SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Download to read offline
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Teacher Sheet 1
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Preparation
It is assumed that students will have done some preliminary work investigating the following:
i. surface processes, such as weathering.
ii. water movements on the surface and within rocks.
iii. sedimentary rock types.
Suggested Approach
1. Prior to the simulations, ask students to work through the sheets referring to the Folkestone Warren slide.
2. This should naturally lead on to a session investigating the processes involved in ground movement.
3. The simulation materials need to be prepared in advance. Teachers may decide to try all of them or a selection.
Depending on class size, it may be easier to separate pupils into groups, with each group assigned to one of the
four simulations. They can then either report their results to the others or move around to the next one.
4. Examine preventive measures using the Barton case study and a personal study near pupils' own homes.
Notes on the student sheets
1. Background information on Folkestone Warren
Introduction
Folkestone Warren is located on the South Coast 2 km north-east of Folkestone itself. The Warren is an undercliff
zone ofrough ground occupying up to 50 metres above sea level. Above it tower cliffs of Chalk, known as High Cliff
and reaching 125 metres altitude. The Warren itselfis an area of contorted hummocky ground distorted by a series
of lands lips, shown on the maps and photographs of the Student Sheets.
The geology is simple and consists of nearly horizontal beds of sedimentary rock. The lowest formation is the
1~~I~f~rllll~llfll~l~m~1N07017
Teacher Sheet 2 .
Unit 8: Moving Ground
FolkestoneBeds, which are sandstone. These are overlain by about 50 m ofa stiff blue clay, the Gaul t Clay, followed
by the Chalk itself, which makes up the bulk of High Cliff, (see section, Figure 5).
Historical Background
Landslipshave been recorded since 1765, although the instability was largely ignored: the opening of the Dover
Rail way in 1844 indicates this. (An alternative - a tunnel of 1.5 kIn length was considered impracticable). A major
slip in 1877 caused partial collapse of the Martello Tunnel and closed the line for a time. The main collapse in 1915
moved almost the whole of the Warren towards the sea. The railway moved 55 m seaward and dropped about 6 m.
This extended the coastline between 240 and 350 m. The train c~ught at the time was derailed by a 5 m step which
developed in the track and parts of the track were buried by the Great Fall. There were other less serious slips in
1937 and 1940. This highlights the problem of containing natural phenomena.
Causes
The slides are considered to be the result of two main factors:
1. The Gault Clay may become unstable when saturated and pressure is applied by the weight of the overlying
Chalk. This leads to failure at the junction with the Folkestone Beds. Shear movements develop and the clay
slips.
2. The main direction of longshore drift ofbeach material is towards the east. This tends to starve East Wear Bay:
of beach sediment and encourages slip within the Warren. Construction of harbour works at Folkestonesince
the 17th Century has progressively worsened the natural situation. The 19th Century construction ofa masonry
harbour led to further erosion within East Wear Bay. Successive pier extensions in 1863,1883 and 1905 have
all been accompanied by landslip a few years later, the last severe one being in 1915, 10 years after the last
harbour extension. Since then, movements have been minor, thanks to preventive measures such as toe
weighting and drainage tunnels within the clays.
The answers to questions 1.1 to 1.11 are largely self-explanatory from the text and diagrams in the Student Sheets.
In 1.8, note that although most of the movement was downwards, the toe of the slip near the coast actually rose.
2. Why does ground move?
The major factors, considered under the headings given, are as follows:
Rock type composition (e.g. the presence of pyrite in a clay causes loss of strength when it weathers. See
Student Sheet 6)
strength (e.g. igneous rocks are usually strong, while fairly recently deposited sediments are not.)
porosity & permeability (e.g. clays can hold much water inthe pore spaces, but will not let it pass
through, thus lubricating slips.)
Rock Structure bedding planes (provide weaknesses along which water can move and weathering and weakening
can take place.)
joints (have a similar effect, increased by the fact that joints, although further apart than bedding
planes, are often vertical.)
dip of beds (can be important because steeply dipping beds allow greater water penetration.)
Rainfall intensity (heavy rainfall during storms can cause water build-up on the surface or underground,
which results in rock failure.)
seasonality (wet seasons may have a similar effect, even though the build-up is over a longer
period)
drought (the 1976 drought caused many clays to dry out and shrink, resulting in subsidence and
Teacher Sheet 3
Unit 8: Moving Ground
other failure.)
salt spray (during storms increases weathering rates in coastal area.)
Temperature
Vegetation
great temperature variation can lead to rock failure, as can repeated freezing and thawing.
vegetation cover slows rates oferosion byreducing temperature variation and by the binding action
of the roots.
Human Activity e.g. road and rail cuttings
removal of groundwater
agriculture
building
The "answer sheet" is Fig TI.
Discussion of these and related factors will lead on to the examination of other critical factors in more detail, such
as: slope angle, height, load, etc. which are examined during the investigations.
3. Experiments in the Laboratory
A) What is the angle of failure of different loose materials?
These experi.ments show how different materials can support different slope angles. The angle of slope that can be
supported by loose materials is controlled by :
a) the wuys in which grains support one another. This in turn depends upon the packing of the grains, with closely
packed grains being more stable and 'supportive' than loosely packed grains. It also depends upon grain shape
because elongated grains can interlock, increasing stability.
b) friction between the grains. Grains with smooth surfaces have low slope angles; once they become rougher (e.g.
rusted ball bearings) they can support steeper slope angles.
c) amount of water present. A little water causes the grains to cohere or stick together, more water acts as a
lubricant and reduces friction, much water buoys up the grains, allowing them to flow more easily. Some effects
of water are examined in experiment B.
In rocks which are no longer loose materials, the situation is complicated by the amount, type and effectiveness of
cement, by the effects of the compression by overlying rocks, by any changes in particle shape or type caused by
increases of heat or pressure, by later fracturing, weathering, etc.
The differences are highlighted where scree slopes are found beneath steeper rock faces, either in natural cliffs or
in man-made cuttings.
B) How does pressure of the pore water affect the strength of material?
Teacher Sheet 4
Unit 8: Moving Ground
The pressure exerted by water flowing through a material such as sand can be high enough to force the grains apart.
This hydrostatic force can cause the sand to lose its strength and begin to flow, becoming a quicksand.
In this simulation, the pressure exerted by the water is proportional to the height of the water column (head) above
the level of the sand surface. At lower heads, water will flow but the bolt will not sink.
This can happen naturally where permeable materials, like sands, are trapped between impermeable materials, like
clay layers. Both materials were present in the Folkestone Warren situation. Sudden increases in hydrostatic
pressures, with their catastrophic effects, can be seen with earthquake triggered slides, as in Anchorage, Alaska.
Both sand and clay can display this almost gel-like quality (sometimes called thixotropic).
Experimental follow-up could investigate the effects of different head pressures, different mixtures of materials,
different thicknesses of materials, etc.
C) What effects do underlying rocks have on slope failure?
When porous materials (sand) lie above impermeable materials (clay) the sand can become saturated during storms,
etc. The addition of more water causes the grain contacts to lose their friction and flow occurs under the influence
of gravity. This effect can be seen quite frequently on motorway embankments, especially after heavy rain.
D) What binds the grains together?
When the water has evaporated, the sand castle made with distilled water will collapse, while the salt saturated sand
will not, since the individual grains are glued together by the salt cement. This illustrates how weak sediments can
be cemented to form stronger and more resistant sedimentary rocks.
The importance ofthe composition ofthe cement can be illustrated by pouring boiling water over a piece ofsandstone
and then over the salt-cemented sand castle. As the less effective cement dissolves, the 'rock' collapses. Calcium
carbonate cements dissolve in acid rain and soil water; iron cements become weakened by oxidation and reaction
with water, but silica cements are resistant to most weathering processes so that the toughest sedimentary rocks
in the U.K. are usually bound by silica cements. These, therefore, tend to form the steepest natural rock faces, where
other factors are not important.
4. Save the Barton Cliffs: Background Information.
The main processes in operation in the cliff area are shown in Fig. 13 and can be grouped as:
1. Surface processes, such as mass movement and seepages along the cliffs. Weathering ofsuIphides such as pyrite
is a contributory factor, although not quite so marked as at Folkestone.
2. Marine processes operating along the cliff foot and beaches.
A combination of these mechanisms has resulted in average cliff recession rates of up to 1metre per year.
Since 1960 remedial measures have been applied, with varying degrees of success. These have entailed twomain
operations:
1. Protection of the clifffoot against wave attack as shown in Figure 12 and by scattering gabions along the beach
to break the force of longshore currents and waves. Gabions are boxes made of woven metal bands filled with
earth or rocks.
Teacher Sheet 5
Unit 8: Moving Ground
