This document summarizes a symposium discussing changes in the Middle East one year after the Arab Spring uprisings. It includes presentations from experts on Palestine, Egypt, Yemen, Bahrain, Syria, and Libya. The speakers discussed the ongoing political transitions, challenges faced, and prospects for democracy in each country. Key points included the failure of the uprisings to bring democratic change in Yemen, repression by Saudi Arabia of protests, and the ongoing civil war and stalemate in Syria between the Assad regime and opposition groups.
The document summarizes lessons learned from efforts to support democracy in Afghanistan and Iraq over the past decade. It discusses the challenges of nation-building, state-building, demobilizing militias, and economic development that have accompanied democracy promotion. Key lessons highlighted include the importance of political agreements among groups in the post-conflict period, establishing stable constitutional and governmental institutions, developing an effective electoral system and political parties, and fostering leaders committed to national rather than sectarian interests.
The document provides historical context on the Arab Spring and its impacts on Egypt. It discusses Egypt's history from the end of the medieval period through Ottoman rule. The Arab Spring began in 2010 in Tunisia and spread through the Middle East and North Africa, toppling authoritarian leaders in Egypt, Libya, Yemen and elsewhere. While some saw it as a movement towards democratization, it ultimately led to political instability and turmoil in Egypt. The military seized power in Egypt which was initially accepted by protesters but later solidified authoritarian rule again under President Sisi. The uprising had significant political and security impacts on Egypt and the region.
The Jordanian state is believed to be on the brink of failure. Many structural tensions has been escalating over the years; thus, weakening the state, making it more vulnerable, and pushing it closer towards the breakout of a crisis. The purpose of this essay is to examine early warning conflict signs present in Jordan. The paper alerts that the escalation of tensions in Jordan leaves it standing on its final threshold before the outbreak of a conflict. This paper aims to encourage policy makers in Jordan to try finding solutions and policies to contain these tensions and prevent the expected eruption of a crisis.
This document discusses the evolution of Turkish democracy and the potential relevance of the Turkish model for democratization in the Arab world. It outlines Turkey's transition from an authoritarian single-party system under Ataturk to a more democratic multi-party system over subsequent decades. Though Turkey's democracy is still imperfect with issues like human rights abuses and military influence, the rise of the AKP party improved reforms and alignment with Western institutions. However, the document argues Turkey's experience cannot be directly replicated in the Arab world due to different historical, economic, and geopolitical conditions that have consolidated authoritarianism. While Turkey provides an example for Arab liberals, its democratic development was unique to the Turkish context.
This document is a thesis submitted by Hillary Crawford to the Department of Political Science at the University of Michigan in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Arts degree. The thesis examines how state-owned and independent newspapers in Egypt portrayed the Muslim Brotherhood during and after Mohamed Morsi's presidency from 2012-2013. Crawford analyzes 120 newspaper articles from Al-Ahram, a state-owned paper, and Egypt Independent, an independent paper. The articles are scored based on their negativity towards the Brotherhood's security, political and cultural values. Crawford hypothesizes that the character of the newspaper and the time period will impact the level of negativity displayed. The findings aim to distinguish differences in how state-
The document discusses whether the Khilafah system is totalitarian like Nazi Germany or other regimes. It analyzes the Khilafah based on six features of totalitarianism: 1) an official ideology, 2) a single mass party, 3) monopolistic control of armed forces, 4) monopoly on mass communication, 5) system of terrorist police control, and 6) central control of the economy. The document finds that while the Khilafah has an Islamic ideology, it does not force non-Muslims to convert or adopt Islamic values, and it allows for diversity of Islamic schools of thought.
This document summarizes a paper about women's rights in Tunisia and Egypt following the Arab Spring uprisings. [1] It discusses how women played a prominent role in the revolutions but face uncertainty about maintaining rights in the new governments. [2] Tunisia has made more progress, electing a president committed to women's rights and gender equality, though full representation is still uncertain. [3] Egypt has seen less progress for women's rights, with Islamic parties seeking to limit women's roles and no women involved in rewriting the constitution.
Benson ivor iran some angles on the islamic revolution - the journal of his...RareBooksnRecords
The document summarizes the Islamic Revolution in Iran in three key points:
1. The revolution showed that religion can be a more powerful motivator for mass political action than secular ideologies.
2. It challenged Western cultural dominance by providing an alternative social model and way of life.
3. The revolution was one of the most important events in modern history, comparable to the French and Russian Revolutions.
The document then explores the causes and implications of the revolution in more depth, focusing on how imperialism and colonialism threatened Islam in Iran and mobilized a hardened form of Shi'ite Islam to challenge foreign influence.
The document summarizes lessons learned from efforts to support democracy in Afghanistan and Iraq over the past decade. It discusses the challenges of nation-building, state-building, demobilizing militias, and economic development that have accompanied democracy promotion. Key lessons highlighted include the importance of political agreements among groups in the post-conflict period, establishing stable constitutional and governmental institutions, developing an effective electoral system and political parties, and fostering leaders committed to national rather than sectarian interests.
The document provides historical context on the Arab Spring and its impacts on Egypt. It discusses Egypt's history from the end of the medieval period through Ottoman rule. The Arab Spring began in 2010 in Tunisia and spread through the Middle East and North Africa, toppling authoritarian leaders in Egypt, Libya, Yemen and elsewhere. While some saw it as a movement towards democratization, it ultimately led to political instability and turmoil in Egypt. The military seized power in Egypt which was initially accepted by protesters but later solidified authoritarian rule again under President Sisi. The uprising had significant political and security impacts on Egypt and the region.
The Jordanian state is believed to be on the brink of failure. Many structural tensions has been escalating over the years; thus, weakening the state, making it more vulnerable, and pushing it closer towards the breakout of a crisis. The purpose of this essay is to examine early warning conflict signs present in Jordan. The paper alerts that the escalation of tensions in Jordan leaves it standing on its final threshold before the outbreak of a conflict. This paper aims to encourage policy makers in Jordan to try finding solutions and policies to contain these tensions and prevent the expected eruption of a crisis.
This document discusses the evolution of Turkish democracy and the potential relevance of the Turkish model for democratization in the Arab world. It outlines Turkey's transition from an authoritarian single-party system under Ataturk to a more democratic multi-party system over subsequent decades. Though Turkey's democracy is still imperfect with issues like human rights abuses and military influence, the rise of the AKP party improved reforms and alignment with Western institutions. However, the document argues Turkey's experience cannot be directly replicated in the Arab world due to different historical, economic, and geopolitical conditions that have consolidated authoritarianism. While Turkey provides an example for Arab liberals, its democratic development was unique to the Turkish context.
This document is a thesis submitted by Hillary Crawford to the Department of Political Science at the University of Michigan in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Bachelor of Arts degree. The thesis examines how state-owned and independent newspapers in Egypt portrayed the Muslim Brotherhood during and after Mohamed Morsi's presidency from 2012-2013. Crawford analyzes 120 newspaper articles from Al-Ahram, a state-owned paper, and Egypt Independent, an independent paper. The articles are scored based on their negativity towards the Brotherhood's security, political and cultural values. Crawford hypothesizes that the character of the newspaper and the time period will impact the level of negativity displayed. The findings aim to distinguish differences in how state-
The document discusses whether the Khilafah system is totalitarian like Nazi Germany or other regimes. It analyzes the Khilafah based on six features of totalitarianism: 1) an official ideology, 2) a single mass party, 3) monopolistic control of armed forces, 4) monopoly on mass communication, 5) system of terrorist police control, and 6) central control of the economy. The document finds that while the Khilafah has an Islamic ideology, it does not force non-Muslims to convert or adopt Islamic values, and it allows for diversity of Islamic schools of thought.
