Post offices have the potential to significantly increase financial inclusion given their widespread networks, especially in rural areas. However, little was known about the types of clients that post offices reach compared to traditional financial institutions like banks. This study uses new individual-level account ownership data from 60 countries to analyze patterns. The results suggest that post offices are relatively more likely than traditional financial institutions to provide accounts to financially vulnerable groups like the poor, less educated, and unemployed. The study also finds that larger postal networks and partnerships between post offices and other financial institutions are associated with higher overall financial inclusion rates.
NORMAT E INTERESIT / INTEREST RATES IMPACT AND LOAN SYSTEM IN THE ECONOMIC DE...Shkumbin Gërguri
Commercial banks are intermediators of the interaction between business entities and other economic, legal and social agents. Today, banks do not have the approach towards the classic model, whose function was only to offer classic services of deposits and loans,; with evolution of global trends and technology banks have created nowadays a modern system of operating that applies techniques and methods that are the trend of globalization.
The document discusses several key topics regarding the European banking sector over the last decade. It outlines how the sector has consolidated significantly through mergers and acquisitions, leading to fewer but larger banks and increased concentration. It also examines developments in areas like retail banking, private banking, investment banking, and the effects of technological advances. Regulatory changes in Europe, like deregulation and the single market for financial services, contributed to the restructuring and changes within the European banking industry.
Three main problems need to be solved for developing an international financial center in Moscow: upgrading infrastructure, working with citizens, and attracting investors. Moscow has the potential to become a strong regional financial center for CIS countries due to its size, location near other countries, and similar system of values to Eastern Europe. A proposed strategy allows Moscow to become a competitive financial center by focusing on initiatives like a uniform payment card, online banking, a uniform borrower registry, debt auctions, educational seminars, and low interest rates for social loans over the next 5 years.
Myanmar Migrant Workers Remittance Data AnalysisMYO AUNG Myanmar
This document summarizes a study on migrant worker remittances from Burmese workers in Thailand to Burma. The study conducted surveys of Burmese migrant workers in Thailand to understand the amounts, costs, uses, and methods of remitting funds. Key findings included that remittances to Burma were large, disproportionately used for basic survival needs, and overwhelmingly sent via informal mechanisms due to Burma's dysfunctional economy and lack of trust in institutions. The use of informal channels limits the potential development benefits that remittances could provide.
The document summarizes recent economic developments and changes in legislation in Ukraine:
1) The head of the IMF mission in Ukraine said that the Ukrainian economy is recovering after the crisis and showed signs of economic growth. However, challenges remain due to uncertainty in global markets.
2) The quantity of active payment cards in Ukraine grew 1% in 2010, while the number of ATMs increased by 4.2%.
3) Ukraine's new law on personal data protection came into effect on January 1st, 2011, creating a new regulatory authority but also raising questions from businesses due to ambiguous provisions that are difficult to implement and enforce.
1) Currently, there are 15,000 immigrants on waitlists for ESOL classes in Massachusetts, waiting anywhere from 6 months to 3 years.
2) In 2006, nearly 88,000 workers in Metro Boston had limited English skills, a 37% increase over 2000.
3) If these 88,000 workers improved their English by one level, it could increase income by $732 million and create over 1,000 new jobs.
Mapping rapidly changing minority ethnic populations: a case study of YorkThink Ethnic
This study aimed to better estimate the size and diversity of York's minority ethnic population using both official data and less formal sources, as official statistics provide a limited picture. The study found York's population to be much more ethnically diverse than recognized, with 78 first languages identified. It estimated the minority ethnic population to be around 21,800 people or 11% of the total population, significantly higher than 2001 Census data. The study recommends strengthening commitments to racial equality, consistency in ethnic monitoring, and increased support for minority communities and vulnerable groups to better meet their needs.
This document discusses several topics related to banking and finance in Jordan and the Middle East region:
1) Majdi Abu Arja suggests that the Central Bank of Jordan revisit the country's banking laws to determine the optimal number of banks needed in each governorate to improve customer service and satisfaction.
2) Mark Galasiewski analyzes how social mood drives events in the Middle East, rather than the other way around.
3) Douglas Clark Johnson discusses investment opportunities in Pakistan's private sector, which is often most active in countries where the public sector faces challenges.
NORMAT E INTERESIT / INTEREST RATES IMPACT AND LOAN SYSTEM IN THE ECONOMIC DE...Shkumbin Gërguri
Commercial banks are intermediators of the interaction between business entities and other economic, legal and social agents. Today, banks do not have the approach towards the classic model, whose function was only to offer classic services of deposits and loans,; with evolution of global trends and technology banks have created nowadays a modern system of operating that applies techniques and methods that are the trend of globalization.
The document discusses several key topics regarding the European banking sector over the last decade. It outlines how the sector has consolidated significantly through mergers and acquisitions, leading to fewer but larger banks and increased concentration. It also examines developments in areas like retail banking, private banking, investment banking, and the effects of technological advances. Regulatory changes in Europe, like deregulation and the single market for financial services, contributed to the restructuring and changes within the European banking industry.
Three main problems need to be solved for developing an international financial center in Moscow: upgrading infrastructure, working with citizens, and attracting investors. Moscow has the potential to become a strong regional financial center for CIS countries due to its size, location near other countries, and similar system of values to Eastern Europe. A proposed strategy allows Moscow to become a competitive financial center by focusing on initiatives like a uniform payment card, online banking, a uniform borrower registry, debt auctions, educational seminars, and low interest rates for social loans over the next 5 years.
Myanmar Migrant Workers Remittance Data AnalysisMYO AUNG Myanmar
This document summarizes a study on migrant worker remittances from Burmese workers in Thailand to Burma. The study conducted surveys of Burmese migrant workers in Thailand to understand the amounts, costs, uses, and methods of remitting funds. Key findings included that remittances to Burma were large, disproportionately used for basic survival needs, and overwhelmingly sent via informal mechanisms due to Burma's dysfunctional economy and lack of trust in institutions. The use of informal channels limits the potential development benefits that remittances could provide.
The document summarizes recent economic developments and changes in legislation in Ukraine:
1) The head of the IMF mission in Ukraine said that the Ukrainian economy is recovering after the crisis and showed signs of economic growth. However, challenges remain due to uncertainty in global markets.
2) The quantity of active payment cards in Ukraine grew 1% in 2010, while the number of ATMs increased by 4.2%.
3) Ukraine's new law on personal data protection came into effect on January 1st, 2011, creating a new regulatory authority but also raising questions from businesses due to ambiguous provisions that are difficult to implement and enforce.
1) Currently, there are 15,000 immigrants on waitlists for ESOL classes in Massachusetts, waiting anywhere from 6 months to 3 years.
2) In 2006, nearly 88,000 workers in Metro Boston had limited English skills, a 37% increase over 2000.
3) If these 88,000 workers improved their English by one level, it could increase income by $732 million and create over 1,000 new jobs.
Mapping rapidly changing minority ethnic populations: a case study of YorkThink Ethnic
This study aimed to better estimate the size and diversity of York's minority ethnic population using both official data and less formal sources, as official statistics provide a limited picture. The study found York's population to be much more ethnically diverse than recognized, with 78 first languages identified. It estimated the minority ethnic population to be around 21,800 people or 11% of the total population, significantly higher than 2001 Census data. The study recommends strengthening commitments to racial equality, consistency in ethnic monitoring, and increased support for minority communities and vulnerable groups to better meet their needs.
This document discusses several topics related to banking and finance in Jordan and the Middle East region:
1) Majdi Abu Arja suggests that the Central Bank of Jordan revisit the country's banking laws to determine the optimal number of banks needed in each governorate to improve customer service and satisfaction.
2) Mark Galasiewski analyzes how social mood drives events in the Middle East, rather than the other way around.
3) Douglas Clark Johnson discusses investment opportunities in Pakistan's private sector, which is often most active in countries where the public sector faces challenges.
The document discusses a survey of 800 slum households in Delhi, India. It finds that:
1) Networks, including kinship, caste, and non-profits, play a key role in accessing urban jobs through information and initial housing.
2) The type of network used varies by occupation. Slums also cluster near certain types of economic activities due to networks and proximity to work.
3) As a result, the urban labor market is highly segmented with variations in activities across different city zones. Uniform policies may not address slum dwellers' diverse needs.
RURAL-URBAN MIGRATION AND URBAN INFORMAL SECTOR IN INDIA: AN INTER-STATE ANAL...Dr Lendy Spires
This document summarizes a research article about rural-urban migration and the urban informal sector in India. It finds that rural-urban migration has increased significantly with economic development in India. Migrants from rural areas often end up working in the urban informal sector due to lack of skills and experience for formal jobs. There is thus a close relationship between rural-urban migration and the growth of the urban informal sector, as migration fuels the informal sector while opportunities in the informal sector also attract more migrants. The document examines trends in internal migration and the informal sector across Indian states and identifies factors like rural unemployment, indebtedness, and industrialization that influence migration patterns.
The viability of informal micro enterprise in south africaDr Lendy Spires
This document analyzes the viability of informal micro-enterprises in South Africa's retail sector. It conducted a survey of over 700 owners of informal retail establishments like spaza shops and shebeens across South Africa in 2007. The study aims to determine if these businesses can generate an income at or above South Africa's minimum wage. It hypothesizes that access to capital, business size, gender of the owner, business training, urbanization effects, and proximity to shopping centers influence owner income and sales. Regression analysis is used to test these hypotheses and provide new evidence on the role of informal micro-enterprises in South African economic development.
This document provides background information and objectives of a project measuring the informal sector and informal employment in St. Lucia. It discusses three key points:
1. The project will enhance statistical capacity through collecting informal employment and enterprise survey data, and training staff on international methodologies. This will improve labor and national accounts statistics.
