SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Abstract.....................................................................................2
Introduction - Background................................................................3
Problem Statement........................................................................4
Proposed Methodology ...................................................................6
Future direction & Long term focus....................................................7
Results & Conclusion .....................................................................8
References .................................................................................9
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 1 of 10
contents
Analyzing Chinese Stock Market Crash of 2015
Agile & Accountable Methodology
A U T H O R : J a i m i n P a r i k h
Abstract
CHINA is certainly not the first country to try to prop up a falling stock market. The central
banks of America, Europe and Japan have all shown form in buying shares after crashes and
cutting interest rates to cheer up bloodied investors. But the circumstances and the manner of
Chinese Governament intervention of the past Few days make it an outlier.
The trigger in China’s case is perplexing. Yes, the stock market is down a third over the past
month, but that has simply taken it back to March levels it is still up 80% over the last year.
Growth, though slowing has stabilized recently. Other asset markets are performing well.
Property long in the doldrums, is turning up. Money-market rates are low and steady, suggesting
calm in the banking sector. The anticipated correction of over-valued stocks hardly seems cause
for much anguish.
The Chinese government enacted many measures to stem the tide of the crash.
• Regulators capped short selling.
• Pension funds pledged to buy more stocks.
• The government suspended initial public offerings, limiting the supply of shares to drive
up the prices of those already listed.
• Brokers created a fund to buy shares, backed by central-bank cash.
• All the while, state media played cheerleader.
Far from saving the market from drowning, the succession of life inform of above strategies only
pushed it further under water.
• The CSI 300, an index of China’s biggest-listed companies, fell almost 10% over seven
trading days after the rate cut.
• ChiNext, an index of high-growth companies that is often described as China's Nasdaq,
fell by 25%.
And now that the global financial system is more interconnected than ever, what goes on over in
China has a greater impact on the rest of the globe than ever before. Today, China has the largest
economy on the planet on a purchasing power basis, and the Chinese stock market is the second
largest in the world in terms of market capitalization.
Theories have flourished about why the government has waded in so heavily. The apparent
desperation is, some believe, a sign that officials see a looming economic collapse, and are trying
to staunch the wound before social upheaval ensues. That story is intriguing.
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 2 of 10
Introduction - Background
China’s economy is slowing. More importantly, it is undertaking a rapid and strategic evolution
from a model based on high levels of credit and investment to one based more on consumer
spending and high-value services. As China watchers and global investors parse their data and
monitor the news, this might be an opportune time to address some prominent themes and adjust
a few misconceptions.
China’s growth has a profound impact on Asia and a significant effect on developed and
emerging markets around the world. The economic slowdown that is underway is entirely
appropriate as the world economy emerges from several years of crisis intervention, as the U.S.
recovery gathers steam and as Europe steadies itself in the wake of its sovereign debt issues.
The second largest stock market in the entire world is collapsing right in front of our eyes. Since
hitting a peak in June, the most important Chinese stock market index has plummeted by well
over 20 percent, and more than 3 trillion dollars of “paper wealth” has been wiped out. Of
course, the Shanghai Composite Index is still way above the level it was sitting at exactly one
year ago.
But what is so disturbing about this current crash is that it is so similar to what we witnessed just
prior to the great financial crisis of 2008 in the United States. From October 2006 to October
2007, the Shanghai Composite Index more than tripled in value. It was the greatest stock market
surge in Chinese history. But after hitting a peak, it began to fall dramatically. From October
2007 to October 2008, the Shanghai Composite Index absolutely crashed. In the end, more than
two-thirds of all wealth in the market was completely wiped out.
The amount of wealth that has been wiped out during this Chinese stock market crash is already
greater than the entire yearly GDP of Brazil.
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 3 of 10
Problem Statement
Chinese stock markets are in complete collapse right now, with the main Shanghai Composite
index losing 30% of its value in just the last three weeks. The turmoil is now starting to spread to
other Asian markets and global commodities markets.
The reason behind the crash is this: millions of ordinary Chinese citizens sunk borrowed cash
into shares, which inflated prices to unsustainable levels. When prices began to dip, these
investors were forcing to sell shares to pay back the borrowed money and cover losses. That
vicious circle of selling is going on right now and it’s creating “panic” and pushing down prices.
A huge amount of money has been put into Chinese stock markets over the past year or so by
regular Chinese people, something the government has encouraged. There are now 90 million
“retail” investors — ordinary people who own stocks — in China, making up 80% of all
shareholders. That means there are more stock market investors in China than there are
Communist Party members, Bloomberg noted recently.
The bubble grew and grew: price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios for Chinese stocks averaged an
astounding 70:1, against a worldwide average of 18.5:1. The value of the A-shares inside China
grew to be nearly double the equivalent shares of the same companies on the Hong Kong
exchange. Ordinary Chinese people had become so intoxicated by bull-market euphoria that
stories began to proliferate about people leaving their jobs, and even their families, to become
day traders, often using funds borrowed from high-interest rate “shadow banks” or loans taken
out against their homes. (By last weekend, margin borrowing on both exchanges had surpassed
$320bn, representing almost 10% of the total market capitalisation of all stocks being traded.)
The rush of money into Chinese stocks coincided with a surge in the benchmark Shanghai
Composite, which had risen over 150% since the start of the year when it peaked in June.
The main Shanghai Composite index has exploded since the start of the year. But the companies
whose share prices were rising weren’t actually getting any better — the prices were going up
simply because there was so much demand and people were bidding prices up.
The cracks began to show when shares in a few notable Chinese companies, such as “Hanergy”,
went into free fall earlier this year. That unleashed the biggest problem of all “Margin calls”.
Most of the retail investors who put money into shares weren’t using their own cash, but using
their money as collateral to borrow way more money than they had to invest. This is known as
“leveraged investing.”
Chinese brokerages went all-in on this — Credit Suisse estimated that the figure for borrowed
funds invested in the stock exchange reached between 4.4 trillion yuan (£460.1 billion,
$US708.3 billion INR 48 Trillion) to 5.9 trillion yuan (£617 billion, $US949.8 billion, INR 65
Trillion) before the pop. At the top end that’s 9% of the exchange’s entire worth.
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 4 of 10
But when prices went down, the brokerages that had advanced all this money asked investors to
put up more cash to cover the fall in value. Sophisticated investors would have the resources to
do this and the understanding to calculate whether it was worth the risk. But most retail
shareholders just sold the stock they’d already bought, using this cash to meet the fees.
That’s now creating the opposite problem to the one that inflated the market — a wealth of
sellers, pushing down prices.
The presence of so many first-time punters has contributed to market volatility. Retail investors
produce more than 80% of transactions in Chinese stocks, driving daily price swings. Moreover
young investors have been among the most aggressive in borrowing cash to buy stocks. They
have limited understanding of risks, which leads to excessive use of leverage.
Technically, it should be difficult for the young to use borrowed cash because of the high
minimum wealth threshold set by the government for margin financing. But online peer-to-peer
lending and smartphone apps have allowed investors to obtain loans with much lower amounts
of collateral. Belatedly, regulators have cracked down on these.
• Along with cutting the interest rate.
• Allowing the use of property as collateral for margin loans.
• Encouraging brokerage firms to buy stocks with cash from the People's Bank of China"
caused Chinese stocks to begin surging in mid-July.
After three stable weeks the Shanghai index fell again on 27 July by 8.5 percent, marking the