This document summarizes a paper about women's rights in Tunisia and Egypt following the Arab Spring uprisings. [1] It discusses how women played a prominent role in the revolutions but face uncertainty about maintaining rights in the new governments. [2] Tunisia has made more progress, electing a president committed to women's rights and gender equality, though full representation is still uncertain. [3] Egypt has seen less progress for women's rights, with Islamic parties seeking to limit women's roles and no women involved in rewriting the constitution.
Benson ivor iran some angles on the islamic revolution - the journal of his...RareBooksnRecords
The document summarizes the Islamic Revolution in Iran in three key points:
1. The revolution showed that religion can be a more powerful motivator for mass political action than secular ideologies.
2. It challenged Western cultural dominance by providing an alternative social model and way of life.
3. The revolution was one of the most important events in modern history, comparable to the French and Russian Revolutions.
The document then explores the causes and implications of the revolution in more depth, focusing on how imperialism and colonialism threatened Islam in Iran and mobilized a hardened form of Shi'ite Islam to challenge foreign influence.
HOW THE 1988 SEOUL OLYMPICS CATALYZED DEMOCRACY- THE SOUTH KOREAN EXAMPLE by ...Kevin Kane
The 1988 Seoul Olympics were expected to provide significant economic and political benefits to South Korea. The South Korean government hoped the Olympics would spur economic growth as had occurred in Japan after the 1964 Tokyo Olympics. South Korea anticipated profits of 50 billion won from hosting as well as Olympics-related projects accounting for 0.4% of South Korea's GNP from 1982-1988. Politically, South Korea saw the Olympics as an opportunity to gain international business connections, security recognition, and national pride through hosting a successful global event. However, widespread protests threatened South Korea's ability to successfully host the Olympics.
This document provides an overview of press censorship in Israel. It discusses the shaky legal status of press freedom in Israel as the country lacks a written constitution. While Israeli courts have traditionally protected freedom of speech and press, Israeli law contains restrictions from the British Mandate era intended to oppress local media. The document traces how freedom of the press was not included in Israel's Declaration of Independence despite a suggestion to do so. It outlines the 1953 Kol Ha'am ruling where the court established balance between national security and press freedom, setting early foundations for these issues in Israeli law and democracy.
Fragility and-resilience Relation Sandro Suzart SUZART GOOGLE INC Unit...Sandro Suzart
relationship between Sandro Suzart SUZART GOOGLE INC and United States on Demonstrations 2013 and Impeachments of 22 governments Relation, Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, United States on Demonstrations countries IMPEACHMENT GOOGLE INC
Abstract: The Central African Republic like the heart World, through the vicissitudes given its geographical position. Its accession in 1960 to the Maoist movement has been consolidated by the China-Africa Forum held in October 2000 in Beijing. It is in this perspective that President François Bozize, September 10, 2009, appealed to his Chinese counterpart Hu Jintao to invest in his country. Which marks the presence of China at the head of the CAR in the peace process and economic rehabilitation. But many development projects have been suspended for the seizure of power by the Seleka coalition March 24, 2013. However, CAR continues to rely on the strategic actions of China in the field of new technology for its agro-pastoral development to food self-sufficiency.
Arab Uprisings and the Outstanding Return to Democracy: Tunisia as a Modelinventionjournals
In the wake of the Middle Eastern crises, the Tunisian case in focus has been doted as a unique
phenomenon being that it was the Genesis of the revolution that ultimately spread across the Middle East like
wild fire, but has eventually heralded a new dawn as democracy has incidentally returned to the Empire. This
literature therefore looks closely at the extent to which the ‘DignityRevolution’ has been instrumental in the
Middle East uprisings, which have brought an end to dynastic autocracies. The literature zeros in on the
Tunisian uprising which has attracted global concerns, sympathy and has sparked interests in the international
arena. The literature finds that the people hold colossal prospect in the uprising and its resultant effect, as it
paved the way for the revolutionist to generate, gather and disseminate information on the condition of the
entire region to the international community. The people in this context were of utmost importance and played a
very crucial role in the creation of awareness, mobilization of protesters and utmost determining the direction of
the uprising and also ensuring a speedy return to democratic rule. The paper submits that the role of the people
in ensuring that the ruins of the uprising is not left littering around and democracy restored is highly
commendable and should be a model for all other Arab countries involved in the revolution.
This document is a thesis submitted for a Master's degree in Global Affairs. It provides an overview of the key topics that will be examined in the thesis, including: ethnic identity and challenges to central governance in Afghanistan; the rise of the communist government and impact on the country; the Taliban's insurgency tactics and justice systems; and potential means of accountability for the Taliban going forward. The acknowledgements section thanks advisors and fellow students who provided support. An introduction outlines some of the uncertainty currently facing Afghanistan and how that has contributed to the Taliban's ongoing threat.
The frequency of the occurrence of terrorist acts such as Istanbul on June 28 near past and violence in general and those who continually take place in Brazil mean the victory of barbarism over civilization. Civilization is considered the most advanced stage of a given human society. The term barbarism has two distinct meanings, but linked: lack of civilization and barbaric cruelty. Barbarism means a break with the moral standards that regulate life in society and the traditional social controls gave way to unbridled violence and contempt for the human being. The great challenge of the contemporary era is to make mankind evolve from the barbarism to civilization.
The document discusses the June 30, 2013 revolution in Egypt which corrected the course of the 2011 revolution and prevented the Muslim Brotherhood from gaining power. It describes the Muslim Brotherhood as representing corrupt capitalist forces and posing a threat to Egypt by conspiring with foreign powers like the US, Qatar, and Turkey. It also discusses how the Muslim Brotherhood pursued a sectarian agenda in Egypt that attacked Coptic Christians and Shi'a Muslims. The June 30 revolution succeeded due to widespread public opposition to the Muslim Brotherhood through the Tamarrod petition campaign and mass protests of over 30 million people. The revolution aims to complete Egypt's unfinished democratic transformation and establish a democratic civil state with economic independence, social justice, and separation of religion
Gregory MacKenzie, "North Korea Must Account for Its Treatment of Political Prisoners," ASIA LAW NEWS (Oct 2013). Published in the ABA Section of International Law Asia/Pacific Committee Asia Law News, October 2012.
This document is an introduction to a dissertation investigating how Israeli citizenship constructs women's place in society as mothers. It begins by defining citizenship as consisting of three pillars - participation, rights, and identity. It then discusses how citizenship has traditionally been a masculine concept focused on military service and exclusion of women. The introduction explores the public/private divide and its gendering effects. It previews how the dissertation will analyze how Israel's republican citizenship model, religious influences, and emphasis on military service have crafted women's role as fulfilling their duty through motherhood rather than equal citizenship. The introduction establishes the theoretical framework that will be used to examine how Israeli citizenship discriminates against women.
Political Unrests and Agitational Politics of Decolonization in Eastern Nigeriainventionjournals
The title of this paper is Political Unrests, and Agitational Politics Unrests of decolonization in Eastern Nigeria. The study is aimed at asserting the view of the liberal nationalist school of thought which is conjectured that sometimes internal dissent and colonial unrest may result in a revolution that hastens the independence of a colony. The position of the liberal nationalist tradition which has been adopted in this paper puts the indigenous people at the centre of decolonization from a reluctant metropolitan power as opposed to the dependentista school of thought.