2. Better informal sector data can help monitor progress on MDGs by providing insights into poverty and gender dimensions of employment.
3. The data can support evidence-based policymaking by informing social and economic policies related to issues like SMEs, poverty reduction, and gender equality. The overall goal is to improve availability and use of informal sector statistics.
Recognising and supporting territories and areas conserved by indigenous peop...Dr Lendy Spires
This document provides an overview report on recognizing and supporting territories and areas conserved by indigenous peoples and local communities (ICCAs). It summarizes the key findings from 19 country case studies on ICCAs that were commissioned for this report. The overview report examines the global phenomenon of ICCAs, their international recognition, legal recognition at the national level, and other forms of non-legal recognition and support. It concludes with recommendations for further recognizing and supporting ICCAs.
This document summarizes a paper that examines the informal economy from the perspective of informal businesses. It defines the informal economy as economic activity that occurs outside the legal framework, though the activities may be legal in nature. The paper explores different views on whether the informal economy is problematic or a solution. It also discusses the size and causes of the informal economy, including how high costs of formalization can drive businesses underground. A case study on Haiti finds that most businesses operate informally there due to legislative and institutional barriers that make formalization excessively costly and complex.
This document provides a summary of Latvia's implementation of WSIS outcomes and progress toward an inclusive information society from 2005 to 2013. Key points include:
- Latvia achieved or exceeded most targets for Internet and ICT access set in its 2006-2010 guidelines. Rates of household broadband access, daily computer/Internet use, and e-government transactions surpassed targets.
- Statistical data show growing Internet usage, computer ownership, and integration of ICTs across society and business over this period. Mobile networks expanded and international bandwidth increased.
- National ICT strategies were developed in line with WSIS and EU goals, focusing on e-government, broadband deployment, skills development, and using ICTs to boost
The document discusses the informal sector in Ghana, which employs 80% of the Ghanaian workforce. It is characterized by underemployment, poor working conditions, uncertain employment status, and low wages. Most people living in the informal sector have high income insecurity. Trade unions face major challenges in organizing informal sector workers to ensure they work in safe environments and have their basic needs met. The topic has not been well researched, so more action is needed to prevent most of Ghana's workforce from being deprived.
This document provides case studies on relationships between mining companies and indigenous peoples from five different locations. It is published by the International Council on Metals and the Environment to provide information on environmental, health, social and regulatory issues related to mining and indigenous communities. The case studies describe the partnerships and agreements established between mining companies like Hamersley Iron, Placer Dome, and Falconbridge and indigenous groups in Australia, Canada and Northern Quebec to foster employment, education, business opportunities and cultural preservation for local communities impacted by mining activities.
This document discusses the informal economy in Latin America. It describes two revolutions that have occurred in Peru - a failed communist revolution led by Shining Path, and a successful informal revolution carried out by popular entrepreneurs working outside the law. The Other Path, a seminal book from 1986, analyzed the reality in Latin America from a classical liberal perspective and showed that popular capitalism exists through informal activities of the poor. It challenged the prevailing ideology of socialism and collectivism, showing that capitalism is embedded in the Latin American spirit. This shifted the debate and allowed classical liberal ideas to gain prominence in the world of ideas.
This document outlines Durban's policy for managing its informal economy. It recognizes the important economic role of the informal sector and aims to promote diverse economic opportunities through area-based management, sector support for small businesses, and integrated functions of management, regulation and enterprise support. The policy proposes pilot programs in specific areas to test its approach and transitional arrangements to prioritize implementation. It takes an inclusive approach to institutional structures and monitoring/evaluation.
This document summarizes a case study examining the challenges faced by local governments in South Africa in delivering energy services to residents of informal settlements. Interviews with residents of an informal settlement in Grassy Park revealed that they spend a large portion of their income on expensive and unsafe fuels like paraffin and candles for lighting, cooking and heating. While national policy aims to address energy poverty through initiatives like Free Basic Alternative Energy, local governments have struggled with implementation. Meetings with officials revealed tensions between national and local roles, and that the funding allocation of R55 per household per month was insufficient for meaningful implementation of energy access programs for residents of informal settlements.
This document summarizes research on financial inclusion and poverty. It finds that while access to financial services has increased in Turkey, there are still gaps for women, the less educated, and younger people. Lack of money and trust are common reasons for not having a bank account. Expanding access requires efforts on both the supply and demand sides, including improving financial literacy, reforming regulations, and integrating financial services with social programs. Overall, increasing deposits and savings for the poor through convenient and secure options can help strengthen labor markets and reduce vulnerability.
- Real average wage growth globally has remained far below pre-crisis levels and turned negative in developed economies, although it remained significant in emerging economies.
- There are major geographic differences in wage growth trends, with wages suffering double-dips in developed economies but remaining positive in Latin America and Asia.
- A smaller share of national income is going to workers as falling labour shares have resulted in a gap between increasing productivity and stagnant wages, hurting household consumption and demand.
The document is the April 2014 issue of the World Economic Outlook published by the International Monetary Fund. It finds that the global economic recovery is strengthening but remains uneven. Chapter 1 notes that while growth is picking up in advanced economies, emerging markets are slowing. Downside risks include potential deflation in Europe and slower growth in emerging markets. The report contains country-specific analyses and projections for major advanced and emerging economies. It also examines factors driving global real interest rates and the external influences on emerging market growth.
Informal sector labour markets in developing countries 0Dr Lendy Spires
This document discusses characteristics of informal labor markets in developing countries. It presents two opposing views on the causes of informal markets - either as a residual sector absorbing excess labor or a dynamic sector of entrepreneurship. It then examines examples of involuntary informal employment driven by state intervention and labor market segmentation in China, South Africa, and India. Specifically, it discusses how China's hukou system and South Africa's labor regulations have segmented their labor markets. The document also notes evidence that wage differentials can exist between large and small firms independently due to efficiency wage theories, as seen in Zimbabwe. Overall, the document analyzes factors contributing to both voluntary and involuntary informal employment.
The document summarizes a field survey report on vocational training in Ethiopia's informal sector. It notes that Ethiopia is undertaking an ambitious reform of its education and training system to better respond to economic needs and integrate formal, non-formal and informal training. However, fully including the informal sector is challenging as officials have differing views of its size and role. The reform aims to establish centers that recognize skills from various sources, but must first acknowledge realities of the informal economy and involve existing stakeholders to be effective. While the reform offers opportunities, its success requires focusing on developing what already exists in the informal sector rather than just pursuing its own training agenda.
1) Millions of Americans lack access to basic banking services due to living in remote areas or not being able to afford banks, keeping them on the economic fringes.
2) The US Postal Service could help address this issue by offering basic financial services through its ubiquitous retail network, bringing services like savings accounts, money transfers, and small loans to underserved communities.
3) A report from the USPS Office of Inspector General found that 10% of spending on high-cost payday lenders being redirected to postal-provided services could generate $8.9 billion annually for USPS, helping its financial situation while serving the "unbanked".
Postal operators are the second largest contributor to financial inclusion after banks, providing basic financial services to over 1 billion people worldwide. Posts play a key role in increasing access to services in rural areas through their extensive network of over 600,000 post offices globally. The UPU is working with partners like the Gates Foundation to research, develop, and expand inclusive postal financial services and facilitate bringing unbanked populations into the formal financial system through posts. Mobile technologies are seen as an important catalyst for modernizing and expanding the reach of postal financial inclusion strategies.
This summarizes the first publicly available dataset measuring financial inclusion across 148 countries. It finds that 50% of adults worldwide have a bank account, but account penetration varies significantly between high-income and developing countries. Within countries, wealthier adults make greater use of formal financial services. The most common reasons for being unbanked are lack of money and banks being too expensive or far away. Most saving and borrowing in developing countries is done informally.
This document summarizes a research paper that analyzes factors associated with greater financial inclusion, defined as the use of formal bank accounts, using individual-level data from 123 countries. The study finds that greater account ownership is associated with a better enabling environment like lower account costs and greater access to financial institutions. Policies targeted at promoting inclusion, such as requiring low-cost basic accounts or using accounts for government payments, may be especially effective for the poor and rural residents who are most likely to be excluded. The study also analyzes perceived barriers to account ownership among the financially excluded and finds lower reported barriers in countries with lower account costs and more widespread financial institutions.
This document summarizes a research paper that analyzes factors associated with greater financial inclusion, defined as the use of formal bank accounts, using individual-level data from 123 countries. The study finds that greater account ownership is associated with a better enabling environment like lower account costs and greater access to financial institutions. Policies targeted at promoting inclusion, such as requiring low-cost basic accounts or using accounts for government payments, may be especially effective for the poor and rural residents who are most likely to be excluded. The study also analyzes perceived barriers to account ownership among the financially excluded and finds lower reported barriers in countries with lower account costs and more widespread financial institutions.
The document discusses a survey of 800 slum households in Delhi, India. It finds that:
1) Networks, including kinship, caste, and non-profits, play a key role in accessing urban jobs through information and initial housing.
2) The type of network used varies by occupation. Slums also cluster near certain types of economic activities due to networks and proximity to work.
3) As a result, the urban labor market is highly segmented with variations in activities across different city zones. Uniform policies may not address slum dwellers' diverse needs.
RURAL-URBAN MIGRATION AND URBAN INFORMAL SECTOR IN INDIA: AN INTER-STATE ANAL...Dr Lendy Spires
This document summarizes a research article about rural-urban migration and the urban informal sector in India. It finds that rural-urban migration has increased significantly with economic development in India. Migrants from rural areas often end up working in the urban informal sector due to lack of skills and experience for formal jobs. There is thus a close relationship between rural-urban migration and the growth of the urban informal sector, as migration fuels the informal sector while opportunities in the informal sector also attract more migrants. The document examines trends in internal migration and the informal sector across Indian states and identifies factors like rural unemployment, indebtedness, and industrialization that influence migration patterns.