largest fall since 2007.
• The vast majority of companies listed in Shanghai, including many large state-owned
firms, fell by the maximum daily limit of 10%. Losses in Shanghai, and on the smaller
Shenzhen Composite index, accelerated into the close. Shenzhen, which is heavy on tech
stocks, closed down 7%.
• Industrial profit data released Monday indicate that factories in the world's second-largest
economy are losing momentum. Profits dropped 0.3% in June, compared to the same
period last year, Also an early measure of China's manufacturing activity for July came in
below analyst expectations. The reading was the lowest in 15 months.
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 5 of 10
Repeated efforts by the Chinese government to stem the losses have failed.
Proposed Methodology
The Chinese government enacted many measures to put a break on Market Slump.
1. Regulators limited short selling under threat of arrest, China Financial Futures Exchange
(CFFEX) suspends 19 accounts from short-selling for one month.
2. Large mutual funds and pension funds pledged to buy more stocks, China's top
brokerages pledged to collectively buy at least 120 billion yuan ($19.3 billion) of shares
to help steady the market, and would not sell holdings as long as the Shanghai Composite
Index remained below 4,500.
3. The government stopped initial public offerings, More than 28 companies suspended
their IPOs, there will be no new IPOs in the near term," the China Securities Regulatory
Commission (CSRC) said in a statement.
4. The government also provided cash to brokers to buy shares, backed by central-bank
cash. Because the Chinese markets are made up mostly of individuals and not
institutional funds.
5. The CSRC announces relaxation of rules on margin trading before market open, lowering
threshold for individual investors to trade on margins and expanding brokerages' funding
channels, 80 percent of investors in China are individuals, state-run media continued to
persuade its citizens to purchase more stocks.
6. China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) imposed a six-month ban on
stockholders owning more than 5 percent of a company's stock from selling those stocks,
resulting in a 6 percent rise in stock markets.
7. Around 1,300 total firms, representing 45 percent of the stock market, suspended the
trading of stocks starting on 8 July.
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 6 of 10
Future direction & Long term focus
China can ill afford this market failure. Its stock market has soared and crashed before, but
earlier booms were tied to a rising economy. This bubble took place in an economy that is losing
steam. China’s miracle years have played out, and the government faces a difficult transition to
the higher-value, more efficient and market-oriented economy needed to sustain the next phase
of development.
The country’s corporate and local government debt totals an extraordinary 280% of GDP, and
has been growing twice as fast as the economy for more than a decade. The property market is
depressed and overstocked, and confidence is fragile. China’s future depends on the party’s
capacity to make its state capitalist model leaner, greener and more efficient.
The road ahead is fraught with risk. Some challenges are now endemic: a demographic profile,
the result of the one-child policy, that gives China the world’s most rapidly ageing population;
poor and expensive education; unpaid bills for environmental damage and its health effects; and
the prospect of escalating climate impacts that will exacerbate an already acute water crisis and
failing crop yields.
China aims to export its over-capacity through grand infrastructure projects around the world,
but many of the proposed host countries are vulnerable to political and economic hazards. It is
betting on rising domestic consumption, but the consumers are getting old, and their children are
a squeezed generation with their own expenses to meet. It is betting on innovation, in a system
that does not support small risk-takers or the free exchange of ideas. And it is betting on the
internationalization of its currency ”Yuan”, and the opening of China’s financial systems to
global markets – but international investors and regulators may well be more cautious than a
month ago.
The immediate repercussions of the crash, in a week when Europe is preoccupied with Greece,
have largely played out inside China. But in a world that has come to rely on China to keep the
global economy ticking over, China’s risk is now everybody’s risk.
The current regime has turned its back on political reform, tightening internal security and
promoting a new insistence on socialist dogma. Ironically, China’s success will hinge on how
well it can play the next round of the capitalist game. After this week, the odds may have to be
adjusted.
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 7 of 10
Results & Conclusion
China may be somewhat out of step with the economic, social and political standards that have
come to prevail in most of the world today. And there is a certain disordered quality to a vast
nation composed of numerous ethnic groups, varying rates of economic development and a
substantial gap between an opaque and rigid central government and local authorities that each
pull in their own direction.
But to presume that China is losing control or that the present downshift in GDP growth is
unplanned would be wide of the mark. However one may feel about China’s reforms, they
cannot be described as haphazard.
China’s experimentation with market forces in financial services, with new approaches to law
and governance, are of a piece with other reforms going on in the social realm—notably in
education, where China is orienting its focus away from rote learning (useful in mass production)
and toward originality of thought (critical for service industries, technology and finance).
As China embarks on its next phase of economic development, we should perhaps be patient. We
should recall how far it has come, note the deliberate but transformational nature of its policy
shifts and remember that China always takes the long view— looking backward to history and
forward well into the future, when it will resemble slower-growing economic blocs such as
North America and Europe more than the developing markets from which it emerged.
Contemporary China seems nothing less than a civilization in transformation.
Stockmarket is that it still plays a surprisingly small role in China. The free-float value of
Chinese markets—the amount available for trading—is just about a third of GDP, compared with
more than 100% in developed economies. Less than 15% of household financial assets are
invested in the stockmarket: which is why soaring shares did little to boost consumption and
crashing prices will do little to hurt it. Many stocks were bought on debt, and the unwinding of
these loans helps explain why the government has been unable to stop the rout. But this
financing is not a systemic risk, it is just about 1.5% of total assets in the banking system.
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 8 of 10
Abbreviations and Acronyms
P/E Price To Earnings Ratio
GDP Gross Domestic Product
CSRC China Securities Regulatory Commission
CFFEX China Financial Futures Exchange
References
<Bibliography of resources and references>
The Economist Magazine The Guardian (UK)
Reuters NDTV Profit
David Stock Mans Corner The Wall Street Journel
The Intellihub Business Standard
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 9 of 10
About the author
About the author: Jaimin Parikh is an MBA in Finance & Did his
Bachelors in Finance & Econometrics From Somaiya College.
Also a Runner Up of IIM A – International Case Writing Masters in its
Annual Biz Fest “Confluence”.
Completed “Management Student Programme” From IIM Ahmedabad.
Has Worked with ING Vysya Bank Ltd.
Working in Standard Bank Enagagement as Business Analyst.
Loves Reading, Photography & Is a Travelling Enthusiast.
About L&T Infotech
Larsen & Toubro Infotech Ltd. (L&T Infotech), one of the fastest growing IT Services
companies, is ranked 5th globally among the Best IT Services Providers by Global Media
Services in 2009, ranked 11th by NASSCOM among the top software and services exporters
from India and also ranked among the ‘Leaders’ category in the prestigious Global 100 list
released by the International Association of Outsourcing Professionals (IAOP). A wholly-owned
subsidiary of USD 9.8 billion Larsen & Toubro, India’s largest technology-driven engineering
organization, L&T Infotech is differentiated by the unique Business-to-IT Connect, which is a
result of our rich corporate heritage.
We offer comprehensive, end-to-end software solutions and services in the following industry
verticals: Banking & Financial Services; Insurance; Energy & Petrochemicals; Manufacturing
(Consumer Packaged Goods, High-tech, Industrial Products, Automotive, Chemicals & Process,
Media & Entertainment, Pharma, Retail and Logistics); and Product Engineering Services
(Telecom).
We also deliver business solutions to our clients in the following Service Lines: SAP, Oracle,
Infrastructure Management Services, Testing and Consulting. Our other Service offerings are:
Business Analytics, Legacy Modernization, Applications Outsourcing, Architecture Consulting,
PLM, Service Oriented Architecture, end-to-end integrated engineering services and
embedded system solutions.
For more information, visit us at www.Lntinfotech.com or email us at info@Lntinfotech.com
Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 10 of 10