Octopus and Midget in the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process: Who Determines W...AJSSMTJournal
The document discusses various proposed solutions to the long-standing Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including a two-state solution, one-state solution, and no-state solution. It analyzes the opportunities and challenges of each approach, with a focus on the two-state solution and one-state solution. The document provides background on the conflict and outlines four trajectories that have been proposed to resolve it: the no-state solution, one-state solution, two-state solution, and three-state solution. It then analyzes the two-state solution in more depth.
The document summarizes the situation in Syria as of August 2011, during widespread protests against President Bashar al-Assad's regime. It notes that millions of Syrians have taken to the streets since March 2011 to peacefully demand democratic reforms, in response to which the Assad regime has violently cracked down, killing over 2,200 civilians. While the regime claims the protests are led by foreign infiltrators and religious extremists, the document asserts that the opposition movement represents all parts of Syrian society and its goals are democratic change, not violence or sectarianism. It maintains the regime has lost legitimacy and its fall is inevitable, though it will continue killing people in its death throes.
The document summarizes the history and identity of the Uyghur ethnic group in China's Xinjiang region. It discusses how Uyghur identity has been shaped by geography, religion, and political influences over time. In recent decades, China has suppressed Uyghur cultural expression and aspirations for autonomy, while portraying Uyghurs as terrorists after 9/11. This has exacerbated tensions in the region.
The document provides an analysis of Egypt's 2011-2012 parliamentary elections following the 2011 revolution. It summarizes that:
1) The elections deepened the revolution by further unleashing social and political changes across Egypt as voters from all perspectives showed sophistication in using their newfound political power.
2) The Muslim Brotherhood's Freedom and Justice Party (FJP) dominated nationally, while the Salafist Nur Party enjoyed strong regional support. Major parties were united in opposition to Nur and remnants of the former ruling party.
3) The FJP was highly successful in individual district races, winning around 80% of contests, especially against secular parties and Nur which it defeated in around three-fourths of their
Incitement against Israel, which frequently turns into genuine anti-Semitic incitement, is an inseparable part of the fabric of life in the Palestinian Authority.
M.A. Labor Studies thesis: US Immigration Law, The Evolution of Ethnic Econom...Stephen Cheng
This document summarizes how changes in US immigration law influenced the development of ethnic economies and immigrant communities. It discusses two key laws: the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965, which ended preferences for European immigrants and increased Asian immigration, contributing to the growth of communities like Chinatown; and the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986, which granted amnesty to undocumented immigrants, reinforcing existing migration networks of Mexican immigrants. The document also provides historical context on 19th and early 20th century immigration policies that restricted Asian immigration, and how public opinion shifted after World War 2, leading to the passage of the 1965 Immigration Act.
1) The document discusses two books related to the Arab-Israeli conflict and prospects for peace. It summarizes their key arguments and conclusions.
2) One book argues that democracies are less likely to go to war with each other, but questions whether Israel can remain a democracy under continual security threats. It concludes democracy may slowly come to the Middle East.
3) The other book provides a sober examination of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) and argues that while it failed to achieve its ultimate goal of destroying Israel, its willingness to accept diplomacy and compromise provides opportunities to resolve issues with Israel.
This document summarizes the perspectives of an Iranian feminist collective, Raha, on building solidarity with popular uprisings in Iran and the Middle East, while opposing foreign military intervention. It argues that the anti-war movement should stand in solidarity with struggles for self-determination and against state repression in Iran by recognizing the humanity and agency of the Iranian people. It critiques refusing to take a position on internal affairs in Iran as hypocritical and disconnecting the movement from social justice. The document advocates building grassroots cross-border solidarity instead of looking to governments or NGOs to support human rights.
1. The conflict in Egypt has its roots in decades of authoritarian rule under Hosni Mubarak and the popular uprisings of the Arab Spring in 2011 that led to his removal.
2. This sparked a power struggle between former president Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood, liberal and secular groups, and the military, leading to Morsi's ouster by the military in 2013.
3. The situation can be analyzed through realism, liberalism, and social constructivism lenses, with social constructivism emphasizing how new communication technologies and the spread of ideas influenced identities and political change in Egypt.
HOW THE 1988 SEOUL OLYMPICS CATALYZED DEMOCRACY- THE SOUTH KOREAN EXAMPLE by ...Kevin Kane
The 1988 Seoul Olympics were expected to provide significant economic and political benefits to South Korea. The South Korean government hoped the Olympics would spur economic growth as had occurred in Japan after the 1964 Tokyo Olympics. South Korea anticipated profits of 50 billion won from hosting as well as Olympics-related projects accounting for 0.4% of South Korea's GNP from 1982-1988. Politically, South Korea saw the Olympics as an opportunity to gain international business connections, security recognition, and national pride through hosting a successful global event. However, widespread protests threatened South Korea's ability to successfully host the Olympics.
This document provides an overview of press censorship in Israel. It discusses the shaky legal status of press freedom in Israel as the country lacks a written constitution. While Israeli courts have traditionally protected freedom of speech and press, Israeli law contains restrictions from the British Mandate era intended to oppress local media. The document traces how freedom of the press was not included in Israel's Declaration of Independence despite a suggestion to do so. It outlines the 1953 Kol Ha'am ruling where the court established balance between national security and press freedom, setting early foundations for these issues in Israeli law and democracy.
Fragility and-resilience Relation Sandro Suzart SUZART GOOGLE INC Unit...Sandro Suzart
relationship between Sandro Suzart SUZART GOOGLE INC and United States on Demonstrations 2013 and Impeachments of 22 governments Relation, Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, United States on Demonstrations countries IMPEACHMENT GOOGLE INC
Abstract: The Central African Republic like the heart World, through the vicissitudes given its geographical position. Its accession in 1960 to the Maoist movement has been consolidated by the China-Africa Forum held in October 2000 in Beijing. It is in this perspective that President François Bozize, September 10, 2009, appealed to his Chinese counterpart Hu Jintao to invest in his country. Which marks the presence of China at the head of the CAR in the peace process and economic rehabilitation. But many development projects have been suspended for the seizure of power by the Seleka coalition March 24, 2013. However, CAR continues to rely on the strategic actions of China in the field of new technology for its agro-pastoral development to food self-sufficiency.
Arab Uprisings and the Outstanding Return to Democracy: Tunisia as a Modelinventionjournals
In the wake of the Middle Eastern crises, the Tunisian case in focus has been doted as a unique
phenomenon being that it was the Genesis of the revolution that ultimately spread across the Middle East like
wild fire, but has eventually heralded a new dawn as democracy has incidentally returned to the Empire. This
literature therefore looks closely at the extent to which the ‘DignityRevolution’ has been instrumental in the
Middle East uprisings, which have brought an end to dynastic autocracies. The literature zeros in on the
Tunisian uprising which has attracted global concerns, sympathy and has sparked interests in the international
arena. The literature finds that the people hold colossal prospect in the uprising and its resultant effect, as it
paved the way for the revolutionist to generate, gather and disseminate information on the condition of the
entire region to the international community. The people in this context were of utmost importance and played a
very crucial role in the creation of awareness, mobilization of protesters and utmost determining the direction of
the uprising and also ensuring a speedy return to democratic rule. The paper submits that the role of the people
in ensuring that the ruins of the uprising is not left littering around and democracy restored is highly
commendable and should be a model for all other Arab countries involved in the revolution.
