This document discusses the indoctrination tactics used by religious and extremist groups to recruit and radicalize young people. It describes how groups isolate recruits, control their daily lives, discourage independent thinking, demand absolute loyalty, and use emotional and intense rituals to reinforce the group's beliefs. The document asserts that most people acquire their religious beliefs through childhood indoctrination by parents and communities, rather than through rational thinking. It warns that failing to overcome this adolescent tendency to prioritize the group can hinder development into a mature, independent adult.
2. My boy, YOU DON'T ASK ME A QUESTION.
'You answer it'.
You just use me as a tool to reinforce your belief.
If your religion is using others, it shows clearly that
religion is a plague to get rid of as soon as possible.
3. IF YOU WERE HONEST.
The question WOULD BE;
- Is there a god WHO MAKES THIS BIRD FLY?
4. Whereas your question, which is not a question, is.
There is a bird that flies, and it is God that makes it fly.
And you ask me to confirm your question WHICH IS AN
ANSWER.
5. This is the old debate between atheists and theists, and
for atheists who are less mentally articulated. Young
Atheists who still fall INTO THE THEISTIC TRAP in which
THEY WERE PUT VERY SMALL.
For the mentally articulate atheists, they have understood
that this is in fact a statement from theists, AND THAT
THERE IS NO QUESTION BEHIND IT.
6. But since there is no question. IT PLAYS FOR THE THEISTS
WHO OCCUPY SOCIAL TIME AND SOCIAL SPACE. In
the end, that is the point for theists; OCCUPY THE
PUBLIC SPHERE.
7. Religion IF TAKEN AS SUCH AS A PUBLIC MATTER, is
to be socially forbidden.
A religion 'has no place in public affairs'.
Religion is a matter of private affairs.
8. THE PROBLEM IS NOT that I believe in God or not, the
problem is that you are not able to answer your own
questions.
And that you are not a real individual able to walk alone
without the help of the group.
A society is a collection of individuals, a society is not a
group.
If you want collectivism, read Marx, join the Communist
party, go live in China.
If you think that the group in which you have been
indoctrinated is going to support you socially when you
are going to do something stupid for them, you are beyond
naivety.
9. These people use you like you use people.
What you don't understand is that SOCIETY will Bend the
group you're IN ONE WAY OR ANOTHER.
The only group that is able to exist in society is society itself.
This is the only group in which you must find your place.
10. Now you have two choices in your life “young theist”;
- Either you break away from the religion group you were
brought into, and you will be able to have an
independent life of your own;
- Or you stay in this tiny group, and you will always be used
by them.
11. SO THE REAL QUESTION BEHIND is:
"Do you HAVE THE BALLS TO STAND ON YOUR OWN
TWO FEET ALONE" and face the others members of
society, and thus be a citizen of the city.
12. From Critical Thinking : The Antidote For Faith by Wayne
Bartz:
“Indoctrination: Once you take the hook, be it AMWAY’s,
the Marines’, or Brother Billy Bob’s, inevitably the next
step involves some form of indoctrination. AMWAY will
put you in a training program with rah-rah lectures, tapes,
and written materials. “Boot camp” is the military version,
a place where the upbeat promises of cheerful recruiters
will fade, becoming distant and fantasy-like. The groups
we like to call cults often place recruits in an
indoctrination situation much like a military boot-camp,
isolated from family and friends, with daily life totally
under the control of a new “family.”
13. RECRUITS are told when to eat, sleep, wake, pray, and
work, what to read, watch, say, and ultimately, WHAT
TO THINK.
They may be sleep-deprived, ISOLATED, screamed at,
prayed for, deprived of food or water, all of which is
unexpected, unfamiliar, and EMOTIONALLY INTENSE.
Some cults use outright trickery to lure prospects into high
pressure indoctrination. Imagine you are a young man
stepping off a bus in an unfamiliar city. You look around
the bus station and an attractive young woman strolling
by stops, smiles and says, “Hi, you look like you’re lost.
Need directions?” If you are a typical young male, your
eager hormones pop to attention and you wonder if this
friendly town might be the right place for you. After some
chit-chat (during which Honey Sweetcakes determines that
14. you are from out of town and on your own), she dangles a
hook covered with attractive bait.
“Hey, if you haven’t got a place to stay, I’m living with
some great people at a beautiful ranch outside town. We
can always make room for one more. Like to come along?”