More Related Content

What's hot

To the Point, November 26 2009
To the Point, November 26 2009To the Point, November 26 2009
To the Point, November 26 2009
Swedbank
 
Gr report global_powers_of_retailing_2016
Gr report global_powers_of_retailing_2016Gr report global_powers_of_retailing_2016
Gr report global_powers_of_retailing_2016
Ethos Media S.A.
 
Gold Demand Trends Q3 2015
Gold Demand Trends Q3 2015Gold Demand Trends Q3 2015
Gold Demand Trends Q3 2015
World Gold Council
 
Market Outlook- 2019
Market Outlook- 2019Market Outlook- 2019
Market Outlook- 2019
Shreya Gulati
 
76 i chronicle
76 i chronicle76 i chronicle
Chinese economy Collapse and Yuan Devaluation
Chinese economy Collapse and Yuan DevaluationChinese economy Collapse and Yuan Devaluation
Chinese economy Collapse and Yuan Devaluation
Amol Patil
 
GDT Q3 2016
GDT Q3 2016GDT Q3 2016
GDT Q3 2016
World Gold Council
 
Thailand Blockchain Community Initiative
Thailand Blockchain Community InitiativeThailand Blockchain Community Initiative
Thailand Blockchain Community Initiative
Rein Mahatma
 
China Currency devaluation - International Business
China Currency devaluation - International BusinessChina Currency devaluation - International Business
China Currency devaluation - International Business
Suryakumar Thangarasu
 
May 2013 World Economic Situation and Prospects
May 2013 World Economic Situation and ProspectsMay 2013 World Economic Situation and Prospects
May 2013 World Economic Situation and Prospects
Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UN DESA)
 