The viability of informal micro enterprise in south africaDr Lendy Spires
This document analyzes the viability of informal micro-enterprises in South Africa's retail sector. It conducted a survey of over 700 owners of informal retail establishments like spaza shops and shebeens across South Africa in 2007. The study aims to determine if these businesses can generate an income at or above South Africa's minimum wage. It hypothesizes that access to capital, business size, gender of the owner, business training, urbanization effects, and proximity to shopping centers influence owner income and sales. Regression analysis is used to test these hypotheses and provide new evidence on the role of informal micro-enterprises in South African economic development.
This document provides background information and objectives of a project measuring the informal sector and informal employment in St. Lucia. It discusses three key points:
1. The project will enhance statistical capacity through collecting informal employment and enterprise survey data, and training staff on international methodologies. This will improve labor and national accounts statistics.
2. Better informal sector data can help monitor progress on MDGs by providing insights into poverty and gender dimensions of employment.
3. The data can support evidence-based policymaking by informing social and economic policies related to issues like SMEs, poverty reduction, and gender equality. The overall goal is to improve availability and use of informal sector statistics.
Recognising and supporting territories and areas conserved by indigenous peop...Dr Lendy Spires
This document provides an overview report on recognizing and supporting territories and areas conserved by indigenous peoples and local communities (ICCAs). It summarizes the key findings from 19 country case studies on ICCAs that were commissioned for this report. The overview report examines the global phenomenon of ICCAs, their international recognition, legal recognition at the national level, and other forms of non-legal recognition and support. It concludes with recommendations for further recognizing and supporting ICCAs.
This document summarizes a paper that examines the informal economy from the perspective of informal businesses. It defines the informal economy as economic activity that occurs outside the legal framework, though the activities may be legal in nature. The paper explores different views on whether the informal economy is problematic or a solution. It also discusses the size and causes of the informal economy, including how high costs of formalization can drive businesses underground. A case study on Haiti finds that most businesses operate informally there due to legislative and institutional barriers that make formalization excessively costly and complex.
This document provides a summary of Latvia's implementation of WSIS outcomes and progress toward an inclusive information society from 2005 to 2013. Key points include:
- Latvia achieved or exceeded most targets for Internet and ICT access set in its 2006-2010 guidelines. Rates of household broadband access, daily computer/Internet use, and e-government transactions surpassed targets.
- Statistical data show growing Internet usage, computer ownership, and integration of ICTs across society and business over this period. Mobile networks expanded and international bandwidth increased.
- National ICT strategies were developed in line with WSIS and EU goals, focusing on e-government, broadband deployment, skills development, and using ICTs to boost
The document discusses the informal sector in Ghana, which employs 80% of the Ghanaian workforce. It is characterized by underemployment, poor working conditions, uncertain employment status, and low wages. Most people living in the informal sector have high income insecurity. Trade unions face major challenges in organizing informal sector workers to ensure they work in safe environments and have their basic needs met. The topic has not been well researched, so more action is needed to prevent most of Ghana's workforce from being deprived.
This document provides case studies on relationships between mining companies and indigenous peoples from five different locations. It is published by the International Council on Metals and the Environment to provide information on environmental, health, social and regulatory issues related to mining and indigenous communities. The case studies describe the partnerships and agreements established between mining companies like Hamersley Iron, Placer Dome, and Falconbridge and indigenous groups in Australia, Canada and Northern Quebec to foster employment, education, business opportunities and cultural preservation for local communities impacted by mining activities.
This document discusses the informal economy in Latin America. It describes two revolutions that have occurred in Peru - a failed communist revolution led by Shining Path, and a successful informal revolution carried out by popular entrepreneurs working outside the law. The Other Path, a seminal book from 1986, analyzed the reality in Latin America from a classical liberal perspective and showed that popular capitalism exists through informal activities of the poor. It challenged the prevailing ideology of socialism and collectivism, showing that capitalism is embedded in the Latin American spirit. This shifted the debate and allowed classical liberal ideas to gain prominence in the world of ideas.
This document outlines Durban's policy for managing its informal economy. It recognizes the important economic role of the informal sector and aims to promote diverse economic opportunities through area-based management, sector support for small businesses, and integrated functions of management, regulation and enterprise support. The policy proposes pilot programs in specific areas to test its approach and transitional arrangements to prioritize implementation. It takes an inclusive approach to institutional structures and monitoring/evaluation.
This document summarizes a case study examining the challenges faced by local governments in South Africa in delivering energy services to residents of informal settlements. Interviews with residents of an informal settlement in Grassy Park revealed that they spend a large portion of their income on expensive and unsafe fuels like paraffin and candles for lighting, cooking and heating. While national policy aims to address energy poverty through initiatives like Free Basic Alternative Energy, local governments have struggled with implementation. Meetings with officials revealed tensions between national and local roles, and that the funding allocation of R55 per household per month was insufficient for meaningful implementation of energy access programs for residents of informal settlements.
This document summarizes research on financial inclusion and poverty. It finds that while access to financial services has increased in Turkey, there are still gaps for women, the less educated, and younger people. Lack of money and trust are common reasons for not having a bank account. Expanding access requires efforts on both the supply and demand sides, including improving financial literacy, reforming regulations, and integrating financial services with social programs. Overall, increasing deposits and savings for the poor through convenient and secure options can help strengthen labor markets and reduce vulnerability.
- Real average wage growth globally has remained far below pre-crisis levels and turned negative in developed economies, although it remained significant in emerging economies.
- There are major geographic differences in wage growth trends, with wages suffering double-dips in developed economies but remaining positive in Latin America and Asia.
- A smaller share of national income is going to workers as falling labour shares have resulted in a gap between increasing productivity and stagnant wages, hurting household consumption and demand.
The document is the April 2014 issue of the World Economic Outlook published by the International Monetary Fund. It finds that the global economic recovery is strengthening but remains uneven. Chapter 1 notes that while growth is picking up in advanced economies, emerging markets are slowing. Downside risks include potential deflation in Europe and slower growth in emerging markets. The report contains country-specific analyses and projections for major advanced and emerging economies. It also examines factors driving global real interest rates and the external influences on emerging market growth.
Informal sector labour markets in developing countries 0Dr Lendy Spires
This document discusses characteristics of informal labor markets in developing countries. It presents two opposing views on the causes of informal markets - either as a residual sector absorbing excess labor or a dynamic sector of entrepreneurship. It then examines examples of involuntary informal employment driven by state intervention and labor market segmentation in China, South Africa, and India. Specifically, it discusses how China's hukou system and South Africa's labor regulations have segmented their labor markets. The document also notes evidence that wage differentials can exist between large and small firms independently due to efficiency wage theories, as seen in Zimbabwe. Overall, the document analyzes factors contributing to both voluntary and involuntary informal employment.
The document summarizes a field survey report on vocational training in Ethiopia's informal sector. It notes that Ethiopia is undertaking an ambitious reform of its education and training system to better respond to economic needs and integrate formal, non-formal and informal training. However, fully including the informal sector is challenging as officials have differing views of its size and role. The reform aims to establish centers that recognize skills from various sources, but must first acknowledge realities of the informal economy and involve existing stakeholders to be effective. While the reform offers opportunities, its success requires focusing on developing what already exists in the informal sector rather than just pursuing its own training agenda.
1) Millions of Americans lack access to basic banking services due to living in remote areas or not being able to afford banks, keeping them on the economic fringes.
2) The US Postal Service could help address this issue by offering basic financial services through its ubiquitous retail network, bringing services like savings accounts, money transfers, and small loans to underserved communities.
3) A report from the USPS Office of Inspector General found that 10% of spending on high-cost payday lenders being redirected to postal-provided services could generate $8.9 billion annually for USPS, helping its financial situation while serving the "unbanked".
Postal operators are the second largest contributor to financial inclusion after banks, providing basic financial services to over 1 billion people worldwide. Posts play a key role in increasing access to services in rural areas through their extensive network of over 600,000 post offices globally. The UPU is working with partners like the Gates Foundation to research, develop, and expand inclusive postal financial services and facilitate bringing unbanked populations into the formal financial system through posts. Mobile technologies are seen as an important catalyst for modernizing and expanding the reach of postal financial inclusion strategies.
This summarizes the first publicly available dataset measuring financial inclusion across 148 countries. It finds that 50% of adults worldwide have a bank account, but account penetration varies significantly between high-income and developing countries. Within countries, wealthier adults make greater use of formal financial services. The most common reasons for being unbanked are lack of money and banks being too expensive or far away. Most saving and borrowing in developing countries is done informally.
This document summarizes a research paper that analyzes factors associated with greater financial inclusion, defined as the use of formal bank accounts, using individual-level data from 123 countries. The study finds that greater account ownership is associated with a better enabling environment like lower account costs and greater access to financial institutions. Policies targeted at promoting inclusion, such as requiring low-cost basic accounts or using accounts for government payments, may be especially effective for the poor and rural residents who are most likely to be excluded. The study also analyzes perceived barriers to account ownership among the financially excluded and finds lower reported barriers in countries with lower account costs and more widespread financial institutions.
This document summarizes a research paper that analyzes factors associated with greater financial inclusion, defined as the use of formal bank accounts, using individual-level data from 123 countries. The study finds that greater account ownership is associated with a better enabling environment like lower account costs and greater access to financial institutions. Policies targeted at promoting inclusion, such as requiring low-cost basic accounts or using accounts for government payments, may be especially effective for the poor and rural residents who are most likely to be excluded. The study also analyzes perceived barriers to account ownership among the financially excluded and finds lower reported barriers in countries with lower account costs and more widespread financial institutions.
