This power point includes Definition ,the Focus of the Investigation ?,How to carry out a content analysis, Kinds of textual analysis , The advantages and disadvantages of content analysis.
1. H E L I N A W .
J U N , 2 0 2 3
Textual/content Analysis
2. Presentation outline
Definition
What is the Focus of the Investigation ?
How to carry out a content analysis.
Kinds of textual analysis
What are the advantages and disadvantages of content
analysis?
3. Definition
It is a research tool.
help to analyze the actual content and its features of
any kind
Word
Picture
Themes
Text
Concepts
Phrases
Characters
Sentences
Sometimes used to describe both quantitative and
qualitative approaches
4. Definition (cont…)
‘content analysis can be effective in qualitative
analysis—that "counts" of textual elements merely
provide a means for identifying, organizing, indexing,
and retrieving data.’
• Bruce L., Berg ,2001
5. Texts
Books
Book chapters
News paper headlines and articles
Essays
Interviews
Conversations
Films
Photo
Historical documents
Advertising
Informal conversations
Speeches
Websites
discussions
6. Focus of the Investigation
identification and interpretation of a set of verbal or
nonverbal signs.
7. The Role of the Researcher
the analyst of the selected text or texts
there are an unlimited number of possible
interpretations of any given text
only one of many possible valid interpretations of a
given text
8. Focus on Meaning
Meaning is fundamental to textual analysis.
Meaning can be examined from the side of
the speaker ’ s intention
the audience ’ s feedback
the historical or cultural milieu in which the text was produced
or the existing historical and cultural background in which the text
is experienced today
9. Where Do we Do Textual Analysis?
wherever you find a text
Any object or verbal or visual text that carries symbolic
meaning is a source for textual analysis
a film
a speech
an advertisement
A magazine
a book
a television show
a statue or memorial
a landscape
or a music video
news report
are all texts that carry interpretive meaning
10. Kind of textual analysis
1/ Rhetorical perspective: persuasion and influence
texts have meanings and meanings influence people
we experience culture through texts.
2/ Critical studies perspective: texts as sites of power
struggle
rooted in popular culture texts (e.g., films, television, music, etc.)
are messages about who has power and who does not
examine texts for evidence of overt and latent oppression,
stereotyping, and discrimination
Texts often present one viewpoint, and that viewpoint often
constructs and reinforces the power of a particular group.
11. Kind of textual analysis(cont…)
3/ Discourse analytic perspective: detailed
analysis of conversations and stories
the window to understanding a particular culture, a particular
social group, or a phenomenon is through the detailed analysis
of conversations and stories
it is through communication that meanings are created and
sustained
12. Types of discourse analysis
Conversation analysis :is the interpretation of a
naturally occurring conversation.
Narrative analysis :is the analysis of naturally
occurring storytelling.
how the story is structured and also what functions the story serves
such as
building community
maintaining relationships
or establishing group identity and values
13. What to Count
Seven major elements in written messages can be
counted in content analysis:
Words or terms: smallest element or unit
Themes: useful unit to count/ a simple sentence, a string of words with a subject
and a predicate
Characters:(persons) the number of times a specific person or persons
are mentioned
Paragraphs
Items: an entire book, a letter, speech, diary, newspaper, or even an in-
depth interview
Concepts: words grouped together into conceptual clusters (ideas)
Semantics: how strong or weak a word (or words) may be in relation to
the overall sentiment of the sentence
14. How to conduct a content Analysis
start with a clear, direct research question
Is there a difference in how the Ethiopian media represents younger
politicians compare to older ones in terms of credibility?
may be based on existing written documents or
transcriptions of oral data
five steps to follow
15. 1. Select the content to be analyzed
The medium and genre
newspapers, speeches or websites
opinion pieces, political campaign speeches, or marketing copy
The inclusion and exclusion criteria
newspaper articles that mention a particular event, speeches by a
certain politician, or websites selling a specific type of product
The parameters in terms of
date range
location
year, etc.
To illustrate: media representations of younger and older
politicians /news articles and opinion pieces in print
newspapers between 2017–2019. three major national
newspapers and sample only Monday and Friday editions
16. 2. Define the units and categories of analysis
The unit(s) of meaning that will be coded.
• the frequency of individual words and phrases
• the characteristics of people who produced or appear in the texts
• the presence and positioning of images
• the treatment of themes and concepts
The set of categories that you will use for coding.
Objective characteristics
• aged 20-30, lawyer, parent
Conceptual
• trustworthy, corrupt, conservative, family oriented
17. 3. Develop a set of rules for coding
organizing the units of meaning into the previously
defined categories/conceptual categories/
important if multiple researchers are involved
recording the rules makes the method more
transparent and reliable
18. 4. Coding the text according to the rules
go through each text and record all relevant data in
the appropriate categories
done manually or aided with computer programs
QSR Nvivo
Atlas.ti
Diction
help speed up the process of counting and
categorizing words and phrases
19. 5. Analyze the result and draw conclusion
the collected data is examined to find patterns and draw
conclusions in response to your research question
use statistical analysis to find correlations or trends
discuss interpretations of what the results mean
make inferences about the creators, context and audience of
the texts.
20. Advantages
1. Virtually Unobtrusive
You can analyze communication and social interaction without the
direct involvement of participants, so your presence as a researcher
doesn’t influence the results.
2. Transparent and replicable
• follows a systematic procedure that can easily be replicated by other
researchers
• yielding results with high reliability
3. Highly flexible/cost effective
• at any time
• in any location
• and at low cost – all you need is access to the appropriate sources
no one needs to be interviewed
no one needs to fill out lengthy questionnaires
no one must enter a laboratory
21. Disadvantages
Reductive
Focusing on words or phrases in isolation can sometimes be overly
reductive, disregarding context, nuance, and ambiguous meanings.
Subjective
Content analysis almost always involves some level of subjective
interpretation, which can affect the reliability and validity of the
results and conclusions, leading to various types of research bias
and cognitive bias.
Time intensive
Manually coding large volumes of text is extremely time-
consuming, and it can be difficult to automate effectively.
22. Conclusion
interpretation of a set of verbal or nonverbal signs
A text can be :Books, Book chapters ,News paper
headlines and articles, Essays, Interviews,
Conversations
It is also necessary, in the report of a textual analysis,
to provide a detailed description of the historical and
cultural context of the text
at the time the text was created
as well as the contemporary historical and cultural context in
which the text is being analyzed
23. Internet suggestion
1. Qualpage, a resource listing for qualitative researchers: http://www.
ualberta.ca / -jrnorris / qual.html
2. The Qualitative Research Page, a listing of relevant topics and resources:
http://www.oit.pdx.edu/~kerlinb/qualresearch/
3. The Qualitative Report, an online journal: http://www.nova.edu/ssss/
QR/index.html
4. The Institute of Sociology, Friedrich Schiller University, lists various
links to information on computer text analysis packages:http://www.
intext.de/TEXTANAE.HTM
5. The Social Science Information Gateway provides a listing of resources
for qualitative analysis including sites for information regarding
computer-based text analysis: http://sosig.esrc.bris.ac.uk/roads/
subject-listing /World / qualmeth.html
24. Thanks to my References
Bruce L., Berg ,2001
Luo, A. (2022, December 05). Content Analysis | Guide, Methods &
Examples. Scribbr. Retrieved January 21, 2023, from
https://www.scribbr.com/methodology/content-analysis/
Vanderstoep & Johnson ,2009