2. Cliff face engineering works designed to intercept and reduce groundwater in order to stabilise the rock.
The whole scheme has cost £1 million. It extends along 1800 m of coastline and was completed in 1968. Unfortu-
nately, there has'never been a complete plan of action and remedial measures have been developed piecemeal. The
sea has found the weakest points in the chain and broken through, as happened in the winter storms of197 4. Then,
the revetment began to collapse and slip recurred. Since then, the authorities have decided to abandon highly
technical defences and to resort to resupplying the beach with sand and pebbles and to allow natural erosion to
operate in a controlled way. It is interesting to note that this method was used successfully in 1812 by William Smith,
(the "father of English geology") at Holkham in Norfolk!
5. Preventing LandsIip: A Personal Study.
Attem pts to stabilise man -made slopes are usually successful; otherwise the slope wouldhave been given a shall ower
gradient. There are of course spectacular examples where calculations have been incorrect; some factors have not
been taken into account; mistakes were made, or where very severe conditions were experienced!
Natural slopes are, however, much more difficult and expensive to stabilise, and, in the long term, many of these
attempts are doomed to failure. Coastal defences are particularly vulnerable and man's rearguard action against
the sea has often proved unsuccessful in the past.
Figure T2 Remedial measures at Barton-on-Sea
Teacher Sheet 6
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Further reading
Other examples may be drawn from a wide variety of sources. Daily newspapers and magazines will often contain
reports concerning slope movements, as there may often be loss of life. This type of information source will involve
students, as they can readily acquire such materials. The Geographical Magazine, Geography Review, National
Geographic and Geology Today will occasionally contain relevant articles.
Study the Earth, Atherton. M. and Robinson, R. Hodder & Stoughton. The unit - Water at Work has useful
simulations of geological processes.
Catastrophe: The Violent Earth. Waltham, T. Macmillan. Contains an exciting chapter on landslips, plus good
reference material for teachers.
Geology and Man. Watson, J. Allen & Unwin. Chapter 6 deals with earth movements, in context ofreservoirs and
coasts.
Experiments in Physical Sedimentation. Allen, J.R.L. Allen & Unwin. Contains a wealth of experiments designed
to illustrate sedimentary principles and processes.
High Roads and Low Roads. Carter, P. and Wallace, G. Article in Geology Today, March/April, 1987 pp. 54 to 59.
A colour slide (CT3) of the view in Fig. 2 is available from the Geological Museum, London, price 30p.
Acknowledgements
This Unit devised by Simon Elsy.
Grateful thanks are expressed to:
The Curator of the Cambridge University Collection of Air Photographs, for permission to publish Fig. 2.
British Rail, Southern Region, for allowing the use of the photograph in Fig. 3.
Dr. J.E. Robinson for his helpful comments on the manuscript of the Unit.
Mrs. H. Busteed and Mr. A. Birchall for diagrams and artwork.
Published by the Association of Teachers of Geology.
Designed and printed by Geo-Supplies, Sheffield.
The publication of this series of Units has been made possible by financial support from the Geologists' Association Fund, which
is gratefully acknowledged.
Copyright. There is no copyright on original material published in this Unit, if it is required for use within the laboratory or
classroom. Copyright material reproduced by permission of other publishers rests with the originating publishers.
"Science of the Earth" Units are obtainable from:
ATG - Ms F Stratton, Sandbourne, Clophill Road, Maulden, Beds, MK45 2AA.
GA - The Geologists' Association, Burlington House, Piccadilly, London, WI V 9AG.
Geo-Supplies, 16 Station Road, Chapeltown, Sheffield, S30 4XH.
Student Sheet 1
Unit 8:Moving Ground
Major earthquakes are uncommon in the British Isles and so we tend to take it for granted that our
land is .safe and will not move. However, it is possible for land on steep cliffs and hillsides to give way.
,When this happens it can prove disastrous for the people who live there or for roads and railways built
across such areas.
We are going to study a famous example of moving ground, near Folkestone in Kent, to find out what
causes land to give way. Later, you will be able to carry out some experiments to test your ideas about
landslip and then devise your own scheme for protecting another part of the south coast from this haz-
ard.
1. Folkestone Warren
The map (Fig. 1) shows the location of Folkestone Warren. It also shows the Folkestone to Dover
railway, built in 1844. Study the map and the photograph and answer the questions which follow.
English Channel
N
1
Clifftop
above landslide
East Wear Bay
'Copt Point
'0 Km 1
oLandslip area
Proposed site of marina,
abandoned due to unstable
cliff at Copt Point
Figure 1. Location of Folkestone Warren.
Erosion is the removal of sediment. In this coastal area,
1.1 What processes of erosion are taking place?
1.2 What evidence can you see that the land surface is moving because it is unstable?
1.3 How might land movements affect the use of the area?
student Sheet 2
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Figure 2. Oblique aerial view looking North -east, taken in 1976, showing details of the western
part of Folkestone WaITen (copyright reserved, Cambridge University).
1.4 What evidence can you see of attempts to stop erosion and land movement?
1.5 Estimate the area of land affected by slipping (in km2).
You will probably have realised that llluch of the area, especially belov the railway track, has slid
downhill. One of the most disastrous slips occurred in 1915.
Read the account overleaf vhich summarises the main events during the landslip. Use the accompa-
nying maps and section to locate the areas mentioned. Study the photos. (Figs. 1 to 5).
Student Sheet 3
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Summary of the sequence of events as reported in 'The Folkestone
Express" and 'The Folkestone Herald" during the Folkestone
Warren landslip on the 19th December 1915..
Shortly after 6.00 pm
Watchman noticed subsidence in the railway track at the Martello Tunnel end of the Warren. Gave his
red light to soldiers to stop the expected 6.10pm train from Ashford. He went to telephone the station
at Folkestone.
About 6.3Opm
Start ofthe Big Fall at the cliffface, seen by the soldiers at Warren Halt. Occupants of the 'Eagles Nest'
notice their ceiling beginning to crack.
About 6.35pm
They try to leave but find doorsjammed and climb out of the windows. Platelayer arrives at Abbotscliff
signal box and tells signalman to put signals at danger because of the fall.
6.36-6.4Opm
'Eagles Nest' occupants reach the end of their garden and see the start of the Great Fall to their east.
Signalman, platelayer and 3 soldiers run from the signalbox as the cliffbehind starts to fall. Signalman
feels rails go down 'quite a foot' as he leaves his box.
6.38-6.43pm
Start of the Great Fall. This turned into a flow slide burying the rail-line under 13 metres of debris for
a length of 250 metres and ran out to sea for 350 metres.
Just after 6.45 pm
The 6.10 pm Ashford to Dover train leaves Folkestone junction, fortunately a little late, with 130 pas-
sengers.
About 6.5Opm
Train brakes suddenly as it emerges from the Martello Tunnel into the Warren on seeing soldiers with
red lamps.
About 6.50-7.10pm
Passengers wait in the train while the engine and front carriages sink slowly down with the continu-
ing movements.
About 7.1Opm
Guard asks passengers to leave the train. Soldiers escort them on foot back to Folkestone junction
through the Martello Tunnel.
Student Sheet 4
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Figure 3. The dramatic effects of the slip of 1915. The train had just emerged from the Martello
Tunnel.
I"Var:en Halt signal box - before
N
I
c:::J after
300m
East Wear Bay L.--.I
A
"} '.,, .>/ position of rail line after slip
{ ,I
original
rai11ineFigure 4. Sketch map of
Folkestone Warren showing
features formed as a result of the
1915slip. Note the movements of
the railway line, the change in
shore line, the new positions of
the Warren Halt signal box and
the "Eagle's Nest".
o Folkestone Beds (sands)
B
Sea level
Railway
cutting
""
Possible curved planes
Ground surface along which slip has
before 1915 slip been most concentrated
........J........
..., ..........Lower
Chalk
Gault Clay
50
100
150
nl above A
sea level
Figure 5. Cross-section of part of Folkestone Warren along line AB.
Student Sheet 5
Unit 8:Moving Ground
When you have gained a good idea of what happened, try to answer the following questions:-
1.6 How has the position of the railway line, shown in the photo, map and cross section, changed?
1.7 What does the cross section show was the cause of these changes?
1.8 At points X and Y, measure the amount of vertical movements caused by the slip and say vhether
it was upwards or downwards.
1.9 Was the slip a single event or a series of events?
1.10 How long did the whole landslip event take?
1.11 What are the first signs of lands lip?
2. Why does ground move?
Now we need to find out what factors cause grou~d to move.
2.1 Working in small groups, examine this drawing (Fig. 6) and list as many factors as possible which
might affect how stable the slope will be. Try to include some of the factors that were active at
Folkestone Warren.
As a guide, think of points under the following headings:
Rock type
Temperature
Rock structure
Vegetation
Rainfall
Man's activities
Figure 6. Some clues to the factors which may cause ground to move.
Student Sheet 6
Unit 8: Moving Ground
When you have finished, ask your teacher for an "answer sheet" which shows you the factors which
geologists and engineers have found to be important.
The factors which you have listed are all linked with one another so that change in one may cause
others to change too.
Generally, slopes become less stable when:
the slope angle becomes steeper.
extra material is dumped at the top of the slope.
material is removed from the base of the slope.
the weight of rock is increased by water seeping in.
the strength of rock is decreased by water seeping in.
the groundwater level rises, causing water logging.
vegetation, whose roots bind the material together is removed.
chemical changes take place within the rock.
On coasts, much material is continually removed from the base of the slope by the erosive action of the