Global panorama on postal finaancial inclusion business models and key issuesDr Lendy Spires
This document provides a summary of a report by the Universal Postal Union (UPU) on postal financial inclusion around the world. The report examines the business models used by postal operators to provide financial services, identifies key issues in postal financial inclusion, and creates an index to rank countries based on their postal operators' ability to foster financial inclusion. It finds that one billion people are currently banked through postal financial services. The report aims to fill knowledge gaps and help postal operators and governments seize opportunities to expand access to financial services.
Global panorama on postal finaancial inclusion business models and key issuesDr Lendy Spires
This document provides an overview of postal financial inclusion around the world. It presents different business models used by postal operators to provide financial services, including as a real estate provider, cash merchant, provider of proprietary financial services, agent for financial institutions, and licensed postal financial services. It also discusses key issues related to postal financial inclusion, such as network capacity, staffing, financial capacity, trust, automation, governance, legal/regulatory frameworks, and flexibility. The document includes regional snapshots of postal financial inclusion and aims to fill knowledge gaps to help postal operators and governments advance financial inclusion through postal networks.
In this file you will have through notes on International Accounting concepts
Subscribe to Vision Academy for Video assistance https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCjzpit_cXjdnzER_165mIiw
The article provides a conceptual analysis of four key issues in the IPSASB's proposed conceptual framework for public sector financial reporting:
1. The meaning of "conceptual framework" which could cause misunderstandings if not clearly defined.
2. The objectives of accountability and decision-usefulness create tension that the framework does not adequately address. Priority should be given to one over the other.
3. The scope of public sector financial reporting is broader than private sector but this is not fully reflected in the framework.
4. The qualitative characteristics proposed need revision to better reflect the priorities and trade-offs in public sector reporting. Specifically, the characteristics of faithful representation and relevance require redefinition for the public
Centre for Social Justice - review of LinkAge ClaireatAnchor
LinkAge Bristol delivers activities and services to reduce social isolation among older people without receiving pilot funding from the UK Department for Work and Pensions. A study visit found that LinkAge Bristol has transferable value as a model that can be duplicated elsewhere. It operates neighborhood hubs managed by community development workers that empower older people to start new social groups and activities. University of the West of England research found LinkAge Bristol improves well-being, social connection, physical activity and provides a social return on investment.
This document summarizes the findings of a CGAP survey of the global outreach of alternative financial institutions (AFIs), which include microfinance institutions (MFIs) as well as other institutions that aim to serve clients below the level served by commercial banks. The survey found over 750 million savings and loan accounts across AFIs globally. However, it cannot be concluded that this represents the number of poor and near-poor clients served, as the data includes clients from various economic levels and the percentage of poor vs non-poor clients is unknown. While MFIs accounted for 18% of total accounts, other AFIs like credit unions, rural banks, and postal savings banks collectively account for the large majority and also
BBVA on Financial Inclusion in ArgentinaChris Skinner
This document analyzes the determinants of financial inclusion in Argentina from a microeconomic perspective. It discusses three dimensions: access, use, and barriers.
Regarding access, the formal financial system in Argentina is supplied through traditional channels like branches and ATMs. Mobile banking is not widely used due to limited smartphone penetration.
In terms of use, factors like education, income, age, gender, and employment status influence whether individuals have financial products.
The document also examines perceived barriers to inclusion, finding that income and age impact perceptions of exclusion.
Fiscal multipliers and foreign holdings of public debt - working paperADEMU_Project
This paper explores the relationship between fiscal multipliers and foreign holdings of public debt. Using data from the US postwar period and a panel of 17 advanced economies, the paper finds that fiscal multipliers are larger when a higher share of public debt is held by foreign residents rather than domestic residents. This is because when debt is held by foreigners, fiscal expansions face weaker crowding-out effects on domestic private consumption and investment. The paper develops a model to explain this relationship and employs various empirical methods to estimate fiscal multipliers conditioned on the foreign share of public debt.
Technical Report of ITU Focus Group on Digital Financial Services : Bulk Payments and the DFSs Ecosystem
Written by Bennett Gordon, Carol Coye Benson, Carolina Trivelli, Daniel
Radcliffe, Abi Jagun, Mireya Almazán, Matt Homer, Toru Mino, Charles Niehaus, Satwik Seshasai,
Michael Goldfarb, Michael Faye, Niyi Ajao, and Quang Nguyen
Government-to-person (G2P) and employer-to-person payments of all sorts, often referred to as “bulk
payments”, are seen by many as key enablers for the growth of the digital financial services (DFS)
ecosystem. In this paper, we examine ways in which bulk payments have been made in the past and
look at ways in which this has improved over recent years. We also analyse the remaining challenges
which have stymied bulk payment rollouts in many countries.
The document discusses shifting financial inclusion measurement away from solely measuring breadth (the number of people accessing any formal financial service) to also measuring depth (the number of different financial product classes used per person). It argues that focusing only on breadth provides an incomplete picture, as evidence shows people rely on portfolios of financial products. Introducing a depth measurement provides more granular insights into levels of financial inclusion and usage. Measuring depth within product classes is also important to fully understand people's financial lives and needs. The document uses data from FinScope surveys in six countries to demonstrate how measuring both breadth and depth provides a more accurate view of financial inclusion.
This document summarizes an analytical study on the relevance of financial inclusion for developing nations. It discusses the need for financial inclusion to promote equitable growth and reduce income disparities. The objectives of the study are to explore the need for financial inclusion in promoting economic and social development, analyze India's current status of financial inclusion, and examine access to banking in rural areas. The study finds that while financial inclusion plays a catalytic role, more progress is still needed to achieve desired outcomes. It also reviews initiatives taken in India to promote financial inclusion since 2005.
An Analytical Study:Relevance of Financial Inclusion For Developing NationsDr Lendy Spires
The document analyzes the relevance of financial inclusion for developing nations. It discusses how financial inclusion, defined as providing affordable financial services to disadvantaged groups, is key to promoting inclusive growth. While initiatives in India have increased access to banking, challenges remain in bridging the gap between financially excluded sections. The study examines objectives and progress of financial inclusion in India, finding that efforts have expanded access points and accounts but more progress is needed to fully achieve desired economic and social development outcomes through financial inclusion.
The 2015 Koda Capital Non-Profit Sector ReviewDavid Knowles
The document provides an overview and analysis of the Australian non-profit sector. It summarizes that the sector is large, diverse, and growing, contributing an estimated $57.7 billion to GDP in 2012-13. While the sector has grown significantly, this growth has not been matched by equivalent increases in income or employment. It also notes that the top contributing subsectors are education/research and social services. In conclusion, it emphasizes that the sector faces ongoing challenges including increased reliance on government funding and pressures to demonstrate impact.
Local financial services persist in popularity despite efforts to promote formal alternatives. Local services are valued for their accessibility, convenience, and flexibility. Decision-making is local, so providers have direct knowledge of customers and context allowing for personalized, responsive service including negotiation and complaint resolution. While forms of local provision vary, what defines them as local is decision-making proximity to customers rather than legal formality or collective/individual structure.
1. Policy Research Working Paper
6630
Financial Inclusion
and the Role of the Post Office
Jose Anson
Alexandre Berthaud
Leora Klapper
Dorothe Singer
The World Bank
Development Research Group
Finance and Private Sector Development Team
October 2013
WPS6630
Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized
2. Produced by the Research Support Team
Abstract
The Policy Research Working Paper Series disseminates the findings of work in progress to encourage the exchange of ideas about development
issues. An objective of the series is to get the findings out quickly, even if the presentations are less than fully polished. The papers carry the
names of the authors and should be cited accordingly. The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this paper are entirely those
of the authors. They do not necessarily represent the views of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/World Bank and
its affiliated organizations, or those of the Executive Directors of the World Bank or the governments they represent.
Policy Research Working Paper 6630
Given their widespread presence in rural and poor areas,
post offices can play a leading role in advancing financial
inclusion. Yet little is known about the type of clients
that post offices reach through their financial service
offerings as compared with clients of traditional financial
institutions (such as commercial banks). This paper
documents and analyzes account ownership patterns
at post offices in comparison with traditional financial
institutions, using the Global Financial Inclusion
Indicators (Global Findex) database, which collects data
on account ownership at post offices in 60 countries
where postal accounts are offered. Controlling for a host
of individual characteristics and country fixed effects,
the paper finds that post offices are relatively more
likely than traditional financial institutions to provide
accounts to individuals who are most likely to be from
This paper is a product of the Finance and Private Sector Development Team, Development Research Group. It is part of
a larger effort by the World Bank to provide open access to its research and make a contribution to development policy
discussions around the world. Policy Research Working Papers are also posted on the Web at http://econ.worldbank.org.
The authors may be contacted at lklapper@worldbank.org.
financially vulnerable groups, such as the poor, less
educated, and those out of the labor force. The paper
also uses data from the Universal Postal Union to explore
the degree to which different postal business models and
the size of the postal network help explain differences
in account ownership patterns. The results suggest that
post offices can boost account ownership by acting as
cash-merchants for transactional financial services, such
as electronic government and remittance payments,
and that partnerships between the post office and other
financial institutions coincide with a higher bank account
penetration. The paper also finds that the size of the
postal network matters; the larger the network-relative
to the network of traditional financial institutions—the
more likely it is that adults have an account at the post
office.
3. Financial Inclusion and the Role of the Post Office
Jose Anson, Alexandre Berthaud, Leora Klapper, and Dorothe Singer*
Keywords: Financial Inclusion; Financial Institutions; Post Office; Emerging Markets
JEL Codes: G2, G21, O16
Sector Board: Finance and Private Sector Development
* Anson: Universal Postal Union (UPU), jose.ANSON@upu.int; Berthaud: UPU, alexandre.BERTHAUD@upu.int; Klapper: World Bank, lklapper@worldbank.org; Singer: World Bank, dsinger@worldbank.org. We thank Isabelle Huynh, Roelof Goosen, Atisha Kumar, and Douglas Randall for helpful comments. This paper’s findings, interpretations, and conclusions are entirely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Universal Postal Union nor the World Bank, their Executive Directors, or the countries they represent.