Gee, a tough decision. Once you get to the “ranch” you find
yourself inside a remote, fenced and gated compound,
and if you ask to return to the city you discover that
unfortunately no vehicles are going back tonight... maybe
tomorrow? You also quickly discover that
INDOCTRINATION BEGINS TONIGHT.
To recap, most groups recruit new members by offering
something (perhaps bending the truth a bit) and provide
15. some form of indoctrination (“training”) AFTER A
RECRUIT SIGNS UP.
That is true of the Boy Scouts, the Democratic Party, the
Catholic Church, the Elvis Fan Club, you name it.”
IN MY ANARCHIST DAYS at a very young age, I had
learned that ANY GROUP 'WAS TO BE FLED'.
THIS ADVICE HAS NEVER LEFT ME.
That's why I hate nationalism, which is just a group in
society, but which pretends TO BE THE GROUP.
IT'S FALSE.
16. “Inspiration: Many groups offer an inspirational message
that attempts to provide meaning to life beyond the
mundane cycle of eat/work/sleep/die. They offer a sense of
purpose, be it through patriotism, belongingness, financial
independence, the “truth,” or perhaps God. An
inspirational message can be highly motivating, not only
as a reason for joining a group, but also as a reason for
remaining in a group and standing up for it in times of
need. (“IT’S THEM OR US.”)”
THIS DUALITY IS PROPER TO RELIGION, which serves
to separate men and NOT TO BRING THEM TOGETHER.
17. “Ritualistic Behavior: Most groups routinely engage in
rituals, from reading the minutes of previous meetings to
singing the school song or reciting a group prayer. Cults
tend to embrace and celebrate ritual, often lengthy,
repetitive and mind-numbing. Recruits may spend hours
in individual or group chants, prayers, listening to tapes of
“father,” sitting silently and contemplating eternity, or
engaging in intensive repetitious activity such as farming,
begging money, or manufacturing products for sale to the
public.
In a cult, your role is always spelled out for you, assigned
and required of you to the letter.
Ritual may include even the most trivial aspects of life,
such as what kind of toothpaste to use, how to trim your
toenails or comb your hair.
18. IF YOU SPEND ALL YOUR TIME DOING EXACTLY
WHAT YOU ARE TOLD, precisely in the manner spelled
out, you may be left with little time to think for yourself.
In fact, you have no need to.
Anti-Intellectualism: Most groups to some degree
discourage independent critical thought. You don’t
challenge the sales methods spelled out by Mary Kay, you
don’t suggest to an Army drill sergeant a better way of
stripping and cleaning your weapon, and you don’t inform
your scoutmaster that you have serious doubts about the
benefit of marching around in para-military uniforms
saluting elderly authority figures. But the anti-
intellectualism of cults again jumps ahead of other groups,
embracing what physicist and science historian Jacob
19. Bronowski called The Eleventh Commandment: “THOU
SHALT NOT QUESTION!”
ALL RELIGIONS EMBRACE THE 11TH
COMMANDMENT to some degree and discourage openly
questioning accepted doctrine, but cults push it to the
limit.
A cult-compound wall-poster summarized one group’s
zealous approach in no uncertain terms: “THE MIND IS
SATAN AND THINKING IS THE MACHINERY OF THE
DEVIL.”
Cult members are typically required TO HAVE
ABSOLUTE FAITH in the leader, the group, and its
teachings, and to keep wayward thoughts quiet or face the
consequences.
20. Those could involve verbal abuse, expulsion from the
group, being given the silent treatment, being physically
punished, OR LOCKED UP.
Loyalty: While loyalty to family, friends, and country is
often held up as a virtue, unbridled and unlimited loyalty
may be more appealing in a pet than in a human being.
Excessive loyalty is embodied in the slogan, “My country,
right or wrong!” Good Americans should stand up for
America no matter what, right? Yet we look at Germany
during World War II and wonder why its citizens didn’t
turn against their government. Weren’t they
demonstrating loyalty by standing behind their country,
right or wrong, thus being “good Germans”? And if they
had turned away, wouldn’t they have been guilty of
21. treason? Obsessive nationalism, loyalty to one’s country no
matter what, has long been a sad human weakness.
When Hitler came to power in Germany, loyalty was
carried to another level.
Members are expected to publicly proclaim their belief in
their leader, sometimes including the notion that he or she
is God, Messiah, or the rebirth of Christ.
Members of Jim Jones’ People’s Temple were required to
show absolute loyalty by reporting negative comments
uttered by anyone. If someone heard something negative
and failed to report it, that failure was a punishable
offense, including for children who failed to rat out their
parents (shades of the Hitler Youth).”
