academic services in FCPS
  • #9 James Borland, In this paper, we report the results of an inquiry into the effects of the placement of five economical disadvantaged minority students from central Harlem, who were identified in kindergarten as potentially academically gifted through nontraditional means, in a school for gifted students. Achievement and aptitude test data and qualitative data collected during the students' first year at the school support the conclusion that the students were appropriately placed and adjusted well academically socially and emotionally. Follow-up data suggest that the students' academic careers have, in the six years since the original data were collected, for the most part progressed well. We present assertions that begin to explain why these students have succeeded academically despite being at-risk for educational disadvantage. These assertions concern the students themselves, their families, their school, and Project Synergy, through whose activities the students were identified as potentially gifted. Joyce Van Tassel-Baska: The study findings suggested that the performance-based protocols were consistent across time in locating a higher percentage of low-income and minority students, as well as female students for gifted programs; a higher percentage of students with uneven verbal-nonverbal strengths were performance task-identified students also. Performance task-identified students scored significantly lower than traditionally identified students on both the English and math portions of the state assessment test for multiple years; however, the performance differences on state assessments were small, rendering small effect sizes. Donna Ford: Gifted with emphasis on minority children and youth; recruitment and retention of diverse students in gifted education; underachievement among diverse students; equity issues in testing and assessment; multicultural education; issues in urban education. Dr. Paula Olszewski-Kubilius: is currently the director of the Center for Talent Development at Northwestern University and a professor in the School of Education and Social Policy. Over the past 30 years, she has created programs for all kinds of gifted learners and written extensively on issues of talent development, particularly on programming for under-represented gifted students. 
  • #10 Students from traditionally underserved backgrounds are not consistently identified using traditional methods- issues and recommendations from research and literature
  • #18 Vision without action is merely a dream. Action without vision just passes the time. Vision with action can change the world. Joel A. Barker
  • #20 When teaching it is important to think about your own mindset. What kind of mindset do YOU have? Ask yourself what is my mindset? How do my students see me learning new things? Most importantly, as an educator we must explore what kind of mindset ;leads to more learning. Based on the traits here which one promotes student learning?
  • #23 We also now have sound scientific evidence through neuroimaging of the brain that shows us that intelligence – develops over time can be nurtured, it is not innate. manifests itself in different ways in different cultures is complex -- not only do genes and environment cooperate as we develop, but genes require input from the environment to work properly.
  • #55 Committee reads all information in the file. Uses a holistic case study approach that includes all data focusing on student strengths. Considers each file on its own merit and does not compare files.
  • #62 Participants talk at their tables about how this is relevant to us as educators. Share out a few.
  • #77 Critical and Creative Thinking Strategies (Level I) are used with all students in grades K – 12. Young Scholars is designed to increase the proportion of historically underrepresented students in AAP School administrators, teachers, AART work together to find and nurture academic potential beginning in kindergarten. Differentiated Lessons in Areas of Academic Strength (Level II, coded DE) Beginning in Kindergarten, students who exhibit characteristics of advanced academic potential or who have specific academic strengths are provided more challenging content, assignments, resources and/or instructional groupings within the classroom.   Part-Time Advanced Academic Program (Level III, coded SE)- consists of direct services in grades 3-6 to students who have been identified by a local school screening committee.  Level III services are provided by the AART and include lessons that enrich and extend the program of studies in specific content areas. At the middle school level school-based services are offered through Honors classes in the four core subject areas.   AAP (Level IV) Curriculum is designed to extend and enrich the Program of Studies in all subject areas - differentiated in depth, breadth, and pace of instruction - Emphasis on higher level thinking - Opportunities to develop independent research skills - Accelerate math by compacting - Advanced reading materials
  • #78 1st grade started receiving YS and Level II services- strength in science and math. In fourth grade, he started receiving AM. In 5th grade, the child was found eligible for III. In middle school, started taking all honors classes including Algebra 1. Grades 9 & 10, he was in all honors classes, then joined the IB program in 11th grade.
  • #79 In 2nd grade, started receiving advanced math and level II services; By 3rd grade, qualified for Level IV services and attended the center school until 8th grade. High school she went to TJ
  • #80 In K-4, child received Level I services. In 5th grade, the child started Level III service. In middle school, he took honors English and social studies, which carried into HS. He took AP World History and AP English in high school.
  • #81 Child moved into FCPS in 3rd grade, and was a YS and receiving advanced math. She was found eligible for Level III services, then placed in the LLIV classroom at her school. In MS, she took four honors classes, all honors in HS, and AP Spanish, English, and History.
  • #88 Quotes from YS at West Potomac