4. 2
1. Introduction
Post offices (or “posts”) can play a leading role in advancing financial inclusion. In Brazil, for example, more than 10 million accounts were opened between 2002 and 2011 after the post established Banco Postal under a partnership model with an existing financial institution (Ansón and Bosch Gual, 2008). Yet little is known about the type of clients that post offices reach through their financial service offerings, as compared to clients of traditional financial institutions (such as commercial banks). Moreover, the role of the post office may vary depending on the business model that a government pursues in providing financial services via the postal network. The lack of systematic data has hindered efforts to understand the role of the post office in providing financial services in most economies.
This paper documents and analyzes account ownership patterns at post offices, in comparison to traditional financial institutions, such as banks and regulated microfinance institutions (MFI’s). We use the Global Financial Inclusion Indicators (“Global Findex”) database, which provides indicators measuring how people in 148 economies around the world save, borrow, make payments, and manage risk based on interviews with more than 150,000 nationally representative and randomly selected adults. For 60 countries these new indicators distinguish whether adults have an account at the post office, a financial institution, or both.1 Controlling for a host of individual characteristics and country fixed effects, we find that post offices are relatively more likely than traditional financial institutions to provide accounts to individuals who are most likely to be financially excluded such as the poor, less educated and those out of the labor force.
Using newly collected data from the Universal Postal Union (UPU), we also explore the degree to which different postal business models and the size of the postal network help explain
1 Account ownership is the only indicator for which a breakdown by institution is available.
5. 3
differences in account ownership patterns across institutions (post offices versus traditional financial institutions) and countries. Partnerships between the post office and other financial institutions coincide with a higher bank account penetration, suggesting that the contribution to financial inclusion through the post is potentially larger than what we can measure with the share of post office accounts. We also find that the size of the postal network matters. The larger the network– both relative to the network of traditional financial institutions and to a country’s population – the more likely it is that adults have an account at the post office.
A formal account provides individuals with a safe place to save and creates a reliable payment channel to transact with family members, an employer, businesses, or the government. It can also facilitate formal savings and credit, which may be used to invest in education or starting a business. As such, account ownership is often the first step towards inclusion in the formal financial sector.
The first postal account was opened in 1861when the post in the United Kingdom established a postal savings bank to encourage the poor to save. Postal services in many other countries soon followed suit in offering savings accounts. In some countries posts operated as agents for private savings institutions before becoming postal savings banks. For example, in the Netherlands the post served as agent based on a royal decree from 1875 which regulated the connection between the post offices and the existing savings banks before the Royal Postal Savings Bank was established in 1881 (Universal Postal Union, 1879). For over a century, the business model of postal savings banks around the world remained essentially unchanged. In 1970, Finland was one of the first countries to convert its postal savings bank into a fully-fledged postal bank reporting to the central bank. This move was taken by the Finnish government to allow the post to provide a wider range of services across its more than 3,000 post offices. The
6. 4
increasing use of digital communication technologies in the 1990s and substitution away from mail, however, forced post operators to rethink their overall business strategy and to diversify product offerings. As a result, some postal operators decided to leverage their existing post office network and expand the number of financial services provided. While posts in some countries such as Brazil chose to partner with existing financial institutions, other posts decided to convert their postal savings banks into fully-fledged postal banks (Berthaud and Davico, 2013).
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the data both at the individual and country-levels. Section 3 introduces the empirical methodology. Section 4 shows the econometric estimation results according to individual (demand-side) and country (supply- side) characteristics. Section 5 concludes.
2. Data
2.1 Individual-Level Data
Our data on account ownership come from the first round of the Global Findex database.2 The Global Findex data were collected over the calendar year 2011 by adding a questionnaire on financial inclusion to the annual Gallup World Poll. The 2011 World Poll surveyed at least 1,000 individuals in 148 economies using randomly selected, nationally representative samples.3 The target population is the entire civilian, non-institutionalized, adult population (age 15 and over) in each country. The questionnaire includes a question on ownership of an individual or joint account at a formal financial institution. For 62 countries in which post office savings accounts are offered, the questionnaire also includes a question on ownership of an individual or joint
2 See Demirguc-Kunt and Klapper (Forthcoming) for a description of the database.
3 Detailed country-level information about the data collection dates, sample sizes, excluded populations and margins of error can be found at: http://www.worldbank.org/globalfindex. In BRIC countries, the sample size ranges from 2000-4000 individuals.
7. 5
account at a post office.
4 In our sample, we focus on the over 65,000 individuals who were interviewed in 60 of these countries.5 Appendix 1 lists all the countries included in our sample.
The Global Findex data allow us to distinguish between three types of account ownership: an account at a financial institution only, accounts at both a financial institution and the post office, and an account at the post office only. Within our sample of countries that offer postal accounts, we find that 49.9 percent of adults have an account at either or both institutions, 11.6 percent of adults have an account at the post office, and 2.8 percent of adults have an account at the post office only (5.6 percent of account holders).
Figure 1 shows a wide variation in overall account ownership between high income and developing countries. While account penetration is close to universal in the developed countries included in our sample (90 percent), on average, only 44 percent of adults in developing countries offering postal financial services report having an account.6 However, beyond account penetration, we are interested in the types of accounts owned by individuals. In most of countries in our sample, account ownership at a formal financial institution only is the most common type of account ownership, followed by account ownership at both a financial institution and post office. Having a post office account only is typically the least common.
One exception to that general pattern is Japan, where 80 percent of adults in Japan report owning an account at the post office. Japan is also the only country where owning an account at both a financial institution and the post office is the most common type of account ownership (77 percent). The gap between the share of post account ownership in Japan and the countries with
4 For seven countries (Algeria, Congo, Rep., Egypt, Arab Rep., Greece, Morocco, Tunisia, and Yemen, Rep.) the data is for 2012 instead of 2011 because of data quality issues in the 2011 round.
5 We drop Madagascar from our sample because more than 20% of the population is not sampled and Taiwan, China because no country-level post office information is available.
6 This compares to 89 percent account penetration in high income countries and 41 percent account penetration in developing countries for the full sample of countries in the Global Findex database. The data are population weighted.
8. 6
the next highest levels of account ownership illustrates that the Japanese case is indeed an exception. In Ireland and Luxembourg, a little over 30 percent of adults report owning a post office account. Furthermore, in most countries, fewer than 10 percent of adults have a post office account. With respect to the percentage of adults who only own an account at the post office, Italy stands out with 16 percent of adults who report owning an account at the post office only. In contrast, in most other countries, less than five percent of adults have a post office account only. We report the percentages for all three types of account ownership by country in Appendix 1.
In addition to sharp differences in account penetration across countries, there are also important disparities in account penetration by individual characteristics. Allen et al. (2012) document that men and more educated, wealthier, and older adults, as well as adults residing in urban areas, are more likely to own an account. We test whether demographic characteristics also matter for the type of account that adults own. Table 1 reports the univariate statistics of type of account by individual demographics which are included in the Gallup World Poll Survey.
Because there are three account ownership types – financial institution only, both financial institution and post office, and post office only – we present two sets of statistics. First, we compare individuals with an account at a financial institution or both financial institution and post office to those with an account at the post office only. We find that individuals with an account at a post office only tend to be significantly poorer, older, less educated, less likely to be married and less likely to be employed. This suggests that post offices may play an important role in providing financial services to segments of the population that might be particularly likely to be financially excluded. Notably, we find no statistically significant gender or rural-urban gap between adults with an account at a financial institution or financial institution and post office
9. 7
and adults with an account at a post office. Second, we compare adults with an account at the post office only to those with no account. We find that individuals with an account at the post office only are relatively more likely be male, richer, older, reside in urban areas, more educated and employed by an employer. They are less likely to be unemployed or self-employed. This suggests that the postal service may provide financial services to vulnerable parts of the population if we restrict ourselves to the universe of account owners. However, relative to the unbanked, adults with a post office account only may not represent the most vulnerable segment of society.
7
2.2 Country-Level Data
We combine individual-level data from the Global Findex database and the Gallup World Poll with country-level information on the post offices’ adopted business model and the types of financial services provided. The data on the different business models pursued by posts with regard to providing financial services was collected by the Universal Postal Union (UPU), a United Nations specialized agency that is the primary forum for cooperation between governments and postal sector players.8 Appendix 2 provides an overview of the included business models. First, we identify dummy variables (0/1) on whether posts have a postal bank license, provide unlicensed postal savings (usually referred to as post office savings bank), or offer financial services through various partnership models with other financial institutions.9 Because few countries have fully licensed postal financial services, we combine the licensed and
7 For the most vulnerable segment of society owning an account might not make economic sense due to costs related to opening and maintaining an account. However, those individuals may use the post for transactional financial services such as sending remittances.
8 See Berthaud and Davico (2013) for a description of the database.
9 Licensed in this context refers to the fact that the post has been issued a banking licenses by the banking supervisor (typically the central bank) and falls under its supervision. Unlicensed here refers to the fact that the postal savings bank does not fall under the supervision of the banking supervisor. Instead, it falls under the supervision of its line ministry or the postal regulator.
10. 8
unlicensed financial services in the regression analysis and create one dummy that equals 1 if posts provide financial services through partnerships and 0 if posts provide licensed or unlicensed financial services directly. Second, we identify dummy variables (0/1) if the post office acts as a cash-merchant for (i) remittance service providers or (ii) government payments. Note that the latter two categories are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Appendix 1 includes data on the post bank business models by country.