sea.
At Folkestone, the effects of chemical changes within the rock are especially drastic. The Gault Clay
contains a lot of the mineral called pyrite, sometimes known as "fool's gold". Chemically, it consists of
iron sulphide (FeS2
). When exposed to air and moisture, this changes to sulphate minerals. As the
change occurs it causes the clay to swell, rather as yeast does in bread dough. Heatis given off by the
reaction and this also causes the clay to crack. Taken together, these processes lead to the rapid dis-
in tegration of the clay, which then slips very easily under the weight of overlying rock.
When Man -made slopes are being constructed, the engineers calculate "safe" angles for the slopes. For
example, in the London Clay, which is a notoriously unreliable foundation rock, the slope of a cutting
has to be as low as 80
to be safe!
It is possible to test some of the factors in the list above by simple experiments and this is the object
of the next section. .
3. Experiments in the laboratory
A) What is the angle of failure in different loose materials?
In these experiments you will find out how steep a slope has to be before it fails or slips. How
important is the type of material in the slope? To find out, use the method below.
1. Collect the apparatus from your teacher.
2. Cut the cardboard into a narrow ring with the outside diameter a little less than the bottle.
Mark on this ring with a protractor a scale with 5 degree intervals and stick the ring to the
bottom of the bottle.
Student Sheet 7
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Value B when surface
of material is on point
of collapse
i
Value A when
surface of material
is horizontal
Reference point where
bottle touches table
Card marked with
angles and glued
to base of bottle
-+
Figure 7. Measurement of the angle of failure in different materials.
3. Halffill the bottle with the sample ofmaterial your teacher has given you. Screw on the top tightly.
4. Lay the bottle on its side and roll it round a few times to allow your sample to pack evenly.
5. Return your sample to the horizontal (you may check this with a spirit level). Record the value of
the angle where the bottle and bench touch. Call this value A.
6. Rotate the bottle until the sand begins to collapse. At this point, record the value of the angle at
the bottle/table contact. Call this angle B. Find the angle of slope failure by subtracting A from
B. Record your result for this material.
7. Repeat the experiment 3 times. Calculate and record the average result.
8. Carry out the experiment for different materials, first dry and then with varying amounts ofwater.
Record all your results.
9. Answer the following questions on the basis of your results:
3.1 What effect does a little water have on your results?
3.2 What effect does a lot of water have on your results?
3.3 What effect does the size of the grains of material have on your results?
3.4 What effect does the shape of the grains of material have on your results?
3.5 Can you relate any of your findings to the slope failure at Folkestone Warren? Give details.
Student Sheet 8
Unit 8: Moving Ground
B) How does the pressure of the pore water affect the strength of material?
When the water between the grains is under enough pressure it can force the grains apart. Test the
effect of this using the method below:
1. Connect a burette filled with water to a container filled with sorted sand as shown in the diagram
(Fig. 8). .
2. Add water to the sand un til it is completely filled. The water levels in the sand and burette should
be the same with the connecting tap open. .
3. Now close the connecting tap and add a heavy object to the top of the sand.
4. Add water to the burette until its level is 3 times the thickness ofthe sand above the sand surface
level.
5. Now open the tap and observe the effects. Record your observations.
6. Close the tap to stop the water flow and add a second similar heavy object to the sand surface.
Record your observations.
Use the apparatus to investigate the water pressures necessary to cause failure in different sizes
~nd mixtures of sediment. Some of your results could be plotted on a graph of water pressure
(height of water) against grain size.
3.6 How do you think this experiment might help to explain the Folkestone Warren slip?
T
.-- water level
bolt
head
1.~__
burette
.-- initial water level
sand
'fine mesh to retain
---------.-.-- sand yet allow water
to pass
funnel
tap
Figure 8. Equipment for testing the effects of pore water pressure on the strength of
sediment.
Student Sheet 9
Unit 8: Moving Ground
C) What effects do underlying rocks have on slope failure?
Try the following imitation of a sequence of dipping sediments:
1. Set up the apparatus as shown in Fig. 9.
2. Measure the angle of sediment slope.
3. Use a watering can to slowly spray 1/2 litre of water onto the sand while observing the slope
carefully. Record your observations.
4. Set up the apparatus again with a different slope and repeat the experiment.
5. Repeat the experiment with no clay layer.
,3.7 How does the angle of slope and the clay layer affect your results?
3.8 Refer back to figure 5 and say how this experiment might help to explain the Folkestone Warren
slip.
damp sand 2cm deep
packed clay (an
impermeable
layer that will not
allow water to
.pass through)
tank or
•• --- box
Figure 9. Equipment to test the effects of different layers of rock on slope stability.
D) What binds the grains together?
Investigate how grains are bound together and the effects of different types of"grain glue" by carrying
out the instructions below:
1. Take two 250ml glass beakers and fill them with dry sand.
2. Saturate the sand in one beaker with distilled water.
3. Make a supersaturated solution of salt by heating some water and adding salt until no more will
dissolve. Saturate the sand in the other beaker with this salt solution.
4. Turn the 'sand castles' out of the two beakers and leave to dry on a tray. This can be speeded up
in an oven.
5. Observe and explain the results.
Student Sheet 10
Unit 8:Moving Ground
3.9 How do the effects you observed in your experiment affect natural slopes in loose sediments?
3.10 What will happen in natural rock outcrops where the material ~ementing the grains together is
an easily dissolved material?
Naturally occurring cements in rocks include silica (Si02
), calcium carbonate (CaC03
) and various
iron oxides.
3.11 Which one of these would you expect to be most soluble in acid rain water?
4. Save the Barton Cliffs
You can now apply what you have learned from your studies and experiments to a real problem on the
south coast. Study the information below and carry out the instructions.
Barton-on-Sea is a small town in Christchurch Bay (see Fig. 10). On the beach the waves come in at
an angle. As they break and run up the beach, they move the sediment up the beach at an angle. The
water and sediment then drain straight back down the beach. This causes both water and sediment
to move steadily along the beach, as show in Fig. 11.
Portsmouth
Christchurch
~
Direction of
longshore
drift.
N
o
I
Km
10
I
Figure 10. Location of Barton on Sea, shaded areas represent unstable coastlines.
Student Sheet 11
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Direction of longshore drift
Le..general movement of
water and sand. . •••..
-----~
Figure!l. The process of Longshore Drift
Beach
Sea
Coastal engineers have tried to keep the ·sand near Barton to attract the holiday makers. To do
this they have built a series of groynes out from the beach so that the sand can build up behind
them. Unfortunately this has starved areas further along the coast of sand. Thus the beaches, and
eventually the cliffs, are being eroded. Erosion of the base of the cliffs together with seepages of
water from above have caused the cliffs to slip. The slip material is then carried away along the
beach. These processes are causing cliff erosion rates of up to 1metre per year.
4.1 Solve the Problem
Fig. 12 shows several different ways in which cliff slip and erosion problems can be tackled.
g.c:el ~P'dltt.
hd; Su/;+omcL
bypo~4t1L
~eLcCl.bles
~on.cL~
Slof.e."
Figure 12. Preventive measures used on natural slopes
Student Sheet 12
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Fig. 13 is a sketch block-diagram of the cliffs at Barton, showing some of the problems mentioned
earlier in the text.
M~c..etosicn
oK.f>.use. -
jnshlbiU1y of
cJa,ys CLt)cL
ternoVQlrcf'
la.nclslip
ma, .
",'
' ....•..
•.. •.
llU
,.....•-._- -
- ---- -
- •... -
""~
. ~l')beHrt~(
. r d~
SafJ- ~~ 'oJie
"Ba.ritw. day ~
Figure 13. Sketch block diagram of the Barton Cliffs.
Redraw the diagram and use it to show your ideas for the prevention of slip and erosion. Use Fig.
12 to help you, together with any methods which you might have seen in your travels to the seaside,
or your own home area. Describe how you hope each of your measures would work. Remember
that many of the processes of slip and erosion are linked, so try to deal with all the problems, not
just one.
5. Preventing landslip: A personal study
5.1 Find a place near your home where civil engineers have tried to prevent landslip. This might be
a road or railway cutting, a natural cliff or a Man-made one. From a safe vantage point, such as
a bridge or pavement, try to spot t~e methods which have been used. Use Fig. 14 as a guide. Do
NOT walk on railway tracks or roadvays or go too close to the foot of any cliff. The best method
of recording might be a labelled sketch or photograph, with something on it to show the scale.
Student Sheet 13
Unit 8: Moving Ground
5.2 To what extent have the engineers been successful?
5.3 Could you have done any better?
-Pa"" ,t¥c:10S
looSt,pleck.
s~ecL+O
~e9s wiHl
S#'eel cables
1?c;c.k an c.hClt:S"
li>o(t:s'"fbf;>~)*
~)o."h.d..t>/o~
~m $ICtlJNt,.J
1>~
.t....., beelCo'led..-
ttt So.nd..
~Gl jt11rVe.t
Figure 14. Preventive measures used in an artificial cutting.
5.4. Watch out for newspaper reports of the progress of the Channel Tunnel. It is due to emerge from
the Gault Clay near Folkestone and some geologists predict that the site may not be the best that
could have been chosen!
Unit 8: Moving Ground
Answer Sheet :
External
Factors
Porosity
and
Penneability
/'
IRock Type I
~
Jointing
Dip of Beds
Internal
Factors
I Seepage I~ Groundwater
Changing Levels
Slope Angle
Figure TI The slope system components. The various factors contributing to the stability or
instability of slopes. Slope angles can vary widely. Variation of one component may lead to a general
readjustment of equilibrium through slope movement.