22. From Faith Versus Fact: Why Science and Religion Are
Incompatible by Jerry A. Coyne, Joe Barrett, et al.:
“But the main reason people turn a blind eye toward
implausible beliefs is that they get their faith not through
reason or deliberation, but through indoctrination from
their family and friends.
Most people acquire their faith when young via
indoctrination by parents, teachers, or peers, so that
religious “truths” depend heavily on who spawned you and
where you grew up.”
From So You Think You Can Think: Tools for Having
Intelligent Conversations and Getting Along by Christopher
W. DiCarlo:
23. “It is impossible for infants, toddlers, and young children
TO RATIONALLY THINK ABOUT RELIGIOUS
DOCTRINE that is taught to them by their parents and
practiced and celebrated throughout their communities.
It is not until a person REACHES A CERTAIN AGE OF
MATURITY that they begin to question their religious
beliefs.
By far, one of the greatest appeals to religious practice is
the communal sense of support that can be found when
like-minded individuals gather for a common purpose.”
24. THE GROUP WHICH CONSTITUTES THE TEENAGE
BAND, unfortunately, this childish-adolescent stage should
be overcome before reaching adulthood.
For most adult Westerners THIS IS NOT THE CASE.
They regularly exhibit this IMMATURE BEHAVIOR that
they should 'have abandoned in their late teens'.
25. From Crosswinds: The Way of Saudi Arabia by Fouad Ajami:
“But some doors are made to be broken, not opened, the
narrator says in The 20th Terrorist. The young boy was
now willing to defy his parents. There was the
companionship of soccer camps, and there was steady
religious indoctrination. He came to despise his family
members; he wanted them to rid themselves of their
television set, to remove the photographs in the household,
to banish music—much beloved in Asir. He told his father
that he was robbing the family of its share in paradise. He
took on the habits of the jamaa (the group). He donned a
shin-length thoub, he grew a long beard, he mimicked the
affectations of the group. “We learned that ours is a world
of unbelievers,” he said. “We were the band of the saved,
all the others were condemned.” He wondered how his
26. group and its leaders financed its activities; he learned that
they did it through theft, and that theft from the state in
the interest of jihad was pleasing to Allah.”
27. BEHIND THIS ADOLESCENT REBELLION, which is now
taken up even earlier by the sects, is the challenge of the
father, of the Adult as a Figure.
It should be noted that monotheism HAS BEEN STRIVING
SINCE ITS BEGINNING to remove the 'Rites of passage' to
Adulthood.
These groups (cults) have taken 'this hole created by
monotheism'.
28. THERE IS NO PASSAGE TO ADULTHOOD without
initiation of one Kind or Another.
The being that we are needs that; 'WE ARE A BEING OF
INTELLECT';
An initiation IS NECESSARY because 'we are intellectual
beings'.
29. Initiation which is forbidden in the Bourgeois Democracy
that is the FORM THAT SUCCEEDED 'THE ANCIENT
PERIOD'.
30. From Online Terrorist Propaganda, Recruitment, and
Radicalization by John R. Vacca:
“The first, anti-monarchy and separatism phase was
characterized by small, local cells within an overall
hierarchical structure. Recruitment was top-down, largely
face-to-face, and radicalization occurred within the cell as
an internal result of socialization, training, and
indoctrination. The impetus to join and act came from a
combination of the nature of the terrorism of the day—
propaganda of the deed (the act and its violence conveying
the group's message)—and the nature of the
GRIEVANCE AGAINST THE MONARCH.”
IT IS THE SAME PRINCIPLE of rebellion against the
father, against the Authority, that's why I often say 'that all
31. revolution is bourgeois, middle-class. It's a Rebellion
AGAINST ORDER, THAT IS TO SAY AGAINST SOCIETY.
If you read the HISTORY OF REVOLUTIONS, you will
always see 'this idea' of Revolt Against Order.
32. "ISIS has proven to be innovative and tech savvy in terms
of fully exploiting the various platforms and tools to
spread their message including the live-streaming of
attacks, recruiting of new members, indoctrination, and
inciting individuals and terrorist CELLS TO VIOLENCE."
It is for this reason of violence that all these groups must
be stopped, at the expense of those young people
indoctrinated in them. I mean even if it means killing
them, if they pose a VIOLENT THREAT TO SOCIETY.
IF THESE YOUNG PEOPLE ARE NOT CAPABLE OF
INTEGRATING INTO SOCIETY, THEN NO MERCY
SHOULD COME TO THEM.