This document is a thesis submitted for a Master's degree in Global Affairs. It provides an overview of the key topics that will be examined in the thesis, including: ethnic identity and challenges to central governance in Afghanistan; the rise of the communist government and impact on the country; the Taliban's insurgency tactics and justice systems; and potential means of accountability for the Taliban going forward. The acknowledgements section thanks advisors and fellow students who provided support. An introduction outlines some of the uncertainty currently facing Afghanistan and how that has contributed to the Taliban's ongoing threat.
The frequency of the occurrence of terrorist acts such as Istanbul on June 28 near past and violence in general and those who continually take place in Brazil mean the victory of barbarism over civilization. Civilization is considered the most advanced stage of a given human society. The term barbarism has two distinct meanings, but linked: lack of civilization and barbaric cruelty. Barbarism means a break with the moral standards that regulate life in society and the traditional social controls gave way to unbridled violence and contempt for the human being. The great challenge of the contemporary era is to make mankind evolve from the barbarism to civilization.
The document discusses the June 30, 2013 revolution in Egypt which corrected the course of the 2011 revolution and prevented the Muslim Brotherhood from gaining power. It describes the Muslim Brotherhood as representing corrupt capitalist forces and posing a threat to Egypt by conspiring with foreign powers like the US, Qatar, and Turkey. It also discusses how the Muslim Brotherhood pursued a sectarian agenda in Egypt that attacked Coptic Christians and Shi'a Muslims. The June 30 revolution succeeded due to widespread public opposition to the Muslim Brotherhood through the Tamarrod petition campaign and mass protests of over 30 million people. The revolution aims to complete Egypt's unfinished democratic transformation and establish a democratic civil state with economic independence, social justice, and separation of religion
Gregory MacKenzie, "North Korea Must Account for Its Treatment of Political Prisoners," ASIA LAW NEWS (Oct 2013). Published in the ABA Section of International Law Asia/Pacific Committee Asia Law News, October 2012.
This document is an introduction to a dissertation investigating how Israeli citizenship constructs women's place in society as mothers. It begins by defining citizenship as consisting of three pillars - participation, rights, and identity. It then discusses how citizenship has traditionally been a masculine concept focused on military service and exclusion of women. The introduction explores the public/private divide and its gendering effects. It previews how the dissertation will analyze how Israel's republican citizenship model, religious influences, and emphasis on military service have crafted women's role as fulfilling their duty through motherhood rather than equal citizenship. The introduction establishes the theoretical framework that will be used to examine how Israeli citizenship discriminates against women.
Political Unrests and Agitational Politics of Decolonization in Eastern Nigeriainventionjournals
The title of this paper is Political Unrests, and Agitational Politics Unrests of decolonization in Eastern Nigeria. The study is aimed at asserting the view of the liberal nationalist school of thought which is conjectured that sometimes internal dissent and colonial unrest may result in a revolution that hastens the independence of a colony. The position of the liberal nationalist tradition which has been adopted in this paper puts the indigenous people at the centre of decolonization from a reluctant metropolitan power as opposed to the dependentista school of thought.
Octopus and Midget in the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process: Who Determines W...AJSSMTJournal
The document discusses various proposed solutions to the long-standing Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including a two-state solution, one-state solution, and no-state solution. It analyzes the opportunities and challenges of each approach, with a focus on the two-state solution and one-state solution. The document provides background on the conflict and outlines four trajectories that have been proposed to resolve it: the no-state solution, one-state solution, two-state solution, and three-state solution. It then analyzes the two-state solution in more depth.
The document summarizes the situation in Syria as of August 2011, during widespread protests against President Bashar al-Assad's regime. It notes that millions of Syrians have taken to the streets since March 2011 to peacefully demand democratic reforms, in response to which the Assad regime has violently cracked down, killing over 2,200 civilians. While the regime claims the protests are led by foreign infiltrators and religious extremists, the document asserts that the opposition movement represents all parts of Syrian society and its goals are democratic change, not violence or sectarianism. It maintains the regime has lost legitimacy and its fall is inevitable, though it will continue killing people in its death throes.
The document summarizes the history and identity of the Uyghur ethnic group in China's Xinjiang region. It discusses how Uyghur identity has been shaped by geography, religion, and political influences over time. In recent decades, China has suppressed Uyghur cultural expression and aspirations for autonomy, while portraying Uyghurs as terrorists after 9/11. This has exacerbated tensions in the region.
The document provides an analysis of Egypt's 2011-2012 parliamentary elections following the 2011 revolution. It summarizes that:
1) The elections deepened the revolution by further unleashing social and political changes across Egypt as voters from all perspectives showed sophistication in using their newfound political power.
2) The Muslim Brotherhood's Freedom and Justice Party (FJP) dominated nationally, while the Salafist Nur Party enjoyed strong regional support. Major parties were united in opposition to Nur and remnants of the former ruling party.
3) The FJP was highly successful in individual district races, winning around 80% of contests, especially against secular parties and Nur which it defeated in around three-fourths of their
Incitement against Israel, which frequently turns into genuine anti-Semitic incitement, is an inseparable part of the fabric of life in the Palestinian Authority.
M.A. Labor Studies thesis: US Immigration Law, The Evolution of Ethnic Econom...Stephen Cheng
This document summarizes how changes in US immigration law influenced the development of ethnic economies and immigrant communities. It discusses two key laws: the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965, which ended preferences for European immigrants and increased Asian immigration, contributing to the growth of communities like Chinatown; and the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986, which granted amnesty to undocumented immigrants, reinforcing existing migration networks of Mexican immigrants. The document also provides historical context on 19th and early 20th century immigration policies that restricted Asian immigration, and how public opinion shifted after World War 2, leading to the passage of the 1965 Immigration Act.
1) The document discusses two books related to the Arab-Israeli conflict and prospects for peace. It summarizes their key arguments and conclusions.
2) One book argues that democracies are less likely to go to war with each other, but questions whether Israel can remain a democracy under continual security threats. It concludes democracy may slowly come to the Middle East.
3) The other book provides a sober examination of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) and argues that while it failed to achieve its ultimate goal of destroying Israel, its willingness to accept diplomacy and compromise provides opportunities to resolve issues with Israel.
This document summarizes the perspectives of an Iranian feminist collective, Raha, on building solidarity with popular uprisings in Iran and the Middle East, while opposing foreign military intervention. It argues that the anti-war movement should stand in solidarity with struggles for self-determination and against state repression in Iran by recognizing the humanity and agency of the Iranian people. It critiques refusing to take a position on internal affairs in Iran as hypocritical and disconnecting the movement from social justice. The document advocates building grassroots cross-border solidarity instead of looking to governments or NGOs to support human rights.
1. The conflict in Egypt has its roots in decades of authoritarian rule under Hosni Mubarak and the popular uprisings of the Arab Spring in 2011 that led to his removal.
2. This sparked a power struggle between former president Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood, liberal and secular groups, and the military, leading to Morsi's ouster by the military in 2013.
3. The situation can be analyzed through realism, liberalism, and social constructivism lenses, with social constructivism emphasizing how new communication technologies and the spread of ideas influenced identities and political change in Egypt.