Table 2 summarizes the number of countries that adopt each business model. Overall, seven countries10 in our sample of 60 countries have a licensed post bank. In 29 countries, the post offers unlicensed postal savings. Posts have entered a partnership with a financial service provider in the remaining 24 countries. In developing countries, unlicensed postal savings are the most common business model. In contrast, in high-income countries the dominant model involves partnerships with financial service providers. In addition, in many countries, the post offers cash merchant services. In 43 countries (72 percent), the post offers such services on behalf of remittance service providers and in 40 countries (67 percent) the post offers services to facilitate government payments. While the postal service in nearly all high-income countries acts as cash merchants for remittance service providers, it only does so in 61 percent of posts in the developing world (25 countries).
In addition to data on the postal networks’ business models in providing financial services, we also use data on post office access points both relative to the total number of post and financial institutions contact points as well as the proportion of access points per 1,000 inhabitants. We hypothesize that a larger presence of post office branches compared to financial institutions or a denser postal branch network in general increase the convenience of having a post office account. This may in turn influence individuals’ choice of account type in favor of
10 China, France, Gabon, Japan, Kazakhstan, Morocco, Poland.
11. 9
postal accounts. Data on post access points are collected by the UPU. The IMF’s Financial Access Survey provides data on financial access such as branch penetration. Data on GDP per capita come from the World Bank’s World Development Indicators database. Appendix 3 provides detailed descriptions of all indicators and their sources.
3. Empirical Methodology
To examine the determinants of individuals’ choice of the type of account owned, we specify a multivariate estimation model. In particular, we fit a multinomial logit regression model to the response variable account ownership since it has four distinct categories: 0 if an individual does not have an account, 1 if the account is at the post office only, 2 if the individual owns an account both the post office and a financial institution, and 3 if the account is at a financial institution only. We choose no account (0) as our baseline category.
푦푖푗=푥푖푗 ′훽+푧푗 ′훾+휀푖푗 (1)
where 푦푖푗 is account ownership type of an individual i residing in country j. The variables 푥푖푗 and 푧푗 are the vectors of country and individual-level characteristics, respectively. Their corresponding vectors of parameters are given by β and γ. 휀푖푗 denotes the error term.
Among the individual-level characteristics we include in 푥푖푗 are the following socioeconomic variables that may be associated with account ownership. We include dummies for gender, income quintiles based on the income of respondents in a country, whether a respondent lives in a rural area, the respondent’s marital status, educational attainment, and employment status. We also include age and age squared in years and the logarithm of household
12. 10
size in our regression. In the first set of regressions, we focus on the explanatory role of individual characteristics and replace the vector 푧푗 of country characteristics with country fixed effects.
In the second set of regressions, we test the explanatory power of the different postal business models and the relative size of the postal branch network on the type of account owned. To do so, we replace country fixed effects with the logarithm of GDP per capita and include the several country-level characteristics that might influence choice of account type. As discussed in the data section above, we include a dummy variable for the different business models with respect to offering financial services at the post office. We also include variables measuring the number of post office access points relative to the total number of post office and financial institutions access points and post office access points per 1,000 inhabitants. Appendix 3 provides detailed descriptions of each indicator and its source.
4. Results
4.1 Account Ownership and Individual Characteristics
Table 3 examines the relationship of individual characteristics and the odds of falling into one of four account ownership categories: no account, account at the post office only, account at both the post office and a financial institution, and account at a financial institution only. Our baseline category is no account. Thus, the coefficient estimates represent the log-odds ratio of each of the three account owning categories relative to not having an account. We report our results for the entire data set in Panel A and separately for high income and developing countries in Panel B. Each regression controls for country fixed effects.
13. 11
The results in Panel A indicate that the log-odds of having any of the three types of accounts relative to not having an account decrease for women compared to men. This drop is statistically the same for both post office only and financial institutions only account holders. The relative log-odds of having any kind of the three types of accounts compared to not having an account also decrease as one moves from the highest income quintile to the lowest and decreases by a larger amount for accounts at a financial institution only versus none than for post office accounts only compared to none for the bottom 60 percent of the population. This suggests that post offices are relatively better in reaching lower income individuals. As expected, an increase in age leads to an increase in the relative log-odds of having an account both at the post office only and at a financial institution only compared to not having an account. However, the relationship between age and account ownership is not linear; the statistical significance of the included square term means that account ownership eventually diminishes with an increase in age. The estimates on the coefficients suggest that an increase in the log-odds associated with age is smaller for accounts at the post office. Living in a rural area has no significant impact on the relative log-odds of having an account at the post office only compared to having none. However, it does have a significant impact on accounts at a financial institution only: it decreases the log-odds of having an account at a financial institution relative to not having an account. This suggests that post offices could play a role in bridging the gap in account penetration between rural and urban areas that we typically observe (Allen et al., 2012).
The relative log-odds of having any kind of the three types of accounts compared to none decrease as one moves from more than 15 years of schooling (masters degree or more) to fewer years. The negative effect is larger for accounts at a financial institution only relative to no accounts than for post office accounts only compared to not having an account. Household
14. 12
characteristics such as household size and marital status only significantly impact the relative log-odds of having an account at financial institutions but not at the post office. Finally, as expected, employment status is an important determinant of account ownership. Our results indicate that the relative log-odds of having any kind of the three types of accounts compared to none increase as the employment status changes from self-employed to being employed by an employer but decrease as the status changes to being unemployed or exiting the workforce. The results are stronger in magnitude for both the increase and decrease for accounts at a financial institution only compared to individuals with accounts at the post office only. Overall, the results thus seem to suggest that post offices may be relatively better at providing accounts to groups that are often most likely to be financially excluded, such as the poor, less educated, unemployed, or those out of the labor market.
In Panel B, we report regression results separately for high income and developing countries. We find three main differences in how individual characteristics influence account ownership in the two groups. Unlike in our sample of developing countries, gender and rural residency no longer have a statistically significant impact on the three log-odds ratios. Furthermore, in high income countries log-odds ratio of having an account at the post office versus not having an account does not significantly change moving from the highest income quintile to the lowest one. The log-odds ratio of having an account at a financial institution, however, does change moving from the richest income quintile to one of the lowest 60 percent income quintiles. Similarly, moving from self-employed to unemployed or exiting the workforce does not affect the log-odds of owning a post office account compared to not having an account while there is a significant impact on accounts at a financial institutions only compared to no account. This suggests that, in high income countries, post offices are not only relatively better at
15. 13
providing financial services such as accounts to some segments of the population most likely to be financially excluded such as lower income individuals and those unemployed or out of the labor force compared to financial institutions, but that there is actually no significant difference in providing account services to them.
4.2 Account Ownership and Country Characteristics
In Table 4, we explore the explanatory power of the different postal business models and the relative size of the postal branch network on the choice of account type. To do so, we use the same specification as in Table 3 but instead of country fixed effects we now control for GDP per capita and one postal variable at a time. In the interest of space and readability the coefficients for the individual characteristics are not reported. They are of similar size and sign as those reported in Table 3.
Our results in Panel A indicate that the relative log-odds of having an account at the post office relative to not having an account decrease if a country moves from a an unlicensed or licensed postal savings model (omitted category) to a partnership model. At the same time, the log-odds of having an account at a financial institution increase. This finding is in line with evidence from Brazil where Ansón and Bosch Gual (2008) show that, in municipalities with certain characteristics, Banco Postal’s launch attracted other bank branches not previously present in these municipalities. This suggests that the contribution to financial inclusion through the post is potentially larger than what we can measure with the share of post office accounts alone.
Our results also indicate that, regardless of whether posts offer financial services as a (un)licensed institution or in partnership with a financial institution, the log-odds of having an
16. 14
account at the post office increase if posts serve as cash merchants for remittances or government payments. Notably, posts serving as cash merchants for remittances moreover increases the log- offs of having an account at a financial institution only compared to none albeit to a smaller degree. While this may at first seem counterintuitive, remittances need both a sender and receiver. If remittances can be received at other financial institutions, posts providing remittance services can increase the log-odds of having an account at only a financial institution as well. When we only consider the sample of developing countries (Panel B), we find that there is actually no statistically significant difference between the increase of the log-odds ratios for post office accounts only and financial institutions accounts only compared to none for remittances and government payments.
Finally, we control for the size of the postal network. As expected, the log-odds of having an account at the post office only relative to having no account increase as the size of the postal branch network increases relative to the sum of post and financial institutions access points. At the same time, the log-odds of having an account at a financial institution only versus not having an account decrease. When we consider the number of post office branches per 1,000 inhabitants, we find that the log-odds of having an account at the post office increase compared to none. This time, however, we do not measure a statistically significant impact on the relative log-odds of having an account at a financial institution only.
5. Conclusion
Using data from the Global Financial Inclusion Indicators (Global Findex) database, which collects data on account ownership at post offices for 60 countries where postal accounts are offered, this paper documents and analyzes account ownership patterns at post offices in
17. 15
comparison to traditional financial institutions such as banks to help clarify the role that post offices can play in advancing financial inclusion. Controlling for a host of individual characteristics and country fixed effects, we find that post offices are relatively more likely than traditional financial institutions to provide accounts to individuals who are most likely to be financially excluded such as the poor, less educated, and those out of the labor force.
We also use data from the Universal Postal Union (UPU) to explore the degree to which different postal business models and the size of the postal network help explain differences in account ownership patterns. The results suggest that post offices can boost account ownership— perhaps at both the post and other financial institutions— and that the size of the postal network matters. The larger the network–relative to the network of traditional financial institutions– the more likely it is that adults have an accounts at the post office.
Overall, our results suggest that post offices can play an important role in advancing financial inclusion. Leveraging their existing postal network infrastructure may be one of the ways that developing countries can use to address the financial inclusion challenges they face. However, more research is needed to better understand under which circumstances and under which business models posts can best expand financial inclusion.
