Systems Planning & Programming
Asset Management Division
  “taking care of what we have”




        It’s a Journey.……
        Ahmad Jaber
        Systems Planning & Programming
                         WASHTO Annual Meeting
                         July 14, 2010
Today’s Presentation


    Overview
    Assets
      Pavements, Bridges, Culverts, MSE Walls
    Measures
      Condition, Trends
    GIS - Graphical Interface
Utah Facts



             • Population 2,800,000
             • Land Area: 84,900 sq
               miles (11th Largest
               State)
             • 1640 UDOT
               Employees
             • 5840 Miles (13% of
               State)
             • 16,250 Lane-Miles
The Challenge
UDOT Strategic Goals


   “The Final Four”

        Take Care of What We Have

        Make the System Work Better

        Improve Safety

        Increase Capacity
Pavement Preservation “Good Roads Cost Less”
UDOT Study Published in 1977
”Bad Roads Cost More”


    Very
    Good




                                     Driving On
     Condition




                                       Lower
                                      Quality
                                       Roads



    Very         5   10    15   20   25    30
    Poor
                          Age
7 Steps to Asset Management Implementation



       1.   Inventory
       2.   Condition Assessment
       3.   Targets
       4.   Deterioration Curves
       5.   Maintenance Strategies
       6.   Cross Asset Optimization
       7.   Projects
Culvert Inventory

  • Inventory is the First Step in Asset Management
MSE Walls


• Inventory Completed
• Condition Determined
• Next Phase
   – Establishment of Targets
   – Integrate with
     Department’s Asset
     Optimization Database
Bridge


 • Inventory Completed
   Every Two Years
 • Condition Assessment
   Determined at Element
   Level
UDOT Strategic Goals


                       • Pavements that are in
                         good condition today
                         can be maintained by
                         an appropriate mix of
                         maintenance and
                         preservation treatments
                         that will maximize the
                         system Overall Condition
                         Index (OCI) and prolong
                         the pavement life.
Construction Cost Index
Pavement System Health

                                                  Statewide Pavement Condition
                                                          % of miles Fair or Better
               100%
               90%
               80%
               70%
  % of Miles




               60%
               50%
               40%
               30%
               20%
               10%
                0%
                  2000         2001        2002        2003     2004     2005    2006        2007   2008   2009
                                                                    Year
           based on "Half Car" IRI and Historical Ride Index                    Interstate      Arterial   Collector
Maintenance Management Levels

                      Interstate
                           Regardless of AADT
                           Miles ~ 935, 16%
                           Lane Miles ~ 27%
                           VMT ~ 53%
                           Combo Truck VMT ~ 63%

                      Level 1
                           AADT > 2,000 and/or Truck Volumes > 500
                           Miles ~ 2,150, 37%
                           Lane Miles ~ 43%
                           VMT ~ 43%
                           Combo Truck VMT ~ 32%

                      Level 2
                           AADT < 2,000
                           Miles ~ 2,750, 47%
                           Lane Miles ~ 36%
                           VMT ~ 4%
                           Combo Truck VMT ~ 5%
Total Funding Needs


                                                                2011          2014

                          Interstate & Level 1 Preventative
                                     Maintenance                 79            60
                          Interstate & Level 1 Major Rehab.
        Pavement                                              Programmed      180
                                 And Reconstruction

                                Level 2 Maintenance               16           18
                             Preventative Maintenance            25            28
          Bridge
                             Rehab. And Reconstruction        Programmed       58
                                                                       32.5          182
     Total Funding
        Needs                                                    120          344
      (Millions of $’s)


    Red = Needs
    Blue = Estimate of Total Available Funds
Diminishing Marginal Returns

                                                                                                Interstate System OCI
                                                                                              (1,875 miles 2009 OCI = 89)
                                  95
        Overall Condition Index




                                  90

                                  85

                                  80

                                  75

                                  70

                                  65
                                       2010

                                              2011

                                                     2012

                                                            2013

                                                                   2014

                                                                          2015

                                                                                 2016

                                                                                         2017

                                                                                                 2018

                                                                                                        2019

                                                                                                               2020

                                                                                                                       2021

                                                                                                                              2022

                                                                                                                                      2023

                                                                                                                                             2024

                                                                                                                                                         2025

                                                                                                                                                                2026

                                                                                                                                                                        2027

                                                                                                                                                                               2028

                                                                                                                                                                                       2029

                                                                                                                                                                                              2030
                                                                                        Average Annual Funding (millions)
                                                10           20           30             40             50            60             70             80             90            100