GDT Full Fear 2015 Gold Demand Trends Report
GDT Full Fear 2015 Gold Demand Trends ReportGDT Full Fear 2015 Gold Demand Trends Report
GDT Full Fear 2015 Gold Demand Trends Report
World Gold Council
 
Focus on Russia (IBR 2013)
Focus on Russia (IBR 2013)Focus on Russia (IBR 2013)
Focus on Russia (IBR 2013)
Grant Thornton International Ltd
 
Gold Demand Trends Q2 2016 report
Gold Demand Trends Q2 2016 reportGold Demand Trends Q2 2016 report
Gold Demand Trends Q2 2016 report
World Gold Council
 
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital ltd
 
Essay Technique: Monetary and Supply-Side Policies
Essay Technique: Monetary and Supply-Side PoliciesEssay Technique: Monetary and Supply-Side Policies
Essay Technique: Monetary and Supply-Side Policies
tutor2u
 
Weekly Market Review - August 16, 2013
Weekly Market Review - August 16, 2013Weekly Market Review - August 16, 2013
Weekly Market Review - August 16, 2013
Franklin Templeton India
 
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
inventionjournals
 
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
David Bourla
 
15480187 (ECO3AWE)
15480187 (ECO3AWE)15480187 (ECO3AWE)
15480187 (ECO3AWE)
Paul Shoobridge
 
H1CY20 Investment Strategy Review
H1CY20 Investment Strategy ReviewH1CY20 Investment Strategy Review
H1CY20 Investment Strategy Review
Adroit Financial Services Pvt. Ltd.
 

What's hot (20)

To the Point, November 26 2009
To the Point, November 26 2009To the Point, November 26 2009
To the Point, November 26 2009
 
Gr report global_powers_of_retailing_2016
Gr report global_powers_of_retailing_2016Gr report global_powers_of_retailing_2016
Gr report global_powers_of_retailing_2016
 
Gold Demand Trends Q3 2015
Gold Demand Trends Q3 2015Gold Demand Trends Q3 2015
Gold Demand Trends Q3 2015
 
Market Outlook- 2019
Market Outlook- 2019Market Outlook- 2019
Market Outlook- 2019
 
76 i chronicle
76 i chronicle76 i chronicle
76 i chronicle
 
Chinese economy Collapse and Yuan Devaluation
Chinese economy Collapse and Yuan DevaluationChinese economy Collapse and Yuan Devaluation
Chinese economy Collapse and Yuan Devaluation
 
GDT Q3 2016
GDT Q3 2016GDT Q3 2016
GDT Q3 2016
 
Thailand Blockchain Community Initiative
Thailand Blockchain Community InitiativeThailand Blockchain Community Initiative
Thailand Blockchain Community Initiative
 
China Currency devaluation - International Business
China Currency devaluation - International BusinessChina Currency devaluation - International Business
China Currency devaluation - International Business
 
May 2013 World Economic Situation and Prospects
May 2013 World Economic Situation and ProspectsMay 2013 World Economic Situation and Prospects
May 2013 World Economic Situation and Prospects
 
GDT Full Fear 2015 Gold Demand Trends Report
GDT Full Fear 2015 Gold Demand Trends ReportGDT Full Fear 2015 Gold Demand Trends Report
GDT Full Fear 2015 Gold Demand Trends Report
 
Focus on Russia (IBR 2013)
Focus on Russia (IBR 2013)Focus on Russia (IBR 2013)
Focus on Russia (IBR 2013)
 
Gold Demand Trends Q2 2016 report
Gold Demand Trends Q2 2016 reportGold Demand Trends Q2 2016 report
Gold Demand Trends Q2 2016 report
 
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
 
Essay Technique: Monetary and Supply-Side Policies
Essay Technique: Monetary and Supply-Side PoliciesEssay Technique: Monetary and Supply-Side Policies
Essay Technique: Monetary and Supply-Side Policies
 
Weekly Market Review - August 16, 2013
Weekly Market Review - August 16, 2013Weekly Market Review - August 16, 2013
Weekly Market Review - August 16, 2013
 
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
 
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
 
15480187 (ECO3AWE)
15480187 (ECO3AWE)15480187 (ECO3AWE)
15480187 (ECO3AWE)
 
H1CY20 Investment Strategy Review
H1CY20 Investment Strategy ReviewH1CY20 Investment Strategy Review
H1CY20 Investment Strategy Review
 

Viewers also liked

The Causes of the Global Economic-cum-Financial Crisis_International Relation...
The Causes of the Global Economic-cum-Financial Crisis_International Relation...The Causes of the Global Economic-cum-Financial Crisis_International Relation...
The Causes of the Global Economic-cum-Financial Crisis_International Relation...
Cearet Sood
 
Rise of the chinese consumer
Rise of the chinese consumerRise of the chinese consumer
Rise of the chinese consumer
Cairns Local Marketing
 
Slowdown in Chinese Economy and its Impact on the World
Slowdown in Chinese Economy and its Impact on the WorldSlowdown in Chinese Economy and its Impact on the World
Slowdown in Chinese Economy and its Impact on the World
inamdaramaan
 
The chinese yuan Devaluation
The chinese yuan DevaluationThe chinese yuan Devaluation
The chinese yuan Devaluation
Shubham Mongia
 
Devaluation of Chinese currency ( Yuan) . A comprehensive case study.
Devaluation of Chinese currency ( Yuan) . A comprehensive case study. Devaluation of Chinese currency ( Yuan) . A comprehensive case study.
Devaluation of Chinese currency ( Yuan) . A comprehensive case study.
Rohit Banskota
 
Chinese Economic Slowdown
Chinese Economic SlowdownChinese Economic Slowdown
Chinese Economic Slowdown
Anurag Gupta
 
A project report on devaluation of chinese currency yuan
A  project report on devaluation of chinese currency yuanA  project report on devaluation of chinese currency yuan
A project report on devaluation of chinese currency yuan
Rohit Banskota
 
China economy
China economyChina economy
China economy
dev234dev
 

Viewers also liked (8)

The Causes of the Global Economic-cum-Financial Crisis_International Relation...
The Causes of the Global Economic-cum-Financial Crisis_International Relation...The Causes of the Global Economic-cum-Financial Crisis_International Relation...
The Causes of the Global Economic-cum-Financial Crisis_International Relation...
 