18. 16
References
Allen, Franklin, Asli Demirguc-Kunt, Leora Klapper, and Maria Soledad Martinez Peria. 2012. "The Foundations of Financial Inclusion: Understanding Ownership and Use of Formal Accounts." World Bank Policy Working Paper 6290.
Ansón, José and Laia Bosch Gual. 2008. “Financial Access and Inclusion Through Postal Networks: Evaluating the Experience of Brazil’s Banco Postal.” In Joëlle Toledano, ed., Postal Economics in Developing Countries. Bern: Universal Postal Union.
Berthaud, Alexandre and Gisela Davico. 2013. “Global Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion.” Bern: Universal Postal Union.
Demirguc-Kunt, Asli and Leora Klapper. Forthcoming. “Measuring Financial Inclusion: The Global Findex Database.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity.
Karlan, Dean, and Jonathan Morduch. 2010. “Access to Finance.” In Dani Rodrik and Mark Rosenzweig, eds., Handbook of Development Economics, vol. 5. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Universal Postal Union. 1879. “Post Office Savings Banks”. In L’Union Postale, vol. IV n.1, January 1, 1879
19. 17
Figure 1: Account Ownership by Type and Country, 2011
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Zimbabwe
Yemen, Rep.
Vietnam
United Kingdom
Turkey
Tunisia
Togo
Tanzania
Sudan
Sri Lanka
Spain
South Africa
Slovenia
Slovak Republic
Sierra Leone
Serbia
Senegal
Rwanda
Poland
Pakistan
Nepal
Morocco
Mauritius
Mauritania
Malawi
Luxembourg
Lesotho
Latvia
Korea, Rep.
Kenya
Kazakhstan
Japan
Italy
Israel
Ireland
Indonesia
India
Hungary
Greece
Gabon
France
Estonia
Egypt, Arab Rep.
Czech Republic
Croatia
Congo, Rep.
Comoros
China
Chad
Cameroon
Burundi
Burkina Faso
Brazil
Botswana
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Benin
Belgium
Bangladesh
Austria
Algeria
% of Population with Account
Account at FI only
Account at BOTH FI and Post
Account at Post only
20. 18
Table 1: Who Has an Account at the Post Office?
FI Account vs Post Office Only Account
Unbanked vs Post Office Only Account
Account at FI or Post Office and FI
Account at Post Office Only
Sig. T- test
Unbanked
Account at Post Office Only
Sig. T- test
Female (0/1)
0.4917
0.4982
0.5405
0.4982
***
Income: poorest 20% (0/1)
0.1718
0.2042
***
0.2631
0.2042
***
Income: second 20% (0/1)
0.1873
0.2190
***
0.2298
0.2190
Income: middle 20% (0/1)
0.1971
0.2144
0.1973
0.2144
Income: fourth 20% (0/1)
0.2212
0.1703
***
0.1759
0.1703
Income: richest 20% (0/1)
0.2226
0.1920
***
0.1340
0.1920
***
Age
42.1835
44.1920
***
35.6902
44.1920
***
Rural (0/1)
0.5885
0.5934
0.7364
0.5934
***
0 - 8 years of education (0/1)
0.2811
0.4585
***
0.6938
0.4585
***
9 - 15 years of education (0/1)
0.5705
0.4572
***
0.2848
0.4572
***
> 15 years of education (0/1)
0.1483
0.0843
***
0.0214
0.0843
***
Household size (ln)
1.2252
1.3257
***
1.6246
1.3257
***
Married (0/1)
0.6012
0.5369
***
0.5255
0.5369
Divorced/Separated (0/1)
0.0510
0.0436
0.0309
0.0436
**
Employed for employer (0/1)
0.4386
0.2877
***
0.1643
0.2877
***
Unemployed (0/1)
0.0526
0.0639
*
0.0922
0.0639
***
Out of workforce (0/1)
0.3332
0.4517
***
0.4666
0.4517
Employed for self (0/1)
0.1757
0.1967
0.2770
0.1967
***
note: *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1
21. 19
Table 2: Overview Postal Business Models
Countries
Business Models
All
High Income
Developing
Licensed postal financial services
7
12%
3
16%
4
10%
Unlicensed postal savings
29
48%
5
26%
24
59%
Partnership with a financial service provider
24
40%
11
58%
13
32%
Total
60
100%
19
100%
41
100%
Cash Merchant for
Remittances
43
72%
18
95%
25
61%
Government payments
40
67%
11
58%
29
71%
22. 20
Table 3: Individual-Level Regressions
Panel A: All Countries
All Countries
Mlogit (Base Category: No Account)
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
p-value diff (1) and (3)
1
2
3
Female (0/1)
-0.131**
-0.280***
-0.166***
(0.049)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Income: poorest 20% (0/1)
-0.892***
-1.350***
-1.214***
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Income: second 20% (0/1)
-0.577***
-1.055***
-0.845***
**
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Income: middle 20% (0/1)
-0.326***
-0.720***
-0.578***
**
(0.001)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Income: fourth 20% (0/1)
-0.373***
-0.402***
-0.278***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Age
0.047***
0.091***
0.085***
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Age squared
-0.000**
-0.001***
-0.001***
***
(0.031)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Rural (0/1)
0.040
-0.234***
-0.241***
***
(0.620)
(0.003)
(0.000)
0 - 8 years of education (0/1)
-1.355***
-2.153***
-1.854***
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
9 - 15 years of education (0/1)
-0.668***
-0.981***
-0.972***
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Household size (ln)
-0.103
-0.305***
-0.274***
**
(0.145)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Married (0/1)
-0.068
0.415***
0.238***
***
(0.419)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Divorced/Separated (0/1)
0.030
0.255**
0.020
(0.860)
(0.038)
(0.801)
Employed for employer (0/1)
0.285**
0.476***
0.489***
*
(0.018)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Unemployed (0/1)
-0.436***
-0.613***
-0.629***
(0.006)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Out of workforce (0/1)
-0.454***
-0.670***
-0.699***
**
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Constant
-1.726***
-3.616***
-2.243***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Country-FE
YES
N
59,550
# countries
55
note: *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1
P-values reported in parentheses.
23. 21
Panel B: By High Income and Developing Countries
High Income Countries
Developing Countries
Mlogit (Base Category: No Account)
Mlogit (Base Category: No Account)
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
p-value diff (1) and (3)
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
p-value diff (1) and (3)
1
2
3
1
2
3
Female (0/1)
0.001
-0.099
0.058
-0.137*
-0.322***
-0.240***
(0.995)
(0.280)
(0.407)
(0.069)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Income: poorest 20% (0/1)
-0.358
-0.663***
-0.792***
**
-1.002***
-1.698***
-1.267***
**
(0.122)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Income: second 20% (0/1)
-0.101
-0.518***
-0.512***
**
-0.678***
-1.284***
-0.861***
(0.663)
(0.001)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Income: middle 20% (0/1)
-0.176
-0.268*
-0.300**
-0.310***
-0.913***
-0.599***
**
(0.447)
(0.085)
(0.013)
(0.005)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Income: fourth 20% (0/1)
0.238
0.016
0.048
-0.510***
-0.513***
-0.309***
*
(0.343)
(0.921)
(0.713)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Age
0.086***
0.122***
0.106***
0.038***
0.082***
0.083***
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.002)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Age squared
-0.001***
-0.001***
-0.001***
**
-0.000
-0.001***
-0.001***
***
(0.006)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.190)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Rural (0/1)
0.204
-0.014
0.043
0.029
-0.235*
-0.342***
***
(0.149)
(0.899)
(0.594)
(0.776)
(0.053)
(0.000)
0 - 8 years of education (0/1)
-0.977***
-1.981***
-1.491***
**
-1.396***
-2.047***
-1.913***
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
9 - 15 years of education (0/1)
-0.450**
-0.888***
-0.837***
**
-0.732***
-0.963***
-0.997***
**
(0.035)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Household size (ln)
0.027
-0.260**
-0.325***
**
-0.143*
-0.313***
-0.233***
(0.866)
(0.017)
(0.000)
(0.071)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Married (0/1)
-0.080
0.406***
0.354***
***
-0.055
0.480***
0.204***
***
(0.656)
(0.001)
(0.000)
(0.570)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Divorced/Separated (0/1)
0.001
0.295
0.088
0.020
0.136
-0.011
(0.998)
(0.113)
(0.543)
(0.928)
(0.489)
(0.912)
Employed for employer (0/1)
0.725**
0.548***
0.506***
0.183
0.426***
0.469***
**
(0.021)
(0.006)
(0.002)
(0.173)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Unemployed (0/1)
-0.574
-0.780***
-0.821***
-0.412**
-0.598***
-0.607***
(0.165)
(0.002)
(0.000)
(0.016)
(0.002)
(0.000)
Out of workforce (0/1)
-0.127
-0.668***
-0.712***
**
-0.525***
-0.683***
-0.720***
(0.669)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Constant
-2.041***
0.248
2.884***
-1.289***
-3.280***
-2.083***
(0.008)
(0.670)
(0.000)
(0.001)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Country-FE
YES
YES
N
17,476
42,074
# countries
18
37
note: *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1
P-values reported in parentheses.
24. 22
Table 4: Individual-Level Regressions with Country-Level Variables
Panel A: All Countries
m1
m2
m3
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
p-value diff (1) and (3)
1
2
3
1
2
3
1
2
3
GDP per capita (ln)
0.608***
1.091***
0.817***
0.528***
1.026***
0.786***
0.588***
1.107***
0.822***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Partnership with a financial service provider (0/1)
-0.692***
-1.084***
0.262***
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
CM for remittances (0/1)
0.517***
0.892***
0.319***
**
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
CM for government payments (0/1)
0.254***
-0.022
-0.086*
***
(0.005)
(0.806)
(0.078)
Constant
-7.224***
-9.776***
-6.254***
-7.127***
-10.127***
-6.160***
-7.391***
-10.078***
-6.173***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
N
59,550
59,550
59,550
# countries
55
55
55
note: *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1
P-values reported in parentheses.