This paper analyzes how nationalism affected political transitions in Egypt and Libya following the Arab Spring uprisings. In Egypt, a long-standing nation-state, nationalism manifested in ideological divisions between secular and Islamic nationalists vying for a regime accountable to the people. Repeated regime changes occurred but the country remained united. In Libya, a recently constructed state lacking a strong national identity, the rupture of Gaddafi's regime also ruptured the state, as tribal and regional groups fought for control, plunging the country into civil war. The paper argues that nationalism plays a key role in determining whether a country remains united or fragments during political transitions sparked by the Arab Spring uprisings.
The Revolutionary Tactics of Sunni and Shia Islam WordJesse LaPadula
This document provides an overview and comparison of revolutionary Sunni and Shia Islamist groups, including their tactics and effectiveness. It discusses the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, founded in 1928, and how they grew into a powerful non-state actor but lacked a detailed vision for an Islamic state. It also examines the Jama'at Islamiyya student group in Egypt, which formed in opposition to President Sadat's more pro-Western policies. Finally, it analyzes the Shukri Mustafa group and their rejection of public employment and emphasis on living according to Islamic principles outside of society. Overall, the document analyzes the development and approaches of these different Islamist organizations in Egypt and the Middle East.
Tariq ramadan islam and the arab awakening-oxford university press, usa (2012)Kammi Daerah Serang
This document provides context about the Arab uprisings that began in late 2010 and early 2011 across several Middle Eastern and North African countries. It notes that the uprisings started with the self-immolation of a Tunisian street vendor in December 2010, which led to protests that toppled the Tunisian dictator. Similar protests then spread to Egypt and other countries in early 2011, toppling other authoritarian leaders. The document questions how to describe these events and discusses some of the common drivers of the protests, as well as the different trajectories in each country affected by the uprisings.
Arab Nationalism emerged in the late 19th century as Arabs sought independence from the Ottoman Empire. It grew in popularity in the 1950s as Arab states gained independence from European colonial powers. The ideology was based on the idea of political, cultural and religious unity among Arab peoples. The movement rose to prominence under Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser in the 1950s-60s as he opposed Western imperialism. However, it declined after Egypt's defeat in the 1967 Six-Day War, which exposed divisions between Arab states. The failure to achieve full political unification of Arab states, along with infighting between leaders with different visions, ultimately led to the collapse of Arab Nationalism.
1. The document discusses various forms of state violence and state-sanctioned violence against minorities in the Middle East. It provides examples from Egypt, Palestine, and Lebanon where women, ethnic/religious groups, and political dissidents experience physical, emotional, and structural violence enabled or directly carried out by the state.
2. It then focuses on Hend Nafea, a young Egyptian woman who was beaten and sexually assaulted by state security forces during the Egyptian revolution in Tahrir Square in 2011. She received a 25-year prison sentence but eventually fled to Lebanon to avoid further persecution.
3. The document also examines the emotional violence of the Israeli occupation of Palestine through the story of a Palestinian village called Jay
Fragility and-resilience Relation between Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE I...Sandro Santana
Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC and United States on relationship among Demonstrations, 2013. IMPEACHMENTS of 22 governments, Relation, Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, United States, Demonstrations countries IMPEACHMENT, GOOGLE INC, the torture suffered by Sandro Suzart, Genocide in Egypt and Lybia.
Women of Egyptian revolution- Credemus Associates-Jamila Boughelaf
Women played a crucial role in the Egyptian revolution through both their physical participation in protests and their use of social media. While women faced obstacles like gender discrimination and lack of political representation, many emerged as leaders of the revolution by organizing demonstrations online and in person. Social media helped spread awareness of the movement and connect women internally and internationally, though post-revolution women's voices have receded. Ongoing challenges include increasing women's political participation and challenging social norms, but new technologies and united activism can help advance women's rights and role in society.
This document summarizes the origins and history of Islamist political parties. It begins by noting that the very idea of Islamist parties was originally seen as paradoxical, as early Islamist thinkers rejected pluralism and parties. It then discusses the Muslim Brotherhood, founded in 1928, which was the original organized expression of Islamism and rejected the notion of an Islamist party. The Brotherhood saw itself as a transnational "movement" rather than a party bound to any single nation-state. While today there are many Islamist parties, the document argues that this history is still relevant to understanding their nature and relationship to democracy. It questions whether they can fully break from their ideological roots.
Democratic Great Power Support for Contested Autocracy: Understanding the U.S...Jason Fasano
Undergraduate honors thesis investigating the role homophily (ideological similarity) and expected utility play in US foreign policy formation, utilizing empirical evidence from the 2011 Arab Uprisings in Bahrain, Syria, Egypt, and Libya.
MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD AND EGYPTIAN POLITICS (1954-2010) (A Lesson for Nigeria in...paperpublications3
Abstract: Religion and Politics play very important roles in the life of every individual and society, directly or indirectly, willingly or unwillingly. This is an indication that both are inevitable aspects of human existence. In the course of human history, however, there have been exaggerations of their influence in the polity. Sometimes, these roles have been translated into fundamentalism, violence, and fanaticism. Examples abound, and I like to use two countries to buttress my argument in this paper: the wrong interpretation and application of religion and politics in Egypt (where I lived and studied for two years, 2006-2008) and Nigeria where I am born and bred. It is a glaring fact that in Africa and in Nigeria particularly, Christianity and Islam have shown various faces of the above-mentioned ‘translations’ associated with religion and politics. Sometimes, they have allowed themselves to produce religious and political disorders – a complete opposite of what they are supposed to achieve in human society. It is my intention in this paper to consider the role of a particular group called the ‘Muslim Brotherhood’ in shaping the religious and political history of an African country called Egypt, and to use the development and possible misuse of the same and similar group in Nigeria to remind the citizenry of the dangers of religious extremism in the practice of democracy in a secular state. In the light of this, one cannot but mention the most recent ugly incident perpetrated by the Boko Haram sect in Northern Nigeria since 2009. It would therefore not be an exaggeration to maintain that if Boko Haram was a Brotherhood, it was simply an anomaly. At best, one can refer to it as a secret cult, detrimental to both religion and society. The world has witnessed its havoc in the last six years. Thus, it is my candid opinion that honest and genuine co-existence rooted in love and mutual acceptance of one another would enhance progress and development in Nigeria, and in the world as a whole. The globalized world cannot but co-operate to eradicate religious violence and fanaticism.
Kerry mcbroome Relation between Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, Unit...Sandro Santana
Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC and United States on relationship among Demonstrations, 2013. IMPEACHMENTS of 22 governments, Relation, Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, United States, Demonstrations countries IMPEACHMENT, GOOGLE INC, the torture suffered by Sandro Suzart, Genocide in Egypt and Lybia.
Kerry mcbroome Relation Sandro Suzart SUZART GOOGLE INC United States ...Sandro Suzart
relationship between Sandro Suzart SUZART GOOGLE INC and United States on Demonstrations 2013 and Impeachments of 22 governments Relation, Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, United States on Demonstrations countries IMPEACHMENT GOOGLE INC
This document summarizes three articles from the publication Watani International discussing sectarian tensions in Egypt between Muslims and Copts.
The first article discusses meetings held by independent Egyptian citizens to analyze recent sectarian clashes and how they have impacted society. It notes that various liberal groups formed consisting of Muslims and Christians united by their devotion to Egypt.
The second article discusses the recent sectarian incidents and notes that Christmas comes as Egypt looks to reform. It wishes Pope Shenouda III and Coptic Christians a blessed Christmas.