Rise of the chinese consumer
Rise of the chinese consumerRise of the chinese consumer
Rise of the chinese consumer
 
Slowdown in Chinese Economy and its Impact on the World
Slowdown in Chinese Economy and its Impact on the WorldSlowdown in Chinese Economy and its Impact on the World
Slowdown in Chinese Economy and its Impact on the World
 
The chinese yuan Devaluation
The chinese yuan DevaluationThe chinese yuan Devaluation
The chinese yuan Devaluation
 
Devaluation of Chinese currency ( Yuan) . A comprehensive case study.
Devaluation of Chinese currency ( Yuan) . A comprehensive case study. Devaluation of Chinese currency ( Yuan) . A comprehensive case study.
Devaluation of Chinese currency ( Yuan) . A comprehensive case study.
 
Chinese Economic Slowdown
Chinese Economic SlowdownChinese Economic Slowdown
Chinese Economic Slowdown
 
A project report on devaluation of chinese currency yuan
A  project report on devaluation of chinese currency yuanA  project report on devaluation of chinese currency yuan
A project report on devaluation of chinese currency yuan
 
China economy
China economyChina economy
China economy
 

Similar to Whitepaper_Analyzing Crash of Chinese Economy 2015

How much should we worry about the chinese stock market collapse
How much should we worry about the chinese stock market collapseHow much should we worry about the chinese stock market collapse
How much should we worry about the chinese stock market collapse
Amol Patil
 
china at the world stage
china at the world stagechina at the world stage
china at the world stage
Tarik Smajlovic
 
Oei feb-16
Oei feb-16Oei feb-16
Oei feb-16
Frank Ragol
 
The Long Term Investment Outlook for China
The Long Term Investment Outlook for ChinaThe Long Term Investment Outlook for China
The Long Term Investment Outlook for China
John M Olson, CLTC
 
What Really Ails China’s Economy
What Really Ails China’s EconomyWhat Really Ails China’s Economy
What Really Ails China’s Economy
Strategy&, a member of the PwC network
 
Feeding the Dragon - GMO
Feeding the Dragon - GMO Feeding the Dragon - GMO
Feeding the Dragon - GMO
ZEV Capital Research, LLC
 
Is the System of Shadow Banking in China a risk for the Chinese Financial Sys...
Is the System of Shadow Banking in China a risk for the Chinese Financial Sys...Is the System of Shadow Banking in China a risk for the Chinese Financial Sys...
Is the System of Shadow Banking in China a risk for the Chinese Financial Sys...
Oriol Caudevilla
 
Allocator November 2010
Allocator November 2010Allocator November 2010
Allocator November 2010
bruno_nautilus
 
TPL Dec 12 17
TPL Dec 12 17TPL Dec 12 17
TPL Dec 12 17
Abraham Gulkowitz
 
Oct2008
Oct2008Oct2008
Oct2008
Greg Meier
 
TKA_PEDC_li
TKA_PEDC_liTKA_PEDC_li
TKA_PEDC_li
Tim Alvner
 
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Rudy Belouad
 
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury GroupsDeloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Digitaluxe
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante
 
The Advisory_March2016
The Advisory_March2016The Advisory_March2016
The Advisory_March2016
Jim Tyson
 
The World This Week November 7 - November 11 - 2016
The World This Week November 7 - November 11 - 2016The World This Week November 7 - November 11 - 2016
The World This Week November 7 - November 11 - 2016
Karvy Private Wealth
 
The Pain of Reform and China's Economic Rebirth
The Pain of Reform and China's Economic RebirthThe Pain of Reform and China's Economic Rebirth
The Pain of Reform and China's Economic Rebirth
Tom Shaw
 
Explaining the Financial Crisis
Explaining the Financial CrisisExplaining the Financial Crisis
Explaining the Financial Crisis
Sal DB
 
China's Turbulent Economy, Summer of 2015
China's Turbulent Economy, Summer of 2015China's Turbulent Economy, Summer of 2015
China's Turbulent Economy, Summer of 2015
MyValueTrade
 
The Financial Crisis of 2015: An Avoidable History
The Financial Crisis of 2015: An Avoidable HistoryThe Financial Crisis of 2015: An Avoidable History
The Financial Crisis of 2015: An Avoidable History
Econ Matters
 

Similar to Whitepaper_Analyzing Crash of Chinese Economy 2015 (20)

How much should we worry about the chinese stock market collapse
How much should we worry about the chinese stock market collapseHow much should we worry about the chinese stock market collapse
How much should we worry about the chinese stock market collapse
 
china at the world stage
china at the world stagechina at the world stage
china at the world stage
 
Oei feb-16
Oei feb-16Oei feb-16
Oei feb-16
 
The Long Term Investment Outlook for China
The Long Term Investment Outlook for ChinaThe Long Term Investment Outlook for China
The Long Term Investment Outlook for China
 
What Really Ails China’s Economy
What Really Ails China’s EconomyWhat Really Ails China’s Economy
What Really Ails China’s Economy
 
Feeding the Dragon - GMO
Feeding the Dragon - GMO Feeding the Dragon - GMO
Feeding the Dragon - GMO
 
Is the System of Shadow Banking in China a risk for the Chinese Financial Sys...
Is the System of Shadow Banking in China a risk for the Chinese Financial Sys...Is the System of Shadow Banking in China a risk for the Chinese Financial Sys...
Is the System of Shadow Banking in China a risk for the Chinese Financial Sys...
 