More Related Content

What's hot

Geologic Processes on Earth
Geologic Processes on EarthGeologic Processes on Earth
Geologic Processes on EarthHanna Elise
 
Erosion and transportation
Erosion  and transportationErosion  and transportation
Erosion and transportationMarsamkayee
 
Weathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionWeathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionAndrew Palmer
 
Geological work of natural agencies like wind
Geological work of natural agencies like  windGeological work of natural agencies like  wind
Geological work of natural agencies like windRAMPRASAD KUMAWAT
 
Weathering, erosion, deposition (teacher background)
Weathering, erosion, deposition (teacher background)Weathering, erosion, deposition (teacher background)
Weathering, erosion, deposition (teacher background)Moira Whitehouse
 
Weathering, Erosion, Mass Wasting.
Weathering, Erosion, Mass Wasting.Weathering, Erosion, Mass Wasting.
Weathering, Erosion, Mass Wasting.Russel Corcino
 
Weathering and erosion introduction
Weathering and erosion introductionWeathering and erosion introduction
Weathering and erosion introductionmrcoyleteach
 
Weathering, Erosion and Deposition.(3rd/4th grade teach)
Weathering, Erosion and Deposition.(3rd/4th  grade teach)Weathering, Erosion and Deposition.(3rd/4th  grade teach)
Weathering, Erosion and Deposition.(3rd/4th grade teach)Moira Whitehouse
 
Weathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionWeathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionAmmadkhan69
 
Weathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionWeathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionlovenaces60
 
AS Level Physical Geography - Rocks and Weathering
AS Level Physical Geography - Rocks and WeatheringAS Level Physical Geography - Rocks and Weathering
AS Level Physical Geography - Rocks and WeatheringArm Punyathorn
 
weathering - meaning and effects
weathering - meaning and effectsweathering - meaning and effects
weathering - meaning and effectssubham12
 
Weathering, Erosion, and Deposition
Weathering, Erosion, and DepositionWeathering, Erosion, and Deposition
Weathering, Erosion, and Depositionrebelbrindley
 
Weathering,erosion,deposition
Weathering,erosion,depositionWeathering,erosion,deposition
Weathering,erosion,depositiontorikid345
 

What's hot (20)

Geologic Processes on Earth
Geologic Processes on EarthGeologic Processes on Earth
Geologic Processes on Earth
 
Weathering
WeatheringWeathering
Weathering
 
Erosion and transportation
Erosion  and transportationErosion  and transportation
Erosion and transportation
 
Weathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionWeathering and erosion
Weathering and erosion
 
Exogenic Processes
Exogenic Processes Exogenic Processes
Exogenic Processes
 
Geological work of natural agencies like wind
Geological work of natural agencies like  windGeological work of natural agencies like  wind
Geological work of natural agencies like wind
 
Weathering, erosion, deposition (teacher background)
Weathering, erosion, deposition (teacher background)Weathering, erosion, deposition (teacher background)
Weathering, erosion, deposition (teacher background)
 
Weathering, Erosion, Mass Wasting.
Weathering, Erosion, Mass Wasting.Weathering, Erosion, Mass Wasting.
Weathering, Erosion, Mass Wasting.
 
Earth and Life Report
Earth and Life ReportEarth and Life Report
Earth and Life Report
 
Weathering and erosion introduction
Weathering and erosion introductionWeathering and erosion introduction
Weathering and erosion introduction
 
Weathering, Erosion and Deposition.(3rd/4th grade teach)
Weathering, Erosion and Deposition.(3rd/4th  grade teach)Weathering, Erosion and Deposition.(3rd/4th  grade teach)
Weathering, Erosion and Deposition.(3rd/4th grade teach)
 
Exogenic processe sppt
Exogenic processe spptExogenic processe sppt
Exogenic processe sppt
 
Weathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionWeathering and erosion
Weathering and erosion
 
Weathering and erosion
Weathering and erosionWeathering and erosion
Weathering and erosion
 
Engineering Geology
Engineering Geology Engineering Geology
Engineering Geology
 
W.E.D. Review
W.E.D. ReviewW.E.D. Review
W.E.D. Review
 
AS Level Physical Geography - Rocks and Weathering
AS Level Physical Geography - Rocks and WeatheringAS Level Physical Geography - Rocks and Weathering
AS Level Physical Geography - Rocks and Weathering
 
weathering - meaning and effects
weathering - meaning and effectsweathering - meaning and effects
weathering - meaning and effects
 
Weathering, Erosion, and Deposition
Weathering, Erosion, and DepositionWeathering, Erosion, and Deposition
Weathering, Erosion, and Deposition
 
Weathering,erosion,deposition
Weathering,erosion,depositionWeathering,erosion,deposition
Weathering,erosion,deposition
 

Viewers also liked

Prof. Dr. Ralf Kreutzer - Marketing as a Service
Prof. Dr. Ralf Kreutzer - Marketing as a Service Prof. Dr. Ralf Kreutzer - Marketing as a Service
Prof. Dr. Ralf Kreutzer - Marketing as a Service SMICS
 
Necesidades Especiales para la educación de niños
Necesidades Especiales para la educación de niñosNecesidades Especiales para la educación de niños
Necesidades Especiales para la educación de niñosbalmaceda2015
 
5 razones por las que se debe aprender un segundo idioma como un freelancer
5 razones por las que se debe aprender un segundo idioma como un freelancer5 razones por las que se debe aprender un segundo idioma como un freelancer
5 razones por las que se debe aprender un segundo idioma como un freelancerfreelancermap team
 
OpenData: El ejemplo de datos abiertos de Dirección de Aduanas Uruguay
OpenData: El ejemplo de datos abiertos de Dirección de Aduanas UruguayOpenData: El ejemplo de datos abiertos de Dirección de Aduanas Uruguay
OpenData: El ejemplo de datos abiertos de Dirección de Aduanas UruguayGeneXus
 
Research Report: Customer Services in Social Media Channels
Research Report: Customer Services in Social Media ChannelsResearch Report: Customer Services in Social Media Channels
Research Report: Customer Services in Social Media ChannelsAlexander Rossmann
 
Anchoring Trust: Rewriting DNS for the Semantic Network with Ruby and Rails
Anchoring Trust: Rewriting DNS for the Semantic Network with Ruby and RailsAnchoring Trust: Rewriting DNS for the Semantic Network with Ruby and Rails
Anchoring Trust: Rewriting DNS for the Semantic Network with Ruby and RailsEleanor McHugh
 
Batalladepueblaygobiernodejurez 110505141701-phpapp01
Batalladepueblaygobiernodejurez 110505141701-phpapp01Batalladepueblaygobiernodejurez 110505141701-phpapp01
Batalladepueblaygobiernodejurez 110505141701-phpapp01mariadelaluz1973
 
Top 5 de guitarras fender
Top 5 de guitarras fenderTop 5 de guitarras fender
Top 5 de guitarras fenderJulian Peralta
 
Books of philippians and colossians [new testament] translated into the burmese
Books of philippians and colossians [new testament] translated into the burmeseBooks of philippians and colossians [new testament] translated into the burmese
Books of philippians and colossians [new testament] translated into the burmeseWorldBibles
 
Master experiencial en dirección de marketing para las industrias creativas
Master experiencial en dirección de marketing para las industrias creativasMaster experiencial en dirección de marketing para las industrias creativas
Master experiencial en dirección de marketing para las industrias creativasJosé Cantero Gómez
 
Испански за начинаещи за една чаша кафе
Испански за начинаещи за една чаша кафеИспански за начинаещи за една чаша кафе
Испански за начинаещи за една чаша кафеAleks Anev
 
Confianza en medio de la Crisis
Confianza en medio de la CrisisConfianza en medio de la Crisis
Confianza en medio de la CrisisBeb0_01
 
Dr. Igor Calzada, Ph.D. Tesis Doctoral "¿Hacia una `Ciudad Vasca´? Aproximaci...
Dr. Igor Calzada, Ph.D. Tesis Doctoral "¿Hacia una `Ciudad Vasca´? Aproximaci...Dr. Igor Calzada, Ph.D. Tesis Doctoral "¿Hacia una `Ciudad Vasca´? Aproximaci...
Dr. Igor Calzada, Ph.D. Tesis Doctoral "¿Hacia una `Ciudad Vasca´? Aproximaci...Dr Igor Calzada, MBA, FeRSA
 
Materiales Infantil
Materiales InfantilMateriales Infantil
Materiales Infantilguest06c0ce
 
Evaluacion de desempeño
Evaluacion de desempeñoEvaluacion de desempeño
Evaluacion de desempeñoEduardo Pcz
 
EstimulacióN Temprana
EstimulacióN TempranaEstimulacióN Temprana
EstimulacióN Tempranakarlaorosco
 