Individual characteristics controlled for but not reported.
25. 23
m4
m5
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
p-value diff (1) and (3)
1
2
3
1
2
3
GDP per capita (ln)
0.712***
1.209***
0.672***
0.470***
1.234***
0.811***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Post branches as % total FI and post branches
1.214***
0.156
-1.438***
***
(0.000)
(0.404)
(0.000)
Post branches per 1000 inhabitants (ln)
0.297***
-0.347***
0.033
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.230)
Constant
-9.514***
-11.963***
-3.985***
-5.558***
-12.069***
-6.050***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
N
43,776
59,550
# countries
42
55
note: *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1
P-values reported in parentheses.
Individual characteristics controlled for but not reported.
26. 24
Panel B: Developing Countries
m1
m2
m3
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
p-value diff (1) and (3)
1
2
3
1
2
3
1
2
3
GDP per capita (ln)
0.655***
0.877***
0.644***
0.572***
0.783***
0.613***
0.601***
0.949***
0.639***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Partnership with a financial service provider (0/1)
-0.741***
-0.772***
0.154**
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.012)
CM for remittances (0/1)
0.466***
0.787***
0.302***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
CM for government payments (0/1)
0.300**
-0.986***
0.108*
(0.033)
(0.000)
(0.099)
Constant
-7.289***
-7.923***
-4.829***
-7.166***
-7.942***
-4.756***
-7.203***
-8.341***
-4.801***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
N
42,074
42,074
42,074
# countries
37
37
37
note: *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1
P-values reported in parentheses.
Individual characteristics controlled for but not reported.
27. 25
m4
m5
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
Post Office Account Only
Post Office and FI Account
FI Account Only
p-value diff (1) and (3)
1
2
3
1
2
3
GDP per capita (ln)
0.685***
0.619***
0.496***
0.496***
0.957***
0.624***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
Post branches as % total FI and post branches
1.622***
0.577**
-1.796***
***
(0.000)
(0.024)
(0.000)
Post branches per 1000 inhabitants (ln)
0.311***
-0.226***
0.055*
***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.071)
Constant
-9.475***
-7.570***
-2.399***
-5.515***
-9.328***
-4.495***
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
(0.000)
N
29,276
42,074
# countries
27
37
note: *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1
P-values reported in parentheses.
Individual characteristics controlled for but not reported.
28. 26
Appendix 1: Summary Statistics of Account Penetration and Post Bank Business Model, By Country
Account Penetration by Type
Post Bank Business Model
Country
Account at FI only
Account at both FI and Post
Account at Post only
Licensed postal financial services (BM 5a, 5b, and 5c)
Unlicensed postal savings (BM 4a)
Partnership wih a financial service provider (BM 3c, 3d, 3e, and 3f)
Algeria
0.10
0.16
0.19
0
1
0
Austria
0.84
0.10
0.02
0
0
1
Bangladesh
0.30
0.01
0.01
0
1
0
Belgium
0.82
0.09
0.01
0
0
1
Benin
0.08
0.01
0.01
0
1
0
Bosnia and Herzegovina
0.52
0.02
0.01
0
0
1
Botswana
0.21
0.05
0.04
0
0
1
Brazil
0.53
0.01
0.00
0
0
1
Burkina Faso
0.11
0.02
0.00
0
1
0
Burundi
0.04
0.01
0.02
0
1
0
Cameroon
0.12
0.00
0.01
0
1
0
Chad
0.06
0.02
0.00
0
1
0
China
0.38
0.21
0.04
1
0
0
Comoros
0.09
0.05
0.06
0
1
0
Congo, Rep.
0.12
0.02
0.02
0
1
0
Croatia
0.78
0.05
0.03
0
0
1
Czech Republic
0.68
0.04
0.08
0
0
1
Egypt, Arab Rep.
0.04
0.02
0.04
0
1
0
Estonia
0.94
0.00
0.02
0
0
1
France
0.73
0.19
0.04
1
0
0
Gabon
0.07
0.04
0.08
1
0
0
Greece
0.66
0.12
0.00
0
0
1
Hungary
0.70
0.02
0.00
0
0
1
India
0.28
0.04
0.03
0
1
0
Indonesia
0.18
0.01
0.00
0
0
1
Ireland
0.63
0.29
0.01
0
1
0
Israel
0.87
0.02
0.01
0
1
0
Italy
0.50
0.03
0.16
0
1
0
Japan
0.16
0.77
0.03
1
0
0
Kazakhstan
0.32
0.06
0.04
1
0
0
Kenya
0.37
0.03
0.02
0
0
1
Korea, Rep.
0.63
0.26
0.04
0
1
0
Latvia
0.81
0.04
0.05
0
1
0
30. 28
Appendix 2: Postal Business Models for Financial Services
Variable Code
Short Variable Descriptions
bm0
Real estate provider
Business model 1: cash-merchant (CM) for transactional financial services
bm1a
CM for remittance service provider
bm1b
CM for government payments
bm1c
CM for bill collection
bm1d
CM for insurance companies – collection of premiums, payout of insured amount
bm1e
CM for mobile network operator – registration, cash-in, cash-out
bm1f
CM for MFIs and banks – loan disbursement and repayment
bm1g
CM for MFIs and banks – deposit and withdrawal from accounts
Business model 2: proprietary transactional financial services
bm2a
Proprietary domestic transfers
bm2b
Proprietary international transfers
Business model 3: partnership with a financial service provider
bm3a
Partnership model with an insurance company to offer its services
bm3b
Partnership with a mobile network operator for financial services
bm3c
Partnership model on a regional basis
bm3d
CM for multiple banks but partnership for savings accounts
bm3e
Partnership model with a bank
bm3f
Partnership model with a post bank or a government savings bank
Business model 4: unlicensed postal savings and financial services
bm4a
Unlicensed post bank
bm4b
Unlicensed postal insurance
Business model 5: licensed postal financial services
bm5a
Microfinance license
bm5b
Limited post bank license
bm5c
Universal post bank license
31. 29
Appendix 3: Variable Definitions
Variable
Description
Source
Panel A: Individual Characteristics
Account (0/1)
Respondent reported to currently have, possibly together with someone else, a bank account at a formal financial institution---a bank, credit union, cooperative, post office, or microfinance institution. This includes having a debit card.
Gallup
Post Office Account (0/1)
Respondent reported to currently have, possibly together with someone else, a bank account at a post office.
Gallup
Account at FI (0/1)
Respondent reported to currently have, possibly together with someone else, a bank account at a formal financial institution---a bank, credit union, cooperative or microfinance institution.
Gallup
Female (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent is female and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
Income: poorest 20% (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent falls in the lowest income quintile and 0 otherwise. Income quintiles are based on the incomes of the respondents in a country.
Gallup
Income: second 20% (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent falls in the second lowest income quintile and 0 otherwise. Income quintiles are based on the incomes of the respondents in a country.
Gallup
Income: middle 20% (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent falls in the middle income quintile and 0 otherwise. Income quintiles are based on the incomes of the respondents in a country.
Gallup
Income: fourth 20% (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent falls in the second highest income quintile and 0 otherwise. Income quintiles are based on the incomes of the respondents in a country.
Gallup
Income: richest 20% (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent falls in the highest income quintile and 0 otherwise. Income quintiles are based on the incomes of the respondents in a country.
Gallup
Age
Age in years
Gallup
Age squared
Age in years, squared
Gallup
Rural (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent lives in a rural area and 0 otherwise. A rural area is defined as a town or rural village with less than 50,000 inhabitants. If this information is unavailable, a rural area is based on the interviewer's perception of whether a respondent lives in a rural area, on a farm, in a small town, or in a village.
Gallup
0 - 8 years of education (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent completed elementary education or less (up to 8 years of education) and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
32. 30
9 - 15 years of education (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent completed secondary education and some education beyond secondary education (9-15 years of education) and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
> 15 years of education (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent completed four years of education beyond high school and/or received a 4-year college degree and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
Household size (ln)
Logarithm of household size.
Gallup
Married (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent is married and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
Divorced/Separated (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent is divorced or separated and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
Employed for employer (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent is employed for an employer, either full or part time, and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
Unemployed (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent is unemployed and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
Out of workforce (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent is out of the workforce and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
Employed for self (0/1)
Dummy that takes the value 1 if the respondent is self-employed and 0 otherwise.
Gallup
Panel B: Country Characteristics
GDP per capita (ln)
Logarithm of GDP per capita in USD.
WDI
Licensed postal financial services
Dummy that takes the value 1 if post office has a post bank license (BM 5a, 5b or 5c) and 0 otherwise.
UPU
Unlicensed postal savings
Dummy that takes the value 1 if post office offers unlicensed postal savings (BM 4a) and 0 otherwise.
UPU
Partnership with a financial service provider
Dummy that takes the value 1 if post office partnership with financial services provider (BM 3c, 3d, 3e or 3f) and 0 otherwise.
UPU
CM for remittance service providers
Dummy that takes the value of 1 if the post office acts as a cash merchant for remittance service providers and 0 otherwise.
UPU
CM for government payments
Dummy that takes the value of 1 if the post office acts as a cash merchant for government payments and 0 otherwise.
UPU
Post branches as % total FI and post branches
Post branches as percentage of total number of post branches and financial institutions.
UPU, IMF FAS
Post branches per 1000 inhabitants
Post branches per 1000 inhabitants.
UPU, WDI