Allocator November 2010
Allocator November 2010Allocator November 2010
Allocator November 2010
 
TPL Dec 12 17
TPL Dec 12 17TPL Dec 12 17
TPL Dec 12 17
 
Oct2008
Oct2008Oct2008
Oct2008
 
TKA_PEDC_li
TKA_PEDC_liTKA_PEDC_li
TKA_PEDC_li
 
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
 
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury GroupsDeloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
 
The Advisory_March2016
The Advisory_March2016The Advisory_March2016
The Advisory_March2016
 
The World This Week November 7 - November 11 - 2016
The World This Week November 7 - November 11 - 2016The World This Week November 7 - November 11 - 2016
The World This Week November 7 - November 11 - 2016
 
The Pain of Reform and China's Economic Rebirth
The Pain of Reform and China's Economic RebirthThe Pain of Reform and China's Economic Rebirth
The Pain of Reform and China's Economic Rebirth
 
Explaining the Financial Crisis
Explaining the Financial CrisisExplaining the Financial Crisis
Explaining the Financial Crisis
 
China's Turbulent Economy, Summer of 2015
China's Turbulent Economy, Summer of 2015China's Turbulent Economy, Summer of 2015
China's Turbulent Economy, Summer of 2015
 
The Financial Crisis of 2015: An Avoidable History
The Financial Crisis of 2015: An Avoidable HistoryThe Financial Crisis of 2015: An Avoidable History
The Financial Crisis of 2015: An Avoidable History
 

