The Cathedral And The Data Bazaar
Enabling Lean Data
@vaibhavb
Who is Vaibhav?
DIRECTOR OF PRODUCT MANAGEMENT, OPTUM
AUTHOR, O’REILLY MEDIA
TWITTER – @vaibhavb
BLOG – http://healthblog.vitraag.com
ME – http://about.me/vaibhavb
Hobbies: Interactive Furniture, Mixology,
Cycling, Mountaineering
Associations: United States Cycling
Federation (USCF) Referee
Agenda
• The Cathedral model for Healthcare Data
• The Bazaar - Lean Data
• Clinical Data Connectivity
– Purpose
– Access
– Security
– Sharing
Problem with current model(s)
• Central Monolithic design with too many interdependencies
• Hard to see value when doing data aggregation
• At scale & adoption issues for data sets released
– Open Data
– Meaningful Use Mandated data
• Design by committee
ONC “Learning Health System” Roadmap
• 10 years!
• Over 50 use cases
• A standards advisory issued every year
Picture
Bazaar – Lean Data
• A bare bones simple platform
• Participants can create and absorb value independently
• Data is judged and consumed by value!
Lean Data – A Case Study
Value Based Consumers
Paper
Charts
EMRs
Labs
Clinical Data
Aggregation
Purpose First!
• Drive Measures
– ABA: Adult BMI Assessment
– CDC-LDL: Comprehensive Diabetes Care & LDL screening
– ..
Pillars of Access
• Transport
• Format
• Semantics
Data Transport
• Secure FTP
• XDS.B
• Direct
• Proprietary REST API
• FHIR REST API
Format
• Proprietary CSV Files
• HL7 V2 (ADT, ORU etc.)
• C32
• CCDA
• FHIR JSON
Semantics
• Problems
– ICD 9/ 10
– SNOMED-CT
• Procedures
– CPT
• Labs
– LOINC
• For example BMI values require SNOMED-CT codes
Security
• Self Signed X509 Certificates
– SFTP
– SSL Mutual Authentication (XDS.B/ REST API)
• Direct Certificates & Identity Proofing
– Direct
• O-Auth2
– FHIR
16
Sharing – Data Access
• Data Access
– Simple
• Member Demographics (First Name, Last Name etc.) shared with
Data Provider
• Data Shared only on a full match!
– Standards Based
• IHE PIX/PDQ
17
Sharing – Data Use
• Data Use established per use-case / measure
• Eventual standards based – XACML
• Data shared with HEDIS engines through network share in flat files –
Lean!
18
Data Value == Data Freedom
• When you are freeing the data make sure there is immediate value!
• Choose Lean vs. end all be all
• Establish valid crawl, walk run approaches for
– Access
– Security
– Sharing
Thank You!
Questions?
TWITTER – @vaibhavb
BLOG – http://healthblog.vitraag.com
ME – http://about.me/vaibhavb

The Cathedral And Data Bazaar - Enabling Lean Data!

  • 1.
    The Cathedral AndThe Data Bazaar Enabling Lean Data @vaibhavb
  • 2.
    Who is Vaibhav? DIRECTOROF PRODUCT MANAGEMENT, OPTUM AUTHOR, O’REILLY MEDIA TWITTER – @vaibhavb BLOG – http://healthblog.vitraag.com ME – http://about.me/vaibhavb Hobbies: Interactive Furniture, Mixology, Cycling, Mountaineering Associations: United States Cycling Federation (USCF) Referee
  • 3.
    Agenda • The Cathedralmodel for Healthcare Data • The Bazaar - Lean Data • Clinical Data Connectivity – Purpose – Access – Security – Sharing
  • 5.
    Problem with currentmodel(s) • Central Monolithic design with too many interdependencies • Hard to see value when doing data aggregation • At scale & adoption issues for data sets released – Open Data – Meaningful Use Mandated data • Design by committee
  • 6.
    ONC “Learning HealthSystem” Roadmap • 10 years! • Over 50 use cases • A standards advisory issued every year
  • 7.
  • 9.
    Bazaar – LeanData • A bare bones simple platform • Participants can create and absorb value independently • Data is judged and consumed by value!
  • 10.
    Lean Data –A Case Study Value Based Consumers Paper Charts EMRs Labs Clinical Data Aggregation
  • 11.
    Purpose First! • DriveMeasures – ABA: Adult BMI Assessment – CDC-LDL: Comprehensive Diabetes Care & LDL screening – ..
  • 12.
    Pillars of Access •Transport • Format • Semantics
  • 13.
    Data Transport • SecureFTP • XDS.B • Direct • Proprietary REST API • FHIR REST API
  • 14.
    Format • Proprietary CSVFiles • HL7 V2 (ADT, ORU etc.) • C32 • CCDA • FHIR JSON
  • 15.
    Semantics • Problems – ICD9/ 10 – SNOMED-CT • Procedures – CPT • Labs – LOINC • For example BMI values require SNOMED-CT codes
  • 16.
    Security • Self SignedX509 Certificates – SFTP – SSL Mutual Authentication (XDS.B/ REST API) • Direct Certificates & Identity Proofing – Direct • O-Auth2 – FHIR 16
  • 17.
    Sharing – DataAccess • Data Access – Simple • Member Demographics (First Name, Last Name etc.) shared with Data Provider • Data Shared only on a full match! – Standards Based • IHE PIX/PDQ 17
  • 18.
    Sharing – DataUse • Data Use established per use-case / measure • Eventual standards based – XACML • Data shared with HEDIS engines through network share in flat files – Lean! 18
  • 19.
    Data Value ==Data Freedom • When you are freeing the data make sure there is immediate value! • Choose Lean vs. end all be all • Establish valid crawl, walk run approaches for – Access – Security – Sharing
  • 20.
    Thank You! Questions? TWITTER –@vaibhavb BLOG – http://healthblog.vitraag.com ME – http://about.me/vaibhavb