Curso Merchandising Modulo 6
Curso Merchandising Modulo 6Curso Merchandising Modulo 6
Curso Merchandising Modulo 6Juan Adsuara
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Prof. Dr. Ralf Kreutzer - Marketing as a Service
Prof. Dr. Ralf Kreutzer - Marketing as a Service Prof. Dr. Ralf Kreutzer - Marketing as a Service
Prof. Dr. Ralf Kreutzer - Marketing as a Service
 
Necesidades Especiales para la educación de niños
Necesidades Especiales para la educación de niñosNecesidades Especiales para la educación de niños
Necesidades Especiales para la educación de niños
 
Live Happy Right Side Up
Live Happy Right Side UpLive Happy Right Side Up
Live Happy Right Side Up
 
5 razones por las que se debe aprender un segundo idioma como un freelancer
5 razones por las que se debe aprender un segundo idioma como un freelancer5 razones por las que se debe aprender un segundo idioma como un freelancer
5 razones por las que se debe aprender un segundo idioma como un freelancer
 
OpenData: El ejemplo de datos abiertos de Dirección de Aduanas Uruguay
OpenData: El ejemplo de datos abiertos de Dirección de Aduanas UruguayOpenData: El ejemplo de datos abiertos de Dirección de Aduanas Uruguay
OpenData: El ejemplo de datos abiertos de Dirección de Aduanas Uruguay
 
Research Report: Customer Services in Social Media Channels
Research Report: Customer Services in Social Media ChannelsResearch Report: Customer Services in Social Media Channels
Research Report: Customer Services in Social Media Channels
 
Convocatoria feria xxii 2014
Convocatoria feria xxii 2014Convocatoria feria xxii 2014
Convocatoria feria xxii 2014
 
Anchoring Trust: Rewriting DNS for the Semantic Network with Ruby and Rails
Anchoring Trust: Rewriting DNS for the Semantic Network with Ruby and RailsAnchoring Trust: Rewriting DNS for the Semantic Network with Ruby and Rails
Anchoring Trust: Rewriting DNS for the Semantic Network with Ruby and Rails
 
Batalladepueblaygobiernodejurez 110505141701-phpapp01
Batalladepueblaygobiernodejurez 110505141701-phpapp01Batalladepueblaygobiernodejurez 110505141701-phpapp01
Batalladepueblaygobiernodejurez 110505141701-phpapp01
 
Top 5 de guitarras fender
Top 5 de guitarras fenderTop 5 de guitarras fender
Top 5 de guitarras fender
 
Books of philippians and colossians [new testament] translated into the burmese
Books of philippians and colossians [new testament] translated into the burmeseBooks of philippians and colossians [new testament] translated into the burmese
Books of philippians and colossians [new testament] translated into the burmese
 
Master experiencial en dirección de marketing para las industrias creativas
Master experiencial en dirección de marketing para las industrias creativasMaster experiencial en dirección de marketing para las industrias creativas
Master experiencial en dirección de marketing para las industrias creativas
 
Испански за начинаещи за една чаша кафе
Испански за начинаещи за една чаша кафеИспански за начинаещи за една чаша кафе
Испански за начинаещи за една чаша кафе
 
Confianza en medio de la Crisis
Confianza en medio de la CrisisConfianza en medio de la Crisis
Confianza en medio de la Crisis
 
Dr. Igor Calzada, Ph.D. Tesis Doctoral "¿Hacia una `Ciudad Vasca´? Aproximaci...
Dr. Igor Calzada, Ph.D. Tesis Doctoral "¿Hacia una `Ciudad Vasca´? Aproximaci...Dr. Igor Calzada, Ph.D. Tesis Doctoral "¿Hacia una `Ciudad Vasca´? Aproximaci...
Dr. Igor Calzada, Ph.D. Tesis Doctoral "¿Hacia una `Ciudad Vasca´? Aproximaci...
 
Materiales Infantil
Materiales InfantilMateriales Infantil
Materiales Infantil
 
Evaluacion de desempeño
Evaluacion de desempeñoEvaluacion de desempeño
Evaluacion de desempeño
 
EstimulacióN Temprana
EstimulacióN TempranaEstimulacióN Temprana
EstimulacióN Temprana
 
Curso Merchandising Modulo 6
Curso Merchandising Modulo 6Curso Merchandising Modulo 6
Curso Merchandising Modulo 6
 
Modelo unico cogp seminario taller total eagg 2015
Modelo unico cogp seminario taller total eagg 2015Modelo unico cogp seminario taller total eagg 2015
Modelo unico cogp seminario taller total eagg 2015
 

Similar to Unit 8 Moving ground

Slope stability question answers
Slope stability question answersSlope stability question answers
Slope stability question answersJyoti Khatiwada
 
Coastal Processes And Landforms
Coastal Processes And LandformsCoastal Processes And Landforms
Coastal Processes And LandformsMalia Damit
 
Chapter 9 Science Ppt
Chapter 9 Science PptChapter 9 Science Ppt
Chapter 9 Science PptP Cole
 
Chapter 9 Science Ppt
Chapter 9 Science PptChapter 9 Science Ppt
Chapter 9 Science PptP Cole
 
Unit 9 Weathering.pptx
Unit 9 Weathering.pptxUnit 9 Weathering.pptx
Unit 9 Weathering.pptxAceCardeno
 
Expansive soils and stabilization
Expansive soils and stabilizationExpansive soils and stabilization
Expansive soils and stabilizationshahzad khan
 
Coastal questions
Coastal questionsCoastal questions
Coastal questionstudorgeog
 
2. Weathering and mass movement
2. Weathering and mass movement2. Weathering and mass movement
2. Weathering and mass movementMr Blackwell
 
Causes of gEOLOGIC hAZARDS.docx
Causes of gEOLOGIC hAZARDS.docxCauses of gEOLOGIC hAZARDS.docx
Causes of gEOLOGIC hAZARDS.docxBalaoroDheoLubang
 
Pre trip task yehliu geopark
Pre trip task yehliu geoparkPre trip task yehliu geopark
Pre trip task yehliu geoparkmgtaiwanrocs2013
 
2. apllied-hydrogeology-fetter- 2--315-324
2. apllied-hydrogeology-fetter- 2--315-3242. apllied-hydrogeology-fetter- 2--315-324
2. apllied-hydrogeology-fetter- 2--315-324massiel mamani marquez
 
Coasts erosion deposition
Coasts erosion depositionCoasts erosion deposition
Coasts erosion depositiondean dundas
 
Liquefaction by alisha kaplan
Liquefaction by alisha kaplanLiquefaction by alisha kaplan
Liquefaction by alisha kaplanmk.amiri
 
Primary Sedimentary Structures
Primary Sedimentary Structures Primary Sedimentary Structures
Primary Sedimentary Structures Sardar Hashim
 
IMPACT OF SUBSIDENCE
IMPACT OF SUBSIDENCEIMPACT OF SUBSIDENCE
IMPACT OF SUBSIDENCEKapil Beniwal
 

Similar to Unit 8 Moving ground (20)

Slope stability question answers
Slope stability question answersSlope stability question answers
Slope stability question answers
 
Coastal Processes And Landforms
Coastal Processes And LandformsCoastal Processes And Landforms
Coastal Processes And Landforms
 
Chapter 9 Science Ppt
Chapter 9 Science PptChapter 9 Science Ppt
Chapter 9 Science Ppt
 
Chapter 9 Science Ppt
Chapter 9 Science PptChapter 9 Science Ppt
Chapter 9 Science Ppt
 
Unit 9 Weathering.pptx
Unit 9 Weathering.pptxUnit 9 Weathering.pptx
Unit 9 Weathering.pptx
 
chapter 3.ppt
chapter 3.pptchapter 3.ppt
chapter 3.ppt
 
Expansive soils and stabilization
Expansive soils and stabilizationExpansive soils and stabilization
Expansive soils and stabilization
 
On Slope Monitoring Methods
On Slope Monitoring MethodsOn Slope Monitoring Methods
On Slope Monitoring Methods
 
Coastal questions
Coastal questionsCoastal questions
Coastal questions
 
2. Weathering and mass movement
2. Weathering and mass movement2. Weathering and mass movement
2. Weathering and mass movement
 
Geology Terms
Geology TermsGeology Terms
Geology Terms
 
Causes of gEOLOGIC hAZARDS.docx
Causes of gEOLOGIC hAZARDS.docxCauses of gEOLOGIC hAZARDS.docx
Causes of gEOLOGIC hAZARDS.docx
 
Pre trip task yehliu geopark
Pre trip task yehliu geoparkPre trip task yehliu geopark
Pre trip task yehliu geopark
 
2. apllied-hydrogeology-fetter- 2--315-324
2. apllied-hydrogeology-fetter- 2--315-3242. apllied-hydrogeology-fetter- 2--315-324
2. apllied-hydrogeology-fetter- 2--315-324
 
Coasts erosion deposition
Coasts erosion depositionCoasts erosion deposition
Coasts erosion deposition
 
Liquefaction by alisha kaplan
Liquefaction by alisha kaplanLiquefaction by alisha kaplan
Liquefaction by alisha kaplan
 
Primary Sedimentary Structures
Primary Sedimentary Structures Primary Sedimentary Structures
Primary Sedimentary Structures
 