Whitepaper_Analyzing Crash of Chinese Economy 2015

  • 1. Abstract.....................................................................................2 Introduction - Background................................................................3 Problem Statement........................................................................4 Proposed Methodology ...................................................................6 Future direction & Long term focus....................................................7 Results & Conclusion .....................................................................8 References .................................................................................9 Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 1 of 10 contents Analyzing Chinese Stock Market Crash of 2015 Agile & Accountable Methodology A U T H O R : J a i m i n P a r i k h
  • 2. Abstract CHINA is certainly not the first country to try to prop up a falling stock market. The central banks of America, Europe and Japan have all shown form in buying shares after crashes and cutting interest rates to cheer up bloodied investors. But the circumstances and the manner of Chinese Governament intervention of the past Few days make it an outlier. The trigger in China’s case is perplexing. Yes, the stock market is down a third over the past month, but that has simply taken it back to March levels it is still up 80% over the last year. Growth, though slowing has stabilized recently. Other asset markets are performing well. Property long in the doldrums, is turning up. Money-market rates are low and steady, suggesting calm in the banking sector. The anticipated correction of over-valued stocks hardly seems cause for much anguish. The Chinese government enacted many measures to stem the tide of the crash. • Regulators capped short selling. • Pension funds pledged to buy more stocks. • The government suspended initial public offerings, limiting the supply of shares to drive up the prices of those already listed. • Brokers created a fund to buy shares, backed by central-bank cash. • All the while, state media played cheerleader. Far from saving the market from drowning, the succession of life inform of above strategies only pushed it further under water. • The CSI 300, an index of China’s biggest-listed companies, fell almost 10% over seven trading days after the rate cut. • ChiNext, an index of high-growth companies that is often described as China's Nasdaq, fell by 25%. And now that the global financial system is more interconnected than ever, what goes on over in China has a greater impact on the rest of the globe than ever before. Today, China has the largest economy on the planet on a purchasing power basis, and the Chinese stock market is the second largest in the world in terms of market capitalization. Theories have flourished about why the government has waded in so heavily. The apparent desperation is, some believe, a sign that officials see a looming economic collapse, and are trying to staunch the wound before social upheaval ensues. That story is intriguing. Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 2 of 10
  • 3. Introduction - Background China’s economy is slowing. More importantly, it is undertaking a rapid and strategic evolution from a model based on high levels of credit and investment to one based more on consumer spending and high-value services. As China watchers and global investors parse their data and monitor the news, this might be an opportune time to address some prominent themes and adjust a few misconceptions. China’s growth has a profound impact on Asia and a significant effect on developed and emerging markets around the world. The economic slowdown that is underway is entirely appropriate as the world economy emerges from several years of crisis intervention, as the U.S. recovery gathers steam and as Europe steadies itself in the wake of its sovereign debt issues. The second largest stock market in the entire world is collapsing right in front of our eyes. Since hitting a peak in June, the most important Chinese stock market index has plummeted by well over 20 percent, and more than 3 trillion dollars of “paper wealth” has been wiped out. Of course, the Shanghai Composite Index is still way above the level it was sitting at exactly one year ago. But what is so disturbing about this current crash is that it is so similar to what we witnessed just prior to the great financial crisis of 2008 in the United States. From October 2006 to October 2007, the Shanghai Composite Index more than tripled in value. It was the greatest stock market surge in Chinese history. But after hitting a peak, it began to fall dramatically. From October 2007 to October 2008, the Shanghai Composite Index absolutely crashed. In the end, more than two-thirds of all wealth in the market was completely wiped out. The amount of wealth that has been wiped out during this Chinese stock market crash is already greater than the entire yearly GDP of Brazil. Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 3 of 10
  • 4. Problem Statement Chinese stock markets are in complete collapse right now, with the main Shanghai Composite index losing 30% of its value in just the last three weeks. The turmoil is now starting to spread to other Asian markets and global commodities markets. The reason behind the crash is this: millions of ordinary Chinese citizens sunk borrowed cash into shares, which inflated prices to unsustainable levels. When prices began to dip, these investors were forcing to sell shares to pay back the borrowed money and cover losses. That vicious circle of selling is going on right now and it’s creating “panic” and pushing down prices. A huge amount of money has been put into Chinese stock markets over the past year or so by regular Chinese people, something the government has encouraged. There are now 90 million “retail” investors — ordinary people who own stocks — in China, making up 80% of all shareholders. That means there are more stock market investors in China than there are Communist Party members, Bloomberg noted recently. The bubble grew and grew: price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios for Chinese stocks averaged an astounding 70:1, against a worldwide average of 18.5:1. The value of the A-shares inside China grew to be nearly double the equivalent shares of the same companies on the Hong Kong exchange. Ordinary Chinese people had become so intoxicated by bull-market euphoria that stories began to proliferate about people leaving their jobs, and even their families, to become day traders, often using funds borrowed from high-interest rate “shadow banks” or loans taken out against their homes. (By last weekend, margin borrowing on both exchanges had surpassed $320bn, representing almost 10% of the total market capitalisation of all stocks being traded.) The rush of money into Chinese stocks coincided with a surge in the benchmark Shanghai Composite, which had risen over 150% since the start of the year when it peaked in June. The main Shanghai Composite index has exploded since the start of the year. But the companies whose share prices were rising weren’t actually getting any better — the prices were going up simply because there was so much demand and people were bidding prices up. The cracks began to show when shares in a few notable Chinese companies, such as “Hanergy”, went into free fall earlier this year. That unleashed the biggest problem of all “Margin calls”. Most of the retail investors who put money into shares weren’t using their own cash, but using their money as collateral to borrow way more money than they had to invest. This is known as “leveraged investing.” Chinese brokerages went all-in on this — Credit Suisse estimated that the figure for borrowed funds invested in the stock exchange reached between 4.4 trillion yuan (£460.1 billion, $US708.3 billion INR 48 Trillion) to 5.9 trillion yuan (£617 billion, $US949.8 billion, INR 65 Trillion) before the pop. At the top end that’s 9% of the exchange’s entire worth. Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 4 of 10
  • 5. But when prices went down, the brokerages that had advanced all this money asked investors to put up more cash to cover the fall in value. Sophisticated investors would have the resources to do this and the understanding to calculate whether it was worth the risk. But most retail shareholders just sold the stock they’d already bought, using this cash to meet the fees. That’s now creating the opposite problem to the one that inflated the market — a wealth of sellers, pushing down prices. The presence of so many first-time punters has contributed to market volatility. Retail investors produce more than 80% of transactions in Chinese stocks, driving daily price swings. Moreover young investors have been among the most aggressive in borrowing cash to buy stocks. They have limited understanding of risks, which leads to excessive use of leverage. Technically, it should be difficult for the young to use borrowed cash because of the high minimum wealth threshold set by the government for margin financing. But online peer-to-peer lending and smartphone apps have allowed investors to obtain loans with much lower amounts of collateral. Belatedly, regulators have cracked down on these. • Along with cutting the interest rate. • Allowing the use of property as collateral for margin loans. • Encouraging brokerage firms to buy stocks with cash from the People's Bank of China" caused Chinese stocks to begin surging in mid-July. After three stable weeks the Shanghai index fell again on 27 July by 8.5 percent, marking the largest fall since 2007. • The vast majority of companies listed in Shanghai, including many large state-owned firms, fell by the maximum daily limit of 10%. Losses in Shanghai, and on the smaller Shenzhen Composite index, accelerated into the close. Shenzhen, which is heavy on tech stocks, closed down 7%. • Industrial profit data released Monday indicate that factories in the world's second-largest economy are losing momentum. Profits dropped 0.3% in June, compared to the same period last year, Also an early measure of China's manufacturing activity for July came in below analyst expectations. The reading was the lowest in 15 months. Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 5 of 10