The third article analyzes statements by President Mubarak calling Egypt home to all citizens, but argues rhetoric does not address real inequalities faced by Copts, such as difficulties constructing churches. It discusses
The arab spring and its implications for nigerian national securityOnyinye Chime
Abstract
Demographic changes, growing unemployment, social media penetration, an interplay of religion and politics
provided the combustible mix for the Arab Spring. The Arab Spring has helped generate awareness about quality
of governance, legitimacy and relationship between state and society but is muted as it relates to its effects on
national security in Nigeria. Indeed, from a historical perspective, a direct effect of the Arab Spring on Nigerian
National Security is not obvious. The paper argues that the challenges facing national security in Nigeria is
independent of the Arab Spring but identifies some ripples from the Arab Spring that could create anxious
moments for national security planners in Nigeria.
Bulletin21 may 2014 Relation between Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, ...Sandro Santana
Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC and United States on relationship among Demonstrations, 2013. IMPEACHMENTS of 22 governments, Relation, Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, United States, Demonstrations countries IMPEACHMENT, GOOGLE INC, the torture suffered by Sandro Suzart, Genocide in Egypt and Lybia.
Similar to UoB Middle East Symposium - Report (19)
Bulletin21 may 2014 Relation between Sandro Suzart, SUZART, GOOGLE INC, ...
UoB Middle East Symposium - Report
1. 1
UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM
MIDDLE EAST SYMPOSIUM
ONE YEAR ON FROM THE ARAB SPRING?
HAS ANYTHING ACTUALLY CHANGED IN THE MIDDLE EAST
AND NORTH AFRICA AND THE INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY?
REPORT
Prepared by Lana Khattab
24 FEBRUARY 2012 EUROPEAN RESEARCH INSTITUTE Room G51
A Middle East Symposium entitled „One Year on from the Arab Spring: Has anything
actually changed in the Middle East and North Africa and the International Community?‟
took place on February 24th at the European Research Institute, University of Birmingham.
Hosting a number of renowned experts on Middle Eastern and Islamic studies and external
actors‟ relations with the Middle East and North African (MENA) region, the Symposium
was split into three panels.
Welcoming the large audience, Colin Thain remarked that the Arab Spring discredited neo-
liberal assumptions concerning the possibility of democratisation in Arab states. Thain
described the uprisings as broader social movements - beyond ethnic and religious boundaries
- rejecting years of perceived humiliation. He also pondered whether the Arab Spring led to
the questioning of Western assumptions in general about how to deal with the complexities of
the Middle East (ME). Has the United States (US) supported the Arab Spring or simply its
national interests? Has the Arab Spring led to a genuine rebirth of MENA societies or not?
The first panel was chaired by Stefan Wolff and focused on Palestine and Egypt. Wolff
started off by emphasising that Chatham House rules applied throughout the day‟s event. The
first speaker, Sari Nusseibeh from Al Quds University, addressed the lack of an Arab Spring-
like uprising in Palestine by highlighting two points:
Firstly, Nusseibeh claimed that the realisation of sovereignty and people power by the Arab
populations lay at the core of the Arab Spring. Arab people realised that they can change the
political order in which they live. However, Palestine‟s unique history and experience of
being under Israeli occupation have made Palestinians feel „sovereign‟ for a while. Nusseibeh
argued that Palestinians have had to take matters into their own hands in the past 40 years of
occupation of the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem. Having been in a constant state of
struggle since the creation of Israel in 1948, Nusseibeh claims that Palestinians have known
the feeling of people empowerment for some time - which the rest of the Arab peoples of the
MENA region have only experienced recently.
Secondly, the Palestinian case is unique in the sense that the political order is more complex
than in other Arab states. Above the immediate layer of Palestinian political leadership exists
the umbrella layer of the occupation. While other Arab states can visibly change the domestic
political layer, Nusseibeh argued that Palestinians are fully aware of the weaknesses of their
leadership in the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem. Staging an uprising against the
Palestinian leadership cannot be effective, since the umbrella layer of the occupation holds
2. 2
the absolute power. Ultimately, Palestinians do not feel that the Palestinian leadership has
any direct power over their lives since the real power is rather the Israeli occupation.
Pointing to the deadlock of negotiations on a two-state solution, the frustration of people on
both sides, the practical difficulty of designing a shared capital for a state of Palestine and
Israel, Nusseibeh proposed a one-state solution, a form of federation for Palestinians and
Israelis, which would uphold principles of freedom and human rights. This solution,
according to Nusseibeh, would require devising a parallel roadmap, and giving back some
basic civil rights to Palestinians in the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem such as the right
of free movement.
Stefan Wolff then gave the floor to Hassan Nafaa from the University of Cairo who spoke on
prospects for democracy a year after the revolution in Egypt. Nafaa summarised events in
Egypt in four points. Firstly, he addressed the specificity of the Egyptian revolution in that it
was an uprising triggered by a well-educated middle-class youth who aspired for freedom,
social justice and dignity and who were not part of any existing political party or group and
who relied on different ideological bases. For Nafaa, the Mubarak regime did not end up
being „toppled‟ but the president was simply „deposed‟. Egypt‟s revolution did not start out
from a vacuum since protest movements such as Kefaya had built the ground for the mass
protests of January 2011 - characterised by a lack of an institutional framework, leadership or
specific ideology. Nafaa claimed that the work of the Egyptian revolution is still unfinished.
Secondly, Nafaa examined the role of the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) in
the revolution by noting that the uprising was protected by the army since the latter refused to
use violence against the protesters. Historically, the Egyptian army is well-respected by the
Egyptian people and in some instances staged coups itself. It is historically difficult to use the
army against the people: the bread riots in 1977 and 1986 during which the army repeatedly
refused to shoot at the people are just one example. Nafaa stated that the army had
reservations regarding the succession scheme of Gamal Mubarak and the role played by the
business elite, embodied by the ruling party the National Democratic Party (NDP).
Nevertheless, the army (represented in particular by the Military Council) has been acting
more as a continuation of the regime rather than a change from Mubarak‟s rule.
Thirdly, Nafaa outlined the ways in which the SCAF has mismanaged the transitional period.
The Military Council has refused to establish a Presidential Council and opted not to involve
civilian opinion. All key players in the government have been selected among those who had
friendly relations with the past regime, instead of involving new players such as the youth.
Moreover, the Council has thus far failed to improve the standard of living of Egyptians and
also failed to re-establish a trustworthy security apparatus, along with committing grave
human rights violations. While the Council is ready to reform the system it is not ready to
change the whole system, including Egypt‟s domestic and foreign policies.
Fourthly, the upcoming Presidential elections will be crucial in determining whether Egypt
will take a democratic course or not. What remains to be solved is how mistakes from the
past year can be corrected. Furthermore, the timing of the drafting of the constitution is
problematic and needs special attention. A final challenge concerns the demands of the
Council which calls for no civilian oversight or interference into its affairs. In concluding,
Nafaa outlined three possible future scenarios. In the first scenario, a moderate Muslim
Brother would be elected as President which would increase the already existing polarisation
between Islamists and non-Islamists. In the second, SCAF and the Muslim Brotherhood (MB)
3. 3
will agree on a President in an undemocratic process which will result in a powerless
President and SCAF “ruling behind the scenes”. The third and most preferable scenario
would be an independent President who enjoys good relations with Islamists and non-
Islamists and who has a good reputation to play a major role in establishing a democratic
system in Egypt. Although the most favoured, the last scenario might not happen. What is
essential to note however is that the Egyptian people will never go back to the status quo: the
Egyptian revolution is unfinished and will continue.