IMPACT OF SUBSIDENCE
IMPACT OF SUBSIDENCEIMPACT OF SUBSIDENCE
IMPACT OF SUBSIDENCE
 
Sinkholes in karst environments
Sinkholes in karst environmentsSinkholes in karst environments
Sinkholes in karst environments
 
Slope Movement
Slope MovementSlope Movement
Slope Movement
 

Unit 8 Moving ground

  • 1. Unit 8: Moving Ground
  • 2. Teacher Sheet 1 Unit 8: Moving Ground Preparation It is assumed that students will have done some preliminary work investigating the following: i. surface processes, such as weathering. ii. water movements on the surface and within rocks. iii. sedimentary rock types. Suggested Approach 1. Prior to the simulations, ask students to work through the sheets referring to the Folkestone Warren slide. 2. This should naturally lead on to a session investigating the processes involved in ground movement. 3. The simulation materials need to be prepared in advance. Teachers may decide to try all of them or a selection. Depending on class size, it may be easier to separate pupils into groups, with each group assigned to one of the four simulations. They can then either report their results to the others or move around to the next one. 4. Examine preventive measures using the Barton case study and a personal study near pupils' own homes. Notes on the student sheets 1. Background information on Folkestone Warren Introduction Folkestone Warren is located on the South Coast 2 km north-east of Folkestone itself. The Warren is an undercliff zone ofrough ground occupying up to 50 metres above sea level. Above it tower cliffs of Chalk, known as High Cliff and reaching 125 metres altitude. The Warren itselfis an area of contorted hummocky ground distorted by a series of lands lips, shown on the maps and photographs of the Student Sheets. The geology is simple and consists of nearly horizontal beds of sedimentary rock. The lowest formation is the 1~~I~f~rllll~llfll~l~m~1N07017
  • 3. Teacher Sheet 2 . Unit 8: Moving Ground FolkestoneBeds, which are sandstone. These are overlain by about 50 m ofa stiff blue clay, the Gaul t Clay, followed by the Chalk itself, which makes up the bulk of High Cliff, (see section, Figure 5). Historical Background Landslipshave been recorded since 1765, although the instability was largely ignored: the opening of the Dover Rail way in 1844 indicates this. (An alternative - a tunnel of 1.5 kIn length was considered impracticable). A major slip in 1877 caused partial collapse of the Martello Tunnel and closed the line for a time. The main collapse in 1915 moved almost the whole of the Warren towards the sea. The railway moved 55 m seaward and dropped about 6 m. This extended the coastline between 240 and 350 m. The train c~ught at the time was derailed by a 5 m step which developed in the track and parts of the track were buried by the Great Fall. There were other less serious slips in 1937 and 1940. This highlights the problem of containing natural phenomena. Causes The slides are considered to be the result of two main factors: 1. The Gault Clay may become unstable when saturated and pressure is applied by the weight of the overlying Chalk. This leads to failure at the junction with the Folkestone Beds. Shear movements develop and the clay slips. 2. The main direction of longshore drift ofbeach material is towards the east. This tends to starve East Wear Bay: of beach sediment and encourages slip within the Warren. Construction of harbour works at Folkestonesince the 17th Century has progressively worsened the natural situation. The 19th Century construction ofa masonry harbour led to further erosion within East Wear Bay. Successive pier extensions in 1863,1883 and 1905 have all been accompanied by landslip a few years later, the last severe one being in 1915, 10 years after the last harbour extension. Since then, movements have been minor, thanks to preventive measures such as toe weighting and drainage tunnels within the clays. The answers to questions 1.1 to 1.11 are largely self-explanatory from the text and diagrams in the Student Sheets. In 1.8, note that although most of the movement was downwards, the toe of the slip near the coast actually rose. 2. Why does ground move? The major factors, considered under the headings given, are as follows: Rock type composition (e.g. the presence of pyrite in a clay causes loss of strength when it weathers. See Student Sheet 6) strength (e.g. igneous rocks are usually strong, while fairly recently deposited sediments are not.) porosity & permeability (e.g. clays can hold much water inthe pore spaces, but will not let it pass through, thus lubricating slips.) Rock Structure bedding planes (provide weaknesses along which water can move and weathering and weakening can take place.) joints (have a similar effect, increased by the fact that joints, although further apart than bedding planes, are often vertical.) dip of beds (can be important because steeply dipping beds allow greater water penetration.) Rainfall intensity (heavy rainfall during storms can cause water build-up on the surface or underground, which results in rock failure.) seasonality (wet seasons may have a similar effect, even though the build-up is over a longer period) drought (the 1976 drought caused many clays to dry out and shrink, resulting in subsidence and
  • 4. Teacher Sheet 3 Unit 8: Moving Ground other failure.) salt spray (during storms increases weathering rates in coastal area.) Temperature Vegetation great temperature variation can lead to rock failure, as can repeated freezing and thawing. vegetation cover slows rates oferosion byreducing temperature variation and by the binding action of the roots. Human Activity e.g. road and rail cuttings removal of groundwater agriculture building The "answer sheet" is Fig TI. Discussion of these and related factors will lead on to the examination of other critical factors in more detail, such as: slope angle, height, load, etc. which are examined during the investigations. 3. Experiments in the Laboratory A) What is the angle of failure of different loose materials? These experi.ments show how different materials can support different slope angles. The angle of slope that can be supported by loose materials is controlled by : a) the wuys in which grains support one another. This in turn depends upon the packing of the grains, with closely packed grains being more stable and 'supportive' than loosely packed grains. It also depends upon grain shape because elongated grains can interlock, increasing stability. b) friction between the grains. Grains with smooth surfaces have low slope angles; once they become rougher (e.g. rusted ball bearings) they can support steeper slope angles. c) amount of water present. A little water causes the grains to cohere or stick together, more water acts as a lubricant and reduces friction, much water buoys up the grains, allowing them to flow more easily. Some effects of water are examined in experiment B. In rocks which are no longer loose materials, the situation is complicated by the amount, type and effectiveness of cement, by the effects of the compression by overlying rocks, by any changes in particle shape or type caused by increases of heat or pressure, by later fracturing, weathering, etc. The differences are highlighted where scree slopes are found beneath steeper rock faces, either in natural cliffs or in man-made cuttings. B) How does pressure of the pore water affect the strength of material?
  • 5. Teacher Sheet 4 Unit 8: Moving Ground The pressure exerted by water flowing through a material such as sand can be high enough to force the grains apart. This hydrostatic force can cause the sand to lose its strength and begin to flow, becoming a quicksand. In this simulation, the pressure exerted by the water is proportional to the height of the water column (head) above the level of the sand surface. At lower heads, water will flow but the bolt will not sink. This can happen naturally where permeable materials, like sands, are trapped between impermeable materials, like clay layers. Both materials were present in the Folkestone Warren situation. Sudden increases in hydrostatic pressures, with their catastrophic effects, can be seen with earthquake triggered slides, as in Anchorage, Alaska. Both sand and clay can display this almost gel-like quality (sometimes called thixotropic). Experimental follow-up could investigate the effects of different head pressures, different mixtures of materials, different thicknesses of materials, etc. C) What effects do underlying rocks have on slope failure? When porous materials (sand) lie above impermeable materials (clay) the sand can become saturated during storms, etc. The addition of more water causes the grain contacts to lose their friction and flow occurs under the influence of gravity. This effect can be seen quite frequently on motorway embankments, especially after heavy rain. D) What binds the grains together? When the water has evaporated, the sand castle made with distilled water will collapse, while the salt saturated sand will not, since the individual grains are glued together by the salt cement. This illustrates how weak sediments can be cemented to form stronger and more resistant sedimentary rocks. The importance ofthe composition ofthe cement can be illustrated by pouring boiling water over a piece ofsandstone and then over the salt-cemented sand castle. As the less effective cement dissolves, the 'rock' collapses. Calcium carbonate cements dissolve in acid rain and soil water; iron cements become weakened by oxidation and reaction with water, but silica cements are resistant to most weathering processes so that the toughest sedimentary rocks in the U.K. are usually bound by silica cements. These, therefore, tend to form the steepest natural rock faces, where other factors are not important. 4. Save the Barton Cliffs: Background Information. The main processes in operation in the cliff area are shown in Fig. 13 and can be grouped as: 1. Surface processes, such as mass movement and seepages along the cliffs. Weathering ofsuIphides such as pyrite is a contributory factor, although not quite so marked as at Folkestone. 2. Marine processes operating along the cliff foot and beaches. A combination of these mechanisms has resulted in average cliff recession rates of up to 1metre per year. Since 1960 remedial measures have been applied, with varying degrees of success. These have entailed twomain operations: 1. Protection of the clifffoot against wave attack as shown in Figure 12 and by scattering gabions along the beach to break the force of longshore currents and waves. Gabions are boxes made of woven metal bands filled with earth or rocks.