  • 6. Repeated efforts by the Chinese government to stem the losses have failed. Proposed Methodology The Chinese government enacted many measures to put a break on Market Slump. 1. Regulators limited short selling under threat of arrest, China Financial Futures Exchange (CFFEX) suspends 19 accounts from short-selling for one month. 2. Large mutual funds and pension funds pledged to buy more stocks, China's top brokerages pledged to collectively buy at least 120 billion yuan ($19.3 billion) of shares to help steady the market, and would not sell holdings as long as the Shanghai Composite Index remained below 4,500. 3. The government stopped initial public offerings, More than 28 companies suspended their IPOs, there will be no new IPOs in the near term," the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) said in a statement. 4. The government also provided cash to brokers to buy shares, backed by central-bank cash. Because the Chinese markets are made up mostly of individuals and not institutional funds. 5. The CSRC announces relaxation of rules on margin trading before market open, lowering threshold for individual investors to trade on margins and expanding brokerages' funding channels, 80 percent of investors in China are individuals, state-run media continued to persuade its citizens to purchase more stocks. 6. China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) imposed a six-month ban on stockholders owning more than 5 percent of a company's stock from selling those stocks, resulting in a 6 percent rise in stock markets. 7. Around 1,300 total firms, representing 45 percent of the stock market, suspended the trading of stocks starting on 8 July. Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 6 of 10
  • 7. Future direction & Long term focus China can ill afford this market failure. Its stock market has soared and crashed before, but earlier booms were tied to a rising economy. This bubble took place in an economy that is losing steam. China’s miracle years have played out, and the government faces a difficult transition to the higher-value, more efficient and market-oriented economy needed to sustain the next phase of development. The country’s corporate and local government debt totals an extraordinary 280% of GDP, and has been growing twice as fast as the economy for more than a decade. The property market is depressed and overstocked, and confidence is fragile. China’s future depends on the party’s capacity to make its state capitalist model leaner, greener and more efficient. The road ahead is fraught with risk. Some challenges are now endemic: a demographic profile, the result of the one-child policy, that gives China the world’s most rapidly ageing population; poor and expensive education; unpaid bills for environmental damage and its health effects; and the prospect of escalating climate impacts that will exacerbate an already acute water crisis and failing crop yields. China aims to export its over-capacity through grand infrastructure projects around the world, but many of the proposed host countries are vulnerable to political and economic hazards. It is betting on rising domestic consumption, but the consumers are getting old, and their children are a squeezed generation with their own expenses to meet. It is betting on innovation, in a system that does not support small risk-takers or the free exchange of ideas. And it is betting on the internationalization of its currency ”Yuan”, and the opening of China’s financial systems to global markets – but international investors and regulators may well be more cautious than a month ago. The immediate repercussions of the crash, in a week when Europe is preoccupied with Greece, have largely played out inside China. But in a world that has come to rely on China to keep the global economy ticking over, China’s risk is now everybody’s risk. The current regime has turned its back on political reform, tightening internal security and promoting a new insistence on socialist dogma. Ironically, China’s success will hinge on how well it can play the next round of the capitalist game. After this week, the odds may have to be adjusted. Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 7 of 10
  • 8. Results & Conclusion China may be somewhat out of step with the economic, social and political standards that have come to prevail in most of the world today. And there is a certain disordered quality to a vast nation composed of numerous ethnic groups, varying rates of economic development and a substantial gap between an opaque and rigid central government and local authorities that each pull in their own direction. But to presume that China is losing control or that the present downshift in GDP growth is unplanned would be wide of the mark. However one may feel about China’s reforms, they cannot be described as haphazard. China’s experimentation with market forces in financial services, with new approaches to law and governance, are of a piece with other reforms going on in the social realm—notably in education, where China is orienting its focus away from rote learning (useful in mass production) and toward originality of thought (critical for service industries, technology and finance). As China embarks on its next phase of economic development, we should perhaps be patient. We should recall how far it has come, note the deliberate but transformational nature of its policy shifts and remember that China always takes the long view— looking backward to history and forward well into the future, when it will resemble slower-growing economic blocs such as North America and Europe more than the developing markets from which it emerged. Contemporary China seems nothing less than a civilization in transformation. Stockmarket is that it still plays a surprisingly small role in China. The free-float value of Chinese markets—the amount available for trading—is just about a third of GDP, compared with more than 100% in developed economies. Less than 15% of household financial assets are invested in the stockmarket: which is why soaring shares did little to boost consumption and crashing prices will do little to hurt it. Many stocks were bought on debt, and the unwinding of these loans helps explain why the government has been unable to stop the rout. But this financing is not a systemic risk, it is just about 1.5% of total assets in the banking system. Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 8 of 10
  • 9. Abbreviations and Acronyms P/E Price To Earnings Ratio GDP Gross Domestic Product CSRC China Securities Regulatory Commission CFFEX China Financial Futures Exchange References <Bibliography of resources and references> The Economist Magazine The Guardian (UK) Reuters NDTV Profit David Stock Mans Corner The Wall Street Journel The Intellihub Business Standard Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 9 of 10
  • 10. About the author About the author: Jaimin Parikh is an MBA in Finance & Did his Bachelors in Finance & Econometrics From Somaiya College. Also a Runner Up of IIM A – International Case Writing Masters in its Annual Biz Fest “Confluence”. Completed “Management Student Programme” From IIM Ahmedabad. Has Worked with ING Vysya Bank Ltd. Working in Standard Bank Enagagement as Business Analyst. Loves Reading, Photography & Is a Travelling Enthusiast. About L&T Infotech Larsen & Toubro Infotech Ltd. (L&T Infotech), one of the fastest growing IT Services companies, is ranked 5th globally among the Best IT Services Providers by Global Media Services in 2009, ranked 11th by NASSCOM among the top software and services exporters from India and also ranked among the ‘Leaders’ category in the prestigious Global 100 list released by the International Association of Outsourcing Professionals (IAOP). A wholly-owned subsidiary of USD 9.8 billion Larsen & Toubro, India’s largest technology-driven engineering organization, L&T Infotech is differentiated by the unique Business-to-IT Connect, which is a result of our rich corporate heritage. We offer comprehensive, end-to-end software solutions and services in the following industry verticals: Banking & Financial Services; Insurance; Energy & Petrochemicals; Manufacturing (Consumer Packaged Goods, High-tech, Industrial Products, Automotive, Chemicals & Process, Media & Entertainment, Pharma, Retail and Logistics); and Product Engineering Services (Telecom). We also deliver business solutions to our clients in the following Service Lines: SAP, Oracle, Infrastructure Management Services, Testing and Consulting. Our other Service offerings are: Business Analytics, Legacy Modernization, Applications Outsourcing, Architecture Consulting, PLM, Service Oriented Architecture, end-to-end integrated engineering services and embedded system solutions. For more information, visit us at www.Lntinfotech.com or email us at info@Lntinfotech.com Chinese Stock Market Crash 2015 Page 10 of 10