After Nafaa‟s presentation, Stefan Wolff opened the floor to questions from the audience. On
the future of the Egyptian-Israeli peace treaty, it was argued that it will stay in place and not
be put to any referendum; however Israel might be forced to respect the agreement of peace
in the region. Following questions from a BBC Reporter and Michelle Pace from POLSIS
focusing on the extent that Palestinian civil society and youth groups could influence Israeli
civil society, it was claimed that the majority of Palestinian youth belonged to existing
political parties (that is, either to Fatah or Hamas) and were not independent. Palestinians
have tried to engage with the Israeli left in the past however the Israeli political left is very
weak.
On the possibility of a secret deal between the MB and the SCAF it was claimed that this sort
of deal would visibly weaken the military‟s status and not succeed in getting the divided
spectrum of Islamists on board. There is a big risk that such a deal would not work well for
both SCAF and the MB, so the likelihood of it happening is quite low. Moreover, anti-US
actions improve SCAF‟s popularity among the Egyptian people. There is a desire on the part
of the Egyptian side to reassess US-Egyptian relations. On the role of secular liberals in
Egyptian politics, it was noted that the past polarisation between the NDP and the MB left
little space for liberal leftist parties to develop. However, the political map is changing very
quickly and will require political parties, including the MB, to evolve and adapt.
The second panel was chaired by Haifaa Jawad from the University of Birmingham‟s
Department of Theology and Religion and focused on Yemen, Bahrain and Syria. The first
speaker was Vincent Durac from the University College Dublin in Ireland who examined the
nature of Yemen‟s uprising. Since Saleh handed over power to his deputy and the transition
to a unity government has been underway, there has been more regime maintenance than
„actual democratic change‟. Durac outlined the context of Yemen‟s uprising: it is the poorest
country in the Arab world with high levels of illiteracy and corruption. Its economy is
dependent on a limited oil industry which constitutes 90% of its export, however oil is said to
be running low by 2015. While Yemen had experienced limited political liberalisation in the
early 1990s, this came to a halt in 1994. Although a lively opposition landscape has existed in
the past, the protests have emerged as a youth-triggered leaderless movement. The uprising
was followed by significant defections from the ruling party and isolation of the regime. The
Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) initiative only involved political parties and did not attempt
to involve Yemen‟s youth. The deal brokered by the GCC guaranteed Saleh and his family
immunity and left a number of his family members in control of the security apparatus. The
current political landscape is characterised by divisions among the coalition of the opposition,
continuing protests and a relative regime continuation.
The floor was then given to Sajjad H. Rizvi from the University of Exeter who shed light on
the neglect of Bahrain‟s Arab Spring. This neglect is attributed to a number of wrongly-held
assumptions. First, as a Gulf country it is assumed to be very wealthy, but the reality
4. 4
represents 40% youth unemployment, poor welfare services, little electricity and housing
shortages. Second, considering the high percentage of the Shia population in Bahrain external
intelligence was argued to be at play. Third, the sectarian nature of the uprising was over-
emphasised which fed into the hysteria about the Shias taking over the region. The Bahraini
uprising has commonalities with other uprisings in the region: it is leaderless, organised by
youth, marked by an impossibility to return to the status-quo, repression by security forces
including deaths of protesters and was partly due to economic concerns such as growing
inequalities and unemployment.
Rizvi then went on to highlight the historical roots of the Bahraini uprising, which include the
spread of an exclusive historic narrative, serious political claims for democratic
accountability and the „Saudi factor‟. Saudi Arabia has attempted a coup in Bahrain in 1991
and fears the threat posed by the Shias in the region. The shifting situation on the ground in
Iraq poses a great concern for both Saudi Arabia and the ruling elite of Bahrain: political
change in the nature of the state – in this case Iraq‟s Shia – can change facts on the ground
and pose a danger to the status quo. Bahrain itself is of utmost importance since it has energy
resources, represents an example of a strong democratic movement in the Gulf, and
demonstrates human rights abuses which should normatively be a matter of concern. Rizvi
argued that any move forward will have to include all parties on the ground. A research area
which will emerge after these events will be on counter-revolution forces notably by Saudi
Arabia. Since the last Spring, 25 people have been killed in Saudi Arabia. Rizvi applauded
the growing condemnation of Saudi hypocrisy as a positive development.
The final speaker on this panel was Christopher Phillips from Queens Mary University of
London, who examined the Syrian uprising and whether the current context of the uprising is
changing Syrian national identity. As a major revolt against the Baathist regime which had to
date claimed well over 8000 dead, Syria entered its 11th month of uprising at the time of the
Symposium. The return to the old flag used under the democratic era when the Sunni
community was in charge arguably highlights rival ethnic and sectarian lines. Phillips closely
examined the causes of the Syrian uprising. Syria is a colonially created state with various
ethnic and sectarian groupings: roughly 65% are Sunni Arab, 10% Alawi, 12% Kurdish, 3%
Druze and 1% other. Between 1935 and 1970, Syria experienced a high level of political
instability (15-19 coups) but enjoyed greater freedom and a more or less functioning political
system. With the coming to power of Hafez Al-Assad, democracy was sacrificed for security
and stability and a „stable state‟ was constructed. Hafez Al-Assad constructed a coup-proof
political system, building his support base on minority rights (such as Alawis, Druze and
Christians), farmers and poor people, in the major cities of Aleppo and Damascus.
Hafez Al-Assad‟s regime seemed most robust when he crushed an uprising in 1982, notably
in the Hama massacre. However Phillips claimed that Hafez Al-Assad failed to create a clear
national Syrian identity. The regime of Hafez Al-Assad built what was very much defined by
sect, including Syria‟s education and legal systems. While his rhetoric used to be very
nationalistic, the reality was based along ethnic lines. By exacerbating the growth of
economic liberalisation by the Alawis and abandoning the wider support base Hafez had built
Syria by neglecting peasants, cutting subsidies, etc and the Syrian people quickly lost faith in
him. In 2000, Hafez Al-Assad‟s son Bashar came to power. Although he has been generally
popular, his manner of rule exacerbated ethnic and sectarian tensions. Furthermore, Syria
possesses a growing urban problem and an increased intelligence presence inside Syria
operating in chiefdoms.
5. 5
Phillips identified two short term triggers that transformed the protests into an uprising.
Firstly, the general events of the Arab Spring and especially the seeming successes of Tunisia
and Egypt raised hopes that something similar could be achieved in Syria. Secondly, what
started out as peaceful protests quickly turned into a violent, sectarian conflict. Crucially,
Syrian people are aware of the need to avoid sectarian conflict, which would only support the
regime. Phillips noted a shift towards more sectarian slogans such as anti-Alawi and pro-
Sunni ones. The use of the old flag recalls Sunni majority power and is suspiciously looked at
by the Kurdish minority.
With the regime still very strong, a weak opposition and a hugely divided international
community, Phillips claims that Syria is likely to face a stalemate. A potential for game
changing includes more defections, large protests from the key cities of Damascus and
Aleppo and international involvement.
After all three panellists held their presentations, Haifaa Jawad opened the floor to the
audience. On the question whether there was a polarisation of the revolution within Syria
asked by a journalist from the BBC, it was argued that the polarisation was between 20% of
pro-regime and 20% pro-revolution of the population. The vast majority of Syrians
represented the silent middle. Michelle Pace from POLSIS asked whether Hezbollah‟s
support of the Syrian regime plays into Israel‟s presumed plan on attacking Iran. It was
answered that Israel is currently quiet on this issue. Although Israel would like to see the
Assad regime gone in the short term since it supports Hezbollah, such an initiative would
destabilise Israel‟s northern border in the short term.