  • 6. Teacher Sheet 5 Unit 8: Moving Ground 2. Cliff face engineering works designed to intercept and reduce groundwater in order to stabilise the rock. The whole scheme has cost £1 million. It extends along 1800 m of coastline and was completed in 1968. Unfortu- nately, there has'never been a complete plan of action and remedial measures have been developed piecemeal. The sea has found the weakest points in the chain and broken through, as happened in the winter storms of197 4. Then, the revetment began to collapse and slip recurred. Since then, the authorities have decided to abandon highly technical defences and to resort to resupplying the beach with sand and pebbles and to allow natural erosion to operate in a controlled way. It is interesting to note that this method was used successfully in 1812 by William Smith, (the "father of English geology") at Holkham in Norfolk! 5. Preventing LandsIip: A Personal Study. Attem pts to stabilise man -made slopes are usually successful; otherwise the slope wouldhave been given a shall ower gradient. There are of course spectacular examples where calculations have been incorrect; some factors have not been taken into account; mistakes were made, or where very severe conditions were experienced! Natural slopes are, however, much more difficult and expensive to stabilise, and, in the long term, many of these attempts are doomed to failure. Coastal defences are particularly vulnerable and man's rearguard action against the sea has often proved unsuccessful in the past. Figure T2 Remedial measures at Barton-on-Sea
  • 7. Teacher Sheet 6 Unit 8: Moving Ground Further reading Other examples may be drawn from a wide variety of sources. Daily newspapers and magazines will often contain reports concerning slope movements, as there may often be loss of life. This type of information source will involve students, as they can readily acquire such materials. The Geographical Magazine, Geography Review, National Geographic and Geology Today will occasionally contain relevant articles. Study the Earth, Atherton. M. and Robinson, R. Hodder & Stoughton. The unit - Water at Work has useful simulations of geological processes. Catastrophe: The Violent Earth. Waltham, T. Macmillan. Contains an exciting chapter on landslips, plus good reference material for teachers. Geology and Man. Watson, J. Allen & Unwin. Chapter 6 deals with earth movements, in context ofreservoirs and coasts. Experiments in Physical Sedimentation. Allen, J.R.L. Allen & Unwin. Contains a wealth of experiments designed to illustrate sedimentary principles and processes. High Roads and Low Roads. Carter, P. and Wallace, G. Article in Geology Today, March/April, 1987 pp. 54 to 59. A colour slide (CT3) of the view in Fig. 2 is available from the Geological Museum, London, price 30p. Acknowledgements This Unit devised by Simon Elsy. Grateful thanks are expressed to: The Curator of the Cambridge University Collection of Air Photographs, for permission to publish Fig. 2. British Rail, Southern Region, for allowing the use of the photograph in Fig. 3. Dr. J.E. Robinson for his helpful comments on the manuscript of the Unit. Mrs. H. Busteed and Mr. A. Birchall for diagrams and artwork. Published by the Association of Teachers of Geology. Designed and printed by Geo-Supplies, Sheffield. The publication of this series of Units has been made possible by financial support from the Geologists' Association Fund, which is gratefully acknowledged. Copyright. There is no copyright on original material published in this Unit, if it is required for use within the laboratory or classroom. Copyright material reproduced by permission of other publishers rests with the originating publishers. "Science of the Earth" Units are obtainable from: ATG - Ms F Stratton, Sandbourne, Clophill Road, Maulden, Beds, MK45 2AA. GA - The Geologists' Association, Burlington House, Piccadilly, London, WI V 9AG. Geo-Supplies, 16 Station Road, Chapeltown, Sheffield, S30 4XH.
  • 8. Student Sheet 1 Unit 8:Moving Ground Major earthquakes are uncommon in the British Isles and so we tend to take it for granted that our land is .safe and will not move. However, it is possible for land on steep cliffs and hillsides to give way. ,When this happens it can prove disastrous for the people who live there or for roads and railways built across such areas. We are going to study a famous example of moving ground, near Folkestone in Kent, to find out what causes land to give way. Later, you will be able to carry out some experiments to test your ideas about landslip and then devise your own scheme for protecting another part of the south coast from this haz- ard. 1. Folkestone Warren The map (Fig. 1) shows the location of Folkestone Warren. It also shows the Folkestone to Dover railway, built in 1844. Study the map and the photograph and answer the questions which follow. English Channel N 1 Clifftop above landslide East Wear Bay 'Copt Point '0 Km 1 oLandslip area Proposed site of marina, abandoned due to unstable cliff at Copt Point Figure 1. Location of Folkestone Warren. Erosion is the removal of sediment. In this coastal area, 1.1 What processes of erosion are taking place? 1.2 What evidence can you see that the land surface is moving because it is unstable? 1.3 How might land movements affect the use of the area?
  • 9. student Sheet 2 Unit 8: Moving Ground Figure 2. Oblique aerial view looking North -east, taken in 1976, showing details of the western part of Folkestone WaITen (copyright reserved, Cambridge University). 1.4 What evidence can you see of attempts to stop erosion and land movement? 1.5 Estimate the area of land affected by slipping (in km2). You will probably have realised that llluch of the area, especially belov the railway track, has slid downhill. One of the most disastrous slips occurred in 1915. Read the account overleaf vhich summarises the main events during the landslip. Use the accompa- nying maps and section to locate the areas mentioned. Study the photos. (Figs. 1 to 5).
  • 10. Student Sheet 3 Unit 8: Moving Ground Summary of the sequence of events as reported in 'The Folkestone Express" and 'The Folkestone Herald" during the Folkestone Warren landslip on the 19th December 1915.. Shortly after 6.00 pm Watchman noticed subsidence in the railway track at the Martello Tunnel end of the Warren. Gave his red light to soldiers to stop the expected 6.10pm train from Ashford. He went to telephone the station at Folkestone. About 6.3Opm Start ofthe Big Fall at the cliffface, seen by the soldiers at Warren Halt. Occupants of the 'Eagles Nest' notice their ceiling beginning to crack. About 6.35pm They try to leave but find doorsjammed and climb out of the windows. Platelayer arrives at Abbotscliff signal box and tells signalman to put signals at danger because of the fall. 6.36-6.4Opm 'Eagles Nest' occupants reach the end of their garden and see the start of the Great Fall to their east. Signalman, platelayer and 3 soldiers run from the signalbox as the cliffbehind starts to fall. Signalman feels rails go down 'quite a foot' as he leaves his box. 6.38-6.43pm Start of the Great Fall. This turned into a flow slide burying the rail-line under 13 metres of debris for a length of 250 metres and ran out to sea for 350 metres. Just after 6.45 pm The 6.10 pm Ashford to Dover train leaves Folkestone junction, fortunately a little late, with 130 pas- sengers. About 6.5Opm Train brakes suddenly as it emerges from the Martello Tunnel into the Warren on seeing soldiers with red lamps. About 6.50-7.10pm Passengers wait in the train while the engine and front carriages sink slowly down with the continu- ing movements. About 7.1Opm Guard asks passengers to leave the train. Soldiers escort them on foot back to Folkestone junction through the Martello Tunnel.
  • 11. Student Sheet 4 Unit 8: Moving Ground Figure 3. The dramatic effects of the slip of 1915. The train had just emerged from the Martello Tunnel. I"Var:en Halt signal box - before N I c:::J after 300m East Wear Bay L.--.I A "} '.,, .>/ position of rail line after slip { ,I original rai11ineFigure 4. Sketch map of Folkestone Warren showing features formed as a result of the 1915slip. Note the movements of the railway line, the change in shore line, the new positions of the Warren Halt signal box and the "Eagle's Nest". o Folkestone Beds (sands) B Sea level Railway cutting "" Possible curved planes Ground surface along which slip has before 1915 slip been most concentrated ........J........ ..., ..........Lower Chalk Gault Clay 50 100 150 nl above A sea level Figure 5. Cross-section of part of Folkestone Warren along line AB.
  • 12. Student Sheet 5 Unit 8:Moving Ground When you have gained a good idea of what happened, try to answer the following questions:- 1.6 How has the position of the railway line, shown in the photo, map and cross section, changed? 1.7 What does the cross section show was the cause of these changes? 1.8 At points X and Y, measure the amount of vertical movements caused by the slip and say vhether it was upwards or downwards. 1.9 Was the slip a single event or a series of events? 1.10 How long did the whole landslip event take? 1.11 What are the first signs of lands lip? 2. Why does ground move? Now we need to find out what factors cause grou~d to move. 2.1 Working in small groups, examine this drawing (Fig. 6) and list as many factors as possible which might affect how stable the slope will be. Try to include some of the factors that were active at Folkestone Warren. As a guide, think of points under the following headings: Rock type Temperature Rock structure Vegetation Rainfall Man's activities Figure 6. Some clues to the factors which may cause ground to move.