  The level of funding to obtain the optimal condition level (point of diminishing marginal
   return) was found to be $60 Million for the Interstate (increasing to $80 million), $50
  million for the Level 1 NHS, $60 Million for the Level 1 non-NHS, and $90 million for the
                  Level 2 system, for a total of $260 to $280 Million per year.
UPlan – UDOT’s GIS Graphical Interface
Northern Utah

                Pan/Min/Max View
                  Road View


                Identification


     Folders
Salt Lake Area – I-215 Belt Route




 I-215
Pavement Condition




 I-215
I-215 Pavement Condition Values
Pavement Rehab Projects
I-215 Pavement Rehab Project
I-215 Long Range Plan
Thank You!

Utah Transportation Systems Planning

  • 1.
    Systems Planning &Programming Asset Management Division “taking care of what we have” It’s a Journey.…… Ahmad Jaber Systems Planning & Programming WASHTO Annual Meeting July 14, 2010
  • 2.
    Today’s Presentation  Overview  Assets  Pavements, Bridges, Culverts, MSE Walls  Measures  Condition, Trends  GIS - Graphical Interface
  • 3.
    Utah Facts • Population 2,800,000 • Land Area: 84,900 sq miles (11th Largest State) • 1640 UDOT Employees • 5840 Miles (13% of State) • 16,250 Lane-Miles
  • 4.
  • 5.
    UDOT Strategic Goals “The Final Four”  Take Care of What We Have  Make the System Work Better  Improve Safety  Increase Capacity
  • 6.
    Pavement Preservation “GoodRoads Cost Less” UDOT Study Published in 1977
  • 7.
    ”Bad Roads CostMore” Very Good Driving On Condition Lower Quality Roads Very 5 10 15 20 25 30 Poor Age
  • 8.
    7 Steps toAsset Management Implementation 1. Inventory 2. Condition Assessment 3. Targets 4. Deterioration Curves 5. Maintenance Strategies 6. Cross Asset Optimization 7. Projects
  • 9.
    Culvert Inventory • Inventory is the First Step in Asset Management
  • 10.
    MSE Walls • InventoryCompleted • Condition Determined • Next Phase – Establishment of Targets – Integrate with Department’s Asset Optimization Database
  • 11.
    Bridge • InventoryCompleted Every Two Years • Condition Assessment Determined at Element Level
  • 12.
    UDOT Strategic Goals • Pavements that are in good condition today can be maintained by an appropriate mix of maintenance and preservation treatments that will maximize the system Overall Condition Index (OCI) and prolong the pavement life.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Pavement System Health Statewide Pavement Condition % of miles Fair or Better 100% 90% 80% 70% % of Miles 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Year based on "Half Car" IRI and Historical Ride Index Interstate Arterial Collector
  • 15.
    Maintenance Management Levels Interstate Regardless of AADT Miles ~ 935, 16% Lane Miles ~ 27% VMT ~ 53% Combo Truck VMT ~ 63% Level 1 AADT > 2,000 and/or Truck Volumes > 500 Miles ~ 2,150, 37% Lane Miles ~ 43% VMT ~ 43% Combo Truck VMT ~ 32% Level 2 AADT < 2,000 Miles ~ 2,750, 47% Lane Miles ~ 36% VMT ~ 4% Combo Truck VMT ~ 5%
  • 16.
    Total Funding Needs 2011 2014 Interstate & Level 1 Preventative Maintenance 79 60 Interstate & Level 1 Major Rehab. Pavement Programmed 180 And Reconstruction Level 2 Maintenance 16 18 Preventative Maintenance 25 28 Bridge Rehab. And Reconstruction Programmed 58 32.5 182 Total Funding Needs 120 344 (Millions of $’s) Red = Needs Blue = Estimate of Total Available Funds
  • 17.
    Diminishing Marginal Returns Interstate System OCI (1,875 miles 2009 OCI = 89) 95 Overall Condition Index 90 85 80 75 70 65 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Average Annual Funding (millions) 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 The level of funding to obtain the optimal condition level (point of diminishing marginal return) was found to be $60 Million for the Interstate (increasing to $80 million), $50 million for the Level 1 NHS, $60 Million for the Level 1 non-NHS, and $90 million for the Level 2 system, for a total of $260 to $280 Million per year.
  • 18.
    UPlan – UDOT’sGIS Graphical Interface
  • 19.
    Northern Utah Pan/Min/Max View Road View Identification Folders
  • 20.
    Salt Lake Area– I-215 Belt Route I-215
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.