The third and final panel chaired by Michelle Pace addressed a number of issues. It started on
the topic of Islamism with a presentation by Abdelwahab ElAffendi from the University of
Westminster. He argued that Islamists were not very keen to push for political power. In
Tunisia, Al-Ghannoushi (leader of En-Nahda party) specifically insisted on keeping a low
profile, but he is nevertheless very popular. ElAffendi claimed that the sudden rise of
Islamists was not something they had planned for nor something they desired. Islamism has
something beyond simply Islamist movements, which might benefit Islamist groups. In
Turkey, for instance, Islamists took over responsibility for state and society. However,
Islamists do not have a practical and feasible programme. It is important to bear in mind that
today‟s Islamists are more political rather than religious groups.
Michelle Pace then gave the floor to George Joffé from the University of Cambridge who
examined whether post-Gaddafi Libya has demonstrated change or has deteriorated towards
chaos. Six months after the end of the Gaddafi regime it is legitimate to evaluate events.
Today, the authority of the National Transitional Council (NTC) is being widely challenged.
There has not been any large scale reconstruction undertaken since the end of the civil war,
and there are doubts over the feasibility of holding elections in June 2012. Although life in
Libyan towns has emerged as normal, it may seem as the appearance of normality rather than
genuine stability. Concerns arise regarding the certainty of Libya remaining a unitary state,
the possibility for the NTC to re-impose its security, and the tackling of tensions between
East and West Libya.
The Libyan revolution began in Benghazi and was not coordinated. There are around 100
militias inside Libya today which act as the security apparatus of the state, since Libya still
lacks one. Joffé claimed that no central state authority exists in terms of articulating law and
order. While the autonomy of the militias is a source of grave concern, the inability of the
6. 6
NTC to bring them together is equally worrying. The unity of the Libyan state is threatened
by the location of the oil fields in the East of the country, which would be the financing
source of the East if it wanted to break out. Libya needs to go through a phase of
reconciliation in order to continue as a state: something it has not managed to do yet. Joffé
argued that the likelihood of elections in June was small. Political parties in Libya are small
and inexperienced. Moreover, Libya is threatened by its neighbours such as Mali and Algeria.
Joffé concluded his presentation by stating that Libya has indeed become the paradigm that
highlights the fact that uprisings and their aftermath do not happen smoothly.
The next speaker on the panel was Proinsias De Rossa, Policy Advisor of the Labour Party in
Ireland and former President of the European Parliament (EP)‟s delegation to Palestine, who
addressed the EP‟s approach to the Arab Spring and its impact on the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict. De Rossa briefly outlined the workings of the EP: it has 750 members who get
elected by around 500 million people. Members are grouped along the political spectrum and
encouraged to take European positions although geographic positions do matter too, for
instance the proximity of Southern EU states to the ME. De Rossa noted that the Arab Spring
and the need for a consistent approach should be factors which make the EU more positive
towards Palestinians, especially since Netanyahu seems „more concerned with keeping his
government in place rather than wanting progress‟. The EU‟s consistency is essential to
ensure it regains credibility. De Rossa claimed that human rights clauses in trade agreements
which theoretically denote the legal basis for measures taken were rejected on the basis of a
„political objective‟ being sought whenever challenged. In the EU‟s response to the uprisings
in the Arab Spring published in March 2011 „A Partnership for Democracy and Shared
Prosperity with the Southern Mediterranean‟ one sentence only refers directly to the Peace
Process.
The last panellist addressing the audience was Mark Fitzpatrick from the International
Institute for Strategic Studies who worked as a US diplomat for 26 years. Fitzpatrick stated
that the US should have claimed some credit when protesters took the streets in Tahrir Square
in Cairo for several reasons. Firstly, the protesters espoused the ideals of President Obama‟s
2009 Cairo speech and he helped to legitimise their political struggle. Secondly, President
Obama directly helped to ensure the end of the Mubarak government. By publically calling
for Mubarak to step down, he made a swift and historic response to such a dramatic change in
US political history. Thirdly, the vast majority of the US public was supportive of the
uprising. Fitzpatrick claimed that the US was blamed for „throwing Mubarak under the bus‟
and abandoning him, especially by Gulf leaders who fear the US would treat them in the
same way. He criticised Russia and China‟s attitude towards the democratic uprisings in the
MENA such as in Syria and argued that the US stood on the right side of history. What the
US currently needs is patience in dealing with a changing region. Fitzpatrick concluded his
presentation by stating that the US has realised that repressive regimes are not a long-term
solution for stability in the MENA.
After the presentations by the panellists, Michelle Pace opened the floor to questions from the
audience. On the similarity between Libya and Somalia, it was argued that the situation in
Libya was no where near that of Somalia, since there is no total breakdown of law and order,
daily life still operates and there is no large rebel group such as Al-Shabab. Moreover, the
Libyan people and militias have enough interest in their common good to not let the situation
slide towards a civil war. A POLSIS student‟s question concerned the role of the EU
regarding the ongoing Israeli-Iranian tension. The panellists‟ reply was that the EU opposed
war with Iran but applied sanctions. The EU‟s role as an external actor being centred more
7. 7
towards democracy promotion and human rights, it is unlikely to support direct military
action. It was pointed out however that individual member states were entitled to and
engaged in their own foreign policy which might differ from the EU‟s position.
On the relation between Israel and Syria, it was argued that Israel would be glad to see
Bashar Al-Assad‟s regime go since it would enhance Israeli national sovereignty by isolating
Iran further in the region. A student for the University of Durham asked the panel why it
thought the US felt reluctant to intervene in Libya from the beginning. While the US was
ultimately glad to see Gaddafi go since he had been an irritant on the international scene for
years, it had reservations for direct intevention for other reasons. After Afghanistan and Iraq,
Americans are tired of supporting war abroad. The Obama administration was clear that it
would not bear the costs of military interventions by Europe anymore. Europe needs to start
taking responsibility for its own military actions.
The concluding remarks of the Symposium were made by Nick Wheeler who thanked the co-
sponsors of the event: the School of Government and Society, the Institute for Conflict,
Cooperation and Security (ICCS), POLSIS, the Security Studies Research Group (POLSIS),
the ERI – all at the University of Birmingham and the British International Studies
Association (BISA) and its working group on International Mediterranean Studies. He also
thanked Michelle Pace, Stefan Wolff and Haifaa Jawad, the prestigious group of speakers, the
excellent audience, as well as Helen, Sam, Lana and Valentina for all their support in
organisational matters.
Nick Wheeler went on to state that Russia and China‟s anger over the UNSC Resolution 1973
which legitimised NATO intervention in Libya should be cause for them to be more
concerned regarding Syria, in which Russia has massive national security interests. Although
the West is criticised to be selective in its interventions, this is sometimes justified:
governments need to be confident about what can be done about the situation since
humanitarian ends are not a guarantee for success, especially when intervention is involved.
Wheeler emphasised the support of the Arab League as a key game changer in the
legitimisation of the intervention in Libya. The recent events in the ME sharpened our
awareness on the protection of human rights in non-direct ways and highlighted the ethical
dimensions of interventions which need to be reintroduced into our reflections.