  • 13. Student Sheet 6 Unit 8: Moving Ground When you have finished, ask your teacher for an "answer sheet" which shows you the factors which geologists and engineers have found to be important. The factors which you have listed are all linked with one another so that change in one may cause others to change too. Generally, slopes become less stable when: the slope angle becomes steeper. extra material is dumped at the top of the slope. material is removed from the base of the slope. the weight of rock is increased by water seeping in. the strength of rock is decreased by water seeping in. the groundwater level rises, causing water logging. vegetation, whose roots bind the material together is removed. chemical changes take place within the rock. On coasts, much material is continually removed from the base of the slope by the erosive action of the sea. At Folkestone, the effects of chemical changes within the rock are especially drastic. The Gault Clay contains a lot of the mineral called pyrite, sometimes known as "fool's gold". Chemically, it consists of iron sulphide (FeS2 ). When exposed to air and moisture, this changes to sulphate minerals. As the change occurs it causes the clay to swell, rather as yeast does in bread dough. Heatis given off by the reaction and this also causes the clay to crack. Taken together, these processes lead to the rapid dis- in tegration of the clay, which then slips very easily under the weight of overlying rock. When Man -made slopes are being constructed, the engineers calculate "safe" angles for the slopes. For example, in the London Clay, which is a notoriously unreliable foundation rock, the slope of a cutting has to be as low as 80 to be safe! It is possible to test some of the factors in the list above by simple experiments and this is the object of the next section. . 3. Experiments in the laboratory A) What is the angle of failure in different loose materials? In these experiments you will find out how steep a slope has to be before it fails or slips. How important is the type of material in the slope? To find out, use the method below. 1. Collect the apparatus from your teacher. 2. Cut the cardboard into a narrow ring with the outside diameter a little less than the bottle. Mark on this ring with a protractor a scale with 5 degree intervals and stick the ring to the bottom of the bottle.
  • 14. Student Sheet 7 Unit 8: Moving Ground Value B when surface of material is on point of collapse i Value A when surface of material is horizontal Reference point where bottle touches table Card marked with angles and glued to base of bottle -+ Figure 7. Measurement of the angle of failure in different materials. 3. Halffill the bottle with the sample ofmaterial your teacher has given you. Screw on the top tightly. 4. Lay the bottle on its side and roll it round a few times to allow your sample to pack evenly. 5. Return your sample to the horizontal (you may check this with a spirit level). Record the value of the angle where the bottle and bench touch. Call this value A. 6. Rotate the bottle until the sand begins to collapse. At this point, record the value of the angle at the bottle/table contact. Call this angle B. Find the angle of slope failure by subtracting A from B. Record your result for this material. 7. Repeat the experiment 3 times. Calculate and record the average result. 8. Carry out the experiment for different materials, first dry and then with varying amounts ofwater. Record all your results. 9. Answer the following questions on the basis of your results: 3.1 What effect does a little water have on your results? 3.2 What effect does a lot of water have on your results? 3.3 What effect does the size of the grains of material have on your results? 3.4 What effect does the shape of the grains of material have on your results? 3.5 Can you relate any of your findings to the slope failure at Folkestone Warren? Give details.
  • 15. Student Sheet 8 Unit 8: Moving Ground B) How does the pressure of the pore water affect the strength of material? When the water between the grains is under enough pressure it can force the grains apart. Test the effect of this using the method below: 1. Connect a burette filled with water to a container filled with sorted sand as shown in the diagram (Fig. 8). . 2. Add water to the sand un til it is completely filled. The water levels in the sand and burette should be the same with the connecting tap open. . 3. Now close the connecting tap and add a heavy object to the top of the sand. 4. Add water to the burette until its level is 3 times the thickness ofthe sand above the sand surface level. 5. Now open the tap and observe the effects. Record your observations. 6. Close the tap to stop the water flow and add a second similar heavy object to the sand surface. Record your observations. Use the apparatus to investigate the water pressures necessary to cause failure in different sizes ~nd mixtures of sediment. Some of your results could be plotted on a graph of water pressure (height of water) against grain size. 3.6 How do you think this experiment might help to explain the Folkestone Warren slip? T .-- water level bolt head 1.~__ burette .-- initial water level sand 'fine mesh to retain ---------.-.-- sand yet allow water to pass funnel tap Figure 8. Equipment for testing the effects of pore water pressure on the strength of sediment.
  • 16. Student Sheet 9 Unit 8: Moving Ground C) What effects do underlying rocks have on slope failure? Try the following imitation of a sequence of dipping sediments: 1. Set up the apparatus as shown in Fig. 9. 2. Measure the angle of sediment slope. 3. Use a watering can to slowly spray 1/2 litre of water onto the sand while observing the slope carefully. Record your observations. 4. Set up the apparatus again with a different slope and repeat the experiment. 5. Repeat the experiment with no clay layer. ,3.7 How does the angle of slope and the clay layer affect your results? 3.8 Refer back to figure 5 and say how this experiment might help to explain the Folkestone Warren slip. damp sand 2cm deep packed clay (an impermeable layer that will not allow water to .pass through) tank or •• --- box Figure 9. Equipment to test the effects of different layers of rock on slope stability. D) What binds the grains together? Investigate how grains are bound together and the effects of different types of"grain glue" by carrying out the instructions below: 1. Take two 250ml glass beakers and fill them with dry sand. 2. Saturate the sand in one beaker with distilled water. 3. Make a supersaturated solution of salt by heating some water and adding salt until no more will dissolve. Saturate the sand in the other beaker with this salt solution. 4. Turn the 'sand castles' out of the two beakers and leave to dry on a tray. This can be speeded up in an oven. 5. Observe and explain the results.
  • 17. Student Sheet 10 Unit 8:Moving Ground 3.9 How do the effects you observed in your experiment affect natural slopes in loose sediments? 3.10 What will happen in natural rock outcrops where the material ~ementing the grains together is an easily dissolved material? Naturally occurring cements in rocks include silica (Si02 ), calcium carbonate (CaC03 ) and various iron oxides. 3.11 Which one of these would you expect to be most soluble in acid rain water? 4. Save the Barton Cliffs You can now apply what you have learned from your studies and experiments to a real problem on the south coast. Study the information below and carry out the instructions. Barton-on-Sea is a small town in Christchurch Bay (see Fig. 10). On the beach the waves come in at an angle. As they break and run up the beach, they move the sediment up the beach at an angle. The water and sediment then drain straight back down the beach. This causes both water and sediment to move steadily along the beach, as show in Fig. 11. Portsmouth Christchurch ~ Direction of longshore drift. N o I Km 10 I Figure 10. Location of Barton on Sea, shaded areas represent unstable coastlines.
  • 18. Student Sheet 11 Unit 8: Moving Ground Direction of longshore drift Le..general movement of water and sand. . •••.. -----~ Figure!l. The process of Longshore Drift Beach Sea Coastal engineers have tried to keep the ·sand near Barton to attract the holiday makers. To do this they have built a series of groynes out from the beach so that the sand can build up behind them. Unfortunately this has starved areas further along the coast of sand. Thus the beaches, and eventually the cliffs, are being eroded. Erosion of the base of the cliffs together with seepages of water from above have caused the cliffs to slip. The slip material is then carried away along the beach. These processes are causing cliff erosion rates of up to 1metre per year. 4.1 Solve the Problem Fig. 12 shows several different ways in which cliff slip and erosion problems can be tackled. g.c:el ~P'dltt. hd; Su/;+omcL bypo~4t1L ~eLcCl.bles ~on.cL~ Slof.e." Figure 12. Preventive measures used on natural slopes
  • 19. Student Sheet 12 Unit 8: Moving Ground Fig. 13 is a sketch block-diagram of the cliffs at Barton, showing some of the problems mentioned earlier in the text. M~c..etosicn oK.f>.use. - jnshlbiU1y of cJa,ys CLt)cL ternoVQlrcf' la.nclslip ma, . ",' ' ....•.. •.. •. llU ,.....•-._- - - ---- - - •... - ""~ . ~l')beHrt~( . r d~ SafJ- ~~ 'oJie "Ba.ritw. day ~ Figure 13. Sketch block diagram of the Barton Cliffs. Redraw the diagram and use it to show your ideas for the prevention of slip and erosion. Use Fig. 12 to help you, together with any methods which you might have seen in your travels to the seaside, or your own home area. Describe how you hope each of your measures would work. Remember that many of the processes of slip and erosion are linked, so try to deal with all the problems, not just one. 5. Preventing landslip: A personal study 5.1 Find a place near your home where civil engineers have tried to prevent landslip. This might be a road or railway cutting, a natural cliff or a Man-made one. From a safe vantage point, such as a bridge or pavement, try to spot t~e methods which have been used. Use Fig. 14 as a guide. Do NOT walk on railway tracks or roadvays or go too close to the foot of any cliff. The best method of recording might be a labelled sketch or photograph, with something on it to show the scale.
  • 20. Student Sheet 13 Unit 8: Moving Ground 5.2 To what extent have the engineers been successful? 5.3 Could you have done any better? -Pa"" ,t¥c:10S looSt,pleck. s~ecL+O ~e9s wiHl S#'eel cables 1?c;c.k an c.hClt:S" li>o(t:s'"fbf;>~)* ~)o."h.d..t>/o~ ~m $ICtlJNt,.J 1>~ .t....., beelCo'led..- ttt So.nd.. ~Gl jt11rVe.t Figure 14. Preventive measures used in an artificial cutting. 5.4. Watch out for newspaper reports of the progress of the Channel Tunnel. It is due to emerge from the Gault Clay near Folkestone and some geologists predict that the site may not be the best that could have been chosen!
  • 21. Unit 8: Moving Ground Answer Sheet : External Factors Porosity and Penneability /' IRock Type I ~ Jointing Dip of Beds Internal Factors I Seepage I~ Groundwater Changing Levels Slope Angle Figure TI The slope system components. The various factors contributing to the stability or instability of slopes. Slope angles can vary widely. Variation of one component may lead to a general readjustment of equilibrium through slope movement.